Free Essay

Guest of the Nation

In: English and Literature

Submitted By JoneSalka
Words 955
Pages 4
“Guest of the nation”

“Guest of the nation” touches upon the dilemma of justifying war on a personal moral and ethical level, and in describing this conflict it implicitly also touches upon the horrors of killing, and perhaps more importantly on what it does to a human being.
The text tells the story of three Irish soldiers holding two Englishmen as prisoners of war and is split into four parts. In the first part we are told about the daily life and interactions of the irish- and Englishmen. Their relationship is generally characterized by an unusual amount of mutual trust and friendship considering that they belong to rivaling armies, and especially considering that the cause that the Irish are fighting for is probably personally motivated, rather than being the result of a draft.
In the second part though this situation is darkened and complicated, by the fact that Jeremiah Donovan reveals that they are holding the Englishmen hostages as a mean of negotiation with the British, and that they are to be executed soon. In the third part the orders to execute are given, and part four depicts the Englishmen’s reluctant realization that they are to be executed by people who they perceive as friends and equals, as well as the Irish's reluctant attitude towards this execution, as Bonaparte puts it: "Why did any of us want to plug him? What had he done to us?" (S.62, L.7).
The overall dramaturgical structure of the text can therefore be seen as a transition from an initial harmonic state , the somewhat carefree environment of part 1, that is then interrupted by the message of the impending execution, eventually leading to a new altered order, resulting from the act of execution and the changes that it generates. And seeing as the initial order, characterized by friendship and trust, the interruption, characterized by reluctance and division, and the changed order, characterized by moral anguish, are the what makes up and drives the plot, these are also the main components of the theme and message of the text. What ties these plot-components together, is generally an underlying conflict between empathy on one hand and duty in a broad sense of the word on the other hand. Bonaparte and Noble's relation to the Englishmen generally represents the empathic side of the conflict; they treat them as equals and do not punish or constraint them, and when they hear learn about the execution they hope for the Englishmen to escape or be spared.
This can be said to reflect the aforementioned initial, harmonic order of the text, in which a humane treatment of the Englishmen is the natural behavior, at least from Bonapartes point of view, as he has an empathic relationship with the them, seeing them as equal human beings.
Donovan on the opposite does not sympathize much with the Englishmen, as Bonaparte expresses it: "it suddenly struck me that he had no great love for the two Englishmen", and he is also, in terms of the structure of the text, the one with the main responsibility for the execution. So being the strict one, having more focus on the war effort than on the specific condition he finds himself in, he represents the other side of the aforementioned conflict.
This order and environment is though pretty drastically tested and changed as the execution is to occur, because even though Hawkins appeals to the empathic side of the Irish men, emphasizing their ethic obligations ("not if I was to be shot twenty times over. I wouldn't shoot a pal"(S.62, L.33-34)) and their friendship ("You and me are Chumps…I'll come over to your side"(S.63, L.17-18)), they passively let the execution take place. Not that they do not feel empathy with the Englishmen, they just show that the power of authority weighs heavier than the power of empathy, in this case the authority of whoever general send the orders of execution. This also applies to Donovan who says "I'm sorry, Hawkins, but it's true" when asked about the execution. Apologizing to the man you are about to kill does not exactly sound like the words of a man completely dedicated to his cause, thus showing that even the man who had least close connection to the Englishmen is still divided between faith in empathy or authority.
And this is where the theme and message of the text appear, and leaves a somewhat dualistic point, because on one hand it shows how empathy and friendship can exist between people who are supposed to be in an antagonistic relationships with each other, but it also shows that it does not take much to overrule an empathic impulse. And the fact that people who are almost as close as friends can be made to passively let an execution take place, stands as a sharp critique of the condition that enables this situation: War.
Because in war you have to degenerate the enemy to something less than human, in order to endure the horrors of killing, and justify and accept your own actions. This requires a kind of cognitive generalization, where you only understand your enemy and yourself in the scheme of the entire war, and where actions are a result of duty and orders, not free moral choices. But when you are put face to face with the enemy, as it is the case in "Guest of the nation", you are suddenly no longer executing an enemy, you are executing a human being, and perhaps even worse, Bonaparte is executing what can best be described as a friend, "And anything that happened to me afterwards, I never felt the same about again"

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Teamwork in the Hospitality Industry

...Teamwork in the Hospitality Industry Teamwork is the primary gear that enables any business to run smooth and efficient. In this paper, the role of teamwork in regards to the food and beverage industry, entertainment, and accommodation will be discussed. Outcomes will be considered, and results of effective teamwork will be analyzed. Ultimately, each component of the industry will be examined in order to conclude how teamwork makes these businesses tick. 1. Food and Beverage The food and beverage industry is often a hectic one, but in order to maintain balance, teamwork, leadership, and communication is required. According to Introduction to Hospitality 6e (Walker), this chain of organization begins with the director of food and beverage. Walker explains that the director is responsible for the overview of restaurants, kitchen, room service, and lounges. In addition, Walker writes that the director must manage the business budget, provide proper leadership for employees, identify trends in the industry, and discover any means of achieving maximum profit capabilities. This may appear as daunting and overwhelming tasks, but none of this can be accomplished without the help of the co-workers. There are many active components within a restaurant that operate in sync to provide the upmost customer satisfaction. The kitchen may be considered to be the most challenging operation within the restaurant. Many individual tasks need to be managed and executed to provide proper......

Words: 1908 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Hospitality in the Iliad and Odyssey

...times of war, hospitality is provided to even the enemy. Housing strangers in one’s home was very common then, as many weary travelers trod by foot or sailed by boat to reach far-off destinations, making stops along the way. Moreover, since the Greeks believed the gods walked the earth amongst them, then turning down a travelers request, could mean rejecting a god masked from view. The Greeks took no chances in this regard; and with only a few exceptions, Homer’s literary characters comply with this religious doctrine and cultural norm. Hospitality in Ancient Greece, as portrayed by Homer, accounts, in part, for their longstanding world dominance and aligns itself in many ways with the Christianity enjoyed by many peace-loving nations of today. The guest-host relationship in both The Iliad and The Odyssey remain constant, the differences between the two dependent only on the differing circumstances posed by each tale (Biggs, Joseph, Schrodt & Dustan, n.d.) Today, America’s dominance in world affairs can be accounted for in part by attitudes towards the civil treatment of those in distress. In Ancient Greece, fear of the gods’ wrath played into what would otherwise be accounted for as acts of generosity. According to Biggs, fear posed by Greek gods dictates most aspects of their lives (n.d.). Similarly, fear of God accounts for many Christian acts of...

Words: 3496 - Pages: 14

Free Essay

Guests or Enemies

...Guests or Enemies In literature most prestigious writers like relating their works to their personal lives and experience. Personal experiences will help writers to shape their characters in more than one ways including psychological and physical aspects. In addition, personal background also helps authors to grasp themes or prospects better so that their stories are more plausible and readable even though they are fictional. Frank O'Connor is a writer who did this. “Guests of the Nation” is definitely a story based on his own experience. Frank O'Connor puts his personal thoughts and experiences to arrange the characters in order to talks about the relationship between personal duty and humanity during the war, which also implies the relationship between political conflicts and the hope of peaceful life for humans. Though out history, at the beginning Ireland was a British colony, the economic depressed and had a time of hardship. By 1900, the Irish Civil War loomed. In the summer of 1913, Dublin workers went on strike for 5 months, indicating that the proletariat had become the Irish independent political force. During World War I in 1914, the Irish national fighting moved to further. Easter Rising broke out in April 1916. In 1919, the Sinn Fein refused to attend the British Parliament, but held their own in the Dublin parliament and the creation of army. In 1921, the Irish Civil War occurred; the Irish people started fighting for national independence, autonomy for land......

Words: 1229 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay


...this report is to develop a new kind of marketing mix for the Four Seasons to meet the demand of different guests. The thesis statement of this report is the Four Seasons may gain more popularity if they adopt the new kind of marketing mix. The research and the interview have been done as for the original sources, and the key finding is his competitor biggest advantage is the cheap price. In conclusion, the Four Seasons will be better if they have developed the new kind of accommodation which has the acceptable price, then Four Seasons hotel will be more competitive because of his services, facility, and the proce. 1.0 Introduction The objectives of this research are analyzing the accommodation market, and creating a marketing mix for a famous 5-start hotel Four Seasons. The reason that the company was chosen is it have high quality of the services and is well-known around the world. The guests for the Four Seasons who are in the group of high social-economics most are travelers for entertainment or business. “Nation of customization” is the key for the success in those country, also the core philosophy “loyal to the guest” gain the popularity for them (Clampet 2014). Design in different style for the customers to give the best experience all around the world is the meaning of “Nation of customization”. This company tries their best to meet the demand of the guests, including the catering, shopping, and the other kind of services. Now four seasons is quite successful,......

Words: 2116 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Sustainability in Tourism

...abbreviations II III. List of tables and Figures III 1. INTRODUCTION 4 1.1 A BRIEF INTRODUCTION OF MANASLU 5 1.2 THE TEA HOUSE PROJECT 6 2. Sustainability Model 8 2.1 Social: 8 2.2 Economic: 9 2.3 Environment: 9 3. THE TARGET GROUP 10 3.1 INVOLVEMENT OF THE LOCALS 11 3.2 TRAINING 11 3.3 PROPOSED MODULE 12 3.4 OUTCOME 15 4. SWOT ANALYSIS 16 IV. List of references VI II. List of abbreviations ITB Berlin Internationale Tourismus Börse Berlin. TRPAP Tourism for Rural Poverty Program WTM World Travel Market. WTO. World Trade Organization UNESCO United Nations Educational and Cultural Organization UNDP United Nations Educational Development Program UNWTO United Nations World Tourism Organization III. List of tables and Figures Figure. 1 Sustainable Model 8 Tab. 1 Training model and curricullum 12, 13 and 14 1. INTRODUCTION Bahadhur (2012) affirms that Nepal is a federal democratic nation that proudly lies in the Himalayas and which borders China and India from the North and South respectively, Nepal is a country that is landlocked but the beauty and the existence of its magnificent high Himalayas mountains and the diverse cultures and ethnic factions makes this country one of the mysterious countries for any foreign visitor.Christie (2008) further states that the Nepalese government depends on tourism as a major source of foreign revenue and a major source of employment for the natives. The need for sustainability in tourism is a......

Words: 3898 - Pages: 16

Free Essay


...3 Branding (Sponsor) (dsaexibition 2014) 13 7.5.4 Facilities (Sponsor) 13 7.6 Legal and Risk, Health and Safety Management 14 8.0 Logistic 14 9.0 Evaluation 15 10.0 Conclusion 15 11.0 References 16 11.0 Appendix 17 Executive Summary DSA 2014 was the biggest Defence Services Asia Exhibition and Conference staged in Kuala Lumpur so far. Attendance were record highs with 344 foreign delegations from over 45 nations, 33,544 trade visitors from 96 countries and 1057 companies occupying a floor area of 41000 sq. metres. The analysis carried out by our group discovered that the organising committee, led by the Secretary General of Defence Malaysia, did a fine job in event design and program. Participants could understand the layout of the venue and so navigate efficiently within the site of the event. The site was themed into country pavilions with designated paths and separate programs for VVIP delegations, distinguished guests, exhibitor’s and visitors to follow. This year's event witnessed the debut of new features: Cyber Security, Humanitarian & Disaster Relief (HADR) and transnational crime & non-conventional security threat in the wake of terrorism,...

Words: 3821 - Pages: 16

Premium Essay


...Housekeeping used to be considered “just a cleaning department”, but hotel surveys have shown again and again that cleanliness is at the top of the list of requirements of hotel guests. This book deals with modern management techniques and equipment used by housekeeping managers to ensure a safe and comfortable stay for hotel guests. The Front Office is the heart of a hotel. Associates of this department are responsible for the guest’s first and the last impression of the hotel. According to studies, the last impression is a lasting impression which will be instrumental for the guest’s decision to return to the hotel for his next visit. This book deals with modern equipment and management techniques used to produce a pleasant environment for guests and how the front line personnel can prevent and solve problems during a guest’s stay. |   Young associates just starting their career in hospitality need to study people carefully before they can figure out what each guest really would like. A special chapter deals with communication and assignments provided on the DVD will develop students’ communi­cative skills and give them an insight in kinesics. |   Human resource Hotel associates with international work experience will be instrumental in bringing about a better understanding among nations and cultures and reduce intolerance. Realising the importance of human resource management, the author has devoted a whole chapter on the process of selecting, training,......

Words: 520 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Executive Summary - Taj Hotel

...assault, known as 26/11, shocked the nation and exposed the country’s vulnerability to terrorism yet again. The Taj’s burning domes which stayed ablaze for two days and three nights, will forever symbolize the tragic events of 26/11. When terrorists attacked the iconic 103 year old - Taj Mahal Palace hotel, there were as many as 600 guests in various rooms and around 600 people were present for dinner events at various restaurants in the hotel. Among them was a dinner hosted by Chairman and CEO of of Hindustan Unilever and several of its directors, senior executives and their spouses to bid farewell to the CEO and welcoming the new CEO-elect of Unilever. The staff quickly realized something was wrong. They locked the doors, turned off the lights and asked everyone to lie down quietly under tables and refrain from using cell phones. They asked husbands and wives to separate to reduce the risk to families. They rushed people to safe locations such as kitchens and basements. Telephone operators stayed at their posts, calling guests to lock doors and not step out. All employees stayed there in spite of the terrorists rampaging through the hotel, hurling grenades, firing automatic weapons, and tearing the place apart. The staff kept calm and constantly went around offering water and asking people if they needed anything else. When evacuating, the staff evacuated the guests first by risking their lives. They formed human cordons around the guests while they were escaping to......

Words: 841 - Pages: 4

Free Essay


...Airline Studies Module Code – 5N4971 An Investigation into Aviation Organisation By: Milton Redmond Table of Contents Introduction: 3 Aims & Objectives: 3 Brief Description of Civil Aviation and Relationship with UNWTO: 4 Chicago Convention 4 United Nations World Tourism Organization 5 ICAO and UNWTO Affirm Cooperation on Joint Aviation and Tourism Goals 5 Description of Etihad Airways: 6 Partners and Alliances: 10 Chartered & Scheduled Flight Services: 20 Etihad Airport Services 23 EAS-Ground 23 EAS-Cargo 24 EAS-Catering 24 Aircraft Type & Passenger Capacity: 25 World's Top 3 Airlines 2013 Profiles and Etihads Direct Competitors: 28 Importance of Branding and General Airport Operations: 29 Movement of Passengers at Abu Dhabi Airport: 31 Communications Utilized by Etihad: 33 Conclusion: 35 Recommendations: 35 Bibliography: 35 Introduction: This assignment requires the author to type a written report on one organisation in the aviation industry which covers learning outcomes 4, 5, 8, 9, 11, 16 & 17 as per the module component. This report is to identify and research an airline related product or service that meets a particular consumer need. Finally the Author will evaluate the findings, draw conclusions and recommendations. Aims & Objectives: * Evidence of understanding and application of Airline Studies. * Detailed Exploration of the chosen topic. * Use / selection of......

Words: 6506 - Pages: 27

Premium Essay

Republic Day India

...independent republic. 26 January was selected for this purpose because it was this day in 1930 when the Declaration of Indian Independence (Purna Swaraj) was proclaimed by the Indian National Congress. It is one of three national holidays in India, the other two being Independence Day and Gandhi Jayanti. Contents [hide] 1 History 2 Celebrations 2.1 Delhi Republic Day parade 2.2 Beating Retreat 3 Gallery 4 Chief guest 5 See also 6 References History[edit] President Rajendra Prasad (in the horse-drawn carriage) readies to take part in the first Republic Day parade on Rajpath, New Delhi, in 1950. India achieved independence from British rule on 15 August 1947 following the Indian independence movement noted for largely peaceful nonviolent resistance and civil disobedience led by Mahatma Gandhi. The independence came through the Indian Independence Act 1947 (10 & 11 Geo 6 c 30), an Act of the Parliament of the United Kingdom that partitioned British India into the two new independent Dominions of the British Commonwealth (later Commonwealth of Nations): India and Pakistan.[2] India obtained its independence on 15 August 1947 as a constitutional monarchy with George VI as head of state and the Earl Mountbatten as governor-general. The country, though, did not yet have a permanent constitution; instead its laws were based on the modified colonial Government of India Act 1935. On 28 August 1947, the Drafting Committee was appointed to draft a permanent...

Words: 877 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Principle of Population

...The full title of the first edition of Malthus' essay was "An Essay on the Principle of Population, as it affects the Future Improvement of Society with remarks on the Speculations of Mr. Godwin, M. Condorcet, and Other Writers." The speculations and other writers are explained below. William Godwin had published his utopian work Enquiry concerning Political Justice in 1793, with later editions in 1796 and 1798. Also, Of Avarice and Profusion (1797). Malthus' remarks on Godwin's work spans chapters 10 through 15 (inclusive) out of nineteen. Godwin responded with Of Population (1820). The Marquis de Condorcet had published his utopian vision of social progress and the perfectibility of man Esquisse d'un Tableau Historique des Progres de l'Espirit Humain (The Future Progress of the Human Mind) in 1794. Malthus' remarks on Condorcet's work spans chapters 8 and 9. Malthus' essay was in response to these utopian visions, as he argued: "This natural inequality of the two powers, of population, and of production of the earth, and that great law of our nature which must constantly keep their effects equal, form the great difficulty that appears to me insurmountable in the way to the perfectibility of society." The "Other writers" included Robert Wallace, Adam Smith, Richard Price, and David Hume. Malthus himself claimed: "The only authors from whose writings I had deduced the principle, which formed the main argument of the Essay, were Hume, Wallace, Adam Smith, and Dr. Price ...

Words: 1548 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Mr Man

...HP Envy dv7t-7200 Quad Edition Notebook PC Acer Aspire V3-571-9890 1) Compare the following items for your selections: a. Price: HP $999.99, Acer $729.99 b. Delivery Charges: HP Standard shipping $9.99, Acer Standard Ground Shipping $15.00 c. Financing Options: HP No payments/Interest if paid full in 12 months, Acer no current offer d. Discounts: HP additional 15% off accessories with pc purchase, Acer free overnight shipping e. Coupons: Could not find coupons, companies possibly send these with shipped items f. Warranties: HP Two year limited hardware warranty, Acer one year international travelers limited warranty g. Installation Offered: HP windows 8 os, Norton internet security 2012, hp games; Acer windows 8 os h. Recycling of Old Components Offered: HP offers information on recycling different products in your local area, Acer also has a recycling program with information on how to dispose of components in your area. 2) What are some factors that can impact the gross profit of a merchandise company? There are many different factors that can impact the gross profit of a merchandise company including an increase in supplies, labor, and taxes. Anything that increases the cost of producing a product or providing a service affects the gross profit of the merchandise/service. In many markets, companies do not have the ability to increase the price of their product just because of increase in production costs, thus costing them......

Words: 1487 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Political Ideology

...Assignment 5 Paper Both freedom and equality are political issues that have yet to be fully resolved and understood despite our nation being founded on both. Although we as a society have glamorized our country as being the “Land of the Free” and where “Everyone is created equal,” there are still social issues that give reason to believe that we as citizens of the United States aren’t so equal and not exactly all that free. In the Dialogue readings, I have selected four of which I feel could be strongly applied to the political beliefs of both freedom and equality. In the “Self and Society” book complied of different readings and philosophical authors, I have chosen Albert Camus, B.F. Skinner, Horace Miner, and C. Wright Mills as comparisons to the ideas on freedom and equality. In Camus’ reading entitled “The Guest,” the schoolmaster named Daru is visited by a horseman, Balducci. Alongside Balducci is his captive prisoner, an Arab who remains nameless throughout the reading. Balducci instructs Camus to take the prisoner to police headquarters to face accusations against a supposed crime he had committed. Throughout the story, Daru is seen living well in his furnished and heated home that looks over an impoverished, cold and often corrupt land. This demonstrates quite obviously that not everyone is considered equal, as the rest of the land is cold and freezing while Daru is kept warm. Daru, who goes against Balducci’s orders, and remains true to his own personal......

Words: 1008 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Pr Advertorial

...Andy Cheung, McDonald's Franchisee, Forced Out After Allegations Of Worker Exploitation The Huffington Post  |  By Bonnie Kavoussi Posted: 03/14/2013 6:52 pm EDT A franchisee who owns three McDonald's restaurants in Harrisburg, Pa., has left the company after allegations of worker exploitation. Foreign guest workers -- students from Asia and Latin America -- employed by the franchisee, Andy Cheung, allege that he forced them to work shifts of up to 25 hours and pay steep rent for living in his and his son's crowded basements, according to The Nation. The workers also allege that Cheung did not pay them for all of the hours they worked and that he retaliated against them for going on strike by locking them out of their living quarters. The guest workers paid as much as $3,000 apiece to come to the U.S. on temporary visas as part of a State Department exchange program, according to the National Guestworker Alliance, which is representing the workers. The group says Cheung deducted rent from the workers' paychecks, pushing their pay below the minimum wage. "We were living 6 men in a basement, on bunk beds that were clearly made [for] children and one tiny bathroom," Jorge Rios, an Argentinian college student who started working for Cheung in December, told CNNMoney. The workers have filed complaints with both the Labor Department and the State Department. Danya Proud, a McDonald's spokeswoman, told The Huffington Post in a Thursday statement that the company has......

Words: 1261 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

India - Russia Relations

...Until January 26th 2015, no American president had ever been the chief guest for the annual Republic Day celebrations of India. However, presidents of erstwhile USSR and present Russia have been the chief guests on multiple occasions in the past, with President Putin gracing the Occasion in 2007. This seemingly inconsequential bit of information goes to show how the relations between India and Russia, have been placed on the back burner. Formerly, India considered Russia to be its ‘Big Brother’ of sorts and turned to Russia for help in all domains be it in the field of supply of arms and ammunition or on the protection of India’s interests in the international forum. Today, India has focussed largely on developing friendly relations with the western nations and it could be argued that, it is a move for the better, considering we are more at sync in ideology with the western nations, than the communist ideologies of Russia. But, the question which needs to be examined in an intricate manner is whether, India should continue to focus on developing relations with the western world, or has the time come to revitalize or reenergise relations with Russia? For India to improve its ties with Russia, there needs to be a committed and definite change in the foreign Policy which India has adopted towards Russia in recent times. India has failed to realise that china seeks to be an uncontested regional power, and by alienating Russia, India only seeks to push the Russians into the......

Words: 769 - Pages: 4