Premium Essay

Mintzberg V Fayol

In: Business and Management

Submitted By benguam
Words 1286
Pages 6
Q) Management functions have traditionally been defined in terms of: planning, organising, commanding, coordinating and controlling. How do these functions compare with Mintzberg’s description of managerial roles and which of these approaches do you think is more useful for understanding management?

Although both Henri Fayol's traditional definition of management functions and Henry Mintzberg's description of managerial roles are useful for understanding management, Mintzberg's theory is more useful. Whilst both theories have many similarities, when compared to Fayol's somewhat vague management functions, Mintzberg's roles of management provide a much more specific and practical outline of the tasks which successful managers must carry out. Indeed many of Mintzberg's roles are nothing more than the tasks that must be performed in order to fulfil Fayol's functions of management. As a result Mintzberg's theory is more useful as it better explains what managers must actually do in the real world- the most important aspect of management.

Henri Fayol (1841-1925) was a prominent French industrialist. Based on his extensive personal experience in management, he proposed that there were five basic functions which management performs in his French treatise "Administration Industrielle et Générale (1916)" which in 1949 was translated into English as "General and Industrial Management". According to Fayol, a manager's work comprised of a constant cycle of the following five functions- planning, organising, commanding, coordinating and controlling.

Planning requires the manager to predict future events, determine future goals and develop a course of action which would allow the organisation to achieve these goals. Organising involves the manager arranging tasks and assigning people to complete them. Coordinating involves the manager synchronising and harmonising

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Fayol vs Mintzberg

...Henri Mintzberg considers the image of management which was developed from the work of Henry Fayol as one of folklore rather than fact. However, it could be argued that the image portrayed by Fayol is superior to that of Mintzberg, and the latter’s description is of rather ineffective management! Who do think is right? Over 50 years ago, English-speaking managers were directly introduced to Henry Fayol’s theory in management. His treatise, General and Industrial Management (1949), has had a great effect on managers and the practice of management around the world. However, 24 years after the English translation of Fayol, Henri Mintzberg in the Nature of Managerial Work (1973) developed another theory and stated that Fayol’s work was just “folklores”. This essay is to prove that work of Fayol and Mintzberg both have validity and they can be reconciled to some extent. It also claims that Fayol’s theory has been proved to be more useful in the practice of management and can not be called “folklores” as stated by Mintzberg. In the book General and Industrial Management (1949), Fayol described management as a function and to manage was to plan, organise, coordinate, command, and control. To plan was to forecast what might happen in the future and determine a chain of actions to be taken by the whole organisation. To organise was to build up a dual structure of the undertakings, allocate the materials and human and lay out the lines of authorities and responsibility. To command...

Words: 2459 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Henri Fayol, Practitioner and Theoretician – Revered and Reviled

...The current issue and full text archive of this journal is available at www.emeraldinsight.com/1751-1348.htm Henri Fayol, practitioner and theoretician – revered and reviled Mildred Golden Pryor and Sonia Taneja Department of Marketing and Management, Texas A&M University-Commerce, Commerce, Texas, USA Abstract Purpose – Fayol’s theories were the original foundation for management as a discipline and as a profession. Also Fayol was the first to advocate management education. Yet he has critics who revile him (or at least disparage his work) as well as followers who respect and revere him. This paper intends to enlighten today’s practitioners and academicians about the relevance and value of Fayol’s theories today. Design/methodology/approach – The paper addresses Fayol’s contributions as well as the disparagement and the reverence. It compares Fayol’s work with that of Follett, Mintzberg, Taylor, and Porter. In addition, it demonstrates the original and current interpretation and application of his theories. Finally, it indicates the alignment of Fayol’s theories with strategic leadership and management. Findings – Fayol’s theories are valuable and relevant for organizational leaders because Fayol was a practitioner who documented theories that worked best for him and his co-workers. While there are those who criticize Fayol’s theories, there are many others who respect them and find them useful as academicians and as practitioners. The theory of management functions aligns...

Words: 7742 - Pages: 31

Premium Essay

Managers at Work

...Managing: the art of determining the right balance Maastricht University School of Business and Economics Maastricht, 6 June 2014 Ignacio, I.K.A ID number: i6016200 Study: MSc Accountancy Course code: EBC4045 Group number: 2 Tutor name: W. Foppen Writing Assignment: Individual paper   Table of Contents 1. Introduction ....................................................................................................................... 2 2. Managing ........................................................................................................................... 3 3. The organization and its people ....................................................................................... 4 3.1 3.2 Company ........................................................................................................................................ 5 Teams ............................................................................................................................................. 6 3.2.1 Familiarity ................................................................................................................................. 7 3.2.2 Open communication ................................................................................................................. 8 3.3 Individuals ..................................................................................................................................... 8 4. A move to the external environment...

Words: 5201 - Pages: 21

Premium Essay

Management Theorists

...M A N AG E M E N T D EV E LO P M E N T Part 1: Machiavelli, Fayol and Taylor The 20th century was remarkable for the rise of the professional manager – often basing his or her approach to management on a particular theory or favoured guru. MBA students all over the world have investigated these theories and written countless assignments discussing their value. As we progress through the 21st century, are these theories still relevant or have they had their day? This article is the first in a three-part series that looks at ten influential theorists and the influence they still have. The series does not attempt to create a ‘top ten’ or rank contributions in any way (they are presented in chronological order), but aims to provide food for thought and debate. Part 1 looks at Machiavelli, Fayol and Taylor – three famous theorists who have all passed into management mythology, but whose views are sometimes misunderstood. MANAGEMENT THEORISTS In a three-part series, Dilys Robinson looks at ten influential theorists and assesses their influence in business today Thinkers for the 21st century? NICCOLO MACHIAVELLI, 1469–1527 The end justifies the means achiavelli lived in Florence, where he worked for the Florentine state as a secretary, then a diplomat. His best known work, The Prince,1 is based on his observation of Cesare Borgia – a cunning, cruel and self-seeking man. Machiavelli did not regard Cesare Borgia as an ideal person, but thought that, under him, the Florentines...

Words: 5652 - Pages: 23

Premium Essay

Googley Way

...| | |0rganisations Behaviour | |Google’s Chaotic-Management Style Assignment | | | | | | | | | GOOGLE Management Style 1.1 The Organisational Structure and Culture at Google, its Pros and Cons with supporting theories of Management In today’s competitive business world, close relationship within an organisation is essential in meeting clients need and promoting the level of customer satisfaction. Organization literally means “a group of people who make up a body for the purpose of administering something”. Carter McNamara (2013) defined an organisation as group...

Words: 4105 - Pages: 17

Premium Essay

The Role of Manager in Functional Areas

...the importance, but all organizations must need to achieve the corporation’s goal effectively and efficiently. Most corporations must need people who manage the organization, and then managers have a different role to support a corporations’ competitiveness. According to Gilbert (1996) “Making broad strategy for a company is one of the major tasks of general managers. This involves setting long-term directions and goals, and allocating resources, so that the directions can be pursued, and the goals can be reached” (p.13) To improve corporation’s competitiveness, the manager in the functional areas takes some roles. There are two structures of the role of manager. One is the management function from Henri Fayol, and the other one is the managerial roles from Mintzberg. Henri Fayol’s the four functions of management are planning, organizing, leading and controlling and Mnitzberg’s the roles of a manager divide by interpersonal relationship, the transfer of information, and making decision. (Robbins & Coulter, 2012). All managers in the organizations like Marketing, R&D, Manufacturing, Human Resources, and Finance must have both structures. They make plans of goal and strategies to succeed, and organizing. Then they lead and control their members to accomplish goals. Furthermore, they have different roles divided their working part or level of positions. Managers are the leader and the figurehead of the organization and a mainstay in between members of the organization. Also...

Words: 1089 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Functions of Management

...Henri Fayol (born 1841 in Istanbul; died 1925 in Paris) was a French management theorist. Henri Fayol was one of the most influential contributors to modern concepts of management, having proposed that there are five primary functions of management:   1. Planning, 2. Organizing, 3. Commanding, 4. Coordinating, and 5. Controlling (Fayol, 1949, 1987).   Controlling is described in the sense that a manager must receive feedback on a process in order to make necessary adjustments. Fayol's work has stood the test of time and has been shown to be relevant and appropriate to contemporary management. Many of today's management texts including Daft (2005) have reduced the five functions to four: (1) planning, (2) organizing, (3) leading, and (4) controlling. Daft's text is organized around Fayol's four functions.   Fayol believed management theories could be developed, then taught. His theories were published in a monograph titled General and Industrial Management (1916). This is an extraordinary little book that offers the first theory of general management and statement of management principles.   Fayol suggested that it is important to have unity of command: a concept that suggests there should be only one supervisor for each person in an organization. Like Socrates, Fayol suggested that management is a universal human activity that applies equally well to the family as it does to the corporation.   Fayol has been described as the father of modern operational management...

Words: 5553 - Pages: 23

Premium Essay

Music

...CHA P TE R Introduction to Principles of Management FIGURE 1.1 The restaurant industry poses many challenges to the successful management of individuals and groups. 1 © Thinkstock C H A P T E R L E A R N I N G O B J E C T I V E S Reading this chapter will help you do the following: 1. Learn who managers are and about the nature of their work. 2. Understand the importance of leadership, entrepreneurship, and strategy within organizations. 3. Know the dimensions of management articulated in the planning-organizing-leadingcontrolling (P-O-L-C) framework. 4. Understand the relationship between economic, social, and environmental performance. 5. Understand how the concept of performance is used at the individual and group levels. 6. Create your survivor’s guide to learning and developing principles of management. Thomas Edison once quipped, “There is a way to do it better—find it.” This simple challenge is at the heart of the study and practice of management. Perhaps you’ve already considered ways to do things better in the organizations, teams, schools, clubs, or social groups in your life. Most of us have thought of better ways to manage others at work or perhaps at home. As you’ve visited or worked at restaurants, coffee shops, schools, or other organizations, it’s likely you’ve encountered many instances where different interactions with individuals would have led to a better experience. 10 PRINCIPLES OF MANAGEMENT VERSION 2.0 management The art...

Words: 10782 - Pages: 44

Free Essay

General Knowledge 2012

...Book's Name | Author's Name | A Bend in the River | V. S. Naipaul | A Bend in the River | V.S.Naipaul | A Gift of Monotheists | Ram Mohan Roy | A House for Mr.Biswas | V.S.Naipaul | A Journey | Tony Blair | A Minister and his Responsibilities | Morarji Bhai Desai | A Nation is Making | Surendra Nath Bandhopadhye | A Pair of Blue Eyes | Thomash Hardy | A Passage to India | E. M. Foster | A Revenue Stamp (autobiography) | Amrita Pritam | A Strange and Sublime Address | Amit Choudhary | A Suitable Boy | Bikram Seth | A Tale of Two Cities | Charls Dikens | A Voice of Freedom | Nayantara Shehgal | A week with Gandhi | L. Fischer | Adventures of Sherlock Homes | Arther Canon Doel | All the Prime Minister's Men | Janardan Thakur | Allahabad Prasasti | Harisen | Amitabh- the Making of the Superstar | Susmita Das Gupta | Amukta Malyad | Krishna Deva Raya | An Unknown Indian | Nirod C. Choudhary | Anand Math | Bankim Chandra Chattopadhaye | Anna Karenina | Leo Tolstoy | Aparajito | Bibhuti Bhushan Bandopadhyay | Apple Cart | G. B. Shaw | Aranyak | Bibhuti Bhushan Bandopadhyay | Arogyaniketan | Tarashankar Bandopadhyay | Astyadhaye | Panini | Bakul Katha | Ashapurna Devi | Ban Palashir Padabali | Ramapada Chowdhury | Bandit Queen | Mala Sen | Bela Obela Kalbela | Jibanananda Das | Bengali Zamindar | Nilmoni Mukherjee | Bicramanchadev | Bilhon | Blind Beauty | Boris Pasternak | Buddhacharit | Asha Ghosh | Captive Lady...

Words: 2869 - Pages: 12

Free Essay

Gestão Organizacional

...A Gestão: Conceito, Funções, níveis ✓ Gestor: ALGUÉM QUE TRABALHE COM E ATRAVÉS DE OUTRAS PESSOAS, COORDENANDO AS SUAS ACTIVIDADES COM VISTA AO CUMPRIMENTO DE OBJECTIVOS ORGANIZACIONAIS. Níveis de Gestão: ( Níveis verticais de Gestão / Níveis do Gestor [pic] Gestor de topo: é responsável pelo conjunto de organização, definindo os objectivos que afectam o conjunto de organização. A este gestor corresponde o nível institucional, onde a gestão se caracteriza fundamentalmente por uma forte componente estratégica (existe um envolvimento da totalidade dos recursos disponíveis na determinação do rumo a seguir, geralmente com implicações a médio e longo prazo) e pela formulação de políticas gerais (definidas de forma genérica e respeitantes a toda a empresa). Gestor intermédio: faz a ligação entre os outros dois níveis. A este gestor corresponde o nível intermédio. Neste nível, predomina uma componente táctica que se caracteriza pela movimentação de recursos no curto prazo e elaboração de planos e programas específicos relacionados com a área ou função do gestor. Exemplo: Administrador, director, chefe de departamento. Gestor de base: gere e coordena o trabalho das pessoas que estão directamente envolvidas com a produção de bens e serviços. Tem como principais funções a execução de rotinas e procedimentos. Ao gestor de base corresponde o nível operacional, caracterizado por uma forte componente técnica. ( Áreas funcionais da empresa /...

Words: 6167 - Pages: 25

Premium Essay

Principles

...INTRODUCTION TO PRINCIPLES OF MANAGEMENT DEFINITIONS Management is a process of achieving organizational goals by engaging in the function of planning, organizing, leading and controlling. Kibera (1996) defines management as a set of activities directed at the efficient and effective utilization of resources in pursuit of one or more objectives. A manager is a person responsible for directing the efforts aimed at helping the organization achieve its goals. Managerial performance is the measure of how efficient and effective a manager is i.e. how well he/she determines and achieves appropriate objectives. Organizational performance is the measure of how efficient and effective an organization is i.e. how well it achieves appropriate objectives. MANAGEMENT FUNCTION Management is referred to as a process because it is a systematic way of doing things. Like any other process, all managers engage in certain interrelated activities in order to achieve their desired goals. Four of the key management functions are:- a) Planning - Is the process of setting goals and deciding how best to achieve them. b) Organizing - Involves allocating and arranging human and non human resources for the successful implementation of plans c) Leading - Is the process of influencing others to engage in work behavior necessary to reach the organization goals. d) Controlling - Involves regulating organizational activities so...

Words: 12514 - Pages: 51

Premium Essay

How to Resolve Ethical Issues Regarding Wages and Employee Walfare in Wal-Mart Stores Inc. Using Organizing and Motivating

...1. Introduction 1.1 Purpose The purpose of this report is to determine, discuss and demonstrate how the management of Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. can apply the concepts of organizing and motivating to reach the organizational objective of resolving the ethical issues regarding wages and employee welfare by June 2012. 1.2 Background Vesilind (1988) defined ethics as the study of systematic methodologies which can assist one in making value-laden decisions when one is guided by his or her individual moral values. Hence, one is said to be practicing ethics when he or she is implementing ethical values in decision-making. When managers and employees do not practice ethical values, an organization will face ethical issues. In this report, the organization that is being discussed is Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. In the United States, Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. run large discount department stores and also warehouse stores. Even though Wal-Mart is the largest groceries retailer, the management of it has caused many ethical issues regarding wages and employee welfare as they did not practice ethical values. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. paid their workers low wages that are even lower than the federal poverty line. Bianco and Zellner (2003) stated that in 2001, documents filed in a lawsuit that is against the corporation showed Wal-Mart sales clerks earned $8.23 an hour, or $13,861 a year on average. The wages is definitely low and insufficient, especially for a family of three, as the federal poverty line...

Words: 3529 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Competencies for Senior Manager Roles

...Competencies for Senior Manager Roles Pradip N Khandwalla includes research articles that focus on the analysis and resolution of managerial and academic issues based on analytical and empirical or case research RESEARCH Executive Summary KEY WORDS Senior Managers Roles Managerial Competencies India This paper identifies competencies that may aid role effectiveness at senior managerial levels. It fills a research gap: while managerial roles and competencies have been studied fairly extensively, their relationships have not been demonstrated. The performance of senior level managers — and therefore of the organization — depends upon how well they play their varied roles. In this paper, the roles of senior managers have been categorized into nine strategic, nine operations-related, and nine leadership roles. Strategic roles relate to such matters of long-term and organization-wide import as policy formulation, setting of long-term objectives, articulation of a vision of excellence for the organization, contributing to the organization’s growth and diversification, procuring of strategic resources and intelligence, etc. Operations-related roles cover implementation of policies and changes, setting short-term targets, work allocation to staff, operating a control system, crisis management, etc. Leadership roles encompass inspiring subordinates, developing effective relationships, getting cooperation, emphasizing core values and norms, mentoring, fostering teamwork...

Words: 10429 - Pages: 42

Premium Essay

Management

...Subject: Management Concepts and Organizational Behaviour Subject: Management Concepts and Organizational Behaviour ------------------------------------------------- Subject Code: MC-101 Author: Dr. Karam Pal ------------------------------------------------- Lesson No: 01 Vetter: Prof. Harbhajan Bansal ------------------------------------------------- Subject Code: MC-101 Author: Dr. Karam Pal ------------------------------------------------- Lesson No: 01 Vetter: Prof. Harbhajan Bansal INTRODUCTION TO MANAGEMENT Objective: The objectives of this lesson are to enable to define management; to describe the nature and scope of management; to know the difference between management and administration; to understand various levels of management; and to describe the various skills that are necessary for successful managers. Lesson Structure: 1.1 Introduction 1.2 Definition of Management 1.3 Characteristics of Management 1.4 Management Functions/ the Process of Management 1.5 N ature of Management 1.6 Management Vs. Administration 1.7 Levels of Management 1.8 Managerial Skills 1.9 The Manager and his job 1.10 Principles of Management 1.11 Significance of Management 1.12 Summary 1.13 Self Assessment Questions 1.14 Suggested Readings 1.1 INTRODUCTION A business develops in course of time with complexities. With increasing complexities managing the business has become a difficult...

Words: 50220 - Pages: 201

Free Essay

Priect Mfc

...PROIECT Management Financiar şi Analiza Economico - Financiară Coordonatori Stiinţifici: Masternad an I: 2010 Managementul financiar: concept, obiect, funcţii şi rolul lui în lumea contemporană 2010 MOTTO: “Managementul este o activitate care îmbină mult meşteşug (experienţă) cu o anumită doză de artă (întelegerea lucrurilor) şi ceva ştiinţă (analiză).” Henry Mintzberg CUPRINS |INTRODUCERE |............................................................................................................................|5 | | |............ | | | |Motivaţia alegerii temei.................................................................................................. |5 | | |Obiective...................................................................................................................|5 | | |...... | | |CAPITOLUL I |CONCEPTUL DE MANAGEMNT – FUNCŢII, ROLURI..................................... |6 | |1.1 |La “graniţa”...

Words: 5176 - Pages: 21