Free Essay

National Response Plan

In: Other Topics

Submitted By eireone
Words 2281
Pages 10
MSSM 517- Critical Infrastructure
Weekly Assignment 2.2

Weekly Assignment:

Provide a detailed description of the National Response Plan (NRP). How has your local government cooperated with the NRP? Pick a U.S. city if located outside of the U.S.

The government of the United States has experienced and continues to establish consistent, often times comprehensive changes to the way it accomplishes Emergency Response operations. The catastrophic events of both September 11, 2001 and the lingering tragedy of Hurricane Katrina proved to be instantaneous prompts for the evolution of governmental amendment to and eventual restructure of the overarching procedural standard for incident response in the country. One of the many important after-effects would become what was labeled the National Response Framework, or NRF.

A detailed outline of the NRF structure and intent follows. The template is a doctrinal approach to the domestic partnerships and implementation of resources above and beyond those rules set by the National Incident Management System (NIMS) and the Incident Command System (ICS) (FEMA, 2012). The sole purpose of the 90-page document is to ensure that government executives, private sector, nongovernmental organization (NGO) leaders, and emergency management practitioners across the nation understand domestic incident response roles, responsibilities and relationships in order to respond more effectively to any type of incident.
General administrators of NRF-specific guidance will typically be policy-level personnel or heads-of-agencies, who directly or strategically coordinate echelon and subordinate agencies at all eventual layers of government emergency response. It is guided mainly by the data and regulatory information offered to emergency managers at the NRF Resource Center, and eventually rests within the realm of the Federal Emergency Management Agency or FEMA. NRF is generally held to have been the much-needed modification to American disaster response, ultimately superseding what was known as the National Response Plan (2004, under HSPD-5)… in the wake of publicly perceived failures within the United States government’s ability to respond and coordinate incident response measures after Hurricanes Katrina and Irene. In the year 2006, the Post-Katrina Emergency Management Reform Act (S. 3721, 2006) set the stage for NRF and in what would be perhaps one of its most sweeping measures, the government transitioned the authority for national disaster mitigation to the FEMA Administrator for emergency management, who serves in an advisory capacity to the President of the United States. The billet is currently held by Mr. William Craig Fugate (FEMA, 2012).

A key method in which the NRF is kept current is one that is particularly easy to classify as an innovative and an appropriate manner in which to ensure relevance in the NRF’s doctrine. It routinely adds and updates annexes to its charter so as to allow for coordination instructions and specific guidance under various worst-case types of scenarios. As with any evolving (and often times bureaucracy-laden) governmental agency, there are measures of success and shortcoming (s) to be expected. Overall, however, it is obvious that the NRF provides a vastly improved approach to high-level oversight and distribution of subordinate mandates in the wake of a catastrophe. As stated by Senator Joe Lieberman (2012) in his comments on the draft of the NRF:
I am pleased DHS consulted with state and local stakeholders to produce a comprehensive and coherent plan for responding to disasters of all sorts when they occur… I am particularly pleased the final National Response Framework, unlike an earlier draft, recognizes the larger role the Post-Katrina Act gave to the FEMA Administrator for emergency management. (p. 1)
It is clear to understand the urgent need, especially in light of fiscal and specialized capabilities offered by FEMA, to assign the Framework’s primary coordination responsibility to the Administrator. This was clearly an effective and well-based move.

As previously stated, however, there are challenges in the NRF which, to date, have not been brought to light during a real-world national crisis, at least not to the scale of 9/11 or Hurricane Katrina. One would certainly be that of some confusion on certain areas of responsibility and authority for assigned personnel such as Principal Federal Officials (or PFO’s) and Federal Coordination Officers (FCO’s). This disconnect, and other potential shortcomings for the initiative, are echoed by Paul Stockton (2007), a Senior Research Scholar at Stanford University, when he states:

Confusion over those coordination roles undermined federal response efforts in Katrina, and should be further clarified in the Framework. The current draft of the that document is also silent on a number of outstanding issues for structuring the U.S. response to catastrophes, including that of the special circumstances in which the president would designate the Department of Defense (as opposed to FEMA and DHS) to serve as the lead federal agency for response activities. (p. 6)
In all though, it is safe to say that the National Response Framework, or NRF, is an effective- albeit fluid- mandate for the hugely multifaceted issue of American Emergency Management, especially when considering policy-level directives. NRF has clearly demonstrated some successes. Among them would be placing authority at the highest level appropriately under FEMA and the inception of an innovative web-based centralized resource center, complete with updated and extremely concise annexes for consumption by subordinate players in nearly any incident response. Of course, its challenges remain and are likely to be proven when least desired, in the midst of a national or regional crisis. It very well may be the Framework’s likely biggest failure is that it does not seem to prevent the eventual duplication or omission of efforts by certain leaders because of vague guidance.

The National Response Framework establishes a comprehensive all-hazards approach to enhance the ability of the U.S. to manage its domestic incidents. It forms the foundation of how federal branches and agencies will strategize collectively on how the federal government will coordinate with state, local, and tribal governments and the private sector entities during incidents. It establishes procedures to help protect the nation from terrorist attacks and other major disasters. The United States’ national economy is in shambles; this includes many of our States. States should concentrate on using budgetary resources in a manner that will encourage State purpose-capacity and advancement. The NRF will permit the State governments to do just that. It may be best to have the States work their budget instead of actually running into a deficit and having to seek financial help from other entities. The NRF is built on a strong foundation and with continued cooperation between private sector and government officials protecting the citizens will remain an achievable task.
How has your local government cooperated with the NRP? Pick a U.S. city if located outside of the U.S.
Pensacola, Florida
The U.S. Department of Commerce, United States’ Census Bureau estimates Pensacola, Florida to have a population of 52,197 as of 2011 (US Census Bureau, 2011). Historic Pensacola serves as the county seat of Escambia County, Florida and is nicknamed the “City of Five Flags” in recognition of Spain, France, Britain, The Confederacy of the United States and the United States, each who have flown flags of government since the city’s founding in 1559 by a Spanish explorer named Tristán de Luna y Arellano. Pensacola is also considered to be the United States’ first established settlement. This distinction, along with the sandy, white beaches of Pensacola Beach brings with it a tremendous influx of tourists every year. It is estimated that $1.5 billion is spent by flocking tourists each year.

Pensacola sits in what is known as “Hurricane Alley”, in the Northwestern part of the Florida panhandle. Many of the deadliest, most costly and damaging storms to hit the Continental United States have blown right through Pensacola. Major hurricanes that have made landfall at or near Pensacola include Eloise (1975), Frederic (1979), Juan (1985), Erin (1995), Opal (1995), Georges (1998), Ivan (2004), and Dennis (2005) (Hurricane City.com, 2012). This makes adhering to and cooperating with the National Response Framework and absolute requirement. Since Pensacola is part of Escambia County it follows the County Emergency Management Plan (CEMP), which is in full cooperation with the NRF guidelines.
The Escambia County Comprehensive Emergency Management Plan (CEMP) dated 2011 states the following:
The Escambia County CEMP is the product of a detailed and focused planning process that: 1) fully incorporates the National Incident Management System (NIMS) concepts, principles, practices and language; 2) capitalizes on the lessons learned from tropical weather incidents, exercises, and other recent disasters; and 3) incorporates plans, programs and policies that have emerged since the last revision of the CEMP. As such, the CEMP describes the basic strategies, assumptions, operational goals, objectives, and mechanisms through which the County will mobilize resources and conduct activities to guide and support emergency management efforts through preparedness, response, recovery and mitigation. (p. 6)

The Local Emergency Operations Center operates on three levels of activation. As stated by The Escambia County Comprehensive Emergency Management Plan (2011) they are as follows:
Level 1: Full Scale Activation
At this level, all primary and support Emergency Support Functions under the
CEMP are activated. The EOC is activated with all personnel in response to a major incident/disaster and may remain activated at this level for several weeks. Level 2: Partial Activation
At this level, the EOC is activated only with the necessary primary and support Emergency Support Function personnel needed to handle a small or short-term incident. Level 3: Monitoring Activation
Level 3 is typically a “monitoring “phase. Notification will be made to those
Emergency Support Functions and/or Departments who would need to take action as part of their everyday responsibilities. The County Emergency
Operations Center will be staffed with Department of Public Safety Personnel. (app. C)

Although untested by any international terrorist event, the Escambia County Emergency Operations Center has proven itself successful time and again during many natural disasters, especially during the months of June through October, primary hurricane season.

Due to Escambia County having several different organizations, people, and jurisdictions, coordinating for an incident requires a unified command structure to bring all parties together in one command structure that coordinates all aspects of disaster preparedness, response, recovery, and mitigation. The Public Safety Bureau (2011) states the following:

In any terrorism incident in Escambia County, State and federal assets will play a significant role; therefore a unified command structure under the Incident Command System (ICS) is of vital importance in the management of any incident. Escambia County promotes the use of incident or unified command on scene for any type of response, as well as, the management structure utilized in the County Emergency Operations Center. (p. 17)

The NIMS Incident Command Structure (ICS) provides the needed structure. Within the ICS, the Emergency Support Function (ESF) groups help bridge the gap between political and geographical boundaries for a more seamless response. The chart below depicts the current structure of Escambia County’s Incident Command Structure. Figure (1) The Escambia County Comprehensive Emergency Management Plan (2011)

Although the above chart details Escambia County, the city of Pensacola adheres to and falls within this command structure. This command structure is created in accordance with the NRF Resource Center’s requirements.
Within the NRF are five key principles, (1) engaged partnerships, (2) tiered response, (3) scalable, flexible, and adaptable operational capabilities, (4) unity of effort through unified command and (5) readiness to act (DHS, 2008). In support of these five key principles are the fifteen Emergency Support Functions (ESF). The city of Pensacola lists the following ESFs: Fire Service, Health and Medical, Search and Rescue, Hazardous Materials, Military Support, Law Enforcement, Transportation, Communication, Public Works, Energy, Mass Care, Food and Water, Volunteers and Donations, Animal Protection and Business and Industry (Public Safety Bureau, 2011).

With Pensacola having the ESFs that clearly follow the guidelines set forth by the NRF in place, goals and objectives properly identified, competent and qualified personnel in position and a monitoring system to measure the effectiveness of the overall plan, the citizens and business’ in the area can rest assured that their safety and wellbeing are first priority of both the public and private sectors.

References:

(2011). State & County Quick Facts. United States' Census Bureau. Retrieved February 19, 2013 from U.S. Department of Commerce. http://quickfacts.census.gov/qfd/states/12/1255925.html

(2012). Pensacola, Florida's history with tropical systems. Hurricane City.com. Retrieved February 19, 2013 from http://www.hurricanecity.com/city/pensacola.htm

DHS. (2008). National Response Framework. (P-682). 8. Washington D.C. http://www.fema.gov/NRF.

FEMA. (2012). National Response Framework Fact Sheet. Retrieved February 18, 2013, from Department of Homeland Security website: http://www.fema.gov/pdf/emergency/nrf/NRFOnePageFactSheet.pdf FEMA. (2012). William Craig Fugate. Retrieved February 18, 2013, from fema.gov website: http://www.fema.gov/about/bios/wfugate.shtm

Lieberman, J. (2008). National Response Framework Represents a Good Start. Retrieved February 18, 2013, from US Senate website: http://lieberman.senate.gov/index.cfm/news-events/news/2008/1/national-response-framework-represents-a-good-start

Public Safety Bureau. (2011). Escambia County Comprehensive Emergency Management Plan. 6. Pensacola, Florida. Retrieved February 18, 2013 from http://myescambia.com/sites/myescambia.com/files/CEMPEntirePlan.pdf

S. 3721--109th Congress: Post-Katrina Emergency Management Reform Act of 2006. (2006). In www.GovTrack.us. Retrieved February 18, 2013, from http://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/109/s3721

Stockton, P. N. (2007). Hearing on Readiness in the Post Katrina and Post 9/11 World: An Evaluation of the new National Response Framework [Testimony]. Retrieved February 18, 2013, from Stanford University website:
http://iis-db.stanford.edu/pubs/21979/Stockton_T&I.pdf

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Nrf Preparedness Cycle

...NRF Preparedness Cycle The National Response Framework (NRF) is the Nation’s guide on how to conduct effective responses through all-hazards. The strategic framework is built upon a foundation adaptable coordinating structures that are scalable, flexible, and to align key roles and responsibilities across the Nation. The NRF defines specific authorities and best exercises for managing incidents that range from the serious but merely local, to surprise terrorist attacks or catastrophic natural disasters. The document explains the common discipline and structures that have been implemented and developed at the local, tribal, State, and national levels over time. It explains strategic lessons gained from natural disasters such as Hurricanes Katrina and Rita, concentrating particularly on how the Federal Government is organized to aid local communities and States in devastating incidents. First and foremost, it contributes to the National Incident Management System (NIMS), which offers a stable template for managing incidents at all levels of government. (Office of the Press Secretary, 2008) The sole purpose of the 90-page document is to ensure that government executives, private sector, nongovernmental organization (NGO) leaders, and emergency management practitioners across the nation understand domestic incident response roles, responsibilities and relationships in order to respond more effectively to any type of incident. (Maniscalco, 2011) One of the interesting areas...

Words: 1054 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Disaser Management

... 1. How is a response to destruction from a terrorist incident different from a response to a natural disaster? Be specific, give examples, and quote from the readings. 2. You are a volunteer for the American Red Cross. You are to enter a scene of destruction in order to assist wounded victims. What are some precautions that you must take? What are some restrictions placed on you? From whom do you receive clearance? 3. First responders should isolate hazards by establishing control zones. There are three types of control zones. List them and give examples. Cite your sources. Difference Between Response to Destruction By Terrorist and Natural Disaster Previous to the National Response network there were various differences on how and when agencies responded to incidents by terrorist groups or natural disasters. Prior to the 11 September 2001 attack on the Pentagon, the plane crash in Pennsylvania, the World Trade Center, and the 2005 Hurricanes Rita and Katrina the Federal Response Plan existed which primarily focused on the Federal roles and responsibilities during an emergency or disaster incident. By using the lessons learned and the response to the hurricane season in 2005 the National Response Plan was replaced by the Federal Response Plan. The United States has dealt with a number of unprecedented disasters and emergencies from small incidents to major catastrophes. The development of the National Response Framework (NRF)...

Words: 1775 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Politics

...A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE BP OIL SPILL RESPONSE AND PREPAREDNESS PLAN FOR THE DEEP HORIZON – WHY DID IT FAIL? Toni Josina Elfrieda Beukes* May 2012† ABSTRACT: Based on events that unfolded in the U.S. in the weeks and subsequently months of the Macondo well blow-out, it is clear that neither industry nor government was equipped to deal with a spill the scale and complexity of the Deepwater Horizon disaster. As one of its key recommendations to President Obama for addressing the causes and consequences of the spill, the National Commission on the BP Deepwater Horizon Oil Spill in its final report, stated the need for “strengthening oil spill response, planning and capacity”. Industry best practice dictates that quickness and accuracy are key requirements for effective oil spill response and preparedness planning (OSRPP); yet it took nearly three months to seal the Macondo well. This paper is accordingly concerned with the reasons for the apparent failure of the BP oil spill response plan. This failure will be considered in light of current international environmental regulations on OSRPP and applicable United States legislation, whilst assessing the BP oil spill response plan’s compliance therewith. The study will also consider some theory in the development of OSRPP by looking specifically at risk assessment tools and applying key criteria to the BP oil spill response plan to determine its adequacy and appropriateness for its operations in the GOM. What...

Words: 9068 - Pages: 37

Premium Essay

Historical Studies

...Order Title Name Institution Course Date Crisis plan Hurricane Katrina was considered as one of the most destructive disaster in the history of the U.S. The extent of damage and level of response during the occurrence of the crisis was a clear indication, that the government lacked management plans and procedures needed to mitigate the outcome. One of the plans that were put into action in the state of Mississippi was the use of the National Guard to enhance relief operations. This was part of the overall plan, the “National Response plan” (Dudley, 2006). This paper aims at evaluating strategies and situations during the occurrence of the Hurricane Katrina Natural Disaster. By so doing, workable strategies are highlighted and the reasons behind their use supported with due consideration to resource availability. The paper further presents an analysis of the Mississippi crisis plan whileexplaining the efficacy of elements selected for the “National Response Plan” consequently stating how the plan could be relevant in either Louisiana or Alabama.The paper summarizes by presenting missing elements. From the journal ‘After Katrina: Building back better than ever’ which is a report by James Barksdale who is the Chairman of the Governor’s Commission on Recovery, Building and Renewal, it is made rife that the ‘National Response Plan’ (NRP) was a workable strategy that provided a big boost to the disaster management efforts made by the American government (Governor's Commission on Recovery...

Words: 957 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

“National Preparedness, as a Whole Community

...Assignment 2: “National Preparedness, as a Whole Community” A look at the National Preparedness Frameworks “National Preparedness, as a Whole Community” The United States has a National Preparedness framework in which Federal State Local and Non-Governmental agencies utilize in order to safeguard the citizen Property and assets of this great nation. (Staff, FEMA, 2015)The National Preparedness framework outlines 5 key areas in which aid and support may be administered to areas affect by natural economic and man-made catastrophes. By looking at and understanding the Framework of the National Preparedness plan, one can better understand how this Nation can come together in times of great need. When to utilize this Preparedness plan and when the individual Agencies and governmental bodies may enact the measures required, even when not specifically requested. In the event of great disaster comes the will of the people to survive. It is the people who must learn from the past to mitigate for the future and prepare for the unknown. By having a National Preparedness plan and Governmental Acts, Such as the Robert T. Stafford Act. (Staff, FEMA, 2015) The Nation can prepare for events that are unavoidable. The National Preparedness plan is a Plan that enables the Community to act as a whole by utilizing a five stage system to achieve one goal. As per Presidential Policy Directive / PPD-8. (Staff, DHS, 2011) The National Preparedness plan encompasses five stages to create the...

Words: 1834 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

1350

...Order Code RL31285 CRS Report for Congress Received through the CRS Web FEMA’s Mission: Policy Directives for the Federal Emergency Management Agency Updated March 13, 2002 Keith Bea Specialist, American National Government Government and Finance Division Congressional Research Service ˜ The Library of Congress FEMA’s Mission: Policy Directives for the Federal Emergency Management Agency Summary The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) assists states and localities overwhelmed by, or at risk from, disasters. FEMA also coordinates federal emergency management activities and planning for the continuity of government should national security be threatened. Since 1979 FEMA has administered a range of authorities that enable the agency to serve as the primary source of federal technical and financial assistance for emergency management. Among the types of aid provided through FEMA programs are grants and material to help disaster victims meet pressing needs such as food and shelter, education and training programs to improve the response capabilities of nonfederal officials, and mobile communications equipment. FEMA exercises little regulatory authority, but directives that underlie the agency’s mission authorize the agency to establish standards for reconstruction of buildings after a disaster declaration is issued, for the construction of federal buildings in earthquake-prone areas, and for the operation of first responder equipment. FEMA has responded...

Words: 9516 - Pages: 39

Premium Essay

Hiv and Aids

...INTRODUCTION The following paper will serve the purpose of analysing the policy response to HIV and AIDS in Kenya as a case study in East Africa. Kenya has the main organisation which facilitates and controls various HIV and aids policy strategic response which is the national aids control council (NACC). It is the mandate of the Kenya Ministry of Health (MoH) to deliver quality, affordable health care to all citizens of Kenya. Various strategic documents have outlined plans towards achieving this goal, including the Second National Health Sector Strategic Plan (NHSSP II, 2005-2010) and the Kenya National AIDS Strategic Plan (KNASP, 2005-2010).They are various other documents which include the HIV and AIDS Prevention and Control Act, 2006 Sexual Offences Act, 2006 Children’s Act, 2001 Medical Laboratory Act, 1999 Science and Technology Act, 1980 Public Health Act (Cap 242) HIV prevalence in Kenya is estimated based on the Demographic and Health Survey (2003 and 2008/9), AIDS Indicator Surveys (KAIS 2007 and 2012) and Antenatal Clinic (ANC) sentinel surveillance. A trend analysis starting from 1990 shows that prevalence in the general population reached a peak of 10.5% in 1995‐96, after which it declined by about 40% to reach approximately 6.7% in 2003. Since then, the prevalence has remained relatively stable. The decline of the prevalence from 1995 to 2003 is partly attributed to high AIDS related mortality while the stabilisation of the epidemic in the last 10 years is...

Words: 2856 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Hurricane Katrina

...Katrina and the devastation that followed, revealed many weaknesses in the country's structure regarding a national emergency response system. The issues identified as the Federal Government attempted to respond to the situation revealed numerous area's of opportunity, regarding the country's lack of readiness to respond. Some of the challenges that surfaced with the wake of Katrina: Ineffective National Preparedness, Public Communication, Public Safety, Search and Rescue and Homeland Security Professional Development and Education to name a few. These challenges made it impossible for the Federal Government to provide a timely and effective response to the devastation. With the challenges that surfaced, it became apparent that new policies would need to be implemented in order to prevent the breakdown and lack of preparedness experienced with Katrina. The first being a need to adopt an effective policy regarding National Preparedness, our current system does not provide the framework to manage the challenges that may surface as a result of natural diasters. There were four critical flaws identified as the Federal Government attempted to respond to Katrina: Processes for unified management of the national response; command and control within the Federal government; knowledge of our preparedness plans; and regional planning...

Words: 812 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Crisis Management Plan Military

...CRISIS MANAGEMENT 1 I am going to discuss a crisis management plan, “Terrorism and the Military’s Role in Domestic Crisis Management”. This crisis management plan will explore how to reviews the current legislation and policies that govern the military’s role when supporting law enforcement in a domestic terrorism crisis and highlights some of the issues confronting the U.S. government. To fully understand the military’s role in domestic crisis response it is necessary to explore existing national level structures and response options prior to the involvement of military forces. (Terrorism and the Military’s Role in Domestic Crisis Management, 2003) Crisis management is predominately a law enforcement function that manages the resources necessary to prevent or resolve a terrorist incident. Current U.S. government terrorism response policy is contained in presidential directives. Among other matters, these directives address National Security Council structure and federal agency crisis response roles when responding to a domestic terrorism incident. (Terrorism and the Military’s Role in Domestic Crisis Management, 2003, CRS6, para 3, line 7). National Security Council (NSC), U.S. agency within the Executive Office of the President, established by the National Security Act in 1947 to advise the president on domestic, foreign, and military policies related to national security. (National Security Council, 2012). Terrorism involves the use or threat of violence...

Words: 2637 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

National Disaster Management

...NATIONAL DISASTER MANAGEMENT SYSTEM 1. Introduction. Pakistan is located in a region which is prone to number of natural disasters. Due to its diverse range of terrain and existence of fault lines, the country is susceptible to wide ranging hazards from earthquake to droughts and floods to cyclones. Pakistan has suffered floods almost every year as monsoon rains cause rivers to outflow from their banks. The country also experiences earthquake regularly ranging from moderate to severe in intensity. We have been suffering from drought like situation of varying degrees from many years and the coastal areas are prone to cyclones. There is no comprehensive, integrated disaster management policy at national level for dealing with major disasters like earthquake of 2005 and floods of 2010 and 2011 partially due to limited resources, economic instability and partially due to absence of well trained and equipped disaster management infrastructure. We also lack proper system for disaster prevention and preparedness that could ensure effective mitigation to reduce the loss of life and property damage in the face of a natural disaster. 2. Disaster management is unfortunately seen as provision of relief rather than the management of all of its phases and long term management of risk. We therefore need a comprehensive preparedness, prevention and mitigation strategy with a view to better manage and coordinate activities of various line ministries, departments and civil society. Pakistan...

Words: 12254 - Pages: 50

Premium Essay

Disaster

...are these plans related to the National Response Framework? Emergency and disaster planning at the State and local government is the main starting point for any natural or man-made disaster and even terrorist incidents. State and local government officials are entrusted with protecting and providing emergency assistance to the local populous. Not only are they responsible for dealing with many issues but also, emergency and disaster planning would be at the top of the list. You could look at many different states and compare their emergency and disaster planes and most would have the same basic concepts “Who will do what, When, and what resources”. Emergency and disaster planning at the state level is all about being prepared and having a well formulated plane that has been fine tuned and activated either in an actual or table top exercise. The main components of a sound plan would include but not limited to: Mitigation, Preparedness, Response and Recovery. All four of these phases are key to all state response plans, each state has it written into their response plan, in the event local and state assets are depleted or inadequate to handle the emergency or disaster they will request help from the federal government, the lead agency in this case would be FEMA. Plans formulated at the state level are similar to the National Response Framework. The National Response Framework...

Words: 630 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Responding in Crises: a Comparative Analysis of Disaster Responses Between Mainland China and Taiwan

...Issue 1 2012 Article 31 Responding in Crises: A Comparative Analysis of Disaster Responses between Mainland China and Taiwan Chun-Chieh MA, National University of Tainan, Harvard University Recommended Citation: MA, Chun-Chieh (2012) "Responding in Crises: A Comparative Analysis of Disaster Responses between Mainland China and Taiwan," Journal of Homeland Security and Emergency Management: Vol. 9: Iss. 1, Article 31. ©2012 De Gruyter. All rights reserved. Authenticated | bee_and_tom@hotmail.com Download Date | 9/16/12 10:06 AM Responding in Crises: A Comparative Analysis of Disaster Responses between Mainland China and Taiwan Chun-Chieh MA Abstract The management of crisis events involves activity at the organizational and governmental jurisdiction levels and is comprised of an integrated system of practice and structure. However, because there are two systems involved in crisis response, namely centralization and decentralization of disaster management, there are differences in governmental actions in response to crisis events. This article analyzes and compares the actions of disaster responses undertaken by mainland China and Taiwan when faced with major natural disasters in order to demonstrate the different response results and defects of centralized and decentralized crisis response systems, respectively. The results showed that the efficiency of decentralized response systems is higher than that of centralized systems, as respondents in a decentralized...

Words: 5900 - Pages: 24

Premium Essay

Mhe 512 Module 1 Case Assignment

...Objectives:  For this case you are discuss the response by government, NGOs and volunteer groups to Hurricane Katrina. The question for you to answer is whether or not the organizational structure for disaster response for the City of New Orleans, State of Louisiana, and FEMA was adequate to effectively respond to a Cat. 3 - 5 hurricane on August 26th, 2005. As you respond to this question please complete the following: o Review the various reports concerning the Katrina response and relief efforts. Identify an example of a relief effort which was successful and one which was unsuccessful. o Discuss the reasons why the examples you cited above were or were not successful. Comment specifically on whether you believe that the organizational structure at the City of New Orleans, State of Louisiana, and the Federal government was adequate, including communications and command and control. (Please refer to the Organization Structure for incident management in the National Response Plan.) Focus on how coordinating structures, processes, and protocols were employed to manage the disaster response. Discuss the importance of social networks during the Katrina Disaster. Please review the following (referenced) article and comment on the importance of social networks during a disaster response.  ~ 1 of 11 ~ MHE 512- MOD 1 - Case Introduction to Disaster Relief; Organizational Structure of Relief Organizations; and, The National Response Framework Hurricane Katrina: Disaster Relief...

Words: 1972 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Incident Action Plan

...Incident Action Plan Jason Robins MGT 401 Hazardous Materials Management Dr. Jeffery Turk Incident Action Plan You look up at the clock on the wall and begin to realize your first day as the newly appointed safety manager of a plastics company. As you look out your office window you begin to realize that’s it been snowing outside and the roads are icing over. There is a knock on your door and one of the dock workers runs into your office shouting one of the delivery vans has slid into some trailers surrounding the truck in flames causing the pellets to give off a toxic smoke. What are you going to do? What is your plan of action? The handling of incidents such as these can turn disastrous if not handled properly. The National Incident Management System Glossary defines incidents as “an occurrence, natural or manmade, that requires a response to protect life or property (FEMA, 2012). When a serious incident happens an Incident Action Plan (IAP) will mean the difference between a quick resolution, and total destruction. With city emergency services delayed with the ensuing ice storm, it will be my responsibility to develop an IAP based on the current events. We can’t always predict the next “big” disaster, but we can always plan for it. No one had any idea of the possibility of a terrorist attack on American soil, but there were concerns about terrorism and the ability to identify and deter it. In September 1999, the U.S. Commission on National Security (the Hart-Rudman...

Words: 1569 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Maritime Industry Case Study

...ENVIRONMENTAL REGULATIONS 2.1. International Regulations 2.1.1. International Convention on Oil Pollution Preparedness, Response and Co-operation 1990Regulatıon for the conrol of Noxious substances(OPRC 1990) 2.1.2. Protocol on Preparedness, Response and Co-operation to Pollution Incidents by Hazardous and Noxious Substances, (HNS Protocol-2000) 2.1.3. International Convention Relating to Intervention on the High Seas in Cases of Oil Pollution Casualties 1969 (INTERVENTION 69) 2.1.4. Other Regulations for...

Words: 7283 - Pages: 30