John Stuart Mill's on Liberty and Same-Sex Marriage Legalization

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By cdesilva621
Words 1052
Pages 5
John Stuart Mill’s On Liberty and Same-Sex Marriage Legalization
There has been a significant amount of controversy in the past few years leading up to the current regarding the issue of legalizing same-sex marriage in the United States. In the recent election, many states have voted in favor of the legalization of same-sex marriage. However, there has been little movement towards legalization on the federal level. Earlier this year, President Obama made the statement supporting the idea that same-sex marriage should be legal. Thus, making a statement on one of the most vexed, and politically charged social issues being faced in the United States presently. Obama made this statement knowing that in a few months he would be announcing his campaign for reelection, and thus received fierce opposition from many groups as well as his Republican opponent in his race for reelection.
My personal stance on this issue is that without a doubt, same-sex marriage should be legalized. In the process of legalization, it would give every American citizen regardless of sexual orientation the ability to marry and their union to be recognized on the federal level. Many individuals might argue that this would degrade the sanctity of marriage, but with the percentage of marriages ending in divorce or otherwise that argument can hardly be supported. Another opposition that is brought up repeatedly is that the Bible and other religious scriptures do not speak in support of same-sex marriage and thus deeming it immoral. In response to this argument, I would reference Thomas Jefferson and his statement, “ wall of separation between church and state.” In accordance with the rights set by the Amendments of the Constitution, it allows individuals to practice religion freely without fear of persecution, and does not allow the government to enforce any laws regarding religious practices.…...

Similar Documents

Homosexuality & Same Sex Marriage

...Homosexuality & same sex marriage Homosexuality is not only offensive to a religious person who believes God created a man and a woman to institute  marriage, but it is also unacceptable to many who see it as a degeneration of the family, and a danger to a healthy society. Many pressures are put upon people by others and their beliefs. In today’s society one of our major pressures of life and freedom is homosexuality. Many people argue whether it is right or wrong, and some people just do not care or just do not want to talk about it. Homosexuality is on the rise in the United States as well as many other countries. Homosexuality and same sex marriages are rising; marriages are taking place. In the eyes of the church, God and many others this is a socially incorrect relationship. Throughout the United States and other countries, Homosexuality or same sex marriages defies the laws of Christianity and it is an immoral acts in Gods eyes and society. God created humanity to be fertile, Adam and Eve to be heterosexuals to populate the world with a heterosexual raise. Man and woman bodies symbolically as one flesh, to marry create children and their children to create children. How is homosexual to be a part of Gods plains. In Genesis 2:4 to 2:25 it states specifically that a man and woman, one flesh one body. Homosexuals raising a kid, which is not in the Holy Bible, in the Bible it reads Adam and Eve not Adam and Steve or Jane and Anne. Homosexuals raising kids this...

Words: 1207 - Pages: 5

Legalization of Same-Sex Marriage

...Should Same-sex Marriages be Legalized? Kristina Linthicum PHI 200: Mind and Machine Instructor Michele Clearman-Warner May 5, 2011 Should Same-sex Marriages be Legalized? In recent news articles, it is being said that the legalization of same-sex marriages is imminent. But the biggest debate about the issue is should it be legalized? While there are many points that are for and against the issue, one thing remains. This is a legal issue on whether the law should be changed. When deciding whether a law should be changed, it should be viewed in a legal manner. Here is why same-sex marriages should be legalized in the United States of America. Part I: Thesis The United States of America was based on freedom. While each freedom was not spelled out in the constitution, it is something that can not be refuted. The Merriam-Webster Dictionary defines to marry as “to take a spouse or to unite in close and usually permanent relations” (Definition 2). While it is socially more accepted now than ever for same-sex couples to live together and even have children together, why are they being held back in receiving the freedom and benefits every opposite-sex couples receive? The right to be able to marry should be equal whether in same-sex couples or opposite-sex couples. Finkelstein (2011) points out that “marriage strengthens commitment between couples and therefore brings stability into the lives of those who enter in it”. If same-sex couples are able to...

Words: 2266 - Pages: 10

Same Sex Marriage: for Liberty Nad Justice for All?

... prohibit us from being at the funeral and visiting our partner’s grave. Family members can take any real estate properties even if we had been paying on it for years, sell it and leave us with the debt on a property that we don’t own anymore (Hertz). The sad thing is that these situations have happened to some of my friends in the gay community. These are issues that have become protected in state laws over the years in many ways that disregard gay individuals from the rights that heterosexual married couples enjoy and believe that is their constitutional right. This is why most gay people say that it’s a civil rights issue. It doesn’t matter to us who is performing the ceremony or if our announcement is in the local newspaper. We just want to be able to enjoy the same rights that other married couples enjoy by law. As pointed out, the arguments against gay marriage don't make a great case and they are a little hypocritical. Scott Bidstrup, an author and human rights advocate, said it best: "Let's get over our aversion to what we oppose for silly, irrational reasons, based on ignorance and faulty assumptions, and make ours a more just and honorable society, finally honoring that last phrase from the Pledge of Allegiance; "With liberty and justice for all" (McCall). Work Cited/Bibliography Chang MD, Louise. “Study: Same-Sex Parents Raise Well-Adjusted Kids”. WebMD. 12 Oct. 2005. Web. 20 Feb. 2012 Eskridge, William, and Darren Spedale. “Who’s Afraid of Gay Marriage...

Words: 2497 - Pages: 10

Same-Sex Marriage

... only then would you agree that same-sex marriage is indeed not immoral and must not be feared. Morals, in its most basic definition can be defined as: motivations based on the ideas of 'right and wrong'. But who decides what is 'right and wrong'? What may be right for you, may be wrong for me, and vice-versa, so who decides? Does the majority get to make all the decisions, and only if you are like the majority, are you granted the most basic rights to love and marriage? Well, you decide. It is of course a free country thanks to all our forefathers and men who lost their lives for freedom. But, I say, you know it is a sad day when politicians and these so-called 'intelligent men' supposed to be conversed in all matters of society CAN NOT see it, but you can see it clear as day. That we are all equal, and all deserve the same rights as the next 'man'. The Constitution of the United States says: 'that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.' Well, that for me is as clear as it gets. Everyone should be granted the most basic right to love and marriage, not just 'straight men'....

Words: 1274 - Pages: 6

Same-Sex Marriage

... that tradition should not be made into law and that it can and should be broken when a person’s freedom and human rights are denied. In the 1600s, pilgrims fled England. They did not agree with the King’s law that you must believe in what he believed. They wanted to live and worship as they chose not as they were told. Because of this, they took a stand and left England in search of freedom from tyranny. Many traditions were brought with them, some they shed, and some new traditions were established through their own ideals and beliefs. In 1776 the political leaders and statesmen of the original thirteen colonies of the United States of America drafted and signed the Declaration of Independence. “We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, which among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.” (Independence Hall Association, 1995) There were no exemptions written. Arguments against same-sex marriage vary depending on the opponents moral, religious, and traditional beliefs. One main argument is that including same-sex marriage in the laws forces tax payers to foot the bill for the benefits that will then be available to this non-traditional couple. These include Social Security and employer provided benefits. Where this argument loses its validity is in its nearsightedness. We pay our state and federal income tax based on our income, and everyone pays the same...

Words: 2331 - Pages: 10

John Stuart Mill's on Liberty and Same-Sex Marriage Legalization

...John Stuart Mill’s On Liberty and Same-Sex Marriage Legalization There has been a significant amount of controversy in the past few years leading up to the current regarding the issue of legalizing same-sex marriage in the United States. In the recent election, many states have voted in favor of the legalization of same-sex marriage. However, there has been little movement towards legalization on the federal level. Earlier this year, President Obama made the statement supporting the idea that same-sex marriage should be legal. Thus, making a statement on one of the most vexed, and politically charged social issues being faced in the United States presently. Obama made this statement knowing that in a few months he would be announcing his campaign for reelection, and thus received fierce opposition from many groups as well as his Republican opponent in his race for reelection. My personal stance on this issue is that without a doubt, same-sex marriage should be legalized. In the process of legalization, it would give every American citizen regardless of sexual orientation the ability to marry and their union to be recognized on the federal level. Many individuals might argue that this would degrade the sanctity of marriage, but with the percentage of marriages ending in divorce or otherwise that argument can hardly be supported. Another opposition that is brought up repeatedly is that the Bible and other religious scriptures do not speak in support of same-sex marriage...

Words: 1052 - Pages: 5

Same Sex Marriage

... marriage as between heterosexual couples will weaken an already threatened institution and by legalizing same-sex unions will introduce legalization of polygamy, incestuous, and non-traditional unions the right to marry, which seems to be a little extreme. Glen Lavy, JD, senior counsel with the Alliance Defense fund, argued in May 21, 2008 Los Angeles Times Op-Ed, “ The movement of polygamy and polyamory is poised to use the successes of same-sex couples as a springboard for further de-institutionalizing marriage.” Although this is a concern for many, polygamy is a union practiced here in the United States today many frown upon such union, but this type of union has also been around just as long as heterosexual unions. In 1967 the Supreme Court case Loving vs. Virginia confirmed marriage is “one of the basic civil rights of man,” and by this meaning same-sex unions should receive the same rights. Matthew D. Staver, JD, Dean of the Liberty University School of Law explained: “The unifying characteristics of the protected classes within the civil rights Act of 1964 include a (1) history of longstanding, (2) widespread discrimination, economic disadvantage, and (3) immutable characteristics and sexual orientation does not meet any of the three objective criteria shared by the historically protected civil rights categories.” There are many arguments regarding same-sex unions/marriage, but the debate over same-sex unions/marriage continues and will continues for many years to......

Words: 671 - Pages: 3

Same Sex Marriage

... the laws found in the Bible, which most religions in America follow. (Messerli) This type of marriage also effects Christian based organizations and colleges in America (Dobson). They would be forced to accept those who are homosexual by giving them an equal opportunity, all while betraying the religion they stand for. Same sex marriages should not be legalized because of its negative effects on children, people in general, and religions. It would only cause more problems and chaos between Americans. It is just not a match for our society. Works Cited Anderson, Kerby. “Talking Points Against Homosexual ‘Marriage’.” Probe Ministries. Probe Ministries. 4 Nov. 2006 . Diggs, John R. Jr. M.D. “The Health Risks of Gay Sex.” Corporate Resource Council, 2002. Catholic Education Resource Center. 2002. Catholic Education Resource Center. 4 Nov. 2006 . Dobson, James Dr. “Eleven Arguments Against Same Sex Marriage.” Marriage Under Fire: Why We Must Win This Battle. Multnomah Publishers, June. Crosswalk.com The Intersection of Faith & Life. Crosswalk. 4 Nov. 2006 . Kiley, Judah. “Evidence Is Clear: Children Are Substantially Better Off When Raised by a Committed Mother and Father.” Values Advocacy Council. Values Advocacy Council. 4 Nov. 2006......

Words: 754 - Pages: 4

Same-Sex Marriage

...Do we get our rights from God or the government? Sophia, October 20, 2013 A lot of cultural commentators believe that what people think of same-sex marriages, depends on their religious beliefs. But it is very far from the truth to call the same-sex marriage debate a religious debate, when it is actually all about politics. What one’s view on same-sex marriages is depends on whether one is conservative, liberal or libertarian. Or perhaps basic human rights and values? At least that is what Mike Adams writes in his article ‘Three Views on Same Sex Marriage’ the 21st of May 2012 for www.townhall.com. He calls the issue pretty simple for the conservatives, because they think the marital institution predates any governmental decision. To the conservatives, marriage is about protecting women and children, and taming men. The liberals do not think that we as individuals get our rights from God, but instead the rights are given to groups by the government. Liberals are of the opinion that any government can change any law and regulation as they want to, and they do not consider marriage to predate any laws. Libertarians, however, think that it is problematic to recognize marriage in any form. The government should not be in the business of promoting a religious institution, nor should the government recognize and regulate an even broader range of relationships than it already does. David Blankenhorn – in value-based opinion shift In 2007 David Blankenhorn, author...

Words: 1007 - Pages: 5

Same-Sex Marriage

...Same-sex marriage is a marriage between two people of the same biological sex identity. It is also one of the most common topics, that is being discussed all over the world. Same-sex marriage is currently legal in eight different countries, and only seventeen states legalized same-sex marriage in the US. From generation to generation people have fought to legalize and ban the rights to same-sex marriage. The world teaches us that love doesn’t have a specific color or gender, but people still are not happy about it. Marriage according to the dictionary is, “any diverse forms of interpersonal union established in various parts of the world to form a familial bond that is recognized legally, religiously, or socially, granting the participating partners mutual conjugal rights and responsibilities.” I believe that marriage is about two people who loves each other unconditionally, it’s a partnership, a life-long commitment to support and be there for each other no matter what. Both participants become “one.” They share this bond with God, our Leader. Denying same sex marriage is a violation of religious freedom. Civil and religious freedom is two separate institutions. A civil ceremony is recognized as legal and valid under the law. The 14th amendment stated, “No state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of the citizens.” Meaning, who are you to tell another human being who they are allowed to love, or how to live their lives. The US......

Words: 351 - Pages: 2

Same Sex Marriage

... could potentially lead down a "slippery slope" giving people in polygamous, incestuous, bestial, and other nontraditional relationships the right to marry.” (ProCon.org) The fact that gay marriage rights is a social problem in American society is clear, and the social problems process is surely in progress. The changes are being made and there are very many more people getting in on the debates, and standing up for what they believe is the right thing to do. In the 1900s gay marriage was not heard of or talked about. Media coverage is used a lot in the Gay marriage conflict. The media has shown pro and cons to gay marriage. I will be explaining why the media has been mostly pro on gay marriage and what the media coverage is doing for it. According to the Pew Research Center's Project for Excellence in Journalism looked at nearly 500 stories on the topic over a two-month period that began just before the court started hearings in March on legalizing same-sex marriage. This topic has been rising in the media and has been talked about weekly in the news. The media also shows a lot of coverage about gay celebrities getting married . Ellen Degenorous and Abby Wombach are some of the many celebrities who have tied the knot. Other celebrities have come out of the closet this year including Raven Symon , Matt Bomer, Lance Bass and Ricky Martin. As you can probably assume feelings towards same-sex marriage has changed over time. In the early 2000’s the gay marriage debate...

Words: 1642 - Pages: 7

Same Sex Marriage

...Southern New Hampshire University 10-2 Same-Sex Marriage Kari Harmon Professor Mary Orcutt June 08, 2014 Introduction Same-sex marriage, popularly known as gay marriage, is a socially or legally reorganized wedlock between two persons of similar social gender or biological sex. Although the idea of same-sex marriage can be traced back to ancient times, in the United States, it not is legally reorganized at the national level. Some federal governments have, however managed to legalize same-sex marriage; namely in Massachusetts, Vermont, the district of Columbia, Iowa and Connecticut. The issue of same-sex marriage is one that has attracted a lot of controversies world over. In many nations, it has attracted conflicts in such issues as social, moral, political, religious and civil rights. The argument of same-sex marriage is an important one. The question of legalization of same sex marriages is an issue in many of our states today. I would like to argue that same-sex marriages do not infringe on any civil rights, but it is also immoral. We, as Christians, should not be afraid to stand up and use our Constitutional rights to speak against same-sex marriages. The debate over whether same-sex marriage should be legalized has focused on the infringement of civil rights. State recognition of marriages is not a common right. States control marriages in many ways, not just by denying same sex gender the right to marry...

Words: 996 - Pages: 4

Legalizing Same Sex Marriage

...Michelle Burns COMM1133 - Section 57 Shelley Bradley Essay 2 - Final draft Thursday, December 5th 2013 Legalizing Same-Sex Marriage Put yourself in the position of a homosexual and imagine how they feel in regards to the injustices of their sexual orientation. Some feel humiliation and others rejection, simply because homosexuals are attracted to the same sex. Same-sex marriages should be legalized internationally because the Bible dictates only one of many lifestyles to live by and there is more to marriage than legal recognition. In addition, it would eliminate discrimination against same-sex marriages. The Bible appears to be the leading argument opposing same-sex marriages. It is known across the Christian religion that homosexuality is a sin. The Bible says that God loves the sinners, but hates the sin (Roman 5:8, English Standard Version). He will not stop loving someone because they want to marry someone of the same-sex, He is against the concept. Although, the Bible also states “sexual immorality, impurity, sensuality, idolatry, sorcery, enmity, strife, jealousy, fits of anger, rivalries, dissensions, divisions, envy, drunkenness, orgies, and things like these. I warn you, as I warned you before, that those who do such things will not inherit the kingdom of God” (Galatians 5:19-21, English Standard Version). There are several sins that are listed in the Bible that people do on a regular basis, such as jealousy, rivalries and fits of anger, yet they are not...

Words: 999 - Pages: 4

Same Sex Marriage

.... Instead, we had always imagined that we would one day have a commitment ceremony in which our own personally meaningful rituals would affirm our commitment, regardless of the lack of legal recognition.” But to her and her partners surprise Massachusetts legalized marriage on May 17th, 2004 after legislation didn’t take action after 180 days. Later on in the article Members of the Wedding: The Psychological Impact of the Legalization of Same-Sex Marriage in Massachusetts by Cara Segal she states, “Complicating matters further is the fact that for many gay and lesbian couples, making the decision to marry legally carries a symbolic meaning of recognition, but in reality can lead to further ostracization by those who feel threatened by our entrance into an institution that remains so heavily guarded. As we gain political proximity, they seem willing to seek any means to bar us from entrance, in a desperate effort to reaffirm their difference from us. It is true that for those who reify their heterosexuality and its supposed God-granted benefits, something is at stake: Any sameness that we achieve dismantles their claim on specialness, not to mention threatens their defensive stake on heterosexuality.” The above statement really connects to popular opinions that surrounded the U.S as well as what happened in California. May 15th, 2008 California legalized same-sex marriage but only six months later a referendum to ban same-sex marriage was approved overturning same-sex......

Words: 1676 - Pages: 7

Same Sex Marriage

... against it argue that same-sex relationships are immoral, against God's will and subvert the goal of human sexuality, which is to produce children. The Jewish church also varies in its approach to same-sex marriage. The Islamic faith openly rejects homosexuality, citing the story of Lot in Sodom as a condemnation of homosexuality. Same-sex marriages are now legal in 17 countries as well as in some jurisdictions within the United States and Mexico. Needless to say, the Filipino LGBT (Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender) community is keenly observing what might happen next overseas, with the hope that someday, similar progress can be achieved here. Based on the arguments presented by advocates of same-sex marriages overseas, the equal protection clause of the constitution (“all people are equal before the law”) should necessarily mean that gay marriages should be recognized just like heterosexual marriages. Incidentally, the 1987 Philippine Constitution actually has an equal protection clause as well (Article III, Section 1). Another argument being raised in support of same-sex marriage legalization is that doing so will give gay couples not only the stability of being in an officially-recognized marriage but also all the benefits that comes with it. While few societies have recognized same-sex unions as marriages, the historical and anthropological record reveals a large range of attitudes towards same-sex unions ranging from praise, through full acceptance and...

Words: 2254 - Pages: 10