Free Essay

Helen Nguyen

In: Business and Management

Submitted By Helenee
Words 1076
Pages 5
HOW MANAGERS’ BEHAVIOURS ARE AFFECTED BY BUDGETING
According to Hopwood (1974), there are three different styles of budgeting information that managers would get evaluated on. The first one is non-accounting, in which managers are not judged based on accounting figures but qualitative factors. The second one is profit style, which means that managers would focus on maximising profit and reducing cost in the long term.
Explain more about the Hopwood style:
1. Profit conscious style: focus on increasing profit and reducing cost in the long term.
The possible managers’ behaviours for this style are that managers would not be put under pressure, which would enable them to create a friendly working atmosphere between colleagues. Furthermore, they only focus on long term profit but not short term performance, therefore they would not have motivation to manipulate the accounting data.
2/ Non-accounting style: the performance is evaluated based mostly on qualitative factors such as consumer satisfaction, quality and timeliness.
As this style is similar to the profit conscious style (both emphasise the profit in long run), thus the managers’ behaviours is similar as well. The main difference is that managers would take the accounting information less seriously and pay more attention on the qualitative factors.
3/ Budget constrained style: managers are required to follow the pre-set budgets, which means that they are evaluated on short term performance.
Because of the pressure to reduce cost as much as possible within a short period of time, managers are often more stressful and so lead to causing employees not working well together. The focus on short-term profit also encourages managers to do anything to better their performance in that period without caring about the return in the long run.
In the DFS case, it is clearly that managers are subjected to budget constrained style, as they are forced to follow the pre-determined budget from Mr Abbas and Mr Jones in order to not get penalised. Therefore, it is expected that managers will be under hard pressure, which they would put on their direct employees instead. This consequently causes poor working environment and affects the relationship between colleagues. Furthermore, the focus on minimising cost in short term may make managers sacrifice long-term profit to achieve the current target. More importantly, it can lead to managers manipulating accounting figures in order to better their performance. (underlined: the possible negative behaviours of managers in budget constrained style)
Also in the case, Mr Abbas and Mr Jones have decided not to let managers participate in the budgeting process anymore but only the directors make the decisions. This would cause difficulties for managers since the directors may not understand all the costs involved in the operation. If the budget is set too low at the level that managers would not be able to follow it; then they would just agree to get penalised (Hofstede, 1968). Therefore, even though the Managing Directors want to minimise the budget, it still has to be over the lower limit. Furthermore, demanding budget is also considered to be more effective in motivating managers than less difficult one, so the upper limit is important as well. In brief, in order to encourage the managers comply with the budget, it has to be at the level which is not only too hard to give up but also sufficient to motivate managers.
MITIGATING DYSFUNCTIONAL BEHAVIOURS
As discussed above, when the budget is too tight, managers would commit in dysfunctional behaviours such as manipulating the cost figures to improve performance. Therefore, the most essential action is constructing a reasonable budget (a sufficient level of cost so that managers can keep up with and also find not easy). To do so, instead of using the top-down budget, managers can try another style. If they do not want to apply the participative budget due to the waste in preparing time and possible conflicts, the negotiated one, which is the mix between two styles, would be fine. (Top-down budget: the CEO would set the budget and force everyone to follow without excuses just like in the case; participative budgeting: managers in each department are required to prepare the budget on their own which would be checked and approved by CEO later)
Using this style, managers would be able to express whether they think the budget is appropriate and which sections should be adjusted. In addition, to make the budget more flexible, the directors could allow managers to exceed the budget within a limit if they have acceptable explanations, instead of penalising them immediately. Flexibility is important because in the operating process, there would be some unexpected problems which require managers to have immediate actions. If those actions are constrained by the budget, managers may not try their best to save the situation and would result in losses for the companies.
Furthermore, the interaction between departments is essential as well. In the case that the budget is set strictly, managers tend to not care about the other departments’ activities but focus only on reducing their own costs. Thus, it may cause difficulties for other departments. (Example: inventory department purchase low-quality stock to save cost, which cause problems in customer satisfaction so the sale department needs to promote more on the products). In brief, the management has to identify the main cause of exceeding budgeting to have a reasonable award system for each departmental manager to ensure that it will not cause unequality to any of them.
ZERO-BASED BUDGETING
Zero-based budgeting is a technique in which all the costs and revenues suggested in the budget would be reviewed and approved by top management. Therefore, the budget has to be constructed carefully and in complete details. Based on the description, it can be seen that zero-based budgeting is more concise and effective in allocating resources in order to improve operations. Furthermore, it also identifies chances to remove or change any ineffective departments to reduce costs. However, as it bases on zero previous details, both the preparing and checking process will take long time and lots of effort to finish, therefore, it may cause the costs to finish the budget much higher. Additionally, in case that the budget is too complicated, managers to resize it into more simple file which could eliminate important sections. Finally, zero-based budgeting is relatively hard to understand; consequently managers need to be trained to successfully implement it into practice. (yellow: advantages; green: disadvantages)

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Sooyoung

...Getting to Know Helen of Troy Helen, who considered being the face that launched a thousand ships, is from Lacedaemon or Sparta in Greece. She is the daughter of Leda and Zeus, the King of Gods. She has four siblings namely, Clymnestra, Tymandra, Castor and Pollux. When Helen was old enough to marry, Tyndareus was besieged with offers from men of wealth and influence. Many men pursued Helen until Agamemnon wooed Helen for his brother Menelaus who was finally chosen to be her husband. The Greeks are plotting to invade Troy to steal the treasures of the Trojans. Meanwhile Prince Paris is assigned by his wise father King Priam and the King of Troy to travel to Sparta and shows the peaceful intentions of his people. Along his journey, he falls into the sea during a storm and is rescued on the shore by the Queen of Sparta, Helen. When he recovers, he believes that she is a slave and they fall in love with each other. When he arrives at the Spartan Palace, he is arrested by King Menelaus but Helen helps him to escape. Helen is in love with Paris, but it happened that she is already married to King Menelaus. With the help of Aphrodite, Paris abducted Helen. They travel together to Troy and give the excuse that the Greeks need to start a war and put Troy under seige for years. The Greeks are unsuccessful in their intents until they listened to the cunning Ulysses. The Greeks then with draw their one thousand ships from the Trojan waters and offer a wooden Horse of Troy...

Words: 439 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Agamemnon

...É P E N DA N T E S Summary of Agamemnon Summary of Agamemnon THE AGAMEMNON OF AESCHYLUS First part of “The Serpent Son” Prologue: The Watchman on the roof of the Palace of Agamemnon at Mycenae presents the facts. He has been watching a year for the fire signal that will announce Troy’s capture, and all is not well within the house. He sees the beacon at last and will tell Clytemnestra, Agamemnon’s wife. He rejoices at the news for it means his master will be coming home. Parodos or Entry of the Choros, who are Elders of Argos, counsellors to the Queen Regent. They chant about the expedition against Troy. The sons of Atreus (Agamemnon and Menelaus) are seen as birds whose nest has been robbed by the stealing of Helen. Par is who stole her thereby offended against Zeus, the God of the host and guest. With legal images the old men say that Paris will be punished. They themselves were too old to go to war ten years ago; like the old man in the Sphynx’s riddle they lean on staffs. Clytemnestra enters with slaves to make sacrifice at the altars; the choros ask her why sacrifices are being made but she ignores them and does not answer. The choros continue with the first Ode, a song about Aulis and what happened there, The omen of the pregnant hare attacked by the eagles: Calchas the prophet interpreted it to mean that Troy would fall but that the goddess Artemis will try to prevent the destruction of Troy. The sons of Atreus, he said, must not annoy...

Words: 2351 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Troy

...evidences which show the reality of Trojan War and that did it really happen or not? It also concerns with efforts and campaigns which were performed in order to find out the existence of Troy and reality of this city. Keywords: Trojan War, Troy, Greece, Legendary, Epic, Homer, Iliad, Archeologist, Turkey, Dig, Excavation, Discover Introduction The Trojan War is one of the most legendary stories of the history. It was said that the cause of the war was when Trojan Prince named Paris went to Greece and kidnapped the beautiful Greek princess Helen. It is believed that the sea trading Mycenae was a cause of the war. But Greek tradition reveals that the romantic cause-kidnapping of the princess- is believed as the cause of the war. Generally, the legend tells us that Prince Paris Alexander of Troy took Queen Helen of Sparta away and brought her back with him to Troy. So the Greeks sailed to Troy in order to rescue the princess Helen. Under their leader Agamemnon, the Greeks attacked Troy for nine years. Because of the massive wall surrounding the city all the fighting took place outside of Troy which totally prevented the Greeks from entering and getting the control of the city. This was a big disadvantage for the Greeks. The legend introduces great heroes from both sides. Each side had a strong belief in Gods and Goddesses and believed they aided them in the war. For the Greeks, the gods were Hera, Poseidon, and Athena who aided them. For the...

Words: 1769 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Pride in the Iliad

...Achilles throughout the story. The entire epic of The Iliad occurs in the middle of a ten-year conflict in the city of Troy between the Trojans and Achaeans. As is the case with most wars, the cause of the Trojan War is arguably quite pointless because it stems from nothing more than wounded egos. The clash of the egos begins when Paris “launches the war” (Homer 14. 33) when he offends Athena and Hera by choosing Aphrodite in a beauty contest between the goddesses. The two who lose the contest feel dishonored, and as a result they take the side of the Achaeans in the war, which causes the Trojans to have a huge disadvantage on the battlefield. Paris continues on his path to starting the war when he insults King Menelaus by charming his wife, Helen, and taking her back with him to Troy. Menelaus, who is offended by his wife running...

Words: 1313 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Jsjs

...WHAT WAS THE TROJNA WAR? In the middle of the 13th century a. C., Troy, flourishing city of Asia Minor, in present Turkey, was ravaged by a coalition of people from Greece. The Trojan War is a fundamental mythical episode that confronted for the first time to Europe and Asia. For the Greeks, it meant the first time aware of its unity as a people, despite their political disintegration. The Trojan war lasted nearly 10 years. It says in the first chapter of the Iliad that the war was already 9 years old and that many of the ships had problems from rotten ropes and wood and the like.  The war starts because Paris, a Trojan prince, "steals" Helen (they feel in love) and whisks her back to Troy. Her husband is a real tough character and is the King of Sparta. Worse yet, his brother is even tougher character and is the King of Mycenae (the richest city) and also the head of all the Greek city states when it came to matters of war. Agamemnon (the brother) and Menelaus convince and bully all the Greek city states into joining with them for the war. A thousand ships are sent.  Despite the extreme force, the Trojans are doing very well at holding the Greeks off. Hector, another Trojan prince, is very good at war. The walls are huge and strong. All the Greeks manage to do in 9 long years is to rape and pillage nearby small towns. Troy still stands.  The Iliad starts with an argument between Agamemnon (top guy) and Achilles (best fighter) and ends, 24 days later, with Achilles killing...

Words: 647 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

How Did Odysseus Build The Trojan Horse

...Trojan Horse The ancient Greeks where in the beginning of a war. Awakening to the lovely Helen being gone king Menelaus was blowing up with fury. She was kidnapped by Paris the prince of Troy. Menelaus furiously declared to get Helen! Then because he asked kings for help they answered and sailed to the treacherous Troy. They got to the city but there was a wall, so they couldn’t get in. So the Greeks who were angry sat on the beach and plotted. Thinking precisely, they knew Helen was behind the enemy wall. Unfortunately they tried for ten miserable years, but failed anyway. Odysseus thought of an idea. First he instructed them to build a fence around them to hide their work. His brilliant idea was to construct a wooden horse, which was...

Words: 261 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Why Is Helen Won In The Iliad

...A Prize To Be Won One of the most ridiculous, expensive and disgusting wars is started over a woman and to whom her body belongs to. In the Iliad, Helen of Argos is the prize to be won. Helen’s appearance causes her to involuntarily be objectified, sexualized and made into a political issue to the point of the Trojan War breaking out. We’re talking about the Trojan War. The society is more responsible for the outbreak of the Trojan War than Helen is for having natural beauty. Although Helen is beautiful, there should not be consequences for having such beauty as it is not something she can help but been created with. An example of how she is viewed through Homer’s words is as follows, “Helen moved like daylight to the vaulted bedroom,”...

Words: 611 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Achilles

...and Menelaus prepare for the battle, the two armed men whose dispute over Helen is the cause of the entire war. Whoever wins the battle stays with Helen. Between Menelaus and Paris, Menelaus attempt to strike the first bow. According to line 413, 414 it shows that Menelaus gets the upper hand. Menelaus wins the battle, but Paris exits the battlefield to find Helen. The book states that Aphrodite was quick to the mark. She takes Paris out the battle and puts him in his room at home with his wife. She tells Helen that Paris is asking for her. As Helen enters the bedroom, she sees Paris. She sees the beauty in him. He doesn’t look like a man who just came from war but rather a gentleman. Her heart begins to race. And she questions what is to come of them now. She asked Paris if he’s come to make her fall for him again; if she’s going to be going through this again. Helen is mad at Aphrodite for taking Paris out of the war with Menelaus and wanting her to sleep with him. Helen announces that she will have nothing to do with Paris, but when Aphrodite confronts her she became threated by it. She believes that her going back to Paris and serve him in bed would be shameful. Helen would like to choose the honorable warrior Menelaos. She then got into an argument with Aphrodite. Helen asks Aphrodite why doesn’t she just marry Paris herself and live a miserable life with him. Aphrodite advises Helen not to provoke her and that she might lose her temper and hate her just as...

Words: 400 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Paper on Agamemnon

...Agamemnon Agamemnon is a confusing tale of the people that are waiting for the soldiers to get home from the Trojan war. Most of the play is the chorus singing about many of the things that happened during the war. The play also shows the disrespect the men had for women in that time period. In front of Agamemnon's palace, a watchman wishes his shift would end. He is tired and wants to sleep but he must stay awake. He awaits news from Queen Clytemnestra. The Chorus of Argive elders enters, singing of the war. They sing of the gods, asking for them to help them win the war, and of the great army. They anxiously await the news from the Queen. In the song, they tell how Agamemnon killed his child. He sacrificed his daughter to Apollo so that Apollo would make the winds blow for his armies ships. The chorus thinks that deed was horrible, but had to be done for the good of the country. The leader asks Clytemnestra if she's heard any news. He doesn't like being ruled by a woman and treats her somewhat rudely. He only listens to her because of his loyalty to his King. She tells the leader that the army has taken Troy. The leader is skeptical and asks her to repeat herself several times. The Queen gets angry and tells him she is not a "credulous girl." When the leader asks how Clytemnestra found out the city was taken so quickly, she tells him that one God delivered the message to another and so on. He yet again asks her, which...

Words: 556 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Module 10 Discussion

...are The Illiad written by Homer, The Odyssey written by Homer, and Oedipus Rex written by Sophocles. How they are relevant to today is; The Illiad makes it relevant to today by in life love can make you do some strange things, The Odyssey make it relevant to today by in life no matter what you go through an how long you go through it if you have a goal in life and all those objects and hurdles come around in life don’t let that stop you from getting to your goal that you want to achieve for yourself, and Oedipus Rex makes it relevant to today by in life your fears my come a reality that you can’t shy away from it cause it can make you or break you. In the story of The illiad Paris, a son of the king of Troy, kidnaps Helen, who becomes the legendary "Helen of Troy" and "the woman with the face that launched a thousand ships." He takes her because he fell in love with her and because of that he cause a war for the empire of troy and cause the destruction of try as well. That goes to show that love can and will make you do the most a strangest things and also will make you not think or consider the outcome of bad decisions that you make. In the story of the Odyssey, Odysseus has been gone from Ithaca for about 20 years — the first 10 spent fighting the Trojan War, the last 10 trying to get home. Odysseus is a king who fought in the Trojan War; but before he left he promised his wife that if he don’t return before his son grows a beard then she was to find suitors to take...

Words: 869 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Agamemes

...First part of “The Serpent Son” Prologue: The Watchman on the roof of the Palace of Agamemnon at Mycenae presents the facts. He has been watching a year for the fire signal that will announce Troy’s capture, and all is not well within the house. He sees the beacon at last and will tell Clytemnestra, Agamemnon’s wife. He rejoices at the news for it means his master will be coming home. Parodos or Entry of the Choros, who are Elders of Argos, counsellors to the Queen Regent. They chant about the expedition against Troy. The sons of Atreus (Agamemnon and Menelaus) are seen as birds whose nest has been robbed by the stealing of Helen. Par is who stole her thereby offended against Zeus, the God of the host and guest. With legal images the old men say that Paris will be punished. They themselves were too old to go to war ten years ago; like the old man in the Sphynx’s riddle they lean on staffs. Clytemnestra enters with slaves to make sacrifice at the altars; the choros ask her why sacrifices are being made but she ignores them and does not answer. The choros continue with the first Ode, a song about Aulis and what happened there, The omen of the pregnant hare attacked by the eagles: Calchas the prophet interpreted it to mean that Troy would fall but that the goddess Artemis will try to prevent the destruction of Troy. The sons of Atreus, he said, must not annoy the gods. There will be ominous sacrifice; the refrain to this Ode is “Sing sorrow, sorrow, but...

Words: 2103 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Agamemnon In Greek Mythology

...In the Greek legend, he was the king of Mycenae or Argos. When Paris (Alexandros), son of King Priam of Troy, carried off Helen, Agamemnon called on the princes of the country to unite in a war of revenge against the Trojans. 2, Alcinous- (al-KIN-oh-us) He was he King of Phaeacians, he was a happy ruler on the island of Scheria. He had five sons but only one daughter. 3, Amphinomus- (am-fin-o-muss) He was the son of King Nisos. He was to be considered as the best-behaved suitor. Amphinomus was killed by a speare. 4, Antinous- (an-TIN-oh-us) He was the son of Eupeithes, and he was an important suitor. He attempted to kill Telemachus but he fails. 5, Arete- (air-e-tea) She was queen of the Phaeacians, married...

Words: 910 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Agamemnon Summary

...Overall Summary Agamemnon begins with a Watchman on duty on the roof of the palace at Argos, waiting for a signal announcing the fall of Troy to the Greek armies. A beacon flashes, and he joyfully runs to tell the news to Queen Clytemnestra. When he is gone, the Chorus, made up of the old men of Argos, enters and tells the story of how the Trojan Prince Paris stole Helen, the wife of the Greek king Menelaus, leading to ten years of war between Greece and Troy. Then the Chorus recalls how Clytemnestra's husband Agamemnon (Menelaus' brother) sacrificed their daughter Iphigenia to the god Artemis to obtain a favorable wind for the Greek fleet. The Queen appears, and the Chorus asks her why she has ordered sacrifices of thanksgiving. She tells them that a system of beacons has brought word that Troy fell the previous night. The Chorus give thanks to the gods, but wonder if her news is true; a Herald appears and confirms the tidings, describing the army's sufferings at Troy and giving thanks for a safe homecoming. Clytemnestra sends him back to Agamemnon, to tell her husband to come swiftly, but before he departs, the Chorus asks him for news of Menelaus. The Herald replies that a terrible storm seized the Greek fleet on the way home, leaving Menelaus and many others missing. The Chorus sings of the terrible destructive power of Helen's beauty. Agamemnon enters, riding in his chariot with Cassandra, a Trojan Princess whom he has taken as his slave and concubine. Clytemnestra welcomes...

Words: 489 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

The Fate of Gods

...The Fate of the Gods Iliad considered as a masterpiece at all levels, Homer combines literally devices in his books to create a vivid image for the reader there by evoking the readers’ emotions. Homer set the scene by giving vivid details of every important warlord and the gods in the battle. Homer includes the role the warlords and the gods play in the battlefield at every stage. Not only does Homer characterize individual roles in Iliad, but also symbolizes the individual’s achievement in the battle by. Gives the details roles the gods play in the battle, which keeps the reader focus on the central conflict. In Iliad, most of the scene depends on the individual’s character decision including the gods. From book 11, it can be seen as Zeus, the head of the gods controls the progress of the battle by first raining blood on the Achaeans causing them to panic. In retrospect, Zeus sends Iris to deliver a message “Hector, son of Priam, Father Zeus Has sent me here with a message for you. As long as you see Lord Agamemnon storming to through the ranks and laying them low you should hold back and order other troops to engage the enemy” (p204, 220) , one of the Homer inclusion indicating the war inspired by the gods. The relationship of fate and human keeps the reader focus and in suspense as the wall of the Greeks is doomed to fall by Poseidon and Apollo. The fall of the war justifies Homer uses of prophecy to progress the plot of the poem personifying the involvement of the...

Words: 395 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Iliad

...Emmett Oh Lyke 4:00 ESSAY 1 FATE IN THE ILIAD Fate is unavoidable, regardless of the effort one puts into changing or avoiding it. Fate in Homer’s ILIAD is depicted as a one way freeway with no exit ramps. No matter what the characters do, once they set foot on their path there is no going back. Dr. Harvey has brought forward the idea in lecture that any speech, simile, or any other small part in the epic can be a microcosm to a greater theme in the text. One of the greater themes that continued to appear throughout the text was fate’s inevitability superseded all other forces in the ILIAD. Fate is the most powerful force in the ILIAD because it shapes the events and decisions that occur throughout the epic. Fate shapes events and decisions by overpowering the will of gods and great warriors, as well as overwhelming characters to the point where they concede to their own fate. Fate`s power is also preserved by the very characters it acts upon. Throughout the Epic, the gods seem to be unable to change fate. For example, the gods are unable to save Hector and Achilles, despite loving them both, as fate has to run it`s course. The Homeric simile described below is a microcosm to these examples. In Book 11 of Homer’s epic, the Acheans are able to drive Trojan forces into a retreat caused by a strong charge put on by Agamemnon. During the Trojan retreat, Agamemnon knocks Isus and Antiphus off their fleeting chariot, killing them, and stripping them of their armor...

Words: 1457 - Pages: 6