Free Essay

How Primary and Secondary Sources Shape History’s View of the Imperialist Age

In: Historical Events

Submitted By luvhaart
Words 608
Pages 3
Two Sides to A Coin:
How Primary and Secondary Sources Shape History’s View of the Imperialist Age
Compare and Contrast Essay on two reading; Differentiate between primary and secondary sources, Discuss the subject of both essays, Provide dates and authors, Mention the time period in which they were written, and Summarize the writing.
There are always two sides to a story, two opinions to be heard, and during the late 19th Century, there were definitely two sides to the issue of Imperialist Expansion. From Messages and Papers of the President, in 1898 President William McKinley addressed Congress with a call to war against Spain, in an effort to expand American influence in Cuba. Conversely, the 1899 Platform of the American Anti-Imperialist League was published to dissuade not only the public, but the Senate as well, from supporting American Imperialism.
Primary sources are vital historical resources that provide a real look into a situation. When analyzed, primary sources can show an author’s motivation to action, or explain an awful circumstance. However, primary resources fail to see the big picture. Secondary sources can provide clues that enable the reader to piece the big picture together more easily. These secondary sources may not provide the exact account of an event, however they remove the emotional bias that can be found in primary sources, and can sometimes link historical events, as they are written after-the-fact.
President McKinley’s address wanted to justify the reach of America’s arm past neutrality and into Cuba, using Imperialism. McKinley lists legal ramifications, economic loss, public outcry, and human rights issues as motivation for why the United States should step in. He even went so far as to say, “It is specially our duty…we owe it to our citizens in Cuba to afford them that protection… no government there can or will,” At the close of the century, McKinley’s address was not the only speech to outline politics for the age of Imperialism; The Anti-Imperialist League’s Platform also highlighted key issues with America’s new route towards global expansion. Prominent party leader, Carl Schurz, said Imperialism went against the moral code of the social contract of the Constitution, and would “destroy its fundamental principles and noblest ideals”. The international issue discussed in the Platform was not that of Spain and Cuba, but of the Philippines, which only shows the speed in which America was grabbing at land. Both McKinley’s speech and the Anti-Imperialists Platform would be primary sources, had they been published independently and not in a collection that had been edited, which therefore makes them secondary sources. McKinley’s speech was from the collection edited by James D. Richardson, and the Platform is an excerpt of a memoir of Carl Schurz that was edited by Frederick Bancroft. Despite the method in which both opinions were given, McKinley and Schurz highlighted justification for both sides with powerful results; McKinley set the stage for the United States to become the world police, something this generation has seen in the War on Terror, and on the other hand Schurz describes President Lincoln’s beliefs, that “if an administration may with impunity ignore the issues upon which it was chosen, deliberately create a condition of war anywhere on the face of the globe, debauch the civil service for spoils to promote adventure, organize a truth suppressing censorship and demand of all citizens a suspension of judgment and their unanimous support while it chooses to continue the fighting, representative government itself is imperiled.” These opinions were two sides of a coin and of a story, that when it was all told, the Administration won, and Imperialism continued on.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Primary Sources

...Explain how a writer should find and use primary and secondary sources. A writer can find sources both primary and secondary from researching and seeking them out. Because primary sources are contemporary accounts of an event, written by someone who experienced or witnessed the event original documents such as letters memoirs, journals, speeches, manuscripts, and interviews would be good to use. Because secondary sources interpret primary sources using published works such as journal articles or books would be good. The internet could basically also be used as either a primary or secondary source. In either event these sources should add credibility and objectiveness to a paper. Explain two issues that may arise if there are differences between the primary and secondary sources. Well one issue that could arise if there are differences is that is that using such a set of sources could cause a paper to lack clarity and depth. The point being put across can lose emphasis which in return can make a paper inconsistent and not easy to read. It also does not help the credibility of the paper. Explain reasons for consulting different kinds of sources on the same subject. Well it is important when writing to be thorough, objective, and to supply as much information as possible. Using different kinds of sources helps to support a paper in this way because of the variety of information being used. This can make the particular paper or writing appeal to a broader......

Words: 388 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Primary and Secondary Markets

...In the financial markets, there are Primary Markets and Secondary Markets. Explain and elaborate on the both markets. What are some differences to an Investor? Which market would an investor want to trade in if they knew there would be a large demand in a market on a later date? There are two types of financial markets available they are Primary Markets and Secondary Markets. A Primary Market is when the company issues stocks available for purchase. The company determines how many stocks they want to offer and what they want the stocks to sell for. In the primary market all money made from stock sales go directly to the company that is selling the stock. In contrast to the primary markets are the Secondary Markets. In Secondary Markets the stocks are already in circulation and have been purchased by investors. The price each share sell for is relative to the amount of shares available and the demand for the stocks. The price that the stock sells for may be higher or lower than the original sale price that the stock holder paid for it. An investor that is looking to make a large profit is most likely going to trade in the secondary market. The investor is hoping to buy stocks when they are at a market low or selling below the original issue price. If they think the market is going to suddenly increase the ideal is to buy when the market is low in the secondary market and hold onto those stocks until they increase to what the investor thinks is the highest point and......

Words: 287 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Evaluate and Explain the Limitations of a Range of Sources of Information Both Primary and Secondary, for Small Scale Public Services Projects.

...limitations of a range of sources of information both primary and secondary, for small scale public services projects. The source's used in the collection of data for a research project or investigation are of vital importance. Characterised as primary and secondary, a good range will provide more information needed to aid decision making. However it is important to note that it can some time's be difficult to distinguish whether the information is primary or secondary. In this essay point's will be made regarding the advantage's and disadvantage's of a number of sources both primary and secondary. Their limitations will be addressed, and an explanation of how data collected during research can help in the decision making process and help organisation's meet their objective's. Ethics will be considered throughout. The actual, origanal or physical materials used in the study of an object, person or particular event in time are known as sources. They are paramount to investigation and are commonly known as primary and secondary sources. A primary source is a physical object or first hand testimony created during the time under-study, an example could be a diary, a piece of writing or photograph. These sources are unique and one of a kind, and could be a copy of the original if they existed during the time of creation. ''Primary research involves the study of a subject through first hand observation and investigation.'' Dawson, (2007,47). Primary sources are great for......

Words: 1491 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Primary Source

...Tyler Fields Western Civ. 4/9/13 Primary Source Assignment #2 I am Gui le Gros, a Norman abbot, who was born into a very wealthy aristocratic family. My cousin, Henry the Fearful, is the head of our noble family and is in great prominence with the King of France. To commemorate the completion of the king’s new cathedral, my cousin wishes to chronicle the history of our glorious province of Normandy from its beginning in 911 to the current year. My cousin put me in charge of this task, so it is up to me to portray the history of Normandy and its people for the king. During this time European people began to advance economically, politically, and socially. Advancements in agriculture allowed the people to produce enough food to support the growing population. A feudal system began to take place that would shape Europe for history. Through these changing times, Normandy was a central focus for multiple nations. . (Brohpy, Cole, Robertson, and et al 350-353) Normandy is a province in North Western France, and the history of it begins with the conquest of England. After the Danish king Canute died, Edward the confessor took power over England. However, Edward did not have any children leading to a dispute over who would be his heir. The Anglo-Saxons decided to pick one of their own to be the heir. Harold Godwinson became the new king but he was quickly challenged but others who also believed they had claims to the throne. Harold Hardradi of Norway was the first challenge. He...

Words: 904 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Secondary Data Sources

...Secondary Data Sources Slide 1 Before conducting a marketing research study, it’s best to consult secondary sources to both inform that study or perhaps to provide the data that would have been duplicated by that study, but at far less cost. Slide 2 Fortunately, there are many resource people, such as librarians, to help with secondary data searches. You’re probably familiar with conducting internet searches using sources such as Google or Yahoo or perhaps a different search engine altogether. You’re also probably familiar with using library databases and searching those as well. There are many non-computerized sources of secondary information and there may be computerized sources with which you’re unfamiliar or unknowledgeable about accessing. Librarians and library personnel are effective in helping you to identify and successfully access that type of information. Slide 3 What do marketing researchers mean when they speak about secondary data? Secondary data is data gathered and recorded by someone else prior to and for a purpose other than the current project. Such data is often historical, already assembled, and needs no access to study participants. Slide 4 Databases of secondary data come in four flavors: bibliographic, numeric, directory, and full text. For bibliographic sources, think in terms of bibliographies or listings; although not self-contained sources, they provide listings of possible sources for further query. Numeric sources contain numbers; for......

Words: 2997 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Evaluation of Secondary and Primary Research

...Report “Evaluation of Secondary and Primary Research” Student Name: Rana Ahmed Saeed Khan Student Number: ST20027073 Course Title: Module Title: MBA Marketing Module number: MBA 7003 Module tutor: Katherine Mutter Submission details: To be submitted on 18th April 2013 Marketing Report Assignment 1 MBA7003 Table of Contents S no. Topics Page 01 1. Introduction………………………………………………………………………... 2. Primary Research…………………………………………………………………. 01 3. Secondary Research……………………………………………………………… 01 4. Value and weaknesses of Secondary research carried out…………………… 03 5. How primary research may be used to supplement the secondary research…03 6. Research report on UK mobile market…………………..…………………..……..03 7. Conclusion…………………..…………………..…………………..……………….. 04 8. References…………………..…………………..…………………..……………….. 04 Marketing Report Assignment 1 MBA7003 1. Introduction: The report analyzes various aspects of primary research and offers an understanding of how secondary research can be used to supplement it. Merits and demerits of primary and secondary research are discussed in academic and marketing terms. 2. Primary Research: Primary research is developed by researchers by witnessing first hand sources without using their own analysis, interpretation and opinions. It usually includes diaries, speeches, autobiographies, interviews and newspapers or magazines (University of Pittsburgh 2003). Further explanation of primary sources is given by Blythe......

Words: 1155 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Primary Sources

...Primary Sources Assignment Newton, John. “Amazing Grace.” Hymns of the 49th Parallel. 5th ed. New York: Baptist Hymnals Publishers, 1974. In the world of music, there are many songs that bring one joy, excitement, or delight. In other cases, there are songs that lead one to sadness, depression, or loneliness. However, there are also significantly few songs that reach down to the very depths of your heart and touch you in a way that is truly moving. This sort of emotion was felt when I heard the hymnal “Amazing Grace” by John Newton, and is still felt today. As a young child, I never really understood the complexity of the Holy Bible, the stories within it, or the ‘grace’ that is so freely offered. I often admittedly fell asleep in church or simply passed the time away by drawing funny pictorials of biblical characters I was supposed to learn about in Sunday school. Considering I was just like the other typical rebellious eight year old boys, this was quite acceptable in my opinion. Nevertheless, it wasn’t until one special Sunday evening service that I finally ‘came of age.’ The standard ‘boring’ service went on as it usually did and as the preacher summed up his message, my mother, the piano player, made her way up to the front of the sanctuary. As she began to play, the choir began to sing. I began to listen, and my heart began to melt. What was this song they were singing? Surely I had heard it. Only this time it was different. The melodious words,......

Words: 1290 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Primary and Secondary Research

...------------------------------------------------- Primary research consists of a collection of original primary data collected by the researcher. It is often undertaken after the researcher has gained some insight into the issue by reviewing secondary research or by analysing previously collected primary data. ------------------------------------------------- Secondary research (also known as desk research) involves the summary, collation and/or synthesis of existing research rather than primary research, where data is collected from, for example, research subjects or experiments. ------------------------------------------------- Quantitative research is about asking people for their opinions in a structured way so that you can produce hard facts and statistics to guide you. To get reliable statistical results, it's important to survey people in fairly large numbers and to make sure they are a representative sample of your target market. ------------------------------------------------- Qualitative research is about exploring issues, understanding phenomena, and answering questions by analysing and making sense of unstructured data. From health studies, to academic, market and policy research; qualitative research happens in nearly every workplace and study environment, nearly every day. The Pros Of Primary Research: * Easy to do. * Can do what you want… surveys, phone surveys, mail surveys, face to face surveys etc. * Quick and cheap for a small sample. ...

Words: 329 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Primary Research and Secondary Researcg

...being a descriptive account of how they could be applied. Primary Research Surveys; A survey helps to get customer feedback that involves Hurum’s to prepare a mini questionnaire they would give to customers. The questionnaire would contain tick boxes and writing their opinions what you can improve on. When Hurum’s gets the returning of the questionnaire it needs read and improved on know what the customer satisfaction is. Experimentation; Experimentation is a different way of trying out new things by experimenting; you can see what error is produced and see if it can be controlled by the researcher. Experimentation can be a way of trying out a new design on a small area. Hurum’s might test a new product to a limited audience of consumers by this it allows Hurum’s to save money as they are letting limited audience to test the product. This allows Hurum’s to go after for more products to invent in. E – Marketing; E marketing, all so known as internet advertising by using internet advertising you will be able to promote your market. By this Hurum’s you can increase their sales, by sharing information about your business through emails and helping the customers see how useful your products are and having newsletters is a great way of updating about your business and updating them with offers. Focus groups; Focus group is bringing potential customers together to discuss business cases, what they think about on certain services and products and how Hurum’s can improve on......

Words: 1033 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Primary and Secondary Sources

...Primary source is a document of a period-of-time being studied. It includes diary, books, music, photographs, paintings, etc. They are created by witnesses who had experienced events during the period. I have looked into several sources, and music from the great depression interests me the most. The lyrics, melody, and tempo expressed the musicians’ subtext profoundly. By looking at the lyrics from the great depression, I have identified the most frequent topic, which was money. Even though the lyrics came with cheerful tones of melody, but the words deeply strikes my heart. Money can’t buy happiness but you can’t survive without money; people during that time were so desperate for a better life, thus they think about fortune all the time. Desperate lyrics along with ‘happy go lucky’ melody made up the music culture of 1930s American history. Primary sources are very interesting to investigate because they contain real historical evidences that bring people back to the old times. One of the strength of using primary source to understand American history is that unlike secondary source, primary source prevents deformation from the original source. It is a first person point of view from that time and place. The music delivers a strong emotion towards the great depression. Music is already an influential art; music from that period could express the feeling much greater than other primary sources. The purpose of communication is very clear in music, it combine words that......

Words: 512 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

How Important Is Primary Socialisation

...Primary socialization is the process of becoming able members of several institutions, including family, religion, culture and education. During primary socialization, language, norms, values and basic expectations of society are learnt, such as the way to dress, eat and communicate, leading to the moral outcome needed to survive. Sociologists have a variety of theories telling us how children understand their role in the social order. George Herbert Mead developed a theory of social behaviorism explaining how social experiences develop a child's self-concept. He argued that the self does not exist at birth, but develops only through social experience, which is the exchange of symbols. Therefore, we tend to find meaning in every action, and further, imagining the intention of others. Others act as a mirror in which we can see ourselves, according to Mead. The key to developing ourselves is learning to take the role of the other. However, with limited social experience, infants are only able to develop a sense of their identity through imitation. He concluded that the final stage of primary socialization is the generalized other, referring to the widespread cultural norms and values. Cooley devised the term, 'looking glass self', meaning self image based on how we think others view us. He claimed that we form our self-images through interaction with other people. He was particularly interested in how significant others shape us as individuals. A significant other is someone......

Words: 450 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Discuss the Primary, Secondary and Source of Information

...Primary, Secondary, and Tertiary source of information Sources of information are often considered primary, secondary, or tertiary depending on their originality and proximity of when it was created. Consider if it is an original work, or whether it evaluates or comments on the works of others. Also consider the proximity, or how close the information is to a first-hand account or if it is after the fact. Sources of information are often considered primary, secondary, or tertiary depending on their originality and proximity of when it was created. Consider if it is an original work, or whether it evaluates or comments on the works of others. Also consider the proximity, or how close the information is to a first-hand account or if it is after the fact. PRIMARY SOURCES DEFINED Primary sources are first-hand accounts or individual representations and creative works. It can also be said to be information that has been stated but not interpreted. They are created by those who have directly witnessed what they are describing, and bring us as close to the original event or thought as possible without being filtered, influenced or analyzed through interpretation. They tend to be original documents that don't usually describe or analyze work by others. Primary information is in its raw state Primary sources may be published or unpublished works. Primary source means it is original article or book created by individual or sometimes a group of people. It may be surprising...

Words: 380 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

More Girls Are Finishing Primary School, but They Are Facing Challenges in Accessing and Completing Secondary Education, a Critical Source of Skills in Changing Economies.

...is undeniable. That is why many governments put a lot of effort into investing in this group of people in order to benefit from its return in a long-term period and also improve lives of future generations. The question then arises: “how to invest in youth?”. The answer to this question can be limitless, but the first thing that comes to my mind is good health and proper education. From my point of view, the proper education is defined as a good combination of primary and second education. The girls’ secondary education is a quite problematic topic, especially when they finish primary school and are on the threshold of starting their secondary education or suffering from life full of bad surprises. The reason why secondary education of girls is of crucial importance is associated with its dramatic effect on the economy and a wider society. Thus, referring to the idea that girls’ education is advantageous not only for individuals but also for the whole society, I would like to express my thoughts about its economic and social impacts, the benefits and costs of both educated and uneducated girls, the barriers girls face in accessing secondary education and to give recommendations on how to improve this critical situation. In today’s modern world, it is not surprising to encounter women who work in the top level positions with high salaries, run their own businesses or drive cars. There is no doubt that they can......

Words: 2109 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Primary Secondary Groups

...A primary group is typically a smaller group with very close and personal relationships. While a secondary group far less personal and usually has a function or goal that was in mind while the group was created. Primary groups build on human’s basic need of being social and accepted. This can come from family or even cliques at school. I chose family and military as my primary groups that I have and am a part of that I will analyze my role in these group situations. The secondary groups I chose are the group that was created the first day of this class and an online gaming community. The role I take on within my family can vary depending on each individual and situation. I would say that I have taken on each group task role, group building maintenance role and individual role at least once at some point. I try to stay in a role that is positive such as standard setter. While in a family many roles are filled but while in the military usually there are few roles being filled. The roles I filled within my time in the Army were still many but not as many as family. The usual roles being fulfilled for anyone is as a follower when in your first few years of military. Later one can become an orienter and coordinator. As a secondary group a gaming community is very informal. The people within the community though are there for one reason and that is to play games. My role usually within the gaming community coordinator and standard setter. In the group that was made......

Words: 320 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Define the Distinctions Between Primary, Secondary, and Tertiary Sources in a Secondary Search

...2 Define the distinctions between primary, secondary, and tertiary sources in a secondary search. The best way to distinct between the sources of secondary research is to define each. Primary sources are those that are direct and un-interpreted records of a subject that you are researching. A primary source can be just about anything such as books, artifacts, or even patents. Secondary sources are ones that build on primary sources. Analyzing, interpreting, and assessing primary information are examples of secondary. Tertiary sources are ones which present summaries of the current state of research topics. Some examples are dictionaries, web sites, or almanacs. The distinction between these can differ between subjects of research. If the subject for research was humanities then an example of a primary source would be letters by Martin Luther King. A secondary source could be a web site of his writings and finally the tertiary source could be an encyclopedia on the civil rights movement. 3 What problems of secondary data quality must researchers face? How can they deal with them? Using secondary data can sometimes cause problems. Although it can be quicker and sometimes cost effective there is always a chance of running in to these issues. The most cautious of these issues the researcher must be aware of is the reliability of the source. If the researcher were to sit in a meeting and take notes of a subject then they would be completely sure of the content of the......

Words: 762 - Pages: 4