Law Reporting in England and India

In: Other Topics

Submitted By apoorvkc
Words 3757
Pages 16
History and Development of Law reporting in England and India

Name: Amitav Singh
Roll No. 740
Semester: 2nd

History and Development of Law reporting in England and India

“It is not open to the courts in India to question any principle enunciated by this Board, although they have a right of examining the facts of any case before them to see whether and how far the principle on which stress is laid, applies to the facts of the particular case. Nor it is open to them on account of “judicial dignity” or otherwise, to question its decision on any particular issue of facts”
-Mata Prasad v. Nageshwar Sahai, 52 IA, 398, 417

In England, the gradual development of the art of law reporting reflects the growth of the authority of precedent. A court is usually bound by the ratio decidendi of a case which is decided by a higher court, but in case of House of Lords and Court of Appeals they are bound by their own decisions. In several cases, such as, Scruttons, Ltd. v. Midland Silicones Ltd. it was decided that House of Lords can limit or question the ratio decidendi of a previous case. Almost the similar view was held in a case of Chancery Lane Safe Deposit and Offices Company, Ltd. v. Inland Revenue Commissioners, that House of Lords is not bound to follow a previous case only because it was indistinguishable in facts.
In India, however, no such development in the field of law reporting…...

Similar Documents

England Project

... Flag: The Flag of England Anthem: The Full version of the British National Anthem: ‘God Save The Queen’. 1. God save our gracious Queen, Long live our noble Queen, God save the Queen! Send her victorious, Happy and glorious, Long to reign over us; God save the Queen! 2. O Lord our God arise, Scatter her enemies And make them fall; Confound their politics, Frustrate their knavish tricks, On Thee our hopes we fix, God save us all! 3. Thy choicest gifts in store On her be pleased to pour; Long may she reign; May she defend our laws, And ever give us cause To sing with heart and voice, God save the Queen! 4. Not in this land alone, But be God's mercies known, From shore to shore! Lord make the nations see, That men should brothers be, And form one family, The wide world over. 5. From every latent foe, From the assassins blow, God save the Queen! O'er her thine arm extend, For Britain's sake defend, Our mother, prince, and friend, God save the Queen! National animal: Lion National flower: Rose National tree: Oak tree Currency: Pound (rate £1 = R11.13) Leader of country: David William Donald Cameron was born on 9 October 1966 and is the current Prime Minister of England. He is aged 43. David was narrowly elected PM in 2010 after A first candidacy for Parliament at Stafford in 1997 ended in defeat, but Cameron was elected in 2001 as the Member of Parliament for the Oxfordshire...

Words: 733 - Pages: 3

Reporting of Intangibles by Service Sector in India

...Title: Reporting of Intangibles by Service Sector in Indian context Introduction "I can make a whole lot more money skillfully managing intangible assets than tangible assets." – Warren Buffet In the current knowledge based economy, there is a transition from matter based economy to one based on ideas. The emphasis is shifting from natural resources to new thoughts and designs. With the shift from monetary economy to knowledge based economy, the wealth can be added by increasing the intangibles. The intangibles are the growth drivers for the Indian Economy. The high productive sector is the service sector whose contribution to GDP of the nation has displaced the contribution of Agriculture and Industry and the contribution is rising. In service sector nearly 22% of the population of the nation is contributing around 55% of GDP. The reason for high productivity can be attributed to only intangibility. The financial statements of the service sector enterprises do not depict the intangibles – because of difficulty in identification, measurement and valuation. The growth of the Service Sector may be slowed down if the service firms which are mostly knowledge driven are not growing and the two major obstacles in the growth of knowledge driven firms are (a) Finance and (b) Coverage of risk. Since the methodologies have not been developed for valuation of the intellectual properties, there are no reported resources on the basis of which sources for raising the...

Words: 1221 - Pages: 5


...The Early History of Accounting The Zenon papyri which were found by people on 1915 contain much information about business activities and several business operation of private estate of thirty year during the third century. This proves that accounting records exist on back to several thousand years. The article present by Hain in 1966 state that .The Zenon’s accounting system contained provision for responsibility accounting, a written record of transaction, personal wages paid account, inventory records, and record of acquisition and disposal of asset. This was show that all the account is subject to auditing. On 1300-1500, because the highly increasing on trade and commerce of Italian. The proper and accurate record for transaction is important urgent need. Through the Arabic numeral system and basis of arithmetic, Italian develops a double entry bookkeeping entry system. This can be found on the book by Italian monk, Fra Luca Pcioli. He formalized the practice and idea that the double entry bookkeeping enabled the organization to keep a proper, complete and accurate record of their transaction. And enhance the organization ability in prepared the financial statement. On 1600, the people desire to obtain capital information rather than the whole financial statement. This had motive the separate the financial statement to statement of profit and loss and statement of financial position. On nineteenth century, the evolution of transform joint ventures into......

Words: 318 - Pages: 2

Law Reporting in England and India

...History and Development of Law reporting in England and India Name: Amitav Singh Roll No. 740 Semester: 2nd History and Development of Law reporting in England and India “It is not open to the courts in India to question any principle enunciated by this Board, although they have a right of examining the facts of any case before them to see whether and how far the principle on which stress is laid, applies to the facts of the particular case. Nor it is open to them on account of “judicial dignity” or otherwise, to question its decision on any particular issue of facts” -Mata Prasad v. Nageshwar Sahai, 52 IA, 398, 417 Introduction: In England, the gradual development of the art of law reporting reflects the growth of the authority of precedent. A court is usually bound by the ratio decidendi of a case which is decided by a higher court, but in case of House of Lords and Court of Appeals they are bound by their own decisions. In several cases, such as, Scruttons, Ltd. v. Midland Silicones Ltd. it was...

Words: 3757 - Pages: 16

Elizabethan England

... COSTUME AND FASHION SOURCE BOOKS Elizabethan England Kathy Elgin Copyright © 2009 Bailey Publishing Associates Ltd Produced for Chelsea House by Bailey Publishing Associates Ltd, 11a Woodlands, Hove BN3 6TJ, England Project Manager: Patience Coster Text Designer: Jane Hawkins Picture Research: Shelley Noronha Artist: Deirdre Clancy Steer All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or by any information storage or retrieval systems, without permission in writing from the publisher. For information contact: Chelsea House, an imprint of Infobase Publishers, 132 West 31st Street, New York, NY 10001. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Elgin, Kathy. Elizabethan England / Kathy Elgin. p. cm. — (Costume source books) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-1-60413-379-0 1. Clothing and dress—England—History—16th century—Juvenile literature. 2. England—Social life and customs—16th century— Juvenile literature. I. Title. II. Series. GT734.E44 2009 391.00942'09031—dc22 2008047258 Chelsea House books are available at special discounts when purchased in bulk quantities for businesses, associations, institutions, or sales promotions. Please call our Special Sales Department in New York on (212) 967-8800 or (800) 322-8755. You can find Chelsea House on the World Wide Web at: Printed and bound in Hong...

Words: 16999 - Pages: 68

Constitutionality of Customary Law in India

...RESEARCH ON THE CONSTITUTIONALITY OF “CUSTOMARY LAWS” IN INDIA. Introduction. There is no universally accepted definition of customary law. Black’s Law Dictionary defines customary law as “customs that are accepted as legal requirements or obligatory rules of conduct, practices and beliefs that are so vital and intrinsic a part of a social and economic system that they are treated as if they are laws. Tobin and Taylor add to this the recognition that such legal regimes are dynamics and constantly evolving and often at all provide a still broader definition of customary law, stating that: “Customary Laws include customary worldviews, principles or values, and codes of conduct, and established practices. They are enforced by community institutions, and can have sanction attached. They are divided from natural resource use – some practices and beliefs acquire the force of law. They are locally recognized, orally held, adaptable and evolving.” Historically, the relative influence of each of natural law, customary law and positive laws has fluctuated throughout time and space. The strong emphasis on positive law in the field of international law during the 18th century led to a decline in the persuasion of natural law and the customary law in the western world. In particular, the doctrine of terra nullius serve to reduced indigenous rights and delegitimize their customary law. Across much of the globe, there has been increasing awareness of the significant role of...

Words: 7596 - Pages: 31

Modern Family Law in India

...Modern Family Law: Changing attitudes and Agendas in the Personal Laws and the Uniform Civil Code Introduction: In the current modern state the need for a legal centralism is required. The dominant legal model of the uniform legal system brings out the modern State and the attitude of the people. India is one of the many countries in which the uniform legal system has gained such momentum maybe not in implementation but has gained much interest in a heated political debate. Article 44 of the Constitution of India, 1950 has anticipated the eventual implementation of the uniform legal system. Article 44 in the constitution of 1950, reads, “Uniform Civil Code for the citizens of India- the State shall endeavor to secure for the citizens a uniform civil code throughout the territory of India.” But the much anticipated eventuality has been a distant dream since the past 60 years. India is known for its socio-economic diversities and inequalities. India is one of the most diverse democracies of the world. India’s secularism which is enshrined in the preamble of the constitution is not an anti-religious policy but outlook to frame the country into one entity. India’s pluralism is linked with how the Hindu culture has never been mono-cultural or monotheistic. India’s democracy also aims at providing all citizens equal rights; this premise is based on treating equals equally. There are many shifting agendas in the personal laws in India. People’s outlook towards bigamy...

Words: 3428 - Pages: 14

Law Enforcement in New England

...Law Enforcement in New England 1600 – Present Day HIS 602 - History of New England – Spring 2013 – Manchester Law enforcement today is very different than what it was when the Puritan settlers first came here to New England. As like the name the name the settlers went with what they knew and followed in England’s footsteps when it came to law enforcement (Johnson 1981). Following in the English’s footsteps would be a president that is followed for centuries until the need for different style of policing becomes apparent due to differences in the countries culture in the 18th century. This is where we begin to see the split that we see to this day. In Saxon England prior to 1066, the absence of effective royal authority, such as a standing army it was up to local communities to keep the peace in regard of criminal behavior (Johnson 1981). In 1252 the title constable was coined, a constable was an officer of the royal court. In the next two centuries following the Norman Conquest constables morphed into elected officials of the manorial courts (Johnson 1981). In 1285 the Normans who invaded England codified The Statue of Winchester which remained in effect until 1829 when the Metropolitan Police Act was established. The Statue of Winchester reenacted “hue and cry” which called upon all residents to assist watchmen if they encountered resistance. The statue gave constables the authority to enroll male inhabitants as said watchmen (Johnson 1981). Basically...

Words: 1878 - Pages: 8


...England’s size relative to Canada : UK - 244,820sqK, Canada – 9,984,670sqK England’s population: 57.1 million Languages spoken: English (main language) GDP per capita: $55309.09 CD World region: Europe Capital city: London Currency: The currency of England is the pound sterling. Paper money comes in £5, £10, £20 and £50 denominations, although £50s can be difficult to change because fakes circulate. (Other currencies are rarely accepted.) 12:00pm in Ottawa is 5:00pm in England. England’s has a maritime temperature climate it is mild with temperatures not much lower than 0 °C (32 °F) in winter and not much higher than 32 °C (90 °F) in summer. The weather is damp relatively frequently and is changeable. The coldest months are January and February, the latter particularly on the English coast, while July is normally the warmest month. Months with mild to warm weather are May, June, September and October. Important influences on the climate of England are its proximity to the Atlantic Ocean, its northern latitude and the warming of the sea by the Gulf Stream. England’s labour force is relatively small. Only 1.4% of England is occupied by agriculture the other 98.6 percent is split up into, Industry which is 18.4% and the most occupied of England’s labour Services which is 80.4% of England’s work force. The England form of Government is a constitutional monarchy, which combines a monarch head of state with a parliamentary system. While many consider the...

Words: 1424 - Pages: 6


...Social Stratification Classes and Castes. Class is the primary way in which people approach social stratification. The upper class (the landed gentry, the titled nobility, and members of the royal family) has roughly the same social position it has had since the nineteenth century, when the middle classes began to compete successfully with the landed interests for influence. However, the upper class lost official political influence (and credibility) in the twentieth century. The major change in England's social identity structure has been the shrinking number of workers in manufacturing and the increasing number of people who work in service industries. White-collar and other service workers have replaced blue-collar workers as England's economic backbone. Consequently, the middle class has increased in size and wealth, and home ownership has increased, while union membership has declined dramatically, along with the size of the traditional industrial working class. Most workers expect unemployment at some point in their careers, especially the unskilled and uneducated. In 1983, only 5 percent of non-manual workers were unemployed. In contrast, skilled manual workers experienced 12 percent and semi-skilled and unskilled manual workers 23 percent unemployment, and manual workers combined accounted for 84 percent of the unemployed. England is becoming a society of the included and the excluded. There has been a sharp rise in long-term unemployment. The nature of work in a...

Words: 3480 - Pages: 14

Research England

... more facilities. Sport is spread with fast pace in schools and to the general public. Year by year there is more demand and more supply in the sport events sector. A wide variety of specialized companies like caterers, entertainment agencies and lighting and sound personnel are widely available to meet the needs of this successful industry. Another major trend to follow up in the next years is the ageing population. Improvements in health care made it possible for people to live longer and this makes the market for Sport Events even more popular, from football for youngsters to bowling for the elder. Another major future issue for the sport events industry is Information Technology. As the technology progress with lightning speed, the event system should be upgraded technologically as well. The growth of internet sets the base for researching, marketing, reporting and communication. Software has also been developed for making sport events more practical. Having events that won’t cost the earth are always in the main plans for event managers. ‘Greening of the Games’ is also a top priority for the IOC for future Olympic games. Environmental Management strategies offer the effect of lower costs as well and more and more events (egg. Virgin London Marathon) promote sustainability which is a trend which is about to continue and improve during the future. Sport England’s funding programmed, Protecting Playing Fields ( PPF ) is part of our Places People Play Olympic legacy mass......

Words: 5699 - Pages: 23

Ip Law in India

...M UM B A I S I L I C O N VA L L E Y BANGALORE S I NG A P ORE M UM BA I -BK C NEW DELH I M UNI CH Intellectual Property Law in India December 2013 © Copyright 2013 Nishith Desai Associates Intellectual Property Law in India About NDA Nishith Desai Associates (NDA) is a research based international law firm with offices in Mumbai, Bangalore, Silicon Valley, Singapore, New Delhi, Munich. We specialize in strategic legal, regulatory and tax advice coupled with industry expertise in an integrated manner. We focus on niche areas in which we provide significant value and are invariably involved in select highly complex, innovative transactions. Our key clients include marquee repeat Fortune 500 clientele. Core practice areas include International Tax, International Tax Litigation, Litigation & Dispute Resolution, Fund Formation, Fund Investments, Capital Markets, Employment and HR, Intellectual Property, Corporate & Securities Law, Competition Law, Mergers & Acquisitions, JVs & Restructuring, General Commercial Law and Succession and Estate Planning. Our specialized industry niches include financial services, IT and telecom, education, pharma and life sciences, media and entertainment, gaming, real estate and infrastructure. IFLR1000 has ranked Nishith Desai Associates in Tier 1 for Private Equity (2014). Chambers & Partners has ranked us as # 1 for Tax, TMT and Private Equity (2013). Legal Era, a prestigious Legal Media...

Words: 27779 - Pages: 112

England Attraction

...Stonehenge Part of an UNESCO World Heritage Site, Stonehenge is one of Britain's most famous sightseeing spots. Believed to date from as far back as 3000BC, historians are still baffled by how the huge slabs of Stonehenge were transported. Weighing up to 50 tons each, it would’ve taken 600 men to move just one. Eden Project collection of unique artificial biomes containing an amazing collection of plants from around the world. Located in a reclaimed quarry in Cornwall, the complex consists of huge domes that look rather like massive igloo-shaped greenhouses. Each houses thousands of different plant species in tropical and Mediterranean environments. As well as these stunning displays of plant life, the Eden Project hosts numerous fantastic arts and music events. Located @ Bodelva, Cornwall Flamingo Land Theme Park and Zoo, Yorkshire With rides, a zoo, live entertainment and a variety of restaurants and bars, Flamingo Land is suitable for just about everyone! Over 140 species live at the zoo, including red pandas and penguins, while the theme park has rides for the whole family; a perfect two-in-one day out. Durham Cathedral, in the city of Durham in northeast England is the greatest Norman building in England and perhaps even in Europe. It is cherished not only for its architecture but also for its incomparable setting. The foundation stone of Durham Cathedral was laid on August 12, 1093. Since that time, there have been major additions and reconstructions of some...

Words: 432 - Pages: 2


... collection of preexisting atomic individuals (as suggested, for example, by Hobbes, Locke, and Rousseau), but rather a processual whole within which individuals define themselves through participation in social acts. The acts of the individual are, according to Mead, aspects of acts that are trans- individual. "For social psychology, the whole (society) is prior to the part (the individual), not the part to the whole; and the part is explained in terms of the whole, not the whole in terms of the part or parts" (Mind, Self and Society 7). Thus, the social act is a "dynamic whole," a "complex organic process," within which the individual is situated, and it is within this situation that individual acts are possible and have meaning. Mead defines the social act in relation to the social object. The social act is a collective act involving the participation of two or more individuals; and the social object is a collective object having a common meaning for each participant in the act. There are many kinds of social acts, some very simple, some very complex. These range from the (relatively) simple interaction of two individuals (e.g., in dancing, in love-making, or in a game of handball), to rather more complex acts involving more than two individuals (e.g., a play, a religious ritual, a hunting expedition), to still more complex acts carried on in the form of social organizations and institutions (e.g., law- enforcement, education, economic exchange). The life of a society...

Words: 3897 - Pages: 16

Nhs England

...=The National Health Service (NHS) is a publicly financed organization created by the government to give free or low cost good healthcare to all legal residents of United Kingdom launched in July 1948, a principle that remains at its core. The aim of this essay is to examine the objectives of NHS, how it carries out its services and its external factors. The National Health Services is divided into four geographical regions, which are: * NHS England * NHS Wales * NHS Scotland and * NHS North Ireland. In this essay, my key focus is NHS England. It is a self-governing organization, with close contact to the government. Its main responsibility is to prioritize and set direction of the NHS to improve health care services for people of England. The NHS establishes enabling environment for health care services and staff to ensure highest quality of care through effective utilization of available resources with best outcomes for individuals within communities and society for now and future generations. NHS is structured into different sections to make-work more identifiable to whom to go to when need arises. There is the secretary of state for services (SSS) and the department of health (DH). The SSS is generally responsible of all the work while the DH is in charge of all the social and health care funding of England and the tactical leadership. The mission of NHS is good healthcare should be available to all, regardless of the wealth. With the expectation...

Words: 2539 - Pages: 11