Free Essay

Legal Activism

In: Social Issues

Submitted By TJCas
Words 809
Pages 4
Tereso Casiano
Instructor: Van Hoy
LST 2010:001
10 December 2011
Legal Activism

In the legal profession, there are many people who become a lawyer not to get rich or to gain prestige, but who go into the law to make real changes. The practice of attempting to make changes to law through the courts is known as legal activism.
Activist lawyers generally are passionate about the causes they are fighting for. They believe that there is a fundamental right to make changes to the law and that society demands that they do this. Some would argue that this kind of activism can be likened to that of the religious fanatic who has no doubts about what God wants of him. They argue that the law is supposed to remain constant and unwavering and that inconsistency in the law is dangerous to society itself.
This paper will evaluate the above claims using examples of cases where activist lawyers have attempted to change a law that they believed needed to be changed and give examples of cases in which activism resulted in significant changes in not only the law as we knew it, but also society’s perception of right and wrong. Many lawyers believe that law was intended to remain constant and unwavering, and that any lawyer who tries to change the law is as dangerous as a religious fanatic. The difference between religious fanaticism and activist lawyers is that activist lawyers generally seek to reform the law in what they perceive to be an injustice to civil rights. Law students, upon entering law school This, however, is an extreme assertion. The legal system itself is supported by the state, which can be repressive toward its citizens. (Bonsignore, et al: 315) There have been cases where the consistency in the law has been more damaging to society. Activist lawyers serve a beneficial role in these circumstances.
In Thornton and Wife v. The Suffolk Manufacturing Company (1852) a married woman was unable to represent herself before the law. In the Supreme Court landmark case of case of Plessy v. Ferguson (1896), it was ruled that segregation was constitutional as long as it was “separate but equal.” This made segregation legal in the south for almost sixty years. The problem was that separate facilities implied that
African-Americans somehow inferior to whites. It wasn’t until another almost sixty years later when the landmark case of Brown v. Board of Education (1954), which involved the desegregation of public schools in Topeka, Kansas that public facilities were made available to everyone, regardless of race. This case involved activism in which an activist lawyer sought to change the law as it was known. This lawyer’s name was Thurgood
Marshall, who fifteen years later would sit as a Justice on the United States Supreme
Court.
Here, legal activism was used to promote equality under the law and is supported by Section One of the Fourteenth Amendment of the United States
Constitution, also known as the Equal Protection Clause, which states that no state can make of enforce any law that limits the privileges or immunities of American citizens, or deny them equal protection under the law.
What, then, was the danger in legal activism such as this? Is it more dangerous to let the law stand still and create tension between two groups of citizens. If an activist lawyer had not argued the case of Brown v. Board of Education, segregation may still be present in our law and our society would have suffered further as a result of racial inequality. In the landmark Supreme Court decision in Roe v. Wade(1973), activist lawyers, Linda Coffee and Sarah Weddington won women the right to choose whether or not to have an abortion and gave them rights over their bodies. Lawyers are intended to be advocate of those they are representing, and if their client is the people their jobs is to serve society as a whole, and to serve the will of the people and make changes to bad law according to the people’s will. In the past, activist lawyers have brought about many changes in society for the betterment of society as a whole; however, this kind of activism has been in decline. The legal profession is geared more now toward corporations and plaintiffs in lawsuit cases than toward individual rights. This could threaten the law’s objective to bring justice to society (Hadfield, 2000: 343).
It is important for a lawyers to remember that activism is what caused people to revolt against the crown, which resulted in the Revolutionary War, and ultimately,
American independence. Without activist lawyers, many of the liberties women and minorities enjoy today may have never come to be. If there aren’t those of us committed to devoting our lives to being advocates for change then democracy is only a charade.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Intenet

...Radhika Nataraj MA131235 The article in The Economist, ‘The new politics of the internet: Everything is connected’ gives us a brief overview into the world of internet activism and how it has been shaped into a political movement protesting several issues and how it has created a forum for free speech and innovation globally. The article traces the development of net activism in relation to the environmental movements of the 1960s and 70s. It also elaborates on the role of the internet as a platform in the anti-SOPA protest , the creation of ‘pirate parties’, and discusses the impact and construction of the net activism movement. In contrast to this article, Astra Taylors ‘How the internet is transforming from a tool of liberation to one of oppression’ on the Huffington Post, deals with how search engines, social media and other networked technologies earn wealth and power by constantly surveying internet activity of an individual. Taylor talks about how internet users are viewed as ‘targeted customers’ and explains how ‘more clicks equal more money’ in the article. The article in the Economist quoted Barry Commoner who said, “The first law of ecology is that everything is connected to everything else”. This quote is especially relevant to the internet which is basically a networking technology connecting people and their interests globally. In the 1960s and 70s, varied issues like cleaning the Hudson river and banning nuclear tests, came together to form a single, powerful...

Words: 1551 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Pepsi and Coke Case Study

...5) How can Pepsi and Coke confront the issues of water use in the manufacture of their products? How can they defuse further boycotts or demonstrations against their products? How effective are activist groups like the one that launched the campaign in California? Should Coke address the group directly or just let the furor subside? Pepsi and Coke should have responded faster to the concerns of the general public. The companies formed committees within India and the United States to work on legal and public relations issues. They commissioned their own laboratories to conduct tests and waited until the results came through before commenting in detail. Their approaches backfired. Their reluctance to give details fanned consumer suspicion. If the companies acted faster to the situation when it first came to light, the could have spared a lot of grief. Pepsi and Coke can defuse further boycotts by speaking directly to the cause of the boycott/demonstration or by allowing demonstrators to investigate their product themselves. The activists groups have proven to be very effective in their efforts. Fear campaigns (like the ones assembled in California) can do a great deal of damage to the brand. They are even more effective when the people targeted are not in the country being referred to as in this case (America/India). They are unable to use their own judgement to dismiss the campaign. Moreover, Coke should address the group directly in order to sort out any misunderstandings as...

Words: 255 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Gender Discrimination

...| Israelis mark anti-McDonald's dayProtesters rally across nation to mark international anti-McDonald's day; activists claim fast food chain harms environment, exploits workers and tortures animalsOrna Yefet Published:  | 10.16.05, 15:54 / Israel Business | | share | Activists throughout Israel demonstrated Sunday afternoon to mark international anti-McDonald's day, by staging protests, presentations and other activities across the country.    This annual demonstration, which has taken place for the past 20 years, aims to protest the fast food chain's destruction of the environment, exploitation of workers, and the torture and killing of animals, activists say. The activists say the protests will focus on the destructive influence of consumer culture and corporate control over our lives.   Protest against MacDonald's (Photo: Courtesy of Indimedia Israel ) | The organization for the liberation of animals in Israel (ALI) and the coalition against McDonald's have partnered together to form a unified front to fight the for the common cause.  Activities against the corporation already began Friday in Tel Aviv, where activists resorted to street theater to protest. They also presented a gallery of photos showing cruelty to animals, harm to the environment, and issues pertaining to workers' rights. Free T-shirts and vegan food were also handed out and stands were constructed to supply information and pamphlets. Later, protesters led a rally past the fast food branches in the center...

Words: 455 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Abortion

...Extremist Anti-Abortion Group 1 Gandhi is reported to have said, “there are many causes that I would die for yet there is not a single cause that I would kill for”. Ghandi's words have the ring of a distant past when the ideals of social and political activism maintained a common sense. Today, terrorists around the world are willing to kill and die for causes that seem unclear and often contradictory. This new method of violence reflects the politics of the anti-abortionist movement that is willing to kill to save lives or willing to die to become enshrined as a martyr. Terrorism is defined by the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) as "...a violent act or an act dangerous to human life, in violation of the criminal laws of the United States, or of any state, to intimidate or coerce a government, the civilian population, or any segment thereof, in furtherance of political or social objectives" ("Terrorism 2000/2001"). The violent faction of the anti-abortion movement certainly fits this description. It is a form of war that is being waged against the domestic social structure with wide ranging implications. The violent anti-abortion groups are a contradiction of values and the extremist motivations behind them make it a dangerous and terrorizing movement. Literature Review Understanding the motivation behind the anti-abortion terrorism is an important step in curtailing the violence. The movement is an oxymoron where killing takes place to save lives. The...

Words: 1440 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Psychology

...28 February 201 In the recent months, the country of Ukraine has been experiencing an intense state of political unrest, the first in many years. The decision of the Ukrainian president to deny political ties to the European Union stirred a lot of controversy within Ukraine. The controversy inevitably divided the country into two groups, those who are pro democratic and support ties to the European Union, and those who support the already deep-rooted political ties with Russia, which is the government and its forces. The conflict intensified as months passed, and violence between the two groups became an issue. By analyzing this current event, the psychological elements of situational attribution, conflict, and deinviduation, can be applied to both sides of the situation in Ukraine to justify their actions and behavior. The conflict in Ukraine arose when the president of Ukraine, Viktor Yanukovych, denied a trade pact offered by the European Union. As a result of the action taken by the president, pro democrats who urged the ties to the EU protested in Independence Square of Kiev, while authorities attempted to suppress them. As the conflict intensified with no solution being brought to the table, aggressive pro democrat protests resulted in a clash with authorities in independence square on February 19th . Surrounding buildings were set on fire, rocks were thrown at riot police, and activists were being shot dead. The fighting between the mostly masked activists and...

Words: 893 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The Other 99%

...On September 17th, 2011, New York City’s Wall Street financial district became home to the first Occupy Protest. That morning several thousand people gathered in the streets of New York City. Upwards of 100 people set up camp later in the evening in Lower Manhattan’s Zuccotti Park, owned by Brookfield Office Properties (van Gelder). The Occupy Protesters were opposed to the expansive wealth gap between the nation’s wealthiest 1% and the remaining 99% of lower to middle class citizens. Before long, protesters began calling themselves “the 99%”. What began as a barely organized endeavor quickly became a global media sensation. In next to no time at all, Occupy Protests began taking place not only in other cities in the United States, such as Boston and Chicago, but all over the world. Protesters emerged in Asia, Latin America, and Europe, all united under the opposition of big banks, corporate greed and economic inequality (Stelloh). In the weeks following the beginning of the Occupy Wall Street demonstration, protesters slept in sleeping bags in Zuccotti Park, constructed greywater systems, started a meal service operated by volunteers, and utilized the bathroom facilities of nearby businesses. Some members of the protest opened their homes to fellow demonstrators for the purpose of taking care of their personal hygiene needs. On October 6th, 2011, Brookfield Office Properties stated that sanitation was becoming a major concern and one week later Mayor Bloomberg and...

Words: 1565 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Disney Case

...Case Study: Disney’s America Theme Park 1. From a government relations perspective, key issues that Eisner must consider include the following: a. Support and opposition for the project was bipartisan. Debate among the House, Senate, and Governor largely focused on financial matters, including how budget resources were to be allocated for road construction. b. Opposition focused mainly on Disney’s choice of the Manassas site, and not the issue of whether the theme-park should come to Virginia. Responding to Disney and Allen’s projections of job creation, opponents argued that employment was already low in northern Virginia relative to the rest of the state. c. Activists with different reasons for opposing Disney’s America united behind the single, common cause of fighting suburban sprawl. The defeat of a developer’s plans to construct a shopping mall in the 1980s was testament to their grassroots capabilities. d. The Piedmont Environmental Council spearheaded efforts to protect the site from development. e. The Manassas Battlefield Park had long been a point of controversy involving those who wish to preserve its historic integrity. Preservationists in the 1980s were already successful in preventing the development of a similar Marriott Co. theme-park near Manassas. f. Vocal opponents included prominent historians, namely David McCullough (a Pulitzer Prize winning biographer and narrator of a public television series on the Civil...

Words: 295 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Dbq Essay On The Grassroots Movement

...The grassroots activism is not a group of people who are on places looking for violence, grassroots activist is crowd of people fighting for something to be truly believed by them reaching out to establish a change. A grass root activist is one who sets out their minds to make a change as betterment for one’s self or others being affected by the same problem. Grassroots activism contributed to changes in public policy and influenced the success of the civil rights movement after World War II by creating a national view of the racial division in the south, starting boycotts and protest in favor of desegregation and creating equality, and having forming programs to help involve African Americans in the U.S government. The Civil Rights Movement...

Words: 1072 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Revie of Sean Mills' "The Empire Within"

...Review of SEAN MILLS’ "The Empire Within: Postcolonial Thought and Political Activism in Sixties Montreal" "The following people are to be released from their captors. In Northern Ireland, the seven members of the New Provo Front. In Canada, the five imprisoned leaders of Liberte de Quebec. In Sri Lanka, the nine members of the Asian Dawn movement…” (Die Hard) There is no doubt that Sean Mills would have felt a flash of amusement at this mention of the (incorrectly identified) FLQ, uttered by super-villain Hans Gruber in his list of demands, in 1988's Die Hard, lumped together with other such revolutionary entities. Indeed, in The Empire Within: Postcolonial Thought and Political Activism in Sixties Montreal, Sean Mills attempts to argue that revolutionary trends and theories in various regions of the world made their way across the globe, bypassing borders and mutually influencing the areas that they managed to reach. More specifically, his intention is to analyze this notion with respects to the situation in Montreal during the 1960's and early 1970's. He does so after outlining three purposes which his work aims to address. Firstly, Mills states his desire to bring about an alternative way of observing Montreal's "political upheavals" during the aforementioned time period, whereby events on an international scale are taken into account. Secondly, he wishes to make clear the ways in which the ideas of various groups and movements were inter-linked and influenced...

Words: 926 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Jesuit Ideals

...finding God in all things. This pursuit began in similitude to a famous poem by Khalil Gibran of a seeker’s quest for God “In the ancient days, when the first quiver of speech came to my lips, I ascended the holy mountain and spoke unto God, saying, ‘Master, I am thy slave. Thy hidden will is my law and I shall obey thee for ever more.’ But God made no answer, and like a mighty tempest passed away.” I also struggled in finding God in my life, it was difficult to see past the grime of poverty and suffering. The answer came in helping those in greater need than me. The scale and impact didn’t matter as much as a passion for humanitarianism. Goodness in action rather than in thought and began what would become a lifelong passion for community activism. I worked with refugees and displaced persons, volunteering for a government agency to provide them with daily necessities. After immigrating to America I found my calling in a local nonprofit organization whose mission statement reads “to help women in need regain their strength emotionally and financially for a stronger family”. The organization was a means for me to help others who had gone through the same emotional, financial, and cultural problems as they attempted to shape their lives in America. It wrought an inner peace and self-satisfaction in helping shape brighter lives with women I could strongly identify with. This inner peace led to an inner realization of God, only by the power of action inspired by an Islamic tradition...

Words: 717 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Art Activism

...Art activism is the practice of vigorous action as a means of creating political or personal goals by use of art. The type of activists practicing now varies greatly, from street artists to conceptual sculptors. Regardless of the medium, everyone has a common purpose for his or her work—attempting to create awareness and change. Embracing the creative nature of humans, artists send messages using visual content; forcing viewers to not only look but also feel the passion within them. The movement of advocacy is considered a phenomenon throughout the 21st century—demonstrating that your voice can be heard around the world if you shout loud enough. Conditional to the period in history, the description for art activism has been constantly evolving. Art activists first gained attention in the early 20’s when World War I began. Notable painters and sculptors from around the world came together to protest against the bourgeois ideologies they believed led to war. Referred to now as the Dadaist Movement, artists organized public gatherings, demonstrations, and publication of art and literary journals to protest the 'reason' and 'logic' of their conservative capitalist society. Marcel Duchamp—a popular multi-media artist, initiated one of the more infamous stories of his time when he submitted a store bought urinal, Fountain, to a annual high-society exhibition for the Society of Independent Artists. Because all artists were commissioned by the society, there was no jury for the...

Words: 1009 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Service: a Duty? a Benefit? or Both, or Perhaps Neither?

...Jenna Mentus Andrew Calis English 102, Section 61 Short Write 3 Control is the key, to take the victory! This is often heard at high school and middle school sporting events, a cheer chanted by the cheerleaders. This cheer though, is often true when it comes to American politics. Through out the years, we hear of congressmen, supreme court judges, and governors resigning from office. Then we are faced with the question, why? Could it be because they really do want to spend more time with family and enjoy life? Political experts, like Dan Schnur, seem to think not. Instead, Schnur suggests in “The Problem With the Middle Ground” that former politicians, such as Bart Stupak, are too much of “moderates” for government. Schnur’s argument is that once either party gets the vote of moderates and obtains power, the use of moderates is no longer needed. Schnur’s use of pathos in his article is much underlying. It isn’t until the end of his article we feel anything. He ends with, “That’s why Senator Arlen Spector is now a Democrat, why Senator Evan Bayh is not running for re-election, and why Bart Stupak is about to become a former member of Congress.” He provides us with the many examples of moderates who are either no longer needed, or have had to change their views completely. Each of these men stood firmly for causes, favored and rejected by both parties. Once either party gained control, they had no use for the moderates. The pressure from Congress and social groups cause...

Words: 493 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Bba Program

...------------------------------------------------- Jahurul Islam  ahurul Islam (1928-1995) businessman, entrepreneur and social activist was born in Bhagalpur village of Bajitpur thana under Kishoreganj district on 1 August, 1928. Jahurul Islam began his career as a contractor. He established Bengal Development Corporation which over time grew into a great construction company.He could foresee the housing problem in Dhaka in near future as a result of its very fast population growth and urbanisation and development spree and in 1964 he established the first real estate organisation in the country namely Eastern Housing Ltd. He later established 'Islam Group'. Since then Islam Group has diverged into multidimensional sectors including engineering, construction, trading and even manufacturing. The group, over the years, concentrated in other sectors including pharmaceuticals, textiles, jute, ceramics, media, real estate, finance, construction and agricultural sector. Through the variety of his concerns, Jahurul Islam has shown diversified thinking capability that no one in his generation possessed. His unique way of thinking and leadership also resulted in Islam Group to be one of the leading industries in Bangladesh. Besides being good businessman, he was also a humanitarian. He founded Jahurul Islam Medical College and Hospital, for the betterment of the country. Although the institute officially began in 1992, the hospital service started as early as 1989. It had...

Words: 314 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

The 99% Fight Back

...Wall Street (OWS) is an evolving succession of demonstrations in New York City taking place in Zuccotti Park in the Wall Street financial district. The protests were introduced by the Canadian activist group Adbusters which mainly protests social and economic inequality, corporate greed, corruption and influence over government and lobbyists. The protesters’ trademark, “We are the 99%”, refers to the difference in wealth and income growth in the U.S. between the richest 1% and the remainder of the public. In the middle of 2011, the Canadian-based Adbusters Foundation, suggested an amicable occupation of Wall Street to formally complain about the corporate weight on our democracy, focus on a growing imbalance in wealth, and the vacancy of legal consequences behind the recent global financial dilemma. Senior editor of Adbusters said it was without delay adopted by all the people of the world. Adbuster’s website claims that from their “one simple demand—a presidential commission to separate money from politics—we start setting the agenda for a new America.” They publicized the event with a poster presenting a dancer on top Wall Street’s famous Charging Bull statue. The internet group Anonymous promoted that its followers take part in the protests, asking participants to overflow lower Manhattan, prepare tents and kitchens along with peaceful barriers and to simply occupy Wall Street. Other groups soon joined in the organization of the protest. The mix includes Hacktivists Anonymous...

Words: 720 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Coke vs Pepsi in India

...Case 1-3 Coke and Pepsi Learn to Compete in India Tyler McBee MKT 3450- 01 17 September 2013 3. Both Pepsi and Coca-Cola have effectively attempted to accommodate their products to the tastes and preferences of India. As an advertisement and sponsorship method, both companies have partnered with cricket, movies, and music. These three entertainment industries are very popular in India. Something that has set Pepsi and Coca-Cola apart from other companies in the food industry is partnering with religious and other festivities. Serving or sponsoring events like Navratri makes a huge impact on society’s eyes causing them to see Coca-Cola and Pepsi as socially responsible companies. Pricing policies in India is difficult to work with, because of the restrictions by the government. Pepsi has had a leg up on Coca-Cola because of their early entry into the industry. Obviously they have had better reactions from consumers because Pepsi seems to care, simply because it reached to smaller villages and different communities than Coca-Cola; in consumers’ eyes this appears that Pepsi just cares more. 5. An idea to help with their water issues within each company’s plants is to recycle water. If water is needed to run a machine or make a certain ingredient for the finished product and the water isn’t contaminated or altered by any way, why not reuse it? I believe that Coca-Cola approached the retalaliation of the water issue with a bad attitude. A foreign company such...

Words: 601 - Pages: 3