Level 5 Leaders

In: Business and Management

Submitted By Philippe2404
Words 1343
Pages 6
Why was the study conducted?
Jim Collins conducted the study with 22 research associates from 1996 to 2000 to search the reason that “catapults a company from merely good to truly great”. Are there any common features – in particular concerning leadership style - within those companies that had shifted from good results to great performance on the long run? Why other companies failed to reach excellence when others outpace their competitors in a sustainable way? Are their managers sharing common personality traits? Can a good company become a great one and how?

What was the main research question?
The study focus on the leadership traits of the CEO of those few companies which reach excellence, so called “good-to-great” companies. How do they behave? How do they communicate? What are their backgrounds?
Same studies have been made among most of the companies who did not really succeed to clearly outperform their competitors during a long period of time.

How was the study made?
• The first step was to select among the “1435 companies that appeared on the fortune 500 from 1965 to 1995” those who had a specific pattern regarding their performance. The targeted companies were those who had during 15 years stock performance below or at the level of the stock market and from a transition point succeeded to have “cumulative returns” of at least 3 times the market during the next 15 years. It is also important to note that this shift should not be industry specific. These criteria have enabled to select a limited number of 11 companies.
• The second step was to select peer companies, i.e. companies who were acting in a similar field and were comparable in terms of size, age, customers and performance until the transition point than those 11 good-to-great companies but did not have the same success afterwards.
• The third step was to search for qualitative and…...

Similar Documents

How to Become a Level 5 Leader

...How to Become a Level 5 Leader - Part 1 by Carl Robinson, Ph.D., copyright 2004 Jim Collins discovered when analyzing the research for his book "Good to Great," that the leaders who ran the "great" companies during the transition from good-to-great were all "Level 5" leaders. For those of you not familiar with "Good to Great," the qualifying criteria was that a company had to have achieved an average cumulative stock return of at least 3 times the market over a 15 year period. Only 11 of the Fortune 500 companies met all the criteria they used. Collins said that the "data won" when it came to understanding the forces behind all good to great companies. In other words, his findings were derived from hard data not from personal opinion or intuitions about what helped propel a company grow from good to great. "...Level 5 leadership is an empirical finding, not an ideological one." "The good-to-great executives were all cut from the same cloth. It didn't matter whether the company was consumer or industrial, in crisis or steady state, offered services or products. It didn't matter when the transition took place or how big the company. All the good-to-great companies had Level 5 leadership at the time of the transition. Furthermore, the absence of Level 5 leadership showed up as a consistent pattern in the comparison companies..." In a nutshell, Level 5 Leaders "blend extreme personal humility with intense professional will." In a previous executive briefing (Charisma Is No...

Words: 2802 - Pages: 12

How to Become a Level 5 Leader

..., treasure and touch B. Personal Growth With 36 years experience in International Air Transport and wide exposure as the former IATA Regional Director for African Airlines and being a former CEO of two African Airlines, I possess unique skills to provide Business Leadership in today’s turbulent environment. Inspired by a long-standing desire to be a professional entrepreneur, I embarked on the Vision to set up my own organization. Together with several international partners and consultants we were able to design the Leadership coaching business model suitable for my company the Vision Leadership Centre (VLC) now operating in and out of Zimbabwe. Right from the start I realized the need for partnerships with credible organizations in order to guarantee sustainable competence in all aspects of successful e-learning implementation in the Strategic Management and Business Leadership spheres. I am passionately committed to my business and have the realism to make inevitable hard choices. From February 7, 2007 I responded to the call to play my role in the turnaround of Zimbabwe by accepting the appointment as Group Chief Executive Officer of Air Zimbabwe. I see my key role being that of building and supporting Professional TEAMs (Totally Engaged Actually Moving with Speed) and building Leaders of Integrity...

Words: 383 - Pages: 2

Level 5 Leadership

... possess this paradoxical combination of traits are catalysts for the statistically rare event of transforming a good company into a great one. (The research is described in the sidebar "One Question, Five Years, 11 Companies.") "Level 5"refers to the highest level in a hierarchy of executive capabilities that we identified during our research. Leaders at the other four levels in the hierarchy can produce high degrees of shunned attention. When a journalist To explain: Shortly after he took over. asked him to describe his management Smith and his team had concluded that style, Smith just stared back at the scribe the company's traditional core businessfrom the other side of his thick black- coated paper-was doomed to mediocrimmed glasses. He was dressed unfash- rity. Its economics were bad and the ionably, like a farm boy wearing his first competition weak. But,they reasoned, if J.C. Penney suit. Finally, after a long and Kimberly-Clark were thrust into the fire uncomfortable silence, he said, "Eccen- of the consumer paper products busitric." Needless to say, the Wai} Street Jour- ness, better economics and world-class nal did not publish a splashy feature on competition like Procter & Gamble Darwin Smith. would force it to achieve greatness or But if you were to consider Smith soft perish. or meek, you would be terribly misAnd so, like the general who burned taken. His lack of pretense was coupled the boats upon landing on enemy soil, with afierce,even stoic, resolve......

Words: 7858 - Pages: 32


...Leader We know that manager is a person who can manage and control but the main goal of this essay is to tell about the people who could combine first and also be a leader. But I want to tell about the person who is a manager and leader and at the same time an innovator too. China has the most self-made women entrepreneurs in the world, which was validated in the Hurun List of Self-Made Women Billionaires. Zhang Yin also known by her Cantonese name Cheung Yan, is a Chinese entrepreneur and is the richest individual in greater China. She is the founder and director of the family company Nine Dragons Paper Holdings, a recycling company that buys scrap paper from the United States, imports it into China, and mainly turns it into cardboard for use in boxes to export Chinese goods. The company is China's biggest paper maker. Zhang Yin and her husband left for the United States. In America, the enterprise that would become Nine Dragons was born. Because there was a shortage of paper materials in China, her paper trading business was not doing as well as Zhang would have liked. In the U.S., however, she had no such problem. There was plenty of waste paper everywhere she and her husband looked. Zhang set up a system to collect and bundle the paper in America, then send it to China to be processed into usable paper products. Once the waste paper was converted into boxes, cardboard, and other paper products; they were sold. Ironically, although the...

Words: 327 - Pages: 2

Level 5 Leaders

... criteria have enabled to select a limited number of 11 companies. • The second step was to select peer companies, i.e. companies who were acting in a similar field and were comparable in terms of size, age, customers and performance until the transition point than those 11 good-to-great companies but did not have the same success afterwards. • The third step was to search for qualitative and quantitative information, which could explain the performance of the selected companies and their peers: “Articles, interviews, internal strategy documents, financial metrics, executive compensation, management turnover, companies lay-offs and restructurings”. • The fourth step was to identify the drivers of good-to-great transformation and see if there was similar features or traits. Which findings? The study shows that one of the clearest driver for excellence was “Level 5 Leadership”. Indeed there were common traits in the leadership style of CEO of the good-to-great companies that the CEO of other companies didn’t have. Jim Collins called them “Level 5” Leaders. This was not the only driver discovered but one of the most obvious that differentiate those companies who had a tremendous success from the others that only achieve above average results. What distinguished Level 5 leaders from other leaders: They demonstrate a “paradoxical combination of personal humility plus professional will”. They are modest in their personal behavior but willful in professional tasks. They are...

Words: 1343 - Pages: 6

Level 5 Leader

...LA level 5 leader has specific qualities that make them so great. They are stubborn and ruthless but they are humble. Level 5 leaders accomplish great things for their company and never take any credit because they give the credit to their people, luck and external factors. Making their company successful and great is what motivates them. When they leave, they expect their company to be even better. These qualities are what makes a level 5 leader take a good company and turn it into a great company. A transactional leader focuses on structure and process rather than outside the box thinking. Transactional leaders use positive and negative reinforcement to manage employees. Praise and bonuses when employees do well is some positive reinforcements that they use. Reprimands or suspensions when work quality falls or something else goes wrong is some negative reinforcements that they use. Transactional leader are also especially effective in times of crisis. A transformational leader can motivate people to want to change, to improve, and to be led. They do this by being a role model. Transformational leaders motivate people to achieve high standards and challenge people to develop creative solutions. They develop people on individual basis. Transformational leaders are great at aligning the company’s interests with employee needs. Executive A is a level 5 leader. Colleagues describe as driven, fiercely ambitious and entirely focused on the company. He shies away from the...

Words: 566 - Pages: 3

Btec Level 5 Hnd Diploma in Busin

...[pic] Assignment Brief Assignment front sheet |Qualification |Unit number and title | |Pearson BTEC Level 5 HND Diploma Business |Unit 1: Business Environment | |Centre name |Centre number | |Okan Universitesi MYO |90258 | |Student name |Assessor name | | |Can Mindek | |Date issued |Completion date |Submitted on | |28th October 2013 |22nd November 2013...

Words: 1335 - Pages: 6

Statistics Charts Level 5

... the results of table two. The first chart is a bar chart, it displays Government satisfaction levels by age group. The chart is divided into three age groups: 18-35, 35-55 and 55-75. It tells us that more people were dissatisfied than satisfied. Also, the younger group were the most satisfied and the middle-aged group were the least satisfied. The second chart is a pie chart. It represents the satisfied number of age groups. The largest component according to the pie chart is the 18-35 age group at 50%. This equals to 2,000 out of the 4,000 people that were satisfied. The smallest component is the 35-55 aged group at 12%. The third chart is also a pie chart. It represents the dissatisfied number of age groups. The largest component according the pie chart is the 35-55 aged group at 58%. This equals to 3,500 out of 6,000 people that were dissatisfied. The smallest component is the 55-75 group at 17%. Satisfaction Levels by Area These three tables will represent the results of table three. The first chart is a bar chart, it displays Government level satisfaction by areas. It shows us that the urban area is 50/50 with satisfied and dissatisfied. Also the urban area is a lot more satisfied than the rural area. The second chart is a pie chart, it represents the satisfaction levels by the area. The largest component according to the pie chart is the urban area at 86%. This equals to 3,000 people out of the 3,500 people that were satisfied with the government. The......

Words: 607 - Pages: 3

1st Assignment Ilm Level 5

... instruments, and be responsible for the maintenance and safe working use of all machinery used in the decontamination process. All Sterilization departments within Wales must have registration with an authorised body for compliance with the Medical Directive as well as ISO9001; ISO13485, registration is subject to annual audits to provide evidence that the department is meeting the organisation managements requirements are being met as well as the department meeting the European legislative requirements Contents Page 3 Page numbers: 1. Title page 2. Purpose of assignment 3. Introduction (myself) 4. Essay No 1; Describes the Goals & objectives of my organisation 5. Example (a. How my organisations Goal & Objectives shall be met 6. Example (b. How Goal & Objectives shall be met 7. The differences between Managers and Leaders 8. ABM Health Board Mission statement Part 3 Describes the specific responsibilities of middle managers in enabling my organisation to achieve its goals. Part 4 Analysis & Conclusion Page 4 Our Purpose, Strategic Aims and Priorities The Health Board has structured its 2013/2014 Final Draft Annual Plan into a series of Strategic Aims and Priorities based on its stated purpose. Below shows how these link together to provide a clear thread from the Health Board Purpose to the planned actions within this year’s plan to achieve the Strategic Aims, Goals & Objectives. Purpose 5......

Words: 5556 - Pages: 23

Business Environment Level 5 Unit

... stakeholders. (12 (b) Explain one model that a business could use to monitor its external business environment. Use examples to support your answer. (8 (Total 20 End of Section B Maximum marks for Section B: 20 EITHER: Q6 (a) (b) OR: Q7 (a) (b) Explain why monopolies act in an uncompetitive way and discuss the impact this may have on consumers and other business organisations. (14 marks) Describe ways in which governments try to control monopoly power. (6 marks) (Total 20 marks) Assess the role of pressure groups and lobbyists on the business objectives of food manufacturers. Give examples to support your answer. (15 marks) Discuss ways in which ICT can increase the effectiveness of pressure groups. (5 marks) (Total 20 marks) EITHER: Q8 ABC Computing Ltd is an ICT firm which is operating in an environment with a high degree of technological change. Discuss the implications of rapidly changing technology on this company’s activity. (20 marks) OR: Q9 Your organisation is under the direction of a new manager who believes the company would benefit from promoting Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR). Discuss the benefits and drawbacks of promoting Corporate Social Responsibility. End of Section D Maximum marks for Section D: 20 (20 marks)...

Words: 443 - Pages: 2

Level 5 Leadership

...Level 5 Leadership The Triumph of Humility and Fierce Resolve A] Verghese Kurien – called the “Father of White Revolution” in India – There are some amazing leaders around world who never cease to inspire me. After reading the article on Level – 5 leadership, one name that immediately came to my mind was of Varghese Kurien who revolutionized milk production in India. Humility + will = level 5 Verghese Kurien (1921 – 2012) was a leader of remarkable vision, creativity and compassion. He came to a small town in Gujarat named ‘Anand’ to serve on a government bond since the government had sponsored his education abroad. During this time the local dairy farmers in Anand were being exploited by large diaries and did not get their fair share of milk price. This was compounded by an inefficient way to get their milk to the market. This is the time when India’s demand for Milk was increasing. They were the second largest importers of milk. Kurien was touched by the plight of the farmers. Kurien also saw this as an opportunity rather than accepting the situation as it is. He truly believed in transforming the lives of the farmers through a business model which can be run as a self-sustained engine – a true trait of a leader to think a long way ahead much beyond his times! He setup a dairy co-operative and insisted that farmers buy a pasteurizing machine; the investment which totally paid off. Milk could reach big cities without getting spoilt and the co-operatives flourished. The co...

Words: 712 - Pages: 3

Level 5

...Introduction The article, “Level 5 Leadership” written by Jim Collins is regarded as one of the best article published in Harvard Business Review. This classic article has identified Level 5 leadership as key ingredient for transforming a company from merely good to truly great. Besides, the author has also introduced the concept of Level 5 leader for the first time from this article. Level 5 leader is defined as an executive who is able to blend genuine personal humility with intense professional will. Summary The Level 5 leadership is an accidental concept which emerged from the findings of the research undertaken by the author himself. The research, which was carried during 1996-2000, was undertaken with the objective to seek answer to one question “Can a good company become a great company and if so, how?” Intrigued by the scenario why great companies exhibited mediocre performance and what can be done to make mediocre company into the great, 11 companies which showed the shift from good to great was selected from 1435 companies for the research purpose. The result of the research, derived from both the qualitative and quantitative analyses showed Level 5 leaders as catalyst for transforming a good company into a great one. Although the research also identified six additional factors such as getting right people on the bus, Stockdale paradox, buildup-breakthrough flywheel, the hedgehog concept, technology accelerators and a culture of discipline responsible for this...

Words: 1543 - Pages: 7


.... I didn’t expect myself to do it because I always have a sense of focus on what I am talking about. Unfortunately, it had happened due to not having much experience in delivering speeches in front of a crowd and I was nervous. Gestures, which represents the body language was not in co-ordination with the phrases I used. It is important for a leader to use correct gestures because; it represents the passion in him/her which motivates his/her followers. Overall, my body language was good but not excellent. I observed that, I was not very comfortable with my standing position but I managed it, which was lacking confidence. I am really glad to see that, I was good at maintaining eye contact drawing the audience attention time to time. It is the essential skill of a leader because; it will create trust about the person who is speaking in the audience and eye contact reflects confidence. Even though, I stared at one place couple of times for more than 30 seconds, overall I am really happy in maintaining good eye communication which will make the audience to feel, not ignoring anyone. Peers Reviews I was rated on a scale from 5 to 1 representing skilled to unskilled respectively by my fellow classmates and by my professor too. I was graded on different aspects like delivery, preparation, pace, audience connection and visual aids. To become an effective leader and to influence my followers to follow me, I must improve my skill set. I was graded 4 on an average in delivering......

Words: 1277 - Pages: 6

Hnd Buisness Level 5

... with repayments? If you do not make the minimum payment we will charge a late payment fee of £12 as well as interest and the total cost of your debt may grow. Missing or late payments will be recorded at Credit Reference Agencies so obtaining credit could be more difficult and expensive in the future. If we register a default or you become insolvent this will remain on your file for 6 years. It could also result in legal action being taken against you, by us or a third party to whom we may have sold the debt. This could result in a court order being obtained (which could possibly be enforced by securing the debt against your home) and you incurring legal costs. In exceptional cases, this could lead to an order for the sale of your home being made. You should contact us if you are having real difficulties making payments. Put Simply You get charged a £12 fee for not making at least your minimum payment. This means your credit rating could go down making it harder to get credit in the future. Important Customer Information 4. Can I withdraw from the agreement once I have entered it? You have 14 days from the day after you receive your card to tell us you want to withdraw from the agreement. You can do this by writing to us or calling Customer Services. We will tell you how much to repay and how to pay it. From then you have 30 days to pay what you owe including any interest. Put Simply You have 14 days after you receive your card to change your mind. 5. Are...

Words: 1430 - Pages: 6

Hnd Level 5 Pearson

...ASSIGNMENT COVER SHEET Course Name: | Edexcel BTEC Level 5 HND Business and Management | Assignment Name: | Managing Financial Resources and Decisions | Section 1: Understanding the Source of Finance Available to Business IDENTIFY THE SOURCES OF FINANCE AVAILABLE TO BUSINESS In order to set up a business the owner or business needs money to get it going, and in cases of established businesses, keep it growing. Business owners will usually use some of their own money coupled with other sources of finance to start their business. There are several ways to acquire financing and a few of them are personal capital and borrowing from friends, borrowing from a bank, factoring, invoice discounting, leasing, hire purchase and franchising. For larger companies they have the advantage of being able to sell shares to raise capital, they can also have large investors, and being able to ‘raise capital’, they can also retain earnings in order to use the money as cash flow for further developments in the company or for a particular project (this money belongs to shareholders). Companies who are already established can retain their profits for a period of time and use this money in the future for projects or business needs, this is usually shareholder dividend and ultimately belongs to the shareholders, but the company is using it to expand or better the business. The selling of company assets is also seen as a way of raising capital, however if you are selling off your...

Words: 3778 - Pages: 16