Free Essay

Just Like Us Review

In: Social Issues

Submitted By alecheininger
Words 1689
Pages 7
Alec Heininger
November 9, 2013
Sociology 001

* Helen Thorpe’s novel, Just Like Us, details the coming of age of four Mexican girls, of whom two are illegal immigrants, as they struggle to break free of the burden placed upon them by the prejudice of the American society. * C. Wright Mills defined the sociological imagination as "the vivid awareness of the relationship between experience and the wider society"(Mills, 1959). This important sociological principle is “the ability to see the impact of social forces on individuals; especially on their private lives” (Scheible, 2013). Thorpe establishes her aversion for illegal immigration not because of the effect it has on America but because of the hardships it forces the immigrants to suffer. The author witnessed the impact of social forces on Marisela as each of her friends was accepted into universities. Marisela had to feign her enthusiasm, knowing she would not qualify for the same opportunities because of her legal status (Thorpe, 2009, 45). Thorpe used the sociological imagination to understand the internal pressures of Marisela’s status. By imaging how the social burdens of Marisela’s status affected her, Thorpe saw how it impacted Marisela’s private life. In addition, when Yadira’s mother was arrested for using a fake Social Security card, Thorpe looked into how this affected Yadira, and realized that Yadira was not recognized as “[existing] in the eyes of officialdom” (Thorpe, 2009, 137). By applying C. Wright Mills’ definition of social imagination, Thorpe was able to visualize the internal conflicts caused by the social pressures on Yadira. * The rational choice theory has many applications to the decisions of Marisela in Just Like Us. Marisela used rational choice to determine that she should indeed invite her former boyfriend Fernando, a boy that her parents forbid her from seeing, to the prom (Thorpe, 2009, 11). She managed to hide all knowledge of her date to her parents, which minimized the cost of secretly inviting Fernando to the prom. By doing so, she ensured that the rewards would be greater than the risks. Marisela’s acting in self-interest and thus, risked her parent’s trust for her enjoyment. In addition to acting in accordance with the rational choice theory, Marisela followed the principles of functionalism. * Functionalism expresses that society functions as a whole and that each part of society has a function. Marisela, for instance, assumed the role of a caretaker of her family and a speaker for immigration reform at a protest. As Thorpe watched Marisela address a crowd of thousands of marchers, she noted that “(Marisela) did not stay long” after her speech because she was required to watch her unsupervised siblings (Thorpe, 2009, 246). She was assuming the role of a voice for her situation as well as helping her family with ensuring the children were under her care. She formed with the social stability of functionalism by allowing her family to provide jobs while she cared for her siblings. * In addition to contributing the main theories of functionalism to her lifestyle, Marisela acted in accordance with the conflict theory, because she, a member of society, was constrained by other members because of their power (Scheible, 2013). Thorpe noticed, “if a student from Palo Alto expressed a worldview antithetical to her own, as often as not Marisela would allow it to go unchallenged”(Thorpe, 2009, 182). This observation showed that the members of Marisela’s class who were from a wealthy town held the power in the class and Marisela, a member of society without the power, constrained her views in accordance with this inequality. This follows one of the assumptions of Functionalism where “a society rests on the constraint of some of its members by others’ power”(Scheible, 2013). * Throughout college, Marisela experiences role conflict as her responsibilities continued to grow as her free time decreased. She struggled to maintain the requirements of each role and responsibilities collided as a result (Scheible, 2013). “Marisela never had enough time for Ramiro, never had enough time for her parents, never had enough time for her classes” and as a result suffered from role conflict (Thorpe). She had many responsibilities and each required a time commitment that she was struggling to fulfill. While her family needed her help at home as a provider and caretaker, she also had to maintain her role as a college student by going to class. In addition to this conflict, Ramiro wanted her to spend time with him because that is what is expected of a girlfriend but it became difficult as Marisela began to spread herself so thin. * Reality manipulation is present throughout Just Like Us, as Thorpe tended to refer to illegal immigrants as “[lacking] legal status” or being “undocumented” (Thorpe, 2009, 23). This presented these individuals as not being the same as illegal immigrants or being in a less serious situation. Reality manipulation allows a negative thing to be viewed in a more positive light such as “passing away” instead of “dying.” The use of reality manipulation by Thorpe presented the girls in a situation unlike the murderer later in the novel. * Deviance plays a huge role throughout this novel, from the view of Marisela’s parents to the country’s view on illegal immigration. People view someone as deviant for attributes they hold or when they violate a social norm. Illegal immigrants are viewed as deviant and untrustworthy. Luke, a friend the girls made at college with conservative views, said that he “couldn’t trust (Clara)… (he) wouldn’t want to be friends with (her)” if she was illegal (Thorpe, 2009, 120). The association between illegal immigration and untrustworthy behavior is strong throughout this book. This labeling occurs as a result of illegal immigration. The girls were afraid of being labeled because of their lack of legal status and were “secret deviants.” This type of deviance is when an individual violates a social norm and society is unaware (Scheible, 2013). * The predictors of youth crime correspond almost identically to the murder of the police officer in the book. Gomez Garcia, the shooter, was a young illegal immigrant from a poor part of Mexico, the same as Marisela. He was also male and had lower levels of parental involvement given that his family turned him in and his grandmother was unaware that he was her kin (Thorpe, 2009,156). Gomez, compared to a chart of adolescent crime, was at the peak age for violence, especially murders (Scheible, 2013). In addition to these other attributes, he lived in a multi-family household with his friend, showing his low economic status. * The Dream Act is a bill that has been proposed to give illegal immigrants who entered the country as children and have graduated high school an opportunity to for a six-year conditional path to citizenship. The conditions are that the individual complete a college degree or two years of military service and have entered the country prior to the age of fifteen. This program would give thousands of youth the opportunity for a means of acquiring secondary education and citizenship (Scheible, 2013). This program would be great for immigrants who are currently forced to risk their residence in this country in order to attend higher-level education. For example, many financial aid applications require a Social Security number, a number that illegal immigrants do not have. Marisela encountered this when she went to fill out a financial aid form from the University of Denver. The application “[asked] for a Social Security number, or a passport number, and there [was] a box that [asked] whether you are a permanent resident or not”(Thorpe, 2009, 77). Cases like these coax many immigrants to lie about their legal status in order to be allowed to apply. In Marisela’s case, she remained honest while forfeiting an opportunity for aid. If the Dream Act would pass, they would be eligible for student loans and work study thus, giving students an opportunity for a higher education. * The Dream Act’s offering of deferred action allows for work during the time of deferred action. This would prevent situations similar to those that occurred when Yadira surprised Thorpe. Yadira said that she “just bought a fake Social Security card” from the black market and showed it to Thorpe (Thorpe, 2009, 161). In this situation, the Social Security number was taken from another individual or was not real and did not offer legitimate work access. By passing the Dream Act, legal work opportunities would become available. * In addition, offering conditional permanent residence to people under the Dream Act would reduce the need for coyotes to return to the country if they were deported. This would no longer occur, as they would not be deported unless they did not follow the conditions of the Act. Marisela’s suggested that if she were to be deported visiting her parents, she “[has] an uncle who is a coyote, so [she] could just come right back” (Thorpe, 2009, 128). This is dangerous and the thought that this is a reasonable means of returning is disconcerting. However, a passing of the Dream Act would eliminate this for eligible individuals. * The Dream Act would also stop the common feeling of being invisible and non-existent in the eyes of the legal system. Thorpe was “struck by the way that Yadira never seemed to exist in the eyes of officialdom”(Thorpe, 2009, 137). This feeling is not unique to Yadira, as many immigrants need to purchase black market Social Security cards and licenses in order to be recognized in a false manner. The Dream Act would allow for these individuals to be recognized by the government as a resident and exist in a legal manner as well. * Thorpe was able to give the reader many real-life examples of major principles in sociology. Her effective use of research gives a detailed view of the situation of illegal immigrants in America and helps to shed light on an otherwise unknown perspective of this controversial topic. * * * * * Refrences * Mills, C.W. (1959) The Sociological Imagination. New York: Oxford University Press
Scheuble, L. (2013). Introductory Sociology Lecture. University Park: The Pennsylvania State University.

Thorpe, H. (2009). Just Like Us. New York: Scribner

* * *

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Jfk and the Management Crisis

...of 31 10Likes * LinkBack * Thread Tools * Search Thread ------------------------------------------------- Top of Form Bottom of Form * Rate This Thread 1. ------------------------------------------------- pdch MemberPosts202 PostsGlobal Posts282 Global Posts | 03-08-2013, 01:24 PM   #1   Head-to-Head: Microsoft Surface Pro vs. Apple iPad 4 :facepalm. | Last edited by Dave Blake; 03-09-2013 at 07:37 PM. Reason: fix titleREPLY REPLY WITH QUOTE   THANKS LIKE * Share * * * * * | | 2. ------------------------------------------------- nottechsmart MemberPosts30 Posts | 03-08-2013, 02:41 PM#2   I don't understand the comparisons either. Every review you read mentions the ipad. When Apple comes out with a I-5 powered, Windows 8 ipad I'd love to compare, till then, don't care about it nor do I need it compared to every full Windows 8 tablet I look up. That was ALMOST a rant:D | REPLY REPLY WITH QUOTE   THANKS LIKE...

Words: 3215 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Critical Analysis

...A CRITICAL REVIEW OF AN ANOREXIA NERVOSA RESEARCH Institution: Name: Tutor: Date: TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION AND LITERATURE REVIEW 3 PURPOSE STATEMENT REVIEW 5 RESEARCH METHOD REVIEW 6 RESULTS ANALYSIS 7 DISCUSSION ANALYSIS 8 SUMMARY REVIEW 8 REFERENCE 10 INTRODUCTION AND LITERATURE REVIEW Factoring that AN is fast rising disease that cannot be treated by common medicine, there is a great need for further information on what it entails. According to the research, the project seeks to further understand what fosters the development of Anorexia Nervosa. This disease is a behavioral disease, meaning that it can be treated and stopped and the research is proving that significant steps can be made towards eradication or maybe just simply minimized. It is terribly sad that this is a disease suffered by women and it is proving very hard to deal with due to the exaltation of the human being physical and thus making people with little self esteem grow up knowing that. This research will prove instrumental as it seeks to create an alternative approach to the said disease. The literature review was not very thorough and comprehensive factoring the number books, references made in the entire book. Some may be of the opinion that a lot of literature material was used in the research, but the fact one uses the same types of book and material doesn’t make them to be thorough but rather biased (Halawi, 2005). The researchers and the literature review were thus biased as the books used...

Words: 1949 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

4.02 United States Government Honors

...Natasha Fullilove Mrs.Broughton United States Goverment 4.02 Judicial Review The Honorable Patti A. Christensen Today I will be interviewing Ms. Salaverez about her career of being a judge. Natasha: How is your role in government different from an elected official? Mrs.Patti: My role in the government can be different from those who are elected officials, I am there to overlook the case and see the evidence, I'm there to make sure that all facts that are stated are facts and that everything is fair. Judges exist to serve the people. Us Judges aren't elected on political party, the presidents appoints this person not people. Natasha : Okay, I can understand that. The president elects who becomes the judge because your main role is to focus on the people. So how are elected officials and judges the same? Ms.Patti, I would say elected officials and judges are the same because we all serve for the same purpose, for the people. At the end of the day we all just want equality in our community and to know that we did all we could do for the people. Natasha: And we as the people do appreciate that. Which brings me another question: Do you feel that judges are under appreciated? Mrs.Patti: I think we are appreciated, it's just I don't think the people of our country know how big of a role judges or political elected officials play in our country. But who's to blame? Things like that don't really concern people until election time and maybe not even then...

Words: 603 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Individualised Learning Plan

...given the opportunity to train and assess in the Diploma of Management within a WA-based RTO. Individualised Learning Plan: TAE40110 SAVE Training Introduction This document is used to plan a learning and assessment pathway that best suits you. The duedates and structure set out in this plan have been tailored to ft your current circumstances. We can review and change this plan at any time if for some reason it's not working out or there has been a major change in your situation. Please contact us if this is the case. Our aim is to help you get qualifed sooner than your maximum enrolment period, this will create a bufer of extra time in case you need it. If you feel you are not going to meet a deadline set out in this plan it is important to contact us so we can review it for you. Don't avoid us if you miss a deadline – it's not the end of the world and we'll help you get back on track. Just because we suggest you work through a certain section or complete a particular activity does not mean you can't explore elsewhere in the site! In addition, it is unlikely that you will get all the information you need just from the Learn section so make sure you get amongst the 'Web and do some research. Remember, we are here to help. We aim to be the most helpful, friendly, approachable trainers around and you...

Words: 1328 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

The Supreme Court and Judicial Review

...and Judicial Review Should the Supreme Court's power of judicial review be strictly limited by a constitutional amendment? Yes, the Supreme Court’s power of judicial review should be strictly limited to the constitution; because their judicial power is in all cases, in law and equity, arising under the constitution. Meaning they are over stepping their initial jurisdiction and have been given the power to have judicial reviews, even though it’s unconstitutional. The only power the Supreme Court is supposed to have is; all cases affecting ambassadors, or the public ministers and consuls, and those in which a state shall be party in the Supreme Court shall have original jurisdiction as stated in article III section 2 of the constitution. The Supreme Court is supposed to be the weakest of the three branches of government. The legislative, and executive branches are supposed to control the judiciary branch, even the states are supposed to have more say than the court. But they have been made more powerful and they are telling the legislative and executive branches what to do. There is no such system of checks and balances any more that protect the states and people when most government branches, are acting in cohorts with one another, eroding and destroying the rights and powers of the states and we the people. Even if the system was working right; who is watching and how will they stop the court from being unconstitutional? Every time the court holds judicial review it commits unconstitutional...

Words: 610 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Performance Review Evaluations

...An Evaluation of Performance Reviews How does a company fully understand the value of an employee? Today, most companies perform what are called performance reviews and this article shows us the effects that this business practice can have on its employees while showing us possible substitutes for this evaluation process. While this article does focus mainly on the employees, the article’s introduction shows the manager’s perspective while discussing the possible ramifications of no more performance reviews. The fear that most companies have when discussing ending performance reviews is the loss of an employee value measuring stick and that their managers will no longer feel the need to give necessary feedback to the employees. Not only will the company no longer know which employees are most important to them, but their quality of work will suffer due to necessary management not being performed. Despite these fears, this article encourages the pursuit of more beneficial and efficient business standards. The argument against the performance review process is split into three main points: managers cannot assess employees accurately, performance reviews demotivate more than they motivate, and that reviews do not improve a company’s performance. The first is a major flaw in the entire process because that is exactly the whole purpose of this procedure. A large problem facing the practice of performance reviews seems to be the enormous bias that comes with the interviewer, especially...

Words: 1192 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Holocaust Abd Film

...part really touched me because I know that when exhaust fumes are covered, they are trapped in the vehicle and you will die. So, he does this and gets in the ambulance and drives a bit by pressing the gas pedal. The next event, they toss these kids one by one on to the ambulance. Just like they weren’t even kids at all. Especially 2 or 3 of the kids, were violently thrown in. The next thing I saw was the man that was with the kids get in as well. It was silent because the director said that words just would not do it justice. People sometimes do end up getting lost in what is going on because they are listening to what is being said. There is no need to have them talking because it’s really self-explanatory and speaks by what is being shown. I learned that these kids were being taken and killed by the loads. It’s sad to think of these kids as alone and being murdered, but this one man that went with them, who didn’t have to, died with them. Very touching and it’s something new that I learned about and decisions that some of the people probably made on a regular basis during the Holocaust. The next film, Imaginary Witness basically just depicted the Holocaust through films. It tells us that compared to how the survivors of the Holocaust actually were. For instance, I learned that after the Holocaust, some of the survivors, became mute. Didn’t say anything...

Words: 2757 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

X Is X

...The Power of Virtual Integration: An Interview with Dell Computer’s Michael Dell by Joan Magretta Harvard Business Review Reprint 98208 The Power of V i r t ua l I n t e g r at i o n : A n I n t e rv i e w w i t h D e l l C o m p u t e r’ s Michael Dell b y J oa n M ag r e t ta H ow do you create a $12 billion company in just 1 3 years? Michael Dell began in 1984 with a simple business insight: he could by- pass the dealer channel through which personal computers were then being sold. Instead, he would sell directly to customers and build products to order. In one swoop, Dell eliminated the reseller’s markup and the costs and risks associated with carrying large inventories of finished goods. The formula became known as the direct business model, and it gave Dell Computer Corporation a substantial cost advantage. The direct model turned out to have other benefits that even Michael Dell couldn’t have anticipated when he founded his company. “You actually get to have a relationship with the customer,” he explains. “And that creates valuable information, which, in turn, allows us to leverage our relationships with both ARTWORK BY NATALIE ASCENCIOS Copyright © 1998 by the President and Fellows of Harvard College. All rights reserved. t h e p ow e r o f v i r t ua l i n t e g r at i o n : suppliers and customers. Couple that information with technology, and you have the infrastructure to revolutionize the fundamental business models ...

Words: 8558 - Pages: 35

Free Essay

Should the Supreme Court's Power of Judicial Review Be Strictly Limited by a Constitutional Amendment

...and Judicial Review Should the Supreme Court's power of judicial review be strictly limited by a constitutional amendment? Yes, the Supreme Court’s power of judicial review should be strictly limited to the constitution; because their judicial power is in all cases, in law and equity, arising under the constitution. Meaning they are over stepping their initial jurisdiction and have been given the power to have judicial reviews, even though it’s unconstitutional. The only power the Supreme Court is supposed to have is; all cases affecting ambassadors, or the public ministers and consuls, and those in which a state shall be party in the Supreme Court shall have original jurisdiction as stated in article III section 2 of the constitution. The Supreme Court is supposed to be the weakest of the three branches of government. The legislative, and executive branches are supposed to control the judiciary branch, even the states are supposed to have more say than the court. But they have been made more powerful and they are telling the legislative and executive branches what to do. There is no such system of checks and balances any more that protect the states and people when most government branches, are acting in cohorts with one another, eroding and destroying the rights and powers of the states and we the people. Even if the system was working right; who is watching and how will they stop the court from being unconstitutional? Every time the court holds judicial review it commits unconstitutional...

Words: 495 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

The Hidden Trap in Decision Making

...the mercy of your mind’s strange workings. Here’s how to catch thinking traps before they become judgment disasters. BEST OF HBR 1998 The Hidden Traps in Decision Making by John S. Hammond, Ralph L. Keeney, and Howard Raiffa COPYRIGHT © 2005 HARVARD BUSINESS SCHOOL PUBLISHING CORPORATION. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. Before deciding on a course of action, prudent managers evaluate the situation confronting them. Unfortunately, some managers are cautious to a fault—taking costly steps to defend against unlikely outcomes. Others are overconfident—underestimating the range of potential outcomes. And still others are highly impressionable—allowing memorable events in the past to dictate their view of what might be possible now. These are just three of the well-documented psychological traps that afflict most managers at some point, assert authors John S. Hammond, Ralph L. Keeney, and Howard Raiffa in their 1998 article. Still more pitfalls distort reasoning ability or cater to our own biases. Examples of the latter include the tendencies to stick with the status quo, to look for evidence confirming one’s preferences, and to throw good money after bad because it’s hard to admit making a mistake. Techniques exist to overcome each one of these problems. For instance, since the way a problem is posed can influence how you think about it, try to reframe the question in various ways and ask yourself how your thinking might change for each version. Even if we can’t eradicate the distortions...

Words: 6773 - Pages: 28

Free Essay

The Boss

...The Ganssle Group logo In any electrical circuit, appliances and wiring will burn out to protect fuses. - Robert Byrnes Seminars Newsletter Videos Tool & Book Reviews Special Reports Articles Random Rants Computer Humor Contact/Search Memo To My Boss The logo for The Embedded Muse For novel ideas about building embedded systems (both hardware and firmware), join the 25,000+ engineers who subscribe to The Embedded Muse, a free biweekly newsletter. The Muse has no hype, no vendor PR. It takes just a few seconds (just enter your email, which is shared with absolutely no one) to subscribe. By Jack Ganssle Published in Embedded Systems Programming, November, 2001 MEMO To: Bob Smith, CEO From: Jake Schmidt Attch: resig.doc Dear Bob, I wanted to respond to your memo of the 16th. Circulated as it was to seemingly half the company I feel we developers are now operating under an insurmountable stigma. Yes, we all know the product shipped late. Very late. You want to know why the schedule was missed so badly, and want an action plan to assure this problem will never reoccur. I was just one of many developers on the project. Others on the team will probably respond with apologetic platitudes. However, you'll note my resignation is attached so I feel no pressure to paper over the very real problems with politically-correct but worthless suggestions. Let me assure you, that, contrary to your strongly-stated opinion, we were not "spending half...

Words: 2456 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Case

...made—the alternatives were not clearly defined, the right information was not collected, the costs and benefits were not accurately weighed. But sometimes the fault lies not in the decision-making process but rather in the mind of the decision maker. The way the human brain works can sabotage our decisions. Researchers have been studying the way our minds function in making decisions for half a century. This research, in the laboratory and in the field, has revealed that we use unconscious routines to cope with the complexity inherent in most decisions. These routines, known as heuristics, serve us well in most situations. In judging distance, for example, our minds frequently rely on a heuristic that equates clarity with proximity. The clearer an object appears, the closer we judge it to be. The fuzzier it appears, the farther away we assume it must be. This simple mental shortcut helps us to make the continuous stream of distance judgments required to navigate the world....

Words: 6870 - Pages: 28

Premium Essay

Kayla Itines Research Paper

...Kayla Itsines Review For Those Thinking About Buying Her BBG. Hi everyone, I'm Jenny and today I want to give a little Kayla Itsines review for those who are thinking about buying her Bikini Body Guide. If you want the real truth about her guides then please do read on... Ohh, and this isn't going to be like all the other hyped up fluff like all of the other Kayla Itsines reviews out there so if you're wanting to read something like that, this isn't for you.. I think it's pretty safe to say that Kayla Itsines does in fact have a sexy body, but has she ever been over weight or been in a position where it is a lot harder to lose weight like most of us? I mean, by the looks of her bio she's been pretty fit all her life so I doubt she's ever...

Words: 1058 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Personal Narrative: Nobody's Perfect

...Nobody’s Perfect “Ally, why are you so upset about that AP Physics test? You always are a perfectionist and get the best grades, I questioned. We were talking near the lockers outside of the AP Physics classroom, where we were just about to enter. Ally was a nervous wreck, her hands were shaking and there were butterflies in her stomach. She didn’t answer, but rushed to her seat just as the bell rang for the start of class. The teacher announced that there would five minutes to review and ask any questions before the test. I decided to review with Ally, who was still shaking like a leaf and kept forgetting simple formulas. I hugged her and told her that she was the best student I knew, in the top 5% of the class and that I had faith she would do well. Then, I took her notes and helped her review over them. When it was time to begin taking the test, I gave Ally an encouraging smile and went back to my seat to take the test. The test was twenty-five questions and five of them were open-ended once asking about terminal velocity where we had to use formulas. Yet, the test was not as hard as I thought and I finished with ten minutes in class remaining. When the bell rang, hurriedly I gathered...

Words: 924 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Soledad's Sister

...[pic] A Review Project in Creative Writing IV Mariel Guerra Alog Batangas Province High School for Culture and Arts Ms. Babyruth Vicencio August 27,2010 I. Introduction This review explains the structure and features of a novel entitled as Soledad’s Sister which has been written by Jose Dalisay. It follows a format in order to present the work of literature clearly and logically. Jose Dalisay, known as Butch Dalisay is a Filipino columnist, poet, writer, teacher and playwright. He has authored more than 15 books since 1984.He teaches English and has some administrative duties as a director of the University of the Philippines Institute of Creative Writing. Soledad’s Sister was his second novel after Killing Time in A Warm Place with the help of a David T.K. Wong fellowship at the University of East and Anglia and a Rockefeller grant in Bellagio, Italy. Soledad’s Sister is the story of a Filipina woman who suffered abuses in foreign countries. It is about the reuniting task of two sisters (Aurora and Soledad Cabahug) and the grieving family which falls to SPO2 Walter G. Zamora, a Filipino cop in the novel,the absurdity of everyday life in the face of countless deaths as the consequence of resilience and other doomed choices people make and the story that deals on the physical world of a man and his personal encounters with man in general and himself. It tackles domestic issues, the current life of...

Words: 1592 - Pages: 7