Gender and Development Theories, Wid, Wad and Gad, Their Strengths and Weaknesse

In: Other Topics

Submitted By mshollah
Words 1973
Pages 8
INVESTING IN AFRICA’S FUTURE
FACULTY OF HUMANITIES AND SOCIAL SCIENCE

Name: Chupical Shollah Manuel

Reg Number: R 086305 HU

Lecturer: Musvosvi, E (Ms)

Course: Gender and Development (HSO 306)

Question: Briefly discuss the following theories and show the strengths and weaknesses of each approach to Gender Development; WID, WAD and GAD.

Gender relates to the social constructions and relations between men and women and it does not simply look at maleness or femaleness. Development is a multidimensional concept but in general it entails social upward mobility and empowerment but not limited to this. In studying gender relations and development it is of great importance to look at the approaches adopted by feminists in redressing and addressing social disparities. There are many approaches but shall give considerable to WID, WAD and GAD and give their contributions to development as well as their strengths and weaknesses.

One of the most famous approaches to development was the feminist Women in development (WID). This was adopted in the 1970s in response to women movement in the west. The women in the west advocated for inclusion of women who have been excluded from development policies and programs. Baserup (1979) point out that the primary goal of WID was to include women into existing initiatives cited in Schech and Haggis (2000). Women were marginalized and excluded from the benefits of development. In so doing, the WID approach pointed out that the major problem to women’s unequal representation and participation is the male biased and patriarch cal development policies (Beneria and Sen 1982:161 c.f Schech and Haggis 2000). In short, the WID approach blamed patriarchy which did not consider women’s productive and reproductive work. In fact, women were tied to domestic work hence were almost invisible…...

Similar Documents

Gender and Development Theories, Wid, Wad and Gad, Their Strengths and Weaknesse

...INVESTING IN AFRICA’S FUTURE FACULTY OF HUMANITIES AND SOCIAL SCIENCE Name: Chupical Shollah Manuel Reg Number: R 086305 HU Lecturer: Musvosvi, E (Ms) Course: Gender and Development (HSO 306) Question: Briefly discuss the following theories and show the strengths and weaknesses of each approach to Gender Development; WID, WAD and GAD. Gender relates to the social constructions and relations between men and women and it does not simply look at maleness or femaleness. Development is a multidimensional concept but in general it entails social upward mobility and empowerment but not limited to this. In studying gender relations and development it is of great importance to look at the approaches adopted by feminists in redressing and addressing social disparities. There are many approaches but shall give considerable to WID, WAD and GAD and give their contributions to development as well as their strengths and weaknesses. One of the most famous approaches to development was the feminist Women in development (WID). This was adopted in the 1970s in response to women movement in the west. The women in the west advocated for inclusion of women who have been excluded from development policies and programs. Baserup (1979) point out that the primary goal of WID was to include women into existing initiatives cited in Schech and Haggis (2000). Women were marginalized and excluded from the benefits of development. In so...

Words: 1973 - Pages: 8

Wid, Wad, Gad

...STATE OF THE WORLD’S CITIES 2008/2009 Case Study Woman-headed households suffer disproportionately from inadequate housing s Turkish women taking a lunch break in Ankara ©Kobby Dagan/iStockphoto A recent report released by the Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions notes that while previous studies found that women who migrate to cities do so to join family members – mostly husbands – in the city, this trend appears to be changing: an increasing number of women are migrating to cities on their own, often to escape domestic violence or discrimination in rural areas, or because they have been disinherited. In some sub-Saharan African countries, stigmatization due to HIV/AIDS has also forced women to move to cities. In Kenya, for instance, many rural women who are infected with HIV, or who have lost a husband to the disease, are sent away from the marital home along with their children. Many of these women end up in urban slums, while their children, who are presumed to be infected with the virus, are often denied a share of the father’s property. While poor women and men in urban centres both face insecurity of land tenure and shelter, women are especially disadvantaged because they are often excluded from secure tenure as a consequence of cultural norms and unequal legal rights in legislative and policy frameworks of political systems. Women who become single heads of households, particularly in Africa, are particularly vulnerable, as in many countries in the...

Words: 1047 - Pages: 5

Wid, Wad. Gad

... the Advancement of Women). Equally significant, concerns for women’s issues raised awareness of broader human concerns in the whole process of development. Many of these advances for women built both on new thinking and on new initiatives for action, in a process that was dynamic and interactive rather than simply linear. As Jain put it, “Women brought into the development discourse the questioning mode: their quest for dignity and equal citizenship led almost to definition by negation” (12). Each advance, each achievement uncovered further goals and aspirations, just as climbing a mountain reveals a new peak on the horizon just as the first one is reached. Thus, the early goal of better welfare for women gave way to broader goals for women in development (WID), then to women and development, then to gender and development (GAD), then to mainstreaming and to the current realization that a combination of all of these is needed. Early Landmarks In the early years of the UN, women struggled to get a commission of their own. They succeeded in 1946 with the creation of the Commission on the Status of Women (CSW). But as Jain poses the underlying issue, “one must ask whether women would have wanted their own space within the UN if they had been comfortable in the mainstream. These issues of whether to remain separate or integrate with the mainstream—‘the common life which is the real life and not of the little separate lives which we live as individuals,’ as Virginia Woolf put...

Words: 2744 - Pages: 11

Wid Wad Gad Theories

... in promoting women's emancipation, seeing it as the duty of the state to provide some of the social services which women in many countries have provided on a private and individual basis. A GAD perspective leads not only to the design of intervention and affirmative action strategies which will ensure that women are better integrated into on-going development efforts. It leads, inevitably, to a fundamental re-examination of social structures and institutions and, ultimately, to the loss of power of entrenched elites, which inevitably will affect some women as well as men. Not surprisingly, a fully articulated GAD perspective is less often found in the projects and activities of international development agencies although there are some examples of partial GAD approaches. Strengths of the WID, WAD, GAD theories The WID theory gave emphasis on strategies that would minimize discrimination against women and their disadvantaged economic position. This approach was closely linked to and represented a modification of the modernisation paradigm concern that the benefits of modernisation should be for women as well as men. The solutions to women’s problems were generally envisaged as technological fixes of one kind or another. Focus on the better integration of women into existing development initiatives. Typical WID projects were income generating activities with social and welfare components added refined typology of WID approaches welfare, gender equality,......

Words: 2167 - Pages: 9

Gender Theory

... says, “ The key to understanding how family psychodynamics create gender lies in realizing that most of us are nurtured by mothers because “women rather than men have primary parenting responsibilites” (49). I think it is important to point out that the mother her self is gendered, this can effect they way she communicates with her children. Masculine would be used to describe a male child who loves sports . Feminine can be described as a female child who enjoys playing dress up and playing with dolls. A mother’s role is very important to early development of these masculine or feminine traits. Mothers are the primary care-givers for infants both male and female, this is important because this early interaction according to interpersonal theory states that this relation ship will help to form ones gender. Girls tend to learn gender from their mothers, however, boys learn gender thought differentiating themselves from their mother. A male child may identify himself different from her mother is important to form a masculine identity. Cultural theories of gender focuses on gender from a cultural perspective. According to our textbooks, “Cultural scholars do not necessarily dispute biological and interpersonal factors, but they do assume that these are qualified by the influence of culture” (56). I understand this to mean that who we are and the environment in which we live shapes our gender. Being an African-American woman has shaped me culturally......

Words: 1534 - Pages: 7

Gender Development

... development. So opportunities and resources should be channelled accordingly for the benefit of the community as a whole. In Zimbabwe the Community Share Ownership Trust, it is a project implemented by the government so that the community benefited from its local resources. For example in Chiyadzwa area the community benefited from the mining companies like Mbada Diamond Company. The community benefited regardless of gender, jobs were created, good houses were built, roads, and boreholes for safe water. According to David Antony (2001), an educated society is productive in its actions and to create a world of equity, shared responsibilities, tolerance cannot happen without gender equality. Gender equality and equity helps to ensure universal education for the benefit of the community. Gender equality in education implies that, there is equal treatment of both men and women when it comes to educational issues. Everyone should be guaranteed the right to education regardless of gender and promote equity, and improve quality of education. If everyone is educated people cannot be deceived easily, they could make their decisions of the right, and wrong so they will support their beliefs. Also people can learn the history of their country. Education develops skills, which is the main function of human capital. Human capital being an input in production increases as education increases. With education there is less conflicts, gender discrimination, gender based violence and......

Words: 860 - Pages: 4

Gender and Development Theories, Wid, Wad and Gad, Their Strengths and Weaknesse

...Theories of Development-Empowerment a)WID,b)WAD,c)GAD Ever since the formation of the United Nations Commission on the Status for Women in 1946, it had been proposing a U. N. Women’s Conference with little success. Gradually with pressure from the American Women‟s Movement, the U.N. General Assembly declared 1975 as the International Women’s Year and 1975-1985 as the International Decade for Women. This declaration led to a growing awareness of women‟s issues and an acceptance of their demands as legitimate issues for policy making, both at the national and international level. The major themes of the International Women’s Year and Conference were-- Equality, Development and Peace. Equality, however, had been a dominant issue for the U.N. Commission on the Status of Women and it came primarily from the feminist movement of the Western industrialized nations. Peace was increasingly considered to be a women issue by the countries of the Eastern block. Development, on the other hand, was a recent issue put forward mainly by the newly independent “Third World” nations as a key to improving women’s lives. During the Decade, the important but previously invisible role of women in the social and economic development of the poorer countries was highlighted. The declaration of the International Decade for Women (1975-85) signified the new visibility of Women in Development (WID) in international forums. During the past few years, the term "women in development" has...

Words: 1100 - Pages: 5

Wid Wad and Gad

... between patriarchy, modes of production, and the marginalization of women. It also presumes that the position of women around the world will improve when international conditions become more equitable. Additionally, WAD has been criticized for its singular preoccupation with the productive side of women’s work, while it ignores the reproductive aspect of women’s work and lives. Value is placed on income-generating activities, and none is ascribed to social and cultural reproduction.[14] Gender and Development (GAD)[edit] Theoretical Approach Gender and Development approach focus on the socially constructed[16] basis of differences between men and women and the need to challenge existing gender roles and relations.[17] This approach was majorly influenced by writing of academic scholars such as Oakley (1972) and Rubin (1975) which emphasize the social relationship between men and women.[18] These relationships they argue have systematically subordinated women.[19] This departs from WID which perceived women's problem in terms of their biological differences rather than gender.[20] Influenced by this work, by the late 1970s, some practitioners working in the development field stated questioning the adequacy of focusing on women in isolation.[21] GAD challenged the WID focus on women as important ‘target group’[22] and ‘untapped resources’ for development.[23] GAD marked a shift in thinking about the need to understand how women and men are socially constructed and how ‘those...

Words: 2016 - Pages: 9

Describe and Evaluate the Gender Schema Theory of Gender Development

...Describe and evaluate the gender schema theory of gender development. Martin and Halverson believe that gender identity is gained around the age two-three. They also stated that when children realise that they are either a boy or girl they split themselves into two groups, their gender group being the ‘in-group’ and the opposite sex group is the ‘out-group’. The children then actively seek out how members of their group should behave (toys, games, activities) and ignore those that do not relate to their group, for example a young boy would completely ignore a girl’s toy and may avoid anything perceived to be ‘girly’. This leads them to form schemas and their environment, peers and parents helps them to develop these which become more complex over time. Gender schemas help us to understand why children’s beliefs and attitudes about sex roles are so rigid, for example children may ignore behaviours which go against gender schemas e.g. female fire fighters or male nurses. Studies that support this have shown that when young children watch films which depict contradicting gender role behaviours, they tune them out. A study that goes against Martin and Halverson’s theory of gender development is Campbell’s study (2000). Although Martin and Halverson believe that gender identity is gained earlier than what Kohlberg thought, Campbell has proof that children develop gender schemas even earlier than ages 2-3. His study was with children of three months, nine months and...

Words: 1040 - Pages: 5

Discuss Kohlberg’s Theory of Gender Development.

... behaviour, what differs this stage from any other is that this behaviour wasn’t learned before as the child believed that their gender was open to change. Slaby and Frey supported this again in 1975. They asked children of this age questions along the lines of, “Could you be a girl/boy if you wanted to be?” In their evaluation, they concluded that children in the final stage of development who scored highly on both stability and consistency questions showed interest in same-sex models. This agrees with what Kohlberg suggests, that constancy leads children to pay attention to models that are appropriate to their own gender. However, there have been some criticisms of Kohlberg’s theory. Slaby and Frey (1975) suggested that Kohlberg had underestimated the age of gender constancy by as much as 2 years. They found that children at the age of 5 displayed complete gender constancy. Although this is not contesting any part of Kohlberg’s theories, it suggests that some adjustments should be made in the age bracket of each stage. Bem (1989) criticised Kohlberg’s method of measuring children’s age constancy. Bem argues that a child’s understanding of social cues for gender, (i.e. what a person is wearing) is all that’s being measured. To conclude, Kohlberg’s theory of gender development is made up of 3 stages: the gender labelling stage, the gender stability stage and the gender consistency stage. He argues that children at stage one (2-3) can identify theirs and others’......

Words: 823 - Pages: 4

Gender Development

... imagination are developed (A&M p.4). * Concrete Operational Stage (Elementary): “Intelligence is demonstrated through logical and systematic manipulation of symbols related to concrete objects” (A&M p.4). * Formal Operational Stage (Adulthood): “Intelligence is demonstrated through the logical use of symbols related to abstract concepts” (A&M p.4). According to Piaget, an important factor in cognitive development are schemas. “A schema can be defined as a set of linked mental representations of the world, which we use both to understand and to respond to situations” (McLeod). Schema can be thought as memory cards or “index cards” (McLeod) that are stored in one’s brain and then pull forward during certain situations telling the person who to respond or react. Piaget noted that an infant’s schemas are much simpler but as the child ages, the schemas become greater and more complex. Piaget’s theory is continuously used throughout early-education programs. The theory also served as the basis for constructivist learning. Cognitive Development Theory urges the learning of primary instincts and interests. Children should learn material that is the same level of their schema and not be pushed into learning material higher than their current level. Piaget believes all children will grow and move on to the next level when they are ready. Critique As previously stated, Piaget’s theory and studies have been continuously supported throughout the years......

Words: 754 - Pages: 4

Wad. Gad, Aid

... from new perspectives. 1 But it is precisely the fact that gender seems self - evident that mak es the study of gender interesting. It brings the challenge to uncover the process of construction that creates what we have so long thought of as natural and inexorable – to study gender not as given, but as an accomplishment; not simply as cause, but as effect; and not just as individual, but as social. The results of failure to recognize this challenge are manifest not only in the popular media, but in academic work on language and gender as well. As a result, some gender scholarship does as much to reif y and support existing beliefs as to promote more reflective and informed thinking about gender. Sex and gender Gender is not something we are born with, and not something we have , but something we do (West and Zimmerman 1987) – something we perform (Butle r 1990). Imagine a small boy proudly following his father. As he swaggers and sticks out his chest, he is doing everything he can to be like his father – to be a man . Chances are his father is not swaggering, but the boy is creating a persona that embodies what he is admiring in his adult male role model. The same is true of a small girl as she puts on her mother’s high - heeled shoes, smears makeup on her face and minces around the room. Chances are ......

Words: 519 - Pages: 3

Wid, Gad and Wad

... patriarchy, modes of production, and the marginalization of women. It also presumes that the position of women around the world will improve when international conditions become more equitable. Additionally, WAD has been criticized for its singular preoccupation with the productive side of women’s work, while it ignores the reproductive aspect of women’s work and lives. Value is placed on income-generating activities, and none is ascribed to social and cultural reproduction.[14] Gender and development (GAD)[edit] Theoretical approach Gender and Development approach focus on the socially constructed[16] basis of differences between men and women and the need to challenge existing gender roles and relations.[17] This approach was majorly influenced by writing of academic scholars such as Oakley (1972) and Rubin (1975) which emphasize the social relationship between men and women.[18] These relationships they argue have systematically subordinated women.[19] This departs from WID which perceived women's problem in terms of their biological differences rather than gender.[20] Influenced by this work, by the late 1970s, some practitioners working in the development field stated questioning the adequacy of focusing on women in isolation.[21] GAD challenged the WID focus on women as important ‘target group’[22] and ‘untapped resources’ for development.[23] GAD marked a shift in thinking about the need to understand how women and men are socially constructed and how ‘those...

Words: 4483 - Pages: 18

Wid, Wad and Gad Theories in Gender and Development

... level of WC be maintained. | Adequacy of Resources = Cash + Marketable Securities + Accounts Receivable Monthly Expenses | Determines the number of months you could operate without further funds received (burn rate) | Leverage Ratios To what degree does an enterprise utilize borrowed money and what is its level of risk? Lenders often use this information to determine a business’s ability to repay debt.   Ratio | What does it tell you? | Debt to Equity = Short Term Debt + Long Term Debt Total Equity (including grants) | Compares capital invested by owners/funders (including grants) and funds provided by lenders. Lenders have priority over equity investors on an enterprise’s assets. Lenders want to see that there is some cushion to draw upon in case of financial difificulty. The more equity there is, the more likely a lender will be repaid. Most lenders impose limits on the debt/equity ratio, commonly 2:1 for small business loans. Too much debt can put your business at risk, but too little debt may limit your potential. Owners want to get some leverage on their investment to boost profits. This has to be balanced with the ability to service debt. | Interest Coverage = EBITDA Interest Expense | Measures your ability to meet interest payment obligations with business income. Ratios close to 1 indicates company having difficulty generating enough cash flow to pay interest on its debt. Ideally, a ratio should be over 1.5 | Other Ratios You may want to develop your own......

Words: 1466 - Pages: 6

Gender and Development Theories, Wid, Wad and Gad, Their Strengths and Weaknesse

...THE WID, WAD, GAD APPROACH ON GENDER DEVELOPMENT March 19, 2013 · by cn2collins · Bookmark the permalink. · Over the years development programs have been criticized for ignoring gender roles and the impact it has on women in the global south. However we see a shift to integrate women into development programs in hopes of eradicating poverty and low social economical status. The six main theoretical approaches are: “(1) the welfare approach; (2) women in development (WID); (3) women and development (WAD); (4) gender and development (GAD); (5) the effectiveness approach (EA); and (6) mainstream gender equality (MGE). Martinez tries to understand the various outcomes and effectiveness of all 6 development theories.  Despite the effort to reinforce gender mainstreaming into society we still see a vast number of gender inequality especially in the developing world. Women make up the 70% of individuals living in poverty and in sub-Saharan Africa 57% of HIV infected individuals are women. This also includes the disproportionate ratio of women to men in the job market and at leadership position, low level of education among women, and low socio-economic status among women.  The term “Women, Gender and Development” could be seen a discipline much like ever other area of knowledge. However, what sets it apart from various disciplines is that, its major contributors are individuals that raise issues and concerns, concerning women, gender and development. These are academics...

Words: 1536 - Pages: 7