Is Astrology Considered Science?

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By anarmstrong26
Words 806
Pages 4
Is Astrology Considered Science Philosophy Essay
At the first instance, one tends to agree with the contention of the author that astrology is not science because the astrological predictions suffer from deficiencies such as (i) they are not supported by sound and verified scientific research, for e.g., statistical studies, (ii) they are not based upon collected data and carefully controlled objective observations, (iii) they are not based upon falsifiable predictions, which are tested and re-tested, by independent observers and researchers, etc. Hence, astrology does not qualify as a study based on scientific theory because it is neither logically consistent internally (all its predictions must be consistent with each other) nor logically consistent externally (unless there are good reasons, it must be consistent with theories which are already known to be valid).

Nevertheless, it may be appreciated that lots of theories in various disciplines don't make common sense either. For instance, Einstein and many other contemporary scientists had proposed all kinds of absurd and seemingly ridiculous ideas such as space is curved, that time is really a fourth dimension and not separate from space, that looking at something alters its position, etc. etc. These ideas also don't make common sense, and sound like the objects of science fiction, but they are taken seriously by scientists not as science fiction but as valid and serious scientific theories. In short, it is not necessary for an idea to make common sense to be scientifically sound. A theory only needs to fit the data. For e.g., Einstein propounded the theory of relativity in 1907-1915 but it was initially considered to be absurd and ridiculous by many till it was corroborated by vast amount of evidence consistent with it. And so far nothing has contradicted it.

Hence, though it may be argued today that…...

Similar Documents

The Astrology

... baffle us with their contradictory behavior. We even confuse ourselves with our own haunting ambivalences. How come you get along with Jack and care so much about him when in fact he gets on your nerves? Jack has an abrasive personality. You know that. But you can’t help liking the guy. He fascinates you. Why? It’s a dilemma. With a solution. In order to understand your attraction for the difficult Jack, so as to comprehend the opacities of your own soul, by yourself, without the aid of a shrink or a psychiatrist, all you have to do is read The New Astrology, apply it to your day-to-day life, and you’re off and running, I can hear it from here. Is Suzanne White crazy? Who does she think she is comparing astrology to science or religion? What bill of goods is she trying to sell us now? What is this marginal balderdash that Suzanne White expects us to fall for? Is she some kind of retarded hippie? It’s a con. Don’t believe that garbage. It’s bohemian. It’s not accepted by the AMA, the Food and Drug Administration, the Council of Churches or the Vatican. Beware, dear reader. A witch is among you, a temptress who will warp and mold your unsuspecting mind with her sorcery. Astrology is hogwash and that is all there is to it! All right, killjoy. You’re right. Astrology is nonsense. Now may we get on with our fun? Copyright © 1986 Suzanne White. All Rights Reserved. TheNewAstrology.com 6 How Does the New Astrology Work? The New Astrology attempts to help us understand...

Words: 231422 - Pages: 926

Astronomy or Astrology

...Astronomy or Astrology? Have you ever finally just gave in to the temptation and read your horoscope in the newspaper on Sunday morning? Sure, we all have. For most of us, itís a curiosity, an amusement to see what they say our day will be like based on the sign of the zodiac that we were born under. Sometimes we forget that this little diversion is actually part of an ancient science called astrology that has had a powerful effect on many cultures dating back to centuries before Christ. That is not to say that astrology is a dead art today. It is easy to find astrology advocates in every town, advertising in the newspaper and on television trying to convince us that they can tell our fortune, our future and help cure our ills by exploring the mysteries of astrology. When you are a lover of astronomy, the confusion between astronomy and astrology by those who donít really understand the differences can get pretty aggravating. And in early civilizations, the two disciplines were not separate. Astrology was just the religious side of the science of astronomy. So what changed? The most significant shift that set in motion the separation of the two lines of thought began in the first century when Ptolemy wrote the very first book on astronomy called the Tetrabiblos. In it, he began to suggest that astronomy should be considered a separate science from astrology. It was quite a revolutionary book because it also was the first scientific document to suggest...

Words: 637 - Pages: 3

Astrology

...Matching Of Charts: A New approach By Tej K. Zadoo, India Volunteer: Maurício Avila, Brazil W Dr. Tej K. Zadoo born on Deepawali day 1948 at Srinagar, Kashmir in a Brahmin family. Got introduced to astrology in 1966, mostly self study of classical texts, he has a Ph.D. degree in Physics, was working in the education dept. of J&K Govt. as a teacher and retired recently. Besides astrology he is interested in 'Ramal' shastra and paranormal subjects. He can read write Urdu, Hindi and Sanskrit. His article BCP & Longevity was praised by senor astrologers as one of the finest articles ever to appear in any magazine. hile commenting on the author's article "3 simple rules of marital disharmony"1 an astrologer friend asked the author: "By using the rules given in your article one can see whether a person is prone to tension in his or her married life or not. If the native has combinations in his or her chart which indicate a troublesome married life the solution you have suggested is to match the charts. But the problem is that we usually use "Guna Milan" method and this method doesn’t give correct results all the time. There are charts where the number of points (Gunas) that are matching are very high but the married life is miserable or there is separation; and there are charts where number of points (Gunas) that are matching are very low and there are doshas like Nadi dosh, Gana dosh etc. but the couple is leading a very harmonious and blissful...

Words: 5848 - Pages: 24

Science

...: Class, what is our topic yesterday? 3.2.2 Motivation - Show a 30 seconds video clip. Teacher: What do you notice about these pictures? Base on the presented illustrations, can you guess what will be our topic for today? 3.3 Lesson Proper Teacher’s Activity | Students’ Activity | 3.3.1 Introduction * In chemistry, solution is homogenous mixture of two or more substances. The dissolving medium is called the solvent, and the dissolved material is the solute. * In most common solutions in our home, the solvent is a liquid often water, and the solute may be solid, gas or liquid. * For this experiment please watch this video about solubility. * Is there any question so far? * Nice question. Actually, you can easily determine if the product in our home is a solution or not by the characteristics exhibited by solution: * First, a solution is a homogeneous mixture. * Homogeneous means that the components of the mixture forms single phase where you observed a single component of matter, and matter is any material or thing that occupies space, mass and volume. * Next, is that the particle of solute in a solution cannot be seen by naked eye. * It doesn’t allow the beam of light to scatter. * And lastly, the solute in the solution cannot be separated by filtration. * Is it clear? Any question?3.3.2 Presentation * Ok, if that so. Let me ask you some questions. * Can you please give me some products which are considered solutions found in......

Words: 1391 - Pages: 6

Science

...Advantage Science gives us safe food, free from harmful bacteria, in clean containers or hygienic tins. It also teaches us to eat properly, indicating a diet balanced in protein and carbohydrate and containing vitamins. The results is freedom from disease and prolonged life. In pre-scientific days, food was monotonous and sometimes dangerous; today it is safe and varied. It is varied because through improved sea, land and air transport food can now be freely imported and exported. Science has also improved clothing and made it more appropriate for climatic and working conditions. Man-made fibers and versatile spinning machines, today enable us to dress in clothes both comfortable and smart without being expensive. Home, school and office all bear witness to the progress and application of science. Nowadays, most homes possess electric lighting and cooking, but many also have washing machines, vacuum cleaners and kitchen appliances, all designed to increase comfort and cleanliness and reduce drudgery. Science produces the fan which cools the air, the machinery which makes the furniture and fabrics, and hundred and one other features for good living. The books and papers are at school, and again everything from the piece of chalk to the closed-circuit television of instruction are the direct or indirect results of scientific progress. Learning is therefore easier. And clerical work is made far more speedy and efficient by the office typewriter, quite apart from the hundreds...

Words: 572 - Pages: 3

Science

...SCIENCE My second month in Gusa Regional Science High School! Do you want to know what are the activities and what have I learn this month? As we all know this month is “Nutrition Month,” so I am excited what are the activities that would be held in celebrating the nutrition month. Come! and let us know what happened this July. On the first day of July we answer our wortext. We answer page 17, 1-5 in ½ lengthwise. The next day we had a contest about the scientist. We were gouped into two groups, group a and group b. Group a scored 27 while group b scored 31. Group b win with the score of 31, while group a lose with the score of 27. Group a’s punishment is they have to dance. The boys did it but the girls pleaded that they will just sing rather than dance. Teacher Cass agreed, and in the middle of singing “Nasayo Na Ang Lahat,”Teacher Cass gestured to the boys to join the girls singing. The boys didn’t insist in joining the girls. On Thursday, the rain was falling hard so teacher Cass is the one who come to us. We were trapped in Teacher Lory’s classroom. We had another game same us what we did yesterday. This time its boys vs girls. The girls won the game and as expected boys got a punishment. Their punishment was they did a fashion show...

Words: 372 - Pages: 2

Science

...Cerca de 2,830,000 resultados (0.37 segundos) Looking for results in English? Change to English Continuar usando español Configuración del idioma Resultados de búsqueda Science Buddies www.sciencebuddies.org/Traducir esta página Free Topic Selection Wizard, science fair project ideas, step by step how to do a science fair project, Ask an Expert discussion board, and science fair tips for ... Science Fair Project Ideas Hundreds of detailed science fair project ideas for all grade levels ... About Us What is Science Buddies? The award-winning, non-profit ... Science Fair Project Guide Ask an Expert - Background Research Plan - Research Paper Parent Resources The Science Buddies Parent page offers information and resources ... Student Resources Student Resources ... Science Buddies has additional ... Advanced Project Guide Advanced Project Guide ... About Advanced High School Science ... Más resultados de sciencebuddies.org » Science Buddies, más de 1000 ideas y recursos para ... wwwhatsnew.com/.../science-buddies-mas-de-1000-ideas-y-recursos-par... 19 de dic. de 2014 - Science Buddies es una excelente herramienta educativa que nos provee de una colección impresionante de ideas y recursos para utilizar en ... Science Buddies - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Science_BuddiesTraducir esta página Science Buddies, formerly...

Words: 414 - Pages: 2

Essay on Astrology

...Regina K. Williams Susan Lowman-Thomas English 101 6 September 2015 The Truth about Astrology Astrology has been in existence for centuries, and its controversy over its relevance. The history of astrology began with the Babylonians, they are credited for the creation of astrology. Their astrological charts enabled them to predict the recurrence of seasons and coming celestial events. Astrology was also used to bring a sense of order out of apparent chaos, it was soon utilized to predict weather patterns, primarily for agricultural purposes. It was eventually broadened to include forecasts of natural disasters and war and other events in the course of human affairs. Amassing successes in these fields, it was a natural progression for astrology to be used as counsel for kings and emperors and in time, for all of us. “Astrology is one of the most ancient sciences, held in high esteem of old, by the wise and the great. Formerly, no prince would make war or peace, nor any general fight in battle, in short, no important affair was undertaken without first consulting an astrologer."- Benjamin Franklin Character traits of an individual are strongly effected by astrology. Learning in depth information related to astrology can help assist with relating with others. Individuals who have a strong Understanding of Astrological signs tend to have a clear understanding of themselves. When studding the science of Astrology, it very important to know the time of a person’s...

Words: 902 - Pages: 4

Science

...Free University of Amsterdam Faculty of social sciences Department of political science Globalization: The end of state Sovereignty? Ofran Badakhshani: 1586513 Words: 1442 Ofran Badakhshani: 1586513 Written assignment for International Relations Index Introduction......................................................................................................................... 3 Globalization....................................................................................................................... 3 State sovereignty................................................................................................................. 4 Analysis............................................................................................................................... 4 Conclusion .......................................................................................................................... 6 Bibliography ....................................................................................................................... 7 2 Globalization: The end of state Sovereignty? Ofran Badakhshani: 1586513 Written assignment for International Relations Introduction “A specter is haunting the world’s governments, the specter of globalization”. The world order and politics are facing a new danger; the sovereignty of the nation states is under question. According to some theorists there is a constantly growing dependency and interconnectedness between...

Words: 1626 - Pages: 7

Science

...05 -071 Page 1 of 24 Chapter 132 - Science and Technology Section SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY Science and technology provide people with the knowledge and tools to understand and address many of the challenges. Students must be provided with opportunities to access, understand, and evaluate current information and tools related to science and technology if they are to be ready to live in a 21st century global society. The study of science and technology includes both processes and bodies of knowledge. Scientific processes are the ways scientists investigate and communicate about the natural world. The scientific body of knowledge includes concepts, principles, facts, laws, and theories about the way the world around us works. Technology includes the technological design process and the body of knowledge related to the study of tools and the effect of technology on society. Science and technology merge in the pursuit of knowledge and solutions to problems that require the application of scientific understanding and product design. Solving technological problems demands scientific knowledge while modern technologies make it possible to discover new scientific knowledge. In a world shaped by science and technology, it is important for students to learn how science and technology connect with the demands of society and the knowledge of all content areas. It is equally important that students are provided with learning experiences that integrate tools, knowledge...

Words: 8232 - Pages: 33

Is Astrology Considered Science?

...Is Astrology Considered Science Philosophy Essay At the first instance, one tends to agree with the contention of the author that astrology is not science because the astrological predictions suffer from deficiencies such as (i) they are not supported by sound and verified scientific research, for e.g., statistical studies, (ii) they are not based upon collected data and carefully controlled objective observations, (iii) they are not based upon falsifiable predictions, which are tested and re-tested, by independent observers and researchers, etc. Hence, astrology does not qualify as a study based on scientific theory because it is neither logically consistent internally (all its predictions must be consistent with each other) nor logically consistent externally (unless there are good reasons, it must be consistent with theories which are already known to be valid). Nevertheless, it may be appreciated that lots of theories in various disciplines don't make common sense either. For instance, Einstein and many other contemporary scientists had proposed all kinds of absurd and seemingly ridiculous ideas such as space is curved, that time is really a fourth dimension and not separate from space, that looking at something alters its position, etc. etc. These ideas also don't make common sense, and sound like the objects of science fiction, but they are taken seriously by scientists not as science fiction but as valid and serious scientific theories. In short, it is not...

Words: 806 - Pages: 4

Astrology vs Astronomy

... astrology, the effects of these constellations on humans continues to be what is studied. The position of a certain zodiac constellation in the sky determines the time of year. Folklore says if one is born under a certain sign, then they will have certain personality traits and tastes. Contrary to the common calendar, the zodiacal year begins on March 21. Each sign spends approximately thirty days in a certain position before being replaced by the following sign. Even though both astronomy and astrology study the stars, they both do so in a completely different way. The most substantial difference between astronomy and astrology is the type of science they actually are. Astronomy is a branch of physics which studies celestial bodies. Astronomy uses formulas, measurements, and variables. Scientists consider astrology a pseudoscience, or fake science, because of interpreting the apparent effects of celestial bodies on human beings. Astrology has no formulas, measurements, and no controlled variables. Astrology cannot specifically determine whether or not these effects are actually from celestial objects, therefore astrology is not an actual science. Astronomy is an actual science because of branching from physics, and studying actual motions and chemical properties of celestial bodies. An abundance of great astronomers such as Copernicus to Kepler, and even Einstein, pave the way to better understanding our universe. The study of other celestial objects also aids in the......

Words: 776 - Pages: 4

Astrology

...Motions of the Sun – Student Guide Seasonal Motion Work through the explanatory material on Sidereal vs. Synodic and Seasons and the Zodiac. All of the concepts that are covered in these pages are used in the Paths of the Sun Simulator. For each of the following statements respond shorter, the same, or longer. A) If the Earth revolved more rapidly, its sidereal day would be _______________. B) If the Earth revolved more rapidly, it solar day would be ________________. C) If the Earth rotated more rapidly, its sidereal day would be _______________. D) If the Earth rotated more rapidly, it solar day would be ________________. Use the Zodiac Explorer to answer the following questions. A) On May 25th, the sun is in the constellation of ___________________. B) What would be a good time of year to observer the constellation Aries? ________________ C) On July 4th at midnight, the constellation __________________ is on the observer’s meridian. D) At sunrise on Christmas Day, the constellation on the observer’s meridian is ______________________. Daily Motion with Seasonal Effects Work through the explanatory material on Meridional Altitude and Sun Paths. Complete the following table on meridional altitudes. You are encouraged to check your answers with the meridional altitude explorer, but you should make every effort to solve these problems yourself first. Note that part D is completed for you. |Location...

Words: 1150 - Pages: 5

Constellation and Astrology

... bordered by Aquila, Sagittarius, Microscopium, Piscis Austrinus and Aquarius. The constellation is located in an area of sky called the Sea or the Water, consisting of many water-related constellations such as Aquarius, Pisces and Eridanus. It is the second faintest constellation in the zodiac after Cancer. * Aquarius (♒) Latin: ("Aquārius") is the eleventh astrological sign in the Zodiac, originating from the constellation Aquarius. In astrology, Aquarius is considered a "masculine", positive (extrovert) sign. It is also considered an air sign and is one of four fixed signs. Aquarius has been traditionally ruled by the planet Saturn, and, since its discovery, Uranus has been considered a modern co-ruler of this sign. "Exalting" planets are either Mars and/or Neptune, while the "fall" planets are Mercury and/or Venus. * The Traditional Rulerships Aries (Mars) Taurus (Venus) Gemini (Mercury) Cancer (Moon) Leo (Sun) Virgo (Mercury) Libra (Venus) Scorpio (Mars) Sagittarius (Jupiter) Capricorn (Saturn) Aquarius (Saturn) Pisces (Jupiter)...

Words: 2095 - Pages: 9

Astrology

...Have you ever wanted to learn more about astrology , I have. Astrology is a gateway into learning more about yourself. During the research I have a lot more about sun signs, or horoscopes , birth charts, and the plaints of astrology. One, of the most important parts of astrology is your sun sign. All you have to do to find your sun sign is to look at the day and mouth your are born in. All the sun signs are Aries, Taurus, Gemini, Cancer, Leo, Virgo, Libra, Scorpio, Sagittarius, Capricorn, Aquarius, and Pisces. They are all of the twelve signs .They are all different in some ways, like all people have their own original personalities First, sun sign is the Aries born from March 21- April 20. Aries are known for being very on-the-go-people. They let nothing get in their way. Also are very bold and not afraid to take chances, but on the other side they can easily hurt others feelings without knowing it. They also have short tempers which can make them uneasy. They also make great leaders, not followers. They are usually very skilled in all sports, but are competitive. Aries are one of the three fire signs. Second, sun sign is Taurus born from April 21 - May 20. These guys are one to relax and take things easy. They are also a big fan of money and love having it. They enjoy foods, jewelry, and good company. You can always find them cooking or enjoy new recipes. They can be lazy or self-loving. They enjoy Tv, short trips, and sleeping in. Taurus is one of the three...

Words: 1133 - Pages: 5