Free Essay

Interpretation and Bridging Gaps

In: English and Literature

Submitted By summerjan
Words 1827
Pages 8
Interpretation and Bridging Gaps In his approach to Reader-Response criticism, Wolfgang Iser stands between subjectivity and objectivity. For him, literary texts do not have one final meaning; nor are they open to as many meanings as there are readers. Iser’s two major books, The Implied Reader (1974) and The Act of Reading (1978), have continued to be sold and reprinted; he has also published an abundance of more recent articles. Iser distinguishes literary texts from non-literary ones and presents us with a phenomenology of reading that has significant implications for literary interpretation. He draws a distinction between literature and non-literature in the book titled: The Act of Reading: A Theory of Aesthetic Response and says: “Literary texts do not contain a referential meaning; if they did, they would not be literature.” Iser’s primary concern is the relationship between the text and its readers. According to Iser, the literary text has a ‘potential’, and ‘the structure of the text allows for different ways’ of fulfilling its ‘potential’. (qtd. The Act of Reading, 13) I believe that to achieve this effect, the literary text conceals as it reveals. The presence of holes or gaps in the text invites the reader to fill in the gaps, but the reader’s activity is guided and molded by that what is revealed. Iser’s blanks come with his points of suspended connectability between segments of the text. (qtd. The Act of Reading, 13) He focuses on the role of the reader, which is controlled by what the text reveals and productive wherever these blanks occur. In this way, reading is not totally subjective; nor is it totally objective. The literary text has relative indeterminacy which allows a spectrum of meaning actualizations. Stanley Fish, in a chapter of his book “Doing What Comes Naturally” that he entitles ‘Why No One’s Afraid of Iser,” considers his theory contradictory as Iser seems to shift the authority from the reader to the text and vice versa.(68-86) Fish describes the main contradiction in Iser’s theory as follows: It is at once spatial – in that it conceives of the text as an object with a particular shape (the shape of the ‘designated instructions’) – and temporal – in that the production of literary meaning is a process that the text only sets in motion; it is for the same reason a theory that can claim a measure of objectivity – its operations begins with something that is ‘given’ – and yet at the same time it requires the subjective contribution of the reader… It is therefore a theory that sets limits to interpretation… (qtd. Doing What Comes Naturally, 68-86)
What is taken as contradictory by Stanley Fish is the very concept of reader-text interaction. In his strong reaction to New Criticism, Fish polarizes the problem as an either-or situation. Iser, on the other hand, says: that “the meaning of the literary work remains related to what the printed text says, but it requires the creative imagination of the reader to put it all together”(qtd. The Act of Reading, 142) Which I agree with. I believe in order to understand the literary text, fill in the holes and bridge its gaps, we need to approach in several different ways and interpret it. We have to not only read the text closely but also read between the lines. Then I think all the gaps could be bridged, a little if not entirely. I tried to do that by creating my own interpretation and analysis for the poem “Metaphors” by Sylvia Plath. I have also asked other people for their own opinions and interpretations of the poem to understand it and its gaps better.
Metaphors
I'm a riddle in nine syllables,
An elephant, a ponderous house,
A melon strolling on two tendrils.
O red fruit, ivory, fine timbers!
This loaf's big with its yeasty rising.
Money's new-minted in this fat purse.
I'm a means, a stage, a cow in calf.
I've eaten a bag of green apples;
Boarded the train there's no getting off.
Sylvia Plath

I imagined the speaker in "Metaphors" holding up a mirror to herself; one that allows full-length representation and subsurface penetration. And I looked at her choice of words in the poem, in my mind I visualized the image in the mirror shifting from a woman into a riddle, an elephant, a house, a melon on two tendrils, a loaf rising in the oven, a purse, a stage, and a cow. And I asked myself, why the poet used those particular images? Does the speaker here really become a series of objects or creatures? Or are they only metaphors? I thought it made more sense that they are metaphors that reflect a pregnant woman. “I'm a riddle in nine syllables” I asked myself what the meaning of the number nine in the first line which is also repeatedly reflected in the number of lines in the poem and the number of syllables in each line. I wondered if it is reflecting the 9 months term of a normal pregnancy but I didn’t know for sure till I connected it to “An elephant, a ponderous house,-- A melon strolling on two tendrils.” I thought maybe the woman feels elephantine because of her increased weight and girth? Perhaps she feels she's as big as a house, now her body has become an object in which a separate being dwells. I pictured the melon on tendrils and I thought perhaps it means that her melon-shaped gravidity makes her legs seem by comparison like slender tendrils. I also asked myself: how is that image is similar to the previous line? I thought of the elephant and realized that it too has a body that is round and heavier than its legs. I guess it is no accident that the poem's title is a nine-letter word as well. “O red fruit, ivory, fine timbers!” I wondered what it the red fruit is reflecting. I assumed the red fruit to be the fetus, and the ivory (reminiscent of the earlier elephant) perhaps the child's skin or the child's bones? “This loaf's big with its yeasty rising-- Money's new-minted in this fat purse-- I'm a means, a stage, a cow in calf.” The yeasty rising loaf is the commonly referred to bun in the oven. Perhaps the slow baking or rising of the loaf is similar to the slow growth of the fetus? But it might also refer to the slow increase in size or weight. I thought of the fat purse as another metaphor for the woman's belly, stuffed with the precious cargo of newly minted and still uncirculated money. But how does the woman turns from a rising loaf, a fat purse and a cow into a stage? Perhaps the woman feels she has lost her own identity in becoming a means for reproduction or a stage on which a dramatic production is about to debut. “I've eaten a bag of green apples” I wondered how eating a bag of apples is relevant and I thought if I ate that many apples I would probably feel nauseous. The apples mentioned are green apples, and they are usually sour. Perhaps it is reflecting the occasional pains or illness a pregnant woman feels? The bag of green apples she ate might also refer to the pregnancy itself, and that it caused abdominal swelling demanding release. “Boarded the train there's no getting off.” I wondered what the train referred to. Is it the impregnation? Is it refereeing to her decision to get pregnant? Or is it referring to motherhood and the infant she is now taking care for? Perhaps the train is a metaphor for all that--a non-stop journey with a destination. Many of the people to whom I read the poem disagreed with my interpretation. I wondered why and the first reason I thought of is that some people look at the poem through a positive perspective and others through a negative one. Those who interpreted it through a negative point of view gave me the following remarks: * The speaker concentrates on the symptoms and things that happened to her during the pregnancy rather than on the fact that she was bringing another life into the world. She didn’t convey that she was fortunate to be involved in a miracle. Instead she focused on her misfortunes and afflictions due to the pregnancy. * The color green means misfortune and green apples must have been used to refer to her unborn child. Maybe all she means is that she is now pregnant with a baby that she knows nothing about and does not want. And an interpretation that I disagreed most with and found peculiar is: * "Boarded the train there's no getting off" refers to her committing suicide.
I disagreed with the previous statement because although I know the speaker in the poem is a woman, I have no way of knowing for sure that the poet was speaking about herself. When I did my research on Sylvia Plath, I found that she did indeed kill herself. According to a brief biography online: “Plath took her own life after she completely sealed the rooms between herself and her sleeping children with wet towels and cloths. Plath then placed her head in the oven while the gas was turned on. The next day an inquiry ruled that her death was a suicide.” (Sylvia Plath, Wikipedia) However despite this fact being true, there isn’t any evidence that the speaker in the poem is the poet herself. That remark was perhaps the readers attempt to bridge the gap between her, her world and the world of the author. I think another reason for the differences in interpretation is that some people apply a psychoanalytical interpretation according to how they relate to the poet and understand the emotions she is conveying through the text. Like in Letty’s Identification with Billie Holiday. “An individual can find a source of psychological strength in an emotional identification with another person, even if that other person is a relative stranger.”(4) People who said, Plath was depressed in the poem never met her, neither did I, but I assume they identified with emotions that they found in the poem. Perhaps trying to make sense out of the literary text is not meant to get us the perfect and only true interpretation, nor is it meant to fill in all the holes in the text. Perhaps the gaps can only be bridged partially and must remain there for the sake of it and meaning can never be exact and complete.

Works Cited: (1) Iser, Wolfgang. The Act of Reading: A Theory of Aesthetic Response (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1978), p13, p142 (2) Fish, Stanley. Doing What Comes Naturally (Oxford: Oxford University Press. 1989), p68-86 (3) Tyson, Lois. Learning for a Diverse World. (pg 47) (4) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sylvia_Plath#Death

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Personal Communication Assessment

...validate this, I followed the steps mentioned above. Assessment There were many assessment tools available via the internet to assess my communication skills but I chose to use (“How Good Are Your Communication Skills?” from Mind Tools. My decision to choose their communication quiz was based on the depth of details it provided me upon completion of the quiz. The quiz had 15 questions which encompassed each stage of the communication process. A score interpretation was provided and also a detailed interpretation for improving my skills in each area. Based on my score interpretation, I am a capable communicator, but I sometimes experience communication problems. I need to take more time to think about my approach to communication, and focus on receiving messages effectively as much as sending them. The encoding part of the communication process was my weakest area. This showed that I have difficulty creating a clear and well-crafted message which often leads to a communication gap. Communication Gaps Communication gaps are frequently...

Words: 756 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Paper

...Grace Chin Paper #2 Intro to Philosophy, Phil-2-2503 Dr. Fjeld October 7, 2010 The Unbridgeable Gap Over centuries, the epistemological gap has been an issue of debate and controversy among deep philosophical thinkers. This very gap refers to the gap between “subject” and “object”, and it is this very gap that provoked the question of true objectivity. Can we reach true objectivity and in essence, know an object in itself? Although many philosophers found their own ways of bridging the epistemological gap and proposed many intellectual explanations, I found that for myself personally, none of the theories settled quite perfectly for me. There was always a lingering question among the theories as their own separate entities, and so as a believer of a mélange of different ideas and philosophies, I must say that I do not believe that the epistemological gap can be bridged. Plato first began to tackle the epistemological gap by presenting the idea of “Forms”. He insisted that through love here in existence, we are pointed to the perfect forms above, with each step up being a step closer to the higher Forms. He believed that all things in existence participated in the perfections above us. For example, anything beautiful here on earth partakes in the bigger, higher Form of “Beauty” in the heavens. Plato gives the cave parable in his dialectical The Republic to further explain the pathway from denseness to clear. All people on earth view only the shadows reflected off......

Words: 1817 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Managing Creativity at Shanghai Tang

...Innovation and creativity are one of the key successful elements in the recent rapid changed environment, and in fact innovation and creativity are changing our world. Since the innovation and creativity are playing an important role in the business world, the conflict between the creative technical employees (creators) and the businessmen (stewards) is increasingly hindering from the business development. Like Shanghai Tang, the conflicts are usually found between its designers (creators) and its management (stewards). As an international clothing chain company, its product design is one of the key successful factors in its competitive industry. In order to build-up a unique fashion style, Shanghai Tang develops two key components which its products are contained: Chinese-ness and the use of bright colors, and so-called “Shanghai Tang DNA”. However, its designers blamed that this Shanghai Tang DNA constrained their creativity in various areas, including the brand consideration, sales considerations and production cost consideration, etc. Positioning is no doubt a critical business strategy. However, the creators argued that their designs always have to be Chinese-oriented and European influence is hardly accepted in the final design approved by the management. The creators think that the Shanghai DNA hinders their own creative ideas and inspirations and hardly accept their creative design which is out of the management mind to maintain the brand......

Words: 1467 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Liberal Arts

...provides an overview of the arts, humanities (the study of the human condition), social sciences, mathematics and natural sciences. Traditionally, liberal art majors find it more difficult obtaining employment because it is assumed that their area of study is not specific enough or perhaps lacks the concentration needed to contribute quickly in a business organization. The advantages a liberal art education provides for a student is the ability to develop his/her critical thinking ability, analytical skills, (Bogart, 2011) among others, which in most cases cannot be learnt from a strictly outlined course work such as accounting. This literature discusses the liberal art major and how they can be aligned with the business education, how the gap between liberal arts and business can be bridged, benefits of a liberal arts education,...

Words: 3235 - Pages: 13

Free Essay

Managing Knowldege for Strategic Effective Ness

...|Assignment | |STUDENTENOMMER: | | |STUDENT NUMBER : | | |VAN : |VOORLETTERS: | |SURNAME: STEPHANS |INITIALS : M | |TELEFOONNOMMER : | |TELEPHONE NUMBER: | |VAK : |Managing Knowledge for Strategic Effectiveness | |SUBJECT: | | |AANTAL BLADSYE | 11 pages including this one | |DOSENT : ...

Words: 2491 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Thesis Proposal

...museums, the visitors are encouraged to appreciate the achievements of our civilization. Whether the displayed objects have artistic, social or cultural significance, the rule is to observe and create interpretation. But what if visitor can’t look or have difficulty in creating the visual image of the object? Does it create limited experience for visually impaired visitors? This study will focus on exploring applied design methods to enhance museum experience for visually impaired visitors. The study will be a combination of theoretical and practical case studies which will discuss the sensorial exhibition space from designer’s perspective. 2. Objective and Scope • To understand effective ways of museum communication for visually impaired visitors. • To understand design strategies for creating experience beyond visual sense. • To identify affectivity of alternate methods like Haptic and Tactile graphics, Braille, models, and audio and touch tours. • To discuss various case studies which are using alternate design techniques for conveying museum message for these visitors. 3. Research Questions • What alternative methods museums are using for creating inclusive experience for visually impaired visitors? • What are the curatorial and design practices in bridging the gap between sight and meaning? • What is the role of technology in achieving this blend? 4. Research Framework The research will be based on comparative study between Haptic (3D Modelling),......

Words: 1514 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Nursing-Pharmacology

...completion of a transition-to-practice program after they have completed a prelicensure or advanced practice degree program or when they are transitioning into new clinical practice areas” (Institute of Medicine, p.7, 2010). Background Many novice NPs feel unprepared, uncertain, and isolated during their first years of practice. According to a study by Hart and Macnee (2007), only ten percent of NPs felt they were well prepared for practice after completing their NP program while fifty one percent felt that they were only somewhat or minimally prepared. Study participants felt least prepared in the areas of “coding and billing, casting, complementary and alternative medicine, electrocardiogram interpretation, microscopy, simple office procedures, splinting, suturing, X-ray interpretation, and clinical management of mental health diseases”. In the study it was felt that basic NP education lacked clinical rigor and could benefit from more clinical hours. Eighty seven percent of the NPs studied stated they would have been interested in entering a fellowship program with supervised clinical experience after completing their NP education had one been available. Several participants suggested completion of a post graduate fellowship as a requirement of NP entry to practice. Given that the clinical training hours required for all NP programs are insufficient to begin practice with confidence and mastery,...

Words: 766 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Statement

...Rebecca Henllan-Jones 5249 N. Meade Chicago Il. 60630 As the daughter and daughter-in-law of Chicago Public School teachers I have heard the good, the bad, and the ugly side of life as a public school teacher. As a young child I remember my mother reading and watching the news incessantly hoping for any droplet of information about CPS, or when we would gather for large dinners with family or friends, also usually CPS teachers, the talk would often turn to budget cuts and Education reform. But I also knew how much my mother loved teaching and really felt like she was making a difference. As I grew up I knew I wanted to make a difference too. I went into school with the feeling that I was carrying on the family business but as the years past I became uncertain and began to doubt my choice. And when I graduated in the spring of 2007 with a Bachelor of Arts degree in Early Childhood Education I knew I had the tools to become a good teacher, but I also knew I didn’t want to be a teacher. I was upset, I felt as if I let my family down and I was also scared; I didn’t have a clue what I wanted to do with my self. I wanted so much more than a job; I wanted to love my career, to be passionate about it, and as much as I loved children and loved teaching, I knew I wasn’t going to be happy as a teacher. When I started at UIC in the winter of 2007 I still wasn’t sure what I was looking for, but I was eager to explore every opportunity that came my way. Very soon after I started at UIC I...

Words: 652 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Research Methods

...Essay 1 – Research methods and Methodological Perspectives Different philosophical foundation create a division in social research methods into two key approaches namely qualitative method which is associated with interprevitism and quantitative methods which is associated with positivism. The main difference between these methodological approaches is that qualitative research is about the expression of meaning. Bowling 2002 defines qualitative research as a “method of naturalistic enquiry which is usually less obtrusive than quantitative investigations and does not manipulate a research setting.”(Bowling 2002). It is as a result of this naturalistic enquiry that feelings or expressions are derived in relation to a particular issue. This process of expressing feelings or thoughts is also known as Phenomenology. Bowling 2002 quoting Smart 1976 states that phenomenology is “based on the paradigm that reality is multiple and socially constructed through the interaction of individuals who use symbols to interpret each other and assign meanings to perceptions and experience; these are not imposed by external forces”. (Bowling 2002). Through the phenomology process research is interactive with the respondent and researcher and is performed through open-ended, unstructured or participant observation and in-depth interviews. The data is collected through a mutual understanding between the researcher and the respondent. Hence the phenomenology process is commonly called the......

Words: 667 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Technology in Education

...observed phenomenon exists and operates. Conceptual Framework Conceptual framework presents specific and well-defined concepts which are called constructs. Its function is similar to theoretical framework because the constructs used are derived from abstract concepts of the theoretical framework. Statement of the Problem Statement of the problem sets the direction of the study. It has to be stated vividly and explicitly in interrogative form. A good research problem should be SMART, that is, Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Realistic, and Time-Bound. Significance of the Study Significance of the study explains its importance. It defines the contribution of the study in relation to solving the problem and need; bridging a knowledge gap; improving social, economic and health conditions; enriching research instruments and methods; and supporting government thrusts. Significance of the study is presented either in inductive or deductive perspective. In and inductive way, the researcher moves from the particular to the general, and presents the importance of the study from target beneficiaries, to the researcher himself, to the people in the community, to the people in the province, region and nation. Likewise, in a deductive perspective, the discussion of the importance of the study is the exact reverse of the inductive process. Scope and Limitation of the Study Scope and limitations of the study...

Words: 1029 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Networking

...individuals on Facebook. Scholars have recently begun to study the Facebook phenomenon using surveys and statistical analyses, but none have used ethnography as a means for analysis. This paper draws upon ethnographic data to provide a phenomenological explanation to the Facebook experience. It argues that the digital world is a large part of the experience of young Americans and that the Internet is more social than commonly thought. Moreover, this paper problematizes the static nature of the Profile, arguing that the Profile converses directly with others’ Profiles in a constantly changing digital context that is simultaneously recreated and interpreted.  Embodied conversation between individuals begins when they weave performance and interpretation into an intricate dance that allows individuals to consider voice and body cues. Meaning is interpreted from the context of the conversation and nuances of body and gesture. However, embodied conversation differs from computer-mediated communication, where individuals must write...

Words: 3201 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Lsi Paper

...Life Styles Inventory Paper Title Page MGMT591: Leadership and Organizational Behavior Student: Rodney Belk Dr. Kimberly Hunley May 15, 2016 After taking the lifestyles inventory interpretation test my primary and secondary personal thinking styles are more apparent to me. I have scored the highest in percentile of Oppositional and Power styles and very closely followed by perfectionist and competitive styles. My percentile scores in these areas were 99% for oppositional, 99% for power, and 95% for competitive. Regarding the primary style, oppositional, it is a very close perception of who I am. Taking the Life Styles Inventory (LSI) survey has really made me realized and confirm many things or styles that I've already knew about myself. On the Life Styles Inventory survey, I scored very high on the "Oppositional", "Power," “Perfectionist”, and "Competitive" styles of life. I strongly agree with this. I've always went about with that mindset. I can honestly say that for every decision I have ever made, I have taken these particular "styles" into consideration. At work as well as in my social life I have a strong tendency to be all of those things. I look at it as a way to survive. I believe in Darwin's concept of survival of the fitness idea. In order for me to live up to that belief, I need to be strong in a society that requires an individual to have those aspects in life. If you are weak, not driven, and make......

Words: 1796 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Kkkk

...Examiners’ Report June 2013 GCE Geography 6GE03 01 Edexcel and BTEC Qualifications Edexcel and BTEC qualifications come from Pearson, the UK’s largest awarding body. We provide a wide range of qualifications including academic, vocational, occupational and specific programmes for employers. For further information visit our qualifications websites at www.edexcel.com or www.btec.co.uk. Alternatively, you can get in touch with us using the details on our contact us page at www.edexcel.com/contactus. Giving you insight to inform next steps ResultsPlus is Pearson’s free online service giving instant and detailed analysis of your students’ exam results. • See students’ scores for every exam question. • Understand how your students’ performance compares with class and national averages. • Identify potential topics, skills and types of question where students may need to develop their learning further. For more information on ResultsPlus, or to log in, visit www.edexcel.com/resultsplus. Your exams officer will be able to set up your ResultsPlus account in minutes via Edexcel Online. Pearson: helping people progress, everywhere Pearson aspires to be the world’s leading learning company. Our aim is to help everyone progress in their lives through education. We believe in every kind of learning, for all kinds of people, wherever they are in the world. We’ve been involved in education for over 150 years, and by working across 70 countries, in 100 languages, we have built an......

Words: 6917 - Pages: 28

Premium Essay

Discussion Bd 1

...to estimate the sales potential of your products in the domestic (U.S. or Canadian) market. Discuss key issues and concerns arising from the fact that you, the manager, are also the researcher. As the area sales manager I will conduct a predictive study. I understand why the decision for the information is needed for this research and the desired goals of the research. I understand that the desired outcome for the company is to estimate the sales potential of our product, the outboard engines, in the domestic market. Further, in order to conduct a quality research, I must have knowledge of market research and be able to interpret the results. Not being knowledgeable of market research could result in poor planning and interpretation of the research results (Marketing Research, 2012). This is sometimes a problem when managers of a company are given the responsibility to do research. In order to be successful in this research I must: a. identify and define opportunities and problems b. define, monitor, and refine strategies c. define, monitor, and refine tactics d. improve my understanding of the various fields of management As the area sales manager, I am knowledgeable of the product, and familiar with its performance. This will be a top tier research; all decisions will be guided by the research (Cooper & Schindler, 2011). Our goal is to obtain deep insights of what our sales potential will be in the domestic market......

Words: 2415 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Appliication of Image Search Engine

...IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON KNOWLEDGE AND DATA ENGINEERING, VOL. 25, NO. 10, OCTOBER 2013 2257 iLike: Bridging the Semantic Gap in Vertical Image Search by Integrating Text and Visual Features Yuxin Chen, Student Member, IEEE, Hariprasad Sampathkumar, Student Member, IEEE, Bo Luo, Member, IEEE Computer Society, and Xue-wen Chen, Senior Member, IEEE Abstract—With the development of Internet and Web 2.0, large-volume multimedia contents have been made available online. It is highly desired to provide easy accessibility to such contents, i.e., efficient and precise retrieval of images that satisfies users’ needs. Toward this goal, content-based image retrieval (CBIR) has been intensively studied in the research community, while text-based search is better adopted in the industry. Both approaches have inherent disadvantages and limitations. Therefore, unlike the great success of text search, web image search engines are still premature. In this paper, we present iLike, a vertical image search engine that integrates both textual and visual features to improve retrieval performance. We bridge the semantic gap by capturing the meaning of each text term in the visual feature space, and reweight visual features according to their significance to the query terms. We also bridge the user intention gap because we are able to infer the “visual meanings” behind the textual queries. Last but not least, we provide a visual thesaurus, which is generated from the statistical......

Words: 11319 - Pages: 46