Free Essay

Life Is Like the Movies

In: English and Literature

Submitted By lodha
Words 1450
Pages 6
Going to the movies is fun. You get your candy and your drink and are taken away into a fictional world for two or three hours, then leave the theater and get back to reality. But is what you're going back to really reality? Plato said no. In the "Allegory of the Cave" (chapter XXV) in the The Republic he proposes that we all live like people in a movie theater, only he uses prisoners in a cave to illustrate the situation. He creates an image of prisoners, chained down in a cave, so all they could see was shadows created by puppets in front of a fire on the cave wall. Their reality was merely the shadows and it is the same for us (as the common man.) According to Plato, our reality is nothing more than figurative "shadows."
Everything in the cave can be attributed to a part of society. The fire can be equivocated to "unwisdom" (229) or even evil, and in society is created by the greed that some have for power over others. It is the driving force behind the entire scheme to misrepresent reality. By controlling what people believe is reality, they in turn gain control of the people by telling them what is true and what should be valued, which gives them the power they crave. The fire (greed) is necessary for the shadows to be cast, without it nothing at all could be seen. Without the fire, the puppeteers would have no purpose, no reason to hold the objects up at all. Without the greed for control, society's "puppeteers" would not have any desire to misrepresent reality.

The puppeteers are the manipulators in society (the greedy people). People in a variety of different positions act as the puppeteers. Anyone who tries to skew reality for his or her own personal gain is a manipulator. Religious and business leaders, as well as politicians are all likely candidates for the role of the "puppeteers" because they often control people's realities. Religious leaders convince massive amounts of people that their ideas and their religion is reality. Business leaders use advertising campaigns to persuade people into believing their products are the best and will change their lives. Politicians often manipulate issues to make people see them their way. In conjunction with each other, all of these manipulative forces basically dictate society's values.
These "puppeteers" take the objects and let their own greed (fire) distort them, so only a small portion of what is "real" is revealed (in the form of a "shadow"). The objects are equivalent to the sermons, the add campaigns and the political agendas of world leaders. Because they have nothing else to look at, the prisoners (society as a whole) believes these shadows of reality to be true, because the manipulators have not given them any other options.
When the relationship between the "puppeteers" and the "prisoners" is examined more closely, the question of whether or not the manipulators actually know what reality is must be addressed. The answer is that they don't. They still only see what is inside the cave, and the enlightened world exists solely outside of it. Most of them actually believe in what they are promoting, which are essentially just "artificial objects" (228). Plato's Theory of Forms explains that one can only have beliefs and opinions about material thing, and the only thing that one can know is science (and universals.) Because these

objects can't be known, they can't be a part of the universal reality that exists "outside of the cave" or as in society beyond the boundaries of the material, manmade world. In the "Allegory" as in life, the only people that are "enlightened" (who know the true, universal reality) are those who leave the cave somehow, or those who see beyond our material world.
The prisoner who is set free and ascends into the light experiences a great deal of pain, "Suppose one of them set free and forced suddenly to stand up.and walk with eyes lifted to the light, all these movements would be painful." (229) Imagine the shock that would come from realizing that the whole world as one knew it for their entire life was only actually a "meaningless illusion" (229.) It would be extremely painful, not just because of the physical affects of bright light on eyes that have never experienced it, but also the emotional struggle one would have to go through to accept a completely new reality. For some amount of time, they would have to be more alone than they ever had before, because they wouldn't even have a reality. In that time of rejection of the first "reality" and acceptance of the new "reality", they would have complete nothingness. It would be much easier for them to forget what they saw and go back to the comfort of believing in what they had their entire lives, rather than try to figure out and then accept a new "reality." But this separation from their former reality is the necessary first "step" in the enlightenment process. Plato shows that one must leave what they know as real and step into nothingness before being able to grasp the new "enlightened" reality (which is the second "step" in the process he illustrates.)

If someone did go through this process and didn't go mad after such alienation, why would they ever want to return from the "sunlight" to the "cave?" The only reason that they would have to leave the glory of "enlightenment" to return to society would be to help other people achieve the understanding that they had. But throughout history, people who have become "enlightened" and "come back" to teach what they have learned (in some people's eyes, this could include Jesus, Ghandi and/or Socrates) have been tormented by the people. It would take an incredibly strong person with unbelievable moral character to actually complete the third "step" in this process, because people don't want to listen to them. Rather than listen to what these "enlightened" people have to teach them, they shun them from society because they are scared, "If they could lay hands on the man who was trying to set them free and lead them up, they would kill him." (231) If they chose to accept the teachings, they too would be forced to go through the terrifying realization that everything they thought they knew was a lie. Plato is clearly stating that the masses are not strong enough to go through this process, ".they would laugh at him." (231) instead of trying to understand the "enlightened" person, they would rather just believe what they have been taught.
Can an "enlightened" person really teach what they have learned? Just as the prisoners still in the cave could not really understand what the "escapee" from the cave would try and tell them, what the "enlightened" person has learned can not be completely communicated. How could the sun be described to someone who had never even seen direct light? It is a big, bright ball in the sky, but what is the sky? It's the blue area above the earth? Obviously, this process would go on forever, since the people in the cave would never have seen anything more than shadows and had no concept of the sun, the earth and the sky. The objects can be described, but the cave prisoners would not really understand until they actually experienced "enlightenment", or until they saw the objects for themselves. Until a person actually goes through at least the first two "steps" (separation and "enlightenment") and finds the "reality" themselves, they cannot truly understand, therefor the "enlightened" cannot truly communicate their wisdom in it's totality.
Plato's "Allegory of the Cave" is clearly more than just an illustration of the way society works. He explains people's resistance to change or to move out of the "comfort zone" of their realities to explore new ideas. Because of this fear and resistance to change, most people never even make it to the first "step" in the enlightenment process, which is leaving everything they believe in search of something better, or in this case more "real." If they actually get past this and become enlightened, completing the third "step" of returning to try and communicate their experience and understanding, they are met with unbelievable opposition and rejection. What they now know cannot actually be communicated to those who haven't experienced it, so these efforts must be fruitless. The only thing that these "enlightened" people can do is to convince people that there is more out there, and push them to find it for themselves, which is what we all must do.

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Re: English as a Global Language

...always into the latest fashion, clothes or music. Movies are also an agenda for youths. It plays a big part in their lifestyle. Youths want to be like their favorite movie star like Dwayne Johnson, Jason Statham or Robert Downey Jr. They play a big role in their youth lives. The movie ‘Avengers’ grossed a box office of $623,357,910 when it was premier at 2013. Half of the audiences are teenagers. Their age group range from 15 – 25. The target market for teenagers are very big; therefore, movie producers must take into consideration of this audience of theirs. They have to be considerate of the content of their movies or movies producers will face criticism from the public audience. Movies plays a big impact to the teens and it will impact them in a psychology way. Thus, movie is the entertainment that affects the youth today. There are few effects of movies on youth today such as, the factors of sociality, educational, cultural and political. Movies are entertainment for youth, because watching movie with family and friends can release their stress, forget everything and concentrate in the movie. In cinema, audience will laugh together or applaud together; share the same emotion with most of the audiences. These bring the viewers experience in more excitement and enjoyable; however, modern generations now are addicted towards movies. Addiction to movies can affect us mentally and physically based on health. Watch a lot of horror movies and you might believe in ghost existence; watch...

Words: 1635 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

James Holmes Research Paper

...and 70 people were wounded. Why would anyone let a man dressed like that come in a movie theater and why would you stay? The first thing you should’ve did when you saw him was run and call the cops or get a staff member. James Holmes was a doctoral study because he had a disorder and he said he went because he wanted to understand his own personal difficulties since he had since a kid. This man was sick and needed help that’s why he shot up the movie theater, not because of the black knight and the joker. Horror movies don’t causes people to turn violent. Violent horror movies are not the reason people go...

Words: 2281 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Different Movie, Different Life

...Different Movie, Different Life I like watching movies in my spare time, such as action movies, emotion movies, and suspense movies, actually I like all kind of movies except horror movies. Action movies can make me passionate and feel good, and actors in action movies are handsome and cool. I am excited by the fight scenes in action movies, which are amazing. I also enjoy in emotion movies. That kind of movies can show me various emotions in our life, and teach me what they are and let me know I should treasure them. Furthermore, I can realize the emotion which I never seen in my life. I can exercise my ability of thinking when I watch suspense movies. My brain is thinking when I watch that movies in a whole time. And I really admire creator of that kind of movies, they are genius and so smart. Let me talk about this kind of movies I dislike, horror movies. Somebody say watch horror movies can release pressure and relax themselves, but I do not think so. I am so upset and afraid when I see something about horror movies, even a playbill or a soundtrack. I do not know why so many people like watching horror movies. My favorite movie is called The Shawshank Redemption. I think so many people have seen this movie. This is an old movie which shown in 1994, I was 2 years old in that year. I watched it some months ago; the story really shocked me indeed. The story is about a banker called Andy; he was falsely charged with murdered his wife and his wife’s lover. He used 19 years to...

Words: 589 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Hum 186 Week 3 – Relationship Between Media and Culture

...For More Courses and Exams use this form ( http://hwguiders.com/contact-us/ ) Feel Free to Search your Class through Our Product Categories or From Our Search Bar (http://hwguiders.com/ ) There is has always been a strong relationship between media and culture. The relationship is a give and take style of relationship, where the media and the culture of the society lead the way. Television, movies, music, clothing, and electronic gaming steal what is popular in culture and make it their own. On the flipside, culture will often influence popular culture. There are three major media forms that reflect society the most, including television, movies, and electronic gaming. Television has been an extremely popular form of media since its inception. The highest rated shows reflect the society of their day, giving the audience an escape from their own everyday lives, and an insight into the lives of others. Television shows like Seinfeld, Home Improvement, Rosanne, Parenthood, and Friends are all shows about nothing really, but include social values and lesson. The life lessons and values are either discreet or out in the open, but reflect the values of society and culture TO Download Complete Tutorial Hit Purchase Button HUM 186 Week 3 – Relationship between Media and Culture Get Tutorial by Clicking on the link below or Copy Paste Link in Your Browser https://hwguiders.com/downloads/hum-186-week-3-relationship-media-culture/ For More Courses and Exams...

Words: 3744 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Summary Of Charpentier's Story Or Spectacle

...In his article Story or Spectacle? Why Television Is Better Than the Movies, David Charpentier claims that contemporary television shows are superior to contemporary films. He supports his claim by comparing television shows and movies in terms of characters and the plot. I agree with Charpentier’s thesis.At the beginning of his article Charpentier says “Steven Spielberg and George Lucas put out doomsday-esque statements about the end of movies as we know them” (Charpentier 308). Both Spielberg and Lucas are directors of credible movies. The fact that he uses movie directors as an example makes it easier to agree with his argument. All of the examples he uses in his article provide evidence that supports his claim and make his claim stronger. A character is a person in either a novel, film, or television show. Characters in television shows and in films are very different. Charpentier says “committing to a series involves watching dozens of...

Words: 1430 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Conflict of the Glass Menagerie

...to escape his situation by constantly going out to drink or see movies. The main conflict in The Glass Menagerie is Tom’s hatred for his situation. Amanda, Tom’s mother, always annoys him. She is disappointed in her fading glory; it motivates her to push her children. She is in constant search of a male suitor for her daughter, Laura, and pushes Tom to work harder. Although she may mean well for her children, the constant nagging and criticism causes more damage then help to Tom. Amanda causes the majority of stress that Tom has to deal with. She nags him about everything, even the way he eats food. “Honey, don’t push with your fingers.” He can only escape these condescending remarks by going to the movies or even to work. Tom’s job at the shoe factory does not help in his aspiration to make more of his life. He continues to work at his dead end job just to support his mother and sister. He often feels like his is stuck, like his father, and the only way out, is to leave. “Look! I’ve got nothing, no single thing, in my life that I can call my own! Everything is-“ He feels like this is it, he will accomplish nothing else, as long as he lives in the two bedroom apartment with his mother and sister. Tom tries to find escape and refuge in his poetry and the movies he goes to, as well as his drinking. Tom goes out every night to see a movie as to suppress his craving for adventure. “I go to the movies because I like adventure, Adventure is something I don’t have much at work, so...

Words: 499 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

It Is Only Worth Watching Movies That Can Teach Us Something About Real Life, Agree or Disagree?

...It is only worth watching movies that can teach us something about real life, agree or disagree? I don’t agree with this statement.In my opinion,all wovies can be,more or less,instructive and beneficial to us. Movies have become an important means of entertainment for modern people.Whether they are science fiction movies ,historical movies or movies that illustrate modern life,most of them are based on the prevailing social perspective and are consistent with our current value systems.When going to the theatre to spend a pleasant weekend,we don’t have to be too selective to watch movies which are meant to “teach” us.In fact,all movies can be,more or less,instructive and we are fully justified to choose whatever we like in the movie theatre. Different movies reflect various aspects of our real life.What we will learn from the movie all depends on how we comprehend these intructive information incorporated within the movies.Some people prefer to watch science fiction movies which not only fulfills their imagination for the future but also evokes their interest in real life science study;some people enjoy historical themes because they find many similarities between historical figure and contemporary people.They find most of the movie characters’ maneuvers still practical in real life;Others,including me,choose to watch movies that illustrate modern life.I discover many novelties from the movies:from basic physics principles in “The big bang theory”,to the breathtaking...

Words: 358 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Crime and the Movies

...seen a movie and automatically thought after now I know their crime story? When people talk about crime, most people are just basing there story off of something they saw in a movie or something they saw on television. Most of the crimes in movies are; assault, bribe, armed robbery, manslaughter, or racketeering, just to name a few. For example the movie “Public Enemies” starring Johnny Depp, it portrays a rough outline of the infamous John Dillinger and his gang. When I first saw this movie I was amazed because the story that they showed wasn't at all what I expected, I expected to see all major crimes take place one after another and grueling shootouts the whole movie but they showed his kind and calm side and it actually turned out to be a great movie. Another example of crime and the movies but on the other side of the law would be any of the “X-Men” series. These people may be mutants but most of them use their gifts for good rather than break the law. A classic example would be “Robin Hood”, he broke the law only to help those in need. (rottentomatoes.com) There are other examples where crime and the movies coexist on both sides of the law, whether it would be cheering for the good guy or cringing when a killer kills their victim, movies cannot show you the whole story and cannot show you the real justice system. During my research I came across this essay called “Does Movie Violence Increase Violent Crime?” (Dahl & DellaVigna, 2006) an excerpt from the essay caught my attention...

Words: 2974 - Pages: 12

Free Essay

The Modern Film

...of current movies on the market today most likely have one thing in common, Computer Generated Imagery, or CGI. Imagine how crude a movie would be without the use of computers and the quality they would posses if these technologies didn’t exist. From Star Wars to The Matrix and even a vast majority of all the more recent animated films such as Toy Story or Monster’s Inc have all used computers to enhance the experience of the movie. Movie goers have been enjoying the quality that these technologies have been adding to movies for years, maybe even longer than some might know of. It’s said that John Whitney, Sr. was the first to bring computer graphics to the film industry with his slit-scan technology creating the visually powerful “into the monolith” imagery of 2001: A Space Odyssey. Over the years computers would keep proving there worth in movies such as Tron, the film many people associate with the birth of Hollywood computer graphics. In 1985 Pixar produced what is said to be the first CGI character animation in film with the stained glass window come to life effect in the Young Sherlock Holmes. Disney, the maker of popular children’s movies of all kinds would later acquire Pixar and take animated movies from the classic sketched scenes of Cinderella and Bambi to the first full length CGI movie, Toy Story. Toy Story changed the way of viewing for animated movies making the characters seem more realistic and giving more detail to the worlds created in the movies. Another...

Words: 612 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Film

...Paper Movies are a big part of life. People love movies because they can relate to them. Others like them for mere enjoyment and see them as an escape from reality if only for a few hours. The types of movies out in the world today are numerous. There is everything from horror movies, to romantic comedies, to drama, to documentaries, indie movies, foreign, and so on. Everyone has their taste of movies, and people decide to watch certain movies based on the actors and actresses who are staring in them and the storyline of the movie. These are all things that help people decide which movies are enjoyable to them, and which ones are not. Deciding Which Films to Watch Ramon decides on what movies to watch with careful consideration. Any movies that have actors that Ramon doesn't like he will not go spend money on them. In his opinion, some actors play the same role over and over again. A perfect example of this is the lead actress in the Twilight Saga movies. Ramon thinks that they could have found a better actress to play the part of Bella, some who could have played a role that was different from all her other movies. He also bases his decision on the type of movie it is. Scary movies, romantic comedies, and action thrillers are some movies that Ramon likes to see. Action movies that do not involve a love story, or have the story be about the love interest is another factor in my decision making. What Makes a Film Enjoyable? The movies soundtrack and the...

Words: 605 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

High School Social Norms In Snow White

...negative effects that these movies can have on the self esteem of those who grew up watching them, especially females. The movies can mold the perceptions females have toward how they should look, act, and the people with whom they are interact. My group researched: To what extent do female high school social norms portrayed by Disney Channel movies from 2006-2010 impact their self esteem? Throughout our research, high school social norms were defined as the average daily experiences that high school students are believed...

Words: 1329 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Bollywood

...Bollywood Overseas Who needs real life when you have the movies? At least that’s what the entertainment industries want the public to believe. Movies are a great escape from reality. It is like stepping out of your world and into someone else’s. That’s partially why movies became so popular. Another reason is because they give a great representation of one’s culture. Movies remind a person of aspects of their own lives which allows them to relate to them. Hollywood is the American entertainment industry and Bollywood is the Indian entertainment industry. Hollywood has been around for much longer and is more established. While people all over the world enjoy the entertainment produced by America, one has to ask, “Is it affecting other entertainment industries?” Bollywood used to be viewed by the people of India only. But to become part of the global economy, industries need to become more globalized. So is that what is happening to Bollywood? Hollywood and the American entertainment industry are globalizing Bollywood to make it become part of the world entertainment industry. Watching a Bollywood movie is an experience of its own. Imagine seeing a three hour long musical with bright colors, upbeat dances and catchy tunes. Bollywood launched in the middle of the 20th century and it was small industry barely reaching the public. All the films were simple with the basic theme being love. The stories involve a girl and a boy in love, but have some conflict that does...

Words: 1545 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Mogul History

...the motion picture industry would have never developed into what it is today. The idea of capturing movement and creating an illusion of life and turning it into a story has been around since the mid 1600’s. Shadow shows eventually led to the invention of the Magic Lantern in 1659. Edison took it a step further and invented the Kinetoscope. The Kinetoscope amazed people with the moving images. However, they were only viewable by one person at a time, as you had to peer through a peep-hole. The Lumiere brothers in France had a better idea for a way of viewing the movies. They invented the Cinematograph in 1895. This was a breakthrough as the films could now be viewed on a projection screen by large audiences. The first commercially successful projector in the United States was the Vitascope, invented by Thomas Edison. Edison is known as the “Father” of motion pictures due to his inventions, which changed the motion picture industry forever. With the breakthrough of sound and motion together, the movies were forever changed. The invention of new technology allowed the industry to grow and develop into what we know it as today. The movies began to turn into a business, a multimillion dollar industry. It was the movie stars who made the motion picture industry explode as it did. Without stars, movies are nothing. Look at the movies today that people watch. If it doesn’t have a major star, many people don’t bother taking time to watch it. The stars in a movie are what...

Words: 1661 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Influence of Home Video on Youths in Nigeria

...TITLE PAGE TRENDS OF NEGATIVE THEMES IN NIGERIAN HOME MOVIES (A STUDY OF FOUR HOME MOVIES) BY OGBONNIA CHINAZA. C MC/2006/118 A PROJECT PRESENTED TO THE DEPARTMENT OF MASS COMMUNICATION, CARITAS UNIVERSITY, AMORJI-NIKE, ENUGU. IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENT FOR THE AWARD OF BACHELOR OF SCIENCE DEGREE IN MASS COMMUNICATION JULY, 201 DEDICATION I dedicate this work to God Almighty for his unfettered love. He is the only guide to my life and studies and he dispenses his grace freely. Also to my parents Mr. and Mrs. Joseph Ogbodo Ogbonnia and my brothers Arinze, Nnamaka, Chukwunonyerum, I remain grateful for their moral and financial support. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT I wish to acknowledge and appreciate all who fired the flame in one way or the other. First, I thank God, the almighty father who has given me life, knowledge, wisdom and strength to accomplish my work. My special gratitude goes to my head of Department, Damian. U. Agboeze who despite his crowded daily programme as the HOD would readily attend to his students and his fatherly advice. My immense gratitude also goes to my supervisor Justina Obi who devoted her time to supervise, correct and criticize this research work to make it a reality. I can never forget the service of my lecturer, Ferdinand Obasi, who made things...

Words: 10702 - Pages: 43

Free Essay

Book and Movie

...subject Books vs Movies (capitalize both words) There are different ways to get a story from different sources in modern times. Books have been good sources for stories, but movies are getting more popular and have the same story with wrong word the books. Why auxiliary verb needed people still reading books, and others are prefer watching should be an infinitive not a gerund the movies? Reading books and watching movies have a lot in common but there are some differences that makes the readers remain faithful to reading books. First, books keep a person’s mind going. A mind is filled with questionspunctuation and as the wheels in your head are turning, your brain is being put to more use rather than if you let it go numb during a movie. It is basically the same as watching television versus going outside and playing for a couple of hours. Movies are like a version of a television show, wrong punctuationthey are just longer. Everyone has heard that if you watch TV for too long it is not good for you, that you should pick up a good book instead.comma splice Should not the same rule apply when it comes to watching a movie?  You are contrasting movies and books but you go off on another idea of television. Keep on topic and show how books contrast to movies. In this paragraph you are trying to show how the brain reacts differently to movies and books. (Give more examples of that.) Films can do a lot of different things. They can bring whole worlds to life before our eyes...

Words: 2110 - Pages: 9