Free Essay

International Humanitarian Law(1)

In: Historical Events

Submitted By ekisanyamori
Words 2082
Pages 9


NOVEMBER, 5, 2013


1950 WORDS
According to the rules of customary international law (IHL), parties to a conflict need to distinguish between the civilians and combatants and military objective and civilian objectives . It is essential to offer a guide on what might be attacked in order to free the civilian populace from the impacts of hostilities. The most important guide regarding armed conflicts is that the combatants may only attack military objectives . However, despite the right to attack only military objectives, the attack will be illegal if the combatants’ use of force may lead to excessive collateral damage on either the civilians or the civilian objects . In addition, the combatants need to take precautionary measures to ensure they do not harm civilians even if they are attacking lawful targets . In this light, it is important to define military objectives and offer an explanation why there are limitations on the attacks on military objectives.
Pursuant to Article 52 (2) of Protocol 1, military objectives need to fulfil two criteria. First, it must be a factor in the military action of the adversary. This is often highlighted by the objects “nature, locality, reason or use”. Secondly, the destruction, capture or neutralization must present a clear military benefit to the combatants. Therefore, an attack on a specific area may be tantamount to a military objective if the destruction, capture or neutralization may present a military advantage to the combatants. However, the advantage that is anticipated from the attack needs to be considered as a whole and not as an isolated part of the war in that an attack as a whole needs to be a limited event rather than the whole war .
The rule stipulating that only military objectives may be attacked is anchored on the principle that the principal aim of any conflict is to triumph politically; therefore, the acts of violence aimed at ensuring political dominance should only endeavour to prevail upon the forces of the enemy . Violent acts that have political, psychological or economic significance may be more resourceful in overcoming the adversary. However, they are not necessary because the enemy can be defeated by weakening its military forces. Once the military force is overcome, there is a guarantee that the economic, political and psychological base will ultimately fail.
The essay will analyze the military objectives and civilian objects in relation to nuclear power station critical to the supply of electricity to the central operative plant of the enemy, a broadcasting station, and members of an armed civilian militia guarding a military installation, and “human shields” who have voluntarily placed themselves inside ammunition depots.
Members of an Armed Civilian Militia Guarding a Military Installation
Combatants fit the definition of military objectives. In this connection, even police officers fit the definition of combatants hence military objectives if they are incorporated in the military. Flowing within this line of reasoning, civilians who are not incorporated into the military but opt to take part in war, lose their protection against attacks so long as they directly participate in the war . Therefore, members of an armed civilian militia guarding a military installation are deemed to have lost their protection by directly participating in the war through guarding the military installation. However, everyone else who is not a participant in the war is afforded full protection under IHL.
Indeed, the grouping of civilians and combatants into mutually exclusive groups that complement each other assists in ensuring the effectiveness and fullness of IHL by avoiding a scenario whereby some people may fight in a war but the other group is precluded from engaging them. The existence of such a privilege would result to a lack of respect to IHL thus undermining the whole fabric of the law. Indeed, IHL frowns upon quasi-combatants . Quasi-combatants are civilians playing a role in a war or a war effort for instance, working in a war factory. This makes them lose their civilian status even though they are not direct participants in the war.
In order to ensure the full protection of civilians, there needs to be a manifest distinction between those directly engaging in military conflicts, and those who are not engaging in hostilities. For one to be in the latter group, their actions should not be such as to hinder the adversary from gaining control on their country through total military occupation . Therefore, the militia that are guarding the military installation are engaging in the hostilities by hindering the attempts of the enemy to suppress the military forces.
However, the combatants need to ensure that they do not harm the civilians because that would be in violation of the principle of necessity that holds that victory can only be attained by defeating the combatants of the country rather than the politicians or scientists.
Human Shields who have voluntarily placed themselves inside Ammunition
Human shielding occurs when persons protected by IHL for instance prisoners are used to deter attacks by combatants and military objectives. Human shielding violates the basic principles of IHL because it skews the flimsy humanitarian necessity balance consideration by influencing its protection for military ends. Additionally, protocol 1 of 1977, Article 51 (7), provides that the existence of the civilian populace shall not be used to cause some parts untouchable by operations. Therefore, parties to a conflict are precluded from shielding their military objectives from attacks by moving their civilian population to the points of attack.

The use of human shields may be passive or active. Passive human shields exist when a party to a conflict makes use of the presence of civilians in a particular locality whereas active human shields are the civilians whom the combatants consciously direct them to a particular location. However, pursuant to article 51 (7), the presence of civilians in a military objective does not render retreat unlawful in the presence of civilians. However, it is unlawful for combatants to intentionally intermingle with civilians. However, The International Committee of the Red Cross’ (ICRC) commentary to Article 51 (7) supports the article interpretation by stating that movement signifies “cover”, in cases where civilians move out of their own volition. Therefore, the intent of the military commander determines the legality of the move. However, in a situation where the citizens voluntarily placed themselves inside ammunition depots, will render themselves unprotected by IHL.
Vide Article 58 of Additional protocol 1; the use of human shield is prohibited by imposing a duty on member parties to “endeavour to remove the civilian population, individual civilians and civilian objects under their control from the vicinity of military objectives”.
Furthermore, the article states that member parties must aspire to avoid “locating military objectives within or near densely populated areas”. Indeed, there may be some humanitarian reasons for the inability to move civilian population from military objectives for instance where the civilian population need to be evacuated from a densely populated city. This may pose a greater threat than leaving them.
Therefore, the provision is underpinned on the caveat that member countries should protect their civilian population to the maximum extent possible . Therefore, the military was under an obligation to ensure that the civilian population removed from the ammunition depot failure of which, the enemy forces would not be at breach of IHL because human shielding is tantamount to a war crime. However, failure to comply with the provisions of Article 58 is not a war crime.
Broadcasting Stations
There is a raging debate as to whether the attack on mass media amounts to military objectives. It is argued that it is desirable from a jus ad bellum point of view to stop the mass media through non violent means. However, if an aggressor opts to stop broadcasting through violent means, and if the broadcasting stations are deemed essential military objectives than bridges, this would be tantamount to changing the basic principles relating to customary international law. This is because the targets of the broadcasts do not constitute military objectives . Therefore, based on this consideration, an attack on the broadcasting station would be a violation of the basic principles of IHL.
Indeed, creating a new system of IHL that does not conform to the principles set out in the traditional concepts on military objectives would be impractical. Allowing attacks on broadcasting stations would make it easy for combatants who have failed in non-violent means of stopping the media to engage in violent attacks on the institution.
Moreover, the object behind the attack makes it fail as a military objective. If ensuring that the civilians do not get information about the state of the war, then the move will be comparable to aiming at the civilian moral rather than the military objectives.
However, attacking a broadcasting station that broadcasts operations about the conduct of the army would not be a violation of IHL.
Nuclear Power Station critical to the Supply of Electricity to the central Operative Plant of the Enemy
Article 56 protocol 1 provides that, works of installation containing dangerous forces namely dams, dykes and nuclear electrical generating stations, shall not be made the object of attack even where these objects have military objectives, if such attack may cause the release of dangerous forces and consequent severe losses among the civilian population. Other military objectives located at or in the vicinity of these works or installations shall not be made the subject of attack if such attack may cause the release of dangerous forces from the works or installation and consequent severe losses among the civilian population.
Therefore, as a general rule, attacks on nuclear stations should not be attacked on the nuclear power station critical to the supply of electricity to the central operative plant of the enemy are illegal under IHL if the attack would bring dire consequences on the civilians . However, pursuant to Article 56 (1) (b), the nuclear power plant may only be attacked if it “provides electric power in regular, significant and direct support of military operations and if such attack is only feasible way to terminate such support”
This provision nullifies the provisions highlighted in Article 56 in the sense that the attack on the nuclear station would be dependent on whether the plant supports the combatants and whether an attack on the nuclear station would assist in termination the support that the military receives.
Nevertheless, the aforementioned provision need not be construed in isolation, Article 57 of the protocol provides that despite the right to attack provided under Article 56 (1), the aggressors should take all the practical steps to ensure that they avoid the release of dangerous forces after attack. Moreover, it is an offence under IHL for a country to make any works or military objectives stated in paragraph 1 the object of reprisal.
In conclusion, there is a clear indication in the rules of the IHL that the distinction between military objectives and civilian objects is apparent. There are clear definitions and principles that govern the conduct and treatment accorded to each. As noted from this essay there is much that needs to be done to bridge the gap between the theories of international conflict and the application of the rules to contemporary situations. Notwithstanding one’s opinion and assessment of the legal structures of Jus ad bellum, the provisions of the IHL laws should guide the use of force against any individual

N, Schmitt & H, Wolff. The conduct of hostilities in international humanitarian law. Farnham, Surrey, England Burlington, 2012.
I, Henderson,. The contemporary law of targeting [military objectives, proportionality and precautions in attack under additional Protocol I. Leiden Boston: 2009.
D, Gary The law of armed conflict : international humanitarian law in war. Cambridge, Eng New York, 2010.
F, Dieter, &M, Bothe. The handbook of international humanitarian law. Oxford, 2013.
L, Henckaerts, , &C,Alvermann. Customary international humanitarian law. Cambridge, 2005.
F, Kalshoven, , &L, Zegveld. Constraints on the waging of war : an introduction to international humanitarian law. New York, 2011.
C, Jonathan, & K, Scheuber. Principles of international humanitarian law. Cheltenham, 2013.
M, Schmitt. Tallinn manual on the international law applicable to cyber warfare : prepared by the international group of experts at the invitation of the NATO Cooperative Cyber Defence Centre of Excellence. York, 2013.
Neff, Stephen C. War and the law of nations : a general history. New York, 2008.
D, Scheffer. All the missing souls : a personal history of the war crimes tribunals. Princeton, 2012.
Roberts, Adam, and Richard Guelff. Documents on the laws of war. New York, 2000.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

International Committee of the Red Cross

...iTHE INTERNATIONAL COMMITTEE OF THE RED CROSS (ICRC): MANAGING ACROSS CULTURE ‘We were an orgn made up of Swiss generalists. We are becoming a multicultural and professional enterprise.” 1. INTRODUCTION Dr. Jacques Stroun, M.D. – (1999) Director of Human Resources & Finance (before Head of Detention Division, Deputy Director of Operations) ICRC – provide humanitarian relief, Humanitarian ‘Multinational’ Organisation Home base: Geneva, Switzerland Orgn Values – Neutrality, Independence, Discretion & Humanism Total Workforce – (2008) over 14,000 over 100 nationalities Until recently – ICRC is very Swiss , very Genevoise Expatriate – open to all nationalities but 93% is westerners (1992) Changing expatriate composition – expatriates number increasing – Africa, Asia & Latin America HR Policy – recruitment from Geneva – sent to field with ‘learning by doing’, operate under sense of danger, meeting immediate challenges, focus on short term, quickly develops and reinforces team and team loyalties, rotation every 12 months, no formal training, no continuity for developing people, Career - little career planning, career developed through interpersonal networks & driven by opportunities, most recruits stayed for 2 to 3 years, no management development, those remain and reach top of HQ –mostly Swiss male (old school boys club) CURRENT CHALLENGES – greater diversity in mgmt ranks – more professionals, foreigners and women. NEW STRATEGIC PLAN (2007......

Words: 1744 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Drone Strikes

...Drone Strikes, Effective Weapon in the War on Terrorism? William DeJarnette United States Diplomatic History November 21, 2014 September 7, 2009, in Machi Khel in Mir Ali, North Waziristan, Pakistan. At 20,000 feet death silently, stealthily, knifed its way through the afternoon sky. Two drones, operated by American Air Force drone pilots 7,000 miles away in Nevada, USA, had been hovering over the area throughout the day. Modern warfare and the fight against terrorism were about to greet Sadaullah Wazir and his family as they reentered their home after evening prayers in the garden. Moments later an explosive concussion from missiles launched by the drones rocked the neighborhood and body parts flew in every direction. Senior al Qaeda leader Ilyas Kashmiri was killed in his car as it entered the village. However, injured in the attack at the same time were fifteen-year-old Sadaullah and several others. Three of Wazir’s family members were killed. Wazir awoke in a hospital the next day, minus both legs and an eye. Objective met, target Kashmiri eliminated. Collateral damage is just another acceptable part of the plan. The Living Under Drones project interviewed Khalid Raheem, an elder in his community in Pakistan. Raheem is bewildered by the current state of affairs in his country. He states that they knew nothing about where the US was or what type of people lived there. They did know that the US supported the Taliban in their fight against the Soviets, until the......

Words: 2790 - Pages: 12

Free Essay

Critically Discuss to What Extent, If Any, Technological Progress Has Undermined the Ability of the Law of Armed Conflict to Regulate the Conduct of Hostilities. Support Your Answer with Reference to Practical Examples

...Advances in technology and weaponry have revolutionised warfare since time immemorial, where inventions such as the chariot, canon powder and the airplane effectively changed the landscape of warfare.1 The law of armed conflict (LOAC) that exists today has developed as a reaction to the atrocities committed in the past; the four Geneva Conventions and the Additional Protocols of 1977 originated as responses to the increased suffering of civilians in armed conflict due in part to developments of weapon technology.2 The legal instruments to regulate the application of these advances in technology can barely keep up with challenges resulting from the rapidness of the advancement of contemporary military technologies. Moreover, recent technological advances raise the prospect of upheavals in practice so fundamental that they challenge assumptions underlying long-established international laws of war.3 This is because advances in technology have dramatically affected the weapons and tactics of future armed conflict, the “places” where conflicts are fought, the “actors” by whom they are fought, and the “means and methods” by which they are fought.4 These changes stress the fundamental principles of the LOAC, thus undermining its ability to regulate the conduct of hostilities; namely, by posing challenges to the principles of distinction, proportionality, military necessity and unnecessary suffering. This essay aims to assess the impact technology has had upon the......

Words: 3294 - Pages: 14

Free Essay

Legality of the Use of Military Force

...a viable option it is important to discuss the legality of the use of military force. This is especially important when taking into account that many of the rules and laws governing this topic were created when wars were fought very differently and opponents in warfare were often better defined than they are today. In most of the world’s conflicts today, a nation may not be engaging into battle against a uniformed militia of a particular state, nor are they engaged in conflict against a ruling government or regime of a state. However many of the laws and rules in place are still relevant and effective even in today’s extremely complex international arena. This topic is one that requires discussion because states need to know when it is legal for them to invade another state and when it is not. Also to outline the consequences of an illegal action in regards to these laws as well as other problems and dilemmas that may arise from this topic. But sometimes situations can call for action immediately. When you must wait on a committee of representatives to vote on the legality of the proposed invasion, you may stand the chance of losing valuable time and effectiveness against enemy combatants. Legal Background The legal background regarding this topic is vague and confusing in some instances. International law prohibits the use of military force, unless it is being used in a manner of self-defense or as a preemptive maneuver to avoid being attacked by another state. However......

Words: 1268 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

International Law

...EXAM PAPER BY Marcie L. Pereira 2. “International Law has never shown such vibrancy as in the present moment and fragmentation is a result of that dynamism and capacity for adaptation and expansion. Moments of transition in conceptualization and institutional set-up are normally very creative.” Do you agree? Present your position. The system of international law has become increasingly fragmented, particularly since the end of the Cold War. Various factors are responsible for the increased fragmentation: • The proliferation of international regulations; • Increasing political fragmentation (juxtaposed with growing regional and global interdependence in such areas as economics, the environment, energy, resources, health, and the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction); • The regionalization of international law due to a rise in the number of regional fora engaged in the formulation of international regulations; • The emancipation of individuals from States; and • The specialization of international regulations. Presently, there exists no homogeneous system of international law. International law consists of erratic blocks and elements; different partial systems; and universal, regional, or even bilateral subsystems and subsubsystems of different levels of legal integration. All these parts interacting with one another create what may paradoxically be called an “unorganized system, full of intra-systematic tensions, contradictions and frictions. In theory,......

Words: 3665 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Humanitarian Intervention within another state? May a state or international institution like the United Nations intervene in the affairs of another state? Do we have a moral and ethical duty for intervention when a political regime is harming its own citizens? Is it legal under International law for a state to intervene in another state’s territorial and political sovereignty with or without United Nation Security Council’s approval? It is the aim of this essay to examine some of the answers commonly given to these questions. To address the ethical and legal justifiability of intervention this essay will begin by analyzing how we define humanitarian intervention. The second section discusses moral and ethical issue relating to humanitarian intervention. The discussion focuses on the several theories that present a moral case for intervention. It concludes by examining whether international law should affirm a right to humanitarian intervention. The literature on the ethics and legality of humanitarian intervention is filled with disagreement. This essay seeks to identify and critically assess the often unexamined moral and legal assumptions behind these disagreements. Definition of Humanitarian Intervention It is necessary to begin with a clear understanding of the concept to be analyzed. We need then to start by addressing the question, what is humanitarian intervention? And to address this we need to study the definition of humanitarian intervention. “It is the threat or use......

Words: 3276 - Pages: 14

Free Essay

Privatization of War

...and now by the democratically elected governments- have been practiced; Historians claims that mercenaries existed in ancient Egypt to safeguard the Egyptian sovereignty by the rebels of that time. Indeed, mercenaries have transformed into private military contractors after the downfall of Soviet Union in 1991 and the characteristics of a PMC and ancient mercenaries are rather similar. However, under The Hague Convention no. 5 mercenaries are illegal organizations but the role and responsibility of private military organizations is unknown in the international law which gives them free reins to operate in a way which fulfills their greed to make abnormal profits. The operations of private military companies is controversial, their contracts with the governments and other non-state actors is discreet in nature which confines the mass media to focus on their operations. The lack of information and lack of oversight under international law makes people all around the world unaware of private military industries. The war on terror executed by the United States empowered PMCs and for profit maximization motives these organization get the job done over the cost of innocent civilian lives. Introduction: The questions below...

Words: 6059 - Pages: 25

Free Essay


...On September 11, 2001, 2977 people lost their lives during the plane hijackings and the attacks on the World Trade Center towers in New York City and the Pentagon in Virginia. This single incident led to major changes in the United States in both domestic and foreign policy. These changes have led to an ever-changing role for the US in the global arena. Following the end of the Cold War and the collapse of the Soviet Union, the United States has been in the position of being the primary military and economic ‘superpower’. Foreign policy was focused on the possible threats of long-range missile attacks by North Korea directly or upon our European allies by Iran. Domestic policy was more economic in nature focusing on developing markets and free trade agreements, such as NAFTA, with emerging foreign markets in developing countries such as Mexico, China, and India. Unfortunately, this has led to a loss of 20% global market share for the US as outsourcing jobs and sometimes entire companies to these countries has become a more prevalent practice. Since the 9/11 attacks, the focus has been on fighting a war against terrorism beginning with the bombings in Afghanistan 26 days after 9/11 in 2001 and the invasion of Iraq in 2003 (, 2014). In a speech to the joint houses of Congress on September 20, 2001, President Bush stated, “We will direct every resource at our command ... to the destruction and to the defeat of the global terror network. ... We will pursue nations......

Words: 892 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Business Purposes

...Unit 1: BUSINESS PURPOSES Task 1 – The Purpose of Business Organization State the name and describe the purpose of four different business organizations. The purpose of a business may well be to supply goods and services at a profit, free, at cost or below cost. Marks & Spencer (a multi-national organization) A multi-national organization is a corporation with production facilities or significant operations in more than one country. It can be based in any country but makes major management decisions in a global context. Marks & Spencer is one of the UK’s leading retailers, with over 21 million people visiting their stores each week. They offer stylish, high quality, great value clothing and home products, as well as outstanding quality foods, responsibly sourced from around 2,000 suppliers globally. They employ over 75,000 people in the UK and abroad, and have over 600 UK stores, plus an expanding international business. Overall, their clothing and home ware sales account for 49% of their business. The other 51% of their business is in food, where they sell everything from fresh produce and groceries, to partly-prepared meals and ready meals. They do this by selling their own products for a profit. They also apply financial services; share stock is one of the main services. Dividends are the regular financial returns to shareholders who invest in the company. When Marks & Spencer earns a profit, it can be put to two uses: either re-invested in the business......

Words: 902 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

International Humanitarian Law

...I. INTRODUCTION The main instruments of International Humanitarian Law (hereafter referred to as IHL) are the four Geneva Conventions of 12 August 19491 for the protection of war victims. These treaties which are universally accepted, protect the wounded, the sick, prisoners of war and civilians in enemy hands. They also protect medical services personnel such as medical personnel, medical units and establishments, and medical means of transport. As a matter of fact this kind of concern for the humanitarian aspect can be found in our ancient epics like the Mahabharata, where the rules of conduct of war as to the timing of attack and the prohibition attacking the unarmed were strictly laid down. The laws of Manu, a compilation of encyclopedic scope, which the British Professor Duncan M. Derrett a known authority on Hindu Law describes as a text "which constitutes India's greatest achievement in the field of jurisprudence" and regards this work as one of the world's premier compositions in ancient law, more valuable in every sense than Hammurabi and able to hold its own in comparison to the covenant and Priestly codes of Moses2 . Manu, while describing the duties of a King, warns against unusual cruelty even against an enemy in warfare, and has this to say, "fighting in a battle, he should not kill his enemies with weapons that are concealed, barbed, or smeared with poison or whose points blaze with fire. He should not kill anyone who has climbed on......

Words: 3960 - Pages: 16

Premium Essay

Angela Merkel

...Europe must not close the doors of their borders to Syrians migrants. The immigration crisis in Syria, to been the more large humanitarian crisis in Europe since the Second World War. But, why are there so many emigrants from the Syrian country. In general the expansion of the Islamic State, religious conflict - the Muslims that Sunni exceeds 70% of the 18 million inhabitants of the country. The Alawi and Shia that they account for more than 10%. Completing the picture Christians (especially Orthodox, 10%) and minorities such as the Druze -.and the pressing economic situation - caused by massive privatization and adjustments demanded by the International Monetary Fund, caused that it will shoot unemployment, exacerbated by the uncontrolled increase of the population: 2000 Syrians were 18 million and in 2005, 21 million - are some of the responses. But the more relevant is the civil war that there is in Syria. Since the beginning of the war in Syria at the beginning of the year 2011, there have been more than 12 million Syrians who have migrated from their country. Consequently this serious humanitarian situation has been repeated for many years, every day becomes more intense and in 2013 was already 60,000 people who launched this risky adventure, to arrive at the figure of most of 210,000 in 2014 that have sought refuge in any country that accepts them receive, asked that today is almost impossible. Up to December 2015, more than one million people had come in Europe,......

Words: 1247 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Humanitarian Intervention

...|HUMANITARIAN INTERVENTION | |INTRODUCTION | Humanitarian intervention poses a hard test for any international society built on principles of sovereignty, non-intervention, and the non-use of force. Immediately after the Holocaust, the society of states established laws prohibiting genocide, forbidding the mistreatment of civilians, and recognizing basic human rights. These humanitarian principles often conflict with principles of sovereignty and non-intervention. Sovereign states are expected to act as guardians of their citizens’ security, but what happens if states behave as criminals towards their own people, treating sovereignty as a licence to kill? Should tyrannical states be recognized as legitimate members of international society and accorded the protection afforded by the non-intervention principle? Or, should states forfeit their sovereign rights and be exposed to legitimate intervention if they actively abuse or fail to protect their citizens? Related to this, what responsibilities do other states or institutions have to enforce human rights norms against governments that massively violate them? Armed humanitarian intervention was not a legitimate practice during the cold war because states placed......

Words: 5806 - Pages: 24

Premium Essay

America's Cuban Conundrum

...America’s Cuban Conundrum 1. Analyze the key issue that prompted the EU to take the Helms-Burton dispute to the WTO The 1963 U.S. embargo was reinforced in October 1992 by the Cuban Democracy Act (the "Torricelli Law") and in 1996 by the Cuban Liberty and Democracy Solidarity Act (known as the Helms-Burton Act) which penalizes foreign companies that do business in Cuba by preventing them from doing business in the U.S. Justification provided for these restrictions was that these companies were trafficking in stolen U.S. properties, and should, thus, be excluded from the United States (Longmire, 2009). According to the Department of State (2000), Helms-Burton Act is the latest incarnation of U.S. efforts to internationalize it embargo of Cuba. Both the 1992 Cuba Democracy Act and Helms-Burton target foreign investment in Cuba, seeking to undermine Cuba’s international access to capital. The European Union (EU), Canada and Mexico have taken steps to challenge the law in the WTO and under NAFTA, seeking the nullification of the law on the grounds that it violates international trade law. The EU resented the Helms Burton Act because it felt that the US was dictating how other nations ought to conduct their trade and challenged it on that basis. The EU eventually dropped its challenge in favor of negotiating a solution. Many nations have enacted antidote legislation that bars their nationals from complying with Helms-Burton, under the threat of fines. They also argue that......

Words: 1594 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

International Adoption

...International adoption Nurman Assima (ID:20110635) Academic Reading and Writing 1 Anna Bondarenko November 11, 2011 Outline Essay question: Whether or not international adoption should be banned? I Introduction Thesis statement: Although there is plenty persuasive evidence supporting the benefits for children to be placed in adoptive homes rather than to be left in orphanages, many negative effects can arise as a result of international adoptions, such as loss of culture or family identity, child trafficking, deceit and kidnapping. II Body A. International adoption is detrimental to the adopted children. 1. National distinctions of children from their adoptive parents lead to the loss of their cultural, physical and psychological identity. 2. Negative social attitude and the stigma attached to adoption is psychologically damaging to adopted children. B. International adoption has transformed from a noble cause into underground profitable business. 1. During the adoption process agencies and advocates are driven by financial incentives. 2. International adoption is accompanied with abuses, crimes and other immoral actions on the part of adoptive parents. C. International adoption gives orphans all over the world a possibility to obtain a family. 1. Adoption gives a possibility to an orphan to obtain a better life. 2. Adoptive parents provide diseased orphans with......

Words: 1556 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

No File Is Uploaded

...The International Committee of the Red Cross Managing Across Cultures Case study Reference no 408-061-1 This case was written by Sowon Kim and Professor Susan Schneider, HEC-University of Geneva. It is intended to be used as the basis for class discussion rather than to illustrate either effective or ineffective handling of a management situation. The case was compiled from published sources. © 2008, HEC-University of Geneva. No part of this publication may be copied, stored, transmitted, reproduced or distributed in any form or medium whatsoever without the permission of the copyright owner. ecch the case for learning Distributed by ecch, UK and USA All rights reserved Printed in UK and USA North America t +1 781 239 5884 f +1 781 239 5885 e Rest of the world t +44 (0)1234 750903 f +44 (0)1234 751125 e 408-061-1 THE INTERNATIONAL COMMITTEE OF THE RED CROSS: Managing Across Cultures This case was written by Sowon Kim, Ph.D. candidate, and Susan Schneider, Chaired Professor of Human Resources Management at HEC – University of Geneva. The case was made possible through the generous cooperation of the International Committee of the Red Cross. The case is intended as a basis for class discussion rather than to illustrate either effective or ineffective handling of a management situation. © 2008 HEC – University of Geneva. All rights reserved. No part of this [publication may be copied,......

Words: 8284 - Pages: 34