Free Essay

John Q

In: Film and Music

Submitted By jayfox1984
Words 447
Pages 2
It's a tribute to Denzel Washington's talent that you are able to forgive a film its shortcomings. His Oscar winning performance in Training Day elevated the otherwise trite cop flick to something more memorable. In less skillful hands John Q's plot of a desperate father holding up a hospital in order to get them to perform heart surgery on his child would be ludicrous, but Washington's unwavering believability at least encourages, if not eliminates, the suspension of disbelief.

Despite its far-fetched premise and often clumsy execution, John Q is creditable for its attempt to illustrate the inequities and failings of the American healthcare system. It makes its points in dramatic if overwrought fashion. The political message is integral but not at the service of the action that is sustained throughout along with a tension that increases with the deteriorating condition of John Q's son Mike (Daniel E. Smith).

The exuberant Mike is the center of the Archibald family. John and his wife Denise (Kimberly Elise) are devastated when the apparently healthy boy collapses during a Little League baseball game. Tests reveal he has an enlarged heart that needs replacing. The Archibald's problems mount when John discovers his health insurance policy does not cover the expensive procedure. The hospital's ruthless administrator, Rebecca Payne (Anne Heche), threatens to send the dying Mike home unless his parents can come up with the down payment of $75,000 required for his name to be put on the recipient list for prospective donors. When the normally law abiding, peaceful John is unable to raise the money, he becomes desperate.

The harsh economics of American healthcare afford little room for sentiment. That a so-called civilised society could condemn someone to death simply because they can't afford adequate insurance is unfathomable, but a reality. That is why when John Q, who chooses to be known by the initial of his middle name Quincy, takes the hospital's top cardiologist, Dr Turner (James Woods), along with some patients and nurses, hostage, the film begins its downward spiral into unreality.

The journey involves the intervention of the straight talking police negotiator Lt. Frank Grimes (Robert Duvall), his contemptuous boss Munro (Ray Liotta), a smarmy news reporter Tuck Lampley (Paul Johansson) and a waiting room full of colourful and cliched stereotypes, headed up by the wise cracking Lester (Eddie Griffin).

Director Nick Cassavetes and screenwriter James Kearns raise some valid arguments and watching John Q's utter frustration in the face of unswerving bureaucracy provides the film with a central figure everyone can identify with. But having established a connection, John Q's relinquishes it with an increasing dependence on melodrama that undermines the film's meaningful intentions.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

John Q

...John Q Melonie Krumm English 225: Introduction to Film Fawn vonFrohling August 13, 2012 John Q Directed by: Nick Cassavetes Wrote by: James Kearns Film Editing by: Dede Allen Casting by: Matthew Barry and Nancy Green-Keyes Production Design by: Stefania Cella Art Direction by: Thomas Carnegie and Elis Lam Set Decoration by: Clive Thomasson Costume Design by: Beatrix Aruna Pasztor Produced by: Mark Burg and Oren Koules Co-executive producer: Howard Burkons and Dale De La Torre, Executive producer: Michael De Luca, Avram 'Butch' Kaplan, and Richard Saperstein Co-producer: Mathew Hart, James Kearns and Hillary Sherman Throughout my life I have watched numerous movies and only a few of them have really caught my attention. The movie that I have chosen to critique is called John Q. This movie was released in Feburary2002 (IMDB, 1990-2012) and has a little bit of everything in it: drama, suspense, and a lot of emotion. The main actor in this movie is Denzel Washington. In the movie, “written in 1993 during the Clinton health-care-reform battle (Kluger and Bjerklie (2002)” as a nation were struggling with everything, especially health care. Denzel portrays a dad that cannot afford a heart transplant for his son and under all of the stress he snapped. In order to get what he wanted he took all of the people in the emergency room hostage. This movie is filled with emotion and it leaves me thinking, along with others, about what I would do in that......

Words: 1993 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

John Q Kohlberg

...The film opens to a young woman recklessly driving a BMW down a mountain highway. After being hit by two trucks, she dies (this whole ordeal is interspersed throughout the movie). John Quincy Archibald (Denzel Washington) and his wife Denise witness their young son Michael collapse at his baseball game. After a series of tests at the hospital, John is informed by Dr. Raymond Turner (James Woods) and Rebecca Payne (Anne Heche), a hospital administrator, that Michael has an enlarged heart and will need a transplant. However because the company he works for dropped John from full-time to part-time, his health insurance has been changed and the new policy does not cover the surgery, leaving them to raise $250,000 in order to get their son's name on the donor list. The family tries to raise the money but are only able to come up with a third of the necessary payment. Eventually the hospital gets tired of waiting and decides to release Michael, leading Denise to tell John to "do something." Unwilling to let his child die, John walks into the hospital ER with a handgun, gathers hostages, and sets demands: his son's name on the recipient list as soon as possible. The hostage negotiator, Lt. Frank Grimes stands down to let John cool off. Meanwhile, John and the 11 hostages communicate and learn more about each other. They begin to understand John's situation and support him a little as he ensures each of them receive the treatment they came to the emergency room for. One of them,......

Words: 735 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

John Q

...A Look at John Q HCS/235 History of Health Care Utilization in the US November 20, 2013 Brett Robinson A look at John Q Too poor to afford private health care insurance coverage, but lucky enough to qualify for Medicaid John Q faces yet another challenge. John’s father recently suffered a heart attack which brought into question his own mortality. John like many Americans is a working class man who works full time but still under the poverty level and into a substandard and overworked Medicaid system. He like many others has high blood pressure and with his father recent heart attack he would like to be checked out. Due to John’s low income he qualifies for Medicaid coverage, but also has work within his restraints. John lives in a rural community where there are local doctors however none accept Medicaid. The closest primary care physician who takes his insurance is a forty minute drive away. John also is without a car, he relies on a friend or public transportation. There are many mutable and un-mutable factors in this case. John could get a better job, which could result in better insurance coverage. “The U.S. Department of Health & Human Services states that one-quarter of America’s population lives in rural areas”(Jones, 2013). John Q lives in a rural area where his son has heart condition and is in need of a heart transplant and the closest primary care physicians is 40 miles away. John usually gets a ride to work from a friend or relies on public......

Words: 783 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

John Q

...REFLECTIONS ON JOHN Q. 25 points Answer the following questions in a nicely written essay format. It needs to include coherent sentences, with correct spelling / punctuation / grammar etc… This assignment will be worth 25 points. 1. How has your view of health insurance changed from before you watched the movie to after? Explain fully and in detail. 2. If you were in John Q’s situation, would you have done the same thing? WHY or WHY NOT? 3. Is there anything that John Q. could have done to prevent this situation from escalating to this magnitude? 4. Use your notes and pick at least 3 terms from the insurance unit and use those to explain John Q’s dilemma. Mini – Rubric | |1 |2 |3 |4 |5 | |Answered Question # 1 thoughtfully and completely. Answer was detailed and was evident that an attempt was made to critically analyze your view of health| | | | | | |insurance before and after the movie. | | | | | | |Answered Question # 2 thoughtfully and completely. Answer was detailed and was evident that an attempt was made to take one side or the other. Also an | | | ...

Words: 268 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

John Q

...John Q. Crystal Beere HCS/235 March 16, 2015 Steve Linerode John Q. John is like many people in the country that have a low income job. He is working a full time job but still doesn’t make enough to afford insurance on his own so he has Medicaid. This limits his options on coverage and who he can go to. He has a condition that needs medical attention, high blood pressure, but because of his insurance he is finding it hard to get the care he needs. Many people have that problem but there are solutions to get the care you need. John lives in a rural area that doesn’t have any primary care doctors that take his insurance. He was able to find two doctors in his area but not a primary care physician. The closest primary care physician he found is forty minutes away from his home. This is a challenge for him because he catches a ride to work or relies on public transportation. These problems are mutable, which means they can change. He could move to a different place, closer to the doctor he needs to see. Although with his low income job he might not be able to afford a place closer to the doctor he needs to see. He could also invest in getting a car. The cheapest option for him would to be get a car so he doesn’t have to rely on others to take him and possibly miss an appointment. He could still catch a ride with a friend or use public transportation if he wants to save on gas so he has it to get to his......

Words: 1127 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

John Q.

...Another movie based on the inhumane effects of our privatized health care system. I was not expecting the type of movie that it was, especially what John decides to do in order to save his son’s life. By now, I have seen two movies on the healthcare system that have truly amazed me and have left me with powerful messages about what we don’t see daily within our so-called expensive health care system. This movie reminded me of the struggles that those within poorer communities suffer from: lack of healthcare coverage. In comparison, to Patch Adams this movie had a much more dramatic effect to capture the battle between loved ones and saving lives. Furthermore, it captures every part of what actual society would go through if their loved ones were denied entry into a list for heart transplants. I think that this movie serves as another reminder of what we still need to improve in our health care. But see I feel that it’s not only our health care that needs fixing but those within it seem to lack of compassion for families of this sort, who cannot pay for their medical expenses. This movie portrays the most frustrating issue that I’ve seen up to this point in several health care movies and that is the inhumane and materialistic ways that doctors handle their medical attention. I think that this really gives me a new outlet on part of why a nationalized health care is not being considered by the AMA (American Medical Association); these doctors just want their money. These......

Words: 352 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

John Q Revenge Quotes

...If there is something that has been going on for years, its revenge. At least everyone has had a situation where they feel that someone has done them wrong, and want to get back at them for whatever they did. Most of the reasons why revenge doesn’t end well, is because whatever is said or done, can’t be changed later on. For example, in the movie John Q, the main character wants to get revenge on the people that work at the hospital for not putting his son’s name on the surgery list. John Q tries to get revenge by keeping a couple people hostage in the Emergency Room, until they put his son’s name on the list. Although he received charges for his actions, his son got the surgery he needed, and could survive. Furthermore, in Poison Tree by...

Words: 274 - Pages: 2

Free Essay


...PART 1 Company Allocation Ticker symbol | Company | | GICS Sector | GICS Sub Industry | Address of Headquarters | | BEN | Franklin Resources | | Financials | Diversified Financial Services | San Mateo, California | | FCX | Freeport-McMoran Cp & Gld | | Materials | Diversified Metals & Mining | Phoenix, Arizona | | The cost of capital of the aforementioned companies will be discussed in the following questions. The companies will be referred to by their Ticker Symbols henceforth. Question 1 BEN The book value of the company’s liabilities and equity can be deduced from a number of online sources. The US Securities and Exchange Commission (2013) provided the company filings data whereby BEN’s Form 10q, dated 29/07/2013, showed the following (included on page 2 of this report). The book value of long-term debt is $1,252.1 million, and the book value of equity is $10,402.3 million. The schedule of outstanding debt shows that this figure includes $54.5 million of FHLB advances and $1197.6 million of Senior Notes at various effective interest rates. The notes on Stockholders Equity and Non- Redeemable Non-Controlling Interests reveal that Franklin Resources Inc Stockholders Equity totals $9779.8 million whilst the Non- Redeemable Non-Controlling Interests (previously referred to as minority interests) totals $622.5 million. FCX The book value of the company’s liabilities and equity can be deduced from a number of online sources. The US......

Words: 2672 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Health Care System and John Q

...The movie John Q is about a desperate father's struggle to find a heart for his dying son. At first we see a pretty happy family. They have their fair share of problems which every family has but they work things out and always try to stay positive. At Mike’s baseball game he collapses and has a seizure. When they go to the hospital they find out that Mike has a heart two times the normal size. This means that if he doesn’t get a heart transplant, he will die. So what’s the problem? Can’t he just get a new heart? If only it were that simple. As we all know, everything in life costs money, especially when it comes to our health. The hospital tells them that they have to pay a down payment of $75,000. As a factory worker, John can’t afford to pay that. On top of that, he finds out that his insurance company doesn’t cover major operations after he decided to work part time. Many people in the United States today don't have health insurance which can be a problem, especially if you have a family to take care of. The article written by Wisdom Workers Ministries describes the insurance companies as "evil" and that it's wrong for hospitals and the government to not guarantee transplants and other expensive medical treatments to everyone who needs them. He even told the hospital that he would pay them back little by little but they refused. According to the U.S. Census Bureau, there are 249,384 families,, 242,403 white people, 38,624 black people, 14,011 Asians, and 48,901 Hispanics......

Words: 779 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Synoptic Problem

...LIBERTY UNIVERSITY THE SYNOPTIC PROBLEM A RESEARCH PAPER SUBMITTED TO DR. CAROL A. THOMAS IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE COURST NBST 525 LIBERTY BAPTIST THEOLOGICAL SEMINARY BY LYNCHBURG, VIRGINIA , 2013 CONTENTS INTRODUCTION 1 EXPLORATION OF THE SYNOPTIC GOSPELS........................................................................1 ORAL THEORY.............................................................................................................................2 THE TWO-SOURCE HYPOTHESIS.............................................................................................3 THE GREISBACH HYPOSTHESIS..............................................................................................4 THE FARRER-GOULDER HYPOTHESIS...................................................................................5 THE AUGUSTINE HYPOSTHESIS..............................................................................................6 DEFENSE OF THE SYNOPTIC PROBLEM................................................................................6 CONCLUSION...............................................................................................................................7 BIBLIOGRAPHY...........................................................................................................................9 INTRODUCTION At first, one reads the words “Synoptic Problem” and assumes the worst. The expression...

Words: 2814 - Pages: 12

Free Essay

The Synoptic Problem

...| The Synoptic Problem | Understanding the relationship between the synoptic Gospels | | The New Testament of the Bible begins with the four Gospels: Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John. These four books are a biography of the life Jesus Christ. Most want to views these books as photographs of the life and ministry of Christ, but they should really be viewed as portraits of Christ. A photograph takes a picture and shows you exactly what is there, while a portrait can add different perspectives on the same image. If four people each painted a picture of a sunset each painter would show the sunset from a different perspective (1). Each author of the books of the Gospels adds his own views into each book. Matthew, Mark, and Luke are known as the synoptic Gospels. The word synoptic in Greek means “seeing together” this is appropriate for these books because of the common viewpoint. While John is known as the supplemental Gospel, and has very different characteristics from the other three books.(2) If we view the Gospels as a modern day biography we would want to see all the facts of Jesus's life and them all to be laid out in chronological order. The authors of the Gospels however were basing their versions of Jesus's life off of ancient biographies. These works were not written in chronological order, but were written with specific facts to show the significance of one's life. The way the Gospels were written was very understandable to the people of that time. (1) The...

Words: 1573 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Ethical Systems and Reaction to John Q the Movie

...many factors, may it be consciously or unconsciously into doing things that we do. John Quincy Archibald, or more well known as John Q. throughout the movie was in a case of bad timing in his life. He saw his son, Michael, collapse in a baseball game due to an enlarged heart. Because of that, Michael needed a donor and an immediate surgery to survive, which will cost a lot of money. Simultaneously, this was also the time where John Q. was dropped by his company from being a full-time employee to a part-time employee only, which affected his health insurance policies. His insurance would not be able to cover up the expenses needed for Michael’s treatment. John Q tried his best to earn money to put Michael in the donor list but fails to do so which leads the hospital to release Michael. Unwilling to give his son to the arms of death, John Q pulls out his handgun and orders the hospital staff to put Michael in the donor list. He then holds hostage on 11 of the people who were in the hospital to meet his demands for his son to survive. As the hostages and John Q spent time in the hospital, they got to know each other a lot better and the hostages actually felt much empathy and sympathy for John. The whole world even witnessed the struggles of John with the law for the life of his beloved son when a news team tapped into the SWAT camera operations with the scene of SWAT sniper was supposed to kill John while in a phone conversation with his son but failed to do so. He gained the......

Words: 849 - Pages: 4

Free Essay


...Problem. Determining the dependence or interdependence of each Gospel then attempts to conclude, which Gospel was written first, and subsequently, which Gospel then used the other as a primary source, and if not what source was then used to compile the gospel in question. “Mark's Gospel is the shortest of the three, yet large portions of it are also found in Matthew and Luke. Additionally, Matthew and Luke share a significant amount of verses (more than 200) that are not found in Mark. The similarities include subject matter, exact wording, and even order of events. When material is found in all three Synoptic Gospels, it is referred to as triple tradition. The material that is only found in Matthew and Luke is called double tradition, or Q. Also, the material that distinctively belongs to Matthew is called the M tradition, while that which belongs to Luke is called the L tradition” (The) The content of M suggests that the community for which this gospel was written, as stricter than the others in its attitude to keeping the Jewish law, holding that they must exceed the scribes and Pharisees in “righteousness (adherence to Jewish Law); and the three M refers to a church, an organized group with rules for keeping order. Biblical scholars generally hold that Matthew was composed between the years c.70 and 100” (Gospels). “Historically, two (2) basic solutions to the Synoptic Problem have...

Words: 1325 - Pages: 6

Free Essay


...Liberty University THE SYNOPTIC PROBLEM A paper submitted to PROFESSOR MONTE SHANKS In partial fulfillment of the Requirements for the course NBST 510 Liberty Theological seminary By Wilbert L. Bracey Lynchburg, Virginia February 1, 2014 TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------1 The Synoptic Problem-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------2 Markan Priority---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------3 Q Hypothesis------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------4 L and M------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------6 Two Gospel Hypothesis-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------7 Conclusion--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------10 Bibliography------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------11 Introduction There are differences in the area of Synoptic Gospel as well as there are large amounts of similarities that can be proved with all the evidence written as well as physical. The synoptic Gospels are ones that include Matthew, Luke and Mark. The reason they are called synoptic, which means, seen together, is......

Words: 3222 - Pages: 13

Free Essay


...THE SYNOPTIC APOCALYPSE (MARK 13 PAR): A DOCUMENT FROM THE TIME OF BAR KOCHBA Hermann Detering* he thirteenth chapter of the Gospel of Mark belongs to those texts of the New Testament which have been examined particularly often in recent times. Despite many differences in detail, a certain consensus is apparent between exegeses in so far as they all assume that the text in question, the so-called “Synoptic Apocalypse” (hereafter abbreviated as the SynApoc), arose either in the first or the second half of the first century. This investigation, however, will show that there are a number of factors which exclude such a dating and that numerous of clues indicate rather an origin in the time of the Bar Kochba uprising (132-135 CE). To be sure, the possibility of assigning such a date, which diverges considerably from what is usually taken for granted, does not even occure to most scholars, since the conclusion of their investigation is clearly determined by a prior methodological assumption: since the common assumption is that both Mark and Matthew were written in the second half of the first century, the SynApoc must also belong to this period or even precede it. In my opinion, however, for various reasons, it is highly questionable whether the customary and generally accepted dating of Mark's gospel around 70 CE is correct. Whoever concerns himself with the question of when the Synoptic Gospels arose quickly notices that he has hit upon a genuine weak point in the scholarly......

Words: 20760 - Pages: 84