Harley Davidson Case Study

In: Business and Management

Submitted By hany
Words 2262
Pages 10
Chapter 6
Strategy Analysis & Choice

Strategic Management:
Concepts & Cases
13th Edition
Global Edition
Fred David

Please note this is not a comprehensive source for studying

Please note this is not a comprehensive source for studying

Ch 6 -1

Ch 6 -2

Strategy Analysis & Choice
“Whether it’s broke or not, fix it – make it
better. Not just products, but the whole
company if necessary.”
– Bill Saporito

“Life is full of lousy options.”
– General P.X. Kelley

Please note this is not a comprehensive source for studying

Ch 6 -3


Strategy Analysis & Choice
Subjective decisions based on objective
Generating alternative strategies
Selecting strategies to pursue
Best alternative course of action to
achieve mission & objectives
Derived from vision, mission, objectives,
external audit, and internal audit
Please note this is not a comprehensive source for studying

Ch 6 -4

Strategy Analysis & Choice
Generating Alternatives –
Participation in generating alternative
strategies should be as broad as

Please note this is not a comprehensive source for studying

Ch 6 -5

Comprehensive StrategyFormulation Framework
Stage 1 - Input Stage
EFE Matrix
IFE matrix

Stage 2 - Matching Stage
SPACE matrix
BCG matrix
IE Matrix
Grand strategy matrix

Stage 3 - Decision Stage
Please note this is not a comprehensive source for studying

Ch 6 -6


Strategy-Formulation Framework
External Factor Evaluation
Matrix (EFE)

Stage 1:
The Input Stage

Internal Factor Evaluation
Matrix (IFE)

Competitive Profile Matrix

Please note this is not a comprehensive source for studying

Ch 6 -7

Stage 2: The Matching Stage

Match between organization’s internal
resources & skills and the opportunities &
risks created by its external factors

Please note this is…...

Similar Documents

Harley Davidson Case Study

...STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT Case Analysis CASE: Harley Davidson, Inc- 2008 By Julian Kee Synopsis Harley-Davidson is one the leading motorcycle manufacturers in the world. It’s hard to imagine the global brand’s simple beginning. In 1901, Harley-Davidson motor company started in a backyard shed by friends William Harley and Arthur R. Davidson who wanted to create their own motorcycles. In 1907, the company had grown to become incorporated. Harley-Davidson was acquired by AMF in 1969, however repurchased in 1981 by the Vaughn Beals. The company then underwent changes to production an inventory management. Since 1996, Harley-Davidson has focused only on producing motorcycles and accessories. The company is run by a 38-year employee name James C. Ziemer, who has experience in many different positions. He is supported by a board of directors with diverse professional backgrounds. Together, they oversee the US and global operations which includes countries like Canada, Latin America, and Europe. Harley-Davidson has two different business segments which include motorcycles and financial services. The current economic conditions have affected all industry including motorcycles. While Harley-Davidson has proven to do well during the recession, they have also faced some challenges. As the economic conditions change, Harley- Davidson has implemented new marketing strategies and e-commerce to gain a competitive advantage. Resources Strong reputation...

Words: 1881 - Pages: 8

Harley Davidson Case Study

... strategic capabilities Rarity Inimitability Non-sustainability 4) Where are Harley’s weaknesses? • The current finance debt of Harley-Davidson is a large sum of 495,441 in 2004 as oppose to 8,000 in 1996 (exhibit 2 of case study). • The median house hold income of Harley-davidson owners are still high at $80930.00 a year so there is still a gap in the lower income riders. In addition, if economical unrests occur then Harley-Davidson may once again loss its customer base. 5) What are the future challenges for Harley 6) Recommendations for Harley. It was able to increase brand loyalty and tap into the US patriotic mentality by attaching its logo with the American symbol. It leveraged its competitive edge of having was in its innovations and continued to invest in R&D to maintain and build on its strengths. When sales cycles declined in the 1950s, the company relied on its innovations, “producing larger, more powerful motorcycles” and building on its established “raw power” image to increase its sales. The distinctive V-twin engine of the Harley helped it to solve a problem with the owners since they can fix the engine themselves at a time when mechanics were unavailable. It had a distinctive look and sound to attract customers. Marketed to customers with an “image and lifestyle” image. Got the support of the government, got celebrities that embodied the image of the brand on become its customers and endorse the Brand. This inturns helps to......

Words: 2650 - Pages: 11

Harley Davidson Case Study

...The Harley Davidson case evaluates several options and choosing the one that best aligns with company’s strategy, is financially viable for long term and provides a strong footing against the rising competition. The case is fundamentally focused on the question of timing and capacity. Timing is a factor that needs built into our decision tree’s framework and in this case, ultimately asking, when and how much capacity? In order to answer the question, we diagnosed the issues and identified limitations of the current capacity, which hampers Harley’s ability to expand and meet demand. It is important to appropriately incorporate risk as it goes well beyond just capacity. For incorporate risk into the analysis and decision making we recognized that a series of tools would be required. The approach involved three analysis tools for considering various factors that are important for decision making: Demand Analysis: We needed to forecast for the demand, supply and margins, while distinguishing demand from output and sales. Scenarios and Capacity Analysis: Next step was to determine the factors for building the scenarios, assign probabilities, estimate the cash flow and then compute the NPV. We modeled capacity adjustments and continuous improvements, then included plans or options for changes and new products. Risk Analysis and addressing management’s success criteria: Our decision needed to account for the risk aversion of the company due to its learning from its...

Words: 2941 - Pages: 12

Harley-Davidson Case Study

...1. Why would Harley-Davidson put as much emphasis on consistency of quality as it does on level of quality? In the 1980’s Harley-Davidson was going through Great Depression and teetered on the brink of bankruptcy. They decided to reduce the inventory and improve total quality of the product in order to attract new as well as experienced buyers. They changed styling, performance, and features which represents the freedom and individuality of the motorcycles. They started doing custom-build bikes, because this way Harley-Davidson can see what customers want in order to express their individuality (Pride, et.al. 2011). 2. How does Harley-Davidson use customer services to differentiate its motorcycle products? Harley-Davidson maintains positive relationship with customers simply by satisfying their needs in the products. They do custom-build bikes and products which are usually in high demand. They also offering the driving courses as well as group riding in order to encourage customers learn how to drive. Harley-Davidson in order to promote their product has web site and sends an existing members two magazines which include: member events, articles about Harley-Davidson’s product and services. I think this is a good idea having the member’s events, because customer’s communication is a mouth-by-mouth advertising, and if the customers are satisfied with the product and services, then the company will definitely grow (Pride, et.al. 2011). 3. What role do you think the......

Words: 340 - Pages: 2

Harley-Davidson Case Analysis

...Harley-Davidson Case Analysis Harley-Davidson should tailor is product and service offerings to the 55-64 year old segment, and expand its Rental and Rider’s Edge programs to continue growing Market leader in motorcycles - Market leader with 50% domestic and 32% global market share in motorcycles - Stock prices CAGR since 1989: 32% - American legendary lifestyle brand - Loyal customers: 900,000 members in Harley-Davidson Owner Group - 50% of sales to repeating customers - Average customer age grew from 35 in 1994 to 47 in 2004 - Young customers are not attracted by the brand - Women are still only 10% of clients - 2005 sales target cut back by 10,000 bikes - Stock price dropped 17% Ageing customer base and difficulty to attract new clients How can Harley-Davidson continue to grow despite its ageing customer base and difficulty to attract new customers? Harley-Davidson should: Adapt product and service offering to cater for the 55-64 year-old segment, retaining it for 10 years longer Expand the rental program to increase seeding, bringing more new customers into the base Expand the Rider’s Edge program to increase seeding in the underexplored women and young segment Harley-Davidson dominated the US market during the first half of the 1900’s, but lost share to the devastating competition of Japanese manufacturers towards the 70’s 1908 – 1920’s 1930’s – 1950’s Strong brand image - Famous ambassadors - National symbol status Powerful/large motorcycle 1960’s...

Words: 1514 - Pages: 7

Harley Davidson Case Study

...Executive Summary “Harley-Davidson is the iconic American motorcycle manufacturer. Founded out of a small shed in 1903 by William S. Harley and Brothers Arthur and Walter Davidson in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. The Motor Company produces traditional cruiser motorcycles utilizing air-cooled V-Twin engines.  When Harley and Davidson produced and sold their first motorcycle in 1903, they were one of many small motorcycle marques springing up across the country. Flash forward more than a century and the Harley-Davidson brand is so rooted in American culture that the history of the company intertwines with the history of America itself. “ Harley- Davidson a brand that say I’m an American with its strong image they summarize what biking is and isn’t. They produce quality products that are reliable and durable. With so much more to offer Harley-Davidson cannot compete with the Japanese in terms of market share in Europe they only have 6.4% which is excruciating for a company who consider their product as a luxury item with all top of the line parts, brand image ,and all the thing they offer to the consumers. That’s why we look for alternative that could be beneficial to Harley-Davidson which is Market penetration, market development, and product development in Europe. We generated this idea ease them and with employees who know what their job is and make the necessary adjustment in their product or service need not worry of what will happen. Situational Analysis Environment...

Words: 3348 - Pages: 14

Harley Davidson Case Study Analysis

...Case Introduction Harley-Davidson, Inc. was established and entered the motorcycle industry in 1903. The company has primarily focused its resources on the heavyweight motorcycle segment of the industry and is differentiated from its competitors because its focus is only on the motorcycle industry as opposed to other transportation markets such as: cars, boats, ATVs or snowmobiles. The company has experienced both the “good and bad times.” The company was founded by several young men in 1903, was bought out by AMF, experienced a leveraged buyout and ultimately became incorporated with its IPO in 1986. In addition to a constantly changing ownership structure, Harley-Davidson has also experienced significant issues with quality control, inconsistent management and a reputation for being associated with tattoos and pornography. By 1998, the company resolved its quality and image concerns, gained financial stability but continued to face supply concerns and threats of competition by new entrants and possible product substitutes. The challenge facing current Harley-Davidson management is how to combine the company’s approach in marketing the Harley image with consistent financial stability and increasing market share to outperform the competition. Industry Overview Harley-Davidson competes against other American and several internationally based companies within the motorcycle industry. Harley...

Words: 1810 - Pages: 8

Harley Davidson Case

...Case 3- Harley-Davidson Motor Company: Enterprise Software Selection 1. For justification of an IT project expense, expected benefits can be divided into three parts as tangible, intangible, and productivity benefits. The first chart represents quantitative alignment corresponding to tangible and productivity benefits. The second one shows qualitative criteria highlighting the benefits to the company. What these charts are lacking is an explicit match to the “as-is” needs of the company as referenced in Exhibit 5 on page 17. It is clear that significant improvements are going to have to be made for purchasing and materials professionals to transition from bolded activities constituting 70% of their time, up from only 10%. Although the self-evaluation is built to fit against the functional specification, it does not call-out the proposed time savings in order to match the envisaged benefits of SiL’K. The first chart seems to lack properly exhibited costs related to “People” and “Process”. In exhibit 9 on page 20 the Strategic Roadmap for this change management initiative is recorded as at least 50% driven by people and 25-50% driven by the process and technology. If the functional specification given to providers was only built to strategically assess only 50% of the project, the qualitative criteria must balance this focus. The second chart lacks soft benefits which are among the most important factors for choosing a provider. Additionally, the second chart...

Words: 869 - Pages: 4

Harley Davidson Case Study

...Case Study 6.1: Harley-Davidson, Inc. Zachary NewComer 11/06/14 Auditing Prof. Riggs (1)Identify the most significant new business risks facing Harley-Davidson as a result of integrating eBusiness into its supply-chain management system and by allowing suppliers to have access to the company’s Intranet. If your instructor does not specify the number of risks for you to identify, list at least three. 1. Suppliers might leak information to Harley-Davidson’s competitors 2. Suppliers might not have the same ability to be technologically advanced as Harley-Davidson’s new systems 3. Going to an internet based system makes you susceptible to people hacking the system and acquiring information. 4. When you have an internet based system it could go down at any point making the time it is down a loss of productive time that in the old system would not have been lost. 5. Hiding fraud would be easier because more people have access to system and there is no longer a paper trail for auditors to trace in the new system. 6. If the system permanently crashes or is destroyed by something like a fire you might not be able to save some or all of the information to continue business afterwards. 7. If Harley-Davidson ever wanted to do business with a different supplier they might not be ready or have the ability to do business with them. [2] For each risk you identified in question number one above, identify a control Harley-Davidson might have implemented to mitigate that risk. 1...

Words: 1393 - Pages: 6

Harley Davidson Case Study

...Introduction The Harley-Davidson Company was founded in Milwaukee, Wisconsin by William Harley and two Davidson brothers Walter and Arthur. They sold their first motorcycle, a motorized bicycle with a three-horsepower engine. In 1907, before they left the factory grounds they sold 50 motorcycles. In 1909, they introduced a iconic two cylinder V-twin engine. By 1920 Harley was the largest motorcycle manufacturer in the United States and the industry's technological leader. During World War I, over 90,000 cycles were built for the military which elevated their production. After the war, Harley went from producing military to recreational bikes. Harley developed and introduced the K-model (1952), Sportster ("Superbike", 1957), and Duo-Glide (1958) motorcycles. By 1953, Harley-Davidson was the last remaining major motorcycle manufacturer in the US. Harley-Davidson became a hostile takeover bid, but the founding families sold it to a “white knight” a large manufacturing company American Machine and Foundry (AMF) in 1969. AMF put the company up for sale in the late 1970's due to a gross reduction in sales. The reduction in sales was representative of a poor level of quality in the Harley bike compared to their Japanese counterpart. In 1981, thirteen members of the Harley-Davidson management team purchased the company from AMF in a leveraged buy-out. The demand for motorcycles dropped dramatically and Harley's share of this market also continued to drop. There was even a...

Words: 1420 - Pages: 6

Harley Davidson Case Study

...Harley Davidson Case Study Case study of Harley Davidson Alan Potrus California Baptist University Author Note: This paper was made for Professor Joe Putulowski in accordance to week 6 assignment instructions for The Harley Davidson Case Study. Intro CEO Jeff Bleustein had his work cut out for him at the end of 2003 when he reviewed the company’s financial statements for the year. It was Harley Davidson’s 100 year anniversary and there were many festivities set out for that year that would eventually attract millions of participants. Sales and profits had broken previous records for the eighth consecutive year. HD has been performing so well it made a 180 degree turn in comparison to its numbers in the early 80’s when it was putting out 40,000 bikes a year and struggling with a mountain of debt. Jeff now had to figure out how to continue the uprising of profits. Because of this, Bleustein had little opportunity to reminisce about Harley’s 100 year celebration. Jeff set a target of 400,000 motorcycle sales by 2007. Jeff knew that in order to achieve this goal he needed to set a prestigious strategy plan that would accommodate the market for motorcycles and possibly attract new customers into the motorcycle market. Harley-Davidson’s Strategy Bleustein began preparing a strategy review with his top management team. They discussed the different forces that would cause HD to fall off course. It is...

Words: 1068 - Pages: 5

Harley Davidson Case Study

...What strategic recommendations for Europe do you have? The objectives of HDI include increasing sales, increasing market share in Europe, and achieving a sustainable competitive advantage. So, HDI is seeking to penetrate the market as well as engaging in market development, which in this case means attracting a new demographic segment of younger and European customers it has not yet attracted before due to several reasons such as the price and the appeal of the Harley Davidson brand as being a motorcycle “an old guy would drive”. As stated in the case study, HDI does not and will not have cost leadership in the industry it competes in. The huge gap between Honda which produces over 5 million bikes annually and HDI, which produces slightly over 200.000, allows Honda to benefit from economies of scale and therefore offer their products at lower prices than HDI. The relatively small size of HDI limits its ability to invest in technology and new products, which means that HDI neither has the most advanced technology, nor superior performance. However, as the company recognizes, it is not selling motorcycles, it is selling the “Harley Experience”. This lifestyle and spirit, which no competitor has been able to copy or even beat so far, is the competitive advantage and USP of HDI. Harley Davidson motorcycles are not primarily a transportation vehicle, but a statement of style. The HDI image and the brand loyalty among its consumer base are the company’s strongest assets. As the...

Words: 2894 - Pages: 12

Harley-Davidson/Ducati Case Study

...Harley-Davidson/Ducati Case Study November 20, 2013 Question 1 Ducati: Ducati is an Italian motorcycle manufacturing company that is renowned for its high performance and stylish motorcycles. Ducati is committed to racing competitions, state of the art design, style, and most importantly, an immense passion for bikes. Ducati has created a strong bond with its customers, beginning on the racetracks and spreading worldwide. Ducati builds high performance bikes for bike enthusiasts, known as “Ducatisti”. Ducastisti are individuals who value performance as the main attribute in a motorcycle. Since Ducati delivers this, it creates brand loyalty. Since the early 90s, Ducati has created a distinctive community image with local and national Ducati enthusiast clubs by placing Ducati as a symbol of refined skills and craftsmanship that every motorcycle evokes and represents. In the World Superbike Championship, Ducati has won 15 out of the last 18 Riders’ titles and 16 Manufacturers’ titles. In conclusion, Ducati customers are confident that they are purchasing high performance motorcycles. Harley Haley Davidson is exhibited as an American icon. Consumers view and associate Harley Davidson with riders, wear leather, have tattoos and with police officers, military dispatch riders and motorcycle gangs. Harley’s image is also viewed as something that is catered for and used by Caucasian American males in their 40-50 (Nolan pg.2-3).Harley Davidson’s riders feel a lifestyle...

Words: 3161 - Pages: 13

Harley Davidson Case Study

...Case Study: Harley-Davidson -Analyse Harley-Davidson resources and capabilities, and identify its key strengths and weaknesses - Analyse the international competitive environment in which Harley-Davidson is operating to identify its main threats and opportunities. Recommend a forward strategy for Harley-Davidson, which addresses these issues. International Management Individual Assignment Table of Contents 1. Introduction 3 2. Harley Davidson Overview 4 2.1. Harley-Davidson Current Strategy 4 2.2. Resources And Capabilities 5 3. Industry Analysis 6 3.1. Porter’s Five Forces Model 6 3.2. International Competitive Environment 7 4. SWOT Analysis 9 5. Forward strategy recommendation for Harley-Davidson 10 6. Conclusions 12 6. References 13 1. Introduction This report is based on Harley-Davidson, Inc., case study. The aim of this report is to analyse industry and international competitive environment where Harley-Davidson is operating in. One must apply and fully analyse theoretical concepts and frameworks in order to fully comprehend how Harley-Davidson is differentiate itself in the international competitive environment and what strategies is using to achieve higher market share. The empirical material is being analysed by exploring the general information of Harley-Davidson company itself, following by the industry and competitive environment analysis, review of SWOT theoretical framework. Finalising with the recommendations of...

Words: 3108 - Pages: 13

Harley Davidson Case Study

... segments it will target. A target market consists of a set of buyers who share common needs or characteristics that the company decides to serve. There are 4 ways of approaching the market 1. Undifferentiated marketing- it’s a market coverage strategy in which a firm decides to ignore market segment differences and go after the whole market with one offer- in other words they are mass marketing- they are going to sell the same product and message to everyone 2. Differentiated marketing – it’s a market coverage strategy in which a firm decides to target several market segments and design separate offers for each. In other words, we decide on several different markets and we approach each one of them differently. For example general motors makes cars but makes different ones for different needs like someone who will buy a Pontiac wont buy a Cadillac- they want to appeal to different markets. Another example is GAP- it has created different retail store formats that serve the different needs of different fashion segments – Gap, Banana republic, and Old navy 3. Concentrated marketing- it’s a market coverage strategy in which a firm goes after a large share of one or a few segments – in other words, we are going to choose one segment are we are going to be experts at it- we are going to own that piece of market. For example there are many motor cycles company out there but when you think of getting a motor cycle you automatically think of Harley Davidson 4.......

Words: 24040 - Pages: 97