Premium Essay

Law and Happy

In:

Submitted By weiser1977
Words 527
Pages 3
Factual Summary:
Bobby Bandleader, a Bistro Operator refuses to pay for copyright song” Happy Birthday”. He has his own version of the song and is one of the main reasons people are coming to his restaurant. If he has to pay for all the licensing fees, he will be bankrupt. Mr. Singstealer has the right of the copyright song and demands fees from the restaurant. He is also not working and the fees from the song are his only income. Mr. Bistro is a customer for the Bistro restaurant and has been going there for years. He goes there because the food is “tasty” and the tradition of getting the “Happy Birthday “song, sung to him. Also his mother sung “Happy Birthday” every year to him, and he also sings the song to his children.
Issue(s):
Is singing a “Happy Birthday” song in public restaurant violation of any copyrights?
Bobby’s own version of the classic “Happy Birthday to You” uses the same tune, but somewhat different wording than does the original song.
Legal Concept(s):
In accordance with title 17 of the United States Code 101, “musical works, including any accompanying words are protected within the copyright law”. The law goes on to say “The copyright in a compilation or derivative work extends only to the material contributed by the author of such work”. With these two basic rules in mind in order to come to a decision I would have to compare both Mr. Bandleader and Mr. Sing stealer’s versions of the song to determine how much material within the infringing song was contributed by the copyrighted material. As an arbitrator in charge of resolving this legal dispute based upon my understanding of copyright law and the facts of this case I would submit a verdict for only the percentage of the song that was contributed. An example of this is if Mr. Bandleader’s version was completely different in melody and lyrics he would not be liable for any

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Marketing

...Healthy Happy foody Introduction Healthy Happy Foody is built around the belief that eating healthy meals can have a magnificent impact on a person’s healthy, This analysis will make the business owner of the business Gino Nutriona. The situation analysis will provide accurate information that he needs to understand before he starts his small business. Situation analysis will cover most of the marketing strategies like economic forces, sociocultural forces, and political forces, legal forces and environmental forces; they all play a major role in business and as a business manager Gino to needs to understand them to be successful. Industry overview it is a complex, global group of diverse businesses that supply food. A lot of fast food businesses in Australia are introducing healthier meals due to a push from those customers that enjoy eating healthy. “Healthy-eating campaigns, such as the ACT government's Towards Zero Growth initiative, have been formed to tackle the crisis and cut down on obesity. They've got their work cut out for them when they consider Australian Bureau of Statistics data that shows more than half of all Australians are still overweight or obese, up to 61.2 per cent in 2008 compared with 56.3 per cent in 1995.” (by Ben Westcott from Canberra time) Political Forces A lot of businesses organisations are influenced by political forces. The healthy happy foody cafe will start as a small organisation therefore it won’t be engaged in politics as much...

Words: 1239 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Sing vs Bandleader

...Lakeshia Hampton Laws 310 Week 3 Singstealer vs. Bandleader Summary of the Facts of the Case: Bobby Bandleader has been singing his own version of “Happy Birthday to You” for over twenty years at his restaurant. Bobby’s version of the song uses the same tune, but different wording. Johnny Singstealer owns the copyright to “Happy Birthday to You”, and the copyright is valid. Johnny discovered that Bobby Bandleader is using his song, and has sued Bobby for copyright infringement and is seeking $1M in damages, as well as an injunction against further performances by Bobby. Legal Issues Presented: Both parties have asked for arbitration on the matter of copyright infringement, damages, and an injunction against further performances of “Happy Birthday to You” by Bobby Bandleader. The court will determine if Bobby Bandleader’s rendition of “Happy Birthday to You” infringes upon the copyright held by Johnny Singstealer, and if any damages ($1M) have been sustained, as well as if an injunction to prevent Bobby Bandleader from performing the song in his establishment will be issued. Legal Concepts: Based on the copyright laws of the United States which are encoded in Title 17 of the United States Code ("Copyright Law of the United States," n.d), some of the facts states: * Bobby Bandleader infringed upon the copyright of Johnny Singstealer according to Section 501(a) Anyone who violates any of the exclusive rights of the copyright owner as provided by section 106...

Words: 699 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Cs Lewis We Have No Right To Happiness Analysis

...achieving freedom of being happy. The author believes that “what methods of pursuing happiness are either morally permissible by the Law of Nature or should be declared legally by the legislature of a particular nation“(2). This statement explains that happiness can be achieved by doing things that are allowed by society’s norms and rules which counter the fact on that we can do whatever we like to reach happiness. However, without any limitations, happiness can be harmful can turn into something misleading, causing harm other people instead. Moreover, Lewis states that the only thing that makes a person feel happy is ‘sex’. It is only a part of numerous fun activities that humans can do when they are alive. Many other things can make a person happy, such as helping others in need. After reading this article, I disagree with Lewis’ statement as he said that we cannot achieve our true happiness by just obeying the norms and law and believing only sex is the thing that makes human being happy. In the same article, Lewis states people cannot find their real happiness by following the norms and rule because he believes that “law and standards are the ones who stopped us from achieving our true happiness.” For...

Words: 600 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Mastering Human Relations

...more for your career and for your personal life than perhaps anything else you can accomplish. The bad news is that the inability to get along with others is the primary reason for failure, frustration and unhappiness in life and work.  According to one study, more the 95 percent of men and women let go from their jobs over a ten year period were fired because of poor social skills rather than lack of competence or technical ability. According to psychologist Sydney Jourard, most of your joy in life comes from your happy relationships with other people, and most of your problems in life come from unhappy relationships with them.  Most of your problems in life are people problems. Fortunately, you can become extremely skilled at getting along with others, and in this chapter, you will learn how.  You’ll learn a variety of proven methods to immediately improve your relationships with virtually anyone, under almost any circumstances. The Law of Indirect Efforts The Law of Indirect Effort states that you get almost everything in your relationships with others more easily by approaching them indirectly rather than directly. For example, if you want to impress people, the direct way of going about it is to try to convince them of your admirable qualities and accomplishments.  But trying to impress another person by talking about yourself usually...

Words: 1071 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Johnny Songstealer

...claims that he now owns the copyright to the “Happy Birthday To You” song for 20 years. The song was inherited from his family. He is seeking royalties from the use of the Happy Birthday Song. Bobby Bandleader says that everybody utilizes the “Happy Birthday To You” song. He has added his own “twist” in the song so it’s not the traditional song. He uses harmonizing chords, as well as, changed some of the words in the song to make it his own creativity. I am going to decide whether or not Bobby Bandleader will owe royalty payments to Johnny Singstealer simply because he uses the melody of the song and the basis of the song, HBTY. “Happy Birthday To You” is a song that is known throughout the world as the birthday song (Cold Case: The Happy Birthday Song Edition, 2011). The origination of the song was copywritten by Preston Ware Orem and R.R. Forman many years ago. They were the first to actually write out the song in which they received the copyright because of that and were estimated at $5 million dollars in 1990. The copyright isn’t due to expire until 2030, but has now been passed down to Johnny Singstealer in which he now owns the copyright. The purpose of copyright laws and royalties is to afford the copyright owner a fair return for his creative work and the copyright user a fair income under existing economic conditions (Proceedings by Copyright Royalty Judges). Bobby Bandleader has not sung the song, “Happy Birthday To You” verbatim. He has taken the liberty...

Words: 514 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Being Happy

...BEING HAPPY! A Handbook to Greater Confidence and Security Author: Andrew Matthews Publisher: Media Masters Date of Publication: 2000 ISBN: 9810006640 No. Of Pages: 136 pages About the Authors Wisdom in a Nutshell Every person's ultimate quest in life is to be happy. But more often than not, people struggle finding contentment, peace and happiness in life. This highly motivational book by Andrew Matthews is written to help both young and old to find the path to bliss. Andrew Matthews An international speaker, bestselling author and award winning cartoonist, Andrew Matthews makes complex issues simple. The author of Being Happy!, Follow Your Heart and Being a Happy Teenager, Andrew Matthews is published in 29 languages in 60 countries and has Andrew has appeared on over 3000 radio and television programmes on 4 continents. This book entitled Being Happy is about the daily experiences in life and how you can change your attitude towards these to become happy. This book talks about forgiveness, confidence, goals, success, humor, and many more. This teaches you how to deal with the daily problems that you face and how you can address them without spoiling the rest of your day. More importantly, Being Happy will help you embrace yourself with respect and love that you deserve. This will help you understand yourself better. And eventually helps you live life to the fullest. Andrew Matthews has presented seminars and keynote speeches across...

Words: 3055 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Paper

...Singstealer. Please write a one-page ruling that details your answer and explains how and why you reached the conclusion that you did.  The issue on the fact pattern of the assignment deals with copyright laws of the United States. For purposes of the one-page ruling that you have to write, I am providing you with the legal background and possible arguments in order for you to arrive at your own conclusion and complete the assignment. Summary of the Facts of the Case: Bobby Bandleader has been singing his own version of Happy Birthday To You for over twenty years at his restaurant. In Bobby's version of the song, he uses the same tune, but has different wordings of the song. Bobby's version of singing Happy Birthday To You became very popular and has contributed to the success of his restaurant. Johnny Singstealer is the copyright holder of Happy Birthday To You. The copyright has not expired and is still valid. Johnny discovered the use of his song by Bobby Bandleader and has sued Bobby for copyright infringement. Bobby is seeking $1million for damages and an injunction against any further performances by Bobby. Copyright Laws: The copyright laws of the United States is encoded in Title 17 of the United States Code. The website to access for the copyright laws is: http://www.copyright.gov/title17/ Below are the applicable sections in the code that applies to this case. I am making annotations in blue why I feel the section applies to this case: Section...

Words: 2805 - Pages: 12

Free Essay

Utilitarian vs Hedonism

...explains that whatever we do matters if it consequently makes us happy or even unhappy. Therefore, nothing else has a part in terms of not making the individuals happy or unhappy. I say unhappy because things that we do or things that happens to us can unintentionally makes us unhappy at the end, however, if we consider the idea of causality, a chain of cause and effect can bring us a chain of happiness and unhappiness. Things that makes us as a society unhappy, we tend to avoid, and things that makes us happy we tend to do more. But what happens if, for instance, something that was supposed to make us happy in the future has been replaced with the sense of sadness and despair. For example, if one’s dream was to fly an airplane and become a pilot was crushed after an unfortunate accident in which the individual loses his eye vision. Then we can see that in this series of cause and effect there was a cause that worked as an obstacle in front of him not to achieve his ultimate happiness which was being a pilot and therefore, not becoming an important part of a society which can, for instance, keep us safe in the sky and so make us happy. However, is it true that what was left for him was merely a sense of unhappiness? What can the individual do to prevent such accident in the future? Does that even matter since the individual already lost his eyes? Therefore, we come to an understanding that what makes us happy is merely relevant to our surrounding and community, and possibly...

Words: 1795 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Business Administration

... | | |Employment Law | Copyright © 2009, 2007, 2006, 2004 by University of Phoenix. All rights reserved. Course Description This course provides an overview of federal statutes and state-regulated areas that affect the personnel function. Among topics addressed are EEO and affirmative action, OSHA, ERISA, FMLA, and ADA; employee privacy issues (polygraph testing, drug and alcohol testing, employer searching and monitoring); and wrongful discharge. Policies Faculty and students/learners will be held responsible for understanding and adhering to all policies contained within the following two documents: University policies: You must be logged into the student website to view this document. Instructor policies: This document is posted in the Course Materials forum. University policies are subject to change. Be sure to read the policies at the beginning of each class. Policies may be slightly different depending on the modality in which you attend class. If you have recently changed modalities, read the policies governing your current class modality. Course Materials Bennett-Alexander, D. D., & Hartman, L. P. (2007). Employment law for business (5th ed.). Boston, MA: McGraw-Hill. All electronic materials are available on the student website. |Week One: The Legal...

Words: 2454 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Moral Theory and Culture

...cultures with living well. However, culture defines the meaning of happiness at different points in ones life. Ones perception of happiness can be quite different from another’s (Scalet and Arthur, 2014). For example, one may define happiness through wealth and success and another may define happiness, not on the material things they own but the family they have and the choices they have made through life. Aristotle also suggests happiness conforms to goodness of virtue (Kucukuysal and Beyhan, 2011). To be happy and good, one must make the right choices. Virtue is taught and learned. The ability to define happiness and decide what is virtuous is an individual choice based upon life teachings and experience. In order to make someone else happy, you must be happy with yourself. Life’s choices, treatment of others should be made with the best of intentions and cause no harm to others. Scalet and Arthur (2014) have suggested the quality of life is determined by activities and that a happy person will never do what is hateful and mean but will live life with dignity and always do what is best. Kant’s theory suggests that actions determine morality and one must not only act in accordance to duty but for the sake of...

Words: 957 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Breaking The Law Essay

...judged in the underworld for running away. He would be running from the law so he would be trading the wrong that the Athen’s society is doing to him for another wrong. He justified this to Crito by saying breaking the law is really bad and no matter what he needs to follow this. He compares breaking the law to hitting a parent as a child. In escaping he would be only hurting himself and the society. He thought that breaking the law would make him look like a bad person and it would only punish him in the afterlife. Not only harm would come to himself he would also harm the society because in his mind a citizen is bound to the law. Soldiers in the USA today are also bound to the United States in a sense and are...

Words: 659 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Rainbow Law Research Paper

...The Rainbow Law Gail Collins once said “Gay rights is just a matter of time. Look at the polls. Worrying about gay marriage, let alone gay civil unions or gay employment rights, is a middle-age issue. Young people just can’t see the problem. At worst, gays are going to win this one just by waiting until the opposition dies off.” To me this quote means they got what they wanted and time has changed over the years. It is 2015 and our generation is acceptable in a way. Some people believe that people of the same sex can’t be together and others believe differently. The homosexuals have been tortured throughout their lives. People should have the right to love anyone they choose. About the rainbow law I will discuss my experience, the effects, and the similarities and differences....

Words: 658 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Crack

...CRACK Should women addicted to crack be able to have children? Barbara Harris says no. Harris has adopted four children from a drug addict. She has also founded CRACK (Children Requiring A Caring Kommunity) a non-profit organization that offers $200 in cash to addicts who agree to be sterilized or undergo long-term contraception like Norplant, which is surgically imbedded under the skin. In this essay I will be discussing what the ethical dilemma is, who the stakeholders are in this ethical dilemma, analyzing the problem by reference to the categorical imperative, analyzing the problem from a Kantian and utilitarian standpoint and giving my overall opinion of this matter. As I understand it the ethical dilemma here is the procedure in itself. Some are saying that the women are doing it for the money to buy more drugs. Also, saying that it takes away women rights to reproduce. Physicians and attorneys are saying that the women are in no condition to consent to being sterilized. They say that because these women are mentally ill and poor they are not capable of making their own decisions. But Barbara Harris from her own experiences says that women addicted to crack do not need to have babies. These women are bringing babies into the world addicted to crack. She tells of a story of how she adopted four children from a crack addicted woman. One of the children would wake up screaming in the middle of the night. She says it looked like his eyes were about to pop out of his head...

Words: 1057 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Case Brief Soldano V. O’daniels Court of Appeals of California March 28, 1983 Statement of Facts a Patron of Happy Jack’s Saloon Went Across the Street to the Circle Inn to Talk with the Owner of the Two Establishments.

...Associate Justice. Does a business establishment incur liability for wrongful death if it denies use of its telephone to a good samaritan who explains an emergency situation occurring without and wishes to call the police? This appeal follows a judgment of dismissal of a complaint for wrongful death upon a motion for summary judgment...[by defendant]. "This action arises out of a shooting death occurring on August 9, 1977. Plaintiff's father [Darrell Soldano] was as shot and killed by one Rudolph Villanueva on that date at defendant's Happy Jack's Saloon. This defendant [O'Daniels] owns and operates the Circle Inn which is an eating establishment located across the street from Happy Jack's. Plaintiff's second cause of action against this defendant is one for negligence. "Plaintiff [Soldano] alleges that on the date of the shooting, a patron of Happy Jack's Saloon came into the Circle Inn and informed a Circle Inn employee that a man had been threatened at Happy Jack's. He requested the employee either call the police or allow him to use the Circle Inn phone to call the police. That employee allegedly refused to call the police and allegedly refused to allow the patron to use the phone to make his own call. Plaintiff alleges that the actions of the Circle Inn employee were a breach of the legal duty that the Circle Inn owed to the decedent." We were advised at oral argument that the employee was the defendant's bartender. The state of the record is unsatisfactory in that it does not...

Words: 2016 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Computing

...DOES ECONOMIC GROWTH MAKE PEOPLE HAPPY Theoretically economic growth is an increasing the economy of a country, an area to satisfy the wants of the members of society, and enable to produce goods and services, which use lower of inputs (capital, labour, raw material, etc) for a given amount of output, to compare from one period of time to another. Economic Growth is a growth in a level of National Income and Gross Domestic Product, which is abbreviated as GDP, is a measuring stick for Economic Growth. In effect of every aspect of economics such as agriculture, manufacturing, structure, energy, services and government department, if GDP decreases then the Economy is shrinking, that means job cutting, falling price, and etc. Behind, if GDP increases therefore the economy is expanding better and more new jobs for civilisation. GDP per capita (GpC) is often considered an indicator of a country’s standard living and is measured in term of dollars. Economic Growth is generally speaking higher incomes mean higher living standards. However, the question is that “does economic growth make people happy?” and we are going to discover to see does everybody be happy when economic growth. First of all, could you distinguish between happy and satisfy and do they always go together? Happy is defined as both a state of mind and an emotion, and “satisfy” on the other hand is the state wherein your desires are met. On the table1 shows that at average of GDP, GpC ($7972.3) and Population the...

Words: 964 - Pages: 4