Premium Essay

Harnischfeger Corporation

In: Business and Management

Submitted By wuzhufeng
Words 4382
Pages 18
Harnischfeger Corporation

Teaching Note

INTRODUCTION

The purpose of the "Harnischfeger Corporation" case is to expose students to the managerial motives for making major financial reporting policy changes.

Generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) allow companies wide latitude in the choice of accounting policies. After a firm chooses a set of accounting policies, current accounting rules permit changes from one alternative policy to another at the discretion of the management. Since reported accounting figures are widely used by a number of external parties, managers of firms have incentives to choose accounting policies in order to influence the behavior of these parties. A variety of managerial motives for accounting policy decisions have been identified in the accounting literature. The Harnischfeger case is designed to encourage students to explore these motives.

Harnischfeger Corporation, a large New York Stock Exchange company, faced a financial crisis in 1982. New management was appointed to turn the company around. As part of its restructuring strategy, the new management team made a number of financial reporting policy changes in fiscal 1984. Together, these changes accounted for most of Harnischfeger's reported 1984 profits. More significantly, these changes represented a substantial switch from the company's earlier conservative reporting philosophy to a more aggressive one.

The case describes the company's financial crisis, the turnaround strategy of the new management team, and the accounting policy changes that took place in 1984.

This case is a by-product of my field research, which is described in the paper, "The Anatomy of an Accounting Change." This paper is published in Accounting and Management: A Field Study Perspective, edited by William Bruns and Robert Kaplan (Harvard Business School Press, 1987).

This...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Harnischfeger Corporation

...CHAPTER 3 OVERVIEW OF ACCOUNTING ANALYSIS HARNISCHFEGER CORPORATION 1 Identify all the accounting policy changes and accounting estimates that Harnischfeger made during 1984. Estimate, as accurately as possible, the effect of these on the company’s 1984 reported profits. i. Harnischfeger Corporation had changed from accelerated to straight-line method for computing depreciation expenses on plants, machinery and equipment in 1984.The cumulative effect is that net income for 1984 increased by $11 million or $0.93 per common and equivalent share. As a result, this change applied on all assets previously subjected to accelerated depreciation, which has an insignificant effect. But in long term, he changes in depreciation policy would cause higher depreciation costs, so the maintenance costs would be higher in the future. ii. The company made a long-term contract about purchasing equipment with Kobe Steel, Ltd, As a result, the manufacturing costs are reduced, and both aggregate sales and cost of sales increased by $28 million. This change influenced on the quality of the earnings, which the profit margin was decreased to 1.44%. iii. Harnischfeger Corporation changed the inventories method to LIFO, thus increasing net income by $2.4 million. iv. Harnischfeger Corporation liquidated excess inventories and stretching payments to creditors. This can decrease the amount of debts and reduce the debts/equity ratio. As a result the company may get a unqualified......

Words: 550 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Harnischfeger Corporation

...Harnischfeger Corporation Introduction Harnischfeger Corporation is a machinery company in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. Harnischfeger was founded in 1884 as a partnership and was incorporated in Wisconsin in 1910 under the name Pawling and Harnischfeger. There were two major segments in this company, Construction Equipment and the Mining and Electrical Equipment divisions and Material Handling Equipment and the Harnischfeger Engineers divisions. Harnischfeger experienced a rapidly growth during the 1970s. However, the worldwide recession in the early 1980s caused a significant drop in demand for the company’s products starting in 1981 and Culminated in a series of events that shook the financial stability of Harnischfeger. (Palepu & Healy, 2013) So the Harnischfeger management decided to make some changes to respond to the financial crisis. Strategy Analysis Rivalry among existing firms Harnischfeger was a leading producer of construction equipment. The company had a dominant share of machinery market. In construction equipment market, Harnischfeger had market shares of about 20% in hydraulic cranes and 30% in lattice boom cranes. In the 1980s the construction equipment industry in general was experiencing declining margins. So the industry growth rate is low. The concentration of the construction equipment industry is quite low. Now there are only about 670 companies in the construction machinery manufacturing industry. The switching costs of this......

Words: 1475 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Harnischfeger Corporation

...Harnischfeger Corporation, a large New York Stock Exchange company, faced a financial crisis in 1982. New management was appointed to turn the company around and as part of its restructuring strategy, the new management team made a number of financial reporting policy changes and accounting estimates in fiscal year 1984. Listed below are all of the changes and analysis on whether they might be real earnings management activities. In addition, the effect of these changes on the company’s revenue, pre-tax profits and cash flows for the year 1984 will also be shown. 1. Depreciation method of its US operating plants was changed from accelerated methods to straight line method for financial reporting purposes (Note 2).This change in depreciation accounting method increased the 1984 income by $11 million. Harnischfeger’s management explained that this change was to conform to the industry standard. Under normal circumstances, this change would be perfectly reasonable. However, in this case, the timing of this policy change is questionable. It occurred when Harnischfeger was in the midst of negotiating its debt restructuring process with the banks. And since changing to a straight line method will improve the company’s financial strength in the short run, it strongly suggests that move was performed by the management to artificially improve the balance sheet in favour of the negotiations. 2. As a result from the change in depreciation method, there was also an adjustment of the......

Words: 806 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Harnischfeger Corporation

...ACCT5910 Business Analysis and Valuation Summary of Case This case is talking about Harnischfeger Corporation, leading producer of Construction Equipment, Mining and Electrical Equipment, Material Handling Equipment and Harnischfeger Engineer, based in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. The main topic of this case is the accounting policy changes after financial difficulties and its effect on financial reporting and the motive of these changes. Questions 1. Identify all accounting policy changes and accounting estimates that Harnischfeger made during 1984. Estimate, as accurately as possible, the effect of these on the company’s 1984 reported profit. Harnischfeger made the following accounting policy changes and accounting estimates during the year 1984. - There was a change in the recognition of some types of sales. This resulted in a change in sales calculation. Harnischfeger incorporated products purchased from Kobe Steel, which were re-sold by the company, into its net sales. This increased aggregate sales and cost of sales by $28 million. - There was a change in the fiscal year for some foreign subsidiaries. - There was a change in the depreciation methods on assets. The depreciation policy for financial reporting purposes was changed to a straight-line method from a principally accelerated method. - There was a change in the use of last-in, first-out (LIFO) liquidation in inventory valuation. - There was a change in the allowance for doubtful accounts. ...

Words: 965 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Harnischfeger Corporation

...Harnischfeger Corp. Case Harnischfeger Corp. is a large New York Stock Exchange company but with old-line, low-tech. This family-based old midwest company had a history for almost 100 years. When the recession hit the financial world during 1980-1981, Harnischfeger could hardly maintain its solid financial performance. Finally, it violated the bond covenants that significantly cause financial distress. In the year of 1984, a number of accounting policy changes were made by the new manager, Peter Roberts. The goals of our team are to figure out whether the company can truly turned around with respect to the Peter Roberts’ decisions. There were several managerial actions that affecting either accounting estimates or accounting policy in the year of 1984. First of all, Harnischfeger’s allowance for doubtful accounts as a percentage of gross accounts receivable dropped from 9.1% in 1983 to 6.3% in 1984 according to the Note 8. If we assume that the company continues to utilize its allowance for doubtful accounts at 9.1% of its gross accounts receivable at the end of 1984, its bad debt expense in 1984 would be $2.6 million more than expenses reported on the incomes statement. Because of the complexity of the components that affects the bad debt expense, it is possible that the management team could manipulate the balance. Then, in 1984, Harnischfeger began to sell products purchased from Kobe Steel in the market. However, a close inspection on the the financial statement......

Words: 1634 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Harnischfeger Corporation

...Case  Treppen aus Nord‐ Case ”Treppen aus Nord‐ Nordwegen” g Story Intro • "We must not underestimate the risks of  this project. Johannes Stiklestad looked  this project " Johannes Stiklestad looked at his in‐law worriedly. Briefly, Per Moen  had a slightly annoyed expression, but he  controlled himself quickly. He was fully  aware that they were talking about a big  investment for such a small business, and  that the implementation of the project  would require great efforts. If it should  would require great efforts If it should fail, it would also likely lead to the  traditional business closing down.  However, after working with this for a  long time, he really saw no other possible  way forward Johannes Stiklestad as • • • • • Established in 1950s by Johannes Stiklestad Producing stairs in pine and spruce + archways Producing stairs in pine and spruce + archways In 1982, Per Moen – Johannes Stiklestad son‐in‐ law entered business Stiklestad is not Chairman, and Moen is CEO Strategy: "We shall, according to customer  needs, develop and market building products for  homes. The products will have an appearance of  craftsmanship and quality, be solid and have  p q y, good custom‐made designs. We will not serve  the cheapest market. Stairs should have a  slightly exclusive impression, but we will not  serve the very exclusive market. “ y Good reputation among customer:  prefabricated houses, medium/small builders,  some private 2000 m2 factory floor 2000 m2 factory...

Words: 2530 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Harnischfeger Corporation

...Question 1. Identifying all the changes in accounting policy and accounting estimates that Harnischfeger made during financial year ending October 31, 1984. Also include in your discussion, what you believe may be real earnings management activities to affect profit. Estimate as accurately as possible, the effect of these changes on the company’s revenue, pre-tax profits and cash flows in 1984. Harnischfeger made the following changes in accounting policy and estimates: Harnischfeger made changes regarding the recognition of some types of sales. They decided to include products bought from Kobe Steel Ltd. and sold by them to be in its net sales, effective November 1983. Before that, only gross margin from products bought from Kobe was included. The company claimed that they wanted to present more fairly the nature of the business transactions with Kobe. Therefore, this increased the aggregate sales by $28 million during the fiscal year 1984. In my opinion, this may be real earnings management activity to affect profit because there is no solid reason for the company to make such changes. It was purely to increase the company’s revenue. In addition, effective fiscal 1984, Harnischfeger changed some of its foreign subsidiaries financial year-end to September 30 instead of July 31. This would affect the consolidated income statement of the company and it increased the net sales in 1984 by $5.4 million since this lengthened the reporting period to 14 months of operations of......

Words: 1416 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Man6608

...Jennifer Diaz ACG6175 Harnischfeger Corp: Case Study 2 1. Describe clearly the accounting changes Harnischfeger made in 1984 as stated in Note 2 of its financial statements. As stated in Note 2 of its financial statements, the accounting changes Harnischfeger made in 1984 are those of net sales of the products that were purchased from Kobe Steel which were then sold by Harnischfeger which added on to the net sales of the company. Harnischfeger included financial statements of certain foreign subsidiaries. Its effect would result in sales which totaled to $28.0 million in 1984. In addition, because Harnischfeger would go on to changed its method of depreciation to a more accelerated version, which would be a straight line method, their net income for 1984 went up by $11.0 million. Furthermore, the company went on to increase and change the depreciation life on US plant, and residual value on machinery, which in essence resulted their equipment increase in net income by $3.2 million in 1984. 2. What is the effect of the depreciation accounting method change on the reported income in 1984? How will this change affect profits in future years? The effect Harnischfeger experiences by using the depreciation accounting method change resulted an income increase by $11.0 million. Because of this method change, the company’s net income in 1984 summed up to $15.2 million. As a result of changed their accounting depreciation method, it will affect its profits in......

Words: 1790 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Accounting

...el informe anual de 1984 de la Harnischfeger Corporation (Anexo 4). Su atención fue atraída por los $ 1,28 por Harnischfeger beneficio por acción neta reportada para el año 1984. Sabía que apenas tres años antes la empresa había enfrentado a una grave crisis financiera. Harnischfeger había de pagar su deuda y se detuvo después del pago de dividendos reportando una pérdida neta de 7,64 dólares pesada por acción en el año fiscal 1982. Pobre desempeño de la compañía continuó en 1983, dando lugar a una pérdida neta de 3,49 dólares por acción. Roberts se sintió intrigado por tiempo de respuesta reducido Harnischfeger y se preguntó si se debería recomendar la compra de acciones de la empresa (ver Anexo 3 para los datos seleccionados en el stock de Harnischfeger). Empresa de Negocios y Productos Harnischfeger Corporation era una empresa de maquinaria con sede en Milwaukee, Wisconsin. La empresa había sido originalmente comenzó como una asociación en 1884 y fue incorporada en Wisconsin en 1910 bajo el nombre y Pawling Harnischfeger. Su nombre fue cambiado al actual en 1924. La compañía salió a bolsa en 1929 y comenzó a cotizar en el New York Stock Exchange. La compañía de dos segmentos principales fueron el Grupo P & H de equipo pesado, que consiste en la Construcción y las divisiones de equipos mineros y eléctricos, y el Grupo de Tecnologías Industriales, compuesto por el Equipo de Manejo de Materiales y las divisiones de Ingenieros Harnischfeger. La mezcla de ventas de la......

Words: 1737 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Harneschfeger Corporation Analysis

...Harnischfeger Corporation Harnischfeger Corporation was a machinery based company based in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. The company had initially started as a partnership; however, in 1910 it was incorporated in Wisconsin under the name of Pawling and Harnischfeger. The company finally went public in 1929 and was listed in the New York Stock Exchange under the new name Harnischfeger. The company had two major segments of business P&H Heavy Equipment Group, which consisted of the construction equipment, the mining, and electrical equipment division. The second division consisted of the Industrial Technologies Group, which involved material handling equipment and the Harnischfeger engineers division. The company experienced a period of financial growth during the 1970s. Harnischfeger was very profitable growing from $205 million in revenues in 1973 to $644 million in 1980. The company made a mistake by depending on debt financing and the firm’s debt to equity ratio rose from 0.88 in 1973 to 1.26 in 1980. The company was hurt financially because of the recession in the 1980s, demand in the company’s products dropped and in turn adversely affected sales and the high interest payments resulted in poor profit performance. Collectively, this culminated to a reported loss in 1982 of $77 million. Accounting policy changes and estimates that Harnischfeger made during 1984 and the effect of these on the company’s 1984 reported profits are further explained in the following......

Words: 985 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Harnischfeger

...1. Identify all the accounting policy changes and accounting estimates that Harnischfeger made during 1984. Estimate, as accurately as possible, the effect of these on the company’s 1984 reported profits. In early 1980s Harnischfeger Corporation, a machinery company based in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, faced a severe financial crisis. The company’s poor performance continued through 1983, however, the company reported net profit in 1984. This positive result was a consequence of a number of changes that have been made in, first of all, management, and, of course, accounting policies and estimates. * Depreciation method has been changed from accelerated to the straight-line. The cumulative effect of this change was increased 1984 net income by $11.0 million. * Estimated depreciation lives on certain U.S. plants have changed as well. This increased net income for 1984 by $3.2 million. * Liquidation of LIFO inventory quantities increased net income by $2.4 million in 1984. * Restructure of Retirement Plan brought $39.9 million actuarial gain to the company. Also, rate of return assumption for determining pension expense has changed from 7.5% in 1982 and 8% in 1983 to 9% in 1984 and together with restructuring of pension plan reduced pension expense by approximately $4.0 million in 1984 and $2.0 million in 1983, and the actuarial present value of accumulated plan benefits by approximately $60.0 million in 1984. * Allowance for doubtful accounts receivables......

Words: 881 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Find a Economics School by Name

...Accounting policy changes: Kobe steels impact on the accounting changes: -Owned 8.4% of the Corporations outstanding common stocks. -Owns 25% of the capital stock of Harnishfeger of Australia Pty. (the owner ship appers as the minority interest in the balance sheet.) -Net fee income received from Kobe was 4.3min in 84, an increase of 1.2 mill from previous year. -ten year agreement with Kobe supplying the corporation requirement for construction cranes for sale in US. -Join R&D program for construction equipment over 3 years -Sales to kobe 5.2mill in 84 and 10.5mill in 83 -Purchases from Kobe 33.7 mill in 84 and 15.5mill in 83 - Corporation owns 19% of ASEA Industrial systems inc. -Purchases from AIS 11.2mill in 84 and 6.1 in 83 -Sales to AIS 2.6mill in 84 and 3.8 in 83 -Due to an Inventory reduction resulted in a liquidation of LIFO inventory. The effect of the liquidation increased the net income by 2.4million in 84. And reduced the net loss by approximately 15.6 million compared with only 6.7 mill in 83 There was a change in the recognition of some types of sales. This resulted in a change in sales calculation. Harnischfeger incorporated products purchased from Kobe Steel, which were re-sold by the company, into its net sales. This increased aggregate sales and cost of sales by $28 million. • There was a change in the fiscal year for some foreign subsidiaries. • There was a change in the depreciation methods on assets. The depreciation......

Words: 778 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Harnischfeger

...Week 3 case study: Harnischfeger Corporation 1. Identify all the accounting policy changes and accounting estimates that Harnischfeger made during 1984. Estimate, as accurately as possible, the effect of these on the company’s 1984 reported profits. * Harnischfeger retroactively changed its depreciation method from accelerated to straight-line for all depreciable assets. The cumulative effect of this accounting policy change, which not including the reduction in the current year’s depreciation expense, increased after-tax net income for 1984. * Harnischfeger changed its estimated depreciation lives on certain U.S. plants, machinery, and equipment and residual values on certain machinery and equipment. This change increased the net income for 1984 by $3.2 million. * Inventory reductions in 1984, 1983 and 1982 resulted in a liquidation of LIFO inventory quantities carried at lower costs compared with the current cost of their acquisitions. The effect was to increase net income by $2.4 million in 1984. * Effective November 1, 1983, the Corporation includes in its net sales products purchased from Kobe Steel, Ltd. And sold by the Corporation, to reflect more effectively the nature of the Corporation’s transactions with Kobe. Only the gross margin on Kobe-originated equipment was included in Harnischfeger’s financials. This change had the effect of increasing net sales by $5.4 million for the year ended October 31, 1984. * The company made agreement with...

Words: 674 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Harisnbherge

...Directions Read the “Harnischfeger Corp” case study and answer the following questions. Submit your completed assignment no later than the last day of Week 2. 1. Describe clearly the accounting changes Harnischfeger made in 1984 as stated in Note 2 of its financial statements. After reviewing the accounting policies of other corporations in similar industries, Harnischfeger decided to adjust their depreciation method. Instead of continuing to use the accelerated method for depreciating their US Operating Plans, Harnischfeger decided to use the straight-line method. The new method was applied to past periods which resulted in an overall increase of net income. However, looking soley at the current period, the adjustment did not have a significant imapact; it seems as if the majority of the depreciation with the accelerated method had already been expensed in previous periods. Regardless of whether or not the change was made, Note 2 is informing the public that the current year depreciation would have been in the same range. In addition to changing the depreciation method, the Corporation also updated the useful lives and residual value for some of their property, plant, and equipment. Some other changes the Corporation made were in regards to their sales with Kobe, and including the financial statements of some of their foreign subsidaries. The inclusion from the subsidaries did not have a significant impact in the current period. However, the adjustment with Kobe did......

Words: 1184 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Harnischfeger Inc.

...1. Identify all the accounting policy changes and the accounting estimates that Harnischfeger made during 1984. Estimate, as accurately as possible, the effect of these on the company’s 1984 reported profits. a. Changes that affect the Harnischfeger Revenues: • The company start to account Kobe Steel sales in US, previously it only add the gross margin in the financial statement. (this sales represents $28 millions) Following are the accounting policy changes and accounting estimates that Harnischfeger made during 1984 : • Starting November 1, 1983, products purchased from Kobe Steel, Ltd. and sold by the Corporation were included in its net sales., previously only the gross margin on Kobe-originated equipment was included in the financial statement. During fiscal year 1984 such sales aggregated $28 million. • Sales to a foreign subsidiary starts to be consolidated as a net revenues (this sales represents $5,4 millions) • Foreign consolidated subsidiaries are effectively included in the financial statement in fiscal year 1984. (This change increased the net sales by $5.4 million. (tax) ) b. Changes that affect the Harnischfeger profitability: • Change in the depreciation accounting method from accelerated to straight line method. Increase of $11 million in 1984 income • Change on the company’s net residual value. Increased net income in $ 3,4millions • Harnischfeger reduced its inventory level in 1984, 1983 and 1982, resulting in a liquidation of LIFO inventory.......

Words: 1118 - Pages: 5