Nature vs Nurture Issue

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By Kstockton000
Words 278
Pages 2
Kristina Stockton
PSY240
Nature-Nurture Issue

I believe it is flawed to ask how much of a particular behavior is due to genetics and how much is due to experience, because there is really no way of telling where a person’s behavior came from. I personally believe that a person’s behavior is determined by both, but more of experience. So therefore, nature and nurture plays a role in a person’s behavior.
A person may be born with the same behavioral patterns as their parents, but it might take a certain experience to make the behavior come forth. A person may inherit genes of anger issues or may have the alcoholic gene in their blood. What people experience makes a huge difference on their behavior, because people have different values, morals, and ethical beliefs. They may change their personality based on the good experiences and bad experiences in their life.
It is appropriate to separate the contributions of genetics and experience when measuring the development of differences among individuals because every individual carries different genes and is also raised differently. There is really no way of judging what factors will affect behavior in a person, because everyone experiences different things.
Nature and nurture will always be an issue, because there is no way of telling what affects a person more. We are all different and I don’t believe that we are suppose to figure out why we are the way we are, because that is going to lead to more scientists cloning and more people paying to change their genetics. The world would be a mess if this was to happen, because there would be no diversity anymore.…...

Similar Documents

Nature vs Nurture

...Nature vs. Nurture General Psychology What makes humans so alike? Throughout different cultures, the human race is very much alike. We all share the same biological system and we also share similar behaviors. However, we are influenced by our family genes and by the culture that surrounds us. Various aspects of nature and nurture have affected who I am today as a young adult. Nature includes the traits that are hereditary or inherited from my ancestors. One way that nature has impacted me is through temperament. From my mom’s stories, my temperament as a baby was very easygoing. This trait continued as I grew from a child into a young adult. To this day, when faced with conflict or new plans, I react in a relaxed way. I don’t stress out or get anxious about things too easily. Another example of nature’s influence is the way that I learn. At a young age I was diagnosed or labeled as a “slow learner.” I had difficulty with reading comprehension and memorization skills. My preferred learning style is tactile or hands-on. I really enjoy getting involved when learning new information and especially enjoyed classes that involved building and discussed practical issues. This trait may be a result of being premature at birth, having spinal meningitis as a newborn, or inherited from my family. My struggle with learning was also affected by nurture, specifically my school environment. Growing up labeled as a “slow learner” did not give me any advantages in...

Words: 566 - Pages: 3

Nature vs Nurture Issue

...Kristina Stockton PSY240 Nature-Nurture Issue I believe it is flawed to ask how much of a particular behavior is due to genetics and how much is due to experience, because there is really no way of telling where a person’s behavior came from. I personally believe that a person’s behavior is determined by both, but more of experience. So therefore, nature and nurture plays a role in a person’s behavior. A person may be born with the same behavioral patterns as their parents, but it might take a certain experience to make the behavior come forth. A person may inherit genes of anger issues or may have the alcoholic gene in their blood. What people experience makes a huge difference on their behavior, because people have different values, morals, and ethical beliefs. They may change their personality based on the good experiences and bad experiences in their life. It is appropriate to separate the contributions of genetics and experience when measuring the development of differences among individuals because every individual carries different genes and is also raised differently. There is really no way of judging what factors will affect behavior in a person, because everyone experiences different things. Nature and nurture will always be an issue, because there is no way of telling what affects a person more. We are all different and I don’t believe that we are suppose to figure out why we are the way we are, because that is going to lead to more......

Words: 278 - Pages: 2

Nature vs. Nurture

...Nature vs. Nurture When looking at the nature and nurture debate, overall, I believe that our thoughts, behaviors, and emotions as humans are more strongly influenced by our environment, or nurtured. However, looking from the other point of view, that they are influenced by nature is also very plausible. In general, the reason that the nurtured makes most sense to me, is that the environment everyone grows up in (which is what influences us, obviously,) is so varied from person to person. What is natural to someone from Sweden, will not be natural to an individual in India, or the U.S., or Argentina. Another great example of variance, which is very applicable to me since I am training to be and working as a chef, is the principal of taste aversion. This was discovered by John Garcia along with other researcher. In taste aversion, foods can give certain people bad thoughts via taste or other consequences from the food, where as others may love the same particular food. When I cook food for friends or family, even though I love it, my sister may despise it, while my parents also enjoy it. There is a variance from person to person and thoughts, behaviors, and feelings can influence a persons rationale even though their environment has been relatively identical to another person with a different rational. The environment of each individual is different, so it makes most sense that individuals are nurtured as opposed to having a natural rationale. A type of social learning...

Words: 524 - Pages: 3

Nature vs Nurture

...The start of this paper I think the best place to look is to the bible for what it says about our human nature as well as how nurturing plays a part inside the life of a person. When we look to the bible for understanding of human nature we are lead to see that our human nature is one of sin and death. Looking at Romans 8:13 for an example of this to quote part of it “For if you live according to the sinful nature, you will die” this tells us that if we live by our human nature that it will only lead to death. However if we finish reading the verse it also says “but if by the Spirit you put to death the misdeeds of the body, you will live” this gives us hope that if we live by the Spirit there is hope in life. Furthermore we can see answers for how nurturing plays a key part inside our lives. Inside the bible we can see a lot of examples of what the bible says about nurturing a child to adult to bring them up right and proper. The best example I have found is inside Ephesians 6:4 to quote it says “bring them up with the discipline and instruction that comes from the Lord”. This is a great example of how to raise a kid inside a household. Moving forward to develop an answer to the first question on my opinion on the idea of the whole argument of Nature vs. Nurture took me on a road that really has left me with more questions than answers. What I have to say about this topic is based upon a lot of my personal experiences with addiction as much as with other addicts. To say...

Words: 1299 - Pages: 6

Nature vs Nurture

...ESSAY: STAGE 1 NATURE VS NURTURE Intro Nature VS Nurture has been a long going debate for many of centuries. Many of people have argued for what side they think is correct. Psychologists such as; Many other studies have been done When in psychology we talk about Nature this means our genetics, what we are born with. Nurture refers to how we have experienced life and how as a child how parents have brought us up. Environmental factors also contribute to Nurture. Many studies have been done in this debate, in the studies there have been twins separated at birth. The twins were moved to opposite sides of the world with completely different family types. When the twins were reunited some aspects of them were the same but things like their beliefs and look on life were different Nature normally refers to our genetics. What we are born with; we may be born with a chemical imbalance causing us to be more depressed then happy or we may have a bad temper. Some genetic mental disease may run through the family such as depression or bipolar. Researcher’s studies people and their relatives because they share most genes so the studies they conduct see whether or not their characteristics are similar. Identical twins have the same genes, so this may be Nature but they usually are treated the same and grow up in the same environment. Nurture is usually the environment we are brought up in; we may be brought up on the streets which can cause us to become aggressive because you had...

Words: 516 - Pages: 3

Nature vs Nurture

...Since the beginning of recorded time one has been told that ‘you have your mothers eyes’ or ‘You’re tall like your father’ and it has been accepted that humans inherit their appearance traits from their parents, however where does one get their talent for hockey, their intelligence, or their habits; does one learn these from their environment or were they programmed by genetics? Well this brings to light the age old debate of nature vs. nurture. The Nature and Nurture debate stems into many areas that make humans what they are, with one of those factors being their religion, and when examining religion it is found that nurture trumps nature in shaping the beliefs of oneself. Since the Ancient Egyptians and even before (Mesopotamians) religion and spirituality have existed, there has been a consensual acceptance that there is a God, and when one closes their eyes for the last time, they become one with God, or in some cases; the devil or the ‘netherworld’. Through those times and the times of the Catholic church according to world renowned psychologist Dr Olivera Petrovich; “Religion has become the natural state-it is now hard wired by families into babies brains, it is atheism that is learned”. She bases the mantra of religion being parental based on a study of four hundred B.C. children of different faiths, and many aged four-six Japanese children. When asking all of these children about their faith they all without any guidance from their parents say they believe in...

Words: 759 - Pages: 4

Nature vs Nurture

...Nature vs. Nurture On the great debate of Nature vs. Nurture I was once the firm believer that one’s identity was shaped through social variables (nurture). Upon further research on the topic my opinion has changed and I believe that biological and social variables both help to shape ones identity and personality. When we are born we all have male or female predispositions. Hormones are released which in turn increase those male or female behaviors (Nature) shaping our gender identity. There was study on a boy Bruce Reimer who had suffered genital mutilation while undergoing a circumcision procedure at 6 months of age. His parents then decided for Bruce to undergo “gender-reassignment” as they were told that gender was determined by environmental variables. Bruce now became Brenda and was raised as a female. While growing Brenda still exhibited male qualities, dismissing “female” toys, trying to use male restrooms, attempt to urinate standing up (despite the fact that Brenda did not have male anatomy). Her brother had even suggested the only difference between them was that Brenda had long hair, and he had short. Although Brenda’s parents had done everything to shape Brenda’s gender identity into female, Brenda still rejected the feminine identity. Brenda’s parents informed her of the gender- reassignment surgery, and at 14 years of age Brenda cut off all of her hair and started living life as “David”. David was able to restore his male identity and live his life out until...

Words: 454 - Pages: 2

Nature vs Nurture

...Nature and nurture are different in many ways, but they both influence behavior. The way I like to differentiate them is you are born with one and the other is a trait you learn. Both are part of our everyday lives, they just might come at different stages. Nature is the hair color, eye color, and skin color I was born with. It is me being 5’8 and right handed because it runs in my family. On my dad’s side of the family, twins skip a generation and that is why I am a twin. Nature is growing up in a small city in North Carolina instead of a big city like New York City. Weight is another genetic trait that my family has to struggle with. We weren’t blessed to eat whatever we want without the consequences that follow. To overcome this, I had to learn to like exercising, which leads me into Nuture. Nurture is me learning to say “Yes Sir/Ma’am” “No Sir/Ma’am” to anyone that is older than me because that is the norm in the south. It is also saying “please” and “thank you” at the appropriate time. Nurture is my mom and dad teaching me that we speak kind words to each other and that we don’t hit someone when they have done us wrong. Nurture is taking what I learned from my mom on how to be a good wife and mom and using those skills to influence my family. Even though I am a twin and we look alike, I believe that nurture rather than nature had more of an impact on both our lives. Despite our looks, we behave in different ways, like different things, and react to......

Words: 320 - Pages: 2

Nature vs Nurture

...Are we Nature or Nurture? Both Nature and Nurture have significant impacts on our lives. Nurture involves how you were raised, the way you were treated, what you were taught to believe, where Nature is your genes, how you were born. Think about your parents. What is their job? Are they a republican or democrat? Do they go to church? Most likely, if they are republicans, you are too. If they go to church every Sunday, you do too. Our parents have perhaps the most impact on our lives, because they are nurtured and shaped us to adulthood. We were raised to believe the same things they do. There is a little that we can do to change that. In my own experience I have grown up in a home where my parents and grandparents have shown me the values of love and compassion and taught me how to trust. And I believe that has affected me more than my genes ever could. The environment you grew up in will influence you in the way you react to certain circumstances. Certainly we may have our own unique qualities, but often our inborn inclinations are still shaped and influenced by our friends, family and teachers. I’m good in music, that is something I may have been born with, but my love for music was influenced by my parents and by my teachers. Technology and the media also have an influence on who we are. We learn moves and words from the music that we listen to and TV shows that we watch. In my opinion, Nurture has everything to do with the person you grow up to be. The way you were......

Words: 330 - Pages: 2

Nature vs. Nurture

...Nature vs. Nurture in Psychology PSYCH 101 Nature vs. Nurture in Psychology What makes you think, feel, and behave the way you do? Were you born predisposed to live the life you are currently living, or were you born a blank canvas upon which your experiences gave shape and expression to the person you are today? These are the types of questions the Nature vs. Nurture debate has posed and scientists have probed for over a century. In this paper we will look at some of the aspects of this debate the scientific community does not attend to, or dismisses, the origin and history of this debate, the essential characteristics around which this issue is debated, and where scientists are today in understanding this issue. What are your thoughts on the Nature vs. Nurture argument? Sir Galton wrote in his book English Men of Science (1874), “Nature is all that a man brings with him into the world; nurture is every influence that affects him after his birth,” (p. 12). I have been led to believe that our biology (nature), our environment (nurture), and our cognitive abilities all interplay and influence our resulting personality and other existing traits. We are, as Myers (2012) continuously asserts, biopsychosocial beings (p.124). These aspects of our existence work in accord to actuate the developmental potential written into our genetic code. Where I think there is a deficiency in the theories proffered, in attempt to answer the Nature vs...

Words: 1666 - Pages: 7

Nature vs Nurture

...The term nature as it has been defined is how a person is from his or her inborn genetics. The term nurture as defined is how a person’s behavior changes or a person is from environment and training. Nature shows the habits and behavior of a student in a genetic way through good parents, but as they grow nature could take different turns in their life. It goes to different paths which could lead them to either good or bad things. Whereas nurture shows environmental behavior of the person that is, the society they live in could be good but surrounded environment could still turn them bad if it is bad. Nature and nurture has been playing huge important role in each and every person’s life till today, and is still playing. These terms have become a huge controversial issue in today’s world, it has even affected politically and emotionally. It has still been an unclear debate of how it influences and impacts on a growing child. The question is whether the impact of nature over nurture is more important or the impact of nurture over nature in a child is more important? In my opinion I would say that the impact of both depends on the growth of a child because people growing in good culture, good nature is still bad, people growing in good environment and surroundings are also still bad in addition people or a child that does not have an impact of nurture or nature is usually half empty. They have no sense or idea about the outer world without each of this...

Words: 681 - Pages: 3

Nurture vs Nature

...Psychologists, philosophers, and others have long tried to determine which factors have the biggest influence on determining who we become. Two of the most debated factors have been Nature vs. Nurture. Were we born the way we are because of our genes, or did we become who we are because of our environment or social interactions? Nature and Nurture have both had influences on my adult physical, cognitive, and psychosocial development. Nature Nature can be defined as our genetic make-up. We inherit physical traits such as height, weight, hair color, eye color, skin color and facial shape. This code is passed on from generation to generation. My son is the greatest example of this heritability. People often refer to him as my mini-me. He resembles me in almost every way. He has the same physical traits as I do, but they are packed into his smaller frame. Our cognitive development may also be determined by our genetics. Intelligence and/or developmental disabilities are often passed down from generation to generation. The most significant trait that I inherited from my mother that influenced my cognitive development is her intelligence. My mother and I both have similar intelligence and we both assimilate and process information in the same way. Nurture Nurture can be defined as different environmental factors and/or social influences that have potential impacts on our development. My mother made sacrifices and selected a safe community where her family could...

Words: 451 - Pages: 2

Nature vs. Nurture

...Homosexuality, Nature vs. Nurture Western Governors University Homosexuality, Nature vs. Nurture Nature versus nurture is one of the most enduring debates in the psychology world today. These debates have been studied and reviewed for many years, with only hypotheses formed, no clear conclusions have been met. In the middle of the debates is human behavior, whether they are learned or inherited remains unanswered. Intelligence, ability, or even personality remains under scrutiny whether these traits are learned or predetermined by specific genes. Physical characteristics can be contributed to hereditary, i.e. eye color or hair color. When referring to nature, it is assumed that what and who we are, as humans, comes in a natural state or inherited. In other words, we are going to be who we are without the influence on how we were raised and matured in our environment. On the other hand, nurture is viewed as what or who we are as a result of our influences and our environment or surroundings. Homosexuality is one of the hottest topics today. One of the reasons for the popularity is the current debate on same sex marriage, along with homosexual human rights campaigns going on in today’s public arena. More so either this “behavior” is by choice or predetermined by genes. The Studies One of the best research in this area is on identical twins. Howard Gruber,  the director of the Institute for Cognitive Studies at Rutgers University in Newark, reviewed and quoted...

Words: 1245 - Pages: 5

Nature vs Nurture

...NATURE V.S. NURTURE The Nature vs. Nurture debate is one of the oldest and most commonly debated psychological conflicts around. Arguments from both sides on this subject are hard to dispute. Whether it is in our DNA or it was predisposition it’s hard to agree or disagree with either stand-point being that they both offer interesting and intriguing views that are insightful, informative and unfortunately unfounded. With that being said it’s still an argument that will continue to stand the test of time and continually be debated for centuries down the road until a definitive explanation can be fathomed. Nature vs. Nurture is a phrase for the long-standing controversy as to the relative influences of genetics versus the environment in the development of personality traits. Nature is represented by instincts and genetic influences and nurture by social influences and environment. The Nature part of this debate is influenced by the idea that we get our traits and characteristics from our DNA and nowhere else. It is easy to ascertain and prove that we get our physical traits such as eye color, hair color, height and otherphysical traits from DNA. The unknown is whether we get our more abstract traits from DNA like character, intelligence, sexuality and preferences to likes or dislikes. The Nurture side of this is debatea agrees that genetic influence is a key factor in the abstract physical traits but nothing more. It also goes on saying that the environment that...

Words: 762 - Pages: 4

Nature vs Nurture

...D1: Evaluate how nature and nurture may affect the physical, intellectual, emotional and social development for two stages of the development of the individual. Therefore you should select two stages, not necessarily in sequence. In order to evaluate you must consider the extent to which both nature and nurture influence the development of the individual. You could conclude by deciding which, if either, is the most influential. You should refer to research evidence in your evaluation. 50+ years Subject A is an elder lady who lives at home with her son and three grandchildren. She also has dementia; a syndrome associated with an ongoing decline of the brain and its abilities. This includes problems with: memory loss, thinking speed, mental agility, language, understanding and judgement. In her situation, nature can have a negative effect on her physical development due to her disorder meaning that she can’t do much for herself. Things like cooking, showering or going shopping influences her development negatively as she can’t do anything herself. As dementia is something that is inherited, it may have been developed from her parents or something that runs in her family therefore it is hard to overcome which are the physical effects on her development. Intellectually, due to old age or just getting older, developing something like dementia, is also seen as a nurture. Someone else in the family may have had dementia which therefore increased the chance of someone else...

Words: 856 - Pages: 4