Premium Essay

Griggs vs Duke Power

In: Business and Management

Submitted By jbutdrake
Words 443
Pages 2
Griggs vs. Duke Power Co. (1971) was a case that helped shape current labor laws after the implementation of Title VII. Prior to Title VII, black employees could not work in four of the five departments at Duke nor could they achieve the same wage as a white employee. The day Title VII became effective, Duke Power Co. introduced a new policy for new hires or department transfers that required a high school diploma or passing scores on two general intelligence tests. This new policy applied to all black employees and applicants but white employees that did not meet those requirements were grandfathered in. Black employees challenged these requirements, stating they were not job related and disqualified blacks from employment or transfer at a higher rate than whites (Bennett-Alexander & Hartman, 2007).
1. What was the impact of the Griggs vs. Duke Power Co. decision on the employer?
The impact on the employer was that stipulations could not be implemented that restricted certain minority groups from being hired unless the employer could prove that those stipulations served a legitimate business purpose or in other words, “The employer must measure the person for the job and not the person in abstract” (Griggs v. Duke Power Co., 2012). This case legitimized disparate impact theory which states if a job qualification or employment practice has an unequal impact on a specific group, it is only justifiable if the employer can prove it has a business related purpose. Organizations had to start looking at the effect of their employment practices and their relation to race. Griggs vs. Duke Power Co. was a precedent case and stood as “good law” until 1989 when the court decided that the burden was on the employee to prove an employer’s policy was not job related instead of placing the burden on the employer. This reversal was considered a setback to civil rights...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Workplace Diversity & Religion

...religious expression in the workplace.” to increase 6.2% which would cause a shift in the gender majority in the workforce. While this number is a major improvement, only 3.6% of Fortune 500 Company CEO’s are women, meaning that the men are disproportionately leading companies at 96.4% in comparison with women. ( ). Herein lies the problem, diversity is a key driver of a successful company. If the Management of most companies lace women in senior leadership positions, they are more than likely limiting their revenue potential. Griggs vs. Duke Power The United States of America’s history is marred by slavery and racial inequality. The 1950’s and...

Words: 841 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay


...Amanda Campbell Carter Cleaning Company Case Study #1 Jennifer’s first question regarding the Human Resources management practices revolves around discrimination within the stores. Her father, the owner, claims that because they hire “mostly women and minorities” that they cannot be accused of discriminatory practices. While this may be true, all of the managers within the stores were white and thus potentially discriminatory against the minority workforce currently employed. If there are minorities that are qualified for the management positions and have not or are not being promoted then according to the Title VII laws there could be grounds for a lawsuit by these employees. To address the sexual harassment charges and problems, Jennifer should create a policy statement condemning sexual behavior. Employees should be taught that sexual harassment will not be tolerated within her company and managers should be educated about sexual harassment. In addition, the manager that has been accused of sexual harassment “quid pro quo” should be disciplined for his behavior. Discrimination is defined as “taking specific actions toward or against the person based on the person’s group. Based on this definition the seventy-three year old man is not being discriminiated against because of his age. According to the problem presented there was not a threat or specific action being taken because of his age and the Equal Pay Act of 1963 states that pay differences derived from...

Words: 458 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Human Resource

...government, local government, and employment agencies. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission was established to enforce and administer the Civil Rights law at work. I believe the Act has been effective in some ways. I definitely think things have come a long way over time. I know there are still employers that seem as though they are following the law but are not. They favor hiring only women in certain positions or males in others. A company will not of course come right out and say they only want a woman receptionist or male salesperson but clearly that is the case. 2) In the Griggs v. Duke Power Company, Willie Griggs claimed the requirement be a high school graduate for the coal handler job was illegally discriminatory. He claimed this would not relate to job performance and it would result in more whites being hired than blacks. The case was won by Griggs. I think this changed hiring procedure across the United States by making employers more aware of their hiring practices. It shows that even though an employer’s intent was not to discriminate it is irrelevant....

Words: 335 - Pages: 2

Free Essay


...This case became a situation when The Civil Rights Act was passed in 1965. African Americans working at Duke Power Company before the act were only allowed to work in the labor department as to where others were “whites only”. During that time frame I assume was very common for practices such like this. After the act was passed, Duke changed their policy which “whites only” doesn’t apply anymore, but requiring them to have a high school diploma along with passing their aptitude test. I can agree favoring both parties, but I would lean more towards Griggs, because of the unfair circumstances put in place. As I stated in the discussion, I felt that this was more involving a violation of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. This act prohibits employers from discriminating against individual because if their race, color, religion, sex or national origin (Textbook p.66). It became obvious that the testing was put in place because of the new act, but I think because it doesn’t show intent to measure the ability for doing that job that it should be invalid. African Americans were being unfair because of the test that measure more intelligence instead of the ability to perform the job. This would fall under a bone fide occupational qualification, which is a necessary qualification for “performing” a job (p.77). A disparate impact was another way that showed potential discrimination by them when they offered promotions mainly within the departments, which can reduce......

Words: 438 - Pages: 2

Free Essay


...( The NAACP examines government policies and public agenda that may cause hindrance to the advancement of African Americans. In 1896, in a case between Plessy vs. Ferguson, the United States Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of state laws requiring racial segregation in public facilities; this decision was detrimental to our society ( In 1954 the NAACP backed the efforts of the case of Brown vs. The Board of Education, which lead to a decision that, “separate educational facilities are inherently unequal” ( The monumental impact of this case is still widely demonstrated today. The government policy of affirmative action is undoubtedly a useful tool in the efforts of the NAACP. In 1971 the NAACP backed the efforts of the case of Griggs vs. Duke Power Company; a decision was made that reflected the policy of fair treatment by affirmative action ( Today there are some who support the policy of affirmative action, and some who are opposed, and some who feel we needed affirmative action at one time but now are no longer in need of it. In 2009 the plaintiffs of the case of Ricci vs. DeStefano sued the city of New Haven, Connecticut alleging they were discriminated against in regards to promotion......

Words: 583 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Hrm 552

...Caso De EstudioGrigg Vs. Duque Resumen El Griggs contra Duke Power Company fue un caso histórico en relación con la discriminación en el lugar de trabajo. Duke Power Company era conocida por discriminar a los negros durante el proceso de contratación sólo por lo que les permite trabajar en el departamento de trabajo que es lo que era la posición mas baja remuneración. Después de la Ley de Derechos Civiles fue aprobada, obviamente, la empresa ya no se puede discriminar legalmente basada en la raza. Sin embargo, la compañía se convirtió en astuto y se requiere un diploma de escuela secundaria para el empleo. Esto, a su vez elimina una gran cantidad de pontenciales empleados negros, porque la mayoría de ellos no tienen el bachillerato. Esto realmente se convirtió en un problema cuando Griggs solicitó un puesto, pero se le negó porque no tenía un diploma de escuela secundaria. Este fue llevado hasta la corte suprema y falló a favor de Griggs por las siguientes razones; En primer lugar, el tribunal dictamió que la discriminación no tiene que ser intencional para estar presente. La discriminación puede ser ilegal, incluso cuando se aplica de manera uniforme a todo el mundo. Por lo tanto, en este caso, a pesar de que los diplomas de la escuela secundaria se requieren para todo el mundo, que dio a los individuos negros una desventja grave y, a su vez limita sus oportunidades de empleo. En segundo lugar, el tribunal dictaminó que las prácticas de empleo debe ser el......

Words: 1259 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Business Law

...Common Law, Statutory Law and Administrative Law Common Law Judge-Made Law: Sum total of all cases decided by appellate courts. 200 yrs ago almost all laws were common laws. Today most laws are statutory. Disadvantages: Each state has a body of law different from other states (problems for businesses) Stare Decisis Stare Decisis is the essence of common law. It means “Let the decision stand”. Law by precedent (by state). So there should be a precedent in that. Disadvantages: This is not easy. How to balance between predictability and flexibility? Because common law is trying to accommodate both above goals. The more flexibility, the less predictability. Bystander cases Bystander cases - where common law says no duty to assist someone in peril unless you created the danger. But common law changes slightly over time. For example bystander law changed in cases where bystander is an employer or a doctor or even a public place where one can make phone calls. Statutory Law Most new law is statutory law. It affects each of us in business, professional and personal lives. This is more a people-made law or a law made as a result of people electing local legislators who pass state statutes; people vote for senators and representatives who create federal statutes. Example: Criminal Law. Bills Bill is a proposed statute (proposed either by House of Representatives or the Senate). A bill must be voted on passed by both houses. Once both houses pass the bill they send it to......

Words: 615 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Employment Laws

... | | | | | | |Said to be the single most important |Griggs vs, Duke Power Company |Is was designed to eliminate the |Typically applied in the hiring | |Civil Rights Act of 1964 |piece of legislation that has had the | |discrimination of potential employment|process or the selection of potential | | |greatest affect on reducing employment| |based on the significant facets of |employment candidates. | | |discrimination; established in 1964. | |discrimination such as: gender, | | | | | |religion, race, etc. | | | |Granted enforcement powers to the EEOC|McDonnell Douglas Corp. vs. Green |The EEOC could effectively...

Words: 913 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Ricci V. Destefano

...Ricci v. DeStefano Jennifer Drab Baker College Abstract Ricci v. DeStefano is case based on reverse discrimination. The New Haven firefighters that brought this suit against the city did so on the belief that the city in its efforts to avoid litigation violated Title VII of the Civil Rights Act. Reverse discrimination is a term that is used widely; however, it is very difficult to move forward with this claim in a court of law. The New Haven firefighters that brought the suit had their case heard before the Supreme Court of the United States. This was not a case that the justices took lightly; they asked many difficult questions, which looked at many different aspects of Title VII. The answer from the high court is that rejecting the test scores in fear of Title VII litigation is not grounds enough to disqualify candidates that qualified for promotion. In the end, the high court upheld the firefighters claim that the city’s rejection of the exam scores violated the rights of those that qualified based on the exam. Introduction Ricci v. DeStefano, is case of reverse discrimination within the fire department of New Haven, Connecticut. This case is an illustration that affirmative action does not always result in fairness. New Haven city officials created a very comprehensive written examination for testing those fire fighters that were looking to be promoted to captain and lieutenant (Epstein, 2009). Unfortunately, the examination showed that there was......

Words: 3478 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Week 2

... | | | | | | |Discrimination in the work place on |Griggs vs. Duke Power Co. prohibits |That organizations cannot discriminate|This Act gives a person equal | |Civil Rights Act of 1964 |race and sex based on hiring, |intentional job discrimination and |upon a person because of his or her |opportunity regardless of the color of| | |promoting, and firing |employer practices that have |race, or sex |skin or male/female in a working | | | |discriminatory effects | |environment as long as they are | | | | | |capable of performing the job | | |Gave the Equal Employment Opportunity |Washington vs. Davis allowed for |The importance is that the...

Words: 1111 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Mgt 515 Case 1 Gelato Eeo and Hrm

...Trident University International XXXXXXXXXX Management 516 Module1 Case Study: Gelato EEO and HRM 2013 Professor: INTRODUCTION Companies operating in the United States need to be in compliant with Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) regulations. There are many laws that are governed by EEOC regulations but in this paper, I will review Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and the Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA). I will apply these two laws to the Gelato company hiring practice operating out of Heartland Corners, U.S.A. With the data I have, I will evaluate if Gelato is in compliant with the Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 for hiring black and other minority groups in the local area. I will also explore their practices of hiring younger employees to determine if they are violation of the ADEA. Lastly, I will make recommendations for compliance with the Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and ADEA if any or needed. THE ISSUE WITH GELATO Gelato is a larger cheese maker that distributes throughout the United States. Gelato is located in Heartland Corners, U.S.A. and employs approximately 200 hundred workers. Currently their employees’ racial make-up is 85 percent white and 15 percent other races. The population of Heartland Corners is 50 percent white and 25 percent African American with the other 25 percent mixed with Hispanic, Asians and other races. The question here is whether or not Gelato......

Words: 2197 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Affirmative Action

...Preferential treatment is the act of providing an individual or group with superior advantage. This may be because of the color of their skin, age, race, or culture. One might argue that this is also the same definition of Affirmation Action. It is not out of the norm for one to discuss their similarities, but what is rarely discussed is the difference in outcome both have on the human race and the global economy. With thousands of applicants applying being denied for their Ivy-league college admission and another million out of the workforce it is clear there is a dire need of assistance in these areas. Affirmative action has been a major contributor to depreciating these skyrocketing numbers, giving many minority Americans a chance they may not have been previously fortunate enough to receive. The goal is not for preferential treatment, but to provide all Americans with an equal opportunity at success. This can only be done with the implication of Affirmative Action and other policies alike. It is well known that for many of us, education is the gateway to receiving advancement in a remarkable career and maintaining a prestigious economic status. Armed with this knowledge, millions of Americans feel that it is imperative to attend college and complete graduate studies. In order to compete in this dog eat dog world, one must do whatever it takes to stay one step ahead. Unfortunately many minorities are not able to compete, due to not being able to further their education.......

Words: 1755 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay


...thereof…… shall be the Supreme law of the Land; and the Judges in every state shall be bound thereby …..” Article VI Judicial Review- U.S. Constitution doesn’t provide that federal courts can declare a statute unconstitutional and void, but they can./Marbury v. Madison, 1803 introduced judicial review Activism v. Restraint- Over time, not a liberal vs. conservative issue.In the early days of the New Deal, judicial activism was responsible for striking down progressive measures. Originalism v. Living- When interpreting the Constitution, ask what the people who wrote it – or wrote the amendments – understood the provisions to mean. VS. To interpret the Constitution look to the language in the document and the understanding of the framers, but do so in light of the long history of common law which preceded and followed it. That gives you a mechanism for applying the document to situations which could never have been envisioned when the Constitution was written. Public v. Private Action- Companies and individuals can’t deprive you of your Constitutional rights, only a govt can. Commerce Clause- “The Congress shall have Power ……… To regulate Commerce with foreign Nations, and among the several States …….”Article 1, Section 8 Affordable Healthcare Act- Nat. Fed. of Independent Businesses v. Sibelius (2012)/Focus: The individual mandate – a requirement that people buy insurance or pay a sum of money,Not supported by Commerce Clause, BUT,The government can impose a tax on......

Words: 2002 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Title Vii

...Issue: Under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 can an employee who is African American demonstrate that her employer discriminated against her by failing to promote her to the position of senior control buyer, where she has seven years of experience in the retail catalog business, two years as a control buyer, trained new buyers, received a special achievement award for contributing to the positive profile of the company and where the person who was hired in her place has no experience as a retail buyer in the private sector and has been with the company for six months? Brief Answer: A court is likely to rule that Mrs. Pitman has been discriminated against under Title VII. Mrs. Pitman is able to prove each of the four elements of the test set out in Texas Dept. of Community Affairs v. Burdine, 450 U.S. 248 (1981). This test known as the McDonnell Douglass test is met when Mrs. Pitman shows that: (1) she belongs to a protected class; (2) she applied and was qualified for the job; (3) despite her being qualified she was rejected; (4) after the rejection the position remained open and employer continued to seek applicannot s. Mrs. Pitman is also able to provide statistical evidence of discrimination and evidence of discriminatory attitudes. Facts: Our client, Jenna Pitman, is seeking to file suit against J. Montgomery for a claim of racial discrimination under Title VII. The allegation stems from a denial of Mrs. Pitman's application for a promotion by J.......

Words: 5593 - Pages: 23

Premium Essay


...SL. NO. | TITLE | SOURCE OF THE PROJECT | PAGE NO. | SIGN OF THE TEACHER | 1 | Acknowledgement | - | | | 2 | Brand RivalryAn INTRODUCTION | | | | 3 | PepsiAn Introduction | | | | 4 | Pepsi the history | | | | 5 | Products Of Pepsi | | | | 6 | Coca-Cola An Introduction | | | | 7 | Coca-Colathe history | | | | 8 | Products Of Coca-Cola | | | | 9 | Pepsi Vs Coca-Cola A Comparison | | | | 10 | Pepsi Vs Coca-Cola THE COLA WAR | | | | 11 | Pepsi Vs Coca-Cola Which Cola brand is the Better Investment? | - | | | 12 | Pepsi Vs Coca-Cola PRESENCE IN INDIA | | | | 13 | Pepsi Vs Coca-Cola Marketing | | | | 14 | Pepsi Vs Coca-Cola Advertising Strategies | | | | 15 | Pepsi Vs Coca-Cola Conclusion | - | | | 16 | BIBLIOGRAPHY | - | | | ACKNOWLEDGEMENT I have taken efforts in this project. However, it would not have been possible without the kind support and help of many individuals and organizations. I would like to extend my sincere thanks to all of them. I thank my God for providing me with everything that I required in completing this project. I am highly indebted to the Teacher in Charge Mr. James Thomas for his guidance and constant supervision as well as for providing......

Words: 10538 - Pages: 43