Free Essay

Intership Report

In: Business and Management

Submitted By miskat
Words 1689
Pages 7
MBA 508: Management Information Systems (Sec 01)
CASE REPORT: Due Date: 1st October, 2014 Structure: • Questions are given at the end. • In total of 1500 words. • Explain in your own words. Evaluation: 10%

Information Systems Failure: The Case of Computer-Aided Dispatch (Cad) System at London Ambulance Service 1. Introduction The LAS covers a geographical area of just over 600 square miles and handles emergencies for a resident population of 6.8 million people. The CAD project is one of the most frequently quoted UK-based examples of information systems failure that took place in early 1990s. The prominence of this particular case is due to the ‘safety critical’ nature of this system and the claim that 20-30 people may have lost their lives as a result of CAD failure. 2. Description of the Manual Dispatch System The manual dispatch system consists of: a) call taking, b) resource identification, and c) resource mobilization. Call Taking: Emergency calls are received by ambulance control. Control assistants write down details of incidents on pre-printed forms. The location of each incident is identified and the reference co-ordinates are recorded on the forms. The forms are then placed on a conveyer belt which transports them to a central collection point. Resource Identification: Other members of ambulance control collect the forms, review the details on the forms and decide which resource allocator should deal with each incident. The resource allocator examines the forms for a particular sector, compares the details against information recorded for each vehicle and decides which resource should be mobilized. The status information on these forms is updated regularly from information received via the radio operator. The resource is recorded on the original form which is then passed on to a dispatcher. Resource mobilization: The dispatcher either telephones the nearest ambulance station or passes instructions to the radio operator if an ambulance is already mobile.

A number of problems exist with the manual dispatch system. Most problems are related to the time-consuming and error-prone nature of activities such as: identification of the precise location of an incident, the physical movement of paper forms, and maintaining up-to-date vehicle status information. Therefore, a Computer- Aided Dispatch (CAD) system was considered as a solution to overcome these problems. 3. The Computer-Aided Dispatch System 3.1 Purpose The objective of the CAD system was to automate many of the human-intensive processes involved in the manual dispatch system. 3.2 How the CAD system was intended to work The essential features of the CAD system are shown in Figure 1 which illustrates how the system was intended to work in practice. British Telecom (BT) operators would route all 999 calls concerning medical emergencies to LAS headquarters. A total of 18 ‘receivers’ were then expected to record on the system the name, telephone number and address of the caller, and the name, destination address and brief details of the patient. This information would then be transmitted over a LAN to an ‘allocator’. The system would pinpoint the patient’s location on a map. The system was also expected to monitor continuously the location of every ambulance via radio messages transmitted by each vehicle. The system would then determine the nearest ambulance to the patient.

Figure 1: The structure of CAD system at LAS

Experienced ambulance ‘dispatchers’ were organized into teams based on three zones (south, north-east, and north-west). Dispatchers would be offered details of the three nearest ambulances by the system and the estimated time each would need to reach the scene. The dispatcher would choose an ambulance and send patient details to a small terminal screen located on the dashboard of the ambulance. The ambulance crew would then be expected to confirm that it was on its way. If the selected ambulance was in an ambulance depot then the dispatch message would be received on the station computer. The ambulance crew would always be expected to acknowledge a message. The system would automatically alter HQ of any ambulance where no acknowledgement was made. A follow-up message would then be sent from HQ. The system would detect messages that would tell HQ when the ambulance crew had arrived, when it was on its way to a hospital and when it was free again. 3.3 How the CAD system was built The CAD system was built as an event-based system using a rule-based approach and was intended to interact with a geographical information system (GIS). The system was built by a small software house called Systems Options using their own GIS software (WINGS) running under Microsoft Windows. The GIS communicated with Datatrak’s automatic vehicle tracking system. The system ran on a series of network PCs and file servers supplied by Apricot. 4. Events that Identified the Flaws of the CAD System On the night of the 26th October 1992 (Monday), things started to go wrong at the HQ of LAS. A flood of 999 calls apparently swamped operators’ screens and many of those calls were being wiped off screens for unknown reasons. Claims were later made that 20 to 30 people may have died as a result of ambulance arriving late on the scene. Some ambulances took over three hours to answer a call while the government’s recommended maximum was 17 minutes. Mr. John Wilby, the chief executive officer of LAS resigned within a couple of days of this event. A number of Members of Parliament called for a public inquiry. The Health Secretary initiated an inquiry and the findings were eventually published in an 80-page report in February, 1993, which immediately became headline news in both the computing and the national press. 5. Findings of the Inquiry The inquiry found evidence of poor management practice, high technological complexities and unfavorable operating environment involved in the implementation of the CAD system in LAS. Systems Options, the company responsible for developing the major part of the CAD system had no previous experience of building similar type of systems. This company, which had won the £1.1 million contract for the development of the CAD system in June 1991, was found to have substantially underbid an established supplier (McDonnellDouglas). Hence, Systems Options was under serious pressure to complete the system

quickly. The managing director of a competing software house wrote various memoranda to LAS management in June and July 1991 describing the project as ‘totally and fatally flawed’. It appeared that Mr. Wilby ignored what amounted to an over-ambitious project timetable. Furthermore, an audit report by Anderson Consulting which called for more finance and longer time scales for the CAD project was suppressed by the project managers. The board of management of LAS was even misled by the project team over the experience of Systems Options and the references supplied by Systems Options were not thoroughly investigated. Due to the extreme time pressure to develop the CAD system within the allocated timeframe, the project team responsible for developing the system practically did not follow any standard systems development approach. As a result, the resultant software was incomplete and unstable. In January 1992, phases one and two of the project began live trials. In March 1992, phase two of the trials was temporarily suspended due to the discovery of system errors. In October 1992, phase three was terminated after two days of reported chaos described above. Questions were raised about the complexity of the technical system. In the manual dispatch system, communication between HQ and ambulances is conducted via telephone or voice radio links. In the CAD system, links between communication, logging and dispatching via a GIS were meant to be automated. The automation was completed but no performance testing was thoroughly performed due to the rushed approach to meet the deadline. The system was lightly loaded at start-up on the 26th October, 1992. Any problems, caused by the communications systems (e.g. ambulance crews pressing wrong buttons, or ambulances being in radio black spots) could be effectively managed by staff. However, as the number of ambulance incidents increased, the amount of incorrect vehicle information recorded by the system also increased. This had a knock-on effect in that the system made incorrect allocations on the basis of the information that it had. For example, multiple vehicles were sent to the same incident, or the closet vehicle was not chosen for the dispatch. As a result, the system had fewer ambulance resources to allocate. At the receiving end, patients became frustrated with the delays to ambulances arriving at incidents. This led to an increase in the number of calls made back to the LAS HQ relating to already recorded incidents. The increased volume of calls, together with a slow system and an insufficient number of call-takers, contributed to significant delays in answering the telephones which, in turn, caused further delays to patients. At the ambulance end, crews became increasingly frustrated at incorrect allocations and this led to an increased number of instances where they failed to press the right status buttons. The system therefore appears to have been in a vicious circle of cause and effect.

There was also an apparent mismatch of perspectives among LAS management, HQ staff, and ambulance staff. The system has been described as being introduced in an atmosphere of mistrust by staff. There was incomplete ownership of the system by the majority of LAS staff. The hardware and software suppliers involved in this project reported low staff morale and friction between LAS management and workforce. In other words, an atmosphere of hostility towards the computing systems was observed. One of the reasons for low staff morale was that control room staff lacked previous experience of using computer systems. 6. Conclusion In summary, no single element of the case can be regarded as the sole cause for the failure of the CAD system in LAS. The description demonstrates that failure of information systems projects tend to be multi-faceted in nature.

Discuss Questions: a) Discuss the failures occurred in this case with proper examples. c) What lessons can be learned from the failure of the CAD project in LAS?

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Intership Report Outline for Ba

...Outline for Internship Report Word length: Minimum 10 pages, maximum 20 pages (excludes Cover page, Reference list & Appendices) 1. First Page (Cover page) First page should display: Student name and surname, internship start and finish dates, number of internship days, type of internship (marketing, finance, production, or design and development, etc.), company/institution name. 2. A Brief Executive Summary of the Internship (5%) A one page summary of the company/institution and a short account of the major activities carried out during the internship period. 3. Description of the company/institution (15%) This section should provide following information: - The full title of the company/institution; Give a brief history of the company, full mailing address and relevant web links. - The type of ownership of the company/institution; State the main shareholders. - The sector that the company/institution operates in; Specify the products and services produced and offered to its customers. - Who are regarded as the customers of your internship company/institution (consider the end users, retailers, other manufacturers, employees, etc.)? - Provide an organization chart of the company, along with information on the number of employees. - Describe the main responsible of different functions in the company - Provide the information of performance of the company (financial status, sales, market share...

Words: 1258 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Cv-Dhn

...Work history 09/2012 – 09/2013 Agribank, Dong Nai – Apprentice (Accountant) - Check and arrange accounting records - Domestic remittance - Switch over organizations’ salary of the employees and expenses - Help customers to make a deposit or transfer of money => Build up specialist knowledge about accountancy such as general ledger accounting, budget forecasting, reports and cash-flow analysis, cash handling. 04/ 2012 – 08/2012 ACB, HCMC - Apprentice (Auditing) - Arrange documents - Typing documents and loan applications => Improve knowledge about auditing, financial forecasting and meticulous attention to detail. 01/2011 – 01/2012 Café Me, HCMC - Accountant - Organizing, calculating budget and implementing marketing plan for Chirstmas and Halloween events. - Recruit and training new staff. Distribute work for staffs - Summarize, input and inventory receipts. Make balance sheet everyday => Improve marketing knowledge, organizing event, calculation skill, schedule management . Education 08/2009 – 09/2013 Open University, HCMC Bachelor of Finance and Banking Degree classification: Good Intership topic: Analyzing position of consumer credit 2009-2011 at ACB Project Involvement - Setting up and calculating expenses for a mini-smoothie shop - Analyzing financing statement and finding solutions for Comeco - Materials Petroleum Joint Stock Company (Project in university) - Analyzing 4 stocks on HCMC Stock Exchange, using Solver and giving suitable......

Words: 367 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Bio Data

...to maintain their day to day transactions.Using this software, they can maintain the transactions like vehicles registration, servicing transaction / history, billing, maintaining customer history also it produce various reports. | Project 2 | Four Wheeler Parking System | SEM | MCA - SEM 3 | Technologies | CSS, HTML, JavaScript, MySQL | Duration | 6 Months | Team Size | 4 | Synopsis: | In PG, I have developed the software for four wheeler parking system on the Web platform.Using this software,user can calculate theparking charges on the basis of parking timing. Also it maintains the visit history of every vehicle. | Project 3 | EMPLOYEE DIRECTORY | SEM | MCA - SEM 4 | Technologies | Android SDK , ECLIPSE, SQLITE | Duration | 6 Months | Team Size | 4 | Synopsis: | In PG, I have developed the Employee Directorysoftware on Android platform.This application can be used by any organization to maintain their employee details.Using this software, user can search employee, get employee details, call employee and send email/ SMS. | Internship Porject | Massive Open Online Course System | SEM | MCA - SEM 6 | Technologies | Apache Structs2.0,HiberNate3.5, JSP,MySQL5.1.68 | Duration | 6 Months | Synopsis: | During Intership, I work on Massive Open Online Course System. On Java PlatformThis system can be used by any organization to give all details of various universities And available courses and courses details in the university . The......

Words: 451 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Proposal of Nbl

...AN INTERSHIP REPORT ON Customer Service Department & Remittance Department OF Nepal BANK LIMITED Submitted By: Birat Raut Everest Engineering & Management College Exam Roll No.: 11450214 PU Registration Number: 2010-2-45-0165 BBA-BI 6th Semester Submitted To: Office of the Dean Faculty of Management Pokhara University In the partial fulfillment of the requirement for the degree of Bachelor in Business Administration –Banking & Insurance (BBA-BI) Sitapaila, Kathmandu Date: 21st September, 2013 INTRODUCTION Nowadays, people are becoming more aware about the importance of education. Due to this reason, many schools and colleges are emerging every day. Among the various universities governing the colleges, Pokahara Univrsity (P.U.) is popular university of Nepal, which brings the courses with the demand of present scenario. So, with the increasing demand of the Management studies, P.U. has gradually prepared an innovative course in order to originate the competent professionals with the changing demands of corporate world since 2005 A.D. Among different management courses of P.U., Bachelor in Business Administration in Banking and Insurance (BBA-BI) is one of the best management courses which also includes the insurance sector. The BBA – B&I is a four-year program spread over eight semesters. A student needs to successful complete 126 credit hours of course work, project work and internship for......

Words: 1230 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Geriatric

...a caregiver to assure the elder’s basic needs or to protect the elder from harm. Unfortunately, no research has been conducted on how many people are suffering from elder abuse and neglect. It appears that female elders are abused at a higher rate than males and that the older one is, more likely one is to be abused. Economic and social factors that intensify risk are also widespread in communities, including scarcity, which may add to or be misinterpreted for abandonment and self-neglect(National Association of Elder Abuse,2013). Signs of elder abuse may be missed by professionals working with older Americans because of lack of training on detecting abuse. The elderly may be reluctant to report abuse themselves because of fear of revenge, lack of physical and/or cognitive ability to report, or because they don’t want to get the attacker (90% of whom are family members) in trouble (Dong X, 2009). Research has also shown that victims of elder abuse have had significantly higher levels of psychological distress and lower perceived self-efficacy than older adults who have not been victimized (Comijs, H.C, 1991). In addition; older adults who are victims of violence have additional health care problems than other older adults. 2 Heightened demands on caregivers, the lack of resources, improperly trained workers, and other factors, add to the risk. I have always been fascinated by the security, aging, health and wellness process of old age (Comijs, H.C,1991). I see the many......

Words: 1250 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Hrm Practice of First Security Islami Bank

... Intership Report On Human Resource Management Practices of the Bangladesh Shilpa Bank (BSB) INTRODUCTION HRM is the strategic and coherent approach to the management of an organization’s most valued assets. The people working there who individually and collectively contribute to the achievement of the objective of the business. HRM and HR have largely replaced the term “Personnel management” as a descriptive of the process involved in managing people in an organization. HRM is evolving rapidly. HRM is both an academic theory and a business practice that address the theoretical and practical techniques of managing a workforce. Employees play a dual role in an organization first as a factor of production and second as a motive force for other factors of production. It makes other factors operative and productive. People are the most valuable asset of an organization. Yet human assets are virtually never shown on the balance sheet OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY This report will mainly focus on Human Resource Management9 HRM) practices of BSB. The proposed study will cover all HRM functions of BSB. The main objective of the study is to get an overall idea about HRM practices of BSB. The specific objective are as follows: v To understand about activities of various department and their key responsibilities. v To know the overall function of BSB for the contribution of industrialization of the country. v To show a concrete overview of HRM practices of the BSB. v To develop......

Words: 4129 - Pages: 17

Premium Essay

Paper

...(100% positive chance). Self-efficacy, or the belief that a person has the capabilities to complete a task, also influences expectancy. In the business world, self-efficacy can be described as an employee’s self-confidence in completing tasks. Employees who feel more confident about completing a specific task are more likely to have higher levels of expectancy. An employee who has a high level of expectancy will choose more difficult tasks and will be motivated to complete those tasks (Colquitt, LePine, & Wesson, 2010, p. 98). The last two aspects of the expectancy theory are instrumentality and valence of rewards. Instrumentality represents the idea that successful work will result in some sort of outcome. Unfortunately, evidence reports that a large number of businesspeople believed that upper management was the key determinant for their pay, instead of successful work. The final feature of the expectancy theory is the idea of valence of rewards. Valence can be described as the value of outcomes associated with performance. Employers must understand the expectancy theory when motivating employees. It is important that managers work to increase self-efficacy, ensure instrumentality, and assign a proper valence of rewards (Colquitt, LePine, & Wesson, 2010, pp. 98-100). The goal setting theory of motivation can also be a positive way to encourage employees. The goal setting theory is defined as motivating employees by clarifying role perceptions and establishing......

Words: 7330 - Pages: 30

Premium Essay

Marketing and Management of Petro Aviation Bangladesh

...University of Dhaka. I have completed my 4th year and therefore I have to conduct a 3 month internship. The reason I choose to do my internship in tour operating organization is because I wanted to benefit from the experience. I wanted to do my internship in a tour operating company to experience the tour operating business world and to learning, improve and develop new sets of skills. One of my main goals is to improve my management and marketing skill. This is why I choose to follow my internship in petro aviation; to learn and develop new sets of skills and to experience working with tour operators. In this internship report I will describe my experiences during my internship period. The internship report contains an overview of the internship company and the activities, tasks and projects that I have worked on during my internship. Writing this report, I also will describe and reflect my learning objects and personal goals that I have set during my internship period. For this opportunity, I thank: Hasan shahid, who is the CEO of petro aviation and my job coach. I want to thank him for giving me the opportunity to follow my internship at his company. He had the kindness to accept me in her company and guide me through my internship with advice, feedback and tips despite his busy schedule. Taklima sayeda, who is my university’s internship supervisor. She helped and coached me during my internship by giving me feedback and tips on how to handle......

Words: 11246 - Pages: 45

Premium Essay

Advanced Management Accounting

...intellectual capital. The results of this study indicate that, through HC management practices, this group of hotels engaged in value extraction rather than value creation as a way of maximizing the value of the firm. This study analyses human capital (HC) management practices in a small privately owned public hotel group, in the context of intellectual capital. This paper presents the findings of research into the HC management practices of a group of privately owned small hotels in the public hotel industry in Australia. This study analyses these practices using multiple data methods; namely, observation, interaction with staff, examination of internal financial and management reports, and semi-structured case study interviews on a continuous basis over a one-year period. The monthly management reports of the group showed that employees are used as a resource base for value extraction, through funding received from the government for off-the-job training. However, a more in-depth analysis of the management of HC could be obtained by the researcher being located within the firm on a continuous basis over a period of time, during which he/she would interact with the staff and directors and analyse the firm’s internal documents. Second, the validity and reliability of the method and outcomes of the study was strengthened by the use of multiple data-collection methods, the research setting cannot be replicated, as business processes and systems change over time, and......

Words: 9295 - Pages: 38

Premium Essay

Casestudy

...INTERSHIP REPORT ON MCB BANK LIMITED U.P MORE BRANCH KARACHI BY MISBAH NOOR M.COM (FINANCE) DEPARTMENT OF COMMERCE JINNAH UNIVERSITY OF WOMEN 12TH SEP, 2013 ACKNOWLEDGEMENT All praise to Allah, the Beneficent, the merciful, and respect for His Prophet “Peace Be upon Him” who made us recognize our creator. I am also thankful to all the staff members of MCB who provided me a friendly and knowledgeable environment through which I have learned a lot. DEDICATION | My all internship work is dedicated to all the staff members of MCB U.P MORE BRANCH (1421) Karachi. * Shahvaiz Siddiqui (Operation Manager) * Farhana Ansari (Supervisor) * Mohsin Saleem, Shazia Asif, Mohammad Muslim (General banking officer) * Shoaib Damri (Clearing) * Saad. Faraz (Customer Service Officer) They are too much supportive and teach me how to learn a practical life. They always give me different tasks which bring more knowledge to me and guide me how to accomplish these tasks.   EXECUTIVE SUMMARY MCB bank limited has a solid foundation over 60 years in Pakistan with a network of over 1150 branches over 850 of which are automated branches, over 350 MCB ATMs in 41 cities nationwide and a network of over 12 bank on the MNET ATM switch. MCB operation continued to be streamlined with focus on rationalization of expenses, re-alignment of back-end processing to increase productivity, enhancement of customer service standard, process efficiency and...

Words: 12394 - Pages: 50

Premium Essay

Aibl

...INTERNSHIP REPORT ON Marketing practices and policies of Al-Arafah Islami Bank Ltd. Rawnak Jamal Adnan. ID: 07882795 Department of Marketing, Jagannath University . To, Mr.Md.Mahathy Hassan Jewel Lecturer Department of Marketing Jagannath University, Dhaka Letter of Transmittal 15th October, 2012 Supervisor Mr.Md.Mahathy Hassan Jewel Lecturer Department of Marketing Jagannath University, Bangladesh. Subject: Submission of the internship working report. Dear Sir, With great pleasure I have prepared this Internship Report on Al-Arafah Islami Bank Ltd. Hopefully this report will provide you a good insight about the marketing practice in bank’s activities. It was a wonderful experience working on this report. I would, therefore, thank you for giving me the opportunity to undertake the preparation of this report. I am grateful for your kind co-operation and immense support. To prepare this report I have tried my best to accumulate relevant information from all available sources. Thanking you once again. Rawnak Jamal Adnan ID No: 07882795 Session: 2007-2008(2ND batch) BBA, Department of Marketing AL-ARAFAH ISLAMI BANK LIMITED Banani Branch, 16 Kamal Ataturk Avenue, Dhaka. Phone:......

Words: 15013 - Pages: 61

Premium Essay

Mumbai Dabbawala

...SUMMER INTERSHIP PROJECT REPORT ON “Dabbawala Employee Satisfaction Survey” At Mumbai Dabbawala SUBMITTED IN THE PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIRMENT FOR THE DEGREE OF MASTER OF BUSINESS ADMINISTRATION BY SHRISH PRATAP SINGH Roll no – (0844370026) (2008-2010) EXCEL SCHOOL OF BUSINESS MATHURA (U.P) (Affiliated to U.P.Technical University,Lucknow) ACKNOWLEDEMENT A task undertaken without offering prayers to almighty and taking blessings from the elders is not a good beginning. Likewise the work completed without acknowledging the assistance to those who were always by my sides to make my efforts fruitful in the task left incomplete. In the beginning, I would like to express my sincere thanks to my Institute teachers for giving me an opportunity to take the practical experience of working life. I convey my sincere thanks to Mr Raghunath Medge or providing me the proper guidance and Mrs. Priyankya Gautam for providing me the opportunity to carry out research effectively and efficiently. I would also like to pay thanks to all my classmates and friends and my family members for co-operating with me and helping me to complete the project. (SHRISH PRATAP SINGH) PREFACE Quality without creativity is meaningless. As changes grow ever more unpredictable creativity is rapidly becoming recognized a core management skill. Today’s business environment demands that managers posses a wide range of knowledge skills and competencies, as well as sound understanding of......

Words: 14614 - Pages: 59