Free Essay

Mysticism in Philosophy

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By HassanOthman
Words 1012
Pages 5
Name: Hassan Othman Kitine
ID: 1000044793
Course code: PHL 105Y
Teacher: Jacqueline Brunning
TA: Agnes Bolinska A mystical experience is one which is outside the realm of our normal consciousness. The point of Stacey’s article is that Mysticism does indeed exist. Stacie is trying to prove that the existence of mysticism cannot be denied and that it is not just some worthless delusion. He states that human beings cannot deny the existence of mysticism because it is beyond the confines of human understanding. One of the main concepts is that Mysticism is Independent of all our senses such as our physical senses of hearing, seeing or smelling. It also excludes any concepts or thoughts. Therefore whatever seems to deviate from our normal way of perceiving things such as having precognitions and visions are indeed not mystical occurrences because they still involve the senses. A man may claim to have a precognition of a neighbour’s death but he still pictured in his mind the image of a coffin and therefore this is not a mystical occurrence. Stacey advances several concepts to try and convince us that mysticism exist. One of his underlying arguments is that even though mystical experiences have different interpretations in different parts of the world, they have common characteristics which are agreed upon by those who practice it. One of the most important of these central characteristics is the existence of an ultimate unity in all things which they call a One or oneness and which is beyond our sensory intellectual consciousness. Stace further states that there are two main types of mystical experiences found in all higher cultures Extrovertive Mysticism and Introvertive mysticism. The extrovertive mystic finds the One or oneness as you may call it through his physical senses. In this sense he sees the grass and the tree as one although in a normal sense they are two different things. Stace mentions Meister Eckhart a Catholic Mystic who said that a man stands above mere understanding if he sees all things as one and not separated from the other. However since the idea of extrovertive mysticism involves the senses, it only partially lives up to the core nature of mysticism, and is only a halfway house to introvertive mysticism. Introvertive Mysticism on the other hand involves the shutting down of all of the senses, with the sensory intellectual consciousness being replaced by the mystical consciousness. Since this type of Mysticism involves a shutdown of all the senses it is often very difficult if not impossible to obtain this level of mysticism on will alone. Therefore mystics employ a variety of ways to reach this state as evidenced by the Yogis of India. The Yogis practice breathing exercises in seeking mysticism, the key underlying factor here is to concentrate ones attention on some single point or object so that all other mental content falls away, in the Yogis case ones mental concentration is on the stream of one’s breathing. Stace further supports his argument by stating that the description of what people encounter during this mystic experience has been given by those who have encounterd it, he uses the Upanishad of India as an example. The Upanishad have expressed their introvertive mystical consciousness as something beyond the senses, a pure unitary consciousness. This goes hand in hand with the perception of Mysticism as a unity in which there is no internal division or multiplicity. The fact that one can find this same evidence such as in Christianity only strengthens the idea that the mystic experience is an undifferentiated unity Another of these central characteristics stated is the relationship between Mysticism and religion. It is clear that most writers seem to associate mysticism with religion. According to Stace, mysticism is not associated with religion, it is an undifferentiated unity separate from the concept of religion. However, the fact that mysticism often finds its way into the religious interpretation of different religions is but further proof of its existence. Stacey further supports this by showing why mysticism usually takes on some religious form. For example undifferentiated unity is necessary thought of as beyond time and space because, unlike time, it is without any kind of division whereas the essence of time is its division into an endless number of successive parts. Therefore undifferentiated unity, since it is beyond time, can be said to be eternal and in Christianity eternal is another name for God. Therefore one can see how the concept of undifferentiated unity takes on a religious meaning. Another way mysticism can be associated with religion is by taking into account its emotional side, people who have experienced it usually feel joy and piece such that it can be identified with the peace of God. Stacey however states that mysticism does not favour any religion. Another argument Stacey offers is based on the ethical aspects of mysticism. He states that mysticism actually exist and serves as a way of spreading the message of love and unity among the people. Mystics stress on the importance of people viewing each other as one and therefore the sufferings of another is also one’s own sufferings, others view mysticism as the basis of all morality. The Christian Mystics also emphasize on the importance of self sacrifice, charity and love. They have also particularly condemned those who view mystics as merely and escape from the harsh realities of life and are indifferent to the sufferings of others. Stacy also states other alternative Interpretations of mysticism. Here he seems to disagree with the skeptic who thinks that mysticism is not real and is subjective. He states that even if one choses to be a skeptic he or she cannot dispose mysticism as a delusion because it reveals something which is a great part of human life. He would rather believe the mystic who claims that he is really in touch with something greater than himself than to believe a skeptic. He says that the road towards mysticism although attainable is very difficult to achieve and that is why its truth is neglected by many people

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Mysticism and Diabolic Witchcraft

...History 200 14 December 2010   1   Mysticism and Diabolic Witchcraft: Female Susceptibility of the Italian Renaissance During the Italian Renaissance, Christianity experienced a heavy resurgence in mysticism. Mysticism was a type of devout faith or spirituality found throughout the convents in Italy and primarily exercised by Christian Italian women (Sheldrake 93-95). These women underwent vivid connections with God which involved an awakening of consciousness and awareness for God’s divine will. In extreme cases, women fell into a transcendental union with God in which they experienced ultimate illumination. In these rare occurrences, women could encounter faith miracles such as stigmatas, ecstasies, or the re-living of Christ’s Passion. During this period, Italy also experienced another intense spiritual movement labeled diabolic witchcraft (Tavuzzi 150). In the case of diabolic witchcraft, again experienced primarily by females, women underwent a concentrated level of worship and contractual relations with Satan. Historical examples show these women developing sexual relations with Satan, as well as maleficia or harmful magic (Tavuzzi 153). The women involved in diabolic witchcraft were pursued by the Church’s legal arm, the Dominican Inquisitors. They were put on trial, accused of heresy, and either imprisoned or killed. Similarly, the Dominican Inquisitors investigated women who were involved in mysticism and upon the examinations performed by the inquisitors;...

Words: 5189 - Pages: 21

Premium Essay

Essay On Mysticism

...Mysticism means many things to many minds and is undeniably a term that is used in varying contexts with different shades of meanings. Many have used this term to designate a special mark of spiritual disposition, and others have employed it to mark off a higher and final development of life itself. Anyone who reflects God or the Holy Spirit as the vital, determining norm or principle of his or her life could validly be called “Mystical.” Mysticism means, the attainment of higher levels of being in which this knowledge is fully realized in conformity with man’s destiny on earth. Mysticism is a living tradition that continues to occupy a central place in philosophy of the Muslim world. Sufi orders continue to flourish openly in worldwide and its mystical presence is apparent even on the more external plane. In the contemporary world which is full of materialism, Islamic mysticism is...

Words: 2533 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Christian Mysticism: Movement On Christianity In The Medieval Period

...Matthew Caldwell 870072854 Dept of Philosophy and Religious Studies – REL 2020 World Religions, Section IA and IB Instructor: Dr. Lily Vuong November 30, 2014 What is Christian mysticism? Discuss the influence of this movement on Christianity in the Medieval Period and consider its attraction especially for Christian women. Thesis: Christian Mysticism does not exist. The term ‘Christianity’ (from the Greek word “Christos”) comes from a Hebrew word meaning "the anointed one.” It is the belief system based upon Jesus Christ, whose death and resurrection eradicated the need for Judaic Law (a faith system based upon rituals, works, and sacrifices) and offered salvation through simple faith in one ultimate atonement. The word “mysticism”...

Words: 1465 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

The Mystical Within an Embodied Experience

...Theories and Methods in the Study of Religion The Mystical Within An Embodied Experience The term ‘religion’ has come to mean a wide variety of things over the years. It has ranged from “a statement of faith” (Gill, 968) to an element constructed to justify a human need for purpose in life. In the most distinguished writers of philosophy, religion, anthropology and psychology, the interpretations of religion and it forces within society, vary as much as their individual specialization fields. Thinkers have always had something to say about the experiences believers encounter when they immerse themselves in their deep-rooted belief systems. They reiterate, agree with, reject, and even propagate the theses brought forth by both past thinkers and their own contemporaries. In the writings of Friedrich Schleiermacher, Rudolf Otto, William James, Richard King, and Alan Cole, the view of how individuals and groups make religion an experience they embody through their actions both individually and as a result of the mystical aspects within the religion, is discussed expansively. These thoughts have led to deeply analytical observations of religious followers who allow themselves to have a more intimate embodied experience within their beliefs. In the writings of Friedrich Schleiermacher and William James, both philosophers, important observations referring to the mystical essence of religion were established. These thinkers were revolutionizing the way people thought about the religious...

Words: 2499 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Philosophy

...| Philosophy 101-01 | 9/21/2012 | | The definition of division causes a basis of argument in Plato’s “Euthyphro”. While awaiting trial, Euthyphro explains that he has brought his father in front of the Judge with a murder charge. The idea of bring one’s own father to court brings forth room for debate between Socrates and Euthyphro. The main question being what is the definition of piety? The main reason that Socrates asks this question is so that he can use the answer to defend himself, but while searching for the definition they find much controversy in Euthyphro’s action of bringing his father to court. It is clear that Socrates is looking for a universal definition of piety, in which all actions can be measure to determine whether or not they are pious. In order for the definition to be universal it must express what is essential about the thing being defined. The word piety was defined several ways throughout the reading. At first Euthyphro explains that “piety is what he is doing now, that is prosecuting his father for manslaughter (Plato 5d ).” Socrates disagrees stating that it was not a definition but simply an example of piety and therefore does not provide a fundamental characteristic which makes a pious thing pious. Euthyphro then continues to explain in his second definition that “piety is what is pleasing to the gods (Plato 6e-7a).” Socrates consents to this definition because it is expressed in a general form, but then criticizes it on the...

Words: 1384 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Kabir Das and Communcation

...also among common man and youth. This article is an attempt to throw light on the various dimensions of Kabir Das’s literature and how it is still effectively communicated and in turn is used for effective communication. This paper contemplates on the varied aspects of kabir’s literature. Kabir’s literature is known for elements of mysticism, spirituality, concept of love, his objectivity in imparting moral education, his attack on vices of human behavior, hypocrisy and materialistic attitude. All these aspects are dominantly reflected in his literary works and are still relevant in today’s social scenarios which are well communicated in the form of his well remembered ‘Dohas’ and poetry. Hence, it is concluded that Kabir’s literature, in spite of being so old and classical is timeless and well applicable and connected with today’s era. His ‘Dohas’ makes an integral part of our day to day communication. Hence, it can be said that, Kabir Das has communicated with the society and is still communicating and will continue to do so through his literature which will never loose its relevance in any of the ages Keywords: Kabir’s literature, mysticism, objectivity, value education, attack on vices of society, communicator, timeless....

Words: 3877 - Pages: 16

Free Essay

Mysticism

...Mysticism, according to its history, implies a relation to mystery. Mysticism is the spiritual quest in any religion for the most direct experience of God. Mysticism is widely practiced in Eastern religions and concentrates on prayer, meditation, contemplation, and fasting to produce the attitude necessary for what is believed to be a direct encounter with the spiritual realm (Bouyer, 1981). Typically, mystics, theistic or not, see their mystical experience as part of a larger undertaking aimed at human transformation (Teresa of Avila, Life, Chapter 19) and not as the terminus of their efforts. Mysticism has been an intimate part of human society, as a still-unexplainable part of nature, the divine forces over God’s existences, as well as the supernatural, that has allured and guided many to look as far as into the future for answers and as close as deep into themselves and an exploration of the unconscious mind. The many tools of Mysticism, like the Tarot, numerology, astrology, and dreams, are all used to provide insights into a "deeper consciousness" and a "higher plane of existence," which when properly interpreted could very well shed light into the murkiest situation. In today's societies, Mysticism continues to intrigue, appeal to, entertain and aid people across cultures that force us to question the existence of God and Man and develop a sense of understanding for Man’s relationship to God. Mysticism has made significant changes in reshaping the mines of people towards...

Words: 1666 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Hum 130 Appendix C Vocabulary Quiz

...Axia College Material Appendix C HUM 130 Week 1 Vocabulary Quiz | |Define these terms in your own words. | |1. Immanent |A natural part of something or someone | |2. Religion |Someone’s beliefs that can include customs and rituals usually have to do with GOD. | |3. Theistic |Theistic believing in a personal creator GOD | |4. Monotheistic |Monotheistic believing there is only one GOD | |5. Profane |Profane unclean or not pure | |6. Polytheistic |Polytheistic belief in many GODS | |7. Monistic |Monistic the belief that all is one | |8. Dogma |Dogma a belief statement or principle believed to be true, sometimes set by church | | | | |9. Nontheistic | The rejection of theism, or a non belief in any GODS...

Words: 338 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

On Meister Eckhart

...Ibalio 1  Charles Ibalio  Mystery of God/Human Person  Prof. Cifone    On Meister Eckhart: The Culling of Worldly Thought    What we have documented and observed from Meister Eckhart, among many things, is  that he was a man of multiple names, of several titles, and of many roles.  He was born in  in  1260 in Gotha, in the Holy Roman empire, as Johannes Eckhart.  In his young adulthood, he  would join the Dominican Order through the Friars Preacher at the young age of fifteen.  Studying, traveling, and teaching, he would live those years in some of the best academic  settings possible, travelling from Germany and across Paris (McGinn 10).  He would write one  of his first works, The Talks of Instruction, at an age where his mastery in theology had not yet  come to full fruition, yet it would reveal his sheer potential as a thinker, as McGinn notes: “It is  indeed striking how little change there is in the principal structures of his thought between this  exciting early work and the later, more sophisticated, sermons of his maturity” (10).  Moving on  to administrative roles for the following decade, he would be known as Eckhart von Hochheim  O.P., and would often be compared to St. Thomas Aquinas, who was recorded to achieve similar  feats during his time as a Dominican (11).    Following his years as an administrative chair, he would become a Vicar­General in  Strasburg, sent to tackle the spreading “heresy” among Beguines, a religious community of  women at the time (11)...

Words: 4158 - Pages: 17

Free Essay

Empedocles

...A philosopher, poet, politician, and visionary, Empedocles of Acragas developed radical new ideas about the nature of the universe. His philosophy of the four elements in the universe and the definition of matter as the various ratios of these elements foreshadowed later developments in atomic theory by philosophers such as Democritus of Abdera (c. 460–c. 370 B.C.). Empedocles was born in Acragas, Sicily. His father, Meto, was wealthy, and his grandfather, also named Empedocles, was renowned for winning a horse race in the Olympia. Empedocles is believed to have travelled to Thourioi shortly after it was established approximately 444 B.C. Empedocles's keen intellect enabled him to combine talents in philosophy, natural history, poetry, and politics, and to achieve superstar status in his day. According to the Greek philosopher Aristotle (384–322 B.C.), Empedocles was the inventor of rhetoric, a talent Empedocles often utilized as a statesman. He became popular among his fellow citizens through his support of democracy. Empedocles's scientific inquiries usually included mysticism. However, his philosophies contained early insight into basic laws of physics, including atomic theory. Although sometimes labeled a Pythagorean, Empedocles followed the Greek philosopher Parmenides (c. 515–c. 445 B.C.) in the belief that matter (or, "what is") is indestructible. Empedocles claimed that matter was the only principle of all things and that four elements in the universe—air, fire, earth...

Words: 548 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Essay On Pure Consciousness Experience

...Matt (1997) also argues that “emptying out” is having one's mind on no object other than God, rather than an absolute emptiness of content. These seem really to be cases of extrovertive mysticism designed to get the practitioner not to think consciously about oneself, often for the purpose of achieving humility, compassion, and selflessness. Bagger (1999) makes an interesting and similar point, “if the Pure Consciousness Event contains absolutely no conscious content, I fail to see how the mystic could possibly remember anything about the experience….To remember an experience an individual must experience it as something”. This in contradiction to nothingness pointed by Forman (1986). A person, or other entity, is conscious if they experience something; conversely, if a person or entity experiences nothing they are not conscious. When consciousness is present, phenomenal content (consciousness of something) is present. Conversely...

Words: 1708 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Eastern Educational Philosophies

...Eastern Educational Philosophies Abstract Hinduism, Buddhism, and Confucianism are compared for historical, ideology, and epistemology, searching for Eastern Philosophy compatible to Western Philosophy. A research for possible influences on Education of Philosophy discovered that it was impossible to bring comparisons and even difficult to separate them into the key issues. Colonialism and Nationalism brings the two philosophies together. Even though the Western mindset can appreciate the fascination concepts it may be impossible to blend East and West. However, it is possible to juxtapose the very different philosophies as it may be represented in the arts. Even Western Philosopher who have been influenced by Eastern Philosophy, it is reasonable to believe it is the philosophers attempt to interpret Eastern Philosophy. However, it is impossible to replicate it. Instead the product is a hybrid and independent of either East or West. Eastern Educational Philosophies Eastern philosophy has a long and varied history. Asian ideas are among the oldest in the world. Great thinkers of the East have developed sophisticated cultural and political systems that have influenced other religions as well as western philosophy. This paper will examine ideological, epistemological, and historical differences in Hinduism, Buddhism, and Confucianism. Ways in which these philosophies have shaped higher education theory and practice are of major importance to educators. ...

Words: 2209 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Humanities 102

...Paper Marlon Chambers HUM/102 Jan 22, 2015 Nancy Erickson Humanities Today Paper In this paper, I will discuss humanities. I will differentiate between the humanities and other modes of human inquiry and expression. I shall list types of humanities and explain why each one gives reflects current developments in politics, socioeconomics, and technology. Colorado State University defines humanities as, “The branches of learning (such as philosophy or languages) that investigate human constructs and concerns, as opposed to natural processes. The humanities, such as classical and modern languages, literature, history, and philosophy, have the overall goal of the exploration and explanation of human experience.” Art has long been a means of expressing social or political ideas. Anselm Kiefer took art and brought it to an entirely new level by using his art to bring attention to national identity and collective memory. In the process his art began evolving to include occult symbolism, theology, and mysticism. All of his work shares a common theme of the trauma experienced by entire societies and the continual rebirth and renewal in life. Music defines periods of history as well as generations. It evolves with societies/cultures and tends to give people their identity. Music has a strong connection through celebration, remembrance, expression of emotions, and ministering to others. It allows the human race to connect to their own humanity...

Words: 866 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Religions

...Following Questions 1. Discuss Sikhism as a syncretism between Hinduism and Islam. Which features has it taken from each religion? Scholars account the development from context of a conversation amongst Hinduism and Islamic mysticism. The worldview is taken from Hinduism and the oneness of god impacted the Sikhs and their literature. 2. What factors worked to turn the pacific movement of Nanak into the warrior caste of later Sikhism? The torture and death of Arjan and execution of Singh. 3. List the three major sects of Sikhism. What are the major characteristics of each? Udasis- order of holy men who follow the rules and principles that govern Hindu, Janism, and Buddhism. Sahajdharis- conservative and slowgoing, reject militant characteristics. Singhs- theology of reincarnation, non use of stimulants long hair on heads and faces. Chapter Eight: Chinese Religions Page 203: Answer the Following Questions 1. Are Taoism and Confucianism truly religions? Argue both sides. They are truly religions because they embody the concept of religion. Taoism cannot be classified as a religion with certain doctrines and practices but it has been converted to one with prescence of gods, temples, priests, and sacrifices. Confucianism is more of a philosophy of the Chinese people and has no sacred writings priesthood etc. but it has affected Chinese character and created cultic development. 2. Describe the Chinese concept of the yin and yang as a unifying explanation for the...

Words: 323 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Paul's Prison Letters

...1. How were the churches in the Lycus Valley founded? (Polhill pp. 330-331) The churches appear to have been established by Paul’s coworker Epaphras, who was a native Colossian. Luke indicated that during Paul’s ministry in Ephesus all the Jews and Greeks who lived in the province of Asia heard the word of the Lord. Paul followed his usual missionary strategy of establishing himself in a major city with his coworkers fanning out into the countryside to establish churches in the wider region. The Lycus Valley churches were a product of Paul’s Ephesian ministry. Epaphras served as Paul’s coworker, establishing the churches there. Paul did consider them his churches, as they were the product of his apostolic ministry. When difficulties arose in them, Epapharas turned to Paul for guidance and assistance. Colossians is the product of that relationship. 2. Describe each of the three cities in the Lycus Valley. (Pohill pp. 331-332) Laodicea was a new fairly city, having been founded by the Seleucid king Antiochus II in 250 B.C. and then under direct Roman rule in 133 B.C. when the last of the kings of Pergamum bequeathed his kingdom in Rom. In Paul’s day, Laodicea was the most prominent city of the Lycus Valley; it was the tax-gathering and judicial center for the whole administrative area, which consisted of twenty-seven towns, including Hierapolis and Colosse. It was prosperous, boasting a thriving industry in black woolen goods and a famous medical center...

Words: 2493 - Pages: 10