Premium Essay

Native American Savages

Submitted By
Words 816
Pages 4
In Benjamin Franklin’s Remarks Concerning the Savages of North America, the White Americans regard the Native Americans as “savages” whose “manners differ from ours [the whites], which we [the whites] think the perfection of civility.” (Franklin, 2) Labeled as “savages”, the lives of Native Americans are distinct from those of the Whites. As a result, with the differences in manners and lives, frequent racism and patronization of the Native Americans by the whites are frequent. In The Crying Indian- Classic PSA, draws awareness to the audience about the danger of contamination along with the deteriorating relationship between the Native Americans and the outside people due to racism. Along with the works of William Cullen Bryant and James …show more content…
Through Bryant’s “Thanatopsis”, nature is personified as a lady with a voice and a personality. As a lady, nature comforts the narrator for “she has a voice of gladness, and a smile and eloquence of beauty” along with “gently sympathy” (Bryant 4-5). As a result, in respect of nature, the narrator “holds communion” (Bryant 2) and serves as a companion and a lover. Nature has been greatly revered Similarly, nature to many of the Native Americans serves as a habitat. The PSA video advocates the Native Americans through a comparison. The contrast between the Native American and the people of the present day, the powerful image of pollution, the destruction of nature symbolizing the obliteration of Native Americans’ lives who value nature as their habitat for humanity, carries visual images that dramatized how every individual should recycle, prevent litter, and beautify America by taking responsibility for enriching the community environments. Furthermore, through the portrayal of the white man polluting the earth, which eventually landed on the Native American’s foot, symbolizes the need for respect of …show more content…
In the PSA video, the Native Americans are unable to adapt to the cosmopolitan society. Starting from appearances, the quality of clothing, the Native Americans riding canoes while the people in the 21st century ride cars, serves as the differences between the two human race. Upon a white man’s action of throwing trash out of his car in the PSA video, the disgust in the Native American’s eyes shows the difference in ones’ priorities and values. The Native Americans are frequently called “Savages” among the Whites, because of their different behaviors. In “The Speech of the Pawnee chief”, the speaker acknowledges the differences between the two races: “[The Great spirit] made the whites to cultivate the earth, and feed on domestic animals; but he made us, red skins to rove through the uncultivated woods….We[the Native Americans] differ from you [the whites] in appearance and manners as well as in our customs; and we differ from you in our religion;.” However along with the PSA video, which displays the differences between the two race and the degrading view upon the Native Americans, it advocates

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Native American Savage Summary

...Throughout the 1800s, colonials were being attacked and captivated my native American who were known as savages. In the narratives, the surviving captives told their stories of what they went through when the savages got a hold of them. People also told stories of the captives who died during their captivity. They talk about their experiences on how they lived during their captivity and if they died, they told how it happen and what the savages did to them. Lieutenant Thomas Boyd of the Rifle Corps from New York lived in the 1770s. He was known for being captured by Indian savages and dying a cruel death by being tortured in the revolution in a town called Little Beard but is now known as Leicester on September 13th, 1770. In the extreme western...

Words: 1023 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Common Stereotypes Of Native Americans In The Noble Savage Image, By Carol Cornelius

...The first common stereotype used to describe Native people, is The Noble Savage Image. According to the book written by Carol Cornelius, the Noble Savage Image was seen as a romantic view of Indians and how they lived in harmony with the nature. It also suggests, that the “outsider” has been not influenced or corrupted by the civilization. A clear example of this image, is the character Hiawatha, which was created from the combination of the Iroquois “Aywetha”, and the Ojibwa mythology. According to this creation, Native Americans are seen as “one people”; which means that they do not show the diversity among Native Americans. Other common stereotype is the idea that states that Native Americans only can better themselves if they are with white...

Words: 314 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Native American Stereotypes

...Throughout American history, Native Americans have become one of America’s most alienated minority groups. The American Indian’s population went through many different struggles, challenges, and progressive strides conveyed presently in time. The American film industry, focusing mainly on Hollywood, has long been misrepresenting Native Americans since the establishment of film. Just as American colonists ounce wrongfully forced Native Americans off their native lands, filmmakers deliberately neglect Native Americans to minor characters roles, that tend to showcase stereotypical, and inaccurate behaviors. Native American characteristics in Hollywood films have contained a range of different stereotypes including the common bloodthirsty, unintelligent, and noble savage ideas that have been prematurely developed. Pocahontas, created in 1995, was a motion picture portraying...

Words: 586 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Comparing Kieft And French Interactions With Native Americans

...Have you ever wondered how William Kieft and the French interacted with the native americans. William Kieft interacted with the native americans much differently than the French.William Kieft felt that the new land should be his and he thought that the native americans were savages. The French saw that the native americans could make really good allies so they made allies with the native americans. The French were a lot more respectful towards the native americans and William Kieft did not like the native americans or as he called them the “savages.” How did the way that William Kieft treated the Native Americans differ from the way the French treated the Native Americans. William Kieft hated the Native Americans he hated them so much that he attacked them while they were sleeping. “Nothing but firing. and heard the shrieks of savages murdered in their sleep.”(paragraph 6) William Kieft attacked the Native American camp while they were sleeping and David De Vires one of the soldiers that was working for William attacked the Natives at night and he did not inform De Vires. De Vires woke up to the sounds of gunshots and the screams of the savages,...

Words: 493 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Summary Of Charles C. Mann's Coming Of Age In Dawnland

...The author, Charles C. Mann's purpose in writing Coming of Age in Dawnland was to inform that Native Americans weren't savages or an enemy even though some people say they were. The story tells you ways that the Native Americans lifestyles or some of the things they do weren't that different from the way settlers or people today do things. An example of this was how the Native Americans were taught to be good people or taught what we call manners. They were taught to be honest and not to complain. They were not taught to be savages. The quote "The primary goal of Dawnland education was molding character. Men and women were expected to be brave, hardy, honest, and uncomplaining”(Mann 28). proves my thesis because it shows that Native Americans...

Words: 353 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

What Makes the Red Man, Red?

...children are exposed to stereotypes and misrepresentations of Native Americans, with a stereotype being “preconceived or oversimplified generalizations usually, but not always, involving negative beliefs about a particular group” (Brunette). For children to learn the stereotypes so young and to think that that is how a certain group of people really is, only perpetuates the cycle of how some races or ethnic groups are treated, even something as seemingly innocent as Disney’s Pocahontas or Virginia Grossman’s Ten Little Rabbit, can really be a stereotype in hiding. “…Children between 2 and 5 years of age start to become aware of race, ethnicity, gender, and disabilities…Children learn stereotypes and attitudes about race from their parents, caretakers and the world around them” (Brunette). The knowledge that young children hold about Native Americans can vary greatly form child to child. Some children know about a tribe that lives in their area, while others just have the images that Disney has put in their heads. Most children believe that Native Americans are a thing of the past, that there are no living Native Americans today, A kindergarten class visits a children’s museum on a nearby American Indian reservation. As they enter the foyer, their guide, a member of the reservation’s Native tribe, greets the group. “When are we going to see some real Indians?” asks one of the children. “You are meeting one. I am American Indian,” says the guide. The children are skeptical. Their...

Words: 1817 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Smoke Signals And Fast Runner: Film Analysis

...They give them characters that make them look backward, look like savages, and people that are extremely dangerous. According to film history, they are villains to the American expansion; when people attempted to progress, they were opposed to change. The two films, Smoke Signals and Fast Runner, despite their differences, they use cinematic aspects such as sounds and shots, framing, angle, camera movement, music, lighting, and editing to give a different view of the indigenous people. The narration is in the native language with English subtitles, and this enables the viewers to appreciate the culture on display. The shots that are up-close give the characters an emotion that allows the audience to connect with them, and view them as ordinary humans (Knopf 342). The two films are helpful in making a way forward where people can be tolerant of different...

Words: 1431 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

False Representation

...Representation   While watching Mel Gibson’s movie, Apacalypto, he depicts Native Americans with typical stereotypes that we commonly see in today’s society. Some of the stereotypes that are included have to do with their clothing, physical features, personality and their ability to become one with nature. All these aspects were shown through the main character Jaguar Paw as he faced the many difficulties that came his way. The clothing and physical features that Mel Gibson present are common stereotypes of Native Americans acting like uncivilized savages. In the movie, Jaguar Paw was mostly naked except for an undergarment he wore below the waist. He had tattoos, big piercings, and wore many necklaces, amulets, and bands around his body. Also, he had the body type of a physical fit and toned man with long braided hair. These are all common stereotypes of a typical Native American. They are seen as savages because they wear little or no clothing at all and the amulets that they wear are made from animals that they hunt. Moreover, Jaguar Paw had the stereotypical body, that all Native Americans were fit and muscularly toned because they are hunters and warriors. However, not all Native Americans were naked and physically fit. Every tribe had their own unique style of clothing jewelry and not all men were in shape. In a particular scene that involved Jaguar Paw, he was portrayed even more as a savage and barbarian. In this scene, Jaguar Paw and his hunting group kill a tapir...

Words: 542 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Edward Winslow's Traveling To Pokanoket

...amongst the savages” and by mentioning that the Governor of the Pilgrims, William Bradford, wanted to send men to Massasoit in order to learn “where to find [the Natives]…see their strength, discover the country, prevent abuses in their disorderly coming into us, make satisfaction for some conceived injuries…and to continue the league of peace” between the Pilgrims and Native Americans (1). Governor Bradford chooses the party of Edward Winslow and Stephen Hopkins along with Squanto as a guide to go meet Massasoit. Bradford wants the party to deliver to Massasoit a coat, which represented a desire of peace between the...

Words: 1148 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Native Americans, Struggles, Mascots, Controversy

...Native Americans, Struggles, Mascots, and Controversy There has been a national debate for years over Native American athletic mascots. “Members of the North Carolina Mascot Education and Action Group and the Guilford Native American Association, however, repeatedly told us that they perceived the use of Indian mascots, logos, caricatures, and similar images by our schools as a clear form of institutional racism” (Grier 2005: 51). In this paper we will discuss the controversial impact of the Native American stereotype used as mascots. In the early 1900’s when the threat of colonization was abolished Americans started to use the Native American mascot to show their acknowledgement of their struggles. Although this was symbolic it has been an ongoing controversy within schools and sports. California is the second highest state that uses the most Native American imagery and symbols. The importance of this contemporary issue is an ongoing debate in California that has impacted the true history of Native Americans and the battles they went through. The truth is crucial because their imagery and interpretation is misunderstood in American history. In the early 1900’s it became acceptable to use Native American imagery for advertisement. “One of the reasons why most Americans find the mascots unremarkable and do not turn a critical eye toward the mascots is because of the prevalence of similar images throughout U.S. popular culture” (King, et al 2002:391). Although years later...

Words: 1493 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Free Argumentative Essays-The Removal Of Native Americans

...The Removal of the Native Americans Many believe than when the United States passed the Indian removal act, they were actually trying to protect the Native Americans. However, some speculate that they may have just been trying to get them out of the way. The United States government only looks out for their own self interests. When they kicked out the Native Americans, they claimed it was for the good of the Indians even though it was only so they could take their land. The truth is that in 2018 the United States government is still only looking out for its own interests. If the government wants to build a highway through where you house is, they will make you move. Some may argue that the government would be willing to pay high sums for you...

Words: 970 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Native American Culture Essay

...Dark times of the Native American Indians The foundation of the United States is based on the belief of peace, freedom and equality, which is enjoyed and practiced by most of the people in this “Country of Liberty.” However, the idea of equality and freedom does not apply to every person living in the U.S. Luis Valdez, an American writer, once said: “No Statue of Liberty ever greeted our arrival in this country. We did not, in fact, come to the United States at all. The United States came to us.” Growing up, children in the U.S. learn little of what has truly happened to the vast population of the Indigenous people on the continent? What has led to such a drastic decease of their culture and tradition? The answer lies in a dark part of the...

Words: 1330 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Hollywood's Wes Studi: The Reality Of Native American History

...hold it represents the reality of Native American history. A stagecoach is traveling through a desolate valley, when the passengers suddenly and without provocation find themselves surrounded, threatened, and eventually attacked for no reason by “injuns” on horses carrying guns and bows and arrows. Movies of Native Americans traveling in large groups circling wagons ready to attack innocent people played a pivotal role in promoting the image of the savage untamed Native American. While at the same time, the white settlers were portrayed as moral humans only trying to protect their land and their family from the brutal and savage Native Americans bent on killing as many white settlers as possible. Of course, there were conflicts and deaths, but very few were the result of hostility between settlers and Native Americans. When Native Americans tried to defend themselves and their land, settlers or troops attacked them. We learned from “Major Problems in the...

Words: 535 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Native American Film Analysis

...the representation of native Americans in the media I found but a few sources that could be cited which is a comment in and of itself about the very lack of historical representation of native Americans with in our society. The very definition of representation should not be confused with its figurative meaning of diplomacy, but in this case is an expression of a group by means of a designation that represents said group, meaning that representation is a form of communication or factor that identifies a set or group, in this particular case a race of people that shall be from here on within this paper be identified as native Americans or native Americans Indians. With this in mind the preponderance...

Words: 629 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Natives and Their Role in the American Frontier

...Natives and their Role in the American Frontier As Americans, we do not usually question how we came to this land or why we are able to live here as we do. We believe that the American frontier is this grand historical past of our growth as a nation. However, the country we know today as the United States of America was originally inhabited by natives such as the Native Americans, or Indians as they are commonly known as, and Mexicans who were robbed of their homeland in order for the white man to take over control. As citizens of this country, it is important to know how the natives were treated and portrayed in literature in order to become educated about our country and the people that inhabited this land before us. Being ignorant about a particular culture leads to misguided feelings and judgments that are not normally acceptable. By looking at examples from John Smith’s The Chesapeake Indians, Mary Rowlandson’s A True History of the Captivity and Restoration of Mrs. Mary Rowlandson, and Frederick Jackson Turner’s The Significance of the Frontier in American History, we will see that natives were portrayed negatively in popular literature and why it is important to understand how they are represented is justified by the colonial expansion of the American frontier. In early literature written by English settlers, Native Americans were portrayed with very negative connotations. The writers often used words such as: brutal, dark, uncivilized, and savage to depict the native...

Words: 1447 - Pages: 6