Free Essay

Immigration

In:

Submitted By heady1099
Words 1320
Pages 6
Adopting Arizona’s Immigration Law in
All states

Does politics have the upper hand on humanity in Arizona's immigration law SB-1070. This law should be abolished because it is racist, unfair and degrading to legal and illegal Latino immigrants? Immigration has always presented a problem for America and we now find ourselves faced with the issue on a large political scale.
On July 29, 2010, the United States of America listened in as Arizona State put into effect their own immigration law. With the backing of Michigan, Alabama, Florida, Nebraska, Pennsylvania, and South Carolina Arizona has set the presence for illegal immigrants to face the law. The new law “directs officers to question people about their immigration status during the enforcement of other laws such as traffic stops, and if there's a reasonable suspicion they're in the U.S. illegally they will be deported”. “Arizona’s illegal alien population is 460,000 and according to a 2008 study by the Federation for American Immigration Reform, Georgia illegal alien population is 490,000”. (Inger Eberhart, 2010). As Americans we need to support Arizona’s efforts to clean house in fight of illegal aliens in the U.S. Most critics are saying that this is the strictest measure in generations for the detaining of illegal immigrants. The key work is “ILLEGAL”. Every American knows that if it is illegal then you should not be doing it, adolescent 101, but we live in a time where people feel that illegal aliens should not be questioned as to their citizenship as it goes against their rights. Number one they have no rights as they are not American Citizens, two if Americans would stop and think how many illegal’s who will work for pennies and are taking our jobs, and education benefits have done nothing but cost our states billions of dollars. Georgia’s cost is over $1.6 billion per year for education, health care and incarceration of illegal aliens, according to FAIR. In looking at the facts, this is not an open invitation for harassment or a poor me act, this is our states trying to protects it’s American Citizens.

Hispanics railed the law as a recipe for racial and ethnic profiling. “Governor Brewer caved to the radical fringe,” a statement by the Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund said, predicting that the law would create “a spiral of pervasive fear, community distrust, increased crime and costly litigation, with nationwide repercussions.” (Randlad C. Archibold, 2010). Answer this question “How can it be deemed as racism is you are guilty of being in our country illegally? So Hispanics are allowed to break the law but Americans are not. So the first time I do something illegal I can tell the police that they are being racist because it’s just something illegal that I done, no harm in that. There has been so much term oil over Arizona controversial immigration law so much so that our own President will not back them. “"Our failure to act responsibly at the federal level will only open the door to irresponsibility by others. And that includes, for example, the recent efforts in Arizona, which threatened to undermine basic notions of fairness that we cherish as Americans."- President Barack Obama (PBS. August 4, 2010). How can a state try and uphold the constitution and safety for its fellow Americans when the President himself will not stand behind them and uphold the law. This is not a debate over what is fair or not this is a debate about people living in the US illegally and Americans have to pay for it. Another quote used in ignorance has been "We’re scared of going outside the house; we're scared of being in certain spots now because of you know we know the police roams around. It has changed Arizona to the point where it's wrong. It's unfair and it shouldn't be like that."- Carla Urqidi, Arizona resident (PBS. August 4, 2010). If you are “scared” to go out of your home because the police are patrolling then wouldn’t that tell you that you are here illegally. There is a reason why we use the word “illegal”. Lets clear up what “illegal” means in layman's terms: not according to or authorized by law also: not sanctioned by official rules. The rules our country has in place for other items include no one under the age of 21 can drink because it would be “ILLEGAL”. What we are telling the youth of today is that we should not discriminate against those individuals who are “illegal Mexicans”; therefore we should not discriminate the age of drinking, Come on people wake up “illegal” is “illegal” I applaud Arizona’s efforts to keep their fellow Americans safe and uphold our constitution. Fences have been put up along the border in order to eliminate illegal immigrants from crossing; however Victor Guzman, supervisory Border Patrol agent who is responsible for the stretch of close together 15-foot cement-filled steel poles planted three feet into the ground have been breached by torches, hacksaws and ladders. Guzman states “We see it once or twice a week”. (Alicia A. Caldwell, April 11, 2008). Agents Border Patrols are not only worried about illegal immigrants trying to clean the fence, they are also considered about the fence itself as it is starting to settle into the ground and gaps have formed between the posts which are widening. With the posts widening, an average sixed women is able to wedge herself through. Joe Romers, border patrol spokesman said the fence was ordered before the congressional mandate to build 670 miles of pedestrian and vehicle fencing across the border with Mexico. Though detractors have argued that the fence will do little to stop determined illegal immigrants and smugglers to the United States one would assume that unless our laws in the united states are enforced no matter what they do they will continue to come across. Arizona’s immigration law was interrupted by the federal government with the judge Bolton had this ruling: “"Requiring Arizona law enforcement officials and agencies to determine the immigration status of every person who is arrested burdens lawfully present aliens because their liberty will be restricted while their status is checked," Bolton wrote. “ Americans need to listen as to why this portion of the law needs to instated. Lawyers for the state continue to fight that the law was a constitutionally sound attempt by Arizona to assist federal immigration agents and lessen border woes, such as the heavy costs for educating, jailing and providing health care for illegal immigrants.” (msnbc.com staff July 29, 2010) We live in the home of the brave and the land of the free where a constitution is upheld and values are weighed. The governor of Arizona is just doing what every state needs to do and that is clean house. and uphold the constitution and protect Americans.

David Runk, Associated Press Writer, (2010 July 15), Associated Press Retrieved Monday, August 2, 2010, from http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20100715/ap_on_re_us/us_immigration_states
Randlad C. Archibold. (April 23, 2010). Arizona Enacts Stringent Law on Immigration Retrieved Wednesdaym August 4, 2010, from http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/24/us/politics/24immig.html Inger Eberhart . (August 4, 2010) . Pro & Con: Should Georgia adopt an Arizona-style immigration law?. Retrieved Wednesday, August 4, 2010, from http://www.ajc.com/opinion/pro-con-should-georgia-585208.html PBS (August 4, 2010). Arizona Immigration Law Sparks Nationwide Controversy. Retrieved Thursday, August 25, 2010 from http://www.pbs.org/newshour/extra/video/blog/2010/08/arizona_immigration_law_sparks.html msnbc.com staff (July 29, 2010). Limited immigration law goes into force in Arizona. Retrieved August 25, 2010. from http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/38436995/
Caldwell, A (2008, April 11). Feds Say Border fence not tough enough. Fox News.com, Retrieved September 18, 2010, from http://www.foxnews.com/printer_friendly_wires/2008Apr11/0,4675,BorderFence,00.html.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Immigration

...Running head: IMMIGRATION 1 Immigration By: Ibrahim Elabani For: Cori Claus Renison University College Writing Skills Level 300 March 2nd, 2015 IMMIGRATION Immigration These days, many individuals who live in developing countries are looking to migrate to developed countries. They would like to ensure a good and safe future not only for themselves, but also for their children. Immigration to developed countries from developing countries is a widespread phenomenon currently to countries such as United States of America, Canada, and Australia. According to Dodamin and LaPorte (2005), “Better standards of living and quality of life, higher salaries, access to advanced technology and more stable political conditions in the developed countries attract talent from less developed areas” (p 487). There are several causes that lead people to leave their lands, such as unstable political issues, poor education systems, and inadequate healthcare systems. 2 Currently, political issues are a major cause of immigration. Many citizens do not have a right of free speech in their countries; for instance, Libya was controlled by a dictatorship that ruled the country for forty-two years, there were limited human rights for Libyan citizens who did not have any freedom of speech during the Gaddafi regime. In 2011 a Libyan Revolution and Civil War took place that lead to the overthrow of the previous dictatorship regime but still did not result in freedom of speech; hence, many Libyan...

Words: 708 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Immigration

...development. This has given such an impetus to international migration that it floods every corner of the world with the momentum of an avalanche. With this comes a substantial increase in the exchange of human capital between nations. Against this background, the pace of international migration keeps accelerating and the scale of it continuesto expand. However, as is often pointed out, international migration is a two-edged sword with dual effects.Nevertheless, the benefits of international migration are in excess of the economic costs. This essay will examine the brain drain and government spending on education problems for origin countries, meanwhile, unemployment problems, wage problems and social service spending for countries of immigration will also be included.(the essay’s structure) Brain drain for origin countries It is believed that international migration does harm to the human capital of origin countries, which is called brain drain.(this is the topic sentence, it is important. Becs readers can understand what you are going to talk about )Research conducted by Indian households in 2004 shows that about 40% of emigrants have obtained at least a diploma of senior high school, the percentage of which is substantially higher than that of all Indians over the age of 25(TheEconomist,2011)(this is the example.it should be closely linked topic sentence) This suggests that rather than contributing to the human capital accumulation of their countries, a portion of well-educated...

Words: 1930 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Immigration

...1. "Allowing more immigration of refugees would be good both for refugees and for the economies they come to." Discuss. Allowing more immigrants would benefit the refuge as it allows them to start earning an income through work, also this allows them to live with benefits such as free healthcare and easy access to free water and food. This all gives the immigrant a better life than what they would have in their home country, however there are negatives for the immigrants could be they are exploited for cheap labour as they are more willing to take a cheaper wage as it would still be more than what they would earn at home. For a business productivity would improve for the businesses which would then lead to the economy being able to produce more as a result of an increase in the supply. However, the economy may be negatively affected by immigrants because the immigrants will be unskilled and not be able to meet technically required jobs so the business will have to retrain the immigrant to meet requirements needed for jobs. Allowing refugees would benefit refugees as it allows them to start earning an income and potentially escape poverty from eastern European countries, this is important for a refugee as it gives them a wage which allows them to be able to live in safe conditions with easy access to food and water which might not be easy to come by in their home countries such as Syria, where warfare is a threat to civilians. To continue the wage they earn will be more...

Words: 1269 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Immigration

...As Canada’s immigrant population grows and diversifies, the challenges facing that sector of the population expand as well. More and more immigrant families move here to start better lives and lifestyles usually through better employment opportunities. This paper will examine some of the continuing obstacles that newcomers face. Immigrant families and immigrants in Canada have a difficult time entering the labour market notwithstanding exemplary educational credentials and extensive professional work experience. These are the result of prioritizing Canadian education and experience, which conceal elements of racism. The consequences are that invisible barriers are put into place; they deny fair access to work and limit the advancement of newcomers socially and economically. Many third-world immigrants to Canada must qualify for entry by demonstrating academic proficiencies and accreditations, which include post-secondary degrees or more. They are well-educated people with professional skills in areas the Canadian economy needs support. Immigrants are eager to continue their careers but soon find a need to reinvent themselves (Omidvar). This is something of a catch-22: their extant educations are what confirm their desirability as immigrants yet Canada employers fail to recognize or accredit foreign educations with any sense of equivalency. Except in rare cases, like the university professoriate or countries like Great Britain or the United States, the extent of an applicant’s...

Words: 1933 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Immigration

...MIGRATORY POPULATION----IS IT A BOON OR A SIN? Singapore is a country where people of different culture and races, ethnicity comes and goes out just as the migratory birds shifts its shelter as per the weather changes. Recently many debates have been made by the politicians and infact created agitation among the citizens who are deeply rooted with their strong emotions and life over here. Now the question is why such agitation or cold war is going on in the hearts of local residents. Secondly, how to control the immigrants issue either stopping it completely or controlling it? Thirdly, what are the possible pros and cons of such particular measures? Lastly, figure out effective and sustained strategic model that will help in ensuring sustained and safe future of Singaporeans. Migration Moving from one place to another in any aspect such as livelihood, food or shelter. It is not as simple as birds that migrate when it is between countries and humans it becomes a little more complex than it appears. Let we think deeply why such migration or relocation becomes an issue? We can derive with many answers in terms of competition for food, shelter, job etc. It tells that when struggle arises for the basic amenities it becomes worsen. However, the relocation or resettlement occurs due to enjoy a betterment of life than what they already had but in current scenario rather it developed into a issue that most of the countries on this universe is facing off. Krugman (1991) highlights...

Words: 849 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Immigration

...Immigration law should not be restricted America is not gold! Over a million immigrants come to the U.S each year (I.C.E 2007). The U.S has become an attractive zone for immigrants worldwide, and many people wonder why immigrants migrate to the U.S. People migrate to the U.S for different reasons; one of the main reasons why people migrate is family reunification (Deparle2). They don’t migrate because it has tall buildings and big cities, but because of problems back in their countries such as, lack of money, lack of freedom of religion, and because of unstable political condition. Subsequently, immigrants to the United States collaborate to the development of the nation in many ways. They do unwanted jobs and pay taxes. One reason why immigration seems so potent is that, it increased unexpectedly (Depaele3). The United State is the leading country with more immigrants. It has estimated that there are 241milliom migrants across the globe, an increase of about 37% in two decades, with many of them coming from North America (Deparle3). According to recent statistics, over a million immigrants in the United obtain legal permanent residence each year (I.C.E2007). Since the liberalization of immigration policy was passed in 1969, the number of immigrants in the country increased highly, from 9.6 million in 1970 to 38million in 2007. 1,046,539 million people were naturalized as U.S citizens 2008(I.C.E2007). The leading emigrating countries were Mexico, India and Philippines...

Words: 1405 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Immigration

...Le Moyne College Renea Scott Sociology: Immigration 12 December 2012 President Barack Obama once stated “"We are the first nation to be founded for the sake of an idea—the idea that each of us deserves the chance to shape our own destiny. That’s why centuries of pioneers and immigrants have risked everything to come here .The future is ours to win. But to get there, we cannot stand still." This quote literally and symbolically embodies the dream that America has sold and many have bought. America’s democratic ideals for centuries have placed an emphasis on the unalienable right of every individual to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. However, this dream has led to mass immigration, which is at the center of many of America’s political, social and economic problems. Similar to the past, Legislators have failed in creating a policy that would not only accommodate immigrants but provides stability and security to its citizens. Congress’s inability to provide tangible paths to legalization is an issue that paves the way for the increase in illegal immigrants. The immigration process serves as a detriment for many foreigners that seek to attain legal entry and status. It violates America’s valued premises by preventing foreigners from pursuing happiness. The process of attaining legal status in the United States has proven to be harsh and extremely bureaucratic, which makes access illegal more viable. The legal status process requires a petition, which is submitted...

Words: 2092 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Immigration

...Joey Dorion American Immigration II Professor McEvoy Paper 1 The United States has long held the title of a “land of immigrants,” a place where the downtrodden and rejected peoples of the old world could come to ply their trade, to attempt to carve out a meaningful existence for themselves. The American Dream was alive and well in the early waves of immigrants, as they came from the desired parts of Europe: namely England and Western Europe. They came with fire in their spirit, and determination to make a better life for themselves than they were able to have back in the Old World. They adapted, they assimilated, and they were able to become functioning and respected members of American society. It wasn’t until the second waves of immigrants arrived that a major opposition was formed, as fear of the foreigner spurred “old” immigrants and the “old” families of the northeast to preserve their ideals. It was with a deliberate and systematic approach that legislation was passed between the years of 1882 and 1929, keeping out those less than desired groups: Italians, Chinese, those from southwestern Europe. The White Anglo-Saxon Protestant preference was alive and out in the open in the American public, and all other policymaking went towards limiting only those who were thought not to possess the potential to become the epitome of the American citizen. The history of American immigration is one that is littered with racism, and more often than not blatant...

Words: 1994 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Immigration

...Immigration July 15, 2016 I agree with many of your points, you have addressed some vital points. I myself an immigrant, but I don’t think bringing refugees or immigrants is not always a healthy decision for nation’s economy. From economic point, how this refugee or immigrant enhance GDP when he or she doesn’t even speak a single English word. I see all the Regina Open Door, Saskatoon Open Door or newcomer centre across the country are filled with new refugees who can barely communicate. Not knowing English is not a fault, but for teaching them basic English government (especially federal government) have to spend millions of dollars, moreover they are receiving fund about $1000-$1400 (depend no. of family members) from Citizenship and Immigration Canada (CIC). There are many potential students in Canada who can’t even afford to go to University or colleges. Many high school or elementary school students living in pathetic situation; many of them have to stand in the line at Salvation Army or Regina Food Bank for food instead of going to school. A nation is obliged to feed its citizen first. Beside these organizations like Regina Open Door, Saskatoon Open Door are highly subsidized or almost completely funded by Government. Why government should spend millions of dollars on those who didn’t even spend a single penny on country’s GDP yet, while lots of people, especially in reserve, are striving for food, malnutrition and living in unhealthy environment. Lets a take a deeper...

Words: 576 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Immigration

...Immigration of people into the United States has been an important part of American culture since before our country was formed. Our country has been built in many ways by the work of many people who came to this country from other lands. However, some people worry that too many people are immigrating to our country. Too many immigrants are taking jobs away from people who live in our country. They also say that immigrants use too many of our country’s resources such as social services and medical care without paying for them through taxes. I believe that the benefits of immigration outweigh the costs that it brings to our country. One of the benefits of immigration is that immigrants take on jobs that many citizens do not want because they do not pay as much or are considered to be low class. Having immigrants fill up these jobs lighten the load of producers and consumers, and results in gains in economic welfare. It is a fact that immigrants are a source of low cost labor, but these cost reductions are eventually passed on to the consumer, so host country citizens benefit from this as well. The goods produced through the efforts of immigrant workers can also generate additional profits as the goods can be sold at lower price. A second benefit of immigration is the increase in cultural diversity. Having foreigners move here also brings in different cultural backgrounds. The third benefit of immigration is the younger workforce that comes with it, especially right now with...

Words: 460 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Immigration

... Effects of Immigration Immigration is the migration of people from their native country to settle in another country. The most probable causes of movement are the need to boost economic prosperity, political issues and escape from conflicts, wars or natural disasters. The recipient nations are countries in Western Europe or the United States that are normally industrialized.The research paper explore positive and negative impacts on both the host country and the original country. The host countries benefit from the immigrants in a number of ways. The incoming immigrants once settled, will do some jobs country that the citizens often do jobs that people in the recipient in the host country can not. Immigrants do jobs that the citizens view them to be dirty and inferior. The second benefit is that immigrant workers often work longer hours and for lower salaries. Although it is exploitative, the host country benefits in more tasks done at lower cost.Immigrants also contribute to the diversity of that society. When they are welcomed, they assist in building harmony in the society. Lastly, well-educated immigrant have good technological know-how thereby increasing the pool of talent in the host country. , the host country,s economy is is improved by the immigrants with the positive notion for movement to the country(Gilmore 31). However, there are also numerous drawbacks of immigrations to the immigrants as well as the recipient...

Words: 591 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Immigration

...Karina Castillo Literature Comp II Professor Oujo     the purpose of this essay is to explore several harmful but also positive effects that immigration has the economy of the U.S The Cold war had become a massive dominant influence on different aspects of the American society for much of the 20th century. This had many effects on society, both today and in the past. It expanded due to antagonist values between the United States, it represented capitalism and democracy. The Cold War was different from most wars in that it was as much of a promotion war as a war with military engagements. The Korean and Vietnam Wars are two examples of military intervention by the Americans in the name of stopping communist expansionism. However, these wars did not have the extra-long impact that the Cold War have on American domestic and foreign policy that the cultural, economic and political battles of the Cold War had. Now this leads into the cultural battles between the superpowers had as much, or more. This left more of an impact on the everyday lives of most American civilians. Not being an American civilian or citizen wasn’t an issue either. So is immigration a positive effect in North America? Without immigration, The United States would not be nearly as diverse as it is today. But illegal immigration is a tremendous drain on the resources of The United States. But we must find a way to humanely treat illegal immigrants today without allowing or encouraging a further disadvantage...

Words: 1264 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Immigration

...Abstract Immigration is the subject of much debate in the United States. Throughout that debate many differing topics are discussed including politics, national security, financial burden and over population. The topic that many would expect to see here is race but it is not part of the current discussion on immigration. Immigration Immigration has been a controversial subject throughout the history of the United States. In the past much of the conversation about immigration had to do with race and racism. Today the conversation has shifted to topics such as politics, security, financial drain on society, and overpopulation. Race is no longer the driving factor in the current debate over immigration in the United States. Politics If you were to look in the newspaper or online for the topic of immigration most of what you will find is about President Obama’s immigration reform. In November of 2014 Obama enacted an executive order to protect up to five million illegal immigrants from deportation. Since then Obama has been sued by a coalition of 25 states. A Texas court issued an injunction to stop Obama’s executive order from being implemented (Hill, 2015). This injunction was then upheld by a federal court and the Justice Department now plans to appeal that decision (Hill, 2015). Immigration has become a very political issue that both Republicans and Democrats feel requires change. Unfortunately the two parties have yet to come to any sort of agreement as to what those changes...

Words: 1170 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Immigration

...Immigration is a very concerning and controversial issue here in the United States. There are many individuals who are in favor of it and many who are not, for several different reasons. I think however that immigration should be strictly monitored for the reason of the events that we have recently experience over the last eleven years, beginning with the World Trade Center tragedy. I believe that individuals should have a right to immigrate if they so choose however I think that it should be for the right reasons. There should not be any such thing as illegal immigration in the United States. While I understand that we have many large borders that would need to be patrolled I think that the mother and father of the eight year old who died in the Boston Marathon bombings would agree that no value can be placed on a life. Taxpayers in America pay hundreds of thousands of dollars each year to the individual who chooses not to work and have seven kids to obtain hundreds of dollars in governmental assistance a month, and that does nothing to keep our nation safe. Therefore in perspective it may be worth the man power and the money to save the lives of the American people. With that being said I believe the only solution to the Indian Question would be to open up immigration completely to all countries around the world. Therefore you would not be considered to be attempting to remove different ethnicities and races of individuals from our country. While I think that the Indian Question...

Words: 636 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Immigration

...From the origin of the United States, immigration has been crucial for the economic advancement and expansion of the nation. The US truly is a melting pot of many cultures and ideas, and it has benefited greatly from its diversity. However, with a much-reduced demand for unskilled or low-skilled workers, US policy must adapt so that it can better maximize the net economic benefits of immigration. While this probably does not include a universal drop in the number of legal immigrants, it would include the screening of applicants in such a way that preference is given to more economically beneficial candidates. It would also include making families totally responsible for their elderly relatives who migrate to the US, eliminating the refugee portion of immigrants, denying more, but not all, government services to illegal immigrants, controlling the southern border with more manpower and better technology, and establishing a national verification database. The optimal policy from an economic perspective should seek to provide U.S. businesses with the labor they require without placing added burden on the taxpayers. Before specific policies can be addressed, it is crucial that immigrants be separated into four categories: legal, working-age immigrants; legal, elderly immigrants; refugees; and illegal immigrants. These groups are radically different, and they must be addressed differently. Universally cutting legal immigration levels would deprive businesses of labor resources that...

Words: 2444 - Pages: 10