Premium Essay

Irac Examples

In: Business and Management

Submitted By hoss1987
Words 278
Pages 2
9/27/15

Case 7.1

Bruesewitz v. Wyeth, LLC

I: Whether or not Wyeth was liable for its product, or vaccine?

R: NCVIA act allows people injured by a vaccine to file for compensation but the acts quid pro quo eliminates liability for a vaccine's unavoidable, adverse side effects. No fault compensation program

A: Acts quid pro quo provides an efficient compensation program for vaccine injuries; in exchange they avoid costly tort litigation

C: U.S Supreme Court affirmed the lower courts judgement and they can't bring further to any court because the party had received enough compensation from the act

7.2 Wilson Sporting Goods Co. v. Hickox

I: Whether there was product liability based on design defect

R: Consumer expectation test says a product is unreasonably dangerous when it fails to perform in the manner that would reasonably be expected by an ordinary consumer

A: An ordinary consumer would have expected the mask to perform more safely than other models and would have expected baseball masks to disperse rather than concentrate energy

C: The judgment of the court affirmed in favor of plaintiff

7.3 Johnson v. Medtronic, Inc.

I: Whether the plaintiff could pursue a theory of recovery alleging both a design defect and defect in warning label

R: Product is defective only when foreseeable risks posed by product could be reduced or avoided by reasonable instructions

A: They could not establish that the Medtronics use couldn’t be anticipated

C: The Missouri court said there was no inadequacy of Medtronics warnings, but could pursue claim alleging design defect; court affirmed trial courts decision in part and reversed it in part not favorable to...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Irac Fo

...rmWhat is IRAC? IRAC stands for Issue, Rule, Application, Conclusion. It is one way to structure legal analysis. An effective essay (no matter the overall length) follows some form of the IRAC structure where it is organized around each of these elements for each and every issue and subissue identified as a legal problem. IRAC is an extremely useful tool in organizing any law related essay answer. It is not the only way to structure an answer, but it helps to make sure all bases are covered. So, until you achieve the level of mental and written fluency where you can weave together rule and fact in a seamless tapestry and transition between thoughts without loss of either the substance or your reader, you might choose to rely on some form of IRAC to keep focused. Use IRAC as tool for organizing your thinking and your writing. Think of it as a weaving loom that is there only to support the threads of your argument, while you weave and create an intricately beautiful piece of fabric, i.e. a complete, logical argument. Soon, the process will become automatic and you will rely less and less on the loom. Until then, you have something you can rely on to guide you through the process. How to IRAC 1. State the issue The issue is the most important element in the analysis and must be stated in a way to show what is in controversy. The legal question weaves together the rule and the facts particular to the problem you identified. Articulate the issue by creating the legal question...

Words: 1126 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

How to Brief a Case

...How to Brief a Case Using the “IRAC” Method When briefing a case, your goal is to reduce the information from the case into a format that will provide you with a helpful reference in class and for review. Most importantly, by “briefing” a case, you will grasp the problem the court faced (the issue); the relevant law the court used to solve it (the rule); how the court applied the rule to the facts (the application or “analysis”); and the outcome (the conclusion). You will then be ready to not only discuss the case, but to compare and contrast it to other cases involving a similar issue. Before attempting to “brief” a case, read the case at least once. Follow the “IRAC” method in briefing cases: Facts* Write a brief summary of the facts as the court found them to be. Eliminate facts that are not relevant to the court’s analysis. For example, a business’s street address is probably not relevant to the court’s decision of the issue of whether the business that sold a defective product is liable for the resulting injuries to the plaintiff. However, suppose a customer who was assaulted as she left its store is suing the business. The customer claims that her injuries were the reasonably foreseeable result of the business’s failure to provide security patrols. If the business is located in an upscale neighborhood, then perhaps it could argue that its failure to provide security patrols is reasonable. If the business is located in a crime-ridden area, then......

Words: 910 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Unit 3

...H A P T E R 22 THE IRAC METHOD A. PURPOSES OF IRAC B. IRAC COMPONENTS 1. Issues 2. Rules of Law 3. Application of the Law to the Problem’s Facts 4. Conclusion 446 446 448 449 451 452 CHAPTER OVERVIEW The IRAC chapter focuses on the writing style used for the discussion portion of the memo. IRAC is an acronym for Issue, Rule, Application, Conclusion. These are the building blocks of a memo’s discussion. You will learn to identify issues and applicable legal authority. You will also learn how to extract the legally significant facts and apply them to the relevant law to draw substantiated conclusions. You will learn to identify effective IRAC use by dissecting discussions and labeling the IRAC components, and you will learn to draft IRAC sequences as well. 445 446 CHAPTER 22 / THE IRAC METHOD A. PURPOSES OF IRAC ! What Is IRAC? IRAC stands for Issue, Rule, Application, Conclusion. IRAC is the architectural blueprint for the discussion portion of a legal memo. It gives legal writing continuity and clarity and organizes the contents of the discussion. IRAC provides legal support and analysis for the issues posed by the problem and guides the writer toward a well-supported conclusion. IRAC benefits both the writer and the reader because the components are essentially a checklist designed to ensure that the discussion is analytically well thought-out and that it contains the necessary legal authority. IRAC is very important......

Words: 5979 - Pages: 24

Free Essay

Mcclain V. Octagon

...IRAC Briefing Content IRAC--BRIEFING CASES For this course, use the IRAC method of briefing for your weekly assignments and for your group assignments. IRAC is: I: ISSUE: What is the question the court (or you in the weekly assignments) must decide? Sometimes there may be more than one issue. 2: RULE: What is the law that the court cites to decide the case? In your individual weekly assignments (not the group assignment) you must cite a page number in your text and the rule you are citing to answer the chapter question. 3: APPLICATION: This is the application of the rule to the facts in the case. 4: CONCLUSION: What does the court actually decide? For example, does the court rule in favor of the party that filed the suit, or the defending party? In the chapter questions, you must decide who prevails. Example: Read the Singer v. Raemisch case, Exhibit 1-6, pages 23-25 in your textbook. Here is how that case might be briefed using the IRAC method. Issue: Can a prison, consistent with the First Amendment, restrict inmates’ speech, when that restriction is reasonably viewed as promoting prison security? Rule: Prison regulations that restrict inmates' constitutional rights are nevertheless valid if they are reasonably related to legitimate penological interests. Page 24. [Notice this is a general statement taken from case law or statutory law, and which would apply to any case that has similar facts.] Application: The D& D ban “bears a rational relationship” to......

Words: 396 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Syllabus

...SYLLABUS LAW/531 Business Law Copyright ©2014 by University of Phoenix. All rights reserved. Course Description This course prepares students to evaluate the legal risks associated with business activity. Students create proposals to manage an organization's legal exposure. Other topics include the legal system, alternative dispute resolution, enterprise liability, product liability, international law, business risks, intellectual property, legal forms of business, and governance. Course Dates Oct 14, 2014 - Nov 24, 2014 Faculty Information Name : Email Address : Alternate Email Address Phone Number : ADRIENNE YEUNG (PRIMARY) Not Available Policies Faculty and students/learners will be held responsible for understanding and adhering to all policies contained within the following two documents (both located on your student website): • Academic Policies University policies are subject to change. Be sure to read the policies at the beginning of each class. Policies may be slightly different depending on the modality in which you attend class. If you have recently changed modalities, read the policies governing your current class modality. Get Ready for Class • Familiarize yourself with the textbook used in this course. Course Materials All electronic materials are available on your student website. Week1 Legal Forms of Business and Alternative Dispute Resolution Tasks • Review the Week 1 Study Guide. • Review the Knowledge Check Faculty and......

Words: 2154 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Irac Brief

...Week 5 IRAC Brief Norma Chavez Clara McKinnie Delia Silva Alejandra Solorzano LAW/531 March 26, 2014 Michael John Abstract NovaStaar Investments, LLC is a private company that was formed in 1999 for the sole purpose of taking control of Staar Surgical Company by offering shareholders $15 per share. NovaStaar’s offer was rebuffed by the then board. Since then several shareholders and board members have approached NovaStaar about their interest in the company. NovaStaar will not reveal their level of interest in Staar until several issues have been resolved. Specifically the lawsuits involving former Chairman of the Board Andrew F. Pollet. Mr. Pollet filed a lawsuit against a former employee alleging libel and defamation of character. Mr. Pollet is also involved in other court action where he allegedly asked Staar board members to forgive debts he had incurred by borrowing money from Staar and where he was accused of pilfering from Staar and using company funds to pay his personal expenses. Week 5 IRAC Brief Methods for managing legal risk Society must balance business interest and injury to prevent legal liability. To minimize liability of legal risk the business and the individual must first understand the process. Once the knowledge has been obtained then the necessary steps can be taken to eliminate and reduce the effects of the risks involved in order to prepare accordingly. Issues On June 3, 1993 in Texas, Novastaar Investments, LLC, an......

Words: 976 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Bus 230 Assignment Use the Irac Method

...BUS 230 Assignment Use the IRAC method Click Link Below To Buy: http://hwcampus.com/shop/bus-230-assignment-use-irac-method/ Use the IRAC method and ensure that you have identified the case problem. Case analyses are extremely helpful in that an analysis teaches you how to read a case. You will always want a heading which gives the case name and its citation . The facts help us decide whether another case is similar or dissimilar to the one we are looking at and helps us to predict what a court will do in the future. The issue is what the court is trying to decide. An easy way to write it is “whether… …when .” For example, an issue from one of the examples on page 9 of your text is “whether tobacco manufacturers have liability for the deaths of smokers when the manufacturers knew that smoking was harmful to the smokers’ health.” The ruling is the answer to the issue. Did the court affirm or reverse the lower court’s decision and happens next? Last, but not least, the reasons should tell the reader why the court decided the way it did. In your case, include statutes and/or cases the court relied upon in reaching its decision. Sources must be cited in APA format and the assignment should be between 4-6 pages in length using 12 point font and one inch margins. The case I have choosen is : IN RE IGLOO PRODUCTS CORP. NO. 14-07-00185-CV. 238 S.W.3d 574 (2007) The case of Joel Varelas family suing for a wrongful...

Words: 269 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Bus 230 Assignment Use the Irac Method

...BUS 230 Assignment Use the IRAC method Click Link Below To Buy: http://hwcampus.com/shop/bus-230-assignment-use-irac-method/ Use the IRAC method and ensure that you have identified the case problem. Case analyses are extremely helpful in that an analysis teaches you how to read a case. You will always want a heading which gives the case name and its citation . The facts help us decide whether another case is similar or dissimilar to the one we are looking at and helps us to predict what a court will do in the future. The issue is what the court is trying to decide. An easy way to write it is “whether… …when .” For example, an issue from one of the examples on page 9 of your text is “whether tobacco manufacturers have liability for the deaths of smokers when the manufacturers knew that smoking was harmful to the smokers’ health.” The ruling is the answer to the issue. Did the court affirm or reverse the lower court’s decision and happens next? Last, but not least, the reasons should tell the reader why the court decided the way it did. In your case, include statutes and/or cases the court relied upon in reaching its decision. Sources must be cited in APA format and the assignment should be between 4-6 pages in length using 12 point font and one inch margins. The case I have choosen is : IN RE IGLOO PRODUCTS CORP. NO. 14-07-00185-CV. 238 S.W.3d 574 (2007) The case of Joel Varelas family suing for a wrongful...

Words: 269 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Business Law

...what others have written is necessary. This guide attempts to provide you with some assistance in writing and referencing law academic papers. Some basic resource materials are also noted. [NB: This guide is a starting point only.] There are two types of Law Academic Papers Students who take the Business Law Major will inevitably be expected, at some stage, to answer at least two different styles of legal questions: legal case studies and essays. Legal case studies These are questions based on a set of hypothetical facts. The purpose of legal case study questions is both to engage you in problem solving and to consider the issues relevant to risk management. In particular, case studies test your ability to complete an IRAC analysis of the question. This analysis proceeds as follows: Issues • Identify a problem that has occurred for one or more of the parties. That is, what has gone wrong? Who has suffered?...

Words: 1487 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Irac Brief

...Risk Management- Drunken Patient Lawsuit LAW/531 February 17, 2014 Risk Management- Drunken Patient Lawsuit The IRAC method is an instructional tool that can aid students in the comprehension and evaluation of information so that they can make informed value decisions. It is an acronym for Issue, Rule, Analysis, and Conclusion. Although this is a legal model used to evaluate hypothetical situations in law cases, it is by no means limited to the study of the law. Useful for case studies presented in varied mediums such as narratives, videos/films, or recordings, the IRAC method may be applied to other activities such as defining a term or demonstrating a concept, principle, relationship, analogy, or contrasting idea. Often the instructional focus is on the end result of case study discussion rather than on how to "walk through" a method or approach to be used by the students in the case analysis (Bittner, M.1990). Issue: A recent court ruling should motivate hospital risk managers to conduct a careful periodic review of their facility's procedures and legal obligations when it comes to treating intoxicated patients. The patient, Kevin Kowalski, later wandered onto a nearby highway and was struck by a car, leaving him paralyzed below the neck. Throughout the case, Mr. Kowalski contended that even though he decided on his own to leave the hospital, the hospital should have prevented him from doing so based on his level of inebriation. Analyze: In order to......

Words: 484 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Hipaa

...HIPAA Ruling in Tennessee Court Failure to adhere to regulatory compliance can impact a litigation process, which in the case of Stevens vs, Hickman Community Hospital was prominent when the Tennessee Court of Appeals dismissed the case based on failure to comply with Tennessee’s Medical Malpractice Act and the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996. This paper will include an IRAC Brief that will explain the case in detail followed by a brief explanation of governmental principles of regulatory compliance requirements, a brief explanation of methods for managing the legal risks that arise from regulatory compliance issues, and how this case can be applied within a business managerial setting. IRAC Brief Christine Stevens a Tennessee woman filed a malpractice lawsuit against Hickman Community Hospital, the emergency room services and physicians who cared for her husband Mark Stevens, which subsequently resulted in his demise. The case however is being challenged as a result of failing to comply with regulatory requirements set forth in the Tennessee Medical Malpractice Act and the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996. Case In accordance with the Tennessee Medical Malpractice Act, on April 11, 2011, counsel for Mrs. Christine Stevens the spouse of Steven Stevens, formally notified Hickman Community Hospital and Dr. Whitaker of the impending malpractice......

Words: 1649 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Business Law Wk6 Reflection

...IRAC Brief Issue In the case of Pierre Konowaloff, Paris, France, v. The Metropolitan Museum of Art New York, New York, Pierre Konowaloff alleges that the Metropolitan Museum of Art acquired, displayed and retained a piece of art that was confiscated by the Russian Bolshevik regime from his great-grandfather in 1918. After gaining power in 1917, the Bolshevik regime issued decrees nationalizing property, and abolishing the private ownership of land and making museums property of the state. The Bolsheviks continued by confiscated artworks for possible sale abroad. In May 1933, Stephen C. Clark was a trustee of the Museum bequeathed the painting to the Museum after he died in 1960. The Museum of Art motioned to dismiss Konowaloff’s complaint, citing that the claims are barred by the act of state doctrine. Rules of the Law(s) Applied to the Case The law applied in this case was the act of state doctrine, which states, “local courts may not question the legal effect of a foreign state’s acts fully executed within its own territory” (US Legal, 2013). Therefore, the court dismissed the action against Metropolitan Museum of Art. Analysis: How the Court Applied the Law The United States Court of Appeals, Second Circuit applied the act of state doctrine to this case because the art work was confiscated from Konowaloff’s family by the Bolshevik regime in Russia. Hence the act of state doctrine states that no other nation is sovereign within its own borders, and its......

Words: 682 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Case Study Analysis Property Issues

...Case Study Analysis Property Issues Learning Team A Law/531 8/25/2014 Craige Harrison IRAC Issue: The issue brought before the Texas Court of Appeals is that the Tarhan’s bought property form the Mettlen’s and the Mettlens claimed that they retained the mineral intrests in the property. The Trahans believe that the interests were, or should have been, part of the transaction. The Trahans filed lawsuit in December of 2010 for the mineral intests more than 4 years later. The Mettlens filed a motion for summary judgment claiming that the lawsuit was time-barred by the applicable four year statute of limitation. The court found that the satute of limitations barred the Trahans lawsuit and judgment to the Mettlens. So the question is: is the four year limitation period applicable to the Trahans cause of action was tolled or otherwise rendered inapplicable by the facts and circumstances of the case and for how long. Rule: Discovery Rule for Fraudulent Concealment Analysis: The contract states that just after the description of the property the mineral, oil and gas and liquid that may be produced are products of the grantors. That there was no evidence of the Merrlens attempting to hinder the Trahans from reading the deed or that they attempted to hinder the Trahans Conclusion: It was found that the warranty deed conveying title to the Trahans contains a clear and unambiguous reservation of mineral rights. The discovery rule for fraudulent concealment tolls the......

Words: 709 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Law 531 Learning Team Reflection Week 5

...Learning Team Reflection - Exide Technologies Business Law - Law 531 March 23, 2015 Instructor: Learning Team Reflection - Exide Technologies Exide Technologies in Vernon, California is an example of a company which failed to comply with government regulations requiring them to properly handle and dispose of toxic battery waste. This case also highlights the negligence in part by state officials regarding violations discovered over a period of almost two decades. These violations included battery acid draining into a manholes and lead waste stored in open containers causing the toxic waste to be exposed. There are consquences when a company such as Exide Technologies fail to comply with state and federal regulations which could ultimately hinder their sustainability and financial prosperity. Principles of regulatory compliance requirements. According to Exide Technologies website, they are committed to comply with applicable legal requirements and other requirements related to environmental aspect. Due to the numerous violations discovered in the Vernon plant, Exide agreed to shut down the plant as a plea agreement to avoid any future criminal charges and additional fines. In addition to the plant shutting down, they were order to decontaminate the site in which they worked due to high levels of lead and arsenic emissions. Exide Technologies was not only mishandling their toxic waste, but they were not complying with all applicable governmental laws and......

Words: 873 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Law 531 Week 3 Assignments

...LAW 531 WEEK 3 ASSIGNMENTS A+ Graded Tutorial Available At: http://hwsoloutions.com/?product=law-531-week-3-assignments Visit Our website: http://hwsoloutions.com/ Product Description PRODUCT DESCRIPTION LAW 531 Week 3 Assignments Week Three IRAC Brief Case:DePuy Orthopaedics, Inc. v. Waxman. August 3, 2012. In the outlined case, DePuy is trying to sue one of their distributors Joint Venture for breach of a non-compete agreement. Under the non-compete covenant Joint Venture disclaim the rights to any of DePuy intangible assets, including intellectual property (IP), goodwill, and customer lists. DePuy claims that Joint Venture breached the non-compete agreement which caused a drop in sales and damaged their relationship with customers in the territories outlined within the agreement.Therefore, the legality of the contract enforced due to the breach of the non-compete agreement. According to Cheeseman 2013, “the section 2-201(1) statue of sales contracts of Uniform Commercial Code laws help prevent fraud like this case” (p. 171). To avoid this case by Depuy or any other companies’ managerial setting must specify agreements with language that is comprehensible by both parties in written valid contracts. Issue:Was there a breach to the contract, under that non-compete covenant between DePuy and Joint Venture? What kind of defenses do companies use to mitigate risk related to personal, real, or intellectual property (IP) issues? The main reason this case went to......

Words: 1050 - Pages: 5