Free Essay

Iq and Heritability

In: Science

Submitted By Muyajohakim2016
Words 1101
Pages 5
IQ and Heritability
According to studies conducted by researchers, it has been shown that genetic factors affect the IQ of a person, and specific genes that take part in influencing the IQ have been identified. The studies have also proposed that performance is affected by genetic factors. However, it has not been clear whether the genes that shape the IQ are the same genes that influence test scores and grades. The high heritability of intelligence proves to be a difficult subject because it may be perceived to imply that the communities or schools that perform poorly produce unfavorable results due to the immutable characteristics present in those populations. This may imply that the poor kids should be left alone just because they are created that way.
However, comprehending the reason why the school system is difficult for some people while being easy for others is important to enabling the researchers to come up with a system that suits the individual strengths of the communities and schools involved. Again, high heritability does not imply total heritability because there is yet another vital role of the environment that requires much consideration, an aspect that informs the scholars of the field of intelligence inheritability how the results can be improved through a change in the environment. A population exhibiting high rate of heritability may be interpreted as a symbol of equality in the sense that environment would be the dominant factor, or it can’t vary radically. For instance, taking height to be an example, people grow to be shorter or taller adults due to the combination of various environmental factors such as nutrition during their early childhood, with their genes.
A country that exhibits high inequality, where some of the children receive excellent or adequate childhood nutrition while the others starve, nutrition will have a very vital role in determination of the height that people can grow without considering their genetic make-up, since the children possessing the genetic ability to be tall may be stunted by unfavorable environment. Likewise, in a population where everyone receives excellent nutrition, the height of the people will largely be determined by the genetic heritability. Considering the effect of environmental factors to the IQ of a person, it is important to use the same perspective for education. When all the learners receive exactly the same quality of education and are exposed to similar good life at home, their tendencies and inherited traits will have an important role to play in their final results. When some of the learners receive better quality education as others receive poorer quality, the educational aspect will have an important role to play in determining the extent to which the learners can reach academically.
This also implies that an approximation of heritability among a population can’t be extended to another population. For instance, since the population of twin study may represent the overall population in the UK, it is possibly safe to come up with conclusions regarding the UK as a country. However, it is hard to conclude much regarding the exact rate of heritability in another country, though it may be expected that other factors apart from intelligence have very crucial roles to play in school results.
Referring to the ancient investment theory, intelligence may be categorized into two major classes, which are: crystallized and fluid. Differences present in fluid intelligence are believed to exhibit novel and reasoning on the spot, while the differences present in crystallized intelligence are believed to exhibit knowledge and skills that have been acquired previously. Crystallized intelligence, according to the investment theory, develops through investing fluid intelligence in a specific body of knowledge. There is a clear prediction of this theory considering genetics. In a vast population, where the educational experiences of the people differ, inheritance of the fluid intelligence is likely to be higher than the inheritance of crystallized intelligence. The investment theory makes the assumption that the fluid intelligence is relatively fixed and it is influenced heavily by genes, while crystallized intelligence depends highly on the learning opportunities and acquired skills.
Kees-Jan Kan and his colleagues carried out an analysis of 23 independent twin studies results carried out, totaling to 7,852 people sample. The study team investigated how the coefficients of heritability vary across particular cognitive abilities. The study majorly assessed the “Cultural load” of different abilities by considering the average percentage of the adjusted test items when the test was used in 13 other countries. According to the results of the study by Kees-Jan Kan and his colleagues, the societal demands have greater impacts on developing and interacting the multiple cognitive knowledge and abilities, therefore, leading to better correlations among each other, resulting to the general intelligence factor. For the sake of clarity, the findings do not seek to imply that the differences in intelligence are fully determined by culture. Various researchers have discovered that genes have strong influence to the structure of cognitive abilities, and they suggest that education, culture, and experience play major roles in developing intelligence than the assumptions of the mainstream theories of intelligence.
There is a possibility that the Western society has a learning environment that is homogenous, where all the school systems are similar. Again, everyone has undergone similar educational experiences, therefore, the only difference stems in the cognitive ability. The other probability is that there is some truth in the traditional investment theory, and crystallized intelligence, for example, general knowledge and vocabulary, is more cognitively important than looking for the solution of the abstract reasoning tests that are most complex. To prove this as the truth, vocabulary tests, for example, would have much dependence on the IQ than the fluid intelligence.
The researchers in behavioral genetics field, who often parse out the environmental and genetic sources of variation, sometimes operate using the assumption that environment and genotype do not co-vary, and are independent.
There are Black-White differences in the IQ test scores. While analyzing the data of the US Army, Charles Spearman, who is a British psychometrician, discovered that the extent of the black-white differences on a test was directly related to the correlation with IQ of the same test. Arthur Jensen formulated a full-fledged theory years later which he called “Spearman’s hypothesis”, which says that there is a direct proportion between the test correlation with IQ and the extent of black-white differences on cognitive ability tests. In the year 2005, Jensen, together with Philippe Rushton teamed up and made the case in a controversial paper that there is a proof that black-white differences are genetic in origin.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Intelligence Environmental Factors

...Spearman’s g is known as the basic general factor of mental ability and as Toga (2005) mentions there has been many psychometric and twin studies which have used this cognitive testing to quantify intellectual function. Intelligence has been quantified throughout decades through the completion of an IQ test. The IQ test which was first created by German psychologist Wilhelm Stern has been widely used over the years for admission to jobs, schools, colleges etc. (Toga & Thompson 2005). IQ tests come in different forms, but they typically assess visuospatial, deductive, semantic, and symbolic reasoning ability. This form of intellectual measuring, even though it may seem like a standard measurement of intelligence has a number of oppositions. In some cases it was seen as an unfair judgement, in 1960 there was an study done in schools in America testing the kids IQ but some schools rejected this due to their thought that there may be cultural biased in the questioning which at the time caused a back lash for psychometric testing (Toga & Thompson...

Words: 1450 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Child Prodigy

...Is There Any Genetic Evidence to Explain Why Musical Prodigies Exist? Kristina Vianca Constantino Tabuena San Diego Miramar College Abstract By definition, one is considered a musical child prodigy if he or she possesses an exceptional ability, at a professional level, for music at a young age. Musical ability is defined as the capacity for music perception and production. This is really interesting because the children looks like they have been hand-picked by nature to have these gifts since they have parents who are just like any of us. This phenomenon has been known for a long time, however, there are only a few researches that have been done about this and that is why we hardly understand why musical geniuses exist and how come it is not common at all. Some theories suggest that prodigies are linked to autism. Some of these children have been treated as subjects for long-term researches to find any genetic factors that will link a trait that characterizes being a musical prodigy. The phenomenon of musical geniuses is a product of both genetic factors, as seen in their family background and link to autism, and environmental factors like family support and their devotion to practice. Methods I chose this topic because I find musical prodigies very interesting. I already started researching about them since I have been watching documentaries and following news about them. I watched a documentary about a polyglot, a master of multiple languages, named Tim Doner and I...

Words: 2698 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Summary Of Tokyll And Robby

...To begin with, both Warwick and Flynn challenge the foundation of intelligence. Warwick establishes and develops his claim by stating that all IQ tests are subjective. First, he addresses the possible misunderstandings on the concept of intelligence. Warwick states, “Any attempts to define intelligence that do not involve identifying specially valued cultural attainments must fail (Warwick 199).”Oftentimes, humans see themselves being on top of the ladder simply because they arrange and connect every aspect according to their own standards and values. However, it is in fact improbable and pointless to compare the mental and physical abilities between two species, except referring to specific assignments. Warwick successfully clears up the assumption...

Words: 1243 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Nature vs Nurture

...Introduction The phrase “nature versus nurture” was first used in its modern interpretation by the British psychologist, Francis Galton (Princeton, 2012). He began his studies concerning heredity in 1865, being moderately influenced by Charles Darwin’s publication “Origin of Species”, Galton was in favor of the idea that success was caused by superior inherited qualities, he hypothesized that human mental and personality traits were fundamentally inherited as they are in other animals (Indiana, 2012). The purpose of this paper is to establish which qualities relating to personality and development are proven to be at least partly inherited, and whether some other aspects of human personality and development are caused by environmental factors. The first section of the paper will be a brief overview of the research methodology of this field, the second section will contain a discussion of research relating to heritable factors and how they influence development, the third a look at how environmental interaction might influence personality and finally some criticism towards this field of study. Main Body The research of genetics and heredity is often difficult due to the vast amount of variables in the development of human beings, to keep variables to a minimum the most popular method of research in this field the study of twins. Twin studies involve comparing data produced by monozygotic (Identical) twins , these are twins who come from the same...

Words: 1767 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Ese210

...Lecture 11 Notes: 1) (a) Mere exposure, even in great quantities, DOES NOT necessarily lead to substantial declarative knowledge that would allow us to remember seemingly obvious facts (b) Brady et al suggests that when people pay close attention, even one exposure is sufficient to recognize, non obvious information. 2) a) Recall is coming up with information about a memory when given a cue to that memory, like imagining what a penny is like when someone asks you to imagine a penny. b) Recognition is just identifying something as familiar, when cued with the training object. Usually this is the easier method a) Learning DOES change your brain. Learning happens in the brain, therefore the brain changes when we learn. b) Jenkins and Merzenich showed that repeated tasks altered the size of the cortical regions related to that task, enlarging the neural area responsible for sensing the fingertips relative to more proximal parts of the hand. 1) a) The knowledge is a corpus found in London cab drivers. c) London cab drivers are found to have significantly larger posterior hippocampi d) People with larger PH have better memories. e) Those who learned to juggle showed an increase in grey matter. f) There is a casual relationship between learning and neurological change. 2) A) Understand what you are trying to learn. g) Use recall based methods more than recognition based methods h) Use flash cards...

Words: 2005 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Statistical

...“SCIENCE FICTION OR SCIENCE FACT” ARE WHITES INHERENTLY MORE INTELLIGENT THAN BLACKS ? ( Delroy Constantine-Simms University of Essex (UK) & Marciea Monique McMillian University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill (USA) ABSTRACT The publication of Hernstein & Murray’s (1994) “The Bell Curve” appears to be the latest expression of pseudo scientific theories with respect to race and intelligence. This paper gives an historical and ideological insight behind the development and application of intelligence tests by citing examples of their impact on legislation, social policy and intervention programmes in relation to Blacks. More importantly, a discussion of cultural bias in test design focuses on the response of Black psychologists who developed Black intelligence tests that portray whites as intellectually inferior in the same manner that Blacks are portrayed as intellectually inferior on tests devised by white psychologist. Furthermore, The hereditary perspective of intelligence is challenged by empirical evidence that centres on children with white ancestry to assess whether white genes influence intelligence while citing several sources that support the environmental explanation of the race gap in test scores. Consequently, this discussion questions the reliability and validity of intelligence tests that are used to reinforce the Black intellectual inferiority myth. The conclusive argument suggests in no uncertain terms that the Bell Curve is nothing more than the repackaging...

Words: 5892 - Pages: 24

Free Essay

Jjjjjj

...Volume 10 Number 6 June 4, 2007 Black Intellectual Genocide: An Essay Review of IQ and the Wealth of Nations Girma Berhanu Göteborg University Sweden Lynn, Richard & Vanhanen, Tatu. (2002). IQ and the Wealth of Nations. Westport, CT: Praeger. Citation: Berhanu, Girma. (2007). Black intellectual genocide: An essay review of IQ and the Wealth of Nations. Education Review, 10(6). Retrieved [date] from http://edrev.asu.edu/essays/v10n6index.html. Abstract I review the book IQ and the Wealth of Nations, written by Richard Lynn and Tatu Vanhanen. I critique the authors’ major assertion that a significant part of the gap between rich and poor countries is due to differences in national intelligence. The authors claim that they have evidence that differences in national IQ account for substantial variation in per capita income and growth of a nation. This essay review debunks their assumptions that intellectual and income differences between nations stem from genetic differences. This critique provides an extended review of the research literature that argues against these assumptions and presents a different picture from that presented by Lynn and Vanhanen about the concept of intelligence, what IQ measures and does not measure. The essay exposes the racist, sexist, and antihuman nature of the research tradition in which the authors anchored their studies and the deep methodological flaws and theoretical assumptions that appear in their book. The low standards of scholarship...

Words: 13913 - Pages: 56

Premium Essay

Wnechie

... Nature • People are born with some innate abilities that they use to interact with and understand the world world. • Through prolonged use, learners will eventually achieve proficiency in the target language. Nurture • People are born “tabula rasa” (or blank slate) and become who they are through the course of their lives alone alone. • Students need to be taught their language. Naturists vs. Nurturists vs • Noam Chomsky oa C o s y • Stephen Krashen • Gardner • • • • Vygotsky ygots y Piaget Pavlov Skinner The Intelligence Quotient (IQ) • Test created in 1905 to predict which students would benefit from teaching. • Attempts to objectively measure “intelligence” intelligence • Scores are given as numbers that show the test taker’s results relative to others. • When adjusted for age, a person’s IQ generally does not vary greatly over the course of their life. • IQ tests can be given on various skills (linguistic, math, etc) Nurture Theories (Skinner) Behaviorism B h i i • Knowledge and Linguistic ability results from stimulus-response conditioning. • Focus is on controlling behavior not behavior, cognitive processes. •C Concerned only with d l ith observable/measurable behavior. Nurture Methods The Audio-lingual M th d Th A di li l Method • Based on Behaviorism – Positive reinforcement of desired production – Emphasis on “correctness” correctness – Seeks to create language habits – Repetition Nature...

Words: 772 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Week 7 Testing Intelligence

...to determine how close to their age they were. This was contributed to the I.Q. exam. The test arranges the chronological age of an individual as the denominator and the mental age as the numerator. This fraction is then multiplied by one hundred, coming up with the intelligence quotient for that individual. With the experimentation of the test, the determination can be made that an individual that has a mental age equal to their chronological age will have an I.Q. of one hundred. It can also be said, that someone with the mental age greater than their chronological age will have an I.Q. over one hundred. Averaging the test, the most common I.Q. score is one hundred. • Describe the kinds of characteristics commonly assessed in an IQ test. The approaches that determine the characteristics vary from test to test but the characteristics remain the same. Fluid and crystallized intelligence; Fluid intelligence would be one that would relate to information-processing-capabilities, memory, and reasoning. Crystallized intelligence relates to strategies learned from experience, along with information, skills. Gardner’s multiple intelligences; could be up to eight independent forms...

Words: 962 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Religion

...first workable intelligence test was A. “What needs to be done in order to ensure a strong military-industrial complex?” B. “What needs to be done in order to produce mathematically gifted students?” C. “How can individuals be helped in their striving for self-actualization?” D. “How can developmentally disabled children be taught more effectively?” 6. An 8-year-old child has just taken Alfred Binet’s test of intelligence and has been told his mental age is ten. This means that A. His chronological age must be nine. B. He is less intelligent than most 10-year-olds C. His score equals the score of the average 10- year-old D. He is probably developmentally disabled and in need of remedial education 7. You are asked to calculate an IQ score. If you were using Terman’s method, you would A. Add mental age to chronological age and divide the result by 100 B. Add 110 to mental age and then divide the result by chronological age C. Divide mental age by chronological age and...

Words: 2958 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Double Trouble

...Twins Photo: Twins A Thing or Two About Twins They have the same piercing eyes. The same color hair. One may be shy, while the other loves meeting new people. Discovering why identical twins differ—despite having the same DNA—could reveal a great deal about all of us. By Peter Miller Photograph by Martin Schoeller Every summer, on the first weekend in August, thousands of twins converge on Twinsburg, Ohio, a small town southeast of Cleveland named by identical twin brothers nearly two centuries ago. They come, two by two, for the Twins Days Festival, a three-day marathon of picnics, talent shows, and look-alike contests that has grown into one of the world's largest gatherings of twins. Dave and Don Wolf of Fenton, Michigan, have been coming to the festival for years. Like most twins who attend, they enjoy spending time with each other. In fact, during the past 18 years, the 53-year-old truckers, whose identical beards reach down to their chests, have driven more than three million miles together, hauling everything from diapers to canned soup from places like Seattle, Washington, to Camden, New Jersey. While one sits at the wheel of their diesel Freightliner, the other snoozes in the bunk behind him. They listen to the same country gospel stations on satellite radio, share the same Tea Party gripes about big government, and munch on the same road diet of pepperoni, apples, and mild cheddar cheese. On their days off they go hunting or fishing together. It's a way...

Words: 4063 - Pages: 17

Free Essay

Phyc One

...15. b Written 1. a. Approach 1 – to study adopted children. The adopted children’s traits are compared with their birthparents and the adoptive parents to compute heritability Approach 2 – to study identical twins that were raised apart. Therefore any of their similar traits must be related to heritability as they share all the same genes. These are also compared with traits of fraternal twins to obtain a better estimate. b. No you should practice if you want to keep improving. While some genes may make you a better flute player than average, you still require practice to improve your play. Many genes and gene expression influence musical ability, and these alone will not make you an excellent player. 2. The fatal flaw here, is that black children and white children have a much different upbringing on average. Black children grow up with worse nutrition, self-belief that they are not as smart, etc. The example used in the book relates this to two genetically identical tomato plants will grow differently depending on their environment. If one plant is grown with poor soil and light then it will grow poorly. These different growing pots can be related to the childhoods or growing pots of black and white children. They are much different, are therefore you cannot imply that black IQs are lower due to genetics. 3. In Milgram’s study the participants obeyed the demands only when the experimenter was in close proximity. The participants feared conflict and...

Words: 1222 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Project Concept

...Triarchic theory of intelligence From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia | This article relies on references to primary sources. Please add references to secondary or tertiary sources. (February 2012) | The triarchic theory of intelligence was formulated by Robert J. Sternberg, a prominent figure in the research of human intelligence. The theory by itself was groundbreaking in that it was among the first to go against the psychometric approach to intelligence and take a more cognitive approach. Sternberg’s definition of human intelligence is “(a) mental activity directed toward purposive adaptation to, selection and shaping of, real-world environments relevant to one’s life” (Sternberg, 1985, p. 45), which means that intelligence is how well an individual deals with environmental changes throughout their lifespan. Sternberg’s theory comprises three parts: componential, experiential, and practical. Contents * 1 Different components of information processing * 1.1 Componential / Analytical Subtheory * 1.2 Experiential / Creative Subtheory * 1.3 Practical / Contextual Subtheory * 2 Challenges * 3 See also * 4 References * 5 Bibliography Different components of information processing Schematic illustrating one trial of each stimulus pool in the Sternberg task: letter, word, object, spatial, grating. Sternberg associated the workings of the mind with a series of components. These components he labeled the metacomponents, performance...

Words: 1632 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Psy 100 Study Guide Exam #3

...PSY 100 STUDY GUIDE EXAM #3 CHAPTER 8 Memory Retrieval Serial Position Effect: Recall is superior for the items at the beginning and end of a list Primacy Effect: superior recall for items at the beginning of a list Recency Effect: superior recall for items at the end of a list Retrieval Cues Recall: individual must retrieve previously learned information (essay test) Recognition: individual only has to identify (“recognize”) learned items (multiple choice test) Encoding Specificity Principle: associations formed at the time of encoding or learning tend to be effective retrieval cues (ex. Mnemonics, semantic encoding) Priming: activating particular connections or association in memory Flashbulb Memories: memories of emotionally significant events that people often recall with more accuracy and vivid imagery than everyday events Factors involved in forgetting Challenges of Forgetting 1. Absent-mindedness: inattention to details produces encoding failure 2. Transience: storage decay over time 3. Blocking: inaccessibility of stored info Challenges of Distortion 4. Misattribution: confusion about source of info 5. Suggestibility: lingering effects of misinfo 6. Bias: belief-colored recollections Challenge of Intrusion 7. Persistence: unwanted memories Proactive Interference: info learned earlier interferes with recall or newer material; material that was learned earlier disrupts the recall of material learned later Retroactive Interference:...

Words: 1427 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Pysch Review

...Psychology Exam 3 Study Guide * Hierarchy of Language: * Phonemes: the smallest units of sound that are recognizable as speech rather than as random noise * Example: the “te” sound of T * Phonological Rules: indicate how phonemes can be combined to produce speech sounds * Example: the ‘”ts” sound is found in German, but not in English * Phonemes are combined to make morphemes: the smallest meaningful units of language * Example: “tele” as in television * Morphological Rules: indicate how morphemes can be combined to form words * Example: tele + phone = telephone * Content Morphemes: refer to things and events * Example: “cat” “dog” “take” * Function Morphemes: serve grammatical functions, such as tying sentences together or indicating time * Example: “and” “but” “when” * Function morphemes are what make human language grammatically complex enough to express abstract ideas * Syntactical Rules: indicate how words can be combined to form phrases and sentences. * Example: In English, every sentence must contain at least one noun and one verb * Deep Structure vs. Surface Structure: * Deep Structure: meaning of a sentence * Surface Structure: how a sentence is worded * Example: “the dog chased the cat” and “the cat was chased by the dog” have the same deep structure, but different surface structures *...

Words: 2111 - Pages: 9