Free Essay

Labour Law in China

In: Business and Management

Submitted By omatai
Words 733
Pages 3
In China there exist labor laws which, if fully enforced, would greatly alleviate common abuses such as not paying workers. In 2006, a new labor law was proposed and submitted for public comment. Enacted in 2008, the Labor Contract Law of the People's Republic of China permits collective bargaining in a form analogous to that standard in Western economies, although the only legal unions would continue to be those affiliated with the All-China Federation of Trade Unions, the Communist Party’s official union organization. The new law has support from labor activists, but was opposed by some foreign corporations, including the American Chamber of Commerce and the European Chamber of Commerce. There is some expectation that the law would be enforced.[4][5][6] In 2010 a substantial increase in labor related cases brought to court in 2008 was reported.[7] There has been many questions as to "Does the Labor Contract Law Cover Foreigners". There has recently been a case in Jinhua China (2011–2012), where a foreigner went through Labor Arbitration, Court and Court of Appeal. The case centered around Article 14 part 3 of the Labor Contract Law. During all the proceeding the Chinese argued that LAW did NOT apply to foreigners. The foreigner easily proved his case yet lost in all 3 venues. Both written court decisions cited that the foreigner did not meet the rule of Art 14 part 2 (which was NEVER argued by anyone in court(s)) and therefore the courts ruled against the foreigner. It is possible that this is an incident of some kind of court corruption but as of now this ruling and the far reaching international legal precedents that it sets remain in effect.

Reading from Documents of this case. Translation of the Arbitration Decision....

"This court thinks this case is a contract dispute about a foreigner who wants to obtain employment in china, the focus is about how to use Chinese law. The applicant thinks he has a working VISA and ‘foreign expert certificate’, that is his legal evidence to work in china, his working relationship with the respondent should apply to article 14.2’s rules of ‘the labor contract law of PRC.’ The respondent should sign an open-ended labor contract with him. This court thinks, ‘ the labor contract law of PRC.’ is a law that set to sign a labor contract, ‘the foreign experts employing contract management rules’ is a rule to the foreign expert who is working in China, these two law are all legal basis for foreign who works in china, and the latter was enacted after the former, it is clear, our country adopt specific rule different from its own citizens on the management issues with foreign experts, this case adopt ‘the foreign experts employing contract management rules’. This rule set: signing a foreign expert employment contract, should follow the principles of legal, fair, equality freewill, consensus and good faith. The article 4 of the rule set: the contract will automatically expired after the contract is finished. So, this court think, in this case the contract had already expired on 30th June 2011 which sign by both parties, and the respondent is not willing to resign again, this contract shall be terminated. The applicant ask for an open-ended contract with the respondent lack legal basis, this court will not support."

This decision shows a clear infringement on the rights of foreigners. It also makes use of a "rule" which is not issued by the State Council as "reason" to take away the rights of foreigners to the LCL. It is very clear in this decision that the worker is “legal” and has all the correct papers for employment at the time in question. A very critical issue is that it gives “right “ to the employer to decide not to enter into an open-ended contract even though the law is clearly written to allow the employee to be granted an open-ended contract if any of the conditions are met in Art 14 parts 1 -3 . If this way around the law stands it can now be used against both Foreigner and Chinese workers. Basically it is as if the courts in small town Jinhua China have in a single stroke nullified the Labor Contract Law that took over 10 years to create in a single stroke and have done this without direction from Beijing

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Management People in China

...Introduction: China as a developing country, she changes a lot especially in the recent years. China had changed planning economic into market economy. After the reform of China policy, China’s gross domestic product growth rapidly. These kinds of situation bring about good opportunities for foreign investment to invest in China. Howton Ltd, is interested to take over a Chinese telecommunication company, New wonders in Shanghai, and Howton Ltd was interested in increasing its market share. Before the take over, to understand the local situation and Human Resource situation in China is very important. In term of the requirement of the Chief Executive Officer of Howton Ltd, Mr. Richard Wilson, we reported some researches and give some recommendations to Mr. Richard Wilson. The purpose of study of this report were as followings: To provide necessary information for Howton Ltd take over the local telecommunication company. Analysis the Chinese local situation for the Human Resource Department, help them to know the opportunities and threat in China. Recommend some suggestion for Howton Ltd to cope with the local situation in China, also give some recommendation for reform New Wonders’s Human Resource System. The scope of our research included all the east city of China; the emphasis of our research is Shanghai. During in the research we use interview, research on the ground, questionnaire, also get some professional report from the......

Words: 3009 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Doing Business in China: the Human Rights Challenge

...DOING BUSINESS IN CHINA: The Human Rights Challenge CONTENTS I. INTRODUCTION China: World Economic and Manufacturing Centre Why Are Human Rights so Important for International Business? Chinese Legislation: Gap Between Theory and Practice p. 3 p. 4 p. 6 II. SPECIFIC ISSUES AND RECOMMENDATIONS 1. Freedom of Association, the Right to Form and Join Trade Unions, and Collective Bargaining 2. Working Conditions 3. Discrimination 4. Forced Labour 5. Forced Evictions 6. The Rights of Children 7. The Right to Freedom of Expression and Information p. 8 p. 12 p. 16 p. 20 p. 23 p. 26 p. 29 p. 32 p. 33 p. 34 p. 37 III. GENERAL RECOMMENDATIONS TO COMPANIES IV. CONCLUSION V. LEGAL STANDARDS AND SOURCES VI. CONTACT ADDRESSES 2 I. INTRODUCTION China: World Economic and Manufacturing Centre Over the years China has become one of the largest economies in the world and the manufacturing centre of the world. Since the seventies, China has sought joint venture partners and encouraged technology transfer through foreign investment. Chinese firms are successfully manufacturing products on behalf of numerous foreign companies. The Chinese government provides massive contracts to foreign firms in order to build up the infrastructure required for its industrialization. Many companies establish distribution networks in China in order to benefit from the large home-market and increasing purchasing power of Chinese consumers. Last but not least, in 2008 China organized the......

Words: 12077 - Pages: 49

Premium Essay

Swiss and China Pdf

...Federal Department of Economic Affairs, Education and Research EAER State Secretariat for Economic Affairs SECO Foreign Economic Affairs Directorate Factsheet Free Trade Agreement (FTA) between Switzerland and China Summary A comprehensive bilateral FTA between Switzerland and the People's Republic of China was signed by Federal Councillor Johann Schneider-Ammann and Minister of Commerce GAO Hucheng on 6 July 2013. Following initial exploratory contacts in November 2007, joint workshops in 2009 and a joint feasibility study in 2010, the negotiations were officially opened in January 2011. The agreement was then negotiated in nine rounds of negotiations and various intersessional meetings from April 2011 to May 2013. The FTA will improve mutual market access for goods and services, enhance legal security for the protection of intellectual property and bilateral economic exchange in general, contribute to sustainable development and deepen bilateral cooperation. For the vast majority of bilateral trade, the FTA will dismantle tariffs fully or partially, sometimes subject to transition periods. In the area of technical barriers to trade and sanitary and phytosanitary measures, sector-specific cooperation agreements are aimed at reducing non-tariff barriers to trade. For trade in services, more precisely defined rules compared to the GATS of the WTO will apply, e.g. for approval processes, as well as improved market access commitments for various services. Regarding......

Words: 4305 - Pages: 18

Free Essay

Expectations of Foreign Investors in Terms of Labor Laws

...Project Report on Expectations of Foreign Investors in terms of Labor Laws India, like other countries worldwide, is experiencing the effects of globalization. In order to make conditions friendlier for investors, there is a need for adaptability. Labor legislation, such as the Indian Disputes Act and Contract Labor (Regulation and Abolition) Act, are now under debate, along with issues concerning special economic zones. Submitted by: Introduction There has been a steady expansion of foreign investment in recent decades. The upward trend is particularly strong for less developed countries, signifying the increased importance for these countries of FDI, as well as the increased presence of multinational firms. Alongside the expansion of FDI have risen concerns regarding competition between countries or regions to attract FDI. After adopting new economic policy by government of India in July 1991 many foreign investors came in the Indian economic scene because the government of India gave many incentives to the foreign investors. So it is clear that government opened the doors of Indian market to foreign investors. With more companies operating internationally, the impact on various business functions and labour laws in India is becoming more pronounced. Globalization, and the need......

Words: 4053 - Pages: 17

Free Essay

Foxconn Technology Group - the Suicides Incidents

...electronic products manufacturing such as Card Readers Graphics Cards, LCD Monitors, and Power Supplies. They have become one of the largest electronic contract manufacturers working with many technology companies around the world. Even though Foxconn is one of the largest manufacturers, they are not really well-known as its size. However, in the recent years, the name of company became more aware of due to their issues on labour practices. This aspect of the company will be explored for this analysis. 2.0 The company’s background Foxcoon was established in 1974, also known as Hon Hai by Terry Geo as a manufacturer to produce plastic parts for television sets. As they started to grow larger, they have started to produce console Joystick controller through receiving orders from Atari. In 1985, Hon Hai established United States offices and successfully branded “FOXCONN”. At the same year, Foxconn entered the top 1000 companies of Taiwan. (Foxconn, 2014) In 1988, Terry Gou made a significant decision, which was to establish first factory in Shanghai China. This strategy proved to be so successful that Foxconn began to grow its business at an unbelievable speed. By 2001, Foxconn became the biggest company in Taiwan. Foxconn continues to grow as they began to expand to telecommunication market and look to use more robots in their manufacturing in 2014. Since the founding of the company, they have expanded scope on electronic business. The Foxconn has recognized to become......

Words: 2563 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

China and Ethics

...1. Comment on three unethical practices that china has been accused, do you think that these practices were necessary for china’s economic survival? China has been accused of various unethical practices in a host of industries. Overall, Chinese business ethics are built on the basis of "guanxi," a fundamental principle and practice underlying the whole of the Chinese social fabric. Guanxi places relationships and the moral obligations flowing from those relationships above other considerations, including written law. It not only is accepted in China, it is regarded as a moral obligation that people who have known each other for an extended period of time and have collaborated and helped each other are obligated to continue this relationship. Guanxi defines both how business is done in China at all levels and how the Chinese view ethics. Corruption and Bribery – In Transparency International’s (TI) Corruption Perception Index 2011, China is ranked 75th out of 185 countries. This has been a consistent score since 2008. The TI Global Corruption Barometer 2010/2011 found that 46% of the 1,000 Chinese respondents felt that the level of corruption in the Country had increased and just over a third considered the Government’s actions ineffective in combating corruption. When respondents were asked “To what extent do you perceive the following institutions in this country to be affected by corruption?”, business was seen as the most corrupt institution, closely followed by......

Words: 1098 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Political Regime

...Essay Topic: Briefly compare the political regime type in China and India. Which of the two would you prefer to do business in and why? (You may specify the type of business.) The Politic regime of a country is imposed to safeguard the interests of that country. However it can have the effect of limiting a country’s growth and development and can cause complications when attempting to do business within a country. China and India are two fast growing and very large countries with clear distinction in social and economic models as well as two very different politic regimes with their own unique characteristics. This essay will include a contrast look into the different political regimes in both China and India and the opportunities and threats of conducting business within these countries. The essay will focus on the different government regulations and control within the two nations as well as tax policy’s, intellectual property rights, and land and labour cost, concluding with which businesses would prefer potential foreign investment in each of these two nations. Political regimes as defined by (Kitschelt, 1992) are “the rules and basic political resource allocations according to which actors exercise authority by imposing and enforcing collective decisions on a bounded constituency”. The People’s Republic of China (PRC) formally a communist regime with Marxist ideologies until the economic reform in 1978 which lead them to a more modern socialism regime. The PRC......

Words: 1861 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

India V China

...stories has been the rise of India and China, two of Jim O’Neill’s “BRIC” countries (FT Magazine, 2010). Despite the implementation of different economic policies (Gupta, 2008) both countries have emerged as major economic forces in the global economy (Bosworth and Collins, 2007), most notably since 1980. Since then, India and China have experienced a significant reduction in poverty with China lifting 500 million out of social deprivation. According to the World Bank (2013), China has had an average GDP of 10% each year while India has seen her GDP double over a similar period. The countries are often compared due to their large population and geographical vastness as well as climbing from third world countries to major economic forces in a relatively short time. However, despite a significant increase in GDP, India has failed to demonstrate the same rates of growth as China. Although both countries were in a similar position during the early nineties, China’s GDP has increased 7 fold since this time; whereas India, although steady, GDP has doubled. The average annual rate is by 10% in China compared to 5-6% in India (see Figure 1). The purpose of this paper is to compare the rates of growth of India and China over the past 30 years and examine possible explanations for this phenomenon. The economies of these countries are underpinned by social, economic and political issues which have all been relevant to their growth. China has placed emphasis on investment......

Words: 2772 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Pestle Analysis that a French group of retail sector called Carrefour needs to use to expand his business in China before other foreign competitors expand in China. Carrefour is a French group of the retail sector founded in 1959 by Defforey Fournier. Currently, Carrefour is the second largest group in this sector in terms of revenue behind Wal-Mart and it is number 1 in Europe, South America (Chester, 2012) Carrefour is also present in Asia with around 371 hypermarkets and with 64 hypermarkets in other areas of the world in the form of local partnership and its aim is “to become the preferred retailer that is supportive throughout the world” in all of its formats (Carrefour Foundation Annual Report, 2010) China is an Asian country, with two states currently claim to have sovereignty: the People's Republic of China, which controls 99.6% of its territory and the Republic of China, which only controls Taiwan. It’s only in 2008, that the two governments united, have agreed for a more cooperative atmosphere (BBC Monitoring, 2014) Currently, China is the most populated country in the world with around a population of 1.33 billion. China has 20 cities with more than 5 million of people and 100 cities with over 1 million people. In the period of 2011 and 2015 China’s annual average GDP growth is predicted to be 9.5%. China is the largest growing GDP per capita in the world (Rodgers, 2012) China is a country with the world’s largest exports and the second largest imports of goods,......

Words: 1475 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Comparism of Hr Practices in China and Pakistan

...COMPARISM OF HR POLICIES AND PRACTICES IN CHINA AND PAKISTAN INTRODUCTION  The introduction of globalization has brought an awareness of the differences in partaking in business activities from one country to the other and from region to region. This is because policies and structures that guide the successful conduct of business activities vary.  Human Resource is the most important asset for any organization as it is the source of achieving competitive advantage as well as the development of organisational strategy. In order to succeed, organisations must ensure that they have an effective HRM system in order to achieve organisational objectives. CHINA  Name: Peoples Republic of China  Population: 1.35 billion  Capital: Beijing  Largest City: shanghai  Area: 9.6 million sq km (3.7 million sq miles) PAKISTAN  Name: Islamic Republic of Pakistan  Population: 176.7 million (UN, 2011)  Capital: Islamabad  Largest City: Karachi  Area: 796,095 sq km (307,374 sq  Major languages: Mandarin Chinese  Major religions: Buddhism, Christianity, miles), excluding Pakistaniadministered Kashmir (83,716 sq km/32,323 sq miles)  Major languages: English, Urdu, Punjabi, Sindhi, Pashto, Balochi Islam, Taoism  Life expectancy: 72 years (men), 76 years (women) (UN)  Monetary unit: 1 Renminbi (yuan) (Y) =  Major religion: Islam 10 jiao = 100 fen;  Life expectancy: 65 years (men), 67 years (women) (UN) CHINA  Main exports: Manufactured......

Words: 1221 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Human Resources Management in Business

...Human Resources Management in Business Today, I will describe the internal and external factors to consider when planning the human resource requirements of Tesco. Tesco is one of the major retailers in the world. They function in 14 different countries around the world. Some of them are UK, Slovakia, China, India or Hungary. Only in UK Tesco employs 300,000 people in over 2,900 stores. Tesco sells different ranges of product; groceries, clothes, furniture, technical equipment and many more. Whoever wants to shop at Tesco doesn’t have to even leave the house to do it. They offer online shopping option so customers can buy their everyday shopping and get it delivered usually the same day. Tesco’s main aims and objectives is to maximise the sales and profits and maintain they place in the market. They want to offer the best possible, deals and prices for their customers and meet their needs in order to stay the leading supermarket in UK. Human Resources Management Human Resources Management is the management of the organisation’s workforce. Its main role is to attract, select, recruit and train employees. Its main aim is to make sure that the organisation get the right people to work which can enable every firm to make profit and become successful. Human Resource Planning Human Resources planning is a process of looking at the current workforce and planning what is going to be needed in the future. The process helps to identify future gaps in workforce and......

Words: 1786 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Fdi in America and China

...advantages and disadvantages of the countries should be considered. For example, China is a developing country, and during the past 30 years, China’s rapid economic development shows that China has a strong power in developing economic. In recent decades, China stays on one of the leading positions in direct investment and therefore a lot of investments to this country are considered to be profitable for any company or investor. The reasons are simple: the growth of the economy and a large number of different projects. Foreign direct investment in China, due to stable growth potential of the economy and a huge production resources, aimed at both the external and the internal market.The innovative ability is a great attraction for investment managers around the world. In contrast, a lot of foreign investors had chosen China for investment and this resulted in a very big competition. Nevertheless, USA is a successfully developed country. And its economy is the top one in the world. As the most important country in the first world countries, the USA has many good experiences in global business. The most strong enterprises were set in the USA and it means that the competition in the USA is very huge. This competition affects many areas, not only the market place but also the labour market and the use of resources. All of these causes higher costs and reduces the profits.Also, American “antitrust law” regulates that a company with market...

Words: 5010 - Pages: 21

Premium Essay

Cola Cola

...BPMN 3123 MANAGEMENT ETHICS SECOND SEMESTER 2014/2015 TITLE UNETHICAL COMPANY-COCA COLA (HUMAN RESOURCES ISSUES IN CHINA) PREPARED FOR: EN. ZAHID ARIFFIN BIN IDRUS PREPARED BY: NURUL SABIHAH BINTI MOHAMMAD 221604 NUR AMALINA BINTI YUSOF 221811 HALIMAH BINTI A KASAH 222147 SHARIFAH NUR ATIQAH BT SYED PUTRA 222210 DATE OF SUBMISSION 14th MAY 2015 Table of Contents 1.0 INTRODUCTION 1 2.0 COCA-COLA 'ABUSED LABOUR’S RIGHTS’ 2 3.0 WORKPLACE DISCRIMINATIONS 3 4.0 HEALTH AND SAFETY WORKPLACE 4 5.0 CONCLUSION 5 6.0 REFERENCE……………………………………………………………………………………………6 1.0 INTRODUCTION China is a major and expanding market for Coca-Cola. Surging sales in emerging markets like China and India have been credited for Coke’s best sales growth for almost nine years with sales rising 19% from 2007 (The Times, 2007). According to President of Coca-Cola China, Doug Jackson, the company currently counts China as it’s fourth-largest market in terms of revenue, although it is expected to overtake Brazil to become its third-largest in two years and the second-largest within five years (China Daily, 2007). In the Hangzhou Coca Cola bottling factory, contract workers usually stay on duty for 12 hours. There were a lot of inappropriate activities on the part of Coca Cola factories concerning violation of labor contract towards its workers. Firstly, almost five bottling factories failed to......

Words: 2852 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Burberry - Individual Report by Hr Director

...Page A. Executive summery ............. 1 B. Contents 1 – Introduction ............. 2 2 – Main body A- PESTE analysis of China ............. 3 B- Opportunities and threats of China ............ 5 C- HR issues and challenges of China and Wales ............. 5 I-HR issues of China ……… 5 II-HR Challenges of China ………. 8 III-HR issues of Wales ……….. 8 IV-HR Challenges of Wales ………… 9 3 – Recommendations ............. 10 4 - Action plane a. For Home Country (England) .............. 11 b. For Host Country (China) ………… 13 5 – Conclusion ............. 15 6 - References ............ 15 A. Executive Summary – The British establishment i.e. Burberry has decided to close its Wales unit...

Words: 3803 - Pages: 16

Free Essay

Carrefour- a Comparison of the Behaviour of Carrefour in- and Outside China in Terms of Csr

...Carrefour- a Comparison of the behaviour of Carrefour in and outside China in terms of CSR - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Table of contents - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Executive summary I. Chapter – Introduction 1. Purpose of the Study 2. Objective of the study 3. The setup of the study II. Chapter – Carrefour’s position in China 2.1 Chinas retail market at a glance 2.2 Carrefour’s role in China III. Chapter – The purpose of CSR for multinational companies 3.1 The definition of CSR 3.2 The growing importance of CSR in China 3.3 The importance of Human Rights 3.4 Human Rights in China 3.5 Carrefour’s general employment practice standards 3.6 Carrefour Europe vs. Carrefour China 3.7 Conclusion VI. Chapter – Environmental concerns and CSR 4.1 Environment 4.2 Environmental Problems in China 4.3 Carrefour Europe vs. Carrefour China V. Chapter – Food Safety problematic and CSR 5.1 Food Safety 5.2 International Food Standards and Initiatives 5.3 Food Safety in China 5.4 Carrefour Europe vs. Carrefour China Literature Internet - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Executive summary China is one of the countries where globalisation has led to a significant change of the economical as well as the social frameworks. Multinational corporations are expending......

Words: 8802 - Pages: 36