Premium Essay

Kellogg's Failed Positioning in India

In: Business and Management

Submitted By anthathia
Words 997
Pages 4
Failed Research Leading to Failed Positioning – Kellogg’s Launch in India

Kellogg’s in the 90’s started facing immense pressure from competitors and their main markets of the U.S and Europe had become sluggish. It is during this time that they decided to launch in India.

Our “Marketing Management” textbook outlines the following six major forces to be researched at a macro level when considering the opportunities and threats, especially when venturing into a new territory: Demographic, economic, social-cultural, natural, technological and political-legal (Kotler, Keller, Koshy, Jha, 2009). If the above has been researched and evaluated carefully, you can then position your product well with the other 3’P’s: Place, Promotion and Price.

Yet, Kellogg’s with their over-confidence just gambled on the economics and here too they failed miserably.

While considering economics in 1994, they considered the overall population. Mr. Bhagirat B. Merchant, at that time director of the Bombay Stock Exchange, agreed on this when he stated, “Even if Kellogg’s has only a two percent market share, at 18 million consumers they will have a larger market than in the US itself” (Cashberry, 2006).

Yet, Kellogg’s forgot to take into consideration, before investing USD 65 million, was the “consumer class” was not more than 100 million and were dispersed geographically with very different cultures, customs, and tastes.

Over-confidence came from the fact that they were a huge company in the west and if they could market their products there, India would be “so easy”. Another point, in my opinion, was they felt that the Indians would rush out to buy an “American” brand.

And then the mistakes started:

When launching their product they priced in three times their nearest competitor. They thought that they had done the right thing when they noticed initial sales…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Failed Products

...was a result of the positioning taken by the marketing managers of the brand. As I look back at the previous campaigns for the Nano, it suddenly struck me that Nano was a consumer behavior assessment failure. The brand managers positioned the car as the next upgrade for a family of four with a two wheeler. But every such household had an aspiration to move to something better and not necessarily cheaper. Even if the consumer was in that income bracket, he aspired for something cooler. This point was not taken into consideration while the brand managers were coming up with the positioning. The next campaign focused on the tier 2 cities with bad roads and little or no inclination to move things along. This further hit the car sales. Finally now the Nano has been positioned as a cool car to have fun with. Also the colors and the powerful AC are being positioned as the differentiators along with the classic adage of better fuel efficiency that has helped its sales. I personally feel that positioning a product or service would be a strong spin off from consumer behavior and without understanding the hopes and aspirations of the masses a product is bound to not have the stickiness factor. TATA Nano was a classic case of a product manager who chooses not to respect the aspirations of his prospective consumers. A famous marketer once told me that “A man buys a car for what he wants to be and buys a house based on what he is”. In such a case the positioning was totally......

Words: 4790 - Pages: 20

Premium Essay

How Can Kellogg's Do Better in India

...How can Kellogg’s do better in India? What were the mistakes it made? ABOUT KELLOGS: Kellogg is $13.2 billion multinational food manufacturing company with its headquarters in Michigan, USA. It has manufacturing units in 18 countries and markets its products in over 180 countries. Brand Kellogg’s a global successful player serving packaged breakfast items across globe. Kellogg’s ventured in India in 1994. On its arrival, it created a new category of branded breakfast cereal products. Since then the journey for Kellogg’s has been far from easy, actually it has been so tough that it has found itself to be one of the biggest brand failures in India. In this article let us study what went wrong for the global brand, what mistakes it made and going forward what should be its strategy. Breakfast Cereal Industry: The Industry was pegged at Rs 150 crores way back in 1995 during early days of Kellogg’s. Today, this new category created by Kellogg’s is pegged at Rs 500 crores. Cornflakes account for 80% of the market, rest is shared by Oats, Muesli and Wheat Porridge. Kellogg has 70% market share i.e. 350 crores. The category has grown by only 8.4% per annum over the last 15 years. The figures are testimony to the fact that Kellogg's effort to change the breakfast habit of the Indian people, has not had as much success as it hoped for. Cornflakes for breakfast is somethings we as Indians are not used to and making us leave our idli’s, dosas and parantha’s for......

Words: 1800 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Marketing - Kelloggs India

...Introduction: U.S based Kellogg’s is a world leader and the most successful cereal manufacturer in the world. Kellogg’s entered India in 1994 and it took them a good 15 years for stability in the Indian markets facing initial problems and trying to change the Indian consumer’s mentality about the morning breakfast About the assignment: (Refer Appendix 1) Growth strategy by Kellogg’s in India: Kellogg’s were successful to create a need for the product which was never a necessity for an Indian household. We will now discuss how the company managed to establish themselves with a dominant market share in the Indian market. 1.) Ansoff Matrix Ansoff Matrix was introduced to address the corporate strategy of the future. It delivers the perspective of growth options on the horizontal level and introduces the possibility of diversification. (Kotler, Berger & Bickhoff, 2010) Market Development: Market Development is capturing new markets with your existing products or services. (Lester, 2009) In a new market or to a new consumer, it will be a quiet a task to have them to believe in your product on launching (Meldrum, M & McDonald, M., 2007) especially, when a country is so fond of their traditional recipes. With the help of extensive market research Kellogg’s found out that there was no breakfast cereal trend in the Indian market. Hence they launched their......

Words: 3792 - Pages: 16

Free Essay

The Failed Affirmative Action in India

...on affirmative action in India is long and not always geared to the desired aim: creation of equality of opportunity. Just like Indian secularism, reservation system in India has always a different political aim to make the system more unequal than what it is. Indian secularism, rather than making the state independent of religion, is intended to provide special privileges to certain religious groups. Similarly Indian affirmative system is politically designed to provide restricted rights not equal rights to some chosen people. The affirmative action in India has started perhaps by Vice-Roy Curzon in 1905 by banning the employment of Hindu Bengalis in the government services; the official argument was that they were too advanced and taking away job opportunity from others particularly the Muslims. Later it was extended in the military services by giving preferential treatments for Muslims and Sikhs branding them as martial races. Reservations in government jobs were introduced in 1918 in Mysore in favor of a number of castes and communities that had little share in the administration. In 1909 and in 1919 similar reservation system was introduced for the Muslims in British India. In 1935, for pure political reason the British government has provided job reservation for the backward castes. The real idea was to divide the population of India into several warring groups along religious, ethnic and caste lines by giving special rights so that future India would be divided and......

Words: 3241 - Pages: 13

Free Essay

Kellogg's Breakfast Mates

...COURSE  TITLE:  MARKETING  MANAGEMENT     COURSE  CODE:  GR  523–1DA         SUBMITTED  TO   DR.  RAJ  SISODIA,  PROFESSOR  OF  MARKETING   SUBMITTED  BY   KHALED  MAHMUD   MCCALLUM  GRADUATE  SCHOOL  OF  BUSINESS   BENTLEY  UNIVERSITY     MARCH  18,  2013     TABLE  OF  CONTENTS   1.  KELLOGG’S  AS  A  COMPANY:  ............................................................................................................  1   2.  BACKGROUND  OF  KELLOGG’S  BREAKFAST  MATES:  ......................................................................  1   3.  KELLOGG’S  BREAKFAST  MATES’  OFFERING:  .................................................................................  1   4.  TARGET  MARKET:  ...........................................................................................................................  1   5.  POSITIONING:  ...................................................................................................................................  1   6.  FAILURE  OF  BREAKFAST  MATES:  ...................................................................................................  1   7.  ANALYSIS  OF  THE  FAILURE  USING  FOUR  “A”  FRAMEWORK: ......

Words: 2366 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Nanao Failed, Why?

...genuine buyers who couldn’t purchase the car. Sale of the car was opened only in some selected states. Till date, it is there only in 12 States.  Not only that it is the spate of fires and the horrific view of a Nano ablaze which is mainly held responsible for scaring the customers away. After that Tata claimed that they have identified the real cause of the fire and have introduced some modification to sort out the problem. Some advertising experts say that Tata has been complacent after the large no. of bookings they got and didn’t implement the required advertising strategy to keep the Nano brand pumped up. But soon after the problem of fires and falling sales, advertisement started. I have tried to sum up the important reasons why Nano failed:- Poor Customer mapping – Tata should have focused on its potential customers. Tata was focusing on totally new segment of customers who were never interested in buying a car. The new segment of customers, in which the only player was Nano, will take time to develop. Potential Nano customers wants to buy the car but don’t buy it because they don’t know how to drive, so Tata should have worked on this problem faced by its potential consumers as Maruti has tackled this issue very well by providing support through Maruti-driving schools to its first-time driving customers. Others problems were that many Nano customers were not credit worthy and so they do not get the loan to buy Nano. No Pride of ownership – from the......

Words: 2071 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Kellogg's in India

...            Report on the case: “Kellogg’s – Moving Beyond  Breakfast”      1.  Kellogg’s encountered tremendous problems when faced with the Indian  breakfast  market  and  cultural  habits.  Kellogg’s  offered  an  upscale  product  that  provided  a  light,  healthy  breakfast  at  a  relatively  high  price  for  the  traditional  Indian  market.  There  are  three  main  obstacles  that  I  believe  should  make  Kellogg’s move to a segment different from the breakfast one:    • Cultural  aspect  –  Indian  breakfast  consumers  are  used  to  a  substantial  amount of cooked food on their table in the morning. They are used to a  wide variety of cooked, spicy food that is consumed warm and gives them  a sense of fullness before they start their day. This does not fit the value  proposition  and  the  positioning  of  Kellogg’s  breakfast  cereals  in  the  Indian  market.  Since  these  habits  are  inherited  from  many  generations,  they  naturally  are  very  complicated  to  break,  even  for  a  firm  as  big  as  Kellogg’s.  Therefore,  the  only  option  available  for  Kellogg’s  in  order  to  satisfy  the  Indian  cultural  demands  would  be  to  change  its  products  completely, which seems a bit farfetched and would go against the history  and the values of the company.    • Price  –  The  price  of  Kellogg’s  breakfast  cereals,  comparing  to  the  prices  obtainable  by  Indian  consumers  of  traditional  Indian  breakfasts  is  another ......

Words: 565 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay


...Identifiable special causes No Yes Improvable? No Yes Remove variation Improve process design Control Figure 4.4 The flow of activities in improvement phase [47]. 4.2.5 Control There are also two activities in control phase. After improvement phase has been carried out, the planned improvements shall be verified. Improper or incorrect improvements will be discovered and corrected in the next improvement project. Control Chart and DPMO Track Chart are highly recommended to verify the long-term effects of improvements. Another important activity in this phase is to formalize the results. The results which only match a single process or product will be reorganized and reanalyzed to match the whole company. Both successful and failed cases shall be formalized, reported and stored. The companies should gain experience from those cases for further improvements. Based on that, 29 a guideline shall be established. And that will be very helpful for the future Six Sigma projects. Every company shall create their own Six Sigma project guideline [47, 61, 66]. 4.3 Ten Tips from ABB ABB is a Swiss-Swedish technology company which has 160,000 employees in more than 100 countries. Its products and services cover five fields – Power Transmission and Distribution; Automation; Oil, Gas and Petrochemicals; Building Technologies; and Financial Services. To have an additional cost reduction and cycle time reduction, ABB starts to apply Six Sigma from 1993......

Words: 32055 - Pages: 129

Premium Essay


...Structured positioning and unstructured positioning is different and both are important. And both can be applied by same brand In unstructured, brand is positioned to prospect’s mind through telling a story with metaphors by analyzing the situation and purpose of consuming a brand, habits of consumers, competitors brand image, consumer’s character and timing of consumption etc .Here storytelling as an art plays an important role because it’s shape the perception of consumers for particular brand or product. So just take the data and fact by research and put in your mind and imagine (the way you want to show yourself or your product or brand on consumer’s mind) Like GET MILK campaign of American dairy group, Apple’s ad for IBM. But it is already constitutes in structure positioning under emotional branding where mystery, sensuality and intimacy are like daewik,dehik and bhautik of TRISHUL. Structured positioning starts with the target certain types of consumer, leads to define the competitive frame of reference (CFR).In CFR, not only present competition arena but also coming competition can be smelled by analyzing both Industry (no. of sellers, degree of product differentiation, entry barrier, cost structure etc) and market competition (relative substitutes) such as coca-cola ignored the coffee bars business. In CFR, category membership is important because “YOU SEE WHAT TO EXPECT TO SEE” pour a gallo in 50 year old French burgundy then carefully decant a glass in front of a...

Words: 442 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Evoe Positioning

...* * * * * * EVOE SPRING SPA: A POSITIONING DILEMMA University of Maryland, College Park Cisco Systems: Launching the ASR 1000 Series Router using Social Media Marketing Section: ENTS 632 - 0201 "I pledge on my honor that I have not given or received any unauthorized assistance 21 April 2015 * I. STATEMENT OF POSITIONING PROBLEM FACED BY EVOE This case is set in August 2010, in Mumbai. The co-founders of Evoe Spring Spa have to choose a positioning strategy for their new business that will resonate with target customers. Their 3 alternatives are: 1)“Affordable Indulgence” 2)“Affordable Health” & 3)“A Little Vacation” II. SUMMARY OF SWOT Strengths: The Company did thorough research into consumer segments using tools like four-stage sequential process & even personally observed FGD’s to figure out customer’s social & cultural needs. The company understood the importance of qualitative research for positioning decisions. Raman, one of the founders has prior marketing experience. The Evoe founders relate to the customers as their need for affordable relaxation led to the idea of Evoe. Weaknesses: Evoe doesn’t have a physical presence; it is still an idea. This could be a disadvantage when looking for investors. It is a new entrant in a market where brand loyalty is high. The survey conducted by Evoe didn’t take into consideration people under 25 & above 55 years. The founders have no experience in the......

Words: 609 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Marketing Positioning

...Guidelines for Assessment 3: Assignment: Creating, Communicating and Delivering Value Background Reading: You must read Chapter 9: Market Segmentation, Targeting and Positioning to understand the process of STP, before you attempt the assignment. Students relying on slides will find themselves confused. Spend time reading the chapter and ask your lecturer questions during consultation hours if you are not clear about any concept. Please do not email to understand theory. Choosing the watch/fast food restaurant: This is the most critical step of your assignment. Your product/service must have a clear differentiating competitive advantage. If your watch is ordinary and does not have a feature that makes it unique, you will find your assignment “bland” and so will your tutor, same applies for fast food restaurant. Conduct extensive research by visiting watch outlets, malls, restaurants, or visiting their websites and carefully select your watch or restaurant. Evidence: In this assignment, we want you to give evidence to almost every claim you make. For example, if you say Kellogg’s Special K is targeting female consumers who have an active lifestyle, then you should look for an advertisement that shows a girl in activity consuming Kellogg’s Special K. Similarly, if you claim Dominos differentiates itself in terms of “Services” then you must find an advertisement that shows Dominos claiming to be Pizza Delivery Expert with 30 minutes delivery promise to support......

Words: 1055 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Market Research Limitations at Kellogg's

...By Jack Semple Market Limitations at Kellogg’s (M2) In this assignment I will be discussing the marketing research techniques used by Kellogg’s and I will also be outlining the limitations that affect Kellogg’s. There are many types of marketing research that Kellogg’s use internally and externally from the business. Primary market research One method of market research Kellogg’s use is primary research, they use this kind of research to gather information on customers and on competitors in the business environment. Another name for this kind of research is ``field research``. This kind of research consists in Kellogg’s carrying out surveys, experiments and observation. Market limitation: Is information that can be inaccurate and misleading and is non specific to Kellogg`s. Experiments A company like Kellogg’s experiment’s with a particular approach in certain areas or for a certain time. For example, Kellogg’s have created their special edition ``Kellogg’s queen flakes``, they created this cereal to celebrate the queen becoming Britain’s longest serving monarch. This example is to experiment in seeing how many of these boxes they can sale and to find out how popular they can be. Limitations of experiments Although this method may be an effective one it also comes with a few limitations. This product is only available at Manchester’s black milk cereal drive and costs six pounds thirty. If they were to of......

Words: 2283 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Failed States

...Failed states propose a great threat to global communities today. The notion of this threat comes from international terrorists, drug barons or weapons or arsenals (Anonymous, 2005) harbouring in failed states, which can bring harm to neighbouring or powerful countries. Somalia appears to be the very definition of what we call a failed state. The last time this desert country possessed anything approaching a “normal” government, with tax collection, social services and law enforcement was a under a bloody dictator named Siad Barre (Cockburn.2002). Now Somalia proposes the risk of consequences to the global community. Like Somalia, Pakistan is one of the failed states that are proving to have major consequences that we are seeing today. Terrorist Groups such as Taliban, Al Qaeda and Lashkar-e-Taiba have established themselves as a state within a state (Boot 2008). These terrorist groups can now make major attacks, which killed more than 170 people in Mumbai alone (Boot 2008). This has become a subject of concern for that western countries have being debating over. The difficulties of trying to bring justice to these failed states is because of the odds of success are low and the risk of unintended consequences is very high (Zakaric, 2010). Since there is an awareness of being passive to these countries to avoid unintended fallouts, rather than taking action to implicate a justified government, there will be an ever-lasting threat to the global communities. Somalia is a failed...

Words: 1395 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Brand Positioning

...Introduction: In their 1981 book, Positioning: The Battle for your Mind, Al Ries and Jack Trout describe how positioning is used as a communication tool to reach target customers in a crowded marketplace. Regular use of the term dates back to 1972 when the same authors published a series of articles in Advertising Age called "The Positioning Era." Not long thereafter, Madison Avenue advertising executives began to develop positioning slogans for their clients and positioning became a key aspect of marketing communications. Positioning: The Battle for your Mind has become a classic in the field of marketing. The following is a summary of the key points made by Ries and Trout in their book What is Positioning? Positioning is a platform for the brand it facilitates the brand to get through to the target consumers. Positioning is act of fixing the locus of the product offer in the minds of the target consumers. In positioning, the firm decides how and around what parameters, the product offer has to be placed before the target consumers. The significance of product positioning can be easily understood from David Ogilvy’s words; the results of your campaign depends less on how we write your advertising than on how your product is positioned. Most authors define positioning as the perception that a target market has of a brand relative to its competitors. This definition raises two points. First, positioning is perceptual. In other words, positioning is not......

Words: 12367 - Pages: 50

Premium Essay


...This article was downloaded by: [] On: 18 June 2012, At: 04:49 Publisher: Routledge Informa Ltd Registered in England and Wales Registered Number: 1072954 Registered office: Mortimer House, 37-41 Mortimer Street, London W1T 3JH, UK Journal of Strategic Marketing Publication details, including instructions for authors and subscription information: Competitive positioning and the resource-based view of the firm a a Graham Hooley , Amanda Broderick & Kristian Möller a b Aston Business School, Aston University, Birmingham, B4 7ET, UK b Department of Marketing, Helsinki School of Economics, Runeberginkatu 14–16, Helsinki, FIN-00100, Finland Available online: 28 Jul 2006 To cite this article: Graham Hooley, Amanda Broderick & Kristian Möller (1998): Competitive positioning and the resourcebased view of the firm, Journal of Strategic Marketing, 6:2, 97-116 To link to this article: PLEASE SCROLL DOWN FOR ARTICLE Full terms and conditions of use: This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes. Any substantial or systematic reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan, sub-licensing, systematic supply, or distribution in any form to anyone is expressly forbidden. The publisher does not give any warranty express or implied or make any representation that the......

Words: 10177 - Pages: 41