Premium Essay

Goodness Has Nothing to Do with It

In:

Submitted By Prateeksha
Words 753
Pages 4
Essay The First – Goodness has nothing to do with it

Utilitarianism is the theory of taking the proper course of action that maximizes utility, resulting in maximum happiness and a reduction in suffering. This article presents an ethical dilemma raising the question, whether or not to push the stranger onto the tracks thus killing him but saving five other lives.

Looking at this scenario and viewing it from different perspectives, the man should not be pushed off the bridge. For a utilitarian, the only morally significant factor is the number of lives that are saved regardless of how they are saved. There needs to be an emphasis on the rules and obligations with respect to morality to guide conduct and morally forbid certain actions. The utilitarian approach of John Stuart Mill is that one should always act; not only to increase one’s own happiness but to maximize overall happiness and the pain or pleasure of others must be taken into account equally. Taking this into consideration, it would be fair to say that the classic utilitarian would kill the fat stranger instead of the five as only one person will endure the pain and suffering. This is where utilitarian reasoning is morally incorrect as it shows the lack of empathy and distances the protagonist from his moral values and beliefs.

Human beings cannot make perfectly objective decisions because we let our emotions rule over our reasoning. Pushing a fat man to his death with our bare hands would set off an emotional alarm in my brain and hence, such utilitarian reasoning does not inspire strong moral convictions. Mill views social utility as "preserving the peace and harmony" but actively killing a person is a direct infringement of his rights and a severe violation to society. If we continue to have such a society where we always act for the greater good where we kill innocent people, the minority

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Sovereignty In Religion

...credentials and experiences of a surgeon before allowing him to your perform surgery? Knowing a surgeon is a qualified expert creates a sense of peace and confidence for the patient. Who is this God we should trust? The more we know of God's character, the more we are open to trusting Him during our trials. God wants us to trust Him, “Trust in the Lord with all your heart and do not lean on your understanding.” Proverb 3:5 This lesson focuses on three pertinent characteristics of God: His Sovereignty His Wisdom His Goodness God’s Sovereignty Definitions of sovereignty: “Supreme and independent power or authority in a state.” “Sovereignty of God, his absolute right to do all things...

Words: 1435 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Is God Good ?

...‘God is good’ is by creation in genesis 1 and 2 which shows God either creating the world or how he is crafting everything, also in the bible of how God has preformed miracles and in todays society. In the bible there are many passages, which say ‘God is good’ for example in James ‘every good thing bestowed and every perfect gift is from above, coming down from the Father of lights, with whom there is no variation, or shifting shadow’ this is clearly saying that God is the source of goodness. Another example is the goodness of God is a character trait, which applies to every other attribute. God’s wrath is good. God’s holiness is good. God’s righteousness is good. God is good in His entirety. There is nothing about God that is not good (Romans), this is basically saying that the goodness of God is a life-transforming truth and that we should use the words of God in are attitudes and actions. The Ten Commandments are the clear example of God setting the standards of what is morally right and wrong. We follow these laws that God has set because we believe that they show us are sins and if we follow these laws that we will be reward towards the light. These Commandments show us the righteous side of being a human being, and that we should follow them because God has set them however God was the one who gave us free will to do what we want but with this free will we must follow what is right in life for example ‘Thou shalt not kill’...

Words: 1287 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Transcendental Properties of Being

...into a mere difference of differences, but in the sense that it would raise this science to a higher kind of unity according to an order of different degrees of being as they relate to a primary analogate as the one to which all relate more or less distantly. To delve more deeply into this analogous subject of consideration one must further distinguish transcendental properties that follow being in its analogous and transcendental sense. In the end, when the question of a first, universal cause of being as being, or of a summit of being that would be totally transcendent, is finally raised, all of this a priori conception of being as analogous according to different degrees with its corresponding degrees of oneness, activity, truth and goodness must be brought into play in relation to things as they come under sense experience as moved, caused, contingent and exhibiting different degrees of perfection in being such as living, sensing and rational consciousness, in order to conclude to the truth of the proposition “God is.” The Concept of Being Being is a nature in the first cause, but in all other things, it is present as a participated act and not as nature or part of a nature. Being is predicable of all things whatsoever. Therefore it is not confined to any one of the...

Words: 2742 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

The Goodness of God

...phrase “God is good” The goodness of God is first revealed in his actions as a Creator. Genesis chapters 1-3 contain the Creation story. God created the world out of nothing – “creation ex nihilo”. Each act of creation is seen to be good. "And he saw that it was good" (Genesis 1: 10). The end result of God's creation is the Earth and mankind. Everything created was made for man to take control of. God is the image of goodness and as mankind was created in the image of God. (Genesis 1:27, "God created man in his own image.") This tells humans that they are required to be good, as good as God.  Exodus 20 describes the Ten Commandments given to the Hebrews by God. Moses received the commandments by revelation from God on the peak of Mount Sinai. They were guidelines given for God’s people to live by. The underlying principle is that humans are to be good and being good means following the Ten Commandments. God's goodness demands that mankind worship only one God and nothing or nobody else "You shall have no other gods before me and you shall not make for yourself an idol." (Exodus 20: 3-4). These commandments show that God is the primary source governing how people should lead their lives because God is entirely good. The Ten Commandments show man how to be good by giving strict guidelines. (Thou shalt not murder; thou shalt not commit adultery; thou shalt not steal). God’s goodness demands a response. It includes the will to punish, so that goodness is combined with justice. The...

Words: 1393 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Henry David Thoreau Kind-Hearted People

...without money to get something to eat or drink. Most just wishing they could jump out of the rat race just as Henry David Thoreau. Yet not all of our society has the same outlook on “goodness is the only investment that never fails” (Thoreau). Most of our society see the less fortunate but never think twice about being kind. However, there is always a few who see the less fortunate as equal to themselves. One thing for sure is those who see them as equal are the kind hearted people. Our society does not agree with our opinions. Our society wants us to follow their rules not matter what we think....

Words: 831 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Similarities Between Good And Evil In To Kill A Mockingbird

...Despite those who exercise evil, goodness will always overcome, even if buried deep within. In the story, To Kill a Mockingbird, two characters who seem similar actually are very distinguishable from each other. These characters help the further development of the two primary characters, Scout and Jem. Through these experiences, Scout and Jem develop skills that allow them to better understand people as a whole. These social skills allow Scout and Jem to perceive why specific people are the way they are and allow them to have a better comprehension of the situation as a whole. Through the continuous battle of good and evil, evil can provide a shell on a person who may be truly good, or succumb someone fully to its immoral ways. Mrs. Dubose,...

Words: 861 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Philosophy of Life

...Nowadays, a philosopher is a thinker of non-materialistic subjects like knowledge. Those subjects like science, history, and economics have their own sets of thinkers labelled scientist, historian, economist etc. Gupta is saying that philosophy used to touch on many subjects, and even though these other subjects are not called philosophy, philosophy is in their DNA and always will be. (Gupta, p. 1) Then Gupta gives an example of “Philosophy of Life” he got of the internet, which is “Any philosophical view or vision of the nature or purpose of life or of the way that life should be lived”. (Random House, Inc., 2015) He does not give his own definition on the subject, but he does go on explaining that everyone has his or her own outlook on the philosophy of life, you do not have to be a philosopher to have an opinion on the matter. Some outlooks that people have change over time in a person’s life. They can think on things effecting his or her life and that will nourish their minds, polishing and fine-tuning their philosophy of life. One of the goals in our lives is to find and expand our truth and knowledge about life, and for that veracity, we should never stop searching. (Gupta, p. 2) The next area under discussion is “Hard...

Words: 3060 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Keinkind's Use Of Neglect In Night And Fog

...involved in any killings; however, his silence just capriciously supported the Nazi in his way. He silently falsified the cause of prisoners’ death to cover the sins of Nazi but never told the truth. He could have refused the orders of the Nazi, but he chose to follow the orders. The neglect of one assistant is tiny, but when each assistant contributes to the same kind of neglect, the inaction becomes a source of power. Even though it is hard to expect every ordinary person to challenge the authority directly, but if one wants to make changes or do something for those innocent people, one should always find a way to fight against the wrong. During World War II, there was a doctor named Hans Munch, who worked at Auschwitz concentration camp. When prisoners disembarked on the camp, Nazi always kept strong men alive and executed women and the sick whom they thought to be weaker. Munch refused to judge who should be executed when the Nazi asked him to do so. As a righteous human being, he could not bear to the end of the lives of others in such a brutal way. He was silent as well, but he...

Words: 1741 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Mencius and Xunzi on Cultivation

...shown by Xunzi’s critique of Mencius. It may be perceived that Mencius has the dominant position in the Confucian tradition as Mencius’s belief that human nature is originally good has often been interpreted into certain sayings of Confucius. Additionally, Xunzi’s claim that human nature is “evil” and that people can be transformed to become good may be inconsistent, as they imply Mencius’s claim that human nature is inherently good. For this reason, it is crucial to analyze both thinkers separately as integration of one thinker’s original thought to another may obscure the important aspects of the assimilated thinker’s position. Secondly, this method of analysis will show that the debate is not one conducted from extreme opposites as it may seem at first sight, for both Mencius and Xunzi agreed that man must cultivate his goodness consciously regardless of whether he is born with it or acquires it from the state. The differences in their views on human nature lead to the ultimate difference of interpretation of the betterment of human nature. Although both philosophers had differences, their ultimate goal was to suggest that human beings can be good and this is what the state needed in such a crucial time in China’s history. To elaborate further on human nature, it is crucial to look at its development within each philosopher’s teachings. Mencius, being the idealist that he was, believed in the innate goodness of man. He believed that man's ability to learn how to be a good and...

Words: 2133 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Theology Revision

...Theology Revision Plato Plato lived in Athens in the 5th and 4th Centuries BC He was the student of Socrates and teacher of Aristotle He was a dualist- believed in the body and the soul He believed the soul was more perfect than the body He believed that societies should be run by philosophers He believed the physical world is a pale imitation of the world of the forms The allegory of the cave The prisoners- normal people of society The prisoner who escapes- philosophers, people that thirst to know the real truth The people casting the shadows- the leaders of society- shaping the world without knowing the truth The shadows/statues- what people believe is reality, what they are told to believe, things people deem to be important The cave- a world without knowledge, the physical world/the body The fire- controlled, dim light- limited knowledge. An imitation of the form of the good The journey outside- a difficult journey, acquisition of knowledge The sun- illuminates the true world- form of the good The journey back into the cave- the desire to educate and inform others of the truth The world of the Forms Forms Plato uses the word ‘form’ to describe the true essence of material objects in the world This idea of the ‘form’ exists in a non physical (yet more real) realm that can only be understood by the mind. This is called the world of the forms Plato believed that the forms were interrelated and hierarchical The highest form The ultimate principle...

Words: 5746 - Pages: 23

Premium Essay

Why Is Morality Wrong

...Morality is a separate and distinct being from god they are however symbiotic of each other however it is shown that god doesn’t always follow morality so it can’t possibly be greater than him It could be argued that morality exists separately from god as murder is innately wrong in humanity people detest and are sickened by such actions it is encoded in our human psychology to think murder is wrong if you see a person bleeding you think it is an emergency and act in such a manner as an attempt to preserve life Plato’s form of the good and god in the bible are very similar they are both sources of goodness also they aren’t physical beings and are instead transcendent existing on a different plain from our existence however the form of the...

Words: 421 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Good Will

...should be used to judge the moral worth of certain actions has remained debated and controversial over time. Though it is hard to apply in real life, I personally believe that the moral worth of an action should be determined by the motivation and intention that initiated it, but not by the consequences or influences that the action brings about. I will illustrate my reasoning by focusing on Kant’s views on good will and moral worth, along with some real life examples, Socrates’s discussion on differences between mere true belief and real knowledge of virtue and several other philosophers’ unique interpretations and related discussions on this topic. Kant makes a clear argument about good will in the very beginning of his book Grounding for the Metaphysics of Morals. He explicitly states that: “There is no possibility of thinking anything at all in the world, or even out of it, which can be regarded as good without qualification, except a good will. (Kant 7)” Kant believes that a good will is always morally good. Therefore, what a good will does is always morally good as well. Also, he obviously takes good will as the only true standard to judge the moral worth of a certain action. He explains that everything that seems to be good by itself actually could only be good if they are driven by a good will; without a good will, these other things might be used to produce negative outcomes. Except for a good will, nothing else would be good simply on its own. For example, loyal...

Words: 2916 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Stylistic Analysis of Various Types of Essays

...STYLISTIC ANALYSIS OF VARIOUS TYPES OF ESSAYS In this chapter we describe different forms and styles of essay writing. These forms and styles are used by a range of authors, including university students and professional essayists. To characterize the peculiar features of the admission essay we would like to make stylistic analyses of an article. App. 1] The beginning of an essay, paragraph 1, is essential to making a good impression. We have elevated the level of diction here and improved the pacing to construct a more fluid beginning, including this sentence: "The injury itself was tendonitis, an elusive malady, not easy to pin down like a simple broken bone." Also, we have introduced a metaphor that will help the reader understand the seriousness of the injury, characterizing the pain as "a knife in my mind, sinking deeper the more I struggled." This will make it that much more impressive when you overcome the arm injury through sheer perseverance later in the essay. In the paragraph 2, a number of overly short sentences here have been combined into longer, more sophisticated phrasings. One example is: "I thought about how many famous soccer players are equally skilled with both feet, and wondered: could I learn to throw left-handed?" These changes help with both word count and readability issues. We have also eliminated or limited repetition by replacing the overused "frustrated" a variety of more illustrative phrasings. Paragraph...

Words: 2587 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

God's Attributes

...in which to do so. Grudem tries to find a way to explain this problem by using communicable and incommunicable attributes. In the handouts, incommunicable is defined as absolute and God chooses not to share them with others, communicable is defined as relative and are the attributes that God chooses to share with others. These attributes are how God chooses to communicate who He is with the world and allow us to better understand Him. The incommunicable attributes that I see most in God are His eternity and His omnipresence. When I think of these attributes and God, I feel that I can better comprehend God. By using eternity and omnipresence to get to know God better, I can have a better faith in knowing that He is always with me and He will never leave me. When talking about a God that is eternal, you must understand that means that God had no beginning and will have no end. To explain God’s eternity Grudem states, “To be “infinite” is to unlimited, and this doctrine teaches that time does not limit God or change him in any way.” If God is infinite then time, as it does to humans on earth, does not apply to Him. We see a day as one rotation of the earth and a year as one rotation around the sun, which is defiantly not how God sees time pass. God, on the other hand, can see any point in time as He sees fit. God knows exactly what is taking place and with his omnipresence can know exactly what needs to be done. Omnipresence is a concept that has baffled many...

Words: 1515 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

You Know

... Now think of the four major religions: ● ● ● ● Hinduism Buddhism Islam Christianity Which one should you choose? Before you decide, here’s some information that will help you determine which one is the wisest choice: All of For most of humanity stands on the humanity, death is edge of eternity. We are all a huge and terrify- going to die. We will all have to pass through the ing plummet into door of death. It could happen to us in twenty years, the unknown. or in six months, . . . or today. For most of humanity, death is a huge and terrifying plummet into the unknown. So what should we do? Do you remember how it was your knowledge of the jump that produced that healthy M 2 fear, and that fear helped you to make the right choice? You know what the law of gravity can do to you. In the same way, we are going to look at another law, and hopefully your knowledge of what it can do to you will help you make the right choice, about life’s greatest issue. So, stay with me—and remember to let fear work for you. THE LEAP After we die we have to face what is called “the law of sin and...

Words: 3631 - Pages: 15