Free Essay

Legal Aspects of Life Support

In: Other Topics

Submitted By vdavis2k
Words 572
Pages 3
Legal Aspects of Life Support In "Legal Aspects of Withholding and Withdrawing Life Support from Critically Ill Patients in the United States and Providing Palliative Care to Them," authors John M. Luce and Ann Alpers, present this article to increase an understanding of the legal obligation of physicians and practitioners.
Studies have shown that most patients, who die in intensive care units in the United States, deaths are related to the withholding and withdrawal of life support and also the administration of palliative care. The process through which various medical interventions are withheld or removed from patients with the expectation that the patient will die of an underlying illnesses is withholding and withdrawal of life support. The prevention or treatment of pain or providing comfort during suffering in terminally ill patients is palliative care. Physicians and practitioners are bound by ethical principles of autonomy, beneficence, and nonmaleficence. This means their actions are done for the benefit of others and they must do no harm.
There are laws that govern the legal aspects and requirements of these practices in which physicians and other practitioners may not be familiar. The limitations of life sustaining treatments vary from each state and are based on statutory and case law. The Fourteenth Amendment to the Constitution protects a competent person’s right to proceed with treatment which includes nutrition and hydration. The legal aspect of withholding and withdrawing life support is legally justified by informed consent and informed refusal in the United States. These principles state that the approval of the patient or surrogate is needed in order for treatment or refusal to be initiated. The only exception to this principle is in an emergency situation. Another legal aspect of withholding and withdrawing life support is futility, which refers to interventions that are unlikely to produce any significant benefit for the patient. In some cases involving futility, courts have intervened when the families choose treatment and the physician opposes treatment. In this case, the legal rule required to measure a physician’s treatment decision against the standard of medical care is the malpractice test.
The legal aspect of providing palliative care was and approved by the Supreme Court. Courts set guidelines so that no healthcare professional is permitted to assist with a suicide. The Pain Relief Promotion Act of 1999 was drafted by Congress to promote pain management and palliative care without allowing assisted suicide. This act allows physicians to administer sedatives and analgesics to dying patients, which could increase the risk of death, but it prohibits intentionally administering controlled substances for the purpose of assisted suicide.
In satisfying the legal requirements, the Pain Relief Promotion Act can still be challenged in that it interferes with state’s rights. One positive outcome for physicians and practitioners is that the bill has been supported by the American Medical Association. The withholding and withdrawal of life support and the administration of palliative care usually involves the physician and other practitioners and all parties should be involved in the planning of treatment. Physicians and practitioners should always act on what they believe to be in the best interest of their patient.

Works Cited

Luce, John M, and Alpers, Ann. “Legal Aspects of Withholding and Withdrawing Life Support from Critically Ill Patients in the United States and Providing Palliative Care to Them.” American Journal of Respiratory Critical Care Medicine vol 163 (2001): 2029-2032 http://ajrccm.atsjournals.org/content/162/6/2029.long

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Ethical and Legal Issues in Nursing

...Ethical and Legal Issues in Nursing NUR/391 Ethical and Legal Issues in Nursing As nurses, it is our duty to advocate for our patients. At times, we are faced with personal and professional challenges that impact how and when we chose to advocate. It is imperative we have a healthy awareness of these potential challenges. Improvements in health care technology have provided patients with an array of treatment options as well as assumed or possible increased chance of survival. As a result, nurses are met with a rise in ethical decision making. This paper will discuss the legal, ethical, social, and personal factors that can impact our decision making process, with the focus on two specific case studies. American Nurses Association Code of Nursing Ethics Role in Practice The American Nursing Association (ANA) has created a set of ethical standards for the profession of nursing to abide by, which is entitled the ANA Nursing Code of Ethics. The ANA Code of Ethics states that collaboration is central to the care nurses deliver and to their ethical commitment to the patient (Garity, 2005). In the end-of-life case study, the nurse (she) has an unwritten obligation to the patient; the family appears to be in conflict with how to proceed with the patient's medical treatment. The medical team has an obligation to give the family all of their options and possible outcomes. If the family remains in conflict, it would then be appropriate for her to refer the family to...

Words: 1859 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Ethical and Legal Issues in Nursing

...Ethical and Legal Issues in Nursing Team C NUR/391 Ethical and Legal Issues in Nursing Nurses face various ethical and legal issues in the medical setting. As professionals, nurses must be aware of these legal and ethical issues when they occur. Nurses have a legal and ethical obligation to respond to these issues. Being a professional nurse requires a nurse to assess the pros and cons of different situations, but also to withhold their personal beliefs and listen and respect the beliefs and traditions of others. Legally Nursing implications require nurses to maintain licensure, obey state and federal laws and to remain within their scope of practice. Within these legal and ethical issues the American Association Code of Nursing ethics, personal and societal values, legal aspects and legal responsibilities all affect decisions. Two different cases will be discussed and explored; an advance directive case involving a woman by the name of Marianne, and a malpractice case involving a nurse and the involved healthcare organization. The American Nurses Association Code of Nursing Ethics can influence the final decision made in the case study involving Marianne’s family by designating a surrogate. According to "American Nurses Association" (2011), “The nurse supports patients self-determination by participating in discussions with surrogates, providing guidance, referral to other resources as necessary, and identifying and addressing problems in the decision-making...

Words: 1826 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Cost Of Euthanasia

...Killing: The Psychological Cost of Learning to Kill in War and Society. Boston: Little, Brown, 1995. Print. Dave Grossman takes a close look at the fundamental process of taking another humans life and the affects it takes on the persons psyche. His experience as a former Army Ranger, West Point psychology professor, and currently the director of the Killology Research Group. This experience is shown in the writing as he notes the shift in our views as a people of taking a life from ancient history to the views on the topic in our current population. The focus of this book is more on the military side of killing and instinct aversion but draws in the effect of media and...

Words: 1239 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Case Report on the Live Case Study “Euthanasia”

...accept by labelling it as the ultimate truth of life. However, the ethical issue we have taken up is about death which is induced before time. The background setting for our live case is the very debatable issue of “Euthanasia”. Literally, euthanasia means “Good Death” (Greek: eu = good, thanatos = death). More formally, euthanasia means the intentional act or practice of painlessly putting to death persons suffering from an incurable and distressing disease as an act of mercy, which is not necessarily at the request of the patient. Forms of Euthanasia: • Voluntary euthanasia: When the patient has requested the death. • Non-voluntary: When the patient has not made any request and gave no consent. • Assisted suicide: Someone provides an individual with the information, guidance, and means to take his or her own life with the intention that they will be used for this purpose. When it is a doctor who helps another person to kill themselves it is called "physician assisted suicide." • Euthanasia by Action: Intentionally causing a person's death by performing an action such as by giving a lethal injection. • Euthanasia by Omission: Intentionally causing death by not providing necessary and ordinary (usual and customary) care or food and water. Euthanasia evokes a mixed reaction among people who come across it. For some, it is unimaginable to end a human life and yet some think it is justified to end a life which is not worth of dignity. There are several...

Words: 2423 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Euthanasia

...euthanasia claim that the concern for happiness and human life and not their obliteration is the objective of any good governance. They say that the terminally ill are people who require protection from social, economic and family pressures, and who are particularly prone to this pressure as a result of chronic depression, pain and effects of continued medication. Arguments for euthanasia say it is impossible to maintain quality of life if a patient is dead. While there have been massive arguments, debates and campaigns against euthanasia, this paper will seek to support euthanasia because of the moral issues that relate to the topic. This paper supports that when a personal is physically dead, the only reason anybody wishes to keep them alive is for their selfish clinging onto them with the hope of a miracle and the fear of closure without regard to the wishes of the person. It supports the practice of euthanasia and seeks to evaluate the reasons why euthanasia should be legalized. This paper will have a general audience because of the controversy that it sparks every time it comes up Death is a dreaded subject for all human beings because it signifies leaving the known to go to the unknown. This is the reason why by its nature euthanasia is a hugely hushed up topic where most people cannot determine whether it is mercy killing, or killing against a person’s will. This paper will useful for those in the medical and the legal profession where there has been heated debate on...

Words: 1514 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Professional Knowledge & Abilities

...is the ability to discover and implement ideas or have a good balance between work and private life. Success by definition is the favorable outcome of something attempted. These favorable outcomes are a product of the professional knowledge and abilities gained through research and affiliation with professional organizations and associations in fields of study that will broaden one’s scope of interest and aid in career success. One such professional association is the American Bar Association. The American Bar Association (ABA) is the biggest volitionary professional association. “With nearly 400,000 members, the ABA provides law school accreditation, continuing legal education, information about the law, programs to assist lawyers and judges in their work, and initiatives to improve the legal system for the public” (American Bar Association, 2011, para. 1). The mission of the American Bar Association is to be the national representative of the legal profession, serving the public and the profession by promoting justice, professional excellence and respect for the law. The ABA contributes toward increasing ones professional knowledge and abilities in numerous ways. The American Bar Association’s mission statement reads, “To serve equally our members, our profession and the public by defending liberty and delivering justice as the national representative of the legal profession” (American Bar Association, 2011, para. 1). Its first goal is to...

Words: 599 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Issues in Psychological Testing Worksheet

... Issues in Psychological Testing Worksheet Using the text for this course, the University Library, the Internet, and/or other resources answer the following questions. Your response to each question should be at least 200 words in length. 1. What are at least two ethical issues associated with psychological testing? What impact do these issues have on the field of psychological testing? One issue, concerning ethics in psychological testing, is obtaining informed consent. This means that prior to the test the subject must be advised of the purpose of the test, procedures that will be used, duration of the test, and the subject must ascertain that he or she fully understands all aspects of participating in the test (American Psychological Association, 2010). A parent or legal guardian must give consent on behalf of any underage participant, or handicapped individuals. Informed consent is meant to protect both the researcher and the participants; it is an ongoing agreement in which the participant may withdraw from at any time during the testing (Hogan, 2007). Confidentiality can be another major ethical issue surrounding psychological testing. Psychologists are governed by ethical codes to withhold information concerning a participant’s test results outside of the appropriate context (Hogan, 2007). Psychologists are also to maintain and protect records, as to prevent records from being shared with inappropriate parties. Confidentiality is so important that...

Words: 831 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Business Operations

...investment and Legal Planning with estate and elder law and elder care health issues. Our goal is to make sure our clients not only enjoy their retirement but stay in retirement. The company principals are to provide exceptional customer service with dignity to our clients. We provide this element of service by starting the relationship with our clients by focusing on what their life goals are. We feel that by helping better define their goals and what steps need to be taken to accomplish them, it brings purpose to their investments, assets and lifetime of hard work, which goes beyond just the idea of growing your money with no end in mind or purpose. We also strive to find creative ways to give back to our communities we live and work in. We feel it is our responsibility to give back to the communities that support us and assist the less fortunate. We have tried to focus a lot of our marketing towards giving to charities and helping our clients give towards causes that are close to their hearts. During the year we have chosen certain causes to donate towards as our clients will give us a referral or donate a percentage of sales towards these causes. We feel that marketing campaigns like this help spotlight our purpose and morals towards supporting humanity and the spirit of a better life. The company I work for is a Limited Liability Company (LLC). The brand name that most of the marketing is gear towards is the comprehensive planning firm for financial, legal and tax planning...

Words: 1274 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

“the Hazards Presented by Volcanic and Seismic Events Have the Greatest Impact on the World’s Poorest People.” to What Extent Do You Agree with This View?

...to decide whether the defendant’s guilty act caused the required consequence of the crime. The defendant’s actions must have caused the consequence; if not there is no criminal liability. There are two types of causation, which are: factual causation and legal causation. With factual causation the defendant can only be guilty if the consequence would not have happened ‘but for’ the defendants actions. This can be seen in ‘R v White’ where White put poison cyanide in his mother’s drink intending to kill her, but she died due to a heart attack. Another way of looking at this is if the consequence would not have happened if the defendant had not acted. In ‘R v Pagett’ the defendant used his girlfriend as a human shield while he shot at armed police, they returned the fire and the woman died. Pagett was guilty of manslaughter as she would not have died but for his actions. Once there is a factual cause there must be a legal cause. This is so that the defendant can only be convicted if he is guilty. The link between the act and the consequence is the chain of causation, and must not be broken if there is to be criminal liability. The operating and substantial cause is the key for legal causation and has several different aspects to consider. One is that the original injury must be the operating and substantial cause. This can be shown in ‘R v Jordan’ where the victim was stabbed, a week later fully recovered and then received an injection from the doctors that killed him and,...

Words: 431 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Nursing : Career Development

...Position Statement Introduction Nursing is a call to serve the humanity. Present day healthcare system focused on preventive care and wellness has become highly advanced which makes every nurse responsible to achieve maximum level of education, skills and power of knowledge to meet the challenges. Continuous research in nursing and the evidence obtained from the research serves to support the nursing care. Continuing education helps nurses to keep track of all the developments taking place in the field, trace advances in technology and care, have a better understanding of all current rules and regulations, beware of all ethical and legal aspects of nursing as envisaged by various boards of nursing and other authorities in the field of healthcare. In this paper, I would like to explain the position statement of career development in nursing. It is only through proper and continued education that nurses can provide patients better care, assess and report what is best for the patient and always seek ways to improve patient outcome. In order to achieve the best results, nurses need to identify the core knowledge, scientific principles, skills and attitudes of nursing practice to improve healthcare system (International Council of Nurses, 2007). Therefore career development must be achieved by integrating care through our scholastic system, giving nurses opportunity to learn, grow and move up the ladder, making them capable of leading from the forefront. Career Development...

Words: 2144 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Euthanasia

...EDUCATION AND TRAINING LEGAL AND EThICAL IssUEs Of EUThANAsIA: ARGUmENTATIvE EssAy Bilal S. H. Badr Naga Majd T. Mrayyan (1) Bilal S. H. Badr Naga., MSN, RN, Prince Sultan Cardiac Center in Qassim, Saudi Arabia (2) Majd T. Mrayyan., Prof, RN, The Hashemite University, Jordan Correspondence: Bilal S. H. Badr Naga., MSN, RN, Prince Sultan Cardiac Center in Qassim, Saudi Arabia Email: Bilal_badrnaga@yahoo.com Case scenario Abstract Euthanasia is one of the issues that has been the subject of intense debate over time. It has been a pertinent issue in human rights discourse as it also affects ethical and legal issues pertaining to patients and health care providers. This paper discusses the legal and ethical debates concerning both types of euthanasia. It focuses on both the supporter of euthanasia and the opponent of euthanasia. Several statements for the Euthanasia argument arediscussed: a merciful response that alleviates the suffering of patients which is sometimes wrongly perceived to be otherwise unrelievable; the autonomy in which the patient has the right to make his own choices; the regulation and legislation of existing practices of euthanasia to protect health care providers and patients. In this heated debate religious, political, ethical, legal and personal views are also included. Among all these, those who desperately want to end their lives because they simply cannot go on in any way, are the ones who suffer. Every individual or group has a different viewpoint...

Words: 7058 - Pages: 29

Free Essay

Singhania & Partner Case Study Report

...Singhania and Partners sustain the effectiveness of people management policies with increasing competition? I think the CEO is worried about what they pay rather than the HR policies per se. Be more specific PESTC Analysis  Political and Legal:       Economic liberalization by the government of India. LPG (liberalization, privatization and globalization) by GOI gave a fillip to foreign investment and subsequently, legal services industry. Foreign law firms are not allowed to set shops in India or practice Indian law. Imminent liberalization of legal service industry which will increase competition. Law firms were prohibited to directly market their services. Legal system was very slow.  Economic:       High growth market for legal services. Availability of highly skilled capital at competitive prices. Growth of LPO (legal process outsourcing) industry providing a boost to legal services. Huge market for legal services in the US accounting for 49% of the global industry. Arbitration opportunities in India provided a market for legal services. Growth in the IT and infrastructure sector giving a fillip to legal services.  Social:  Lack of educational and vocational opportunities for the people to develop their career in legal services industry.  Inclination of people to make out-of-court settlement due to extended nature of court cases.  Technological:    Use of efficient and state-of-the art system and processes to increase effectiveness of services...

Words: 2138 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Benefits of Dehydration in the Terminally Ill

...and caring. The giving of food is often considered to represent compassion in the minds of most people. It is not surprising that the issue of withholding artificial hydration and nutrition is such a heavily debated topic. To make a more informed decision, patients and/or family members need to be educated about the benefits, legal, and ethical considerations of dehydration in the terminally ill patient. Literature supports that forced hydration during the end of life is of little benefit and may actually worsen a patient’s condition. Dehydration in the terminally ill can be a very therapeutic treatment. The deterioration of the terminally ill patient coincides with no longer having the ability to take oral fluids or nutrition. Dehydration is usually characterized by thirst, dry mouth, decreased skin turgor, decreased urinary output, and electrolyte imbalance. However, not all patients who are terminally ill and not medically hydrated exhibit these signs and symptoms (Vaz, 2010, p.1). This suggests that dehydration in the terminally ill is different than in the acutely ill patient. Dehydration has potential benefits for the end-of-life (EOL) patient. Benefits of dehydration in the terminally ill include perhaps, the most important issue to families, patients, and caregivers concerning the dying patient which is comfort. Dehydration is often incorrectly considered painful. Printz (1992) reported that “patients in end-stage dehydration experience less discomfort...

Words: 1273 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Society Should Not Play God

...most controversial topics in the world today is assisted suicide. There are many aspects of this subject that could be discussed. However, the most argued aspect of assisted suicide is whether it should be legal or not. Some people think assisted suicide should be legal to help put terminally ill individuals out of their misery, while others believe assisted suicide should be outlawed because it contradicts morals and religion. Assisted suicide should be legal because it is morally right to help others die the way they want to. Assisted suicide occurs when a doctor decides to help, or assist, a patient in suicide, usually by prescribing patients medication. One of the most common drugs used by doctors is sleeping pills. The doctor will give the patient sleeping pills and direct the patient to take an excessive amount of them. This ensures that the patient passes away as peacefully as possible (Welsh-Huggins). Many doctors that assist in suicide use pentobarbital, which is a very strong sleeping aid. This pill is always available for prescription use, but very few doctors prescribe it due to the numerous amounts of deaths associated with it. This is part of the reason why many doctors use pentobarbital for assisted suicide. When this medication is taken in excess it ensures a peaceful death while sleeping. Passing away peacefully while sleeping is another reason why assisted suicide should be legal. Some believe that assisted suicide is ideal for patients who are terminally ill...

Words: 1333 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Legilize Marajuana

...Legalize Marijuana I think that making marijuana (Cannabis) legal makes a lot of sense in a time when tobacco and alcohol products are available to citizens all the time when the right age. Sometimes I question why there is such argument about the thought of making marijuana legal. Legalizing the sale of cannabis could do a lot of good for the economy is facilitating more jobs in the United States. The legal sale of Cannabis could be a positive thing for the government with a tax on the sale of it. For a drug such as Cannabis to be illegal I would think it should have more harmful causes than helpful. Of course, as with any kind of change you have arguments for both sides on way it should be approved. I think it has more positive than negative effects. Nonetheless, marijuana does less harm than tobacco and alcohol products. In some cases I have seen marijuana be medically helpful. The benefit with using marijuana for medical reason is, it alleviates the pain, and calms them down so they can appreciate the rest of their life. For these terminally ill patients the marijuana also makes them enjoyable and happy to be around. Marijuana should be made legal for several reasons. Some of those reasons are medical, tax benefits for the government and it would remove the need for to illegally sale it and would reduce crime rates. Marijuana does less damage to a person’s body than the currently sold tobacco and alcohol products already sold in the U.S. In fact sucking Helium causes...

Words: 1024 - Pages: 5