Free Essay

Legal Memorandum

In: Other Topics

Submitted By kelisha97
Words 1294
Pages 6
Legal Issues for Jane Asylum Case
Kelisha Marshall
Kaplan University
PA401: Advanced Legal Writing

MEMORANDUM
To: Linda Ashar, Esq
From: Kelisha Marshall, Paralegal
Date: November 13, 2012
RE: Jane’s Asylum Petition |
Statement of Facts
Jane is only 14 years-old, she is neither a citizen of the United States nor a dual citizen of any other country. For six years Jane’s parents have shared full custody and parental rights. Jane would spend the school term with her father, John, in Quebec and school breaks and holidays with her mother, Anne, in New York. Halfway through the school break in New York, Jane telephoned her father stating she wanted to come home early. Her father encouraged her to get along with the mother until break was over. Two days after this incident, Jane left her mother’s home and never returned. Upon Anne’s arrival to her home that evening she listened to a message left by Jane stating she hated them both and was going to live with her Uncle Billy in California. John also received the same message. Rushing to the airport in effort to stop Jane, Anne was killed in a car accident. Now Jane is in California with her uncle and refuses to return to Quebec with her father.
Issues
Does Uncle Billy have the authority to apply for petition of asylum on behalf of Jane?
Does Jane herself have the authority or right to apply for a petition of asylum in regards to the alleged exposure of being a propaganda tool?
Has time elapsed for the processing of an asylum petition due to Jane being back and forth for so many years?

Rules of Law In trying to address these issues we must first determine the rights of the clients and what Jane’s classification will fall under.
According to Universal Declaration of Human Rights:
Article 14. * (1) Everyone has the right to seek and to enjoy in other countries asylum from persecution. * (2) This right may not be invoked in the case of prosecutions genuinely arising from non-political crimes or from acts contrary to the purposes and principles of the United Nations.
This rule as read does not seem to discriminate against age.
Article 25. * (1) Everyone has the right to a standard of living adequate for the health and well-being of himself and of his family, including food, clothing, housing and medical care and necessary social services, and the right to security in the event of unemployment, sickness, disability, widowhood, old age or other lack of livelihood in circumstances beyond his control. * (2) Motherhood and childhood are entitled to special care and assistance. All children, whether born in or out of wedlock, shall enjoy the same social protection.
Pursuant to the 8 USC § 1158 - any alien who is physically present in the United States or who arrives in the United States (whether or not at a designated port of arrival and including an alien who is brought to the United States after having been interdicted in international or United States waters), irrespective of such alien status, may apply for asylum in accordance with this section or where applicable 1225(b) of this title.
Due to Jane being a minor it should be established if she is an unaccompanied minor or minor principal. A minor principal is an applicant under the age of 18 at the time of filing. An unaccompanied minor is an applicant under the age of 18 and who has no parent or legal guardian in the United States who is available to provide and physical custody. This definition encompasses separated minors, e.g., those who are separated from their parents or guardians, but who are in the informal care and physical custody of other adults, including family members. Note that a child who entered the U.S. with a parent or other adult guardian but who subsequently left the parent’s or guardian’s care would be considered an unaccompanied minor. For purposes of the unaccompanied minor definition, guardianship refers to a formal (legal/judicial) arrangement. If the parent is deceased and there is no legal guardianship arrangement, the child would be considered unaccompanied.
If all the terms of the custodial agreement are correct in saying that Jane has been between Quebec and the United States for the last 6 years, then it is possible that her time limit has been reached to file a petition for asylum. Per the following: 8 USCS 1158 § Asylum (2)(B) Time limit. Subject to subparagraph (D), paragraph (1) shall not apply to an alien unless the alien demonstrates by clear and convincing evidence that the application has been filed within 1 year after the date of the alien's arrival in the United States. On the other side of this law, the next section may lend a helping hand to the fear of future persecution.
In determining Jane’s fear of potentially returning home to her father the following is stated:
CFR § 1208.13 Establishing asylum eligibility.
(a) Burden of proof. The burden of proof is on the applicant for asylum to establish that he or she is a refugee as defined in section 101(a) (42) of the Act. The testimony of the applicant, if credible, may be sufficient to sustain the burden of proof without corroboration. The fact that the applicant previously established a credible fear of persecution for purposes of section 235(b) (1) (B) of the Act does not relieve the alien of the additional burden of establishing eligibility for asylum. (B) The applicant could avoid future persecution by relocating to another part of the applicant's country of nationality or, if stateless, another part of the applicant's country of last habitual residence, and under all the circumstances, it would be reasonable to expect the applicant to do so.

Analysis
In order for it to be deemed suitable and lawful to file a petition of asylum, many requirements have to be met especially with a child. Although Jane is stated she fears going back to Quebec, you can’t rule out the information of knowing, she actually asked to go back days before her departure of New York. With regards to Uncle Billy, the law will possibly hold him at no regards, because Jane still has a legal parent that is capable of caring for her. In Chen v. Gonzales 439 F.3d 109, 111 (2d Cir. 2006), the courts became aware of the BIA’s failure to respond to the reports Chen made available in order to corroborate his story. In Jane’s case, some type of proof besides her word of mouth would have to be established, to corroborate her story of future persecution. Just noting her father’s affiliations in Canada, does not warrant the alleged allegations of physical abuse and usage of her being a separatist tool.

Conclusion
Based on the facts supplied, I do believe Jane can file a petition for asylum. As an unaccompanied minor, she will have to bear the burden of proof for all the alleged allegations, unless the Attorney General finds to need to corroborate. Also seeing that she does have a living relative in the United States, she can possibly be granted a stay in California until the petition is either approved or denied, depending on the evidence required. I think it’s important to understand that everyone has the right to file for an asylum petition, if the eligibility requirements are met. The more in-depth process of this filing comes after that, which is looking into the history of claims, time frame and proving persecution. Jane is a teenager, so things can be interpreted differently when in a rebellious state of mind. Proving her fear is true and genuine and not just rebellion is going to be difficult considering all the facts.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Legal Memorandum - Business

...people. The company was started five years ago in Nashville, TN, and has seen steady growth in the United States. Narcissus Denim currently fabricates its denim jeans in the USA, with only some of the materials coming from China. The cost of raw materials and manufacturing domestically have become too expensive, so Narcissus needs look outside of the USA. Narcissus is aware of other creators of designer apparel that have gotten bad press for using the “Made in the USA” label because the brands only make a portion each piece of their apparel in the USA. The purpose of this memorandum is to examine the possibility of bringing to the USA neighbor by working with “Maquiladora”, the Spanish word for manufacturer, in Mexico. Aspects of US law, international legal implications, as well as the ethical implications of moving this portion of the company to Mexico are the primary focus areas of research. Domestic Legal and Ethical Implications: Narcissus Denim was founded and gained success because of the quality of the product, in great part because the apparel is “made in the USA”. In order to create a portion of the product in Mexico and keep the “made in the USA” label, Narcissus Denim must ensure at least a portion of jeans be manufactured in the United States. The Federal Trade Commission is the governing body and requires certain standards be met. These standards are also monitored by the commission, “The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) is charged with preventing deception...

Words: 1750 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Technical Writing

...Technical reports are often prepared for sponsors of research projects. Another case where a technical report may be produced is when more information is produced for an academic paper than is acceptable or feasible to publish in a peer-reviewed publication; examples of this include in-depth experimental details, additional results, or the architecture of a computer model. Researchers may also publish work in early form as a technical report to establish novelty, without having to wait for the often long production schedules of academic journals. Technical reports are considered "non-archival" publications, and so are free to be published elsewhere in peer-reviewed venues with or without modification. A memorandum (abbrev.: memo) was from the Latin verbal phrase memorandum est,...

Words: 1284 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Legal Writing

...LEGAL WRITING Prof. Gajić FINAL EXAM 1. Who can an attorney ask to prepare a brief? _________________________________ 2. Briefs should not be longer than one to two pages long and should be easy to read so that the reader does not have to spend much time understanding the reasoning of the case. T F 3. What are the two most important parts within the heading of internal legal memorandum? 4. The memo should begin with a statement of the issue, which is the legal question that the memorandum addresses. T F 5. The largest portion of the memo is the ______________ section. 6. The last section of the memorandum is the _________________, in which a brief summary of the memorandum is offered. 7. Name a few factors to consider when designing a law office space. What should be considered and offered to clients? _____________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________ 8. Successful interviews require the right __________________ and _____________. 9. Describe a situation in which you are meeting with a client for the first time, how would you behave, approach him/her, guide the interview. _____________________________________________________________________ _____________________________________________________________________...

Words: 254 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Eng 221 Week 2 Individual Assignement Option 2

...The Kudler Fine Food Company will be having new registers installed in three of their stores. This is the main piece of information being communicated in the memo that was sent from Yvonne Reynolds to Brenda Wagner. Based on the criteria of organization, clarity, tone, and style this memo is not a very good example of what a memo should be. The organization of this memo is done in a way that you can understand that they are going to be getting new registers. However, the clarity of the memo makes it difficult to understand. Yvonne informs Brenda that the vendor of the new registers will give some training materials and train the company’s trainer. She then states, “We need to determine the best way to train the cashiers in the three stores, the management team in each store and the computer support specialists.” This makes is confusing to understand who is suppose to be doing the training in the store. It leaves questions as to why the vendor id training someone if it is then up to the stores to find a way to train the employees. The clarity also comes into question when Yvonne says to, “have someone evaluate the various means we could use to deliver the training and make a recommendation of how we should proceed.” This leaves Brenda to try to figure out where to look for someone and to figure out when exactly the training is suppose to happen. The tone and style are on the casual style for a business memo. The whole thing is typed in one paragraph that is not as informative...

Words: 419 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Home Work Week 1

...DATE: January 12, 2012 TO: All Employees of Denver Branch FROM: Leonard Schwartz, Branch Manager SUBJECT: New Loss-Prevention System As you may have recently heard, lately we received news from the corporate headquarters of the company that it would be in the best interest of the entire company to pay more attention to matters of preventing accidents and any other safety-related measures that affect the workplace, including both office and field activities related to all types of jobs that we complete. Every single employee in each office at every branch needs to be ever mindful in this regard so that they are more efficient and effective in the daily performance of their everyday tasks that relate to their job responsibilities so that safety is always of paramount concern. With this goal of safety ever present in our minds, I believe the bottom line of the emphasis on safety could be considered to be the training that each of us receives in his first, initial weeks on the job as well as the training provided on a regular basis throughout each year of our employment with M-Global, so that we are always aware of how to operate in a safe manner. The training vehicle gives the company the mechanism to provide each of you with the means to become aware of the elements of safety that relate to the specific needs and requirements of your own particular job. Therefore, at this point in time I have come to the conclusion in the process of contemplating the relevance of the new corporate...

Words: 633 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Business Memo

...Business Memos A memo, short for the word memorandum, comes from the Latin word memorandus, which means, "to be remembered." It is a compact written message designed to help someone remember something. Unlike letters, the external communications of a company, business memos are an internal form of communication and it is standard practice to save them. Their objective is to deliver information or instructions and writing them in a sensible manner that the information is delivered with more meaningful note and its impact on its reader is also serious. Confined to a single topic, each interoffice, interdepartmental and company - wide memo becomes part of the institutional memory of an organization. They record daily activities and eliminate the need for time-consuming meetings. As historical documents they are often referred to when writing reports or resolving disputes regarding past activities. In short, they speed up the daily business of doing business; they keep people who need to be kept in the know, in the know. When a business organization designs an official letterhead it often also designs an official memo sheet, complete with a company logo featured at the top of the page. Besides having a professional look and feel, preprinted memo sheets often provide specialized information fields that accommodate specific procedures for expediting in-house communications. Memos Types 1. Informational Memos 2. Instructional Memos Informational Memos is an in-house...

Words: 4308 - Pages: 18

Free Essay

Memo

...Memorandum To: Management and staff of O’Charley’s From: Jacqueline Kinuthia Date: 7/28/2014 Re: Overhead Cost Confidential Problem: Over the past three months, the company has exceeded its proposed budget for this quarter. Most locations have reported an increase in associates’ turnover rate. The problem has a common key factor caused by under staffing. During the complete exit interview, most associates cited total burnout during their work shifts. An attempt to remedy this problem has been unsuccessful. New associates hired to correct this problem of maintaining a full staff at all shifts have turned most locations into a revolving door as the problem persists. Analysis: Each location has a set budget for hiring and retention of associates. A planned orientation for new associates is detailed, time consuming, and costly. During this training period the new associates are usually over burdened with filling in for an absent associate. In most cases the orientation is interrupted resulting inadequate training and education. Essential skills such as learning to deal with and handle difficult customers are not relayed. Proposed Solution: To improve the hiring and retention at these locations, the district managers held several meetings with their fellow associates. During the open forum, associates proposed ways to improve their workplace to make it more favorable. Most of the ideas proposed ranged from having uninterrupted work breaks, having a buddy system, an incentive...

Words: 278 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Memo Template

...MEMORANDUM Heading Segment The heading segment follows this general format: TO: (readers' names and job titles) FROM: (your name and job title) DATE: (complete and current date) SUBJECT: (what the memo is about, highlighted in some way) Make sure you address the reader by his or her correct name and job title. You might call the company president "Maxi" on the golf course or in an informal note, but "Rita Maxwell, President" would be more appropriate for a formal memo. Be specific and concise in your subject line. For example, "Clothes" as a subject line could mean anything from a dress code update to a production issue. Instead use something like, "Fall Clothes Line Promotion." Opening Segment The purpose of a memo is usually found in the opening paragraph and includes: the purpose of the memo, the context and problem, and the specific assignment or task. Before indulging the reader with details and the context, give the reader a brief overview of what the memo will be about. Choosing how specific your introduction will be depends on your memo plan style. The more direct the memo plan, the more explicit the introduction should be. Including the purpose of the memo will help clarify the reason the audience should read this document. The introduction should be brief, and should be approximately the length of a short paragraph. Context The context is the event, circumstance, or background of the problem you are solving. You may use a paragraph or a few sentences to establish...

Words: 724 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Request for Funding Memo

...Memo To: Edward Nelson, Executive Director From: Tabatha Monroe, Librarian Date: Monday, September 10, 2012 Subject: Request for Professional Development Funding I am writing this memorandum to request Kaplan College to sponsor a Business Writing course that I wish to enroll in at the University of Miami. I spend a fair amount of time at work communicating via emails, notes, letters, and reports and many of these documents are read by our internal and external customers. And I believe that a Business Writing course will improve not only my job skills, but productivity as well. In my current position as a librarian, I am responsible for communicating with students, faculty and staff members, publishers, and vendors about academic issues on a daily basis using email, memos, and reports. I also compose, edit and publish user guides with instructions on how to access and use various library resources. And I annually submit a report that provides details on how the learning resource center is complying with federal and SACS regulations. By focusing on the particular types of documents that I use on a daily basis, this course will help me to improve the skills needed to write and edit business documents that are concise, correct, and clear. This course will assist me in developing my business writing skills that will allow me to better meet the needs of this organization through effective communication. After this course, my productivity will increase...

Words: 446 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Business Memo

...MEMO To: All Departments From Thrit Tuachob, Director of Human Resources Date: July 13, 2015 Subject: Revisions to Employee Wellness Program Because of the company’s rapid growth and because of continuing developments in the field, even employees with advanced scientific training are having trouble keeping up with new developments. EBG wants all employees, whatever their position, to be able to discuss with customers, at least in a basic way, the scientific concepts behind the company’s products and services. Beginning six month from now, January 13, 2015. EBG will offer basic, intermediate, and advanced courses in reading, writing, and math. Basic Program Overview The courses will be offered during work hours, employees will be paid for the time they spend in class. Books will be provided. Progress in these courses will be taken into account in employees’ quarterly performance reviews and annual salary reviews. There are some requirements and information for this course * Managers will evaluate employees and may recommend that employees take one or more of these courses. * Employees can choose to take a course or courses without their manager’s recommendation. * Homework and studying must be done on employees’ own time. Reimbursement Programs Employees who are beyond these basic courses but who need help in keeping up with scientific developments related to their work are encouraged to take courses at local universities, using...

Words: 357 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Date: January 12, 1996 to: All Employees of Denver Branch from: Leonard Schwartz, Branch Manager Subject: New Loss-Prevention System

...DATE: January 12, 1996 TO: All Employees of Denver Branch FROM: Leonard Schwartz, Branch Manager SUBJECT: New Loss-Prevention System As you may have recently heard, lately we received news from the corporate headquar­ters of the company that it would be in the best interest of the entire company to pay more attention to matters of preventing accidents and any other safety-related measures that affect the workplace, including both office and field activities related to all types of jobs that we complete. Every single employee in each office at every branch needs to be ever mind­ful in this regard so that he is most efficient and effective in the daily performance of his everyday tasks that relate to his job responsibilities such that safety is always of para­mount concern. With this goal of safety ever present in our minds, I believe the bottom line of the emphasis on safety could be considered to be the training that each of us receives in his first, initial weeks on the job as well as the training provided on a regular basis throughout each year of our employment with McDuff, so that we are always aware of how to operate in a safe man­ner. The training vehicle gives the company the mechanism to provide each of you with the means to become aware of the elements of safety that relate to the specific needs and requirements of your own particular job. Therefore, at this point in time I have come to the conclusion in the process of contemplating the relevance of the new corporate...

Words: 640 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Science

...The writing in college composition classes and the workplace both rely upon Selected Answer: Correct a) organization & clear expression. Correct Answer: Correct a) organization & clear expression. Question 2 4 out of 4 points The three basic parts of a document in transactional writing are Selected Answer: Correcta. message-support-closure. Correct Answer: Correcta. message-support-closure. Question 3 0 out of 4 points How many functions of external and internal correspondence does your text identify? Selected Answer: Incorrect a) two Correct Answer: Correct b) three Question 4 4 out of 4 points Another word for template is Selected Answer: Correct c) macro. Correct Answer: Correct c) macro. Question 5 4 out of 4 points How many key types of basic communications from an institution to an individual does your text cite? Selected Answer: Correct d) three Correct Answer: Correct d) three Question 6 4 out of 4 points Collection letters, like other transactional communications, are constructed to get the desired Selected Answer: Correct b) result. Correct Answer: Correct b) result. Question 7 4 out of 4 points The three forms of business letters discussed in the text are Selected Answers: Correct Full Block Correct Semi-block Correct Simplified Correct Answers: Correct Full Block Correct Semi-block Correct Simplified Question 8 4 out of 4 points The correspondence that conveys information inside a single business...

Words: 776 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Memo 1

...Engineering-Masters, Inc. MEMORANDUM Date: Wednesday, July 1, 2007 To: Harold Johnston From: Isabel Higginbot Subject: Procedure for Handling Payroll Advances ------------------------------------------------- There is a new procedure (to reflect updated policies) for obtaining payroll advances. I believe that our employees will find an improvement over the old, confusing procedure. The new procedure is as follows: Procedure 1. Obtain Form PR-7, Request for Payroll Advance, form your supervisor. 2. Complete the form by filling in all the blanks in the Employee Section of the form. 3. Have your immediate supervisor approve your request by signing on the Supervisor Approval line. 4. Take the approved Form PR-7 to the receptionist in the Payroll and Benefits Office, Building Z, Room 1620. 5. Pick up your check from the cashier’s office, Main Building, Room 201 three working days after turning in Form PR-7. You must have your employee identification card with you to receive your check. 6. Sign the receipt form in the presence of the cashier’s office clerk. Policies The following policies govern the issue of payroll advances: 1. Payroll advances may not total more than 80% of an employees normal net pay for a payroll period. 2. Except in the case of a documented emergency, payroll advances are limited to one every two months. 3. Don’t try to cheat the system we will catch you every time. 4. Honesty is the best policy...

Words: 252 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Memorandum Example

...------------------------------------------------- MEMORANDUM TO: Mr. Sanjiv Sidhu FROM: Mr. Emmanuel Morin SUBJECT: Potential strategic threats, new IT developments, improved vision ------------------------------------------------- DATE: 10/16/12 INTRODUCTION i2 Technologies currently has a strong position in the industry market, excelling in innovation, industry knowledge, and IT methodology. Yet, there are strong potential threats in the form of IT development that can weaken i2’s position in the future. This memo proposes potential strategic threats that may develop over the next decade and key IT developments that may be overlooked. This memo also suggests an improved vision regarding the future business path of i2 Technologies. PROPOSED STRATEGIC THREAT One of the key strategic threats i2 may face in the next decade is the IT development of its competitors. SAP’s ERP, for example, is currently the leading competitor for i2. Although ERP’s focus is different to i2’s supply chain planning, SAP has the capability and the resources to expand its services to match SPC. This expansion can significantly reduce i2’s market share. It is important that i2 leverages its differentiation strategy within the SCM optimization to prevent competitors from increasing in market power. KEY IT FUTURE DEVELOPMENTS OVERLOOKED Technology is always changing and companies are finding new ways to make their operations...

Words: 455 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Project Budget

...Project Budget Marie Harper CMGT/410 October 13, 2013 Joel Erickson Project Budget BUSINESS MEMO IT TRAINING OUTLINE INTRODUCTION: There should be a method which has to be used for training as well as a method should be created together with that method. For both of these ways to achieve success, training resources should not be wasted. To make sure that resources would not be undermined, a lot of problems must be resolved. The organization policies, infrastructural problems, as well as social problems within the company may all require to be noted prior to a properly oiled training session can happen. It is, nevertheless, worth noting that irrespective of the scheme selected for training, the route must be clear for the users. The training which the users will need will depend on their background, the objective of the training, attributes of the system, any kinds of latest user interfaces, and so on. This task is an explanation for a demonstration provided by a combination of HR as well as IT experts, streamlining organization policy and procedures, for a company-wide conformity system. The training will be put into practice by the head office, along with training to be implemented in a central location. This will be favorable to all of the other satellite offices, making them effortlessly accessed by the administrators who will be attending the training classes. Training will be located on the Central Office site, to reduce training expenses. The training...

Words: 1078 - Pages: 5