Free Essay

How Primary and Secondary Sources Shape History’s View of the Imperialist Age

In: Historical Events

Submitted By luvhaart
Words 608
Pages 3
Two Sides to A Coin:
How Primary and Secondary Sources Shape History’s View of the Imperialist Age
Compare and Contrast Essay on two reading; Differentiate between primary and secondary sources, Discuss the subject of both essays, Provide dates and authors, Mention the time period in which they were written, and Summarize the writing.
There are always two sides to a story, two opinions to be heard, and during the late 19th Century, there were definitely two sides to the issue of Imperialist Expansion. From Messages and Papers of the President, in 1898 President William McKinley addressed Congress with a call to war against Spain, in an effort to expand American influence in Cuba. Conversely, the 1899 Platform of the American Anti-Imperialist League was published to dissuade not only the public, but the Senate as well, from supporting American Imperialism.
Primary sources are vital historical resources that provide a real look into a situation. When analyzed, primary sources can show an author’s motivation to action, or explain an awful circumstance. However, primary resources fail to see the big picture. Secondary sources can provide clues that enable the reader to piece the big picture together more easily. These secondary sources may not provide the exact account of an event, however they remove the emotional bias that can be found in primary sources, and can sometimes link historical events, as they are written after-the-fact.
President McKinley’s address wanted to justify the reach of America’s arm past neutrality and into Cuba, using Imperialism. McKinley lists legal ramifications, economic loss, public outcry, and human rights issues as motivation for why the United States should step in. He even went so far as to say, “It is specially our duty…we owe it to our citizens in Cuba to afford them that protection… no government there can or will,” At the close of the century, McKinley’s address was not the only speech to outline politics for the age of Imperialism; The Anti-Imperialist League’s Platform also highlighted key issues with America’s new route towards global expansion. Prominent party leader, Carl Schurz, said Imperialism went against the moral code of the social contract of the Constitution, and would “destroy its fundamental principles and noblest ideals”. The international issue discussed in the Platform was not that of Spain and Cuba, but of the Philippines, which only shows the speed in which America was grabbing at land. Both McKinley’s speech and the Anti-Imperialists Platform would be primary sources, had they been published independently and not in a collection that had been edited, which therefore makes them secondary sources. McKinley’s speech was from the collection edited by James D. Richardson, and the Platform is an excerpt of a memoir of Carl Schurz that was edited by Frederick Bancroft. Despite the method in which both opinions were given, McKinley and Schurz highlighted justification for both sides with powerful results; McKinley set the stage for the United States to become the world police, something this generation has seen in the War on Terror, and on the other hand Schurz describes President Lincoln’s beliefs, that “if an administration may with impunity ignore the issues upon which it was chosen, deliberately create a condition of war anywhere on the face of the globe, debauch the civil service for spoils to promote adventure, organize a truth suppressing censorship and demand of all citizens a suspension of judgment and their unanimous support while it chooses to continue the fighting, representative government itself is imperiled.” These opinions were two sides of a coin and of a story, that when it was all told, the Administration won, and Imperialism continued on.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Shir

...politics • Historical context • ZANU PF’s ‘Patriotic History’ • Patriotic History’s detractors • What is Patriotic History? • The opposition’s use of history 5 5 6 6 8 CHAPTER 2: History in secondary and higher education 11 History curriculum development in Zimbabwe’s secondary schools and higher education institutions, and the implications for reconciliation, national healing and transitional justice • The growth in education since independence • History in secondary schools • History in higher education • A review of the NASS syllabus 11 11 14 17 CHAPTER 3: Teaching history 23 Challenges of teaching history in Zimbabwe, points of contention and consensus, and future prospects • Repression in tertiary institutions • Decline in secondary schools • National youth training service centres • Reasons for optimism 23 25 25 26 CHAPTER 4: Supporting history teaching 29 Supporting secondary and higher educators, and proposals towards learning sessions, modules and activities for history teaching • Funding education • Resurgence of liberal principles • Key proposals and teaching suggestions 29 30 30 CHAPTER 5: Teaching with Becoming Zimbabwe 33 How the Zimbabwe history book can offer opportunities to support history teaching at secondary and higher levels iii EXECUTIVE SUMMARY History is the study of the transformation and growth in society over time and space. Examining the past allows us to understand how history influences our present and future. A study of......

Words: 16487 - Pages: 66

Premium Essay

Citizenship

...CURRICULUM REVIEW Search using the ref: 00045-2007DOM-EN Copies of this publication can also be obtained from: DfES Publication PO Box 5050 Sherwood Park Annesley Nottingham NG15 0DJ Tel: 0845 60 222 60 Fax: 0845 60 333 60 Textphone: 0845 555 60 Please quote ref: 00045-2007DOM-EN ISBN: 978-1-84478-883-5 PPSLS/D35/0107/14 © Crown Copyright 2007 Produced by the Department for Education and Skills Extracts from this publication may be reproduced for non commercial education or training purposes on the condition that the source is acknowledged. For any other use please contact HMSOlicensing@cabinet-office.x.gsi.gov.uk DIVERSITY & CITIZENSHIP You can download this publication or order copies online at: www.teachernet.gov.uk/publications Diversity and Citizenship Curriculum Review Review Group members Sir Keith Ajegbo retired in July 2006 as Headteacher of Deptford Green School, a multiethnic school with a strong reputation for Citizenship education. He is currently working as a coach on the Future Leaders Project, as a School Improvement Partner, and as an education consultant for UBS. He is also a Governor of Goldsmiths College and a trustee of the Stephen Lawrence Trust. Dr Dina Kiwan is a Lecturer in Citizenship Education at Birkbeck College, University of London. Previously she was seconded to the Home Office as the Head of Secretariat to the Advisory Board for Naturalisation and Integration (ABNI), carrying forward......

Words: 37771 - Pages: 152

Free Essay

One Significant Change That Has Occurred in the World Between 1900 and 2005. Explain the Impact This Change Has Made on Our Lives and Why It Is an Important Change.

...of the Soviet Union, the reunification of Germany, the surge of globalization from the mid-1990s) and afterward (9/11, or the global recession of 2008) when one could quite plausibly argue that a new era had begun. A compelling case can be made for viewing the decades of the global scramble for colonies after 1870 as a predictable culmination of the long nineteenth century, which was ushered in by the industrial and political revolutions of the late 1700s. But at the same time, without serious attention to the processes and misguided policies that led to decades of agrarian and industrial depression from the late 1860s to the 1890s, as well as the social tensions and political rivalries that generated and were in turn fed by imperialist expansionism, one cannot begin to comprehend the causes and consequences of the Great War that began in 1914. That conflict determined the contours of the twentieth century in myriad ways. On the one hand, the war set in motion transformative processes that were clearly major departures from those that defined the nineteenth-century world order. On the other, it perversely unleashed forces that would undermine Western world dominance and greatly constrict the forces advancing globalization, both of which can be seen as hallmarks of the opening decades of the twentieth century. This intermingling of the forces and processes that were arguably essential components 2 • INTRODUCTION of two epochs we routinely set apart......

Words: 163893 - Pages: 656

Premium Essay

Multinational Corporation

...to Understanding Foreign ix 3 Direct Investment and Multinational Corporations 2 Defining the Subject: Subtleties and Ambiguities 3 From Obscurity to International Economic Powerhouse: 11 27 41 The Evolution of Multinational Corporations 4 Heterogeneity: The Many Kinds of Foreign Direct Investment and Multinational Corporations and Their Disparate Effects 5 Perceptions and Economic Ideologies 62 93 Part II The Strategy of Multinationals 6 Why Companies Invest Overseas 7 Where Multinational Corporations Invest and 117 148 Don’t Invest and Why Part III Impact on the International Order 8 Effects of Foreign Direct Investment on Less Developed Countries: Vagaries, Variables, Negatives, and Positives 9 Why and How Multinational Corporations Have 179 205 233 Altered International Trade 10 Multinational Corporations versus the Nation-State: Has Sovereignty Been Outsourced? 11 The International Regulation of Multinational Corporations: Why There Is No Multilateral Foreign Direct Investment Regime 252 Part IV Three Bottom Lines 12 The Case for Foreign Direct Investment and Multinational Corporations 13 The Case against Foreign Direct Investment and 283 308 332 Multinational Corporations 14 An Agnostic Conclusion: ‘‘It Depends’’ Part V Recommendations 15 An Agenda for Future Action 355 365 Index viii contents Abbreviations AFL-CIO American Federation of Labor and Congress of Industrial......

Words: 160016 - Pages: 641

Premium Essay

Bdhs

...formulations were slow to appear. For these thinkers social change was "a property of social order, known as change" (Luhmann 1984, 471). Moreover, in the midst of change observers began to look in retrospect to the dramatic changes that had occurred in earlier epochs, for examples, in the development of the Egyptian Empire or the Western Roman Empire. Contemporary theories of social change have become more generalized in order to explain far-reaching processes of change in past and present. In a review of contemporary theories of change Hermann Strasser and Susan C. Randall have identified the following attributes for these changes: "magnitude of change, time span, direction, rate of change, amount of violence involved" (1981, 16). In our view any theory of change must contain three main elements that must stand in definite relation to one another: 1. Structural determinants of social change, such as population changes, the dislocation occasioned by war, or strains and contradictions. 2. Processes and mechanisms of social change, including precipitating mechanisms, social movements, political conflict and accommodation, and entrepreneurial activity. 3. Directions of social change, including structural changes, effects, and consequences. Graphically, these may be arranged as follows: ―3― Even this rendition of the metaframework for models of change is overly simple, for among the structural determinants of different processes of social change are the accumulated......

Words: 171529 - Pages: 687

Premium Essay

Managing Cultura Differences

... Summary, References 6 MANAGING TRANSITIONS AND RELOCATIONS Coping with Transitional Challenges, Culture Shock and Acculturation, Relocation and Deployment Systems, Business Etiquette and Protocol Abroad, Summary, References 7 MANAGING DIVERSITY IN THE GLOBAL WORK CULTURE Globalization and Diversity, People on the Move, Defining Cultural Diversity, The Microculture of Work, New Work Procedures, A Macrosystemic Perspective on Organizational Diversity, A Microsystemic Perspective, Empowerment, Summary, References 8 WOMEN IN GLOBAL BUSINESS Current Status of Global Women Managers, Global Barriers Hindering the Advancement of Women, Persistent Global Cultural Stereotypes, Balancing Work and Family, Selected Woman Managers’ Views, Company Initiatives to Break the Glass Ceiling, The Next Generation, What the Future Might Hold, Summary, References 9 EFFECTIVE PERFORMANCE IN THE GLOBAL MARKETPLACE Global Leaders and Strategic Alliances, The Psychological Contract, Developing Human Resources, Global Performance, Integrity in Business Organizations, Ethical Relativism, Cultural Changes, Managing Technology Transfer, Effective Global Leadership, Summary, References UNIT 2 REGIONAL CULTURE SPECIFICS 10 DOING BUSINESS WITH NORTH AMERICANS (United States and Canada) Pan-American Management Perspectives, Northern America’s Indigenous People, Canada, The United States of America, Summary, References 11 DOING BUSINESS WITH LATIN AMERICANS (Mexico and......

Words: 229816 - Pages: 920

Free Essay

Globalisation

...1988. First published 2006 by PALGRAVE MACMILLAN Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS and 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, N. Y. 10010 Companies and representatives throughout the world PALGRAVE MACMILLAN is the global academic imprint of the Palgrave Macmillan division of St. Martin’s Press, LLC and of Palgrave Macmillan Ltd. Macmillan® is a registered trademark in the United States, United Kingdom and other countries. Palgrave is a registered trademark in the European Union and other countries. ISBN-13: ISBN-10: ISBN-13: ISBN-13: 978–1–4039–8638–2 1–4039–8638–X 978–1–4039–8639–9 1–4039–8639–8 hardback hardback paperback paperback This book is printed on paper suitable for recycling and made from fully managed and sustained forest sources. A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. A catalogue record for this book is available from the Library of Congress. 10 15 9 14 8 13 7 12 6 11 5 10 4 09 3 08 2 07 1 06 Printed and bound in Great Britain by Antony Rowe Ltd, Chippenham and Eastbourne Contents List of Boxes Acknowledgments Introduction 1 Theorizing Globalization: Introducing the Challenge Introduction Critical theory Defining globalization Perspectives on globalization Globalization in history Theories of social change ‘Development’ and ‘modernity’ Conclusion 2 Economic Globalization Introduction Capitalism, social democracy, and neoliberalism Neoliberalism and the IMF, World Bank, and WTO Global finance New technology Trade and......

Words: 100030 - Pages: 401

Premium Essay

Reading a Novel in 1950-2000

...would also like to thank several editors at Blackwell – Emma Bennett, Mary Dortch, Karen Wilson, and Astrid Wind – for their expert advice and tireless efforts on behalf of this volume; and Professor Daniel R. Schwarz of Cornell University for approaching me to contribute a volume to the present series. As always, I am deeply grateful to my wife Rachel and daughters Hannah and Ruth for making everything possible and worthwhile. An earlier version of portions of Chapter 9 first appeared in Brian W. Shaffer, Understanding Kazuo Ishiguro (University of South Carolina Press, 1998). viii RTNA01 8 13/6/05, 5:28 PM Preface Arthur Marwick opens his book British Society since 1945 by observing: “Nobody has ever said precisely how many ways there are of skinning a cat. Probably there are about the same number of ways of writing a Social History of Britain since 1945.”1 The same might be said of the subject of the present volume, the novel in English, exclusive of the US novel, between the end of World War II and the turn of the millennium. This vast, rich, spectacularly heterogeneous field of the British and postcolonial Anglophone novel is only now, at the beginning of the twenty-first century, coming into focus. John Brannigan cautions in his book on literature in England between 1945 and 2000 that “the period since 1945 is too recent to see anything but its diversity and complexity, and is too diverse and complex to enable us to construct......

Words: 123617 - Pages: 495