Premium Essay

How Should We Study the Mind?

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By kalerb
Words 316
Pages 2
How should we study the mind?

In Precursors to Cognitive Psychology we saw that psychologists adopted a number of methodologies throughout the late nineteenth century and the twentieth century, including focusing only on observable behaviour. One early methodology was introspection, which was used to study the elements of perception, although this ran into difficulties. However, for higher-level cognitive processes such as decision making and voluntary behaviour, many social scientists continue to ask people about the reasons for their own behaviour. In a key paper published in 1977, and titled Telling more than we can know: Verbal reports on mental processes, Richard Nisbett and Timothy Wilson reviewed several studies that appeared to show that people are sometimes unaware of the reasons underlying their own behaviour.

In one study, Nisbett and Wilson observed consumers choosing between identical packs of nylon stockings arranged in a row. They found that people were biased towards choosing from the right side of the array but, when asked about their choice, people did not refer to the position of the stockings in the array. When specifically asked whether they might have been affected by the position of the item, almost everybody denied this. Based on this and the results of many other studies, Nisbett and Wilson concluded that people's explanations of their own behaviours were not based on having access to the underlying cognitive processes, but rather were theories about the causes of those behaviours. In other words, people may be aware of the products of their cognitive processes but are not aware of those processes themselves.

Introspections may not always be wrong, but Nisbett and Wilson's analysis indicates that they are not a reliable guide to the causes of behaviour. They may be useful in generating hypotheses, but these should then be subject to

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Human Development

...Development; Child Psychology Child Psychology is concerned with the mentality and actions of children from a very tender age and through their youth as they prepare for adulthood. According to Cherry in her article, this covers mind development that is reflected in physical reactions either socially or emotionally. Initially, children were perceived as mere representatives of adults but at a smaller scale both in term of age and reasoning capacity. This theory perceives them as being sample representative of adults which means they may contain all or smaller traits in characteristics or in terms of behavior. I beg to differ because physical brain structure is totally different from psychology which involves reaction of the brain based on how it is programmed to react to a varied number of stimuli. According to Jean Piaget, children do act differently from adults and Albert Einstein concurred with the simplicity of the statement. Child psychology is universally agreed to be complex by experts and psychologies and yet they also differ in a wide variety of approaches they use to study the phenomenon. Development of the child is normally perceived from the internal aspects like genes and hereditary personality and analysts alongside other interested parties should consider external aspects such as social, cultural and socioeconomic contexts (Cherry). Social context refers to human interaction and that is the main source of behavioral adaptation through the five senses. Children tend...

Words: 1249 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Essay

...Chapter 1—What Is Psychology? Learning Goals 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Explain what psychology is and how it developed. Describe six contemporary approaches to psychology. Describe two movements that reflect a positive approach to psychology. Evaluate careers and areas of specialization in psychology. Apply some strategies that will help you succeed in psychology. After studying Chapter 1, you will be able to: Define psychology. Describe the influence that philosophy, biology, and physiology had on the beginnings of psychology as a science. Compare the two early scientific approaches in psychology: structuralism and functionalism. Describe the focus of each of the six contemporary approaches to psychology. Describe the positive psychology movement, and discuss why this movement recently emerged in psychology. Discuss career opportunities in psychology. Profile the main areas of specialization in psychology. Say how studying habits may be optimized. Understand how to be a critical thinker. CHAPTER 1: OUTLINE Psychology is a science dedicated to the study of behavior and mental processes. In this chapter you are introduced to the history of this science, a variety of contemporary perspectives in psychology, the positive psychology movement, and an overview of psychology-related careers. At the end of the chapter, the reader learns about the most effective methods of studying and learning. There are three concepts important to the definition of psychology: science, behavior, and mental...

Words: 11126 - Pages: 45

Premium Essay

Book

...Research 1 Why Make Assumptions? How Did Philosophers and Early Psychologists Study the Mind? ■ ■ ■ ■ Philosophical Underpinnings The Beginnings of Modern Psychology The Response: Behaviorism Behaviorism’s Success How Do Cognitive Psychologists Study the Mind? ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ ■ What Behaviorism Couldn’t Do Failures of Behaviorism to Account for Human Behavior The Computer Metaphor and Information Processing The Behaviorist Response Abstract Constructs in Other Fields So What, Finally, Is the Cognitive Perspective? ISBN: 0-536-25527-X Cognition: The Thinking Animal, Third Edition, by Daniel T. Willingham. Published by Pearson Prentice Hall. Copyright © 2007 by Pearson Education, Inc. 2 Chapter 1 Have you ever wondered how we see or how we remember things? Have you ever contemplated the strange nature of attention? I didn’t think so. Most of the people I know do contemplate how the mind works, but only when their mind lets them down. They contemplate memory (“Why can’t I find my keys?”), attention (“I want to find my keys, so why can’t I concentrate?”), and vision (“How could I not see my keys when they were right in front of me the whole time?”). Questions such as “How does vision work?” seem somewhat interesting, but no more interesting than thousands of other questions. It’s like someone asking you whether you want to know about the history of guitar making. “I don’t know; maybe. Is it interesting?” Truthfully, “How does vision work?” is a bad question...

Words: 15470 - Pages: 62

Premium Essay

Psychology

...Chapter 1—What Is Psychology? Learning Goals 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Explain what psychology is and how it developed. Describe six contemporary approaches to psychology. Describe two movements that reflect a positive approach to psychology. Evaluate careers and areas of specialization in psychology. Apply some strategies that will help you succeed in psychology. After studying Chapter 1, you will be able to: Define psychology. Describe the influence that philosophy, biology, and physiology had on the beginnings of psychology as a science. Compare the two early scientific approaches in psychology: structuralism and functionalism. Describe the focus of each of the six contemporary approaches to psychology. Describe the positive psychology movement, and discuss why this movement recently emerged in psychology. Discuss career opportunities in psychology. Profile the main areas of specialization in psychology. Say how studying habits may be optimized. Understand how to be a critical thinker. CHAPTER 1: OUTLINE Psychology is a science dedicated to the study of behavior and mental processes. In this chapter you are introduced to the history of this science, a variety of contemporary perspectives in psychology, the positive psychology movement, and an overview of psychology-related careers. At the end of the chapter, the reader learns about the most effective methods of studying and learning. There are three concepts important to the definition of psychology:...

Words: 11126 - Pages: 45

Premium Essay

Private Sectors and Public Private Sectors to Improve the Entrepreneurial Mindset in Young Jamaicans?

...Northern Caribbean University College of Business and Hospitality Management Chapter 1 Assignment Presented in Partial Fulfilment Of the Requirements for the Course Business Research Method: BSAD Andrew Chin: 18100460 Petekaye Clarke: 11100138 Ellsworth Dixon: 26120390 Hervel Walker: 11100193 Dana Sinclair: 11090085 Denique Mitchel: 11100136 September 29, 2014 Northern Caribbean University College of Business and Hospitality Management Chapter 1 Assignment Presented in Partial Fulfilment Of the Requirements for the Course Business Research Method: BSAD Andrew Chin: 18100460 Petekaye Clarke: 11100138 Ellsworth Dixon: 26120390 Hervel Walker: 11100193 Dana Sinclair: 11090085 Denique Mitchel: 11100136 September 29, 2014 Abstract WHAT ARE POSSIBLE ARE POSSIBLE AVENUES THAT CAN BE TAKEN BY THE GOVERNMENT, PRIVATE SECTORS AND PUBLIC PRIVATE SECTORS TO IMPROVE THE ENTREPRENEURIAL MINDSET IN YOUNG JAMAICANS? By: Andrew Chin: 18100460 Petekaye Clarke: 11100138 Ellsworth Dixon: 26120390 Dana Sinclair: 11090085 Denique Mitchell: 11100168 Hervel Walker: 11100193 Advisor: Dr. Sachin Pilli ABSTRACT OF BUSINESS RESEARCH METHODS CLASS Research Paper Northern...

Words: 1378 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Phil 201

...Individual Project 2 Thursday, April 16, 2015 Metaphysics Study of Existence What's out there? Epistemology Study of Knowledge How do I know about it? Ethics Study of Action What should I do? Politics Study of Force What actions are permissible? Esthetics Study of Art What can life be like? Metaphysics: ◦What is real? What is real in life is what you make your life out to be yourself. Real is hugging your children and having the person that you love telling you that they love you for life? Real is the pain that you feel when you lose your brother and greave. You do not know if you will ever see this person again because you don’t know if there is a spirit world. ◦Is the physical world more or less real than the spiritual or psychological world? It’s hard to explain if the spiritual world or the psychological world are real or if it is just something that we have been lead to believe so we have spent years rolling over and over in our minds and made ourselves believe that it is real. From the time we are babies we are lead to believe that there is a heaven and angels and such. We are lead to believe in Santa and the tooth fairy and the Easter bunny, but who is to say that any of that is real except what we believe in our own minds and hearts. ◦Is there such a thing as a soul? If so, how does it survive outside of a physical body? I want to believe that there is such a thing as when we are buried that we have a soul that lives on in a beautiful place. I have a really...

Words: 1653 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Introduction to Economics

...role in various fields of our life. Most of us may feel that we are familiar with economics, but we seldom think about what economics is and how we can apply it into our future life. These two questions are going to be covered in this essay. 1. What is economics? The definition of economicsWhy should your students consider studying economics at degree level? The Economics Network's website (whystudyeconomics.ac.uk) attempts to answer this question, guiding A-level students through the difficult decision of choosing a degree course and encouraging students who might otherwise not consider a degree in economics that it is a worthwhile subject. It also provides information to students and parents. This year the website has been relaunched with a brand new look. But why should students consider economics and what can they expect? [PUBLICATION ABSTRACT] As a new science, economics has been interpreted by professional economists in different ways. However, the definition of economics in Alfred Marshall’s textbook is as widely accepted today as it was in 1890, when the first edition of Principles of Economics was published. As Marshall (1961, p. 1) indicated, ‘Economics is a study of mankind in the ordinary business of life; it examines that part of individual and social action which is most closely connected with the attainment and with the use of the material requisites of wellbeing’. Economics is not only the study of business phenomenon or rules, but more important in the human...

Words: 1670 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

History of Psychology

...UNIT 1: THE DEFINITION AND HISTORY OF PSYCHOLOGY QUESTION #1.1: What is the definition of psychology? Psychology is best defined as the "scientific study of behavior in humans and animals." Behavior is what people and animals do: e.g., what a person says about last night's dream, and how long it takes a rat to run a maze. You might think that psychology was the "study of the mind" due to the fact that the prefix psyche is Greek for mind, soul, spirit, and the suffix ology refers to the study of something. Almost a hundred years ago, John Watson decided that psychology should be a science: not just a vague and introspective reflection on our own thoughts and feelings. Watson urged that psychology be defined as the scientific study of behavior. Since about 1920, most university psychologists have accepted Watson's definition. So, think of psychologists as scientists who study behavior. Introspection was the first technique for studying the mind There are some terms related to psychology that are frequently confused with it. Psychiatry is a branch of medicine specializing with mental disorders. Psychiatrists are medical doctors, and have been through medical school, an internship, residency training, and board certification as specialized physicians. The letters M.D. usually appear at the end of the name. The letters at the end of the name of a psychologist may be 1 Ph.D., Ed.D., or Psy.D., and so it may be appropriate to address a psychologist as...

Words: 4382 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Children's Theoretical Perspective on the Theory of Mind and False Belief on Social Cognition

...Children’s Theoretical Perspective on the Theory of Mind and False Beliefs on Social Cognition Questions seeking an answer to a missing piece, puzzled with things unknown, and bothering twisted thoughts. These are primordial stuff experienced by an individual leading to curiosity. Curiosity which makes every person motivated in finding an answers. The fact that curiosity about a matter will always be the starting point of a new development. One of the best examples is the children. As we can see, children are the most determine explorer because for them everything is a mystery. To discover simple unfamiliar objects, to meliorate their knowledge and to understand their environment are their major goals which we can identify as mediocre. The genuine truth about children is their capacity to understand someone even though they have minimal knowledge on how mental life processes goes through. They can easily figure it out when someone is motivated in acquiring their wants or goals. As a matter of fact, sometimes they can also distinguish what are the positive and negative emotions. On the other hand, they can also practice their false beliefs where they can hardly define between what is real and what is true. Furthermore, as we adults, we are more matured enough in thinking and behaving in all matter. We have the responsibility to modify what we perceive and to justify and stand on what we believe is right and wrong. Nevertheless, people talk too much; people think...

Words: 4765 - Pages: 20

Premium Essay

Silence by Jd Shuduku

...Dr. Chan Thrs 231 Jannie Or Paper1 I disagree that the best way to study religion is learning from a page from the World Almanac. The information is not accurate and not adequate when comparing the world non-Christian on a few paragraph. First, Among all those ambiguous religion questions, one of them is very difficult to answer- who is the founder of the religion? According to the informative paper: "Founder of Hinduism--The Aryan invaders" which actually in the modern history people consider that there is no single founder. However, the religion is originally established by God Himself (dharman tu sakshad bhagavat pranitam) which claimed by the ancient scriptures of India; as well, "Islam's founder is Muhammad" who is known as rasul Allah, or God's Messenger to the Arabs, and to all of humanity. In my opinion, it is very difficult to specified the founder of religion into a particular person. The sacred text is difficult to conclude in some religion. For example, Buddhism's "sacred text is the Tripitaka" however, Buddhism's sacred text might include not only The Tripitaka, the Mahayana Sutras, and the Tibetan Book of the Dead. I need to think the reason why only list The Tripitaka as Buddhism's sacred text might be it is because The Tripitaka is the most important one. Another problem is how to classified the most influential sacred text, the information is not very precisely stated. For example, the sacred text of Hinduism can...

Words: 1981 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Defining the Humanities

...Defining Humanities: The humanities are the stories, the ideas, and the words that help us make sense of our lives and our world. The humanities introduce us to people we have never met, places we have never visited, and ideas that may have never crossed our minds. By showing how others have lived and thought about life, the humanities help us decide what is important in our own lives and what we can do to make them better. By connecting us with other people, they point the way to answers about what is right or wrong, or what is true to our heritage and our history. The humanities help us address the challenges we face together in our families, our communities, and as a nation. Academically, we refer to the humanities as the study of arts – the visual arts such as architecture, painting and sculpture; music; dance; the theater or drama; and literature. They are the branches of learning concerned with the human thought, feelings and relations. The study of arts is the study of mankind. Humanities, being the study of arts, have always been concern with the importance of human being, his feelings, and how he expresses those feelings. However, it should be stressed that the humanities emphasize analysis and exchange of ideas rather than the creative expression of the arts or the quantitative explanation of the sciences. Significance of the Humanities Art is very important in our lives. It constitutes one of the oldest form and most important means of expression developed...

Words: 617 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Health and Children

... Physical and mental health of children and adolescents are becoming extremely important to many people, without the attention given to this matter we wouldn’t be benefiting the children right now who will one day be in charge taking our place. In this report we will look at what importance’s physical activity can have and what surroundings are affecting children’s physical and mental health. There are a variety of things that affect the health of children. One of my studies I found that different types of advertising greatly affect the physical health of children. Soda advertisements are greatly affecting children in highly populated neighborhoods (Lenard, et al. 15). The children don’t realize that the things that they are consuming at a young age can have serious effects on them as they grow older. Sleep deprivation is something else that can greatly effecting children. This lack of sleep isn’t coming from the children though, it is coming from the parents. Parent’s lack of sleep is affecting their moods and they may be taking out their frustrations either physically, mentally, or emotionally on their children (Chapman, et al. 33). There are many more ways that children’s health is being affected and everyone needs to be aware of what these things may be. Although some of these things may seem very harmless to us we need to know that they are greatly affecting the youth in our world. I searched through the ISU main library’s ProQuest database, I have searched these...

Words: 2173 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

The Behaviorist Approach

...a child is more important that the nature of the child. Psychology approaches the fact that behaviour is more learnt from the environment than it is just born it to you. For example, you learnt that you have to get dressed every morning and not go out the house with nothing on as it is illegal. That is not born into you; you have to be taught it. However depending on the environment you are brought up in, psychologists say, depends on what you learnt and how you behave. The more you learn the less likely you are to commit a crime and the more likely you are to teach your own children that they should behave in life. The case study for The Batista Boys is an example of how nurture for children can be more powerful than nature. All 18 boys in the family had a condition where they were born appearing to be female. All of them were raised as females and it wasn’t until they hit puberty than the whole family knew any different. The boys all were raised as girls and they acted feminine until they found out the truth. This case study could prove that nature can be overruled by nature and that it is a lot more powerful than it seems. Psychologists, such as Pavlov, believe that animals can learn from classical conditioning in the environment. Pavlov classically conditioned his dog to salivate when he heard the sound of a bell. He did this as followed, He used a neutral stimulus, the bell which before the experiment had no response and when he presented his dog with food and the dog would...

Words: 1046 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Foundation of Psychology

...Rosarminda Aguilar Abstract Psychology is a scientific study that all investigate of the human mind, body and over matter in many different fields of psychology to understand and conduct observations on the mental process of the human mind and behavior. It is used to define the mysteries of the human behavior, such as expressions on how people feel and observe actions. The study of the mind is to observe both conscious and unconscious states. Every day we live, breathe, walk, talk, think, and experience in our lives. All of us have so many thoughts and ideas that build up with time which can create issues within ourselves if we don’t vent it out. Psychology studies the brain and mental behaviors. “If we want to understand the mind and behavior, we should investigate it scientifically, just as physicists study the nature of light or gravity, through systematic observation and experimentation” (Kowalski & Westen, 2011). There are theories within psychology that have influenced our knowledge such as structuralism, functionalism, behaviorism, psychoanalysis, cognitive, and evolutionary. The first school of psychology was Structuralism which focused in studying down the mental process and its basic components. There were two major structuralist thinkers include Wilhelm Wundt and Edward Titchener. They used techniques such as introspection to analyze the inner process of the human mind. Functionalism was influenced by William James. Two major functionalist...

Words: 672 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Philosophy

...fundamental truths about themselves, the world in which they live, and their relationships to the world and to each other. As an academic discipline philosophy is much the same. Those who study philosophy are perpetually engaged in asking, answering, and arguing for their answers to life’s most basic questions. To make such a pursuit more systematic academic philosophy is traditionally divided into major areas of study. Metaphysics At its core the study of metaphysics is the study of the nature of reality, of what exists in the world, what it is like, and how it is ordered. In metaphysics philosophers wrestle with such questions as: Is there a God? What is truth? What is a person? What makes a person the same through time? Is the world strictly composed of matter? Do people have minds? If so, how is the mind related to the body? Do people have free wills? What is it for one event to cause another? Epistemology Epistemology is the study of knowledge. It is primarily concerned with what we can know about the world and how we can know it. Typical questions of concern in epistemology are: What is knowledge? Do we know anything at all? How do we know what we know? Can we be justified in claiming to know certain things? Ethics The study of ethics often concerns what we ought to do and what it would be best to do. In struggling with this issue, larger questions about what is good and right arise. So, the ethicist attempts to answer such questions as: ...

Words: 557 - Pages: 3