Jane Elliott - Class Divided

In: Social Issues

Submitted By godlylove1st
Words 350
Pages 2
Jane Elliott - A Class Divided
C. Love
University of Life
Research Techniques for Educators

October 13, 2015

Jane Elliott - A Class Divided (You Tube Video)

The Jane Elliott Video was very insightful to how racism is taught through generations of people. I believe the experiment has helped many people including those who want to learn to be fair and just human beings. The children were used as research participants involuntarily, they were at school that day because they were sent by their parents, and they did not go agreeing to be involved in a research project. The children could not get up and freely leave so yes the research was involuntary. The children were not old enough to understand fully the objectives of research however they were smart enough to voice what they had heard and was taught. The results of the documentary featuring Mrs. Elliott and the students did provide valuable information that has helped society and probably will continue to do so for years to come. Today if that was done Mrs. Elliott would probably be fired and lawsuits filed against her and the school in which she taught. I believe the method she used was brilliant, the collars and differentiating between blue and brown eyes, it should be done again in this period and time in a controlled setting. Most of the children did not suffer any harm except the one little guy that suffered from the physical fight. A number of children were hurt inside from not getting extra food or time on the playground or from losing their friends for a little while. The kids were able to feel the plight of people of color for a little while and that is something invaluable. I do not believed the children suffered any mental harm it is children of color that continue to suffer intense and emotional harm.
My question: Knowing that some research is justified how so, that it may not be ethical, to…...

Similar Documents

Elliott Wave

...In The Elliott Wave Principle — A Critical Appraisal, Hamilton Bolton made this opening statement: As we have advanced through some of the most unpredictable economic climate imaginable, covering depression, major war, and postwar reconstruction and boom, I have noted how well Elliott's Wave Principle has fitted into the facts of life as they have developed, and have accordingly gained more confidence that this Principle has a good quotient of basic value. "The Wave Principle" is Ralph Nelson Elliott's discovery that social, or crowd, behavior trends and reverses in recognizable patterns. Using stock market data as his main research tool, Elliott discovered that the ever-changing path of stock market prices reveals a structural design that in turn reflects a basic harmony found in nature. From this discovery, he developed a rational system of market analysis. Elliott isolated thirteen patterns of movement, or "waves," that recur in market price data and are repetitive in form, but are not necessarily repetitive in time or amplitude. He named, defined and illustrated the patterns. He then described how these structures link together to form larger versions of those same patterns, how they in turn link to form identical patterns of the next larger size, and so on. In a nutshell, then, the Wave Principle is a catalog of price patterns and an explanation of where these forms are likely to occur in the overall path of market development. Elliott's descriptions......

Words: 453 - Pages: 2


...Ms.Dotson English 2 24 April 2012 Jane Austen’s Accomplishments Jane Austen was such a remarkable author. Growing up in such a judgmental period gave her many ideas due to her many stories coming from personal experiences. One thing is she stayed true to herself and others. Jane’s significance on her novels made her the great author of her decade. Jane Austen is such a loving person who shows her love through her actions by her novels, the way she treats her family, and how she puts others first. Austen was born on December 16th, 1775 to Reverend George Austen and Cassandra Austen. She lived her life in Steventon rectory with her close knit family. Her parents had seven children with Jane being the last. There were five boys and two girls. With her only having one sister name Cassandra they became best friends. Out of all her brothers she was closer to Henry. Even though she loved both of her parents very dearly she was more of a daddy’s girl. During Jane’s childhood, open learning, dialogue and creativity was the key to there life. Her parents wanted there children to express their self and be creative as possible. Education was so important in Jane’s family that her father took neighborhood children in their home to teach them. Jane’s house had a huge library full of literature. Jane and Cassandra were the main children who took the library seriously. Jane took over the library reading many books of different genres also writing. All the books she read helped her......

Words: 1016 - Pages: 5

Reaction to "A Class Divided"

...Kiana Stinney | A Class Divided | Reactionary Paper | | Period 1 | 5/16/2013 | | Watching A Class Divided really brought along a lot of different feelings. First and foremost I learned from watching the kid’s scene that you work better when you feel better and when you feel confident. The scene that I’ll probably remember most is when Ms. Elliot did the test on the adults. It was shocking and interesting to see how adults act in such a situation where as they are being discriminated against. I hope it showed many people how African Americans felt and sometimes still feel. The part that surprised me was the scene with the kids, when one group felt like they were in power; they completely turned on the other group with no remorse. Best friends became worst enemies, and they didn’t even think twice about it. I feel as though Ms. Elliot’s way of showing these kids about discrimination and racism was very effective, in a way she provided an answer to the question “why would anyone want to murder Martin Luther King?” When the two boys fought at recess the teacher asked if responding with violence made him feel better, he replied no. His answer goes to show that responding with violence is ineffective and a waste of time and energy. There were many quotes used but this one really stood out to me; “Help me not judge a person until I have walked in his moccasins”, a self-explanatory Sioux prayer quoted in the documentary. This prayer related to the brown eyes/blue......

Words: 693 - Pages: 3

Jane Eyre: a Class Act

...Logan Bell Miss England English 282, Section 005 18 March 2010 Major Paper 1 Jane Eyre: A Class Act Charlotte Brontë portrays the strict, hierarchal class system that existed during the Victorian era in her novel Jane Eyre. Characters throughout the novel are fully aware of and reference the social statuses of others and judge one another based on stereotypes associated with each persons position in society. Unlike other characters in Jane Eyre, Jane retains her morals and standards while her social class seems ambiguous and transforms continually as she progresses during her own bildungsroman. Through the character of Jane Eyre, Brontë not only illustrates that class divisions are not absolute and individuals can transcend these boundaries, but also suggests the need of morality and integrity in the upper class. Jane traverses the entire range of social classes from a beggar at the steps of Moor House to an upper class married woman at Ferndean. Ambiguity characterizes Jane’s status even before birth. Susan Fraiman attributes this uncertainty to Jane’s parents who were both “socially ambiguous, and this ambiguity is part of their legacy to Jane” (Fraiman 616). Her mother’s marriage to a man of a lower hierarchy creates a “legacy” that foreshadows Jane’s life-long search for her position in society. Jane’s time at Gateshead bolsters Fraiman’s belief that Jane will fulfill her parents’ “legacy.” She is never recognized as part of the Reed family at Gateshead......

Words: 1518 - Pages: 7

A Class Divided

...Ms. Elliott was a woman that went above and beyond her job as a teacher, and took it upon herself to teach her children something school would never teach them typically. She taught them moral values and the unfairness of prejudice and discrimination. I found the experiment interesting; I was wondering what the children would get out of this discrimination experiment. The reactions of the children were obvious that they learned their lesson on understanding discrimination because they lived through it themselves. The social interaction between the students and Ms. Elliot was completely changed during the experiment. The children who had once been best friends with each other have turned on because they are no divided on not equal to each other. Once their teacher, the authority figure, told them one group was better than the other, the recognized different social identities for each other. The adults reacted differently to the experiment. I don’t think they exactly saw Ms. Elliot as an authority figure because they are of more of a similar age to her. Watching the adults reaction to the experiment made me somewhat uneasy. The brown-eyed adults went along with everything she said and felt a power of authority because they were told that they were better than the blue-eyed people. I think that this activity wasn’t nearly as successful for adults as it was for children. Children are completely open to new aspects of learning at their young age, but a lot of adults already......

Words: 436 - Pages: 2

A Class Divided

...novel and film. He has to be careful with plagiarism that is what his professor talked about in the class. Before begin writing hence, Dylan wants to know more about plagiarism. Dylan, conscious about plagiarism copies direct quotations from the source and places quotation marks around it. He knows that copying a direct quotation from a source or a paper without placing quotation marks is counted as wrong work which is a plagiarism. He also acknowledges the quotations by crediting the source by work citing. Picking up a statement from a source and crediting means avoiding a plagiarism. Readers will have a clear idea about where the statement is extracted from. Quoting and paraphrasing, both are fine as long as their sources are credited. He takes Steinbeck's ideas or words and puts them into his own words, Dylan paraphrases by crediting the source by citing it. Paraphrasing is equally important as quoting to keep in mind while writing a paper to avoid plagiarism. If someone's ideas or words are taken without changing words, and is not quoted and not credited then it is considered a plagiarism. There are whole bunch of things Dylan has to consider while writing his paper. He should not have his friend or someone to write papers for him. Using a paper written by someone else other than himself is a plagiarism. Submitting a paper or an assignment for more than one class, and downloading or buying a term paper from the web are all considered plagiarisms. Plagiarism......

Words: 448 - Pages: 2

A Class Divided

...1960’s, around the time when Martin Luther King Jr. was fighting for civil rights for people of color, a 3rd grade school teacher, Jane Elliot, from Riceville, Iowa was busy at work in an attempt to recreate the negative emotional and physical effects of racism within her classroom. She created an experiment in which she divided her students into unequal groups as a way of creating artificial stereotypes, prejudices, and discrimination. Jane Elliot eventually expanded her experiments into the adult population. She has done these experiments on corrections workers in prisons, as well as college students. Through all these experiments, Jane Elliot has made many conclusions and generalizations that can directly relate back to the real world, and hopefully aid in solving the problem of racism. Jane Elliot’s experimentation with stereotypes first began within the walls of her 3rd grade classroom. Before the experiment began she asked the students for their opinions on minority groups. Many of the students answered with statements regarding black people as being dumb and different than whites. They also discussed how African Americans do not have to same opportunities as white people do because of the color of their skin. Jane Elliot continued by effectively dividing the students into unequal groups based on eye color. From the initial division, Jane Elliot treated the students in the brown eyed group as if they were inferior to those in the blue eyed group. She set a vast amount...

Words: 1643 - Pages: 7

A Class Divided

...history. We have no obligation to make a statement. We are here to make money.” If that doesn’t say it loud and clear about how the media cares about our young men and women, I don’t know how I could make it any clearer. In an interview with several San Francisco high school students, no older than sixteen, each described the internal and external pressures they face to ‘look good,’ the frustration of not being appreciated for anything outside the realms of their physical being. As I stated earlier, being a mother of a sixteen year old daughter, I have witnessed this first hand. Since, she started school in kindergarten, I have seen the effects of her being judged on her outward appearance. She was always taller than anyone in her class. Because of her outward appearance, she was teased and bullied all throughout her elementary and middle school years. She was called names that were very hurtful and lowered her self-esteem. Here are some more startling statistics. 78% of girls hate their bodies by the age of 15. 65% have an eating disorder. 17% cut themselves, and the number of cosmetic surgeries quadrupled on women ages 17 from 1997 and 2007 and have increased six fold since. Women are 56% percent of the population, yet only 17% of Congress, 3% of Fortune 500 CEO’s, hold only 3% of clout positions in media (and in a staggering unreal statistic, only 1 women is on the our role a board of Fox News out of 15) and are 7% of directors and 13% of the film writers. ......

Words: 1527 - Pages: 7

Jane Eyre

...Jane Eyre by Charlotte Brontë An Electronic Classics Series Publication Jane Eyre by Charlotte Brontë is a publication of the Pennsylvania State University. This Portable Document file is furnished free and without any charge of any kind. Any person using this document file, for any purpose, and in any way does so at his or her own risk. Neither the Pennsylvania State University nor Jim Manis, Faculty Editor, nor anyone associated with the Pennsylvania State University assumes any responsibility for the material contained within the document or for the file as an electronic transmission, in any way. Jane Eyre by Charlotte Brontë, the Pennsylvania State University, Electronic Classics Series, Jim Manis, Faculty Editor, Hazleton, PA 18202-1291 is a Portable Document File produced as part of an ongoing student publication project to bring classical works of literature, in English, to free and easy access of those wishing to make use of them. Cover Design: Jim Manis Copyright © 2003 - 2012 The Pennsylvania State University is an equal opportunity university. Charlotte Brontë Jane Eyre by Charlotte Brontë PREFA PREFACE A PREFACE TO THE FIRST EDITION of Jane Eyre being unnecessary, I gave none: this second edition demands a few words both of acknowledgment and miscellaneous remark. My thanks are due in three quarters. To the Public, for the indulgent ear it has inclined to a plain tale with few pretensions. To the Press, for the fair field its honest......

Words: 189679 - Pages: 759

A Class Divided

...A Class Divided Everyone is likely to some form of discrimination or prejudice. On April 5th, 1968, a teacher in Riceville, Iowa named Jane Elliot conducted an exercise on her third grade class students that dealt with the concept of discrimination that would grow up to be a renowned experience. The exercise was the result from Martin Luther King’s assassination. The documentary is an eye opening into the world of racism and discrimination. The dictionary defines racism as “a doctrine that one race is superior” and discrimination as “the denial of opportunities and equal rights to individuals and groups because of prejudice or for other arbitrary reasons”. Throughout the American society and through its history you can find discrimination. The documentary shows us that discrimination doesn’t just go to the extent to the color of your skin or what your ethnicity is, but can fall into any physical characteristics, your social status, where you’re from, having a developmental disability, simple as being a woman and what not of other things, and in this case the color of your eyes. Nevertheless, we past judgment and prejudice based on these types of things where the person themselves are not accounted for. The concept that Jane Elliot is teaching us is that racism is a learned behavior and not part of the human genetic code. This coming from herself and in addition to, just as you learn something - you can unlearn something. You can unlearn racism if it has...

Words: 960 - Pages: 4

Jane Elliot

...America country was divided. Jade Elliott carried out a study one morning after King’s assassination. Elliott on morning she told the children in her class that there was going to be a change to the way that they do things. She spit her class into two categories on of them contained children with brown eyes whilst the other category contained children with blue eyes. The children with the Blue-eyes were treated better than the brown eyed children. The blue eyed children got the best places to sit in the classroom, they got extra break time, got fed better as they were allowed to go up for seconds at lunch and they also were allowed to sit at the front of the classroom to take part in class discussions. On the other hand the Brown eyed children were treated the total opposite they were forced to sit at the back of the class and they were totally isolated from the blue eyed people. The brown eyed people also got punished for things that that the blue eyed people got away with. Elliott also told the blue eyed people that they were more intelligent than the brown eyed people which took away their confidence. At the end of the day of doing her study she found that the blue eyed children put down the brown eyed children. She also found out that the blue eyed students did better on class assignments than the brown eyed student didn’t do as well as they ere isolated and hardly got any help as they didn’t participate as much in class discussions. The following day Elliott reversed......

Words: 329 - Pages: 2

A Class Divided

...3/31/2016 A Class Divided ­ Research Paper ­ Winquist09 Login Join The Research Paper Factory Join Search Browse Saved Papers Search over 100,000 Essays Home Page  »  Other Topics A Class......

Words: 521 - Pages: 3

Response Paper on a Class Divided Video

...and those emigrating from the other nations. Americans spend a serene and contented life, whereas the Mexicans live a substandard and boring life. The motive of Cándido Rincón to bring his wife to the US was to make their US dream get realized. But the native people always cast a suspicious eye upon the intents of the immigrants. Though there are some miscreants living in every society, they make every other person subject to suspicion. In the novel, where the man with the backwards cap creates the problems for the other people, they make the other people find the same suspicious treatment for themselves. The plot of the story opens accident of Cándido Rincón, who is hit by the car of Delaney Mossbacher. Delaney Mossbacher is a middle-class, nature writer. Cándido is a Mexican, illegally living in the US. Candido gets badly injured. But, on being offered a nominal amount of twenty dollars, he is ready to reconcile with Delaney. The accident just puts a timely effect upon Delaney and he is soon able to resume his normal routine of life. His unshaken routine of life gets disturbed when a coyote comes rushing into their lawn and kills their pet. The act of coyote is linked with the Mexican immigrants living in Aroyo Blanco, who feed these coyotes. The issue is raised in the meeting of the town hall, but Delaney fails to solicit attention. Kyra cares more for her work than her domestic routine. The only thing she is concerned with at home is her beautiful mansion at home that......

Words: 1239 - Pages: 5


...in the 1840s, with Charles Dickens, thatthe novel again reached the popularity it hadenjoyed in the 1740s. Between 1847 and 1850appeared  Jane Eyre, Wuthering Heights, VanityFair  and  David Copperfield. In 1860, Dickens wasstill at his peak, Mrs Gaskell and Trollope were going strong, and George Eliot hadbegun to publish. Poetry was popular, but prose more popular. The popularity of broadlyrealistic novels seems to go with the broadening basis of middle-class democracy.For the sake of clarity, this cornucopia of fiction is treated author by author, at theexpense of chronology, interrelation, context. Dickens coincidentally published his first novel in the year of Victoria’saccession. Although the Brontë sisters wrote ten years later, they are here treated first, not in chronological order. Their novelsare closer to the genres of Romantic poetry than to the realism of the mainstream novel; fantasy and family are more relevantto their work than the currents of national[p. 273]history. This also allows Mrs Gaskell, Dickens and Thackeray, who are closer to historical developments, to be taken together. Two Brontë novels  Jane Eyre Elizabeth Gaskell’s  Life of Charlotte Brontë  (1857) tells this family story of misery and splendour, dwelling on the misery. The eldest sister, impresario,editor and survivor, impressed first, and her  Jane Eyre is a first-personautobiography of emotive, narrative, and at times mythic power. The orphanheroine suffers, is tried many times,......

Words: 859 - Pages: 4

A Class Divided

...Chelsea Mason March 11, 2010 CMST 10 Jane Elliot held a very interesting experiment for a lesson in discrimination. She divided her class of third graders into brown-eyes and blue-eyes and made certain rules for each group. For one day the blue-eyed children were “more superior” then the brown-eyed children. On the days that the children were part of the less superior part of the class, their thought process wasn’t on track like any other day. During and after this experiment, the children learned how unfair it was to be divided just because of the way that they looked. It made them fight and when they were dived it didn’t matter that they had been friends for a long time. At that time all that mattered was that one was better than the other one. This lesson seemed to have a lasting impact on these children because when they met up later in life they talked about how they were teaching their children not to discriminate, and how they ignored people when they would get looks for talking and hanging out with a black person. It just shaped the way they would think for their lives. If they wouldn’t have been part of this experiment they may not have the same thoughts, but because they got to be up close and personal to segregation and discrimination they got to see what it was really like. When Jane Elliot did this experiment later on with the adults, they seemed to try to stand up a little bit more to her about how she was treating them. She separated the different eye......

Words: 477 - Pages: 2