Free Essay

Law and Ethics Paper

In: Business and Management

Submitted By sli12
Words 1296
Pages 6
Law Case Analysis According to the law case EEOC v. FREEMAN, the EEOC filed a law suit against Freeman and alleged the company’s hiring policy which includes criminal background and credit history checks, has a disparate impact on African-American, Hispanic, and male applicants. And the material fact of this case is whether Defendant’s hiring criteria of conducting criminal background and credit history checks is consistent with business necessity. Since the Defendant was charged by the EEOC with unlawful discrimination in this case, the source of law is the Title VII of Civil Rights Act of 1964. “Title VII prohibits discrimination in hiring, firing, trainings, promotion, discipline, or other workplace decisions on the basis of an employee or applicant’s race, color, gender, national origin, or religion” (Bennett- Alexander & Hartman, 2011). As a federal law enforcement agency, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission has obligations to investigate violations of Title VII and enforce laws against discrimination in workplace. In addition to the EEOC’s unique role, Title VII requires federal district courts to take the Title VII discrimination case for judicial review only after the EEOC has first disposed of the claim (Bennett- Alexander & Hartman, 2011). And according to the case, since the EEOC accepted applicant Katrina Vaughn’s discrimination complaint about Defendant’s violation of Title VII by rejecting hiring her based on her credit history information, the legal issue of this case before the court is after accepted Vaughn’s complaint and conducted investigation through legal process, the EEOC has disposed of the claim. However, the conciliation was not reached between Vaughn and Freeman, and the EECO eventually filed the suit in the federal district court. Because the court requires “reliable and accurate statistical analysis performed by a qualified expert” to prove defendant’s practice of disparate impact, the plaintiff submitted “initial and amended” reports that included a statistical analysis of Defendant’s hiring policy prepared by expert Murphy and Huebner. However, the Plaintiff’s statistical report caused the Defendant’s three motions included precluding the testimony of Murphy and Huebner, summary judgment, and leaving to file a sur-reply in response to the motion to exclude expert testimony. Also, Defendant argued the experts’ statistical reports are “inadmissible” to prove the existence of disparate impact, because experts’ conclusions were depending on unreliable data, untimely, and had analytical errors. In addition, Defendant argued that the experts were unclear and unable to isolate “which aspect of Defendant’s credit and criminal check processes allegedly causes the disparate impact”; which showed the failing to identify a prima facie case. Lastly, Defendant argued that the national statistics were unable to prove suspect classes received disparate impact from harsh hiring policies. On the contrary, the Plaintiff’s argument was even though two experts’ statistical reports were inadmissible to demonstrate disparate impact, the citation of the national statistics were sufficient to prove the disparate impact. Since the Defendant claimed the background investigation policies were multi-step processes that involved “different types of checks depending on the specific job and individual was seeking, consideration of both subjection and objective criteria, and examination of a long list of faction, any one of which might control the ultimate employment decision”; the EEOC also argued it was unfeasible, not meaningful, and unnecessary to examine each sub-factor separately. Furthermore, the EEOC argued that Defendant provided error data and finally caused many alleged errors in Murphy’s dataset. Later, Plaintiff contended that Defendant’s reply brief included “new” evidence and “new” arguments, so the EEOC should be allowed to file a sur-reply. Without showing sufficient evidence and reliable statistical demonstration to prove Defendant’s background check policies caused a disparate impact under Title VII, the court granted the Defendant Freeman’s motion to preclude Expert Testimony, and granted the Defendant’s motion for Summary Judgment, and also denied Plaintiff EEOC’s motion for Leave to File Sur-Reply. Finally, the court dismissed this case. Undoubtedly, the court’s decision was made upon several legal bases. Firstly, the court granted the Defendant’s motion for summary judgment relied on the rule of law that “when ruling on a motion for summary judgment, ‘[t]he evidence of nonmovant is to be believed, and all justifiable inferences are to be drawn in his favor.’” Also, based on the law, “if the plaintiff cannot make a prima facie showing of disparate impact, it is appropriate to grant summary judgment for the employer”, the court decided to grant summary judgment in favor of Defendant. Moreover, the court granted the Defendant Freeman’s motion to preclude expert testimony, because the “Federal Rule of Evidence 104(a) allows for the exclusion of unreliable expert testimony if the proponent cannot establish by a preponderance of the evidence that these requirements are met”. Besides, under “Rule 26(e)”, Murphy failed to provide proper supplemental reports and declarations. Finally, the court denied Plaintiff EEOC for leave to file sur-reply, because the “Local Rule 105.2(a)” stated that surreplies may be permitted when the moving party would be unable to contest matters presented to the court for the first time in the opposing party’s reply.” However, under the court’s scheduling order and the federal rules regarding expert discovery, the sur-reply was denied. As far as I am concerned, there is no deny that the court’s decision was correct, because the EEOC really failed to provide reliable and sufficient evidence to support the claim that Freeman’s criminal and credit background checks created disparate impact. Also, Plaintiff didn’t make a Prima facie to demonstrate the practice of disparate impact. Besides, based on the evidences of using “incomplete data sets and inadequate statistical techniques”, making “plethora of errors and analytical fallacies”, and using data from irrelevant time period; the two experts’ reports not only were inadmissible but also should be precluded. When compared with the EEOC, Defendant not only proved that the company used a “multi-step evaluation process to review the information obtained by PSA and determine whether an applicant was qualified to begin work”, but also showed the allegedly discriminatory hiring policies were job-related for the position . Furthermore, Defendant received support from lay witness Suzanne Bragg with a declaration and exhibits, and the witness pointed out the numerous factual and analytical fallacies in the two experts ‘reports. Due to those reasons, I strongly agree with the court’s decision. Although the EEOC has obligations to help employees against workplace discriminations, the EEOC’s active investigation of employer’s wrongful behaviors might cause employers in trouble. Since if employers ignore or abandon the criminal and credit background checks based on the fear of EEOC’s, employers might be liable for negligent hiring. On the contrary, those background checks can ensure qualified employees but will cause increasing law suits of discrimination. So, should employers ignore or still use the criminal and credit background checks during hiring? As this case presented, the ethical implications are firstly employers should use the criminal and credit background checks for avoiding negligent hiring and business necessity; then employers have to be very careful about hiring criteria-making; and employers need to prepare for the EEOC’s investigation finally. To sum up, after analyzing this case, the first lesson I have learned from the court’s decision is sufficient evidence really plays an important role and can influence the outcome of the case. Secondly, although the EEOC has responsibility to enforce laws against discrimination in workplace, the expert testimony can be precluded without providing reliable and accurate statistical records. In addition, in order to avoid negligent hiring and further issues, it is ethical for employers to conduct criminal and credit background checks during hiring. Finally, employers have to prove criminal and credit background checks are job related based on the disparate impact claim.

Works Cited
Bennett- Alexander, D. D., & Hartman, L. P. (2011). Employment Law for Business. New York: McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Business Law and Ethics Paper

...FACTS: Luke is an employee of ABC Company and is involved in the division that deals with recently purchased land. ABC has just acquired a new piece of land with plans to build an adult entertainment retail store, which is located quite close to where Luke’s brother, Owen, lives. Because of the new land acquisition, property values surrounding this land will significantly decrease in the future. Luke and the rest of ABC Company are aware of this, but ABC does not have plans to announce this news for another month. A week ago, however, Owen reached out to Luke about wanting to sell his house as he had received an offer to sell it at a decent price. Owen is still debating with himself whether to sell it or not, but he has not made a decision yet. ISSUE: Luke is a loyal employee and does not want to risk a breach of confidentiality with ABC, but he is also genuinely concerned about the well being of his brother. Selling the house now would mean potentially higher profits for Owen. A dilemma exists about whether or not Luke should tell his brother about the upcoming building of the adult entertainment store, which would decrease the property value of the house he is trying to sell versus disrespecting ABC Company and their confidentiality agreement. Should Luke protect his brother and advise him to not sell his house or should he respect ABC Company and keep the information to himself until it is publically announced? It is clear there is an ethical dilemma in this......

Words: 1899 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Law and Ethics Medicine Paper

...medical records. Any information pertaining conversations with medical staff, health insurance, billing information and health information is protected. For example, employers cannot see you medical records and can’t be shared; unless you give your employer, a written consent or authorization. If rights are being denied based on discrimination or a violation of HIPAA privacy or security rule occurs; a complaint can be filed. Therefore; HIPAA does affect medical records, but it also protects our health information. A complaint is filed; when a cover entity has violated health information either by privacy rights or violation of privacy rules or security rules. Any person can file the complaint. The complaint must be filed in writing either by paper or electronically. When emailing the complaint, a signature is not needed for consent forms or the complaint. An email represents the signature. The complaint must name the cover entity and description of the violation act of what you believed that was violated and what happened. The complaint must be filed within 180 days from the day the incident occurred. For an extension, you must show a good cause to the office of civil rights. A complaint filed can be sent by mail, fax or email. Cover entities are required to provide any notifications of breached of unsecured protected health information. Cover entity must notify affected individuals by first class mail or email with a written form notice, but only to individuals who has......

Words: 930 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Business, Ethics, Laws and Regulation Paper

...Business Entities, Laws and Regulation Paper Earnestine Pearson BUS/415 April 23, 2012 Tony Cardillo A entrepreneur according to Cheeseman, 2010, “is a person who forms and operates a business” (p. 250). In opening and starting a business, an individual will have to decide what type of business to form, and if he, she, or they is qualified to do. Individuals must also be able to determine the different forms of business organizations. These forms include: sole proprietorship, general partnership, limited partnership, limited liability partnership, and corporation. According to Cheeseman, 2010, “the selection of business forms has many factors to depend on. Factors including the ease of cost of formation, the capital requirements of the business, the flexibility of management decisions, government restrictions, personal liability, tax consideration, and the like” (p,250). In this paper, I will also discuss three scenarios: Business Professional Practices, the Extermination Business, and the Construction scenario. I will discuss the business entity of each scenario, the taxation of each scenario, taking charge, liability issues that each business must consider, identify the laws and regulations, and risk associated with each scenario. Professional Practice This scenario is about two friends Akiva and Tara who wants to open a birth clinic together. They have both completed all of their educational and experimental requirements of becoming obstetricians. Before......

Words: 1058 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay


...principles. 1.3 Describe problem-solving methodologies. Readings Read Ch. 1 of Health Care Ethics. Read Ch. 1 & 2 of Medical Law and Ethics. Read this week’s Electronic Reserve Readings. Read the Week One Read Me First. Participation Participate in class discussion. 4/10/2014 1 Discussion Questions Respond to weekly discussion questions. 4/10/2014 1 Nongraded Activities and Preparation Ethics Case Study Begin working on the Ethics Case Study due in Week Two. Learning Team Instructions Begin working on the Code of Ethics Paper due in Week Three. Review the Week One objectives and discuss additional insights and questions that may have arisen Individual Health Care Ethics Matching Exercise Complete the Health Care Ethics Matching Exercise, located on your student website. Match keywords commonly used in health care ethics to the definitions on the page. Discuss the exercise in class and turn in your answer sheet to your facilitator. 4/10/2014 15 Week Two: Application of Ethics Within Individual Organizations Details Due Points Objectives 2.1 Describe ethical principles used in health care organizations. 2.2 Explain the relationship between an organization’s culture and ethical decision-making. 2.3 Recognize the role and importance of ethical values within an organization. Readings Read Ch. 3 & 5 of Health Care Ethics. Read Ch. 8 of Medical Law and Ethics. Read this week’s Electronic Reserve Readings. Read the Week Two Read Me......

Words: 751 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Hcs Syllabus

...Week Two: Application of Ethics Within Individual Organizations | | Details | Due | Points | Objectives | 1 2.1 Describe ethical principles used in health care organizations. 2.2 Explain the relationship between an organization’s culture and ethical decision-making. 2.3 Recognize the role and importance of ethical values within an organization. | | | Readings | Read Ch. 3 & 5 of Health Care Ethics. Read Ch. 8 of Medical Law and Ethics. Read this week’s Electronic Reserve Readings.Read the Week Two Read Me First. | | | Participation | Participate in class discussion. | 4 of 7 days/wk | 1 | Discussion Questions | Respond to weekly discussion questions. | DQ 1: Day 2 (June 6, 2012) DQ 2: Day 4 (June 8, 2012) | 1 | Learning Team Instructions | Continue working on the Code of Ethics Paper due in Week Three. Review the Week Two objectives and discuss additional insights and questions that may have arisen. | | | Individual Ethics Case Study | Resource: Ethics Case Study Grading Criteria on your student website Read the case study in Ch. 4 of Medical Law and Ethics that begins, “Jerry McCall is Dr. William’s office assistant.” Prepare a 700- to 1050-word paper in which you answer the following questions: Does Jerry’s medical training qualify him to issue this refill order? Why or why not? * Would it make a difference if the medication requested were for control of high blood pressure......

Words: 1206 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

American Counseling Association's Ethical Code

...Term Papers and Free EssaysBrowse Essays Read full version essay Aca Ethics Aca Ethics Print version essay is available for you! You can search Free Term Papers and College Essay Examples written by students!. Join and get instant access to Aca Ethics and over 30,000 other Papers and Essays Category: Psychology Autor: anton 15 November 2010 Words: 1489 | Pages: 6 Running head: Ethics Paper ACA Code of Ethics and AACC Code of Ethics; what are the Similarities and Differences? Abstract The American Counseling Association Code of Ethics (ACA Code) and the American Association of Christian Counselors Code of Ethics (AACC Code) has many similarities as well as differences. Codes of ethics are designed to protect the client, counselor and the profession. This report will compare and contrast three separate areas within each of the two ethics codes. All areas of the ethics codes are important; however the three that have been chosen are of particular interest to the writer. Two of the areas that are addressed, confidentiality and sexual intimacies, come from duties to the client and the last area, reporting colleagues, comes from duties to the profession. ACA CODE OF ETHICS AND AACC CODE OF ETHICS, WHAT ARE THE SIMILARITIES AND DIFFERENCES? In the field of counseling, either secular counseling or Christian counseling ethics play a large and vital role. The ACA Code serves five main purposes. The five purposes...

Words: 1531 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay


...Organizational Management and Operations Paper CJA/484 Criminal Justice Administration Capstone There are countless diverse sorts of relationships that exist in America’s criminal justice system. Some of which can be founded on their interactions. Others can be based on what it is that they are responsible for. Regardless of the origin of the relationship or its purpose on any level the core values that remain at the heart of any relationship within the criminal justice system is the one between ethics and professional behavior. Ethics is one of the most essential and fundamental matters that are necessary for the criminal justice system to be more than a success. The citizens of the United States need these people who are working within our criminal justice system, and for America’s criminal justice system to uphold the United States laws and uphold America’s constitution as well as be ethical and professional people. In this paper a discussion will take place as well as an analysis of the relationship between ethics and professional behavior in the administration of criminal justice. An explanation will be provided on the role of critical thinking with regard to the relationship of ethics and professional behavior. The paper will include a proposal for a seminar in ethics training for law enforcement officers. In this paper five areas of ethical conduct that will be stressed for the seminar will be chosen. Furthermore, details will be given as to why these areas were......

Words: 917 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Essay Paper

...Differences of Ethic Carolyn Anderson ETH/316 June 24, 2014 Dr. Nancy Kennedy This paper basic on the elements of how ethic can be somewhat value of one’s life, and how a person can react on how a person feels about laws, one owns opinions of how one life should be guided, and this ethic shows how to keep the responsibility terms, standard of actions in one’s life. The main point of the three theories knows what each of the three mean and how they react to each other such as the skills of each virtue in a general decisions, which formats on amoral laws that ones can focus on the main viewpoints of a day to day basic life. Similarities The similarities difference of the three ethics such as virtue theory, deontological ethic, and Utilitarianisms is that these ethics have facts, which format a wide value of responsibility. The main part of these ethics is that they have concepts, which basic on action, terms, and standards. Differences The differences among the theories is that one of them shows how the government has ways of showing the world how moral laws should be addressed, one ethic show a person how to interact with one’s self emotions, and the other one shows the world how different options of value have certain decisions of one’s opinions. A description of the differences of the three ethics According to BBC Ethic guide “Virtue ethics is......

Words: 543 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay


...considerations. 4.3 Determine methods for managing legal risk arising from regulatory compliance issues. Readings Read Ch. 31 of Business Law: Legal Environment, Online Commerce, Business Ethics, and International. Readings Read Ch. 32 of Business Law: Legal Environment, Online Commerce, Business Ethics, and International. Readings Read Ch. 33 of Business Law: Legal Environment, Online Commerce, Business Ethics, and International. Readings Read Ch. 43 of Business Law: Legal Environment, Online Commerce, Business Ethics, and International. Readings Read Ch. 44 of Business Law: Legal Environment, Online Commerce, Business Ethics, and International. Readings Read Ch. 45 of Business Law: Legal Environment, Online Commerce, Business Ethics, and International. Readings Read Ch. 46 of Business Law: Legal Environment, Online Commerce, Business Ethics, and International. Readings Read this week’s Electronic Reserve Readings. Participation Participate in class discussion. 2 Discussion Questions Respond to weekly discussion questions. DQ 1 due Day 3 and DQ 2 Due Day 5 2 Nongraded Activities and Preparation Podcast Listen to the Week Four podcast. Learning Team Reflection Check out the local and national news sources and find a current event that reflects what we are learning this week-- Write a 350- to 1,050-word team paper explaining the event and its relevance to the week’s studies-- Day 6 1 Individual . Resource: University of Phoenix Material:......

Words: 594 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Ethics in Computing

...The concerns of ethics and computer is a constant balancing act. Technology will continue to advance and it’s our job to make sure that we always keep ourselves and our neighbors in mind when it comes to ethical behavior and computer technology. In this paper three article that touch on ethical concerns in computing in their own way. One will discuss how the concerns that we all may be very easily find ourselves in on a daily basis. One will look into more specific areas where ethics and computers intertwine, using cell phones to track pedestrians and home monitoring for the elderly. The other will hit on the risk and rewards of cloud computing and the ethics behind law firms and their move into the 21st century. Ethics surrounding computer technology are currently an ever evolving conversation. As technology advance so must the ethics and rules of how we handle our personal information and how others can and cannot used that information. With this evolution in technology there are many topics of concern that raise red flags and force people to reevaluate what needs to change in order to make sure that the very principals we hold as a country are not bent to meet the demands of changing technologies. Concerns over personal and private data who can see what and at what point is personal data no longer private. Identity theft is another issue as people become more and more willing to use computers to bank and pay bills they are more at risk of another person electronically......

Words: 1690 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay


...Ethic Essay Virtue ethics is a choice of what the outcome will become. It would be the best choice for yourself even it would break a law or rule. It's what you believe in; that will benefit you after you realize it will cause you dearly also. It will also boost your morality. It's like breaking to a nightclub without paying the entrance fee and never got caught. For this situation, you can able to save the money and spend it on drinks instead of paying to enter only. Utilitarianism is a part of virtue ethics, and this could be a non-moral situation. It avoids suffering in which rightful or wrongful will be a result of some consequences. This ethics is for the greatness of numbers. It more relates to a religious-like Christianity. They decide to believe in happiness even it's against the religious law, and the consequences are not healthy. An example is to lie at to anyone to have happiness in life or for a better life. In medicine, it has its cure but will have its side effect. The cure is more important for most people than thinking about the side effect of the medicine. Deontological ethics is against utilitarianism. It's all about the rule in either they suffer or not the needs to follow. Following your duties is the correct moral rule. If you don't do your duty, you will be immorally behaving. Society and religion make their rules that need to be followed even it will have suffered. Some examples are food; we have to kill a living thing to live. These living things......

Words: 685 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Law Enforcement Guidelines

...Law Enforcement Guidelines Shawntel Mack American Intercontinental University Abstract This paper will briefly discuss Robert Peel’s principles of policing. My research will explain the importance of having control of your temper results to disintegrating a situation. This paper provides two examples of police-involved shootings where better judgment could have applied. I will express my opinion on what I think should been to develop proper demeanor of law enforcement officers. Lastly, this paper pinpoints training deficiencies and will provide feedback of the area of training needed to satisfy the deficiency. Law Enforcement Guidelines We, as ordinary people, oftentimes find ourselves in situations where people push our buttons, or they try to see just how far they can push us before we totally loose our composure. Our temper is an additive tool that is essential in helping if a situation is diluted or if a situation is escalated. Today, there is much scrutiny of excessive force, corruption and brutality within our local police departments and among law officials. According to Sir Robert Peel’s first principle, the main goal and accomplishment for the police is to hinder disorder and criminal offenses (New Westminster Police Department, 2013). It is of the police ethics and duty of not wavering by one’s threats or any type of language, especially offensive. The advantage of displaying such ethical behavior is in the event that the police......

Words: 694 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay


...Ethics Reflection Paper Ethics Reflection Paper Ethics and social responsibility are important concepts that play a significant role into implementing a strategic plan. Ethics and social responsibility will benefit an organization into having a successful strategy plan and reduce and any potential negative impact of a operation. The subjects to address in this paper are the following, the role of ethics and social responsibility in developing a strategic plan considering stakeholder needs and how my ethical perceptive has evolved throughout the program. Ethics is an important concept as well as the fundamental principles of right individuals conduct. “Business ethics seek to proscribe behavior that businesses, firm managers, and workers should not engage in. Ethics is a source of guidance beyond enforceable law. It is clear and uncontroversial that firms and their workers should not engage in unlawful acts, such as selling harmful or defective products, and ignorance of the law cannot be used as a justification for unlawful actions. Business and management ethics goes beyond the law lo provide guidelines as to what is acceptable behavior in business transactions” (Haq, 2011, p.1). The way a company could successfully establish a mission, vision, or objective for its organization is through adhering ethics. The company must develop values that interest stakeholders. The values should include direction and expectation of the organization. The values......

Words: 590 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Fidos Bistro

...Fido’s Bistro Code of Ethics, Roles and Behaviors Patrick Mobley University of Phoenix Fido’s Bistro Code of Ethics, Roles and Behaviors In order for Fido’s Bistro to be ran smoothly, each person must play their role efficiently. Entrepreneurs will be innovative new dog treats, ideas such as new ways of advertising also enhance organization of the gourmet dog treats. At Fido’s Bistro, there will be three employees. In my company I will be in charge over all business decisions. By having control over the business I will delegate scheduling and training. Trained employees will be responsible for taking customers’ orders, deliveries and helping with the baking and packaging of the treats. All advertising will be conducted through social media and word of mouth. Fido’s Bistro has a strong ethical code of conduct. This company will be based of strong ethics. Firstly honesty everyone working at Fido’s Bistro should be honest in actions and communications. The employees should maintain personal integrity. There should be a commitment to fairness. Everyone will be open minded and accepting of diversity, not only with staff but with customers also. Treating others with respect. While representing the company employees should be law abiding. Abide all laws, rules and regulations pertaining to Fido’s Bistro Company. Being accountable for your personal actions. All employees should follow the ethical code of conduct. The rules and principles this company uses in decision making......

Words: 743 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Sweetpea's Doc.

...Running head: BUSINESS ETHICS CASE Individual Assignment: Business Ethics Case Individual Assignment: Business Ethics Case Ethics plays a role in everything individuals do throughout their lifetime. Ethics is very important in business. In order to be in the business field you have to ethics to back up the actions that an individual does whenever working. A business person needs to act ethically in order to conduct themselves properly. A person can violate a law if he or she does not judge a favorable decision in a case. The rule of law and the rule of ethics go hand and hand to one another. The National Enquirer “is a national weekly newspaper with a total circulation of more than 5 million copies.” (Cheeseman, 2010 page 49) There are nearly 600,000 copies sold within California. The National Enquirer published an article about Shirley Jones. Shirley Jones was an entertainer and a California resident. Jones “filed a lawsuit in California state court against the National Enquirer and its president, who was a resident in Florida. The California lawsuit sought damages for alleged defamation, invasion of privacy, and international infliction of emotional distress.” (Cheeseman, 2010 page 49) The Superior Court granted the motion on the group that the First Amendment concerns weighed against an assertion of jurisdiction otherwise proper under the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. It was unethical for the National Enquirer to try to avoid suit in......

Words: 684 - Pages: 3