Free Essay

Greed, the Opposite of Compassion

In: English and Literature

Submitted By shivakaze
Words 846
Pages 4
Greed, the Opposite of Compassion
Greed is shown as the opposite of compassion in both A Christmas Carol and Wuthering Heights. Ebenezer Scrooge and Jacob Marley are characters in A Christmas Carol that showcase the harm of greedy living without compassion. The rest of the characters, such as the Cratchits or Fred, contrast the miserly moneylenders. Heathcliff and Hindley Earnshaw are characters in Wuthering Heights who cause so much pain to others and themselves due to their obsession of ownership and revenge. Cathy serves as foil characters, showing how loyalty and compassion can lead to a happier existence. Charles Dickens’ A Christmas Carol has two main types of characters: the compassionate and the greedy. Ebenezer Scrooge has a lot of contrast between the people who are willing to feel pity towards him (his ex-fiancé, his nephew, his clerk) and those who coldly dismiss him as he does them (fellow business people, his servants, the pawn shop owner). The entire supernatural ordeal that Scrooge goes through is meant to show him the error of his greedy ways and teach him the importance of compassion.
Scrooge starts in the story with a personality so cold, it freezes his features. His dispassionate nature forbids any kindness, whether it be giving it, like towards his clerk, or receiving it, such as his nephew’s invitation. Yet, Scrooge’s compassion almost suddenly appears when he sees his past (27). It is not like he never knew such things growing up; he was taught through his books and by Fezziwig. His greed drowned out Scrooge’s compassion and made him the bitter man that he was. By only caring about business, Scrooge loses track of the people who cared about him (28) which leads to his lonely, miserable life.
Dickens begins off Scrooge’s supernatural encounter with a visit from his long-dead business partner, Jacob Marley. As he spent his life on this earth obsessing over money and mistreating the poor to fill his pocket, Marley is condemned to walk the earth for eternity never to find rest or peace (14). He begs Scrooge to learn the error of his ways, to change before it is too late. His suffering serves as a warning against a life obsessed with money and one without compassion.
A Christmas Carol is filled with characters that showcase why a compassionate life is more important than one obsessed with money. The Cratchit family is the main point for this argument. Despite the state of their clothes, feast, or even health, their happiness is due to their love for each other (42). Another example, one that is on the other end of the wealth spectrum, is Scrooge’s old teacher, Fezziwig. Despite being a moneylender like Scrooge, Fezziwig was a kind hearted man who was able to share so much happiness to whoever, no matter their social class (25).
Emily Bronte’s Wuthering Heights shares a story of how the greed of two men caused so much turmoil for multiple generations. Hindley’s and Heathcliff’s greed force these men to become monsters in the eyes of their own families.
Hindley Earnshaw is shown from the very beginning as a cruel, jealous person. His treatment of Heathcliff stems from sheer jealousy of the love Heathcliff receives from Mr. Earnshaw (41). After Mr. Earnshaw dies, Hindley seeks to degrade Heathcliff by turning into a manual laborer and depriving him of access to an education. Later, Hindley concocts a social-climbing scheme to unite the Earnshaws and the Lintons by marrying Catherine off to Edgar. And yet, despite all of his scheming against Heathcliff and greed for a higher status, Hindely falls into a pitiful state. Regardless of his college education, huge inheritance, and loving family, Hindley dies miserable and penniless.
Heathcliff, at first, appears to be a quiet outsider, one who endured Hindley’s transgressions without any vindication (40). However, his determination to gain control of both Wuthering Heights and the Grange is driven by his greed to become master in spite of being so much an outsider. Heathcliff’s actions lead him to become a vicious, abusive man who is hated by everyone. In his quest for utmost control, he terrorizes his family, desecrates the grave of his beloved, and falls into a maddened state.
The story of Wuthering Heights is a depressing one that shows no signs of happiness until character, Cathy, arrives at the Grange. Catherine Linton is a kinder, gentler version of her mother (189), thanks in part to her relationship with Edgar, an extremely dedicated father. Though she can be peevish and snobbish, Catherine's generosity and kindness toward Hareton, not to mention her love of Linton Heathcliff, demonstrate a kind of compassion and selflessness that her mother never had. This compassion leads to the only happy ending in the entire story.
Both A Christmas Carol and Wuthering Heights show characters miserable due to their greed. Characters, such as Scrooge and Heathcliff, are shown as physically hindered and emotionally damaged because of their desires. It is only through compassion, shown by the Cratchits or Cathy, does happiness ever appear in these stories.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Virtues

...external factors like hunger level, fatigue and stress will influence a person’s response to a certain or particular situation. Given a different day and time that same individual may react quite differently because of their feelings. Everybody can relate. I also notice many actions that I may do resulting in this matter without realizing it. It’s from our human tendencies to respond to different scenarios with a moral dilemma. Through our actions and experiences, a character is created. In the essay by Appiah, he explains the differences between situational ethics and virtue ethics. Situational ethics is often argued that many of the decisions we make can be directly influenced by the situations we find ourselves in, rather than the compassion that one finds. As I explained in the paragraph before, humans will not always address situations of ethical dilemma with the same matter of approach. In a personal experience, I have witness and experienced this many...

Words: 1492 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Truth Be Told

...decision was acutely driven; partly by my family pressure, a considerable peer pressures and mostly the greed to earning lot of money. I did clear my CAP-1 of CA with flying colors. Very soon my false dreams and fake hopes were all shattered. I failed CAP-2. I realized that I was once again trapped into the same scary infinite failure loop. I attempted 4 back to back re-sits and still my best was not good enough to get me through CAP-2 exams. I had completely lost peace of my mind. And in the due course, I had even messed up my BBS. I had realized that if something is not working your way maybe it’s time you change gears. As such, I chose to switch my inclination to the complete opposite and hence got myself completely immersed into noble causes of social welfare without caring what would happen in my life. Then only I realize the true warmth in giving. I got to know about my interest during this time frame. I learnt Indian cooking, bakery etc . I love food and I love cooking. And there are thousands of people who love to eat. I want to start my own business focusing on food business. And doing MBA will teach me the entrepreneur skills and help in my career goal to become a good business person. Doing MBA in Ace will give me a brighter and clear picture of achieving my goals. In the nutshell, I am an ordinary girl with less expertise, lots of failure stories, and compassion with tons of hope for myself. Last but not least, in this competitive world, I definitely see opportunity...

Words: 353 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Vices and Virtues

...Vices and Virtues 1. What is vice? Vices are your bad or immoral habits. They are the little devil on your shoulder telling you to give into something that is considered to be wrong. Vices are usually represented by Dante Alighieri’s seven deadly sins. These include pride, greed, lust, anger, gluttony, envy, and sloth. These seven deadly sins categorize the vices that people are faced with every day. 2. What is virtue? Virtues are the opposite of vices. They are the moral and good habits of people. There are numerous virtues that people show some of which include honesty, responsibility, compassion and many more. Virtues are the driving force behind making the right choice to not only better ourselves but also those around us. 3. How have your virtues changed since coming to Elizabethtown College? I do believe my virtues have changed for the better by coming to Etown. I have become a more compassionate person. In high school I wasn’t really one to get tied up in the issues of others, but here I have changed drastically. I have become more open to others on what issues they are facing and I try to do all that I can to make their situation better. I also believe I have become more self-aware of my life choices more in terms of healthiness. I make a lot of smarter food choices as well as athletic choices and try and get others to do the same. I’ve also become more responsible for my work. I remember in high school I tended to put off my work and studying...

Words: 435 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Treasure Island Chapter 1 Summary

...means a pirates longing for adventure but at the cost of uncontrolled behavior. The skeleton pointing towards the treasure - The skeleton pointing in the direction of the treasure is a symbol that reminds the crew how much violence there is to being a pirate, as well as how much violence went into the cost of the treasure. “Indeed, on a second glance, it seemed impossible to fancy that the body was in a natural position. But for some disarray (the work, perhaps, of the birds that had fed upon him or of the slow-growing creeper that had gradually enveloped his remains) the man lay perfectly straight - his feet pointing in one direction, his hands raised above his head like a diver’s, pointing directly in the opposite.” While this does startle the crew, they show no compassion for the man because they only care about the treasure, which goes along with one of the themes,...

Words: 1058 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Open Handed Theory

...Mary Ann A. Cabildo Instructress: Ms. Emelia E. Almerol BSBA- Financial Management Class schedule: T-TH|2:30-4:00 OPENHANDED THEORY “Helping without expecting for return will lead to a better journey” Many of us are unconsciously so self- centered that everything we do, even within our closest relationships is actually bartering rather than unselfish giving. This is one of the reasons why a country is still not fully developed and not really reaches the good condition of the economy. Just as in the Philippines, it is a culture of a Filipino for having crab mentality- it is pulling down others who are improving from the status of their living; those people don’t want that others are improving or developing but then they themselves are not developing. These people are thinking only about their selves and not thinking about the negative effect of pulling others down. When it comes in extending help, many people helped with wrong motives, they usually extend help because of the expectation of a return more than what they give. This kind of help won’t result to the betterment of a country, since they will only help if they can assure of a return but if there’s no return for them they are seldom to extend their help. When we give with the expectation of receiving something in return we are not really letting go of what we are giving. If we do not let go completely, then we are still clinging to whatever we gave. We all know that there...

Words: 660 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

The Buddhism Four Noble Truths

...The Four Noble Truths "I teach suffering, its origin, cessation and path. That's all I teach", Is the what Buddha quoted 2500 years ago. The Four Noble Truths contain the essence of the Buddha's teachings. It was these four principles that the Buddha came to understand during his meditation under the bodhi tree. 1. The truth of suffering (Dukkha) 2. The truth of the origin of suffering (Samudāya) 3. The truth of the cessation of suffering (Nirodha) 4. The truth of the path to the cessation of suffering (Magga) The Buddha is often compared to a physician. In the first two Noble Truths he diagnosed the problem (suffering) and identified its cause. The third Noble Truth is the realisation that there is a cure. The fourth Noble Truth, in which the Buddha set out the Eightfold Path, is the prescription, the way to achieve a release from suffering. The First Noble Truth Suffering (Dukkha) Suffering comes in many forms. Three obvious kinds of suffering correspond to the first three sights the Buddha saw on his first journey outside his palace: old age, sickness and death. But according to the Buddha, the problem of suffering goes much deeper. Life is not ideal: it frequently fails to live up to our expectations. Human beings are subject to desires and cravings, but even when we are able to satisfy these desires, the satisfaction is only temporary. Pleasure does not last; or if it does, it becomes monotonous. Even when we are not suffering from outward causes...

Words: 1023 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Happiness Economicd

...has seen a sustainable rapid growth in its economy. China’s real GDP has already surpassed 7 trillion US dollars in 2011 in current dollars, and it has replaced Japan as the world’s second largest economy. People in China also have significant improvements in their standards of living and material life. However, my findings contradict the notion that an increase in income and standard of living will gain people happiness. My major findings show that income inequality and other major social problems, such as lack of religious belief and faith, political problems, and family burden have contributed to the decline of happiness among Chinese people. Other negative feelings emerging with the rapid economic growth, such as greed, interpersonal distrust and less compassion show adverse effects on Chinese happiness. I conclude the research by suggesting possible future researches for further studies. 1. Introduction After the Cultural Revolution ended in 1978, China launched a comprehensive reformation in its state controlled economy under the new leadership, Mr. Deng Xiaoping. Since then, China has gradually opened its door to the world and begun its transition into a market economy. (Chai, 1997) Over the past thirty years, China had the most enduring and rapid economic growth in the human history. According to the Federal Reserve Bank of Saint Louis, China’s average GDP growth is nearly 10 percent for the past 30 year. (FRED, 2013) In urban China, the average disposable income increase...

Words: 4222 - Pages: 17

Premium Essay

Christianity vs Buddhism

...This paper is a comparison between two very different religions. Specifically Christianity and Buddhism. Coming from opposite sides of the globe these two religions could not be any farther apart in any aspect. I will discuss who Christ is for Christians and who Buddha is for Buddhists. I will also get into the aspects of charity, love, and compassion in both religions and I will be looking at the individual self and how christians see resurrection where the buddhists feel about the afterlife. One thing to keep in mind is that the two religions are very different but they seem to have a very similar underlying pattern. Both believe that there was a savior of their people, Buddha and Christ, and both believe that there is something good that happens to us when our time is done here on earth. This is a very generalized summarization but in order to go in to depth I need to explain the two religions more to fully convey this theory.  The Christian religion, like all other religions has its strengths and weaknesses in our modern society. Perhaps the strengths out weight the weaknesses as this is one of the largest religions in the world. Hundreds of people follow the Catholic/Christian religion yet still a greater number follow yet other religions. Perhaps this is because they see the weaknesses or perhaps it is simply because their parents have taught them that it is a sin to follow this religion. The Christian religions do however present much more of an appealing atmosphere...

Words: 2080 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Religon

...This paper is a comparison between two very different religions. Specifically Christianity and Buddhism. Coming from opposite sides of the globe these two religions could not be any farther apart in any aspect. I will discuss who Christ is for Christians and who Buddha is for Buddhists. I will also get into the aspects of charity, love, and compassion in both religions and I will be looking at the individual self and how Christians see resurrection where the buddhists feel about the afterlife. One thing to keep in mind is that the two religions are very different but they seem to have a very similar underlying pattern. Both believe that there was a savior of their people, Buddha and Christ, and both believe that there is something good that happens to us when our time is done here on earth. This is a very generalized summarization but in order to go in to depth I need to explain the two religions more to fully convey this theory. The Christian religion, like all other religions has its strengths and weaknesses in our modern society. Perhaps the strengths out weight the weaknesses as this is one of the largest religions in the world. Hundreds of people follow the Catholic/Christian religion yet still a greater number follow yet other religions. Perhaps this is because they see the weaknesses or perhaps it is simply because their parents have taught them that it is a sin to follow this religion. The Christian religions do however present much more of an appealing atmosphere...

Words: 2077 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

The Buddha

...Intro -Born between India and Nepal 25hundred years ago -His mom had a Dream before he was born. A white elephant offered her a lotus flower and then entered her side of her body. Predictions she will have a son either Ruler or Holy man who will become and elighten being. -Born emreging from her side. 7 Days later the queen died. -Buddha said the world is filled with Pain and Sorrow but he had found a serenity that everyone can find. -Learn how to accept life as it is. (Pain suffering, getting sick etc..) -Buddha says you are you are own Master, future depends on us! He just wants to show us happiness. THE BUDDHA (Siddharta Gautama) -First Buddha biography was written 500 years after his death -Born 500 years before Birth of Jesus -Grew in a town vanished for 3 decades he wouldn’t see nothing of the world beyond -Son of a King raised in a palace named Siddharta Gautama a Prince! -HIs dad wanted him to be a king not a teacher etc.. -Dad married him to her cousin -He steps out kingdom and sees Old man, Sick person, by the third trip he sees a corpse. 4th trip outside he sees a spiritual seeker. Someone who tried to live a life completely other than his life in order to escape from impermanence, pain, suffering and death. -At 29yrs he left the palace. He wanted to comprehend nature of suffering. -His wife just gave birth to Rajula Fedder, Ball and Chain -He chose not to hold his son bcus it will stop him from leaving -Lara the god of desire was waiting told...

Words: 1818 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Animal Farm Comparative

...Animal Farm Comparative Essay Rebellion, gluttony, and manipulation are all common themes when it comes to the struggle for power. Animal farm by George Orwell, a book which all of these take place is remarkably similar to the Crucible by Arthur Miller and Macbeth by William Shakespeare. Animal farm, The Crucible, and Macbeth are all written similarly and revolve around the same themes, such that many characters in Animal Farm and Macbeth portray similar characteristics. Animal Farm and The Crucible share common themes and conflicts. In all three books the structure of peoples values change drastically for a turn for the worst. These novels and play all follow popular foundations of literature which revolve around inner evil, the addiction to power, and the loss and regaining of self-identity. Animal farm and Macbeth’s antagonists, Napoleon and Macbeth portray similar characteristics. Napoleon and Macbeth both share important roles in their respective books in that they directly influence and change the fate of many. The two power hungry tyrants go to an extreme to achieve their goals but in two very different ways. Napoleon a more cunning character abuses his superior intellect to deceive the other ignorant farm animals in order to gain power. Through Machiavellian methods he slowly begins to take over the farm by convincing the animals to be more reliant on him, ultimately making his self-proclamation of leader a reality “No one believes more firmly than Comrade Napoleon...

Words: 912 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Rhetoric of the Tao-Te Ching

...number of pieces of can qualify. In particular, the idea of leadership is arguably one of the most written about topics with regard to comparing and contrasting. Throughout history, it can be argued that the majority of successful societies have been based upon effective divisions of leadership. Accordingly, in their pieces of literature, The Tao-te Ching and The Qualities of the Prince, Lao-tzu and Machiavelli have sought to convey a more complete and concrete understanding of their respective definitions and duties of a ruler (leadership). The theme of political leaders and their intricate relationship with society indeed validate itself within both texts. However, both Lao-tzu and Machiavelli approach this issue from almost entirely opposite positions, though sharing minute similarities. Lao-tzu appears to focus the majority of his attention on letting problems or situations take their course, and consequently good would prevail. On the contrary, Machiavelli advocates the necessity for a successful leader, or prince, to take control of his deeds, and the skills or qualities necessary to maintain power. Since both writers propose a question as to what is in essence the same dilemma, effective leadership, it becomes almost natural literary etiquette to contrast the two in an effort to better understand what qualities a prosperous leader must possess. Despite each author’s contrasting approaches to rhetoric, they agree that a ruler should avoid being hated and despised, but disagree...

Words: 1499 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

The Exploration of the Connectedness Between Texts Enhances an Understanding of Text’s Textual Integrity.

...The exploration of the connectedness between texts enhances an understanding of text’s textual integrity. This is evident within William Shakespeare’s ‘King Richard Third’ and Al Pacino’s docudrama ‘Looking For Richard’, where composers portray, through literary and film techniques, texts which reveal to their respective audiences valuable insights into their differing contexts. ‘Looking For Richard’ is based on ‘King Richard Third’ and adapts Shakespeare’s values to a modern context. Exploration of connections between the texts enhances the understanding of the values and contexts of each text. Connections enhances context, character and perspective as these values intensify connections. Through exploring context and character connections between texts, new perspectives of each text are possible, creating textual integrity. Richard Third - Context Richard Third was written to a superstitious Elizabethan audience. It was written as pro-Tudor propaganda, whereby the representation of Richard as a sly and deformed character perpetuates the Tudor Myth, within the context of the War of the Roses. Richard exudes traits of a Machiavellian villain, with imagery exaggerating Richard as a “Deformed, unfinished” man who was “Sent before his time” in order to maintain his discontent. Furthermore, Richards evil characterization and relentless pursuit of power is highlighted to his audience through his opening soliloquy “since I can not prove to be a lover….. I am determined to prove...

Words: 1500 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Leo Tolstoy's The Death Of Ivan Ilych

...Life in this story however, comes in two forms. First is the artificial life which is represented by the characters of Ivan, Peter, Praskovya, and almost everyone in Ivan’s circle. And the second one is the authentic life which is represented by Gerasim. The authentic life is life filled with compassion, respect and empathy. The artificial life is filled with materialism, self-interest, and shallow relationships. Such is the life led by Ivan. In the narrative, Tolstoy describes Ivan as a common and almost non-descript man. The author further emphasizes this “everyman” characteristic by making his protagonist the middle child of three sons. He also has a middle temperament as he is not as stiff as his eldest brother nor as wild and reckless as his youngest brother; thus making him a “happy mean” between the two. He is unexceptional in so many ways and lives a life that is “most simple and most ordinary and therefore most terrible” (Tolstoy 11). The character himself knows this; thus, strives to change this. At a young age, he enters the...

Words: 2197 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Compare/Contrast Buddhism and Hinduism

...Compare and contrast Buddhism and Hinduism Buddhism and Hinduism are two of the world's largest and oldest religions. Both are excellent examples of how religions that come from the same part of the world can develop differently and appeal to different people. When comparing Buddhism and Hinduism focus could be placed upon a myriad of ancient traditions and beliefs, so many traditions and beliefs that the mind begins to swirl in the attempt to comprehend everything. To summarize the similarities and differences of these two religions, focus will be on placed on three aspects of each religion, karma, worship practices/belief in a supreme being and the philosophy each religion holds regarding reincarnation. Despite bearing some striking similarities, the differences between Hinduism and Buddhism are pronounced. While reincarnation is an important aspect of both Buddhists and Hindus faith, it is quite different in each religion. Karma is quite similar in each religion. Karma is the basic belief that a person's fate is determined according to his actions while on earth. A soul who does good Karma in this life will be awarded with a better life in their next life. Souls that have bad Karma will be punished for their sins, if not in this incarnation then in the next incarnation and they will continue to be born in this world again and again. “The good souls will be liberated from the circle of rebirth and get redemption. In the Hindu religion this cycle is called 'Moksha' meaning...

Words: 1192 - Pages: 5