Free Essay

Government Regulations and Elder Care

In: Social Issues

Submitted By missbett
Words 860
Pages 4
Government Regulations and Elder Care

The recent array of Medicare proposals on Capitol Hill focus on the provision of prescription drugs. While this sounds good, seniors should be aware that most of these proposals also include restrictive drug formularies, or preferred drug lists. These would restrict their access to new and effective prescription drugs.
The purpose of these formularies is to control costs. However, research has shown that restrictions on prescription drugs will increase overall health care costs; drive up the utilization of other medical services, including hospitalization; and result in adverse outcomes for patients' health. The evidence also indicates that restrictive drug formularies have a greater negative impact on senior citizens than the younger patients
Seniors have a large stake in the design of a Medicare prescription drug benefit because some of them think that they will still be able to have any drug that they need, without restriction, but they are gravely mistaken.
The major Medicare prescription drug bills that are now under consideration in Congress focus on controlling the cost of medications. In order for this to happen, they would rely upon three basic methods: 1. restricting new drugs in favor of generic drugs; 2. limiting patients to one or two drugs of a particular kind (based on the assumption that all medicines in a group are more or less interchangeable); and 3. replacing the judgments made by physicians and their patients with those of a committee far removed from the actual medical problem.
Most members of Congress support these formularies. They are ignoring studies that suggest that limiting the elderly to older drugs or restricting their access to certain medications would compromise their health and ultimately increase their total health care costs. While the most expensive drug is not always the best drug for a medical condition, research clearly shows that the introduction of new drugs has been associated with a general improvement in patients' well-being, better care, and a decline in total treatment costs in dealing with numerous diseases. These diseases include depression, schizophrenia, cancer, HIV, heart disease, and also ear infection. (Horn, 1998)
Formulary restrictions are likely to provide only "second-best" drug therapy, especially in the case of the elderly. Restricted formularies limit the choices a patient has within a particular class of drugs. In some cases, seniors could be forced to choose a drug that leads to other illnesses that require a doctor's attention or even hospitalization.
Not only do formulary limitations and therapeutic substitution place the elderly at particular risk, they also ultimately increase the total cost of their medical care.
The significant associations between formulary restrictions in a drug class and the greater utilization of health-care services were often greater for elderly patients.
In comparison with younger patients, seniors who were faced with formulary restrictions were twice as likely to be hospitalized or to go to the emergency room for treatment.
The fewer drugs seniors were able to choose from, the more likely they were to use inappropriate and more expensive medical services.
Greater limitations for the drug class of anti-ulcer drugs were associated with higher total drug costs for both elderly and non-elderly patients. However, greater limitations within the drug classes of propionic acids, immediate-release theophylline, and diuretics were associated with higher medical costs for elderly patients, but not for non-elderly patients.
Most of these proposals would limit patient choice. They would take the decisions regarding the drugs that should be prescribed out of the arena of physician-patient consultation. Such provisions for prescription drugs in Medicare would have adverse outcomes including a rise in total health care costs and the well-being of millions of Americans would be jeopardized. Horn, 1996)
In order to resolve these issues, Congress should go back to the drawing board to develop a plan to provide prescription drug coverage to Medicare patients. They should not tinker with restrictive formularies or try to design a stand-alone benefit with separate premiums and co-payment arrangements. Legislators should work to place prescription drug coverage into existing insurance plans. This will allow the health plans to develop a regimen of disease-management programs that incorporate drug treatment.
A model for such Medicare reform already exists in the Federal Employees Health Benefits Program, the consumer-driven health program that covers Members of Congress and federal workers and retirees. All of the health plans of the FEHBP provide prescription drug coverage, and the enrollees can choose the specific prescription drug coverage that best meets their needs. (Antos & Turner, 2002).

Reference Page 1. Antos, Joseph R., & Turner, Grace-Marie. (September 5, 2002). “What Congress Should Do About Prescription Drugs for Seniors”. American Enterprise Institution. 2. Horn, S.D., Sharkey, P.D., & Phillips-Harris, C. (August, 1998). “Fomulary Limitations in the Elderly: Results from the Managed Care Outcomes Project”. American Journal of Managed Care. Vol. 4. No.8. 3. Horn, S.D., Sharkey, P.D., Tracey, D.M., James, B., & Goodwin, F. (March, 1996). “Intended and Unintended Consequences of HMO Cost-Contained Strategies: Results from the Managed Care Outcomes Project”. American Journal of Managed Care. Vol. 2. No.3.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Elder Abuse in Residential Care Facilities

...Elder Abuse in Residential Care Facilities Elder abuse is a catch all term referring to any deliberate or negligent act by a care giver or any other individual that results in harm or a major risk of harm to a vulnerable adult over the age of 60 years (Stefanacci & Haimowitz, 2013, p. 68). Under the umbrella definition for elder abuse, more specific types of abuse can be identified such physical abuse, sexual abuse, emotional abuse, exploitation, neglect and abandonment (Stefanacci & Haimowitz, 2013, p. 68). The physical abuse refers to the infliction, or threat to inflict, physical harm onto an elderly individual or the deprivation of their basic needs. Sexual abuse is defined as any form of nonconsensual sexual contact. Exploitation refers to the illegal misuse, theft, or concealment of an elderly individual’s funds, assets, or property. Neglect is the failure or refusal of a formal or informal caregiver to supply the vulnerable elder in their care with shelter, food, health care, or protection. Abandonment refers to the desertion of the vulnerable elder by either a legal custodian or anyone who has assumed responsibility for their care (Stefanacci & Haimowitz, 2013, p. 68). Residential care facilities (RCFs) have a multitude of different names across the Unites States but are most commonly referred to as assisted living facilities (ALFs), adult congregate living facilities, domiciliary care homes, and shelter care homes. Since the mid 1990’s, RCFs have made up one...

Words: 2314 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Hsm210 - Wk 4 - Examining Government Regulations for the Elderly

...Examining Government Regulations for the Elderly HSM/210 November 8, 2013 Examining Government Regulations for the Elderly In order for any organization to run properly there must be regulations and laws in place. The Human Services Department of any state must adhere to strict guidelines provided by the federal government because if these rules are not followed there would not be enough resources to help every individual that desperately needs it. Therefore, in order to prevent to rise of elder abuse as our aging population continues to grow by the thousands each day, there must be some changes made to our existing social policies in order for these people to have their needs met. With this said, my target population in week two was the elderly population. With the ever growing number of people reaching retirement age each year since 2011 when the generation known as the Baby Boomers started to retire at the rate of almost 10,000 per day, many of these elderly people must rely on the services provided by their local human services organizations. In the state of Missouri alone, where I live, Missouri’s elderly population, which is defined by those age 65 and older, is expected to rise significantly over the next several years, from less than 15 percent of the state population in the year 2000 to over 20 percent of the population by the year 2030 (Missouri Senior Report, 2013). However, the needs of the elderly population vary greatly because the youngest...

Words: 861 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Administrative Ethnic Paper

... 2013 Susan Morgan Administrative Ethic Paper 2 The thought of abuse in elderly are very disturbing but it does happen. They are very vulnerable and dependent on other people to function in everyday life. Resident abuse in nursing homes facility or home care facility is a problem all over the world, but has become less of a concern in America, because the Department of Health Services become very strict on rules and regulation for nursing home and home care. This is for the protection of elderly and to provide the best care for them and have a quality of living. Nursing homes provide best patient care and services for elder patients and well being of these residents are provided. Most of the workers in the nursing home are caring, compassionate and conscientious and help their patients in their everyday life from bathing, eating, activities, and total patient care if needed. However, some time in other facility, staff, fellow residents or sometimes visitors to the facility may be guilty of abusing patients in some point, this will cost a lot because it is a federal felony to abuse a patient and may cause jail time and penalty. Different Types of Elder Abuse: •Physical Abuse: The most common type of abuse in elderly. This is a type of abuse that the caregiver force the senior citizen to do something that the caregiver wants him to do. Physical abuse can be hitting, pushing, confining and restraining the elderly. •Emotional...

Words: 1274 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Elder Abuse

...Unavailable Health Care: A Nurse’s Problem In the year 2000, it was reported that 44% of residents were abused and 95% were neglected and also witnessed someone else being neglected. According to the National Center on Elder Abuse, elder abuse is common is in community settings such as nursing homes. These numbers are part of many reasons why others do not receive the proper health care that is needed. Not only is it absurd for these statistics to be high, but it also is absurd for these two statistics to be within the healthcare profession. With the baby booming population being at an all-time high, many of them turn to long-term living facilities. Being that nurses are more hands on with patients in any facility, but more importantly, being more involved with older patients in LTCF (long-term care facilities), it is crucial that we examine the reasoning behind these numbers. This is a representation of the lack of passion, integrity, and proper education regarding the profession of nursing. With the exception of not having anyone else to care for them full time, residents have no choice in how much they may depend on a nurse. Due to things such as chronic illnesses, mental disorders, and psychological deformities, the residents of rehabilitation centers and long term care facilities instills trust with the nurses. The humility of the resident leaves their vulnerability levels to be heightened in the nursing and resident relationship. Vulnerability within the resident opens...

Words: 1042 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Elderly Care

...Elderly Care Ethical issue Paper Oshein Robinson Abstract When we are talking about the word neglect or abuse it is usually associated with woman, children and or animals. We forget to think about elderly abuse, which is overlooked because there is plenty of elderly who can look after themselves and still be a valuable part of society, but we forget the ones who are not capable of that. This paper is about raising concern about the ethical issues of elderly being abused and mistreated. Table of Contents Introduction 4 Physical Abuse 5 PYCHOLOGICAL ABUSE 6 neglect & Financial ABUSE 6 Sexual abuse 6 scope of the problem 7 SOLUTION 8 Conclusion 8 Citations 10 Introduction Elder Abuse is any form of mistreatment that results in harm or loss to an older person, elder abuse can be divided into the categories of physical abuse which is physical force that results in any bodily injury or pain this can be assault battery, and inappropriate restraint. Psychological and or emotional abuse which is tearing down their self-esteem, and belittling them. Neglect which is just providing the necessities for everyday living such as food, shelter, health care or protection. Sexual abuse can also be elder abuse it is still non-consensual. Last there is exploitation which is illegal taking of senior benefits. Each year hundreds up to thousands of elders are abused, and neglected for many victims they cannot help themselves since they are older and frail. In...

Words: 1982 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Indoor vs Outdoor Tanning

...ELDER ABUSE IN NURSING HOMES: THE IMPACT OF DEMENTIA/SPECIAL CARE UNITS BY CHRISTINA KAY FALK THESIS Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Science in Community Health in the Graduate College of the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 2013 Urbana, Illinois Adviser: Stephen J. Notaro, Ph.D. ii ELDER ABUSE IN NURSING HOMES: THE IMPACT OF DEMENTIA/SPECIAL CARE UNITS By: Christina K. Falk Elder abuse is a topic that impacts everyone in America at some point in their life. Special care units also called dementia units are protected areas in a nursing home that are specially designed for dementia/Alzheimer patients. This thesis reviewed how a special care unit in a nursing home affect the number and severity of deficiencies reported to Medicare. The data was collected from Medicare’s Nursing Home Compare system and the Illinois Public Health Department. This study reviewed 770 nursing homes in Illinois were reviewed, 141 had special care units during the time of data collection. The facilities had a range of total deficiencies from one to 74 with Level of Harm ratings ranging from one to four on a four-point scale. The results showed that residents in a nursing facility that has a special care unit are at a greater risk of a higher Level of Harm but no difference in the number of deficiencies. Possible causes of this greater risk are due to the intrinsic nature of the population in special care units, the need for policy and procedural...

Words: 14268 - Pages: 58

Premium Essay

Human Resource Management

...BALANCE PROGRAMMES IN UNITED STATES, UNITED KINGDOM AND INDIA A.Chitra Devi, Research scholar, Sathyabama University, Chennai Dr. S.Sheela Rani, Research Guide, Associate Professor, New College Institute of Management, Chennai ABSTRACT Work-life balance is gaining increasing importance and considered to be the most important challenges encountered in the field of Human Resource Management. With the advent of technology, increase in the complexity of work, change in the values and attitudes of the young and energetic work force are some of the factors that compel us to address the work-life balance issue and hence Work-life balance has become one of the foremost work-place issue. To meet the employees’ changing needs, to comply with Government regulations, and to fulfill the broader objective of corporate social responsibility, employers across the world provide several work-life initiatives/ policies and programmes. This article discuss about the various Work-Life Balance Initiatives/Programmes available to employees in United States, United Kingdom and India. Key Words: Work-Life Balance, Work-Life Balance Initiatives/ Programmes INTRODUCTION Work-life balance issues have been particularly strong in developed countries where they are pushed high on political agenda. But this problem is not expressed to the equal level in developing countries (Catherine Hein, 2005). Today’s employees place more emphasis on quality of working...

Words: 2403 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Auditing - Research Paper

...passed the Sarbanes-Oxley Act its role in the economy was greatly solidified. Auditing is the accumulation and evaluation of evidence about information to determine and report on the degree of correspondence between the information and established criteria. Auditing should be done by a competent, independent person. “The auditing profession offers a wide range of employment opportunities for new accountants. Most accounting firms offer client services in three areas: auditing, tax, and consulting. A new accountant might be hired to work in any of these areas. In the audit area, the accountant may work for a variety of clients including private or public companies, clients in banking, insurance, manufacturing, technology, retail, health care, or government. Individuals working in the audit area may also spend most of their time providing internal audit services to clients rather than working as an external auditor. Working in any of the areas in an accounting firm may be one of the most demanding jobs, but it is also one of the most interesting, exciting experiences and a great way to prepare to work in the corporate business world.” “What is Auditing?” Web. 29 September 2013 Accounting is the recording, classifying, and summarizing of economic events in a logical manner for the purpose of providing financial information for decision making. To provide relevant information, accountants must have a thorough understanding of the principles, and rules that provide the...

Words: 2376 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Auditor Independence

...Running head: AUDITOR INDEPENDENCE Auditor Independence Linda Bell Strayer University Auditing ACC403 Ronal P. Lentz, CPA, PhD March 26, 2010 Auditor Independence After the Enron scandal in late 2001, the government decided that there was a need for more regulations for the accounting profession. The Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 was enacted to ensure more controls on accountants and public companies. One of the issues addressed in the act was the independence of auditors. In 2003 the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) strengthened their regulations regarding auditor’s independence and requires additional disclosures to investors of public companies about the services provided by the independent accounting firms that are hired to audit the companies. The American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA) Code of Professional Conduct has required accountants who perform attest services to be independent of their clients. The Sarbanes-Oxley Act lists the services that auditors can no longer provide to audit clients in Title II. The reasoning for this is that maintaining auditor independence is essential to the audit process. It is necessary for retaining the confidence in the stock market so that the public continues to invest the market. The provision that will have the greatest effect on the accounting profession will be the inability to sell additional services to their current clients and also future clients. (Kleckner & Jackson,...

Words: 1180 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Asian American Studies

...Pei Zhen Qu December 14, 2015 Professor Liu ASIAN 231 Research Paper The life of a Chinese American Growing up in a country where you are a minority amongst many other minorities can be difficult. This can cause many mental illnesses to the families and the individual itself. The United States is a country with many minority groups, one of which includes Chinese Americans. I know myself that it’s hard living in a place where there is racism and stereotypes about Chinese people, since I have been through this. The Chinese community is one of the fastest growing communities in the United States. The Chinese first came to the United States in the middle of the nineteenth century. The reason why they left their home country was due to high taxes, peasant rebellions, family feuds, and poverty. The reason they came to the United States during that time was because of the California Gold Rush and a better economic opportunities. But because there were so many Chinese coming, the people of the United States developed xenophobia (a fear of people from other countries). So 1882, the Chinese Exclusion Act was put upon. But many years later, Chinese Americans were able to slowly to come back into the United States. Living in a different country can be very difficult. Especially if you are a parent trying to raise your children. This can cause a lot of stress because they have to work really hard in order to provide for their family. In “Chinese American Parents’ Acculturation...

Words: 2754 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Aca Analysis

...The Affordable Care Act The Legal Environment of Business September 14th, 2014 Copyright 2014 The Affordable Care Act The Affordable Care Act also called “Obamacare” which was signed by President Barack Obama in 2010. The Affordable Care Act is about the new health insurance, which aims to cover everyone in the United States. “Under the Affordable Care Act, the Federal government, State governments, insurers, employers, and individuals are given shared responsibility to reform and improve the availability, quality, and affordability of health insurance coverage in the United States.” (Reyes, 2013) This article concludes five specific provisions of the Affordable Care Act about improving the quality and efficiency of health care. After that, three regulations based on the Affordable Care Act will be discussed. Finally, the Constitutionality of the ACA will be discussed as it refers to two landmark cases. Five Provisions of the ACA There are many provisions in Affordable Care Act, and all the provisions I choose are from title III—improve the quality and efficiency of health care. In my opinion, the most important factors of health care are the quality and efficiency which are indispensable in the Affordable Care Act. My choices are about the data collection from the patient and privacy protection, the performance report, the treatment for cancer hospitals, prescription drug’s benefit and risk, and guarantee benefit for Medicare. Provision 1. SEC. 399II [42 U...

Words: 3682 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Medicare

...increases the proportion of the population over age of 65 who be eligible for Medicare benefits. The problem with Medicare is that they never made adjustments for people who live longer. Also, there are inadequate funds to meet the needs of the future enrollees. Organization Information Medicare is a national social insurance program. It is administered by the United States federal government and was signed into law on July 30, 1965 by President Lyndon Johnson (CMS, 2012). Currently Medicare covers 60 million Americans. The health insurance is available to individuals 65 years and older. It is an insurance program for which these enrollees have money deducted from their pay while they are still working. The health care insurance covers hospitals, physician’s services, nursing home care or home and community-based services Also, the participant pays part of the services called “deductibles”. Medicare provides health insurance benefits to 38.7 million people age 65 years and older. (Center for Medicare & Medicaid services, 2011). Gist of The Problem The problem with Medicare is that the regulations have not changed even though there are more people enrolled in the program. Medicare will be unable to provide the same services unless the premiums are increased. Description: The Problem The baby boomer generation, who were born between 1946 and 1964, makes up a substantial portion of the North American population. They represent 20% of the American public that have a significant...

Words: 1460 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Blah

...and those who believe that the government should regulate the economy. Two of the most famous and influential economists of the modern world, John Maynard Keynes and Frederick Von Hayek, stand on opposite sides of the battle lines drawn between the two positions. Keynes is a staunch believer of the government intervention and regulation of the economy, whereas his personnel friend and ideological rival Hayek believes in the markets ability to control the economy. The differences in economic theory have spilled over into political debates, heated division within countries, and war. The battle between these two ideologies goes beyond sheer economic theory and spills over into individuals beliefs on how the world should be run and organized. John Maynard Keynes was an English economist who was educated at Cambridge University. He was considered by his peers and elders to have incredible potential as an influential world leader in the field of economics. During the First World War he served as an advisor to the government of the United Kingdom on how to organize their economy in the time of war. Keynes economic theory was based on the fact that in order to be successful an economy needed to be regulated and planned, to an extent, by the government. Based on his theory slight inflation was good, and necessary in order to keep unemployment down. The economy should be mixed between a free market economy for regular businesses and government regulation for the large industries such...

Words: 630 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Falls Prevention Policies

...Falls are not a part of the normal aging process even though the risk increases with age and falls are preventable and manageable (National Council on Aging, 2015). There are legislations and regulations at the national, state, and local levels, which are paying attention to identify serious issue such as falls among older adults. These policies, legislations, and regulations help to improve existing or developed new effective fall prevention programs based on researches. Therefore, the policies can play a pivotal role in preventing falls and falls-related injuries, and reducing risk for falls among older adults. Some of the legislations that were identified are as follows: Safety of Seniors (SOS) Act of 2007 The Safety of Seniors Act of...

Words: 1757 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

The Prevalence of Elder Abuse in Nursing Homes

...who will care for the person when they are no longer able to do so, and where they will live. In today's society, nursing homes are a favored choice regardless of the gender, sexual orientation or socioeconomic status with approximately 352, 300 seniors living in special-care facilities throughout Canada (Stat Can, 2013). To many, nursing homes are seen as an ideal living arrangement for their loved elders, unfortunately that is not the reality for all seniors in these nursing homes. What seniors are led to believe is their new haven, may in fact, be just the opposite. Elders in Ontario nursing homes are being beaten, neglected and even sexually assaulted by people who were hired to care for them (McLean & Welsh, 2011). According to the reports that the Star was able to obtain, more than 10 residents in Ontario each month are verbally, physically and sexually assaulted (McLean & Welsh, 2011). Many reported abuse cases have been life-threatening and have led to death due to assault and neglect. Despite the provincial vow of improved care in these homes, it is evident that seniors are facing the same problems with abuse in nursing homes today. On November 17th, 2011, the Star examined 70 percent of the inspection reports from last year, 1500 reports in total, and serious problems were located in 900 of the cases. Of these 900, approximately 350 revealed neglect of seniors, 125 were abuse related and the remainder found other types of mistreatment and poor care (McLean...

Words: 1784 - Pages: 8