Premium Essay

Girls on Boys Sports Teams

In: Social Issues

Submitted By jwsemus3
Words 1352
Pages 6
“Oh, man, look guys, they’ve got a girl on their team…” “Ah, man, again? I hate playing against girls. I always feel like I’m going to hurt them.” “Just don’t think about it, dude. Go up against her like she’s just another player.” “Okay boys, watch out for the girl on their team. If she’s playing with the guys team, she’s gotta be good.”
Countless times, my teammates and I would watch a girl walk on to the field for the other team and start warming up. Instantly, stereotypes were made, and probably to many peoples’ surprise, they were in her favor. Any girl playing on a guy’s team has to be highly skilled, so we tried our hardest not to take her lightly. We did our best to keep this mentality in our minds during the game, but the instant there was a close ball and there was going to be some hard contact, the guys on our team, almost every time, would back off the ball in fear of hurting her. While going up against a girl, this restraint is almost always going on in guys’ minds. Guys shouldn’t have to limit how hard they play at any time, but almost all boys, whether they mean to or not, do not go as hard against a girl as they might a boy.
Ever since girls have been playing sports, and even more so since the passing of Title IX, the debate of girls playing on a boys sports team has been a hot one. In my eyes, there isn’t even a real argument to be made. It is frowned upon for boys to play on girls teams, so why let the girls play on boys teams? By the end of high school, boys are, on average, just bigger and stronger than girls. and it pulls many of the great competitors from the girls teams.
If you asked people what they thought if they saw a boy playing on an all girls team, almost everyone would say that it would be unfair, since boys, on average, are bigger, faster, and stronger than the girls, and that he is putting all the…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Ethics and Issues in Sport Interview

...Ethics and Issues in Sport Project 1 I interviewed my Mother. In England sport is really not very popular for girls in high school or college, back before 1980's and still to this day, not only the women but also for the men. Club teams are whats important and school sports are around but are more just for a bit of fun. Girls seem to be more interested in the girly things in life and the majority of the girls would not even enjoy participating during Physical Education class. My mum was slightly different and was a slight tomboy, she is the youngest child of 4 and she has 2 older sisters and the oldest of them all is her brother. My mum looked up to her brother the most with him being oldest and this is where her tomboy personality came into effect. She told me that during high school she liked to participate in P.E class and she also played street hockey for the school after hours on a small team of girls and boys. They played inner squad games between each other and was non contact but still quite tactical. There was one teacher at her school who did take it seriously and wanted the children to be involved with the school sports and he was also the coach for the boys soccer team. There were no real facilities for hockey just a painted area on the concrete where they held recess. She also told me that none of the school teams were taken seriously, and the soccer team was one of the only sports to actually go and play other schools in the surrounding area, but still...

Words: 668 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Rules and Guidelines in Cheer Dancing

...level. (Spotters/lifters can be boy or girl) Dancers (boys and girls); Pep squad (mixed; maximum of 20 members) 2. There shall be no limit on instruments (tape, drums, guitar, keyboard, etc.) to be used in the cheer dancing presentation, as well as in the number of props (except for hazardous ones). 3. Only light apparatus are allowed for the cheering presentation such as ribbons, dumbbells, small flags and the like. 4. A number shall include choreography of the following: * More or less 20% for gymnastic skills (basic positions, stunts, floor skills, tumbling, pyramid building, etc.) In pyramid building, the highest level can only reach up to 2nd level including the base. Basket tossing is not allowed. * More or less 80% for dance skills (aerobics, jazz, modern dance, social dances, etc.) 5. Criteria for the performance in cheer dancing are as follows: * Choreography - 45% * Overall Impact/Projection - 15% * Synchronization - 10% * Costume - 10% * Voice Quality - 10% * Clarity of Cheer - 10% 100% 6. The duration of the presentation will be a minimum of 3 minutes and a maximum of 5 minutes including the entrance and exit sequences. There will be a 0.5 point deduction for every excess of 10 seconds. 7. Production of costumes will depend upon the team’s chosen supplier. Thus, the team is authorized ......

Words: 1868 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Gender Equity in Sports

...Gender Equity in Sports Colleen Iardella American Military University Gender equity in sports describes an environment in which fair and equitable distribution of overall athletic opportunities, benefits, and resources is available to women and men and in which student athletes, coaches, and athletics administrators are not subject to gender-based discrimination. Title IX, passed in 1972 at the pinnacle of the women’s rights movement, banned sex discrimination in any federally financed education program. It threw into quick relief the imbalanced treatment of male and female athletes on college campuses. Ever since Congress passed the federal gender-equity law, universities have opened their gyms and athletic fields to millions of women who previously did not have chances to play. But as women have surged into a greater part on campus in recent years, many institutions have resorted to deception to make it look as if they are offering more sports to women. Throughout this paper I will discuss the issues of gender equity in sports. I will mention what equal opportunities women have to play sports and how they can develop the psychological, physiological and sociological impact from sports participation. Females are playing team sports more now than they were a decade ago and far more women will play team sports in the next decade. In the Sporting Goods Manufacturers Association's (SGMA) study, the authors analyzed many team sports and the role that......

Words: 2350 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Women and Sports

...pastime, the sport of baseball has been cultivated and altered to amputate women exuding the masculinity of baseball. The emergence of baseball as popular and profitable sport has failed to acknowledge and highlight the athletic abilities women. Instead its conception has affirmed women to be fragile and it has also depicted women to not have the skills or talents to play and compete alongside men. There are numerous individuals who are opposed to fusion of women and men on the baseball field. These individuals use demeaning stereotypes and beliefs to support their claims. Often these claims are false and are not supported by factual or scientific data. For example these claims say that women are weaker than men, women are not physically capable of playing sports, or a woman's place is in the home rather than on the playing field. These claims have been in existence since the beginning of time and have filtered into the arena of baseball. These claims are used as agencies to enforce the superiority of men and the inferiority of women.  Those who are opposed to the idea of men and women playing baseball together, often defend their argument with the belief that women are not physical capable of participating in sports. In addition they often entice the belief that women are more susceptible to injury than men. This is not a valid reason to exclude women and there is an abidance of research that refutes this claim. In addition to excluding women based on their sex, the sport......

Words: 2816 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Picture Essays

...of condition; (ii) inequality of opportunity Gender discrimintaition Symbolize inequity in power – holding all sports Ahead start why? – inequality of capability. Write a four-page essay based on the photo. In the body of your essay, begin by explaining how the image symbolizes inequity. Next, argue for what you believe to be the ultimate cause/causes of the inequity. Finish off the body of the essay with a brief account of what you think should be done to help resolve the inequity. The body of your essay should make up about three and a half pages. Finally, write a short introductory paragraph in which you briefly describe the circumstances under which you took the photo and state your thesis (in a sentence or two) about the ultimate cause/causes of the inequity, and a short conclusion paragraph in which you emphasize what you believe to be the most important points in the essay. Intro Over time the types of physical activity inequities in sports have become better understood and recognized by our changing society. I took this photo because it captures inequity of ‘condition’ and ‘opportunity’ on a basketball court in the west end of Toronto. IWhile I was there it dawned on me that the ultimate causes of these inequities were class discrimination and the false ideology of his incapability to successfully keep up with the rest of the boys who were playing. Therefore the inequity of condition and the inequity of opportunity have prevented him from......

Words: 2490 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Academic Success Among Boys

...public school system for the decline of academic success among boys. However, this assumption is incorrect and the decline in academic success is due to more obvious reasons. Public school systems allow both genders to receive the same education so the “gender disparity” Ann Hulbert presents is false. What holds boys back from academic success is simply their engagement in sports and videogames, the fact that girls are more encouraged to rise above, and most importantly the boundaries boys place on themselves. In our society boys are expected to be involved in a sport and spend endless hours playing videogames. These activities have become more accepted and now have taken up the time that boys should be using to do school work or studying. Paul Theroux, author of “Being a Man”, says “I was told to take up a sport, get more fresh air, join the boys scouts and I was urged not to read so much” (1985). The fact is, sports are more important than school in boys’ minds. Also, in order to be “masculine” and get girls’ attention, boys assume they should not be academically successful. “In a nutshell, the girls liked the jocks the best, and sometimes decide to give the time of day to the other team, the computer nerds” (Walker, 2004). After playing sports and videogames the last thing boys want to do is crack open their books and study. Sports and video games contribute to the decline of academic success among boys. While boys have become content with average academic......

Words: 702 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay


...friend Maria Sandoval. She was different from all the other girls. As a young girl she have always admired baseball. Baseball by so far has always been the greatest sport that she have encountered in her life. Now where she stand in life and taking Theory of Coaching baseball class made her realize that she can go for more than just one career. To her baseball was not just a sport but a way of being discipline, and building up a character. There was a time in her life where she felt a bit out of place due to the fact that she would not play with other girls, but much rather hang out with the boys.       In our free times we always used to go to the park and play baseball. I always teased her that she should play for the boys. And well it was no longer a teasing matter when our coach decided to bring her on boys team. At that time I was really happy for her. She was a very good player, she had all the attributes and fully deserved it to be on the team. Before the game she always used to visualize the field, the smell of grass being wet in the mornings for practice, the fresh breezy air, the sound of aluminum bat hitting the baseball, that sounds very define in the ear. Being the only girl in an all boys teams, she could see how her mother was proud of her not just being in a sport but staying out of trouble. Staying productive was her mother's goal for her. Baseball was a thing in her life that was not just a sport, but a way to be disciplined, motivated physically,......

Words: 519 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Writing Assignment

...dominant sport. She would sit down at the poker table with all other men, and take all the wrong things the men would say to her or about her. If anyone was was subject to stereotype threat it was her. In the podcast, she describes three ways she would separate the different stereotypes she experienced. I can only imagine how hard it was for Annie to stay in and finish off some of those games. It would have been so much easier for her to quit the rounds and leave. Annie could have allowed the stereotypes that the other men had about her get to her head and cause her to play bad and even quit playing altogether, but she didn’t. She overcame the stereotype threat by letting those stereotypes about her being a girl work to her advantages. Annie thought about each of the men at the table and essentially thought about how she could play them. She knew how to separate her emotional reaction and think about how she could use it to her advantage. Recently this past fall I played on the boys tennis team. At our TVC conferences of all the teams there I was the only girl. I knew that just joining my own team at my school would be hard, but I didn’t care. I know that some guys had big egos and would say, there's no way I'm losing to a girl. But that only gave me the energy to win more. Like mentioned in the podcast where Annie learned how to use the stereotypes to her advantages I like to think so did I. Just like in the movies where a girl tries out for a guy's dominated sport where......

Words: 644 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

The Great Tackle

...and appearance or more importantly about the gender in question. Then when and why, did football become a man’s sport? For women who choose to ignore that stereotype, pursuing the sport professionally or even as a hobby in India can prove to be an uphill task. As a girl who plays football as a hobby and pursues it as a distant professional dream, stepping out onto a field dominated by the opposite sex can be mortifying and exhilarating at the same time. In a country like India, that is traditionally and educationally rigid, girls playing football is considered a rarity. In Bangalore schools specifically, the Physical Training instructors tend to stick to the gender assigned sports and those who deviate receive a sever tongue lashing. Having played for the Karnataka state team, my first encounter with stereotyping as a hurdle and how I jumped it not-so-gracefully but while creating controversy nonetheless was in school itself. Only after the boys of my school vouched for capabilities was I allowed to be a part of the house team, an opportunity that was earlier that was not available to girls. Now it seems like a trivial achievement, but its magnitude then was colossal. Chitra Gangadharan, a veteran who coaches the Karnataka Senior Women's Football Team and the South zone of the Sports Authority of India and who also in her days was selected to the All Asian Star team, is a coach that is close to my heart, having trained under her for 2 years. Directing both men and women on......

Words: 875 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay


...male or females. For example, one of the students received a paper with a hard, and tough and rough around the edges “unknown girl”. She has tattoos, worked at bar, and slept with many people. The majority of the class guess second male and when asked why they answered more men are lowlifes like the person described, and they hang out at bars. This example absolutely ties in the second essay by Rosenfeld and links it with the first essay by Mitchell. “ Re-examining the plight of Young males” talks about how males, as well as females, are defined by certain traits. If you are a boy and like pink, why does everyone automatically assume you are gay? Rosenfeld takes the next step into answering questions throughout her essay that Mitchell has you asking but never quite getting the answers. This is why the essays go so well together they complement each others’ works very nicely. Instead of Rosenfeld saying exactly what Mitchell said, in that identity is being defined by gender and sex, she goes the next step and talks about why they become defined the ways they do. A big factor Rosenfeld feels is environmental. Boys do not have an older man in the family to look up to in many cases, making them the man of the household. Many boys become troubled inside and out of school in this situation, unfortunately, and boys become targeted as “misfits” and “trouble makers”. Parent......

Words: 1143 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

What’s Wrong with School Systems Today?

...talking about sports. Sports in most public high school allow most kids to just slid by with their grades. I asked my boss at work once, how his school treated sports players. He answered “well I played both football and baseball so I didn’t have to do crap in school they just let my slid by with the easiest class.” He also added that “even if you were failing a class if you were valuable to the team the coach would call your teacher and tell her to give you a D for right now so you could play.” If you ask me that is kind of messed up like in the section of the book They Say I Say, by Gerald Graff and Cathy Birkenstein. The authors state “what happened to personal responsibility” this it talking about why do people take responsibility for their own actions and that is so true. If you do this then what are you teaching these kids? Are you teaching them to work hard for their grades or are you teaching them to just be good in one category in their lives? If you think you are actually going to go pro here are so statics from the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA). Estimated Probability of Competing in Athletics beyond the High School Interscholastic Level. “Three in 10,000, or approximately 0.03 percent of high school senior boys playing interscholastic basketball will eventually be drafted by an NBA team.” “One in 5,000, or approximately 0.02 percent of high school senior girls playing interscholastic basketball will eventually be drafted by a WNBA team.”......

Words: 1252 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Media Research

...comedy show in which the father of three girls offers his perspective regarding day-to-day situations that families are dealing with, in today’s society. In the episode “Here’s the Kicker” the family has to deal with the decision of the youngest female member of joining the men varsity football team (Shipley & Pasquin, 2014). Gender Stratification in Today’s Media According to Helsin (2009), “It is not the work that provides prestige, but the sex with which the work is associated” (p. 303); therefore, as Linton and Rosaldo noted (as cited in Helsin, 2009), “Universally, greater prestige is given to male activities – regardless of what those activities are”. An example of the previous is given during the episode “Here’s the Kicker”, because the parents disregard the accomplishment in fashion of their middle daughter as soon as the younger daughter mention she joined the men football team and her interest in the military. Furthermore, according to the perspective of the oldest daughter, women should not join “men teams”, because that would be accepting that female competitive teams are not as good as male teams, and another character noted that a “girl in a football team is a gimmick” (Shipley & Pasquin, 2014). Nevertheless, this is not limited to this television show, because the lineup of television networks like ESPN provides more coverage for men sports than women sports (ESPN, 2014); therefore, reinforcing the idea that men sports in general are of most......

Words: 900 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Title Ix

...shows how many people worked rigorously to get the law passed. Furthermore, Title IX’s numerous tests show how verify schools complying with the law. Lastly, Title IX has increased the participation of women in athletics significantly over the past forty years. Title IX, the controversial federal civil rights act, has shaped athletics to how they are today by creating equal opportunities for female athletes. Flashback forty-one years to before Title IX changed the lives girls and women forever. Girls were not encouraged to play sports at a young and scholarships were not available for women to play athletics in college. People like Pat Summitt, arguably one of the best women’s basketball coaches ever, was not receiving fair treatment while playing collegiate basketball. In 1972, before Title IX was signed, Summitt played basketball for the University of Tennessee-Martin. The team was given uniforms that were used in the Physical Education classes and placed numbers on the back with tape. Also, when the team traveled to away games, they stayed the night in their opponent’s gym and slept on sleeping bags (Soup). Little did the athletes know, their lives would drastically change for the better the following year. Assuredly, Title IX was not drafted in one night. It took many people numerous hours and a lot of passion to bring this law to life. Bernice “Bunny” Sandler first thought of the idea for law after she was denied tenure for being “too strong for a woman” (Wulf).......

Words: 2712 - Pages: 11

Free Essay


...College hoops' black coaching issue Myron Medcalf [ARCHIVE] | July 18, 2013 When a national sportswriter calls to talk about minority hiring in college basketball, folks of all races seem to get nervous. As I sought feedback following last week's release of the "2012 Racial and Gender Report Card: College Sport" by Central Florida's Institute for Diversity and Ethics in Sport -- the report excludes historically black colleges and universities -- which states that the current pool of Division I African-American head coaches (18.6 percent through the 2011-12 season) is at its lowest mark since the 1995-96 season, people weren't sure what, if anything, they should say. Multiple administrators passed on the opportunity. The NCAA wanted to see my questions, and then it wanted a pre-interview phone conversation before it ultimately emailed its responses. The coaches who talked on the record always ended our chats with the same concern: "I didn't say anything that will make me look bad, right?" Shaka Smart Andy Lyons/Getty Images To reach Shaka Smart's level, black coaches often have to overcome certain labels. I don't blame them. It's an incendiary issue, because we're uncomfortable with race as dialogue. It's still a subject that makes athletic directors -- 89 percent of whom are white at the Division I level, per the report -- squirm. Minority coaches speak cautiously, because they don't want to be labeled as rebels or militants. That......

Words: 8597 - Pages: 35

Free Essay


...The need for comprehensive wellness programs in Canadian workplaces and diversified physical activity among Canadian boys and girls IGWEAGU Kenechukwu O. 7692210 PERS 1200 Reflection 2 30/10/15 The need for comprehensive wellness programs in Canadian workplaces and diversified physical activity among Canadian boys and girls Talking about the Epidemiological transition, countries in the age of pestilence and famine cannot progress from this stage unless they target the spread of infectious diseases through improvements in sanitation and public health and by stabilization of food supply. Similarly, western countries in the stage of degenerative and man-made diseases must make active efforts to move to the next stage, if the next stage is going to be the stage of delayed degenerative disease. These countries moved from the first to the second to the third stage by making good decisions about the country’s organization and control. There was a clear goal in sight, and then a group of concise plans to achieving the different components of the singular goal. The singular goal was to reduce the mortality rates of people living in that country. In other to achieve this death must be reduced by reducing its causes. “Life expectancy at birth in the United States was 77.8 years in 2004, which is a dramatic increase from 49.2 years in 1900 to 1902.” The paper attempts to use this information as well as information about the trend in the physical activity levels of to establish......

Words: 1075 - Pages: 5