Free Essay

History and Memory Essay

In: English and Literature

Submitted By XOXOTashK
Words 1051
Pages 5
Explore how the fiftieth gate and one other related text of your own choosing represent history and memory in unique and evocative ways.
The interplay of history and memory combine to provide greater insight into events.
Through the manipulation of textual forms and features, Mark Bakerʼs hybrid text “The
Fiftieth Gate” expands and humanizes oneʼs understanding of the Holocaust in unique and evocative ways. A unique feature of the text is clever fusion between personal accounts and documented history using mediums such as, interviews, official documents, poetry and song. This enhances the stories of the authorʼs parents, Yossl and Genia, whilst evocatively capturing the atrocities of the Holocaust. The relationship between history and memory is further explored in Kevin Ruddʼs “Sorry apology to Stolen Generations”.
Bakerʼs “The Fiftieth Gate” suggests that memory humanises historical events, juxtaposed by the emotionless discourse of history in unique and evocative ways. Baker provides insight into the historical events associated with the Holocaust,emphasising number of deaths that occurred during the genocide. In Gate 26, Baker explores the deaths Geniaʼs parents witnessed in the lines, “Among 1380 people, one family survived by chance. They were Leo Krochmal and his wife Rosa who witnessed the shooting,” The impersonal tone and simple language in the lines underscores the straightforward and detached nature of history. In contrast, the recount of Genia hiding from Germans in Gate 6 is markedly more confrontative, “we could hear the footsteps, the shots, the screams”. The alliteration of
“shots” and “screams” accentuates Geniaʼs fear and trepidation. The sensory imagery positions the reader as Genia, struggling to survive, humanizing the atrocities of the
Holocaust. The inclusion of song, particularly a confessional prayer forcibly recited by
Jews highlights members of the Nazi regime as an oppressive force, evidenced in the lines, “For centuries weʼve cheated the people.../We heave but tricked and lied and cheated/ With either dollars of with German marks.” The use of words with negative connotations such as “cheat” conveys the profound impact the Holocaust had on its survivors and victims. It evokes the powerful image of Jews forced to sacrifice their identity for the amusement of the Hitler Youth. Thus, memory humanises historical events, evidenced in “The Fiftieth Gate” in unique and evocative ways.

In unique and evocative fashion, “The Fiftieth Gate” questions whether memories validate history. Throughout the novel, Baker actively pursues his quest to validate his parentʼs

memories. With marked success, he find historical documents that verify his fatherʼs stories. In Gate 14, “the Judenrat reports in its census of the town completed on my fatherʼs thirteenth birthday, there are 3569 Jews resident in the areas of StarachowiceWierzbnik” proves that his father spent his childhood in Wierzbnik prior to being sent to concentration camps. However, Baker has limited success with his mother. In Gate 24,
Baker questions the importance of using history to validate memory, identified in the lines,
“Wonʼt she recognise the shameful truth that I doubted her.. that I only recognise suffering in numbers and lists and not in the laments and pleas of a human being, on a mother, screaming for acknowledgment?” The use of rhetorical question indicates that Mark Baker realises the power of history to recognise the experiences of an individual. The reflective tone augments a feeling of disillusionment about the realities of history and memory.
Further, the non-linear sequence of events replicates the dispersed nature of history and memory. The novel is structured in fifty gates, with each gate representing the journey to towards unlocking the past using history and memory. Therefore, the unique and evocative use of documented evidence and personal accounts questions whether memories validate history. Similarly, “The Fiftieth gate” frequently mediates between history and memory as a means of reaching the truth in unique and evocative ways. The clash between history and memory demonstrates that the past is not straightforward and conclusively established.
Baker employs repetition to reiterate the power of history to illuminate memory and shed light upon it, identified in lines,
“It always begins in blackness, until the first light illuminates a hidden fragment of memory”
The strategic placing of the phrase at the beginning and end of the book mimics the cyclical nature of memory. The binary opposition of “light” and “darkness” stress the symbolic representation of history as a light in the darkness. The inconsistency of history and memory is prevalent through the conflicting sources in Gate 22 regarding Yosslʼs age.
The variation in birthdate, evidenced in the lines, “ ʻBorn in 1929ʼ he tells the doctor at
Auschwitz...ʼ Born in 1926ʼ....ʻBorn in 1928ʼ he tells the American military-officer....ʻBorn in
1929ʼ..which grants him a childʼs visa to Switzerland.” The recurring use of documented evidence humanises the measures taken by Yossl to survive the Holocaust. In addition, this highlights the unreliability of history and the importance of memory to find the truth.
Hence, the mediation between history and memory in depicted in “The Fiftieth Gate” in unique and evocative ways.

The link between history and memory is further represented in unique and evocative ways in Kevin Ruddʼs speech “Sorry apology to Stolen Generations”. The “Sorry apology to
Stolen Generations” marks a milestone in Australian history by acknowledging the injustices suffered by Indigenous Australians. Both, “Sorry Apology to Stolen Generations” and “The Fiftieth Gate” explore the concept of injustice suffered by a racial/religious group.
Whilst Baker uses documented evidence personal accounts to depict the past suffering of
Holocaust survivors, Rudd explores the past injustices and conjures hope for the future.
History and memory intersect when Rudd recounts the story of Nanna Fejo, “...she remembers the coming of the welfare men. Her family had feared that day and had dug holes in the creek bank where the children could run and hide.” Rudd uses rhetorical devices such as anecdotes to personalise the history behind the Stolen generations.
Therefore, Ruddʼs “Sorry apology to Stolen Generations” explores history and memory in a unique and evocative manner.
Overall, the inextricably link between history and memory is thoroughly explored in “The
Fiftieth Gate” in unique and evocative ways. This is achieved using the combination of documented evidence and personal accounts, illuminating the stories of Bakerʼs parents and capturing the atrocities of the Holocaust. History and memory is further represented in
Kevin Ruddʼs speech “Sorry apology to Stolen Generations”.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Reaction Paper

...I really enjoyed reading the essay by Kim Zorn Caputo. As I began reading the essay, I immediately imagined myself in her place. I then thought of my own memories of going to community pool entered my mind. When Kim spoke about artists yearning for the past, I interpreted this as her speaking of artists (including herself) wanting to rewrite their own history through their art and wanting to go back to yesteryears. When creating art, you can create any feeling or illustration you wish. When she talks about Thamyris and her feeling of great loss, I imagine her speaking of being punished for longing. She speaks about longing and wanting something so badly and being punished by not being able to have them. I really liked what she said about the drive to remember and that the creation of art is driven by memory. This is true, I suppose because without memory, how would you create art. In photography, I think this applies really well because your photographs are your memory, they are your creation. I love being creative and expressing myself through art, so what she wrote really spoke to me. I sometimes find myself with the desire to create art and find deep meaning in life and I felt this feeling being explained in her essay. She talked about the many years of ancient voices, sacred texts, laboratory rats, Capitol Hill, and CNN and I believe this shows her passion for history and for finding purpose. Every generation learns more and discovers more and passes this on,......

Words: 744 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Barrio Boy

...Alexandra Ortiz English 120 Professor DiFranco Essay #2 Sacramento Both Ernesto Galarza’s “Barrio Boy” and Joan Didion’s “Notes From a Native Daughter” write about Sacramento’s past. Both authors talk about Sacramento during two different time periods. Joan Didion talks about the mid-century and Ernesto Galarza talks about the early 20th century. Although both author’s perspective of Sacramento differs from era to era, there are differences in certain characteristics described by both authors. Galarza’s essay focuses on an immigrant point of view arriving into Sacramento versus Didion’s experiences as a native decedent of Sacramento. Joan Didion’s Sacramento is a very different place compared to Ernesto Galarza’s , for him it’s an immigrant place where Mexican, Yugoslavs, Chinese and many other different cultures come together to make one home. For Joan Didion, Sacramento is a place that with the pas of time and the changes that has come with time, have forced memories to be lost and most importantly identities. Didion highlights the true nature of Californian lifestyle and how with its gradual disappearance more than the past is being lost, but a new generation is also losing an understanding of its true roots, its true history and as a result a loss of knowledge. The loss of knowledge is equivalent to the loss of identity because if one doesn’t know where they came from how one can truly know who they are. Didion talks about her own experiences as a child in......

Words: 1435 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay


...History, Memory, and Monuments: An Overview of the Scholarly Literature on Commemoration   Kirk Savage, University of Pittsburgh   (…) The first key question might be, what is commemoration? Dictionary definitions tell us that to commemorate is to “call to remembrance,” to mark an event or a person or a group by a ceremony or an observance or a monument of some kind. Commemorations might be ephemeral or permanent; the key point is that they prod collective memory in some conspicuous way. French sociologist Maurice Halbwachs ushered in the modern academic study of collective memory with his book The Social Frameworks of Memory (1925) in which he argued that all memory – even personal memory – is a social process, shaped by the various groups (family, religious, geographical, etc.) to which individuals belong. In an even more influential posthumous essay, “Historical Memory and Collective Memory” (1950), published after his death in a Nazi concentration camp, Halbwachs insisted on a distinction between history and collective memory: history aims for a universal, objective truth severed from the psychology of social groups while “every collective memory requires the support of a group delimited in space and time.” Thus our view of the past does not come primarily from professional historical scholarship but from a much more complicated and interwoven set of relationships to mass media, tourist sites, family tradition, and the spaces of our upbringing with all their......

Words: 844 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Computer Technology

...Final Project: Expository Essay Samantha A. Medina University of Phoenix Final Project: Expository Essay Computer technology has developed tremendously over the decades and centuries to become so modern in every aspect including education and personal leisure. It is breath taking to see how modernized out computer technology is today as opposed to the limited computer technology that was available in history. The changes that have occurred over history to today will be discussed and focused upon in this essay. The Mechanical Era: Early Computing Devices The Abacus The abacus was the first machine to be used computational science. It is considered to be the first computer. This machine was inspired by one of Charles Babbage’s designs. The abacus could process 15 digit numbers and calculate fourth-order differences. In 1885 the machine won gold medal at an exhibition in Paris and also helped calculate the orbit of mars! The abacus is still in use today. Imagine that a computing device from centuries ago still being used to this day! Charles Babbage Charles Babbage was an English mathematician, philosopher, inventor and mechanical engineer ("Charles Babbage", 2012). Babbage is known to have invented the first programmable computer. As stated earlier his design inspired the abacus and other complex designs. He won the Gold Medal of the Royal Astronomical Society for inventing an engine for calculating mathematical and astronomical tables. Babbage was also Lucasian......

Words: 1624 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Cognitive Psychology Definition Paper

...information, think, rationale, and respond. There are sub domains of cognitive psychology which are insight, attention, knowledge, memory, idea formation, way of thinking, judgment, choice making, predicament solving, and language dispensation. Perception is how we understand things around us. Attention is how we decide what is significant to us when offered with numerous things. Learning helps to enhance the response that we have to our surroundings. Memory is the capability at which we obtain things. Concept configuration is the ability to systematize our many diverse perceptions. Conclusion, decisions, reasoning, and predicament solving are how we shape the choices that we create and how we believe about the choices that we create. Language insight is how we understand the things we say and hear (Scholarepedia, 2011). Perception is one of the main landmarks of cognitive psychology. Perception is how people deliberately distinguish objects. From a visual point of view insight would include recognizing the form of an object, dimension, and distance away from the person. Perception is how a person gains access to information about the adjacent environment right away (Willingham, 2007). George Berkeley discussed insight as being a fraction of the empiricist versus nativist dispute. Berkeley happened to be an intense empiricist. He written an essay titled, An Essay towards a New Theory of Vision, he attempted to demonstrate that even essential perceptual experience is......

Words: 999 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Developmental Psychology

...In order to fully understand human development, this essay will discuss the importance of the lifespan perspective. Many researches believe that the lifespan orientation consists of several classic beliefs that form a family of perspectives that gives a cohesive view on the nature of development. While each of these seven perspectives are essential to lifespan development and emphasize a different aspect of development, this essay will focus on the two aspects of plasticity and contextualism as a paradigm. It will also illustrate how they give evidence supporting development as a life long process. Lifespan development can be defined as “the field of study that examines patterns of growth, change, and stability in behaviour that occur throughout the entire life span” (Sigelman & Rider, 2011). Lifespan development takes a scientific approach in its study of growth, change and stability as researchers use scientific methods to test their assumptions (Sigelman & Rider, 2011s). Previously child development was the focus of many theorists but within the last two decades lifespan development has begun to be studied empirically. Another justification for lifespan development is that it originates in other disciplines as well such as sociology and anthropology and this suggests that this field of lifespan development did not originate solely from developmental psychologists (Baltes, 1987). There are three relevant areas in lifespan development: physical development which looks at...

Words: 1643 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

History of Psychology

...History of Psychology Danielle Shank PSY/310 February 18, 2013 Kelle Daniels History of Psychology To understand psychology today, one must understand the past of psychology. Rene’ Descartes believes a person’s mind to have an ability to reason and the body to be a machine. However, John Locke believed a person’s mind to be a clean slate and it is filled from experiences. These are two amazing theories about the mind and body. However, if all of the theories were to be discussed this would not be an essay; this would be a book series. Psychology dates back to the 1900’s but the true history goes back to the Greek philosophers or even farther to the 17th century B.C. with Psamtik 1 (King of Egypt). He believed the Egyptians were the oldest race and was curious about how. The foundation of psychology starts with philosophy and medicine than later becomes its own category of psychology. Psychology gets broken down into smaller parts. This paper will go over different philosophers of the past that brought the start of psychology and then a man who was in the 19th century of psychology. Philosophers That Began Psychology Hermann Ebbinghaus states in his textbook called “Psychology An Elementary textbook”, “Psychology has a long past, yet its real history is very short” (Ebbinghaus, 1908, p. 3). When this statement is......

Words: 1165 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Remembering and Commemorating the War Essay

...Remembering and Commemorating the War Essay According to Blight, Fredrick Douglas fought hard to protect the memory of the war. What was Douglas’s memory of the war and why did he try to protect it? North vs. South, Confederates vs. The Union. Rifles were fired… brother vs. brother. Men were named heroes for seemingly valiant acts in battle. We learn many things from the past. A nation was literally ripped in half in what was called the bloodiest conflict in American History. History is not an obsolete thing. Rather, it teachers valuable lessons. It can’t be denied how tragic the Civil War really was in American History. “It is not well to forget the past. Memory was given to man for some wise purpose. The past is the mirror in which we discern the dim outlines of the future and by which we may make them”(97). Prominent American Figure Fredrick Douglas was born a slave, educated, freed himself then became an accomplished author that fought for equality for blacks and many other groups in America. In the text Beyond the Battlefield: Race, Memory, and the American Civil War, author David W. Blight describes Douglas’s memory of the Civil War as something beyond the battlefield. Fredrick Douglas recognized the heroism and the death that happened on the battlefield. However there was much more than the combat and battle happenings that Douglas remembered. Douglas remembered what it was to be a slave; this very insight was the key to his memory of the Emancipation......

Words: 1526 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Ahiska & Altinay

...The similarities and narratives being told in both Ahiska’s piece and Altinay’s piece correlate in theory and discourse. The resemblances between the two narratives are striking and complimentary of one another even though the focus of both articles are different, yet they share characteristics of remembrance, counter-memory symbolism, state and power structures. In this essay I will demonstrate the relationship in narrative and substance, which both authors are discussing. Aysi Gul Altinay is focused on the Armenian Genocide of 1915 by the hands of their Turkish rulers and the following historical counter-memory provided by Turkish nationalist historiography, specifically on the implications on the ‘un-silencing’ of the ‘Armenian question.’ Turkish nationalist history has largely accepted the silence on the events of 1915 as the historical norm, not to be questioned. In a way it is worse that this discussion, which has only surfaced recently in mainstream Turkish society, is not one of responsibility for the massacre of an estimated 2 million Armenians but rather one of the very existence of these atrocities. What few pieces of archived information that exist from 1915-1920 do not give specifics on the fate of so many Armenian women and children but do point to the survival of large numbers of women and children through Islamization. Ataturk’s own biographer gave reason and definition to the reason behind the organized historical silence of all things Armenian genocide by...

Words: 875 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The Effect of Sleep Deprivation in Flowers

...need to view an essay Again, I’m soooo sorry for this. Please do not take it to heart I have an essay due in today and I have not started yet please let me see some so i can get help omg iosnfanafiofjaedad *collapses* Sleep deprivation can adversely affect the brain and cognitive function.[21] A 2000 study, by the UCSD School of Medicine and the Veterans Affairs Healthcare System in San Diego, used functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) technology to monitor activity in the brains of sleep-deprived subjects performing simple verbal learning tasks.[22] The study showed that regions of the brain's prefrontal cortex, an area that supports mental faculties such as working memory and logical and practical ("means-ends") reasoning, displayed more activity in sleepier subjects. Researchers interpreted this result as indicating that the brain of the average sleep-deprived subject had to work harder than that of the average non-sleep-deprived subject to accomplish a given task, and from this indication they inferred the conclusion the brains of sleep-deprived subjects were attempting to compensate for adverse effects caused by sleep deprivation. The temporal lobe, which is a brain region involved in language processing, was activated during verbal learning in rested subjects but not in sleep-deprived subjects. The parietal lobe, not activated in rested subjects during the verbal exercise, was more active when the subjects were deprived of sleep. Although memory performance......

Words: 770 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Divorced, Beheaded, Survived

...Robin Black Essay The text “Divorced, Beheaded, Survived” is a short story written by Robin Black in 2010. It deals with the theme “death” a specifically engages in how death affects our relations. The short story contains mental and social issues connected to losses and the generational recurrence of these. “Divorced, Beheaded, Survived” shows how a woman’s life was changed because of her brother’s death and how she is still affected as an adult. The main theme in the short story is depression caused of a death. The following essay focuses on the structure and symbols in the short story. “Divorced, Beheaded, Survived” is about a 40-year-old mother - Sarah, from whose the point of view is told – therefore a first person narrator. The woman looks back upon an essential episode in her childhood when her older brother became sick and died. The setting is also important in these realizations. The story takes place in Manhattan in the present, but the setting of Sarah’s childhood home is described positively with a sense of calming familiarity. “Day after day, dusk really, in the time between school and dinner, in the small, untended yard behind my childhood home…” When we see at the setting the exiting aspect is to see at the lack of details in the description. The result of this is that the focus of the story becomes the emotional way Sarah experiences and creates a deeper understanding of death and all it’s terrible consequences. The emotional aspect of the history is......

Words: 902 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Native Guard Tretheway

...Mr. Randolph Engl. 210 9/21/12 Tainted History in Natasha Tretheway’s Native Guard Passion, precision, and technique are all synonyms used to describe Natasha Tretheway’s Native Guard that take the reader through the heart of the south and the heart of the family. This essay will examine the contradictions of (African) American life, especially concerning themes of history and memory. “Southern History”, “Incident”, and “South” will demonstrate these contradictions of (African) American history and memory. Serving as a scribe, Tretheway writes these poems for those people history has muted and closed the veil on. Southern History, Incident, and South; poems from section two of her book, depict racism during slavery and the Civil War, which is a part of forgotten history in the eyes of “Americans.” These historic experiences have not been given the proper examination, discussion, or acknowledgement. Tretheway refuses to allow African American history to remain as footnotes and brings out the real “American” history in her collection of poems. Tretheway’s personal experience growing up as a mulatto in the South is seen in her poem “Southern History”. This poem shows that even after more than a hundred years after the Civil War, history is still tainted. History is imperfect and at times intentionally false as textbooks in this time period were used to misinform students; keeping them bound and restricted from the real history of America. As Tretheway’s teacher......

Words: 1280 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Ellen J. Langer Book the Power of Mindful Learning

...however to maintain a formal tone when writing in first person and it might still be evident in this essay itself. I think that the essay itself is still choppy and I should put more time in making more flow and connections between the paragraphs and different points. It is also relatively short for the essay requirement. If I had to do it again I would definitely revise it more than once and probably ask someone else to proof read it. I learned to cite personal experience and information from the book and put it into an argument however I still think that I could still do some improvement on that matter. Mindful Memorization in Education Memorization is something that a lot of people take for granted. Most people memorize information without knowing what they actually remember. Those people remember the information by constant mindless repetition. Another way of memorization comes from making connection of the information with something that is related to it. Although memorizing through relevance is a more recommended way in memorizing information, based on my personal experience and observations constant repetition was also needed throughout my academic journey. When it comes to memorization, something that always appears in my thought is my cousin’s immense skill in memorizing. Going through high school she was always able to recall anything she read from the textbook. History tests were no-brainers for her and going through the SAT vocabulary lists was......

Words: 1133 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Spanish Period

...LEAH N. ORDONIO BSN EVOLUTIONS OF DEVICES A device is usually a constructed tool, but may refer more specifically to: Technology Machine Tool Gadget Improvised explosive device (IED) Appliance (disambiguation), a device for a particular task A component of personal computer hardware Peripheral, any device attached to a computer that expands its functionality Electronic component Nuclear device Device file, an interface of a device driver Music Device (heavy metal band) Device (Device album) Device (pop rock band) Device (Eon album), 2006 Here’s a complete history of just how storage memory devices for computers have evolved ever since their inception: Paper data storage Believe it or not, paper has been [and still is] a form of electronic data storage as early as 1725 when Basile Bouchon used punched paper rolls to store instructions for textile looms. This technology was later developed into the wildly successful Jacquard loom. Later during the 19th Century, telegrams could be prerecorded on punched tape and rapidly transmitted using Alexander Bain's automatic telegraph in 1846. In the late 1880s Herman Hollerith invented punched cards which were used in the 1890 census and the completed results were finished months ahead of schedule and far under budget. This technology was widely used for tabulating votes and grading standardized tests. Barcodes made it possible for any object that was to be sold or transported to have some computer readable......

Words: 1135 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Biological and Humanistic Theoy

...Introduction Socrates’s famous statement “know thyself” gives an explanation for history and connecting with cognitive psychology and all of its’ different areas of study. “The single most important reason to study history is that the present time we are living in cannot be understood without knowing something about the past-how the present came to be” (Goodwin, 2008). We have to understand the first theories and concepts where psychology came to being. How did psychologies’ first pioneers approach and solve the main concerns of their time? People have to recognize psychologies’ “evolving history” (Goodwin, 2008). Knowing psychologies’ history and origins helps us to be aware of complications in the future. To “know thyself” in psychology is to understand psychologies beginnings, strengths, weaknesses, achievement, down falls, disciplines and so much more. This essay will take a look at four key milestones in the development of cognitive psychology. The four key milestones that will be viewed are behaviorism, psychoanalysis, humanism and cognitive psychology. Along with the four key milestones this document will also go over the major importance of behavioral observation. Behaviorism Behavior is defined as a way in which on functions in “response to stimulation” (Merriam-Webster, 2012). Founder of behaviorism John B. Watson is well known for his statement “Give me a dozen healthy infants well-formed, and my own specified world to bring them up in and I’ll......

Words: 1105 - Pages: 5