Free Essay

Legal and Professional Implications in Nursing

In: Science

Submitted By Biju007
Words 1077
Pages 5
The Legal and Professional Implications of an incident witnessed during clinical placement.

This paper highlights an incident that occurred during a clinical placement. It will also address any legal or professional issues that surround it. Any details of the patient or institution have been withheld to maintain confidentiality. This is in line with the Nursing and Midwifery Council (NMC) Standards of Conduct Performance and Ethics for Nurses and Midwifes (2008).

Mr John Jones had suffered a stroke and had severe difficulties with swallowing (Dysphagia). He was unable to take in any fluid or medicine orally. These had to be given via a Pecutaneous Endoscopic Gastrostomy (PEG) tube into his stomach. Mr Jones was aware of his treatment. However, during a shift a newly qualified nurse (NQN) tried to administer John’s medicine orally despite John’s refusal to accept the treatment. John was extremely upset and distressed by the nurse’s actions and verbally refused to take the drug orally. The drug was also documented to be given via the PEG tube. The incident was then witnessed by a more senior nurse who then administered the medication correctly.

This incident outlines several issues concerning legal and professional accountability. According to Dimond (2011) ‘Accountability’ is defined as how far a person can be held in law to account for their actions. This seems an appropriate definition to give because a person who has to answer to the law then has a vital responsibility. Griffith & Tengnah (2008) however points out a distinct difference between ‘accountability’ and ‘responsibility’. A responsibility means a nurse can control the way they practice. Accountability on the other hand means they are answerable to a higher authority for their practice. Dimond (2011) tells us that every nurse is accountable to criminal law, civil law, the NMC and his/her employer. A nurse who conducts a criminal act could be held into account by all four bodies or one authority only.

The NMC (2008) as a single body regulates the standards required of every nurse in accordance with legal and ethical boundaries. This is primarily via the Professional Code of Conduct, Performance and Ethics for Nurses and Midwives (2008). A principle standard as outlined by the NMC is that every nurse owes a duty of care to all patients. The duty of care was defined in the case of Donoghue v Stephenson (House of Lords) (1932) in Dimond (2011). In this case a manufacturer was found to owe a duty of care to a customer. The customer had already drunk a bottle containing a decomposed snail. Lord Atkin concluded a duty of care existed because the manufacture should have taken reasonable care to avoid injuring his customer.

This concept can be equally applied to nursing because a nurse owes a duty to care for their patients. Dimond (2011) highlights the fact that the duty of care has become a significant part of the law but how it is established has received much debate. In a recent case Kent v Griffiths and others (2000) in Dimond (2011) the difference between who is owed a duty of care was established. The case confirms the fact that nurses in providing care owe a duty to the patients they are nursing. This is upheld by the NMC (2008) in that the law will find a nurse to be ‘negligent’ if they have carelessly caused harm to a patient. Brazier (2007) and Herring (2008) also agree that the nurse has a legal duty to meet the professional standards.

Whilst administering John’s medicine it seems the NQN failed to meet several professional standards. She did not follow the policy guidelines as outlined by her employer to safely administer the drug (appendix 1). She also failed to adhere to the NMC (2008) guidance for medicine management. In which standard 8 states, the nurse:

‘Must have considered the dosage, weight where appropriate, method of administration, route and timing and must also ‘Be aware of the patient’s plan of care’.P.7

The NQN did not meet the criteria as outlined above and committed a drug error even though she had to abandon administering the drug (National Patient Safety Agency (NPSA) 2011). It is also very likely that she was unaware of John’s plan of care as she seemed to overlook his difficulty swallowing. If this is the case the NQN disobeyed NMC guidance along with the regulations of the Disability Discrimination Act (1995) in Carvalho et al (2007). The act mentions it is unlawful to discriminate against anyone with a disability. The nurse should have considered John’s dysphagia and put the provisions in place to administer his drug safely.

This is of crucial concern because if the nurse had not been stopped when trying to administer the drug she could have caused John to suffer serious harm or physical pain. Groher & Crary (2010) confirm this that John could suffer aspiration if he had taken the drug orally. It is therefore easy to see that it was vital for the nurse to consider John’s safety and identify the correct route for his drug administration. In failing to do so she disregarded the legal directives of the Medicine Act (1968) in Heffner & Lawson (2010) and the NMC (2008) standards for medicine management. It seems unclear as to why the NQN committed this error.

Kelly et al (2010) and Kelly & Wright (2009) however offer a reason for why the error took place. They find dysphagic patients become the victims of drugs errors due to the inexperience of staff. It seems plausible the NQN might have lacked the experience needed to administer the drug. However the NMC code of conduct (2008) states the nurse should work within their own level of competency. This means then that although the nurse had been stopped by a more senior nurse she should have asked for the assistance directly. This might mean that professionally due to her lack of competence her ‘fitness to practice’ is questioned.

The NMC (2008) defines ‘fitness to practice’ as the nurses suitability to be considered for or to remain on the nursing register. If the NQN is referred to the NMC because her fitness to practice is questioned she might deal with an investigation, a suspension or removal from the professional nursing register. With this however the NMC (2008) also states that ‘lack of competence’ might be an issue if over a prolonged period of time the nurse makes continuous errors. Legally the NQN might face allegations for negligence.



Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Legal Principles In Nursing

...Legal principles Nurses like other healthcare professionals need to practice according to a complex web of federal and state statutes – while making decisions in an ethically responsible manner. Nurses tend to consider the ethical implications of their decisions to ensure their actions are in the interest of their patients and do not cause harm. At first glance, it may seem that making these decisions should be straightforward, but many situations are not clear-cut, and there are times when what seems legal is not ethical and vice versa. The nursing, legal principles fall on the licensure, federal and state laws, the practice scope and the expectation of professionalism. Their license and nursing standard offers a framework that stipulates...

Words: 1115 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Applying Framework Into Practice Health Care October 9, 2011 Health care professionals are exposed to a mass of professional, legal, and ethical responsibilities which call for special judgment to be employed in such a manner as to safeguard an individuals as well as public wellness and interests. Considerations in managing such responsibilities may be considered the respect of an individual’s autonomy, confidence, and acknowledgement of responsibilities owed to all individual. The above-mentioned acts fall within the professional jurisdiction; there are legal repercussions that direct care. As a result, it can be said that ethical respects transpire in remark of legal responsibilities. According to the Encyclopedia of Nursing & Allied Health, confidentiality is the right of an individual patient to have personal, identifiable medical information kept private; such information should be available only to the physician of record and other health care and insurance personnel as necessary. With ethics playing an essential part in the groundwork of nursing, a break of confidentiality can have ethical consequences fluctuating from individual’s uncertainty, legal implications, and other inadvertent results. Difficulties on the subject of the exemption to the obligation of confidentiality come under the imprecise description of public distress and awareness. Which increases ethical dilemmas as to who a nurse is obliged to protect? Nursing duties include prevention of disease, the......

Words: 1131 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Assisted Suicide

...Supreme Court declared that the prohibition in section 241(b) of the Criminal Code on assisting with suicide is unconstitutional to the extent that it prevents physician-assisted death for “a competent adult person who (1) clearly consents to the termination of life and (2) has a grievous and irremediable medical condition (including an illness, disease or disability) that causes enduring suffering that is intolerable to the individual in the circumstances of his or her condition.” In creating this exception, the Carter decision represents a profound change to Canadian law. Nurses may now expect to receive more questions from patients and their families related to end-of-life care. It is important for nurses to understand the law and professional nursing standards relating to end-of-life care as they currently exist and as they may develop. The Carter ruling will take effect on Feb. 6, 2016. The Supreme Court suspended the operation of its ruling to allow the federal government time to consider its response to the judgment. The federal government has several options: invoke the Charter section 33 “notwithstanding clause” to suspend the operation of the Carter ruling for five years; amend the Criminal Code, section 241(b), to align with the Carter ruling; or do nothing. If the federal government chooses the latter, the Carter ruling will be the law in Canada. Provincial and...

Words: 1295 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Application of Theory

...Application of Nursing Theory Nurses have to make numerous decisions on a day to day basis. Some are simple decisions and other issues are more complex and require guidance to make decisions. Nursing theory is one way for nurses to make decisions based on problems or situations they face. As Cody (2003) states, “one learns to practice nursing by studying nursing theories” (pg. 226). This statement can be applied to problem solving and decision making. By using theory, nurses can apply concepts to solve problems, since practice is derived from theory. It is also noted by Cody (2003), that “nursing practice will be transformed to the betterment of humankind when all nursing practice is fully autonomous and guided predominantly by nursing theory” (pg. 230). This includes all aspects of nursing including nursing leadership, nursing education, nursing informatics and health policy. The middle range nursing theory of nursing intellectual capital is one that was developed to understanding how nursing knowledge within healthcare organizations influences patient and organizational outcomes (Covell, 2008). It is comprised of two mutually supporting concepts of nursing human capital and nursing structural capital. Nursing human capital is influenced in the workplace by nurse staffing and employer support for continuing professional development and is directly related to patient and organizational outcomes. The nursing structural capital is directly related to patient outcomes......

Words: 1829 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Patient's Decisions

...1) Introduction – a. Thesis statement -- However, if the patient is irrational or uninformed, it could have profound implications for the health care professionals treating the patient, and they could end up in court if they do not have the proper documentation of consent. 2) Argument – a. The patient has the right to fee will with their own mind and body. b. Religious reasons may be a larger deciding factor to refuse. c. One's cultural norm is not the same as another's and there for treatment cannot be forced. d. Irrational patients, their guardians, and treatment. e. Specific case examples. 3) Counterargument – Examples of invalid arguments. 4). Response. a. Examples to prove the argument valid. 5) Conclusion. Patient Decisions Not to Treat The purpose of this paper is to introduce and analyze the topic of patient decisions on the health care professional. Specifically it will discuss whether a patient's irrational decision to refuse treatment is binding to a health care professional. A patient's consent to treatment has become a thorny issue in the courts and in the nation's health care facilities. A patient has the right to refuse medical treatment for moral, religious, or cultural reasons. However, if the patient is irrational or uninformed, it could have profound implications for the health care professionals treating the patient, and they could end up in court if they do not have the proper documentation of consent. ......

Words: 1949 - Pages: 8

Free Essay


...JUSTICE AND DIVERSITY WORD COUNT 3846 Introduction The aim of this assignment is to consider whether mental health patients have autonomy or do staff and the healthcare environment merely allow them a measurable quantity of autonomy based on legal, ethical and moral restrictions, if this is the case, is this autonomy at all? Placement experiences will be given in relation to patient autonomy and related ethical, legal and professional issues will be supported and/ or contrasted by relevant literature. Patient autonomy and capacity, consent, compliance, coercion and paternalism with be considered. In an attempt to show a deeper understanding and ability to apply theory to practice, the moral theories of liberal individualism, utilitarianism, Kantianism and communitarianism will be discussed in relation to patient autonomy. Attitudes, values, assumptions related to patient autonomy, implications for practice and care provision will also be reviewed. This topic has been chosen, due to personal interest following practice experiences on an adult acute mental health unit. All identifying factors relating to the patients have been changed to maintain client confidentiality (Nursing and Midwifery Council’s (NMC) Code of Professional Conduct 2002). A conclusion will be offered to evaluate findings, finalising with a reflective summary focusing on the process of enquiry. Autonomy Autonomy means self rule (Dworkin 1988). It as the ability to think, choose and act freely and......

Words: 4615 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Nvt2 Task 1

... In the case study, the nurse is facing ethical as well as professional dilemma regarding the patient’s rights. The nurse’s role in this case study is to, work according to the Maryland state regulations and nursing standards; But as per Maryland nursing standards, she is not working as an advocate for her patient, Mr. E at this situation (Code of Ethics - the Division of State Documents, The patient already signed advanced directive against life saving measures almost seven years ago, at the time of admission to a nursing home, with the help of patient advocate; but Dr G. is planning patient care in opposition to Mr.E’s active advance directive and his expressed objections to the medical care. There are numerous issues to consider in this case study. The nurse has to review her professional role according to code of ethics and nursing standards in relation to advance directives and medical power of attorney. The nurse also has to consider the patient’s right to privacy and confidentiality according to HIPPA Policy. The issues in contemporary healthcare facilities are sometimes the statues can be vague, and issues can be in conflict with own personal beliefs in most areas. A) State Regulations and Nursing Standards of practice There are specific Maryland state regulations and nursing standards regarding patient rights in this case study. However, the most relevant regulation is that, the......

Words: 3104 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Concept Analysis of Empowerment

...concept we all have heard at one time or another it is utilized in numerous professions and specialties. Analysis of this concept will further understanding of empowerment for nursing professionals in areas from research, theory development or practice. Exploring the attributes, consequences, implications and model cases of empowerment can assist the nursing professional in utilizing empowerment to its fullest potential. Within the scope of nursing, empowerment can be seen not purely as how it relates to the client, or the nurse but also how it relates to both the client and the nurse (Rodwell 1996). The Walker-Avant method was used to analyze this concept, as it was the most commonly seen in nursing literature (McEwen & Willis, 2007). Aim This paper’s aim is to clarify the concept of empowerment and its implications for the nursing profession, by exploring how it pertains to nursing as well as other disciplines, its essential attributes, antecedents, consequences and empirical referents. Definition What is empowerment, and what does it mean? American Heritage dictionary defines empowerment as “To invest with power, especially legal power or official authority” or “To equip or supply with an ability; enable”. defines it as “to give power or authority to; authorize, especially by legal or official means” or “to enable or permit”. Synonyms for empower include capacitate, entrust, permit and privilege according to Rogets Thesaurus. Understanding......

Words: 2470 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay


...National competency standards for the registered nurse Introduction • • returning to work after breaks in service, or • National competency standards for registered nurses were first adopted by the Australian Nursing and Midwifery Council (ANMC) in the early 1990s. The ANMC was a peak national and midwifery organisation established in 1992 to develop a national approach to nursing and midwifery regulation. The ANMC worked in conjunction with the state and territory nursing and midwifery authorities (NMRAs) to produce national standards – an integral component of the regulatory framework – to help nurses and midwives deliver safe and competent care. educated overseas seeking to work in Australia involved in professional conduct matters. The National Board may also apply the competency standards in order to communicate to consumers the standards that they can expect from nurses. Universities also use the standards when developing nursing curricula, and to assess student and new graduate performance. The ANMC officially became the Australian Nursing and Midwifery Accreditation Council (ANMAC) on 24 November 2010. The name change reflected ANMC’s appointment as the independent accrediting authority for the nursing and midwifery professions under the new National Registration and Accreditation Scheme (the National Scheme) that came into effect on 1 July 2010 (18 October 2010 in Western Australia). These are YOUR standards —......

Words: 5094 - Pages: 21

Premium Essay

Reflective Account on Role as a Student in Higher Education and as a Future Health Practitioner

...will be able to apply to improve nursing care outcomes concerning patient care, quality standards, and other nursing skills. In this respect, graduating from a nursing program will offer me the opportunity to be a better healthcare practitioner and work within teams for the best outcomes. In fact, the higher education knowledge base that I will acquire upon graduation will make me more attractive to employers. In this case, employers will trust me with more responsibilities since I will know more about the patients’ overall conditions, work independently with minimal supervision, actively engage teams, and even make leadership decisions with regards to the direction that the care plan will take (Oermann 2015). As a result, the higher education program for nurses will make me more attractive to employers and enable me to get jobs with more responsibilities, work independently with minimal supervision, work within teams, and occupy leadership positions that come with the duty of decision-making. I have embarked on many endeavours in my life, but I believe that attending higher education at UWL has been the most rewarding as well as challenging mission. Not only have I gained valuable academic knowledge, but I have also learnt communication skills and how to apply them for the best outcomes in group settings. In fact, I already understand that hard work and optimism (qualities that did me well in my eleven years as a health care assistant in nursing homes for the elderly) even......

Words: 1706 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Professional Ethics

...Running head: PROFESSIONAL ETHICS Professional Ethics Paper Patrick Kelley University of Phoenix Health Law and Ethics NUR 478 Susan Lawson, RN, MS, CLNC July 18, 2010 Professional Ethics Paper The purpose of this paper is to describe the relationships between legal and ethical issues, identify personal values and professional ethics, examine ethical theories and principles, and apply these to current practice examples. Nurses face an ever-growing complexity within their practice as professionals. Understanding the relationship between legal and ethical issues and how to apply that understanding to every day practice is paramount for today’s professional nurse. This paper will further explore these ethical theories and principles while discussing how personal values affect an individual’s nursing practice. The Relationship Between Legal and Ethical Issues Nurses, as with any job, face challenges in order to accomplish the tasks of their role. This is one of the reasons that it is important to have a description that serves as guidance as to how the role is to be accomplished. Without such guidelines, it is likely that there will be a breach of established rules along the way to performing duties and accomplishing the job duties. In situations where one person exercises authority over another, there are important guidelines that define relationship between the two parties. Legal and ethical......

Words: 2093 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Analysis of an Ethical Dilemma currently illegal due to many ethical implications. Euthanasia is an ongoing ethical dilemma that affects nursing as a profession, has legal implications, and stirs up ethical debates over social values, morals, and norms. “Standard 7, under the heading “Standards of Professional Performance,” reiterates the moral obligation of the nurse to practice ethically and to provide care “in a manner that preserves and protects healthcare consumer autonomy, dignity, rights, values, and beliefs” and “assists healthcare consumers in self determination and informed decision-making”” (ANA position statement, 2013). Nurses in all healthcare related settings play a key role in patient care at end-of –life. Nurses’ care for the physical and spiritual needs of patients and their families while, also collaborating with all members of the interprofessional healthcare team. Nurses witness the devastating effects of life-threatening diseases. It is difficult to balance amongst saving a life and the enabling of a dignified death. Nurses need to keep their own feelings in check because they could have an influence on clinical decision making. “It is within the framework of the Code for Nurses and professional standards that nurses make ethical decisions and discharge their responsibilities.” (ANA position statement, 2013) The American Nursing Association (ANA) provides the profession of nursing with a code of ethics to be applied to nursing care. “The ANA prohibits nurses’......

Words: 1173 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Quantitative Reserch Study

...STUDY Quantitative Research Study Knowledge Pressure Ulcer Prevention among Nursing Professionals Jeamol Joseph Grand Canyon University NRS-433= Introduction to Nursing Research 24 July, 2011 Quantitative Research Study Nursing research is a process which helps to improve the patient outcomes through a thorough analysis of data collected and making new contributions to the healthcare field. Evidence based nursing is the process by which nurses make clinical decisions using the best available. In quantitative studies researchers identify the problem and collect relevant data from subjects. The researchers plan in advance the steps to be taken and collect data in numerical form. In qualitative studies, researchers collect narrative descriptions. Data is collected and progression takes place as the research is continuing. Nursing research is systematic search to develop evidence on problems of nursing profession. Now days hospitals deliver higher quality care to critical patients .In hospital settings these patients are more susceptible to hospital acquired infections and injuries. All the institutions have used effective strategies to avoid complications that keep their patient’s safety at risk. Quality improving programs and patient safety committees are available in all hospitals to promote patient safety. Pressure ulcer or bed sores are important problem in hospitals and nursing homes. Pressure ulcers prolong the hospital stay of hospital. They increase the......

Words: 1146 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Nr 360 Complete Course Nr360 Complete Course

...NR 360 Complete Course NR360 Complete Course Click below link for Answer NR 360 Week 1 Discussion Introductions Please introduce yourself to the class. Tell us about your career background, what you like so far about your learning, and something that you’re comfortable sharing about yourself, your family, or your hobbies. NR 360 Week 1 Discussion What Is Nursing Informatics? Discuss ways that nursing informatics could be applied to all areas of professional nursing practice, including clinical practice, administration, education, and research. Provide examples of each. What do you see as the biggest significance of nursing informatics, and why? NR 360 Week 1 Discussion Technology Literacy and Electronic Health Records (EHR) What are your experiences with using an electronic information system (EHR)? Describe the components of an EHR, and using the assigned readings, any past experiences or observations, and your imagination, share your thoughts on the following question: Can you give one pro and one con of an EHR with regard to enhancing patient care and safety? Include rationale for each. How do you see the EHR enhancing patient health literacy? NR 360 Week 2 Discussion Database Search Choose a topic related to health that has meaning to your personal health, interests, and well-being. This may be a disease,...

Words: 1487 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Ethical and Legal Issues in Nursing

...Ethical and Legal Issues in Nursing Team C NUR/391 Ethical and Legal Issues in Nursing Nurses face various ethical and legal issues in the medical setting. As professionals, nurses must be aware of these legal and ethical issues when they occur. Nurses have a legal and ethical obligation to respond to these issues. Being a professional nurse requires a nurse to assess the pros and cons of different situations, but also to withhold their personal beliefs and listen and respect the beliefs and traditions of others. Legally Nursing implications require nurses to maintain licensure, obey state and federal laws and to remain within their scope of practice. Within these legal and ethical issues the American Association Code of Nursing ethics, personal and societal values, legal aspects and legal responsibilities all affect decisions. Two different cases will be discussed and explored; an advance directive case involving a woman by the name of Marianne, and a malpractice case involving a nurse and the involved healthcare organization. The American Nurses Association Code of Nursing Ethics can influence the final decision made in the case study involving Marianne’s family by designating a surrogate. According to "American Nurses Association" (2011), “The nurse supports patients self-determination by participating in discussions with surrogates, providing guidance, referral to other resources as necessary, and identifying and addressing problems in the......

Words: 1826 - Pages: 8