Free Essay

Jury Selection Process

In: Other Topics

Submitted By makusayhmm
Words 679
Pages 3
Jury Selection Process Paper
David L. Clay
CJS/211
August 10, 2015
Johnny Cotton

Jury Selection Process Paper

In this paper we will discuss what the author in The Color of Justice: Race Ethnicity, and Crime in America refers to as the disparity “in the jury selection process”. In this paper we will address the processes and cases that have helped control the systematic discrimination of the court process, how the jury nullification is used in relation to diversity, as well as discussing the use of peremptory challenges to jury selection and the impact on the jury composition. In order to fully discuss these issues you must first know the definition of disparity. Disparity is defined as inequality were things are different or not equal. The disparity that is explained by the author is in reference to how African American and Mexican Americans were excluded from the process of jury selection but was found to be protected according to the Equal protection Clause in the 14th Amendment. It states that they cannot be prohibited from serving on a jury. In the beginning jury selection was geared toward white males only. The process of jury selection is usually compiled from two major sources of voter registration cards and driver’s license. One case that represents the control of the systematic discrimination is the case of the Scottsboro boys. Nine African American boys were accused of raping two white girls on a train. The boys were convicted of a capital offense. In the first trial case there was no counsel to represent the accused. Eight of the accused was sentenced to death. They appealed and the Supreme Court reversed the decision citing that due process was by law not afforded to them. Later they were retried after a brief reprieve were in they were convicted a second time. Appeal was made citing that all the jurors were white, it was found that black jurors were not even placed in a pool for selection. Ultimately the state eight months later comprised a jury of 13 whites and 1 African American. The conviction was up heled and the prosecutor used the peremptory challenge to achieve the jury selection. Jury nullification in reference to diversity suggest that racially biased jury nullification that African American were less likely to convict one of their own even though the evidence against them was present. Rooted in English law were jurors believe that the evidence in the trial proceedings clearly convicts the defendant but the juror chooses to acquit rather than to convict. Circumstance that would be mitigating could be the cause of this acquittal. Punishment for the crime could be too harsh or crimes that are committed in the protection and the safety of children and family members. Jurors clearly have the power to nullify the law and to vote their conscience. Juries who acquit the double jeopardy clause in the Fifth Amendment bans reversal of their decision. Even though that evidence may be staggering against the defendant the decision of the jury is final. The peremptory challenge that prosecutors and defense use is the subject of controversy and seemed by some as being racially discriminating. It has been studied that substantial evidence has been presented that suggest that challenges issued in Louisiana 1976-1981 there was found that prosecutors eliminated African American jurors lopsided disproportioned to whites. According to Turner, Lovell, Young, and Denny it was also found that minorities make up most of the jurisdictions therefore the exclusion of black prospective jurors is accomplished a lot more easily than those of their Caucasian counter parts. In as much as our justice system is founded on blind justice, it is this blind justice that comes into play when seeing the disparity in the jury selection process. Seemingly there is a conscience for equality however there are tools such as the peremptory challenge that make this type of justice null and void.
Reference
Spohn, C., Walker, S., & Delone, M. (2012). The Color Of Justice, Race, Ethnicity, and Crime in America (5th ed.). Belmont, CA: Cengage Learning.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Jury Selection Process

...Jury Selection Process Every American that has registered to vote or has a drivers license can at any time be called to serve on a jury. There are mixed feelings about being called for duty. Some Americans see it as a nuisance that will disrupt their lives. Others see it as an opportunity to serve their country. Being called to serve, and actually serving is two different matters. A jury is ultimately selected by the judge, prosecutor and defending attorney. How they are they picked? How are they released? Maybe this paper will answer a few of these questions. The selection of a jury is the process that occurs right before the actual trial, and after the trial initiation and the arraignment and plea. Only about 10 percent of actual arraignments see an actual trial, because 90 percent of cases that are preparing for trial end up accepting a plea bargain (Schmalleher, 2009). Any one who is accused of a crime and will stand trial is allowed by the Sixth Amendment the right to an impartial jury. For a jury to be impartial, it is not always true that they have no prior knowledge of the case at all. In the case of a highly publicized trial, it can be almost impossible to find 12 people who know nothing about the case at hand or the accused. Some jurors will be excused based on how suitable they are judged to be for the case, and some may be excused because of reasons beyond their control (Schmalleger, 2009). I have been called to serve jury duty one time in my life. At the...

Words: 1205 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Jury Selection Process Paper

...I am thankful to have existing knowledge of the jury selection process in Madison County due to my affiliation and activity with the criminal justice system there. Brian Risinger is the Madison County District Attorney and through the years I have learned the process from him. I have also provided courtroom security through these processes and have observed them firsthand. The first thing the DA’s Office does is request a copy of the jury list from the district clerk a few days before trial. They run everyone through our local system to check for previous offenses, convictions, etc. They have several eyes comb the list to see if there are particular jurors that would not be good to have on the jury. These characteristics will vary depending on the nature of the case. For instance if they know there is someone on the jury list who was wrongfully accused of rape, they wouldn’t want them on a sexual assault trial....

Words: 603 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Cjs 211

...Wilfredo Hernandez Rivera Disparity in the jury selection process CJS/221 September 7 2015 Christopher Manning In the United states of America talking about racism is something uncommon as a lot of if people know that they are laws that go against discrimination and racism, however this does not mean that thoughts and emotional racism feelings are involve in the daily life of a lot of people in the United States, therefore this discriminatory thoughts or ideas are always involve in all the system that are meant to serve and protect society, this would also include the same system that is meant to provide equality and justice in America, the court justice system. In this paper there will be some key points to study, such key points includes: An explanation of the process and cases that have helped to control the systemic discrimination of the courts in this process, a discussion of how jury nullification is used in relation to diversity, and a discussion of the use of peremptory challenges to jury selection and the impact on the jury composition. Firs let’s start with how some processes have helped to control the systematic discrimination of courts in this process. One of the most common process to fight discrimination is the selection of a jury pool. There are different facts about the jury pool selection, this one’s includes “that all white jury has been a staple of the America criminal justice system for...

Words: 846 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Psychologists’ Roles Within the Legal System

...Psychologists’ Roles within the Legal System Introduction There are many roles a forensic psychologist can choose to take part in, within the legal system, such as; the basic scientists, the applied scientists, policy evaluator, forensic evaluator, and consultant. Each of these roles has different duties/ responsibilities and may assist in or concentrate in different areas/ environments within the legal system. As a psychologist, within the legal system you will examine many individuals from the police officer to the victim. Being a psychologist within the legal system has many ethical obligations or issues that can arise. With this in mind, I will discuss more in detail the roles a psychologist plays in each environment within the legal system and some of the ethical issues. Basic Scientist There are many environments a forensic psychologist may choose to take part in. These environments are law enforcement, corrections, court system, and academic. Even though a psychologist can play a role in many environments, not all environments need every role of the psychologist. ”A basic scientist pursues knowledge for its own sake and studies a phenomenon for the satisfaction of understanding it and contributing to scientific advances in the area” (Greene, & Hailbrun, 2010 p18). As a basic scientist, there are some opportunities for the psychologists, in law enforcement and corrections. The psychologist can do training in a specific area; if the psychologist has knowledge of the...

Words: 1519 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Jury Paper

...------------------------------------------------- jury selection process Jocelyn Edwards April 15, 2016 CJS/221 Instructor EBONY PULLINS-GOVANTES Jocelyn Edwards April 15, 2016 CJS/221 Instructor EBONY PULLINS-GOVANTES An explanation of the jury selection process is known as several methods normally used to select the people that will serve on a jury. During this process you have several steps that occur and they are listed as the following: First thing first, you start off with a jury pool which is where the individuals are selected from a community simply by using a fair random method. Then, a list of names for the jury are collected from Voter's registration and driver's license or state ID renewals. Next, there are summonses mailed to different citizens and that’s where a panel of jurors are appointed to a courtroom and randomly picked to serve in the jury box. Third, the judge and attorneys have an option whether or not to challenge for a cause argument or use one of the peremptory challenges based on jurisdiction. Lastly, the jury in certain jurisdictions must be death qualified to remote those who are opposed to the death penalty. Here are a few cases that helped controlled the systemic discrimination of the courts in this process: 1880 decision of Strauder v. West Virginia, United States v. Nelson, Swain v. Alabama, Purkett v. Elem, and Batson v. Kentucky just to name a few. Jury nullification is used in relation to diversity because it's based on an ultimately...

Words: 859 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Crime

...Jury Selection Process Paper Amber Spencer CJS/221 August 24, 2015 Stephen Humphries The disparity in the jury selection process has been present in the United States for centuries. The jury is a very important part of the justice system, even though many cases are settled by the plea deal and never make it in front of a jury. The cases that seem to end up in front of a jury are very high-profile crimes that have long prison sentences or even the death penalty on the table. What the jury was developed for was to provide "the criminal defendant's fundamental protection of life and liberty against race and color prejudice" (McCleskey v. Kemp pg. 279). In the early 1800's only white men were allowed to serve on a jury. In 1880 in the case of Strauder v. West Virginia, the supreme court found that it was violating a clause under the Fourteenth Amendment by excluding African-Americans from the jury pools because of their color alone was causing a great deal of harm to the African American population. In the case of Neal v. Delaware, which occurred only a few years after Strauder v. West Virginia. The courts stated that they were not allowing African Americans to the Jury pool because they were not meeting the criteria of intelligence, moral integrity, and experience. The same issues arise for any Hispanic personal as well. Even though they technically fell under the same guidelines as the Struater v. West Virginia by violating the fourteenth amendment by not allowing them...

Words: 798 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Courtroom Psychology

...human beings judge others has been the subject of many psychological studies over the years. In this paper, psychology in the legal arena is discussed including jury selection, juror life experiences and how it affects their biases, and the impact of the media on their decisions. Jury Selection and Its Importance Juries have the all too important task of making life altering decisions dealing with money, freedom, and many times life or death situations. Therefore, serving on a jury is a very serious and important proposition. Unfortunately, in today’s society it appears that many times juries are selected in a rather casual manner. Many individuals called to jury service, especially those with a higher education or in a higher economic echelon, can find ways to escape their civic duty, while those who are less educated and theoretically less qualified for jury service, end up serving on the jury and making critical decisions. A fairly new trend in jury selection is that of trial consulting, which gained notoriety in the mid 1990’s in the O.J. Simpson trial. The application of scientific jury selection (SJS) was first applied in 1971, and has grown tremendously in recent years for those who have the means to employ such methods. The goal of the trial consultant is to find persons to fill the jury seats who optimally will arrive at a decision that will be favorable to their client. The tools used by the trial consultant include “…community surveys, focus...

Words: 2300 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Fiction vs. Reality

...events that actually unfold in courtrooms across the country. However, these programs are created for the purpose of entertainment, and while some of what they portray is true to real life, a great deal of it is overly glamorized, and much of what actually occurs inside the courtroom is not covered. Popular movies like Runaway Jury and A Few Good Men are examples of programming that depict courtroom activity in a more exciting and dramatic light. While some of the circumstances presented in these are parallel with reality, when compared to real life cases that can be viewed daily on TruTv’s In Session, it is clear to see that the majority of the content is intended for entertainment purposes and are designed to appeal to the public’s need for instant gratification: heart-pounding anticipation followed by a neatly wrapped up resolution, all in the span of less than two hours. Unfortunately, this is not the case in real life. Jury selections are often arduous (as I have recently seen through viewing the jury selection for the Casey Anthony case on In Session), trials can last for months upon months, and there is not always a happy ending. Runaway Jury, a popular 2003 film based on the book by John Grisham, is an excellent example of entertainment that showcases a great deal of truth in regards to the inner-workings of the courtroom, but also offers a good bit of exaggeration. In the movie, which is set in New Orleans, Louisiana, a disgruntled employee at a stock brokerage firm...

Words: 1426 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Business

...perspective of the effectiveness of the group. Be certain to use your knowledge of conflict management, group dynamics, and decision making theories. Here’s what I took from “Twelve Angry Men”. Instead of analytical narrative, I’ll try to encapsulate using bullets so this might be a little disjointed: * Even though I’m sure the lawyers had a jury selection criteria, this is still a randomly selected group. They are immediately at a disadvantage for being effective since complementary skills and backgrounds are not really part of the equation. They are not a balanced team (Bell & Smith, p. 22). * Being isolated in the juror’s box and (presumably) unable to discuss the case beforehand, they have not had the time to go through any of the stages of any of the models on group development (M12-21). * Each of the member’s needs is different and affects their motivation for being active participants in the sentencing process (M12-11). In particular, a couple of jurors just want to get done as quickly as possible (#3, #7, #10). * Because there was no time for role differentiation to happen before the sentencing process, the foreman was selected by virtue of being juror #1. He was not the best equipped to handle the task (M12-13). * Groupthink was initially in full force, until juror # 8 was able to persuade just one man to his way of thinking. Because no norms had really been arrived at juror # 8 made his appeals to the core human values that he presumed resided...

Words: 320 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Skilling vs Us

...(Slip Opinion) OCTOBER TERM, 2009 1 Syllabus NOTE: Where it is feasible, a syllabus (headnote) will be released, as is being done in connection with this case, at the time the opinion is issued. The syllabus constitutes no part of the opinion of the Court but has been prepared by the Reporter of Decisions for the convenience of the reader. See United States v. Detroit Timber & Lumber Co., 200 U. S. 321, 337. SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES Syllabus SKILLING v. UNITED STATES CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FIFTH CIRCUIT No. 08–1394. Argued March 1, 2010—Decided June 24, 2010 Founded in 1985, Enron Corporation grew from its headquarters in Houston, Texas, into the seventh highest-revenue-grossing company in America. Petitioner Jeffrey Skilling, a longtime Enron officer, was Enron’s chief executive officer from February until August 2001, when he resigned. Less than four months later, Enron crashed into bankruptcy, and its stock plummeted in value. After an investigation uncovered an elaborate conspiracy to prop up Enron’s stock prices by overstating the company’s financial well-being, the Government prosecuted dozens of Enron employees who participated in the scheme. In time, the Government worked its way up the chain of command, indicting Skilling and two other top Enron executives. These three defendants, the indictment charged, engaged in a scheme to deceive investors about Enron’s true financial performance by...

Words: 40397 - Pages: 162

Premium Essay

The Process of Selecting a Jury in the United States

...The process of selecting a jury in the United States accords attorneys with options of excluding able jurors. An option that challenges for cause where the attorneys ought to define the reason for a challenge. This could be in the form of bias or conflict of interest. In such a case, the opposing person is given the opportunity to respond and the judge decides on the juror’s exclusion. Another option is a peremptory challenge. This option gives the attorneys the power of excluding jurors with no explanation for it. Considering that challenges for cause are unrestricted, attorneys are barred on the number of peremptory challenges. The number may go as low as 4, though 10 is the most common in felony cases. Attorneys have in the past been known to exclude jurors of undesirable potential, though they have not been as effective. Most of the efforts applied in the past were with regard to lawyers’ folklore of who can be a good juror. For instance, a jury consultant assisted in the selection of the jury in the case of O.J. Simpson. Criminologist Jo-Ellan Dimitrius made use of surveys to form his defense juror demographic who were balck women. He then assessed and judged the potential jurors’ response as based on a questionnaire and response and read their body language. Considering the several criticisms that thrown at scientific jury selection, about it allows lawyers stack juries and destroys the influence brought about by money...

Words: 337 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Prejudice

... recently auditioned for a local theater production of Twelve Angry Men. As a jury researcher, how could I resist? Although I did not get a part, I still went to a performance, and I was struck by how powerful and instructive the play still is, more than 50 years after its premiere. TAM was originally written for television by Reginald Rose and broadcast live on September 20, 1954. Rose then rewrote it as a stage play in 1955, and Sidney Lumet turned it into a 1957 film starring a veritable who's who of leading men of the day: Henry Fonda, Lee J. Cobb, Jack Klugman, Jack Warden, Martin Balsam, E.G. Marshall, Ed Begley. This is the version that most people associate with the play. William Friedkin (who also directed The French Connection and The Exorcist--how's that for a curious portfolio) did a TV remake in 1997, with Jack Lemmon in the Henry Fonda role; Friedkin also had a couple of jurors be African American, which added a layer of complexity to the already present racial overtones. A Russian version, entitled 12, appeared in 2007 (Russia is one of several countries that has recently adopted or expanded its use of juries). That same year TAM was added to the National Film Registry by the Library of Congress. It has been popular since its premiere and is one of the things that many people think of when they think of juries. But in case you haven't seen it, here's the gist: The entire play takes place in the jury room, leaving the audience to piece together the facts of...

Words: 1096 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Employment-at-Will Doctrine

...Employment-At-Will Doctrine Introduction Employment-At-Will is a common legal doctrine that an employment contract of indefinite duration can be terminated by either the employer or the employee at any given time for any reason. In essence, an employer can discharge an employee for any reason which can be good, bad, or no reason at all. At the same time, the employee is equally free to cease work at any time without giving a reason to the employer. This doctrine of Employment-At-Will has been well established in the American legal system since the 19th Century, but nowadays employers find it confusing and with potential liability. This paper will provide different scenarios where employees’ behaviors trigger the Employment-At-Will ruling and how the newly hire Chief Operating Officer (COO) should address these scenarios following the company policies and the law to limit the company’s liability, as well as, the Whistleblower Policy. Scenarios Scenario 1 John posted a rant on his Facebook page in which he criticized the company’s most important customer. In my opinion, the COO has grounds to fire John because there are several clauses in the employee handbook that talk about the limitations on sharing information of the company and its customers on social media such as Facebook. Specially, if John has placed the name of the company in his profile. John can be terminated immediately due to his critics against the company’s most important customer because this could lead...

Words: 1695 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Jury Process

...The Jury Selection Process Taurean F Dawkins Strayer University Huntsville, AL February 10, 2013 Abstract “The Jury Selection Process” is a research paper that reviews the jury selection process in detail. First we will review the stages of the criminal trail and go in depth with the jury selection process. The paper will demonstrate why the jury selection process is necessary for the United States as well as its patrons. The paper will also provide a break down of advantages and disadvantages on the jury selection process. In addition to the information listed above, we will review some large profile court cases and its jury selection process. This will determine just how detailed and challenging the process can prove to be. The criminal trial process is a precaution that the United States Government has in place in order to protect the patrons of this country constitutional rights. By using the criminal trial process, they ensure that each civilian is offered a far and speedy trail. The criminal trail process has a number of different steps in order for it to flow seamlessly. The steps of the criminal trial process are as follows: trail initiation, jury selection, opening statements, presentation of evidence, closing arguments, judge’s charge to the jury, jury deliberations, and the verdict. Within this body we will be reviewing the jury selection process within detail. Within the Sixth Amendment of United States Constitution it points out that a citizen...

Words: 1142 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Jury Trial Analysis

...Jury Selection, Trials and Constitutional Rights The jury selection process is a significant portion of the trial process. Jury selection ensures that courts maintain proper Due Process and comply with constitutional guidelines. Furthermore, it gives lawyers the ability to evaluate the people in the jury and determine how they would feel about the case. The trial process branches out into six steps: jury selection, opening statements, presentation of evidence, closing arguments, charging of the jury and deliberation of jury. Throughout the process of jury selection, potential jury is based on a process names an voir dire; otherwise known as committing to telling the truth. During voir dire, potential jurors are included in the case or eliminated from the jury. Potential jurors are required to answer a series of questions concerning their personal bias regarding the case. The series of questions help determine if any of the potential jurors have had previous exposure to the context of the case, or a personal connection to the actual trial. If a lawyer can conclude based on the questioning, that the juror may be biased, they have the ability to challenge their position on the jury. Voir dire will be further examined in order to discuss how an unbiased jury is prepared for a trial. The following step once the jury is selected is the opening statements. The prosecution and the defense each have an opportunity to present their case to the jury. Although, no...

Words: 930 - Pages: 4