Free Essay


In: Business and Management

Submitted By id0notkn0w
Words 438
Pages 2
This case became a situation when The Civil Rights Act was passed in 1965. African Americans working at Duke Power Company before the act were only allowed to work in the labor department as to where others were “whites only”. During that time frame I assume was very common for practices such like this. After the act was passed, Duke changed their policy which “whites only” doesn’t apply anymore, but requiring them to have a high school diploma along with passing their aptitude test. I can agree favoring both parties, but I would lean more towards Griggs, because of the unfair circumstances put in place.
As I stated in the discussion, I felt that this was more involving a violation of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. This act prohibits employers from discriminating against individual because if their race, color, religion, sex or national origin (Textbook p.66). It became obvious that the testing was put in place because of the new act, but I think because it doesn’t show intent to measure the ability for doing that job that it should be invalid. African Americans were being unfair because of the test that measure more intelligence instead of the ability to perform the job. This would fall under a bone fide occupational qualification, which is a necessary qualification for “performing” a job (p.77).
A disparate impact was another way that showed potential discrimination by them when they offered promotions mainly within the departments, which can reduce well-qualified candidates who may be better fit for the job (p.77). The four-fifths rule could also be argue because the hiring rate for the minority group is less than four-fifths the hiring rate for the majority group in other departments, but more evidence would need to be known first. (p.77)
Another strong point Griggs could argue is “Disparate Treatment” which includes hiring or promoting one person over an equally qualified person because of the individual’s race (p.76). Also the fairness in testing, where Duke Power would have to demonstrate that a diploma or their test requirements will show a relationship to the job performance.
My ruling would be to favor Griggs because of the unfairness of their job requirements. They required a high school diploma and both the intelligence tests, which neither would show the ability of that person performing that job. The court should measure the unfairness African Americans were against, because of the unreasonable requirement Duke Power’s put in place for them. I rule this was a violation of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Griggs vs Duke Power

...Griggs vs. Duke Power Co. (1971) was a case that helped shape current labor laws after the implementation of Title VII. Prior to Title VII, black employees could not work in four of the five departments at Duke nor could they achieve the same wage as a white employee. The day Title VII became effective, Duke Power Co. introduced a new policy for new hires or department transfers that required a high school diploma or passing scores on two general intelligence tests. This new policy applied to all black employees and applicants but white employees that did not meet those requirements were grandfathered in. Black employees challenged these requirements, stating they were not job related and disqualified blacks from employment or transfer at a higher rate than whites (Bennett-Alexander & Hartman, 2007). 1. What was the impact of the Griggs vs. Duke Power Co. decision on the employer? The impact on the employer was that stipulations could not be implemented that restricted certain minority groups from being hired unless the employer could prove that those stipulations served a legitimate business purpose or in other words, “The employer must measure the person for the job and not the person in abstract” (Griggs v. Duke Power Co., 2012). This case legitimized disparate impact theory which states if a job qualification or employment practice has an unequal impact on a specific group, it is only justifiable if the employer can prove it has a business related purpose. ......

Words: 443 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Human Resource

...government, local government, and employment agencies. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission was established to enforce and administer the Civil Rights law at work. I believe the Act has been effective in some ways. I definitely think things have come a long way over time. I know there are still employers that seem as though they are following the law but are not. They favor hiring only women in certain positions or males in others. A company will not of course come right out and say they only want a woman receptionist or male salesperson but clearly that is the case. 2) In the Griggs v. Duke Power Company, Willie Griggs claimed the requirement be a high school graduate for the coal handler job was illegally discriminatory. He claimed this would not relate to job performance and it would result in more whites being hired than blacks. The case was won by Griggs. I think this changed hiring procedure across the United States by making employers more aware of their hiring practices. It shows that even though an employer’s intent was not to discriminate it is irrelevant....

Words: 335 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Workplace Diversity & Religion

...or religious expression in the workplace.” to increase 6.2% which would cause a shift in the gender majority in the workforce. While this number is a major improvement, only 3.6% of Fortune 500 Company CEO’s are women, meaning that the men are disproportionately leading companies at 96.4% in comparison with women. ( ). Herein lies the problem, diversity is a key driver of a successful company. If the Management of most companies lace women in senior leadership positions, they are more than likely limiting their revenue potential. Griggs vs. Duke Power The United States of America’s history is marred by slavery and racial inequality. The 1950’s and...

Words: 841 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay


...Amanda Campbell Carter Cleaning Company Case Study #1 Jennifer’s first question regarding the Human Resources management practices revolves around discrimination within the stores. Her father, the owner, claims that because they hire “mostly women and minorities” that they cannot be accused of discriminatory practices. While this may be true, all of the managers within the stores were white and thus potentially discriminatory against the minority workforce currently employed. If there are minorities that are qualified for the management positions and have not or are not being promoted then according to the Title VII laws there could be grounds for a lawsuit by these employees. To address the sexual harassment charges and problems, Jennifer should create a policy statement condemning sexual behavior. Employees should be taught that sexual harassment will not be tolerated within her company and managers should be educated about sexual harassment. In addition, the manager that has been accused of sexual harassment “quid pro quo” should be disciplined for his behavior. Discrimination is defined as “taking specific actions toward or against the person based on the person’s group. Based on this definition the seventy-three year old man is not being discriminiated against because of his age. According to the problem presented there was not a threat or specific action being taken because of his age and the Equal Pay Act of 1963 states that pay differences derived from...

Words: 458 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Principles of Management

...Pollution Act of 1990. After the enactment of OPA it was clearly spelled out that the Federal officials (Coast Guards) were responsible for offshore incidents. Therefore, the Coast Guard responded to the spill the first day and remained on site with BP until the explosion was under control. The Coast Guard supervised and directed the capping of the well on July 15, 2010 and completed it on September 19, 2010. The Oil Pollution Act of 1990 is a law that caps on liability for oil spills caused by tankers and drilling vessels in the United States' territorial waters. It was designed to improve the nation’s ability to prevent and respond to oil spills. “OPA 0f 1990 was enacted largely because of the Exxon Valdez spill in March 1989”. (Griggs, 2011) Its general provisions consist of the following: * Providing a comprehensive legal framework that establishes federal management and control of oil spills, and federal control of containment, removal, recovery and clean-up efforts. * It holds each “responsible party “liable for the costs of containment, clean -up, and damages sustained as a result of the spill. * It creates a single, unified fund...

Words: 999 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Social Studies

...Chapter 2 Basic concepts Contents Introduction 17 2.1 2.2 2.3 Relevance, weight and admissibility 18 Classification of evidence 20 Development and current objectives of evidence law 23 Introduction When you begin to study a new legal subject, you soon find that you come across words and expressions that you have not encountered before, or that you suspect are being used in a special way. This is especially so for evidence law. You need to understand the most important of these early on in order to get to grips with the subject. This chapter introduces you to these words and expressions. Besides ‘learning the language’ of evidence, you need to begin to develop a critical attitude towards the law so that you can write good answers to essay questions in the examination. But it’s impossible to adopt a critical attitude if you have no opinion about what the objectives of the law should be, and so this chapter introduces you to that topic too. Learning outcomes By the end of this chapter and the relevant readings you should be able to: explain what is meant by ‘relevance’, ‘weight’ and ‘admissibility’ present arguments defending or attacking the relevance of a given item of evidence explain what is meant by the following major technical terms used in evidence law: the best evidence rule, circumstantial and direct evidence, collateral facts, documentary evidence, facts in issue, original evidence, real evidence, hearsay, the best evidence rule and the voir dire describe......

Words: 4210 - Pages: 17

Free Essay

Hrm 552

...Caso De EstudioGrigg Vs. Duque Resumen El Griggs contra Duke Power Company fue un caso histórico en relación con la discriminación en el lugar de trabajo. Duke Power Company era conocida por discriminar a los negros durante el proceso de contratación sólo por lo que les permite trabajar en el departamento de trabajo que es lo que era la posición mas baja remuneración. Después de la Ley de Derechos Civiles fue aprobada, obviamente, la empresa ya no se puede discriminar legalmente basada en la raza. Sin embargo, la compañía se convirtió en astuto y se requiere un diploma de escuela secundaria para el empleo. Esto, a su vez elimina una gran cantidad de pontenciales empleados negros, porque la mayoría de ellos no tienen el bachillerato. Esto realmente se convirtió en un problema cuando Griggs solicitó un puesto, pero se le negó porque no tenía un diploma de escuela secundaria. Este fue llevado hasta la corte suprema y falló a favor de Griggs por las siguientes razones; En primer lugar, el tribunal dictamió que la discriminación no tiene que ser intencional para estar presente. La discriminación puede ser ilegal, incluso cuando se aplica de manera uniforme a todo el mundo. Por lo tanto, en este caso, a pesar de que los diplomas de la escuela secundaria se requieren para todo el mundo, que dio a los individuos negros una desventja grave y, a su vez limita sus oportunidades de empleo. En segundo lugar, el tribunal dictaminó que las prácticas de empleo debe ser el......

Words: 1259 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Assignment: Eeo years, thousands of court cases, some reaching as far as the Supreme Court, have brought about change for employee’s equal rights. One precedential Supreme Court case in particular, Griggs v Duke Power Company, has created major changes in corporate hiring and promoting policies. Willie Griggs applied for a position as a coal handler with Duke Power. Griggs was denied the position because he did not have a high school diploma or an equivalent, which is a requirement. Griggs argued that the requirement was discriminatory because it did not relate to job success and because the standard had an adverse impact on a protected class. The Supreme Court ruling in favor of Griggs established two important principles affecting equal employment opportunity. The first ruled that employer discrimination need not be overt or intentional to be present, but employment practices can be illegal even when applied equally to all employees. The second principle established that employment practices must be job related. In other words, when employees use education, physical, or intelligence standards, even with good intent, as a basis for hiring or promotion, these requirements must be necessary for job success. Duke Power could not prove that a high school diploma or equivalent was necessary for Griggs to be successful in the position, and therefore lost the case and had to make changes to their hiring and promoting policies. Another equal...

Words: 908 - Pages: 4

Free Essay


... in a case between Plessy vs. Ferguson, the United States Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of state laws requiring racial segregation in public facilities; this decision was detrimental to our society ( In 1954 the NAACP backed the efforts of the case of Brown vs. The Board of Education, which lead to a decision that, “separate educational facilities are inherently unequal” ( The monumental impact of this case is still widely demonstrated today. The government policy of affirmative action is undoubtedly a useful tool in the efforts of the NAACP. In 1971 the NAACP backed the efforts of the case of Griggs vs. Duke Power Company; a decision was made that reflected the policy of fair treatment by affirmative action ( Today there are some who support the policy of affirmative action, and some who are opposed, and some who feel we needed affirmative action at one time but now are no longer in need of it. In 2009 the plaintiffs of the case of Ricci vs. DeStefano sued the city of New Haven, Connecticut alleging they were discriminated against in regards to promotion (,0,554886.story). The plaintiffs passed a test for promotion, but because the African Americans did not have high enough scores the test was......

Words: 583 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

A Poison from the Future

...something amazing and incredible for everyone to use in today's society, but underneath the amazing and colorful page are small networks filled with nasty secrets, harsh gossip, and photos not meant for the eyes especially your eyes. You decided to surf through the internet to find an image of what you're looking for and you find something that you did not expect to see; an image that probably scarred you and your eyes. You think that social networks are private, but once you or someone else submits an embarrassing photo of you without your permission, everyone will see it. People may have settings to keep things private, but when it's out on the internet, everyone will find it somehow from a different resource. In an article by Brandon Griggs called "The 12 Most Annoying Types of Facebookers", the paparazzo is known for posting or tagging their friends and family to pictures that might be either inappropriate or humiliating without their permission. "Ever visit your Facebook page and discover that someone's posted a...

Words: 582 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Biblical World Essay

...and ask a person and to ask them if there is any restriction within their religion as pertaining to the way I as a nurse would take care of them. “The historical biblical account of the creation of Adam and Eve (Genesis 1:26-27) states that God made the first man and woman 'in His own image'” (Grigg, 2015). It is important to set a good example since we have been created in the image of God. Being in the world of nursing I try to be mindful of what I say and do since I am a representation of God. It is always important to show goodness, kindness and to have empathy for those whom you are taking care of. There are many challenges face within nursing from the patients, the patient families and just the overall work environment. I try to remain positive and just let the patient voice what is going on with them. The best form of effective communication is just to listen. I teach them how to keep positive and help them to determine their own outcome. If they are a Christian, I remind them that God is there to help guide them through these times and he will provide an answer. “Hebrews 1:2 tells us that when God made the worlds (KJV) or universe (NIV), He did so by His Son” (Grigg, 2015). As a nurse, it is important to have patients trust you and to know that you can be trusted. After all their lives are in your hands and God’s. The people of whom you take care of and those with whom you work with must come to know that you are a trustworthy person. Gossip is a......

Words: 815 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Business Analysis

...achieve their strategic goals. Within this paper it opened elements of the role of human resource management and the roles they played to helping the company achieve its business goals for the present and future. Business Analysis Apple, Inc. continues to strive to be the best company in the industry of technology. Continuing to improve year by year in growth and products, Apple revenue has grown by 82% year by year. Apple continues to compete across the board in several highly competitive markets, and article from CNN states “ranging from personal computer industry, the consumer electronics industry with products such as the iPhone, iPads, iPods and Mac and as well as digital music distribution through its iTunes Music store.” (Griggs, 2011, p.1) Apple’s strategic initiatives are to reconnect their employees into developing new products, services, and markets. The iPhone combines a mobile phone in a desktop category, providing e-mail, web browsing, and compatibility with both Macs and Windows-based computers. Ipad is very similar to the iPhone with a Co.’s Mulit-Touch technology and allowing customers to connect with their applications in a very interactive away anytime and anywhere in the world. “Strategies Apple are opening and expanding its own retail stories in key cities around all over the world in up-market, quality shopping stores.”(Marketingminds, 2010, p. 1). Apple structures many of its products towards...

Words: 974 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Human Resource Management

...Chapter 2: Equal Opportunity and the Law Multiple Choice 1. The _____ Amendment to the U.S. Constitution states, “no person shall be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of the law.” a. First b. Fifth c. Tenth d. Thirteenth e. Fourteenth (b; moderate; p. 30) 2. The _____ Amendment outlawed slavery, and courts have held that it bars racial discrimination. a. First b. Fifth c. Tenth d. Thirteenth e. Fourteenth (d; moderate; p. 30) 3. In what year was the 13th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution ratified? a. 1776 b. 1791 c. 1808 d. 1865 e. 1868 (d; difficult; p. 30) 4. The _____ Amendment makes it illegal for any state to “make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges and immunities of citizens of the United States.” a. First b. Fifth c. Tenth d. Thirteenth e. Fourteenth (e; moderate; p. 30) 5. Which amendment is generally viewed as barring discrimination based on sex, national origin, or race? a. First b. Fifth c. Tenth d. Thirteenth e. Fourteenth (e; moderate; p. 30) 6. The _____ gives all persons the same right to make and enforce contracts and to benefit from the laws of the land. a. Fifth Amendment b. Civil Rights Act of 1866 c. Title VII of the 1964......

Words: 5338 - Pages: 22

Premium Essay

Revenue and Expenses

...Affirmative Action and Social Psychology Tamara Hill PSY11017VA016-1134001(Social Psychology) Profess. Jason Hamilton June 08, 2012 Bottom of Form Over the years there are a number of laws that have been put in place that has shaped society and paved the way for many to succeed. The Affirmative Action Law is one of the laws that were established to provide an equal playing field in many environments such as schools, employment, businesses and our daily lives in society. For many years there have been unrepresented groups that experienced discrimination during times of enrollment into schools, on the job promotions and even when trying to receive bank loans to start up his or her own business. Since the establishment of Affirmative Action in 1961it has paved the way to ensure that unrepresented groups are represented throughout society as we know it today. This law has been amended several times to ensure that no minority group is unrepresented in any circumstance. In the 1960’s Affirmative Action in the United States was used as a tool to address the persistent discrimination against African Americans. This specific term was first used to describe US government policy in 1961. President John F. Kennedy in 1961 mandated "affirmative action to ensure that applicants are employed, and that employees are treated equally during employment, without regard to their race, creed, color, or national origin......

Words: 1137 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay


...La Salle Academy Iligan City S.Y. 2015 – 2016 An Investigatory Project On Diet Coke & Mentos In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements in Science 7 Submitted by: Alejo, Frank Felipe Endangan, Andrea Villiarosa, Ray Dominic Patero, Trexie Rashid, Rashida Submitted to: Maria Isabel Alesna Chapter I Introduction: Our topic is all about Coca-Cola. It is produced by the Coca-Cola Company in Atlanta, Georgia. And is often referred to simply as Coke. Originally intended as a patent medicine nor an exclusive right officially granted by a government to an inventor to make or sell an invention. And that was invented in the late of 19th century by John Pemberton, Coca-Cola was bought out by a business man Asa Griggs Candler, who’s marketing tactics led Coke to its dominance of the world soft-drinks market throughout the 20th century. We choose this topic because we want to realize that every person must to know that Coka-Cola is very acidic and not good for people. Even how you loved drinking soft drinks, but you must to knew that those ingredients can kill you. Our problem was all about what will be the reaction of the Coka-Cola if we put a mentos on it. We want to study this problem because we want to know what is the truth about the acid in the Coka-Cola. We wanted you to find out that when we show you our SIP, we want you to investigate how acid reacts. Our hypothesis is, If we put mentos in the diet Coke, the mentos react in the......

Words: 550 - Pages: 3