Free Essay

How Should the Banking System Be Regulated?

In: Other Topics

Submitted By ap11
Words 551
Pages 3
How should the banking system be regulated?
• The post Bretton woods era was marked with political disputes by developed countries and new policy regimes in response to the failures of previous crises. During the Bretton Woods system, capital controls were an instrument to prevent the instability but with the rise of the Euromarkets in the 1960’s capital controls had been reduced and became difficult to enforce effectively. Towards the end of the 1970’s both the UK and US had adopted financial deregulation which encouraged competition between banks and this led to developing countries adopting similar methods.
• Since the Bretton Woods era, there has been more integration between economies and this has led to a more globalised world. Global capital mobility along with global lending has increased, and advances in technology have allowed financial innovation that tested state boundaries encouraged more globalization, not less. Trade continued to expand as it had during the Bretton Woods era, but after Bretton Woods there was a shift towards more neoliberal policies which favoured liberalisation and the openness of markets.
• Many of the debates that took place after the financial crisis were concerned with an increasing role of regulation around the world with the help of governments. Firstly, after the financial crisis it was clear to see that the goal of financial stability had to be included in monetary policy but what tool could be used to do this effectively? Interest rate setting by central banks was not seen as being sufficient as it would be difficult to achieve two different objectives using the same tool. The response by the FSB has been to implement a new tool known as the Basel III which is said to have a countercyclical effect to credit raises and inflation. Secondly, those institutions that posed a systemic risk had to be identified and looked at to see what improvements could have been made. There have been debates about crisis management mechanisms and banking methods which are both aimed at preventing the triggering of a financial crisis.
• In the past, regulation has been undertaken to improve the risk management practices in individual banks whereas the focus should be on the systemic externalities and consumer protection. There has been a call for a ‘level playing field’ as financial cycles differ from country to country therefore regulation will be different for all countries. This is why it would be harder to regulate finance at international level. Furthermore, as long as financial institutions believe that they state will bail them out, we will continue to have problems no matter how much regulation is put into place. International regulation differs from domestic regulation due to the fact that at international level, the geographic scale of systemic risk is bigger. As financial markets become more integrated, network interdependency increases and therefore the failure of a foreign institution will have a big impact at domestic level.
• The turmoil witnessed in the financial crisis poses a challenge to traditional views of financial regulation. I believe that the purpose is to create a more stable base for the financial system as a whole and to prevent a reoccurrence of a financial crisis. Financial regulation can also promote competition between countries and increase efficiency among institutions. On the other hand, governments use regulation to balance private and public interests.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Accounting

...a huge role in avoiding the crisis. Many countries around the world have to decide whether to regulate or not to regulate their accounting standards. Supporters of regulation usually state that the free market notion states that accounting information is like an economic good so it is best to leave the markets to decide what and how much information is needed. This will help achieve efficient market system, however this kind of a system exists only in theory and not in reality, and so then what is the point of a free market system when it cannot be efficient? (Y. Hong, 2007) The rewards of free market system are realized only when it is executed in isolation. But in reality, markets cannot be left completely on its own and some regulation or government intervention is required. Government intervention even at its minimum will not be able to achieve efficient markets and thus it is better to have a well regulated system. Free market system has led to market failures that have had major adverse effects globally in the past. On the contrary, planned economies have also hampered innovation and productivity like China and thus some market system should be there. Y. Hong (2007) in the article mentions the Australian accounting regulations and describes them as very stringent resulting in negative consequences. Australian reporting...

Words: 1762 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Why Are Banks Regulated

...that they should be functioning for years to come. According to the Business Dictionary a regulation is a principle or rule (with or without the coercive power of law) employed in controlling, directing, or managing an activity, organization, or system. Banks are regulated to give guidelines as to how the bank should be run to ensure their services are available for years to come. One main reason why banks are regulated is to protect and prevent the bank from fraudulent activities. The regulators protect the consumers from possible fraudulent activities as small as misleading advertisements on the banks part to major acts as money laundering. The possible effects of poor regulations in the banking sector was clearly depicted in the case of Stanford where, since the bank was poorly regulated Mr Stanford had the opportunity to steal millions of dollars from the customers and as a result when he was brought to justice the ripple effect it had was devastating since many individuals lost their money in his ponzi scheme. The regulators also ensure that the banks do their part in giving their consumers a return on their savings and aren't depriving the consumers of their basic benefits. Another reason of why banks are regulated is to reduce the systematic risk, where this is the risk of the bank completely failing. It is important that a bank thrive because if one bank fails it does not affect that particular bank alone, it has a ripple effect throughout the entire banking industry...

Words: 473 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Corporate Financing Environment in India: a Critical Review

...Submitted By : Santhosh Kumar Submitted to : Dr YogeshMaheshwari CCBMDO-09 Financial Management I Assignment I 31 Oct 2012 CORPORATE FINANCING ENVIRONMENT IN INDIA: A CRITICAL REVIEW S No | Topic | Page No | 1. | Executive Summary | 2 | 2. | Financial Instruments | 3 | 3. | Financial Markets | 4 | 4. | Financial Intermediaries | 5 | 5. | The Regulatory Environment | 6 | 6. | The Way Forward | 9 | Executive Summary 1. Corporate finance is used to collectively identify the various financial dealings undertaken by a corporation. Ideally, corporate finance is the division of the company that is mostly concerned with the financial operations of the company. In some businesses, corporate finance primarily focuses on raising money for ventures and projects. For other corporations and investment banks, corporate finance concentrates on analysis of corporate buyouts and other decisions. The core functions of corporate finance are making wise use of the financial resources available to the company. Corporate finance may also take on many different aspects of the overall management of the finances of the company. The functions may also include managing of investments like acquisition and selling stocks, bonds, and other investment ventures pertaining to other companies. It may also involve creating and managing the process for issuing shares of stock or offering corporate bonds to generate resources for expansion projects. 2. The pattern...

Words: 5192 - Pages: 21

Premium Essay

Problems Facing Us Banking System

...Problems facing the U.S. Banking sectors There are still a number of problems that face the U.S banking sector. The banking industry is slowly emerging from the financial crises of 2008 that left its reputation battered and tarnished. This has created a much tougher and a more competitive market. There are around 7,200 commercial banks in the United States. I will identify some of the problems as well as suggest some policy recommendations to resolve these issues in order to overcome and help strengthen and growth this sector. Regulatory issues, emerging technology demands and customer service focus are three main areas I have identified as well as will provide suggestions and recommendations for in the paper. The U.S. banking sector continues to face a great deal of uncertainty in regards to regulations. Bank regulations in the United States are highly fragmented when compared to other countries. Most countries only have one bank regulator as opposed to the United States that is regulated at both the federal and state level. Within those federal and state levels there are a number of regulations that were delayed and or are still being defined. This causes a great deal of uncertainty in regards to the costs associated with complying with these new proposed standards and regulations. In addition, it makes in tough for these institutions to predict or implement a long term strategic plan when there is so much uncertainty with policy in the upcoming years. ...

Words: 1476 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

The Implication of Ppp on Ptm

...3 The Regulatory System in the United Kingdom This chapter examines the regulatory system currently in place in the United Kingdom. It provides an overview of the structure and objectives of regulation, the role of the regulator and the techniques that are employed in regulating firms and individuals who engage in investment business. 3.1 Background: the financial crisis and regulatory reform 3.1.1 Responding to the financial crisis In the UK, as elsewhere, the onset of the financial crisis exposed deficiencies in financial regulation and led to calls for regulatory reform. The Treasury Select Committee1 led the way, with its hearings into the collapse of Northern Rock exposing serious deficiencies in supervision and risk management.2 In October 2008, the Chancellor of the Exchequer asked Lord Turner, the newly appointed chairman of the FSA, to review the causes of the crisis and to make recommendations on the changes in regulation and supervisory approach needed to create a more robust banking system for the future. The Turner Review3, published in March 2009, made a 1 The Treasury Select Committee is a Parliamentary (House of Commons) committee that scrutinises the activity of the regulatory authorities in the UK. 2 See House of Commons Treasury Committee, The Run on the Rock HC 56-1 (Fifth Report of Session 2007-08). 3 FSA, ‘The Turner Review, A regulatory response to the global banking crisis’ (March 2009) at http://www.fsa.gov.uk/Pages/Library/Corporate/turner/index...

Words: 25821 - Pages: 104

Premium Essay

Theory & Practice of Regulation of Anti-Money Laundering for Banks & Nonbanks

...HND h.k.annor@gmail.com Abstract A deregulated financial sector is free to accumulate and allocate funds from anywhere irrespective of the nature, form, intent and source. Without regulatory oversight, this poses zero risk to banks and nonbanks no matter how they finance the capital structure. In the real world, banking is an outcome of interactions between the regulator and the regulated. Regulatory consequences apply for failure to comply with the acceptable standards of best practices of banking regulation which include fines, sanctions, jail terms and revocation of the banking license for willful or non-willful noncompliance. The physical disposal of proceeds of funds’ from crime with aim of separating same, through creation of layers to disguise trails of the source and make it seem legitimate undermines the integrity of the financial system. It is required of the banking sector to build a comprehensive framework that identifies, assesses, monitors, mitigates and reports perceptions of suspicious activities of money launderers under the discipline of the regulator to avoid being sanction for the related offences. This paper reviews theory to link practice towards money laundering risk assessment of banking customers to maintain the integrity of the financial sector. 2 Introduction In a deregulated financial economy without transaction costs and costless enforceable contracts, the choice between the financial market instruments and products the institutions...

Words: 4377 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Banking

...1. Introduction to banking sector Whenever you think of Banks what comes to your mind? Your salary account, your savings account or if you are a businessman your current account. Maybe you are also thinking about loans you took from a bank – your home loan, your car loan or your personal loan. But, did you ever pause to think how does this industry actually work – What is the structure of the Indian Banking Industry? What is its business model? How does a bank make money? What is its future outlook? Let us demystify it. The Banking industry plays a dynamic role in the economic development of a country. The growth story of an economy depends on the robustness of its banking industry. Banks act as the store as well as the power house of the country’s wealth. They accept deposits from individuals and corporate and lends to the businesses. They use the deposits collected for productive purposes which help in the capital formation in the country. Today, the Indian Banking System is known the world over for its robustness. The Reserve Bank of India is the central/apex Bank which regulates the functioning of all banks operating within the country. The banking system, largely, comprises of scheduled banks (banks that are listed under the Second Schedule of the RBI Act, 1934). Unscheduled banks form a very small component (function in the form of Local Area Bank). Scheduled banks are further classified into commercial and cooperative banks, with the basic difference in their holding...

Words: 602 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Basel Corporate Governance and How It Will Affect Banks in the United States

...There has been no shortage of news regarding banking scandals and crises over the past three decades both globally and in the United States. This increased awareness has led to the focus upon legislation to stem this trend in addition to creating guidelines for how financial reporting should regulated in order to stabilize the banking industry. Part of this effort has been led by the Basel Committee in its creation of its Core Principles for Effective Banking Supervision consultative document that was released in December 2011. The committee consisting bankers and regulators from its 27 member countries provides a framework for establishing bank governance. The United States, even though a member of the Basel Committee, had previously resisted implementing this framework, instead favoring its own legislation. However, the Federal Reserve agreed to adopt the Basel rules as means of governing the nation's banks against the objections of large financial institutions who argued that these guidelines are too strict. As of May 2012, the proposal of this agreement has not yet been released by the Federal Reserve. It is hoped that the endorsement from the United States of the new requirements under Basel III will work to encourage the European Union to follow suit. Banking Supervision Unlike many of the other countries that follow the Basel framework and have only one bank regulator, the United States banking system is governed by the Federal Reserve. The Federal Reserve consists of...

Words: 2223 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Charles Schwab

...Charles Schwab Corporation should take over the next ten years. To answer this question, an analysis of where Schwab and the financial industry are right now. In addition, it will examine what social and technological trends are shaping the way financial industry might be heading in the future. Lastly, it will recommend the direction the Schwab organization should take over the next 10 years. Introduction The Charles Schwab Corporation (NYSE: SCHW) is a leading provider of financial services, with more than 300 offices and 8.9 million active brokerage accounts, 1.6 million corporate retirement plan participants, 895,000 banking accounts, and $2.11 trillion in client assets as of April 30, 2013 (Krieger, 2013). Through its operating subsidiaries, the company provides a full range of securities brokerage, banking, money management and financial advisory services to individual investors and independent investment advisors. Its broker-dealer subsidiary, Charles Schwab & Co., Inc. (member SIPC, www.sipc.org), and affiliates offer a complete range of investment services and products including an extensive selection of mutual funds; financial planning and investment advice; retirement plan and equity compensation plan services; compliance and trade monitoring solutions; referrals to independent fee-based investment advisors; and custodial, operational and trading support for independent, fee-based investment advisors through Schwab Advisor Services. Its banking subsidiary, Charles Schwab...

Words: 2626 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Shadow Banking

...Term paper of Ef4461 Topic : Shadow Banking in China Created by Pan Date: 24/4/2015 Abstract: In this paper , I will examine the China’s shadow banking for its potential risks. China, an expansion of risky and complicated financial practices in the world’s second-largest economy , what is the potential risk behind? Introduction: From Bloomberg, the definition of“shadow banking” encompasses risky investment products, lending between individuals, pawnshop and loan-shark operations in emerging markets, as well as more respectable activities like derivatives, money-market funds, securities lending and repurchase agreements at financial institutions These activities are beyond the control regular banking system and regulators. Therefore are exempt from the limited regulations and oversight placed on the traditional banking sector. So it is hard to restrict risky lending for the regulators. In china, savings deposit rates of 3 percent which is lower than the target for inflation, combined with at least 90% of small businesses could not get bank loans which propelled the shadow-banking sector to an estimated $6 trillion. Overview of shadow banking in the world and China There are $75 trillion global shadow banking assets worldwide in 2013 according to Financial Stability Board Report,(Appendix 2). After 2008 crisis, The U.S. and the euro area each accounted for a global shadow banking assets, followed by Britain with a 12 percent share and Japan’s 5 percent share(Appendix3)...

Words: 2498 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Evaluating Basel

...(2014042) Bakul Malik (2014072) Gurusha Godwani (2014100) Ketki Chaturvedi (2014133) CHAPTER 1 BANK CAPITAL MANAGEMENT- CAPITAL ADEQUACY FRAMEWORK INTRODUCTION Bank capital is often defined in tiers or categories that include shareholders' equity, retained earnings, reserves, hybrid capital instruments, and subordinated term debt. Capital ratios are commonly measured as a percent of bank assets or risk-weighted bank assets. Bank capital serves as an important cushion against unexpected losses. It creates a strong incentive to manage a bank in a prudent manner, because the bank owners’ equity is at risk in the event of a failure. Thus, bank capital plays a critical role in the safety and soundness of individual banks and the banking system. Role of bank capital: • Source of funds – Start-up costs – Growth or expansion (mergers and acquisitions) – Modernization costs • Cushion to absorb unexpected operating losses – Insufficient capital to absorb losses will cause insolvency – Long-term debt can only absorb losses in the event of institution failure • Adequate capital – Regulatory requirements to promote bank safety and soundness – Mitigate moral hazard problems of deposit insurance by increasing shareholders’ exposure to bank operating losses – Market confidence is important to depositors and other bank claimants Capital Adequacy Capital Adequacy is the minimum amount of capital that a bank must hold to function effectively. It is a measure...

Words: 10400 - Pages: 42

Free Essay

Rbi Functions

...Reserve Bank of India RESERVE BANK OF INDIA www.rbi.org.in ž¸¸£·¸ú¡¸ ¹£ö¸¨¸Ä ¤Îˆ RBI Central Office Building, Mumbai RESERVE BANK OF INDIA www.rbi.org.in ž¸¸£·¸ú¡¸ ¹£ö¸¨¸Ä ¤Îˆ 2 Contents Overview: Who We Are � Celebrating Our Platinum Jubilee � The Reserve Bank: Tradition and Change � Celebrating 75 years: Highlights Organisation and Structure: How We Operate � Management and Structure Main Activities: What We Do � Monetary Authority � Issuer of Currency � Banker and Debt Manager to Government � Banker to Banks � Regulator of the Banking System � Manager of Foreign Exchange � Regulator and Supervisor of the Payment and Settlement Systems � Developmental Role Research, Data and Knowledge Sharing: How We Communicate � Communicating with the Public � RBI Publications Addressing Current and Future Challenges Customer Service: How Can We Help You? 3 4 5 6 8 9 11 12 15 18 20 22 24 26 28 31 32 33 34 36 Overview: Who We Are The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) is the nation’s central bank Since 1935, when we began operations, we have stood at the centre of India’s financial system, with a fundamental commitment to maintaining the nation’s monetary and financial stability. 3 From ensuring stability of interest and exchange rates to providing liquidity and an adequate supply of currency and credit for the real sector; from ensuring bank penetration and safety of depositors’ funds to promoting and developing financial institutions and markets, the...

Words: 6885 - Pages: 28

Premium Essay

Present Education System

...SHORT COMINGS OF PRESENT EDUCATION SYSTEM AND HOW TO MAKE IT EMPLOYMENT ORIENTED Col HR Ruhil (Retd) Singhania University Introduction The aim of any education system is to provide inclusive quality education and learning opportunities for all which ensures that a learner is eventually transformed into a good human being imbibed with moral and ethical values and is equipped with adequate employment skills (self employment or job). In addition, the individual attains good communication skills imbibed with logical reasoning power and analytical powers so that his intellectual ability is not confined to his own field but can be used in any situation and in any field. Thus as useful member of society, this passout student is ready to contribute...

Words: 1774 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Acts and the Financial Crisis

...ROOTS OF A FINANCIAL CRISIS Most companies are currently faced with specific challenges, questions and concerns that are caused by today's uncertain economic environment. In times of market instability, there is an increased potential for management fraud as unexpected losses and financing difficulties create pressure on those who are concerned about the financial performance and solvency of their business. Decisions made in the past due to financial crises are constantly being reconsidered and old certainties questioned. Accounting has been evolving with the development of advancements and setbacks of society. The SEC has to constantly reevaluate their accounting policies due to past events and changes from various economic and financial crises. The complexities and debates that arise from the causes of a financial crisis result in revisions to accounting regulations and standards that seem to be quickly implemented in order to prevent future disasters. THE SECURITIES ACTS OF 1933 AND 1934 The Securities Act was Congress' opening shot in the war on securities fraud with Congress primarily targeting the issuers of securities. Companies which issue securities (issuers) seek to raise money to fund new projects or investments or to expand; thus, companies have an incentive to present the company and its plans in the rosiest light possible. The Securities Act serves the dual purpose of ensuring that issuers selling securities to the public disclose material information to investors...

Words: 1538 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Banking Features of Australia and Canada

...the common features of the banking systems in Australia and Canada. Then I will compare their banking systems in structure and regulation with United States. Finally, the different ways mortgage lending is conducted in these three countries will be emphasized. Common features The common features of the banking systems of Australia and Canada are embodied in the high concentrated banking system along with intensive supervision and sound regulation. It is the common features that contribute to the resilient performance in these two countries’ banks through the global financial crisis. Generally speaking, the whole banking sector in either Canada or Australia is monopolized by a few large-scaled national banks. In Australia, there are mainly four banks, Commonwealth Bank, Westpac Banking Corporation, Australia and New Zealand Banking Group and National Australia Bank, which dominate Australian banking market. They are individually and collectively huge compared with the size of banking system and their total assets are vast compared with GDP. These four banks occupy 75% of the total banking assets and 80% of the residential mortgage market (Jang & Sheridan 2012, p3). Also, due to there are no mergers and acquisitions between top four banks, the major financial institutions tend to have good profitability and rarely pursuit to develop “high-risk high-yield” financial products. As for Canada, there are big five banks that oligopoly banking markets: Royal Bank...

Words: 3294 - Pages: 14