Premium Essay

Marx vs Smith

In: Other Topics

Submitted By Chavisda
Words 2039
Pages 9
Throughout history, economists have debated over various theories, in an effort to discover the one solution that will achieve the most efficient and beneficial economy. One school of thought titled, Classical Economics, is infamous has been called the “first modern school of economic thought.”[1] Two economist/philosophers who have been placed within this Classical category are Adam Smith and Karl Marx. Though these two men are polar opposites in the political-economic spectrum they share some similarities; and although dated, there are points of value to both Adam Smith’s and Karl Marx’s theories.
Adam Smith, the father of economics as a science, combined economics with moral theory in regards to the way societies ought to live. Today’s capitalist economic systems have been shaped by Smith’s explanations of market factors and the role of the state, or lack thereof, in economics. Karl Marx, a fundamental revolutionary, is one of the original minds behind communism. He is renowned as a radical political philosopher. These men have together been placed in the school of classical economics, signaling that there are similarities in their ideology. Politically, however, these men differ greatly. This essay intends to study some of their most poignant theories to compare fundamental differences. Karl Marx became famous for his revolutionary ideas and as one of the originators of communist theories. He is renowned for his book on economic theory, Das Kapital. As members of the Communist League, Marx and his friend Friedrich Engels authored the Communist Manifesto—which discussed the class struggle and the need for a revolution of the proletariat.[3] Common Sense dictates that without production, consumption would not be possible. capitalism can be broken down into two essential parts: production and consumption. Without the production portion,…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Hello Korea

...Discussion Questions for Smith vs. Marx (October 8, 2013 pp. 134-165) An Essay on the Background of Business Ethics: Ethics, Economics, Law and the Corporation 1. What is philosophy? A conversation. 2. What is "philosophical ethics"? A conversation about conduct, the doing of good, and the avoiding of evil. 3. What is "business ethics"? A conversation about right and wrong conduct in the business world. 4. Business ethics was once known as “the world’s most famous oxymoron” until about thirty years ago. What happened to change that view? Newspaper headlines of foreign bribes, Wall Street scandals, exploding cars, whistleblower conflicts and civil rights in the workplace allowed the view that value questions are never absent from business decisions to come into play and that moral responsibility is the first requirement of a manager in any business. From then on, it has become the general consensus that a thorough grounding in ethical reasoning is essential preparation for a career in business. 5. How was the “ruling class” defined in the seventeenth century according to Karl Marx? The ruling class in every age is the group that owns the means of production of the age’s product. In the 17th century, the product was almost exclusively agricultural and the means of production was almost exclusively agricultural land; landowners were the aristocrats and rulers. With the coming of commerce and industry, the owners of the factories joined the ruling......

Words: 1055 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay


...The conversation between Morpheus and Smith, The Battle between the humans and the machines. “Human beings are a disease, a cancer of this planet Cross cutting with Neo and Trinity trying to save Morpheus, testing Neo‟s powers and the length he will go to save Morpheus. * 3. Semiotic Analysis * 4. Semiotics and Structuralism• The war between man and machines.• Humans compared to a virus.• The five black marks: Signifier and Signified (Ferdinand De Saussure, The Theory of Semiotics, Umberto Eco, 1977)• The Wachowski brothers incorporate many signs and symbols into the movie, relating to Christianity, Greek mythology and Marxism. * 5. The Matrix compared to the Bible – Biblical Semiotic Theory. Alice In Wonderland The Matrix and Marxism (Karl Marx)Bourgeois vs. Proletarian Upper Class/Agents vs. Working class/Humans (Mythologies, Roland Barthes,1972) * 6. Formal Textual Analysis * 7. Morpheus‟ body language and mouth bleeding presuming his been beaten, body language showing his weak on the other hand Agent Smith. When reading a close analysis on both actors Morpheus is the stronger heroic protagonist whereas Agent Smith is the antagonist. This is established to us through the use of sweat to suggest his struggle in resistance to tell agent Smith where „Zion‟ is.„ Mr Smith‟ use of costume shows he is dominant in this clip. The formality represented through wearing suits establishes to the spectators that perhaps Agent Smith who is a machine is a......

Words: 2560 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Buddha Man

...Intro to Economic Concepts Definition of Scarcity A situation in which human wants are greater than the capacity of available resources to provide those wants. 3 Parts: 1. People want it 2. There is a limited amount of it 3. It has more than one productive use Scarcity Scarcity vs. Abundance – people see many signs of abundance (e.g. cell phones, iPods) and also see resources wasted daily (e.g. water and food). However, as long as resources are limited and people’s wants are unlimited, scarcity (in the economic sense) will exist. Scarcity In economic reasoning, scarcity is a relative concept, not an absolute one. Scarcity does not mean “not plentiful.” In economics, something is scarce when it has more than one valuable use. = & Opportunity Cost Opportunity cost is what you give up to obtain something else, the second-best alternative. However, what you must give up is not money – it is whatever good or service you would have spent the money on as your next favorite choice. Goods v. Services Good – something that is tangible; it can be seen and felt. It requires scarce resources to produce and it satisfies human wants Goods v. Services Service – something that is intangible; yet it too requires scarce resources to produce and satisfies human wants Is it a good or service? Productive Resources L – land (and stuff from land) L – labor (physical and mental) C – capital......

Words: 1239 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay


...employment, income and interest rate. 4. COMPLETE KEYNESIAN MODEL: Three sectors model Keynesian vs. Classical REFERENCE: Mankeiw – Macroeconomics Branson – Macroeconomics Dornbusc, Fischer, Startz– Macroeconomic Theory PAPER – III: MATHEMATICS Full Marks - 50 1. Sets: (i) Set operations (ii) Finite and infinite sets (iii) Mapping of Set (iv) Ordered Sets (v) Linear point Sets. 2. Elements of Calculus: Functions, Total derivatives, partial derivatives, Homogeneous function, Euler’s theorem, simple integration, definite integrals 3. Maxima & Minima of functions (constrained or unconstrained) 4. Linear Algebra: (i) Determinants – minors and cofactors, properties of determinant, Jacobian theorem (ii) Matrix 5. Some simple applications of mathematics on economic theory REFERENCE: Taro Yamane- Mathematics for Economists Henderson & Quandt -Microeconomic Theory PAPER – IV: DEVELOPMENT ECONOMICS Full Marks - 50 1. MEANING OF DEVELOPMENT : Broad indicators of development, international comparisons, distinction between growth and development, economic development considered in terms of capability 2. STAGES OF GROWTH : Rostow and Marx 3. SOURCES OF ECONOMIC GROWTH : (i) Land: contribution of land, theory of and......

Words: 602 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay


...Conservative views – decline, pessimists, and their values were traditional Avoid talking about women’s rights, claim that America’s problems are a result of the breakdown of family values Liberal – diversity (variation), optimists, and values were changing Claims that women’s problems are a result of job discrimination Feminist – diversity, caring for each other, women’s roles, individualism over collectivism, free child and healthcare and raise minimum wages Coontz – ahistorical not typically historical says conservatives are ahistorical Static – concepts and ideas remain the same (opposite of dynamic) Family is not static because it is always changing Stop moralizing and start mobilizing mythmaking is not a solution Idealized past vs terrible present – saying that the past wasn’t everything that it was cracked up to be with statistics and that the present isn’t worse than the past although it may not be better Coltrane and gender – gender is tied together with the family Gender is biological, how you act, expectations, social construct, and identity Social constructionism is a shared understanding, history, language discourse, fluid (changeable), reproduction, common sense (invisible) The idea is to gain social change, social constructionism is everchanging It is how you perform your gender, adhere to norms, reproduce through ritual, and day to day life Biological determinism is fixed and unchangeable and biology is destiny and is......

Words: 1229 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Capstone Project

...Marketing Thought - A few selected readings from Cicero to Galbraith will form the basis of a discussion on the critical importance of marketing to the existence of a business enterprise and we will learn what issues relating to marketing great thinkers have felt are important. C. Accounting Thought – Pacioli wrote a compendium of accounting procedures over five hundred years ago. Much of his original manuscript, which was published in 1494, will be read. In addition, the contemporary accounting information model will be presented and discussed. D. Financial Thought - From age old writings, the roles of money, borrowing and financial management will be examined. Markets will be discussed using, as a basis, the writings of North, Smith, Mill and Mackay. Current financial thought will be discussed in light of modern business activities. Exam 2 Section 3: E. Management/Organization Behavior Thought - Drawing on the readings from the first section and their messages about management, leadership, and organizational behavior, we will add some additional readings from literature, philosophy and business. We will more fully understand human behavior and how that translates to society and to the workplace. We will relate current organization behavior concepts to those of old and discuss their impacts on the modern business enterprise. F. Production/Operations Management Thought - Beginning with the writings of Marco Polo and ending with a piece by Gandhi, we will......

Words: 3371 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay


...Context of Business Economic Environment Factors of production: Resources used to produce goods and services 1) Land (natural resources) 2) Labor (workers) 3) Capital (buildings, equipment) 4) Entrepreneurship 5) Knowledge/Information World Economic Systems 1) Communism: All factors owned by all people * Big government * No competition * Karl Marx 2) Socialism: Some factors owned by all people * More equal allocation of resources * Government/central planning for basic goods/services * Most basic industries owned by the government 3) Capitalism: Factors are privately held and used to make profit * Promotes competition and freedom. * Driven by self-interest, rewards innovation * Adam Smith: father of free trade and capitalism Market Economy A) Supply and Demand B) Levels of Competition * Pure: Indistinguishable products, infinite sellers, i.e. Retail gas * Monopolistic: Similar products, many sellers, i.e. Candy, Athletic Shoes, Apparel * Oligopolies: Market is dominated by a few sellers, i.e. Soft drinks, Airplanes * Monopolies: One firm owns majority of market, i.e. Electricity, Gas, Water Economic Indicators (indicate health and trend of an economy) 1) GDP: Measures the sum of all goods and services produced in a country in a year 2) Unemployment rate: Measures percentage of population 16 and over looking for work but cannot find it. Three types of unemployment *......

Words: 983 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

The Day We Meet

...links Content The film is arranged into four parts. Each part is an amalgam of interviews, narration and animated sequences.[3] Part I: Human Nature The film begins with an animated sequence narrated by Jacque Fresco. He describes his adolescent life and his discontinuation of public education at the age of 14 and describes his early life influences. Human behavior and the nature vs. nurture debate is discussed. Robert Sapolsky sums up his opinion of the nature vs. nurture debate in which he refers to it as a "false dichotomy." The film then says that it is neither nature nor nurture that solely shapes human behavior, but the combination of both. Disease, criminal activity and addictions are also discussed. The overall conclusion of Part I is that social environment and cultural conditioning play a large part in shaping human behavior.[citation needed] Part II: Social Pathology John Locke and Adam Smith are discussed in regard to modern economics. In Two Treatises of Government, John Locke lays out the fundamental principles of private ownership of land, labor and capital. In The Wealth of Nations, Adam Smith uses the term invisible hand as a means to explain how an individual's self-interest benefits society as a whole.[4] A critical view of economic theory is made by questioning the need for private property, money and the inherent inequality between agents in the system. Also seen critically is the need for cyclical consumption in order to maintain market share which......

Words: 2123 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Social Theories

...|concept of ownership in capital goods. Production is |or cooperatives, and individuals are compensated based | | |organized to provide for human needs directly without any |on the principle of individual contribution. Production | | |use for money. Communism is predicated upon a condition of|may variously be coordinated through either economic | | |material abundance. |planning or markets. | |Religion |Abolished - all religious and metaphysics is rejected. |Freedom of religion, but usually promotes secularism. | |Political System |Usually takes the form of totalitarianism as Marx |Can coexist with different political systems. Most | | |described in The Communist Manifesto. Cronyism common. |socialists advocate participatory democracy, some | | | |(Social Democrats) advocate parliamentary democracy, and| | | |Marxist-Leninists advocate "Democratic centralism". | |Ideas |All people are the same and therefore classes make no |All individuals should have access to basic articles of | | |sense. The government should own all means of production |consumption and......

Words: 3092 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Communism vs Capitalism

...Capitalism vs. Communism Throughout history, there have been many systems developed in order to have a better society. Two of the most analyzed, and debated systems that have tired to change an economy for the best are communism, and capitalism. Communism, and capitalism have been compared on many levels, such as why they will or will not work, and which one works better. Throughout this essay I will concentrate on the differences, and similarities of how each operates, along with the benefits, and problems that each of them produces. Both of these economic systems theories came about around the same time, in the late 17th to mid18th centuries. One of the main contributor for capitalism was Adam Smith, writing The Wealth of a Nation in 1776, and Karl Marx for communism publishing the Communist Manifesto in 1848. These both were looked as a manual or guide for achieving such advancements. Communism called for the people to not be selfish and work for the benefits of the community rather for their well being. It asks them to see that what benefits the whole, benefits themselves. Capitalism on the other hand is focused on working for individual growth, and personal ownership to provide wealth for one's self. Communism plans to have a higher power or government control the economy to create a better way of living, by which all goods are equally distributed. As capitalism wants the government to not play a big role in the system, but instead wants it to be up to private......

Words: 1788 - Pages: 8

Free Essay


...kaynağa göndermede bulunulur. Örneğin, (Zizek‟ten aktaran Sancar, 2009). Sancar (2009), kaynak listesinde bütün künye bilgileri ile yer alır, Zizek‟in kaynağı almaz. Metin içinde kullanılan ikincil kaynakta alıntılanan birincil kaynak, makale yazarı tarafından hiç okunmamış ise o zaman örneğin, - - - Zizek‟in ideoloji görüşündeki sorun (Zizek‟ten aktaran Sancar, 2009)… olarak belirtilir. E-maille, telefonla, yüzyüze ya da başka biçimlerde yapılan kişisel görüşmelere dayalı bilgiler, metin içinde gösterilir, ancak kaynakçaya yazılmazlar. Örneğin: Martin Jay, “yapısalcı Marksizmin ABD‟de asla güçlü olmadığını” söyledi (Martin Jay, kişisel görüşme, 21 Nisan 2003) Klasik kitaplar, özgün tarih biliniyorsa şu örnekteki gibi yazılır: (Marx, özgün eserin tarihi/yararlanılan kitabın-makalenin tarihi) Özgün eserden doğrudan bir alıntı yaparken çıkarılan sözcük/cümle(ler) parantez içinde üç noktayla (…) gösterilir. Metin içindeki diğer kısa ve doğrudan alıntılar çift tırnakla yazılır. Çift tırnak içinde çift tırnak yer alamaz. Bir dergiden ya da kitaptan kullanılan makalenin metinde başlığıyla belirtilmesinde de çift tırnak kullanılır. Örneğin: Meyde Yeğenoğlu‟nun makalesi (2003) “Öteki Mekanda Olmak: PostKolonyal Dünyada Göçmenlik ve Turizm” ….. Dilsel örnek olarak bir harf, sözcük veya cümle aktarılarak kullanılacaksa, bunlar italikleştirilirk, çift tırnak kullanılmaz. Örneğin: Teknik bir terim sunuluyorsa ilk sunum cümlesinde italik yapılır, sonraki kullanımlarında......

Words: 2405 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Classical Management Theories

...perspective roots in management occurred rapidly through expanding manufacturing organizations that typified U.S and European industrialization. Early contributions were made by management practitioners and theorist from several corners of the world (Eastern, n.d.). The classical perspective consists of three main subfields: 1. Scientific Management (by Frederick Taylor) 2. Bureaucracy Management (by Max Weber) 3. Administrative Management (by Henry Fayol) Scientific Management Theory In the 19th century machinery was changing the means of production, and managers needed to find more efficient ways of production. Traditional methods of production, where a worker did all the steps to manufacture a good, were being challenged. Adam Smith found that the factory method was more productive, where each worker became very skilled at one specific task. "Breaking down the job allowed for the division of labor" (Unknown, n.d.). Fredrick Taylor further defined Scientific Management by seeking to reduce the time a worker spent on each task by optimizing the way the task was done (Unknown, n.d.). Frank and Lillian Gilbreth, who were supporters of the Scientific Management Theory, developed a Time and Motion study they called Therblig (Gilbreth spelled backwards) (Hartman, n.d.). Rather than focusing on a particular management style, Frank and Lillian’s study focused on repetitive motion tasks and by analyzing the movements, they were able to eliminate unnecessary motions,......

Words: 4106 - Pages: 17

Premium Essay


...standard of living. To do so would freeze the foreign workers out of the job market. 2. So we need to seek out responsibilities we hold as minimums – versus enlightened ones. Minimum duties are required for the continued existence of the company; enlightened ones are very nice if they can occur but not required. 3. Rights are requirements that impose minimum behaviours on others. 4. Possible models are: a. Sterba – 3rd world countries enjoy welfare rights – workers must not have health/sanity endangered. b. Shue – basic rights must be protected. Health, safety, no avoidable harm. This works for the obvious safety type harms, but is vague concerning other possible issues. 5. Local peoples may choose to trade off different things – pollution vs. the need for fertilizer. 6. Therefore – we need a more complex formula than a simple appeal to rights (which follows). Definitions: 1. Type #1 conflict – based on the relative level of economic development. For example – their view might change when (or if) they achieve the higher levels of economic success that other countries have achieved. But for now, they are willing to accept a particular trade off (lower wages, higher pollution of some kind) because what they do get is more important to them now. 2. Type #2 conflict – the conflict is not related to economic development in any way. It is cultural, related to some other factor. Implications: Type #1 conflicts can be worked through, because they often do not......

Words: 10507 - Pages: 43

Premium Essay

Recognizing the Need Delegation

...Recognizing the Need For, Impacts and Benefits of Effective Delegation in the Work Place CASSANDRA C. SMITH Graduate Research Thesis Lawrence Technological University Southfield, Michigan Dr. Thomas Marx Senior Service College Fellowship (SSCF) 2011-2012 Midwest Region Published by Defense Acquisition University 28 Mar 2012 Submitted to Lawrence Technological University (LTU) College of Management in partial fulfillment of the degree of Masters of Science in Global Leadership and Management Submitted to Defense Acquisition University (DAU) Midwest Region in partial fulfillment of the requirement of the Senior Service College Fellowship (SSCF) Program UNCLASSIFIED: Distribution Statement A Approved for public release Report Documentation Page Form Approved OMB No. 0704-0188 Public reporting burden for the collection of information is estimated to average 1 hour per response, including the time for reviewing instructions, searching existing data sources, gathering and maintaining the data needed, and completing and reviewing the collection of information. Send comments regarding this burden estimate or any other aspect of this collection of information, including suggestions for reducing this burden, to Washington Headquarters Services, Directorate for Information Operations and Reports, 1215 Jefferson Davis Highway, Suite 1204, Arlington VA 22202-4302. Respondents should be aware that notwithstanding any other provision of law, no person shall be subject to a penalty......

Words: 13429 - Pages: 54

Free Essay

The Firm

...Emne nr: 12, 11 og 10 12. Staten og bedriften (2) 11. Innovasjon og samfunn (2) 10. Hvordan skapes og utvikles bedrifter (1) 12. Statens rolle i den økonomiske historien * Under merkantilismen, hierarki og ”Good trade” * Etter Adam Smith, 1776 Nattvekterstaten * Spredningen av den 1. industrielle revolusjon, GB 1850 * Økt proteksjonisme før og etter 1. verdenskrig * Tvunget liberalisering og gjenoppbygging etter 2. verdenskrig, gullalderen 1950-70 * 1971 og 73, stagnasjon og nye betingelser * Fra 1980 økt tro på markedet * Forsterket etter Berlin-muren og Sovjet-imperiets fall 1989/1990 * Fra 1990-tallet nettverk og klynger * Statens rolle etter Lehmann Brothers 15. september 2008 og ”finanskrisen”, nasjonale tiltakspakker, Keynes og/eller nasjonalisme? 12. Staten og bedriften * Den nordiske modellen * Klassekompromisser i mellomkrigstiden * E.2VK velferdsstater * Sikkerhetsnett * Blandingsøkonomi * Sterk eiendomsrett * Blandingsøkonomi * Tillit * Politisk konsensus * Sammenpresset lønnsstruktur * Flexisecurity * Sejersted: Demokratisk kapitalisme * WTO 11. Næringsklynger (clusters) * Schumpeter II, institusjonalisering av innovasjoner * Det kan ses på som en fleksibel spesialisering. * De små bedriftene erstatter på en måte storbedriften, fordi de til sammen utgjør en stor enhet. * Silicon Valley ...

Words: 2512 - Pages: 11