Free Essay

Gender Foucault

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By patelmi6
Words 2378
Pages 10
1) How do the texts you have selected EITHER challenge or reinforce conventional ideas about the following discourses?
a. Gender b. Power (& Leadership) c. Identity d. Nature e. Culture

The societies encountered by the Theban woman Antigone is Sophocles' Antigone, and the 19th century Englishwoman Jane Eyre in Jane Eyre, can be seen as highly unfavourable and disdainful of women. Both Antigone and Jane Eyre struggle and resist against a society which places men above them, and which sees expressions of female autonomy and liberty as unfavourable trends. Antigone and Jane Eyre both live in societies where a patriarchal culture dictates how these women should act within society, and what type of behaviour is acceptable, and which isn't. The control and subjugation of women – and the way they express themselves – can be seen as a consequence of discursive formations which aim to define the intrinsic qualities of men and women. It is in this context that the stories of Antigone and Jane Eyre can be seen as challenging conventional notions of gender and gender stereotypes, a highly pervasive discourse which affects a cluster of other ideas. This essay will argue that the characters Antigone in Sophocles' Antigone and Jane Eyre in Charlotte Bronte's Jane Eyre are characters who challenge gender discourses which were very prominent during their time, and subsequently, the ideational influences which structured leadership, the creation of identities, opinions regarding natural attributes, and cultural . While Antigone lives in a pre-modern society dominated by males who take the subservience and submission of women to be a given, Jane Eyre is a young woman within modern society who also challenges residual gender discourses which have normalized the importance of men within society. The following paper will attempt to first understand what a “discourse” truly is, and how the discursive production of knowledge within society, a process best characterized by the French post-modern philosopher Michel Foucault. Focauldian discourse analysis can assist in understanding and demystifying the manner in which the actions and opinions of Antigone and Jane Eyre directly challenge conventional ideas of female subservience within Thebes and late 19th century England. The placement of males as the dominant figures within social hierarchies can be seen as a gendered discourse which manifests itself discursively. The placement of heterosexual males as the dominant figures within society is a a phenomenon that can understood as taking place “discursively” and through the aegis of discourses. In his highly influential book “Discipline and Punish” Foucault is able to describe how unequal power relations manifest themselves within society, a hierarchy which aptly describes the societies of Jane Eyre and Antigone which are dominated by the male gender and the discourse which normalizes this inequality. This is a phenomenon analyzed by sociologists Allan Edwards and James Skinner in the book “Extending the Boundaries,” where they analyze how clusters of ideas are generated through the discursive production of knowledge described by Foucault in his writings. “Discourses” influence who wields power and how this control expresses itself, and an analysis of “discourses” assists in explaining the significance of Antigone and Jane Eyre's resistance against gendered discourses. For Foucault a “discourse” is “closely interrelated” with power and knowledge, and it is noted that they are so intimately intertwined that “discourse” can be seen as “co-extensive with a field of power” (Edwards and Skinner 60). “Power” and “Knowledge” assist in generating discourses, and it is in this manner that gender discourses which subjugate women, such as those encountered by Jane Eyre and Antigone, can be seen as part and parcel of a unique way of understanding male power and the knowledge which he wishes to see permeate society (Edwards and Skinner 60). By analyzing discourses, such as those witnessed within Antigone and Jane Eyre, one becomes privy to how there are “links between knowledge, power and resultant discourses” (Edwards and Skinner 60). This emphasis upon “links” in Foucauldian thought is especially pertinent to our analysis of Antigone and Jane Eyre, and the manner in which their challenge against traditional and conventional gender norms in the respective books that have received their namesake, also have implications for the way in which other discursive formations, such as those relating the leadership, identity, nature and culture, are also questioned. Foucault believed that all discourses – because of their intrinsically oppressive nature and substance – possessed “internal contradictions” which exposed the false way in which they aimed to structure and explain reality in a skewed manner (Edwards and Skinner 60). Foucault argued that in order to understand these “contradictions,” one should “describe the contradictions and puzzles as they become apparent, as a 'tool for radical political action'” (Foucault 205). This final insight is very important to the present understanding of how Antigone and Jane Eyre challenge conventional ideas and views relating to gender, and how this can be seen as part and parcel of the “radical political action” discussed by Foucault and which witnesses these two young ladies radically voice their opinions in Antigone and Jane Eyre. Foucault does caution that when engaging in discourse analysis, and while aiming to understand how a particular discourse oppressively determines how a particular reality is to be understood, one must understand that a “discourse analysis recognizes itself to be a historically situated interpretation of a historically situated discourse related to a discourse and power for the people involved” (Edwards and Skinner 60). It is in this manner that Antigone and Jane Eyre – women who can be seen as feminist activists who are attempting to thwart the male dominated gender discourse within their societies – are themselves discourse analysts, and as such many of Foucault's ideas relating to discourse analysis have resonance with these two texts. Challenging a discourse by a discourse analyst requires one to understand “the regularities that determine the operation of a specific historically situated discourse, including social practices as well as the rules of written and spoken discourse” (Edwards and Skinner 61). Foucault believed that one must be very vigilant when examining a discourse in order to resist it, and when analyzing a discourse it is imperative that one “consider what conflicting groups of people are saying within the discourse” and that it is important to understand “who gets listened to most often and why, what the hidden agendas are, who gets chastised for their deeds or writings” and also “how the discourse becomes widespread and to whom, and how the existence of the discourse is said to be necessary and to whom” (Edwards and Skinner 61). These insights provide a rich cornucopia of insight into how power and knowledge intimately intersect with discourses, and it is through the minds of Antigone and Jane Eyre we are privy to the attempt to two women to challenge a gender discourse within their societies which has implications for a cluster of other ideas, namely leadership, power, nature, and culture. Foucault's belief that a discourse is heavily dependent upon these ideas – ideas and sub-discourses concerning knowledge and power – is pivotal to understanding how Jane Eyre and Antigone are themselves challenging the dominance of males and a discourse which favours their monopoly on power and knowledge. In Sophocles' Antigone the story's main character Antigone can be seen as a woman who is disheartened by the highly oppressive and dictatorial rule of the Theban King Creon, who often justifies his harsh ways by alluding to the “natural-ness” of male domination within Theban society. This feeling is manifest in Creon's mind, which can be seen as a component of how knowledge and power and intimately intertwined in this gender discourse in the following quote: "And no woman shall seduce us. If we must lose, Let's lose to a man, at least! Is a woman stronger than we?" (Sophocles 218). This feeling is expressed by Creon as he is being challenged by Antigone, who wishes to go against his harsh decrees and laws. Antigone views Creon's desire to physically desecrate her brother's body as a great shame, and although Creon is the King, she understands that he will not listen to her since she is a woman. Antigone hopes to go against this male-centered gender discourse by taking her brother's body and providing it with a proper burial, much against Creon's wishes. The highly contentious nature of this action – and how significant it is that Antigone is challenging the gender discourse of male dominance – is manifest by Creon's reaction: “The is guilty of double insolence, Breaking the given laws and boasting it. Who is the man here. She or I, if this crime goes unpunished?” (Sophocles 209). Creon sees Antigone's actions as a threat to the entire way in which Theban society is structured, with the discourse of male dominance deeply interwoven into society. Ideas relating to leadership and identity – with men naturally being fit to rule and dominate women – are also being questioned through Antigone's recalcitrant actions. Not only is she questioning conventional ideas relating to gender, but also the very cultural ideas which states that they are part of nature. It is in this way that Antigone's mission against Creon can be seen as directly challenging the cluster of ideas conceptualized by Foucault, which see the intersection of power and knowledge. Antigone's mission against Creon is quite remarkable, and witnessing a woman evangelize against a male-centered society – and the discourses which sustain it – is indicative of how significant Antigone's actions and ideas truly are. Antigone is very self-aware of how she is going against the grain of established norms within society, and she is very self-conscious of this reality. Her mission against the male dominated gender discourse is clear when she states: “They say no woman has ever, so unreasonably, Died so shameful a death for a generous act: 'She covered her brother's body. Is this indecent? She kept him from dogs and vultures. Is this a crime?” (Sophocles 218). These conscious statements by Antigone suggest that she is resisting the gender discourse of male dominance which dominates Thebes, and which is reinforced in society by Creon's heavy-handedness. The character Jane Eyre in Charlotte Bronte's Jane Eyre also appears to be a figure who challenges the discourses of 19th century England through her desire to obtain freedom and equality on par with that of men, and which is denied to her. Jane Eyre actively aims to challenge the discourse of male domination in England, and in the following passage she directly addresses how women are relegated to an inferior position in comparison to men:
“Women are supposed to be very calm generally: but women feel just as men feel; they need exercise for their faculties, and a field for their efforts as much as their brothers do; they suffer from too rigid a restraint, too absolute a stagnation, precisely as men would suffer; and it is narrow-minded in their more privileged fellow-creatures to say that they ought to confine themselves to making puddings and knitting stockings, to playing on the piano and embroidering bags. It is thoughtless to condemn them, or laugh at them, if they seek to do more or learn more than custom has pronounced necessary for their sex” (Eyre 112). Jane Eyre hopes to achieve a semblance of equality with men so that she can focus on the interests and pursuits which she holds very dear. She intuitively understands how a particular gender discourse that is in place within 20th century England determines what women's natural faculties may be, and the intersection of how this “knowledge” determines relations of “power,” just as Foucault had intimated in his own writings on discourse analysis. She states that women are expected to be “calm generally” but in reality “women feel just as men feel” and that they must be able to “exercise... their faculties” (Eyre 112). She is aware that the male dominated culture takes women to adhere to a particular identity, which takes women's nature to be very stereotypical. Women are expected to fulfil household duties, and this is something that Jane Eyre takes great issue with, since their own creativity and freedom is restrained. She views with great sorrow how it is truly “narrow-minded” that “more privileged fellow-creatures” (in this case men), say that women “ought to confine themselves to making puddings and knitting stockings” and “playing on the piano and embroidering bags” (Eyre 112). This domesticated function is seen as “thoughtless” by Eyre who believes that women should be able to “do more or learn more than custom has pronounced necessary for their sex” (Eyre 112). This last idea relating to “custom” is highly penetrating, for it displays how women are oppressed on account of what is actually a discursive formation that attempts to create knowledge regarding their nature and identity, which does not bode well for their ability to express leadership and power. This “custom” is part of the gender discourse which Jane Eyre wishes to challenge, and it is through the perceptive views expressed by her in this passage that one is privy to her desire to go against this discourse and expose it for what it is – a means of creating unequal hierarchies through knowledge, and by extension, leadership/power. In conclusion this essay wished to problematize the male dominated gender discourse which forced both Antigone and Jane Eyre to engage in deep introspection regarding how oppressive it truly was. The assistance of Michel Foucault's theories regarding discourses provides Jane Eyre and Antigone's views/opinions with greater lucidity, since it was these women who wished to deconstruct the discourse of male dominance which limited them, and which intersected with ideas relating to leadership, nature, culture and identity. A cluster of ideas exist within the gender discourse encountered by these two women that operate together to place women in a subservient position, and it is through an analysis of each respective woman's own attempt at discourse analysis – and questioning the supposed normalcy of male centered society – that a clearer understanding of the oppression of gender discourses is obtained.
Works Cited
Brontë, Charlotte. Jane Eyre. New York: Random House, 1943. Print.

Edwards, Allan, James Skinner, and Keith Gilbert. Extending the Boundaries. Altona: Common Ground Publishers, 2002. Print.

Sophocles, E F. Watling, Sophocles, Sophocles, and Sophocles. The Theban Plays. London: Penguin, 1974. Print.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Consumption and Public Spaces

...Introduction The role of hyper-consumerism on culture as a source of control and power relations has been discussed by a variety of scholarly voices. Among the most prominent is Michel Foucault, who described the various ways that consumer markets circumscribe public spaces, placing important distinctions between class members. In particular, Foucault discusses heterotopia – the public space which carries both physical and psychological gravity. For Foucault, public spaces are characterized by existing without truly existing. The heterotopia serves as a metaphor for a larger context while having the appearance and characteristics of other everyday spaces. Tyndall takes this notion a step further by developing social rules that are attached to consumer places, such as malls and shopping districts (Tyndall, 2009). This version of consumer-driven rules – culled from qualitative research and personal interviews – depicts a new notion of public-ness that is less egalitarian than ever before. It is a version of public space that is not entirely open to the public. Baker adds to this perspective by historicizing the commercialization of public space, dating the use widespread use of public space for advertising purposes to before the dawn of the 20th century (Baker, 2007). This argument inextricably links the notion of “culture” with “consumerism”, and sets the stage for the potential for access to public spaces to be consumed, or purchased. Finally, Klingle underscores......

Words: 1702 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Mrs. Beeton

...Foucault and the New Historicism Author(s): Geoffrey Galt Harpham Source: American Literary History, Vol. 3, No. 2 (Summer, 1991), pp. 360-375 Published by: Oxford University Press Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/490057 . Accessed: 18/10/2011 05:25 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Oxford University Press is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to American Literary History. http://www.jstor.org the Foucault and New Historicism GeoffreyGait Harpham "People are always shouting they want to create a better future,"Milan Kundera writes in The Book of Laughterand Forgetting."It's not true. The futureis an apatheticvoid of no interestto anyone. The past is full of life, eager to irritateus, provoke and insult us, tempt us to destroy or repaint it. The AfterFoucault: HumanisticKnowledge, only reasonpeople want to be mastersof the futureis to change PostmodernChallenges the past"(22). Not only is the historicalrecordlargelyan archive Edited by Jonathan of domination and......

Words: 5701 - Pages: 23

Free Essay

Psychology of Education.

...Comparison and Contrast between the Disciplined and Controlled Societies Sociology Theorizing Introduction According to Deleuze disciplinary societies existed in the 18th and the 19th centuries. He explains that these societies were located by Foucault. Deleuze explained that the disciplinary societies were much evidenced in the 20th century which according to him was the time when the practice reached its peak. According to him in this system the individuals were operating enclosed environments. Such environments were having the laws to be followed closely by the people. These enclosed environments included the family, the school, the barracks, and the factory and the hospital that people would visit from time to time. Still another enclosed environment was the prison which was seen as an analogical model of laborers who were treated as prisoners. He uses the exclamations of the heroine of Rossellini’s Europa ’51 whom at the sight of some laborers was reported to have thought that she was seeing convicts. Analyzing such environments enclosure in the context of a factory Foucault explained that the major goals of a factory is to concentrate, distribute in space, order in time, compose a force of production within the dimensions of both space and time to ensure grater effect than that of the sum of its component forces. Comparison and Contrast of the Disciplined Society with Controlled Society In discipline societies an individual passes through different......

Words: 3017 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Do We Now Live in a ‘Panoptic’ Society? Discuss Through the Ideas of Michel Foucault.

...society? Discuss through the ideas of Michel Foucault. This essay will examine French social theorist Michel Foucault’s (1926-1984), concept of Panopticism. It will give an example of the way it can be observed, through contemporary society. Firstly, it will cover a general aspect of Foucault’s work, regarding his historical method and his understanding of madness, power, knowledge and the body. It will discuss the idea of the Panopticon and how it shaped the idea of discipline and power. Furthermore, it will examine one element of Foucault’s theory, and how it could be applied in contemporary society, through the subject of security in public places. Foucault’s 1964 work Madness and Civilisation, studied the evolution of madness from the sixteenth to the twentieth century, showing the evolving change of how madness was perceived over time in society. During the time of the Renaissance, Foucault found that people who were ‘mad’ were seen as liberated (Foucault 1967). However, the classical age in the seventeenth century created ‘enormous houses of confinement’ which reduced madness to silence (Foucault 1967:35). The mid seventeenth century saw madness associated with confinement. These institutions housed people who were poor, unemployed, prisoners and insane. In 1656, the ‘Hôpital Général’ was founded in Paris and could be seen from the start, that it was not a ‘medical establishment’, but rather a sort of ‘semi-judicial structure’ (Foucault 1967:37). It had absolute......

Words: 2282 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Who Knows

...We are living in a time where the sketched epistemes of political rationality for which ‘life’ is the organizing object of politics (i.e., biopolitics) is being challenged. During the 1970s and beginning of 1980s theorists such as Foucault argued that the sovereign right to kill was increasingly displaced by the administrative compulsion to make live. That is, instead of ending violence or killing especially in the context of Europe and North America lethal conflict was redistributed through out the population turning politics into war by other means such as the withdrawal of the state from the household (i.e., oikos) and national life and hence with a more focus on biopolitics. In the Global South though theorists like Mbembe challenge Foucauldian biopolitics to argue that outside Europe and North America this governing of life (zoe) took a different form: necropolitics resulting from the histories of power relations such as slavery and colonization. Yet, theorists in the Global North such as Foucault insisted that the 1970s the life of power mutated increasing the neoliberal turn in government leaving our times and more concretely “the future as yet unthought.” This class begins with Foucault’s concept of biopolitics and Mbembe’s idea of necropolitics and asks: what are the stakes in thinking and practicing power today through the locus of biopolitics and/or necropolitics? What are the stakes in reading these tensions with respect to yesterday—and to tomorrow for the......

Words: 580 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

The X-Ray Tube

...Michel Foucault, the French postmodernist, has been hugely influential in shaping understandings of power, leading away from the analysis of actors who use power as an instrument of coercion, and even away from the discreet structures in which those actors operate, toward the idea that ‘power is everywhere’, diffused and embodied in discourse, knowledge and ‘regimes of truth’ (Foucault 1991; Rabinow 1991). Power for Foucault is what makes us what we are, operating on a quite different level from other theories: ‘His work marks a radical departure from previous modes of conceiving power and cannot be easily integrated with previous ideas, as power is diffuse rather than concentrated, embodied and enacted rather than possessed, discursive rather than purely coercive, and constitutes agents rather than being deployed by them’ (Gaventa 2003: 1) Foucault challenges the idea that power is wielded by people or groups by way of ‘episodic’ or ‘sovereign’ acts of domination or coercion, seeing it instead as dispersed and pervasive. ‘Power is everywhere’ and ‘comes from everywhere’ so in this sense is neither an agency nor a structure (Foucault 1998: 63). Instead it is a kind of ‘metapower’ or ‘regime of truth’ that pervades society, and which is in constant flux and negotiation. Foucault uses the term ‘power/knowledge’ to signify that power is constituted through accepted forms of knowledge, scientific understanding and ‘truth’: ‘Truth is a thing of this world: it is produced only......

Words: 2182 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Enlightenment of Society and the Death Peantly

...Enlightenment of Society Examining the enlightenment, it can be seen that it was a force for change in the way that societies thought about equality toward individuals. As the ideas of justice, deterrence, and individual rights evolved during the Enlightenment, so did the application of capital punishment. It became a tool to help reform individuals instead of punishing them, and capital executions became a private practice. It also evolved from being an arbitrary punishment against minorities, to a consistent and steady punishment for anyone who broke the law, eventually morphing into the punishment system of today. As history has progressed, a complete difference has been seen in regards to the rights of the minorities and the poor in the courts of law. The stark difference in the courts opinion toward minorities can be seen if you compare the way that they were tried during the colonization of Mexico with the way that they were treated in English society after the Enlightenment. As Martinez talks about in her essay, blacks were heavily discriminated against. This social tension carried over into the High Courts of Spanish society, which caused them to be extremely biased against the blacks. The courts bias can be easily observed in the Translated Documents from New Spain, in which the courts, under the façade of a trial, punish a group of blacks simply to make an example of them. The effect of the deterrence was undermined by the fact that these......

Words: 1612 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Ethical Dilemma Essay

...Ethical Dilemma Essay Tiffany Christiansen Baker College Ethical Dilemma Essay Like many professionals, a code of ethics must be followed. When a sociologist chooses to do research, they must follow the ethics of sociology. These ethics are clearly outlined in the American Sociological Association: Code of Ethics. Some of these ethics include honesty and truth. They forbid a sociologist from providing false results as well as condemn plagiarism. Ethics of Sociology also require that anonymity be upheld of those who provide information (Henslin, 2014). When looking at Principle E: Social Responsibility under the General Principles of the American Sociological Association: Code of Ethics, it states that “Sociologists are aware of their professional and scientific responsibility to the communities and societies in which they live and work. They apply and make public their knowledge in order to contribute to the public good. When undertaking research, they strive to advance the science of sociology and to serve the public good” (Code of ethics and policies and procedures of the ASA Committee on Professional Ethics, 1999, p 6). Therefore, Robert’s responsibility should be that he makes contact with the police and quite possibly even the homeowners of the house in which is intended to be burglarized, beings it is contributing to the public good. Robert could still protect the anonymity of the professional burglar by only divulging information that could help to prevent the......

Words: 387 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

What Is an Organisation

...Providing an answer to the question “What is an organisation?” could appear like a very demanding task. In fact, not only might different people have different views on what the term suggests, but, also, the concept is in itself quite broad. The evolution of this phenomenon is quite complex. An “organization”, meant as a union between different individuals who join their strengths in order to achieve a common goal, is a concept, which has been present since the beginning of time. Nevertheless, the way in which we interpret this term has undergone a big evolution in recent times. If we ask a researcher, he would most certainly tell us that organizations are a very specific subject and are defined in a very unique way. So, exactly, what is an organization? If we look it up in the dictionary the answer we will more or less find is the following: “a group of people that work together in a structured way for a shared purpose.” (Cambridge Dictionary, online). And this is also what the common belief seems to think. Nevertheless, researchers have analyzed the subject with more in depth observations and have situated this phenomenon in specific historical times. One historical background in particular has been taken into consideration while studying these structures: Capitalism. Capitalist organizations were at the base of the 19th and 20th centuries and researchers from the Frankfurt School, also know as the Institute for Social Research, took time in analyzing them. The......

Words: 2488 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Discourse Analysis

...Table of Contents 1.1 Introduction1 Extract Overview1 Discourse Analysis………………………………………………………………………………………………….2 Alternative Discourse…………………………………………………………………………………………….3 Conclusion…………………………………………………………………………………………………………..4 1.1 Introduction Discourse analysis is both an old and a new discipline. Its origins can be traced back to the study of language, public speech, and literature more than 2000 years ago. (Schiffrin, 2001) Much of the structural analysis of the term can be said to have resulted from books such as the archaeology of knowledge, discipline and punish and the history of sexuality which were written by the famous sociologist Michael Foucault. Foucault defines discourse as ways of constituting knowledge, together with social practices, forms of subjectivity and power relations, which inhere in such knowledge, and relations between them. (Quinby, 1999) Putnam and Fairhurst [2001: 79] use the term 'discourse analysis' to refer to 'the study of words and signifiers, including the form or structure of these words, the use of language in context, and the meanings or interpretation of discursive practices'. Discourses are more than ways of thinking and producing meaning (this meaning could be in form of language, speech, text etc.). They constitute the ‘nature’ of the body, unconscious and conscious and conscious mind and emotional life of the subjects they seek to govern (Weedon, 1987) 1.2 Extract Overview The extract to be assessed is...

Words: 1691 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Institutions and the Self

...Do the institutions that deal with people with social and personal problems always act in the interests of those they serve? Discuss through the ideas of Erving Goffman and Michel Foucault. Introduction This essay will concentrate on the works of Erving Goffman and Michel Foucault. Erving Goffman is seen as the sociologist of the micro level and Foucault at the macro level. What this essay will aim to do is to distinguish the works of both these sociologists and identify the concepts that both try to portray. When speaking in relation to the works of Erving Goffman, one must speak about his studies of the self and the identity that one creates in society. He speaks of how people are actors and that performances are what the people see and thus creating the self identity of one self. Performance is the key area which Goffman speaks about in his writings. From here, the essay will establish how institutions have an effect on certain societies and what happens to identity once someone enters into an institution and the meaning of total institution and will incorporate the work of Foucault. Michel Foucault looks at the long term history of madness, asylums and prisons. The essay will elaborate on Foucault by discussing what he says in relation to where and why such institutions came about, thus the effects that they have on an individual. Erving Goffman Identity “I shall consider the way in which the individual in ordinary works situations presents himself and his......

Words: 2543 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Prison

...difficult times. Michel Foucault in his "Surveiller et punish" ( Discipline and Punish ) notes that its use as punitive punishment of crime, is a recent phenomenon that was instituted during the nineteenth century . Earlier, jail, only used to hold prisoners who were waiting to be sentenced (or not) effectively (punishment, execution or rejection). The prisoners were held in the same space, regardless of their offense and had to pay child support. The disruption was such that the same crime suspects could, with ease, change the version of events before processing. The application of justice at the time was in the public domain. It showed the torture to which they were subjected defendants and their executions. Michel Foucault mentions the large venues or the ship of fools, as particular examples of detention prior to the modern era. Contrary to the conviction that establishes a prison sentence on the offense, the prisons of the time served as a means of exclusion for all marginalized people (criminals, crazy, sick, orphaned, homeless, prostitutes, etc..) All were imprisoned, haphazardly, to silence the conscience of the "honest" people without more aspiration than to make them disappear. The creation of prisons arose from the need to keep secret the treatment of crime. The executions, carried out in public, were increasingly discrete to disappear completely from view. The torture, considered barbaric, had to be changed to something else. Foucault notes that the......

Words: 623 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Biopolitics, Intersectionality and Reproductive Justice

...Phil Chu AMS/WMS 139 11/2/11 Reading Response #2–Biopolitics: Population, Intersectionality and Reproductive Justice In 1996, the Personal Responsibility Act “reformed welfare” when it created the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program (Mink 196). The most significant aspect of these reforms was the fact that welfare was now designed not only to help impoverished families, specifically children, but also to “promote marriage, reduce out-of-wedlock births, and to ‘encourage the formation and maintenance of two-parent families’”(196). The Adoption Promotion Act, passed in the same year, called for “the removal of barriers to interethnic adoption,” which Ana Teresa Ortiz and Laura Briggs argue was meant to “put the children of welfare mothers . . . into white adoptive homes” (203). These two changes in welfare policy marked a significant increase in the amount of biopower wielded by the state. The importance of the health and development of children within a society had been recognized early in the 20th century when particular emphasis began to be placed on “the value of a healthy and numerous population as a national resource”(Davin 161). However, the changes in welfare policy that were enacted in the 90’s went a step beyond mere protection of children, but in order to understand this significance it is necessary to look at it within the context of American biopolitics as a whole. The term “biopolitics”–which evolved from 18th century discourses about the......

Words: 1099 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Penitentiary

...Jeremy Bentham's Panopticon Design Two models A penitentiary had purposes to be both secular and spiritual. Instead of a penitentiary being all about physical punishment, it was supposed to be a place of humane punishment for wrong doers. Instead of prisoners being bunched together, the true penitentiary was meant to have them separated from each other to avoid contamination of the body and spirit. I personally think that a penitentiary should be more like a place to make an inmate know that they did wrong by breaking the law. The first model was called the Pennsylvania system. It was based on the idea of "separate and silent." The state of Pennsylvania built two big prisons, one in Philadelphia and another in Pittsburgh. These were known as Eastern Penitentiary and Western Penitentiary, respectively. Eastern Penitentiary was operational from 1829 to 1971, and there are some good photos and videos of it at http://www.easternstate.org/explore/flickr, and the Wikipedia article on it is pretty good. Western was a poor imitation of Jeremy Bentham's panopticon design (explained shortly), and Eastern better characterized the model as consisting of large cells that faced outside so each inmate would have a small amount of outdoor space or footage. Inmates could exercise in their own cells, have their meals delivered, and never come in contact with another inmate. If they wanted to plant a garden in their outdoor patio, they could. If they wanted to engage in......

Words: 431 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

What Is Humanism? What Is Post-Structuralism?

...1. What is Humanism? What is Post structuralism? Humanism refers to the belief of human-centered, and not centered by god. It is said that in the pre-humanist western culture, god was presumed to the origin of the universe, and the center of meaning. After the 17th – 18th centuries, the figure of god was slowly replaced by ‘man’, as it becomes the center and measure of all things. Humanism is also centrally concerned with ‘reason’ (Rationalism), where it enables us not only to think, but also to act correctly. Moreover, it also emphasizes on individualism. According to the humanist system, individuals are unique and autonomous by nature, rational and free. Humanism also embraces the idea of ‘general principles’ (Idealism), these principles are believed to be equally applicable to all people, at all times, in all places (Universalism). Besides, these principles must also be able to be proven to be true in and through careful observation and rational, objective methods of argumentation, known as ‘Empiricism’. Last but not least, humanism is founded on dichotomous logic, where the world is centered with a serious of oppositions. (E.g. Male vs. Female, Good vs. Bad). Post-structuralism is referred to ‘the crisis of humanism’, where there is a diminishing belief in rationality, absolute truth, objectivity, universal principles and dichotomous logic. It claims that people cannot always be rational and objective, as we are always affected by our emotions and results in being......

Words: 325 - Pages: 2