Premium Essay

Holding Fast

In: Business and Management

Submitted By noobasuar
Words 1436
Pages 6
Oleg Lisovskiy
3/03/12
HBR Business Case Assignment

1. This case starts out in a lab that is located in a building that is operated by Crescordia. Crescordia is a company that makes a range of products such as artificial hips and scalps but also is one of the few companies that sell fixation devices. At the beginning of the case Crescordia holds a seminar for orthopedic surgeons so they can better familiarize themselves with the products and procedures that are needed when dealing with using these fixation plates. During this seminar the CEO Peter Walsh enters excitedly to see what is going on. You can tell right from the start that he is a very big people person and is incredibly interested in finding out the needs and what surgeons are saying about the products that he puts out. After Peter Walsh enters the seminar is put on hold and they all go out to lunch. During lunch one of the surgeons launched into a story about having to remove a resorbable plate, which are fixation devices that instead of having to be removed by doctors after the bone is healed these would just disintegrate after the bone had been healed which would mean that you would not have to have surgery again to remove the plate. The story however takes a sad turn as you find out that most resorbable plates have a lot of problems that have not been figured out and is still a technology that is not capable of doing what it says. The surgeons asked Peter Walsh when Crescordia would plan to launch its own resorbable’s and his response was that Crescordia is a company that has a reputation for quality and that resorbable’s were not at the stage where they would live up to what they set out to do. Resorbable’s are a huge potentially untapped market so Peter Walsh made it his first priority to find out where Crescordia is at with its resorbable’s. He talked with Gary Miskimen who is the head of...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Holding Fast

...Holding fast. Gourville JT. Source Harvard Business School, Boston, USA. jgourville@hbs.edu Abstract CEO Peter Walsh faces a classic innovator's dilemma. His company, Crescordia, produces high-quality metal plates, pins, and screws that orthopedic surgeons use to repair broken bones. In fact, because the company has for decades refused to compromise on quality, there are orthopedic surgeons who use nothing but Crescordia hardware. And now these customers have begun to clamor for the next generation technology: resorbable hardware. Resorbables offer clear advantages over the traditional hardware. Like dissolving sutures, resorbable plates and screws are made of biodegradable polymers. They hold up long enough to support a healing bone, then gradually and harmlessly disintegrate in the patient's body. Surgeons are especially looking forward to using resorbables on children, so kids won't have to undergo a second operation to remove the old hardware after their bones heal, a common procedure in pediatrics. The new products, however, are not yet reliable; they fail about 8% of the time, sometimes disintegrating before the bone completely heals and sometimes not ever fully disintegrating. That's why Crescordia, mindful of its hard-earned reputation, has delayed launching a line using the new technology. But time is running out. A few competitors have begun to sell resorbables despite their imperfections, and these companies are picking up market share. Should Crescordia join......

Words: 496 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Holding Fast

...BUS 223: Principles of Management HBR Business Case Assignment – Holding Fast by John T. Gourville Issued: September 10, 2012 Due: October 19, 2012 NLT 9:00pm in Blackboard Points: This assignment is worth 50 points towards course grade Format: Student papers will be submitted online in Blackboard as a Word document attachment. Your essay must be double-spaced and be at least 3-4 pages in length. Requirement: Students will read the case and provide (as a minimum) responses to the information listed below: 1. A summary of the case (synopsize all the players, the business environment and the major (key) issues in the case). Make sure you leave no stone unturned when identifying all the major players (who are they, what job title, what’s their take on situation, etc.) and issues. But, do not parrot…put in your own words. Be concise. 2. What are the drivers of the tension related to Crescordia offering “resorbables”? Identify and comment on some of the financial, ethical, quality, management “tensions” wrought by competing viewpoints in the case. 3. Given your understanding of the situation, do you think that Crescordia should launch resorbables? (Take a stand. No wishy-washy fence sitting.) A. If yes, in what manner should the launch proceed and with what guidelines? B. If no, what will your (alternative) approach be for this market? Be specific. 4. What are the pros (advantages) and cons (disadvantages) of your chosen approach?......

Words: 307 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Holding Fast

...HBR CASE STUDY Crescordia’s products are respected the world over. Now, rivals have launched a radical–albeit still buggy–new technology. Can the company afford to sit out the revolution? Holding Fast by John T. Gourville “N DANIEL VASCONCELLOS ow remember, with every blow of the hammer, you’ve got to feel the femoral nail advancing through the bone. If you don’t, then for heaven’s sake, stop. It might be impinging on the cortex or it might be too large for the canal. Keep whacking, and you’ll fracture the cortex.” The trainer’s calm, authoritative voice boomed out across the room as a dozen orthopedic surgeons toiled away on the cadaver limbs laid out before them. Pausing to observe the technique of one of the surgeons, he glanced up to see his boss, CEO Peter Walsh, crack open the door and squeeze through, trying his best to be unobtrusive. The trainer glanced at the clock.“Okay, let’s save some of this fun for the afternoon,” he called out. “We’ll meet in the lobby in ten minutes and walk over to lunch.” In addition to making a range of products from artificial hips to scalpels, Crescordia was one of a handful of major companies that developed, manufactured, and sold the steel and titanium plates, nails, and screws – known as fix- ation devices – that surgeons used to repair broken bones. At least twice a month, Crescordia hosted training sessions like this one for orthopedic surgeons who used the company’s products. Walsh joined the group for lunch as......

Words: 2985 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Holding Fast

...CEO Peter Walsh faces a classic innovator’s dilemma. His company, Crescordia, produces high-quality metal plates, pins, and screws that orthopedic surgeons use to repair broken bones. In fact, because the company has for decades refused to compromise on quality, there are orthopedic surgeons who use nothing but Crescordia hardware. And now these customers have begun to clamor for the next generation technology: resorbable hardware. Resorbables offer clear advantages over the traditional hardware. Like dissolving sutures, resorbable plates and screws are made of biodegradable polymers. They hold up long enough to support a healing bone, then gradually and harmlessly disintegrate in the patient’s body. Surgeons are especially looking forward to using resorbables on children, so kids won’t have to undergo a second operation to remove the old hardware after their bones heal, a common procedure in pediatrics. The new products, however, are not yet reliable; they fail about 8% of the time, sometimes disintegrating before the bone completely heals and sometimes not ever fully disintegrating. That’s why Crescordia, mindful of its hard-earned reputation, has delayed launching a line using the new technology. But time is running out. A few competitors have begun to sell resorbables despite their imperfections, and these companies are picking up market share. Should Crescordia join the fray and risk tarnishing its brand? Or should the company sit tight until it can offer a perfect......

Words: 288 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Holding Fast

...Now remember, with every blow of the hammer, you’ve got to feel the femoral nail advancing through the bone. If you don’t, then for heaven’s sake, stop. It might be impinging on the cortex or it might be too large for the canal. Keep whacking, and you’ll fracture the cortex.” The trainer’s calm, authoritative voice boomed out across the room as a dozen orthopedic surgeons toiled away on the cadaver limbs laid out before them. Pausing to observe the technique of one of the surgeons, he glanced up to see his boss, CEO Peter Walsh, crack open the door and squeeze through, trying his best to be unobtrusive. The trainer glanced at the clock. “Okay, let’s save some of this fun for the afternoon,” he called out. “We’ll meet in the lobby in ten minutes and walk over to lunch.” In addition to making a range of products from artificial hips to scalpels, Crescordia was one of a handful of major companies that developed, manufactured, and sold the steel and titanium plates, nails, and screws—known as fixation devices—that surgeons used to repair broken bones. At least twice a month, Crescordia hosted training sessions like this one for orthopedic surgeons who used the company’s products. Walsh joined the group for lunch as often as possible. It was a great opportunity to connect with the physicians and hear firsthand what they liked and didn’t like about Crescordia’s products. Besides, he just plain enjoyed their company. Trauma surgeons tended to be brilliant but down to earth. With......

Words: 898 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Phd Student

...Institutional holding and market friction Ping-Wen Sun Louisiana State University psun1@lsu.edu Abstract This study investigates the relationship between the institutional holding and the stock’s market friction measure. According to Sun’s (2007) findings, I use Hou and Moskowitz’s (2005) price delay measure (D1) and Liu’s (2006) liquidity measure (LM12) to proxy for a stock’s market friction. I find that a higher total institutional holding tends to decrease a stock’s price delay measure, but institutional holding exhibits a U-shaped relationship with a stock’s LM12 measure. However, as the number of institutions increases, the stock’s market friction decreases. In terms of different types of institutional holdings, higher total block holding or higher top five institutional holding of a stock increases a stock’s market friction level. Furthermore, in contrast to Agarwal’s (2007) findings, higher independent long term institutional holding and risk averse institutional holding tends to decrease a stock’s market friction level. Institutional holding and market friction Abstract This study investigates the relationship between the institutional holding and the stock’s market friction measure. According to Sun’s (2007) findings, I use Hou and Moskowitz’s (2005) price delay measure (D1) and Liu’s (2006) liquidity measure (LM12) to proxy for a stock’s market friction. I find that a higher total institutional holding tends to decrease a stock’s price delay measure, but......

Words: 6255 - Pages: 26

Free Essay

Production Managment

...1. How do customers judge the quality of a supermarket? * The customers judge the quality of a supermarket in a highly subjective manner and in different ways, and this depends on their wants and needs. One way of judging the quality of a supermarket is the availability of goods and its wide range. It means that the supermarket should keep a wide range of products so that customers can pick and choose from them. Another is the quality of the customer service that they receive in the store. The behaviour of the customer care executives and to what extent they were eager to not only satisfy but delight the customers. Customers judge through the competitive price. A supermarket that can provide cheaper price with same product will attract more customers. Various products and services should be made available to the customers in one stop so that he gets a complete shopping experience in the supermarket. Another way they judge a supermarket is the customer friendly layout so that they can easily locate things in the store. From the point of view of customers location accessibility is very important. For example, if the supermarket is near their home or office they would find it more convenient to shop in the place. The quality of a supermarket is also judge through the additional services that they offer to its customers. Most of the customers are willing to buy products with high quality and with competitive price, so the quality of the merchandise also plays an important......

Words: 701 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Barilla Case Study

...CASE STUDY – 1 BARILLA SPA IMPLEMENTATION OF JITD Submitted as a requirement for completion of Module 5 – Supply Chain Inventory Management of the SCMP Program. By: Iqbal Gill (Registration Number – 201501160004) Date: 14 February 2015 Table of contents Executive Summary 3 Statement Of Issues 4 Impact of Issues 5 JITD Implementation 6 Barriers 7 Recommendations 11 Conclusion 14 Executive Summary: The Italian Pasta Manufacturer, Barilla SpA, is experiencing a tremendous impact of the BULL WHIP effect (Appendix 1) causing inefficiencies and increases in cost due to variability in demand from its distributors. Giorgio Magialli, the Director of Logistics, wants to implement a Just-In-Time Distribution (JITD) system to gain more control. The new system is untraditional and is being rejected by both distributors and Barilla's internal departments. I have reviewed the reasons for opposition and have made recommendations to gain support for the new JITD system. I feel that with proper implementation and some tweaks; Barilla can garner leverage in the near future and can outgrow the pangs of the newly launched system. Although the case focuses on domestic (Italy) distribution-related operational issues, the Barilla management team should define their operation strategy for the near future that covers both domestic and international markets in alignment of Barilla’s market vision. The operation strategy should identify the order of......

Words: 2225 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

The Past, Possible and Future of Singtel

...Managing Change BUSM 1208 Overview The SingTel Group (SingTel), the incumbent former monopoly, is Asia’s leading communications group, providing a diverse range of communication services and solutions including fixed, mobile, data, internet, info-communications technology, satellite and pay TV. With 130 years of operating experience, SingTel has played an integral part in the development as a major communications hub in the region (SingTel 2011). It has operations and investments in more than 20 countries and territories globally, primary in communications companies beyond Singapore’s border. Exhibit 1 shows SingTel’s investments in various regions. Today, SingTel is listed on the Singapore Exchange, and also the Australian Stock Exchange with the acquisition of Optus in 2001 (Sainsbury 2005). Being the largest company listed on the Singapore Exchange, SingTel had a market capitalization of S$50 billion, and had a turnover of S$16.87 million and net profit after tax of S$3.91 million for the year ended March 2010 (Singapore Telecommunications Limited 2010) as shown in Exhibit 2. Despite enduring a global financial crisis, SingTel is still ranked the top mobile service provider and national telephone provider in its home base, with a market share of 44% and 86% respectively (SingTel 2010). History of Singapore’s Telecommunications Industry SingTel’s heritage could be traced back to 1879, when Singapore became one of the first cities in the East to have telephone service......

Words: 2467 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Zara

...9 - 8 0 2- 0 0 3 R EV : OC TO BER 25 , 2004 LYNDA M. AP PLE GATE NEO BOON S IONG NANCY B ARTL ET T DOLLY CH ANG -LEOW PSA: The World’s Port of Call Shakkei is a Japanese landscaping strategy. It means “borrowed scenery.” If you can integrate the distant scenery into the landscape of your garden, a beautiful garden can be created . . . A good landscaper is able to bring about this kind of integration. This same philosophy is true within Singapore today. If we want to realize the full potential of Singapore as a global business hub, we must leverage global resources to overcome our constraints and limitations . . . A small country is no longer small. This is our strategy to transform Singapore for the 21st century and beyond.1 Corporatised on October 1, 1997, after 33 years as the Port of Singapore Authority (PSA), the mission of PSA was to be the “World’s Port of Call.” A favorite lunch stop for many PSA visitors was the Prima Revolving Restaurant, located just outside the Brani Gate entrance to the port. From this lofty perch, Singapore harbor, port facilities, and operations could be viewed. On a sunny day in late 2000, PSA group president and former chief executive officer for Singapore’s urban redevelopment agency, Khoo Teng Chye, was entertaining a group of visitors. The panoramic view of the sea was dotted with container ships of all sizes, flying flags of many nations. As the restaurant rotated, the massive port infrastructure came into view with its many berths...

Words: 11892 - Pages: 48

Premium Essay

Assignment Economics

...or on-line and occasionally face to face depending on the company. What does a Reservations Sales Agent do? The agent processes customer bookings and answers customer enquiries over the phone and on-line. All bookings (or reservations) then go into a computer reservations system. A Reservations Sales Agent needs to ask and answer questions to ensure their customers get what they are looking for. It is important that a Reservations Sales Agent has comprehensive product information about what they are selling in order to answer customer enquiries accurately. What does it take to be successful? A love of dealing with people, good listening skills, attention to detail and accuracy. The Reservations Sales Agent needs to be able to work at a fast pace as they will often find reservations roles are located in call centres with large numbers of phone calls on hold with clients awaiting your help. What is the Travel Agencies Industry? This industry includes businesses that sell, book and arrange travel, tour and accommodation services for the general public and commercial clients. The industry also encompasses companies primarily engaged in providing travel arrangement and reservation services, including online-only booking systems. Industry Products International and domestic airline bookingsTour and packaged travel bookingsAccommodation bookingsCruise bookingsCar rentalOther services   Industry Activities Retailing and reserving travel ticketsRetailing and reserving......

Words: 6521 - Pages: 27

Premium Essay

Kmart and Sears

...that would have to be stored in semi-trucks beds behind the store because the current products on the shelves weren’t moving. By the start of 2000, Kmart locations looked like they had been foreclosed on with giant cement parking lots filled with maybe a dozen cars on a good day. Eventually retrenchment day came Kmart filed for bankruptcy in January of 2002. Kmart was able to regain control of the company and emerge from bankruptcy in May of 2003. The growth strategy to acquire Sears who at the time had the second highest annual sales behind Wal-Mart was tactical but also risky due an unstable U.S. economy. Going forward with the acquisition the newly formed Sears Holding needed to create new competitive strategies to improve their position in the very competitive market. To be competitive Sears Holding...

Words: 1418 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Smdc

...SM Development Corporation Vision We envision SM Development Corporation to be a leading developer of world-class residences in the Philippines, uplifting Filipino lifestyles into one that is convenient, upscale yet affordable, and environment friendly. SMDC Mission Statement SM Development Corporation will realize its vision by: Ensuring that its homebuyers enjoy the best value for their investment with an upscale lifestyle, generous amenities, and a safe, secure, and friendly neighborhood; Providing an excellent after-sales and maintenance service that will preserve and enhance the long-term value of its residences; Delivering sustainable long-term growth and increasing shareholder value by exercising prudence in resource management based on the principles of good corporate governance; Becoming an employer of choice, offering comprehensive opportunities for career growth and enhancement; and, Assisting and nurturing the communities in which it operates by progressively building on its role as a responsible corporate citizen; SMDC Core Values Vision. Leadership. Focus. Hard Work. Integrity. Innovation. Prudence. Nurturing. Aggressive. Financially Conservative. SM Development Corporation is the real estate arm of the SM Group of Companies. As of December 6, 2010, its total market capitalization is P63.4 billion and its share price is P8.66. Business development SM Development Corporation was incorporated in 1974 as Ayala Fund, Incorporated, a......

Words: 616 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Business 499

...Running head: DIVERSIFICATION STRATEGIES Week 4 Assignment 2 Dr Hassan Yemer Contemporary Business/BUS 508 Strayer University January 24, 2011 1) Compare and contrast the two businesses—core business, their size, financials, global presence, use of e-business (marketing, sales, etc.). A diversified company is one that has multiple, unrelated businesses. Unrelated businesses are those, which (1) require unique management expertise, (2) have different end customers and (3) produce different products or provide different services. One of the benefits of being a diversified company is that it buffers a company from dramatic fluctuations in any one-industry sector. However, this model is also less likely to enable stockholders to realize significant gains or losses because it is not singularly focused on one business. Investopedia (2011) states that companies may become diversified by entering into new businesses on its own, by merging with another company or by acquiring a company operating in another field or service sector. One of the challenges facing diversified companies is the need to maintain a strong strategic focus to produce solid financial returns for shareholders instead of diluting corporate value through ill-conceived acquisitions or expansions. Wal-Mart and Kmart; along with Target are the three primary......

Words: 1543 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Internal & External Environment

...Full control ensures shoe retailer never misses a step By RACHAEL BOON THE success of shoe label and fashion retailer Charles & Keith International on the global front can be attributed to its ability to have a firm grip of its operations across its vast network of stores and factories. This unwavering commitment has put the company in good stead to weather the major crises it had faced, dating back to the days when the retailer was operating out of a small store in Ang Mo Kio in 1990. Back then, co-founder and chief executive Charles Wong, 39, and his younger brother, Keith, 37, were just teenagers helping out at their mother’s shop. She wanted the older Mr Wong to close the unprofitable shoe section, but the future shoe maven was determined to turn it around. He mapped out a plan to take control of the entire shoe business operations – from stocks to design and even shoe sizing. As a result, the shoes sold well and Mr Wong managed to stave off the store’s closure. This experience honed his business acumen, which would serve him well when he decided to set up his own shoe company with his younger brother, who is the firm’s chief operating officer. From the outset, the siblings were determined to make a name for themselves by starting their own brand. In 1996, they set up shop in Amara Shopping Centre to market and sell Charles & Keith shoes at a time when it was unheard of for local shoe retailers to brand themselves. The move was......

Words: 1128 - Pages: 5