Premium Essay

Negative Outcomes in Mentoring

In: Business and Management

Submitted By bxgurl
Words 1108
Pages 5
There is much discussion of the positive effects mentoring can have, for the mentor, the protégé, and the organization. According to Robert Kreitner, “mentoring can serve to embed an organization’s culture when developers and the protégé/protégée work in the same organization. First, mentoring contributes to creating a sense of oneness by promoting the acceptance of the organization’s core values throughout the organizations. Second, the socialization aspect of mentoring also promotes a sense of membership.” There is less discussion about what happens when mentoring goes wrong, and the fallout from these failures.
According to a study by Eby, McManus, Simon, and Russell, 54% of those mentored reported being in at least one negative mentoring relationship. Mentoring, like all interpersonal relationships, is a very complex and ever changing situation. Negative events happen even in the healthiest of relationships, and are not necessarily a bad thing. The focus of this essay will be on particular behavioral patterns that have negative repercussions for an organization.
In order for a mentoring relationship to have value to the mentor, protégé, and the organization, there needs to be a certain level of trust between the parties. Sometimes this trust fails to develop due to simple personality differences or styles of work, but in other situations, it is the direct result of intentional behaviors on one or both parties.
In a 2010 Q&A with the Wall Street Journal, Dawn E. Chandler, Lillian Eby and Stacy E. McManus stated that simple neglect of a protégé, which is often unintentional, could have serious consequences that affect an organization.
This often is not the intended action when someone enters into a mentoring relationship, but usually a reaction to concerns about their own career, personal life, or standing in the company, that causes the mentor to put

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

At Risk Youth Mentoring

...(McWhirter et al., 2012). Specifically, the definition of at risk youth involves individuals who have certain "cause-effect dynamics"( McWhirter et al., 2012, p.45) that will most likely result in negative outcomes down the line. In a sense, the outcome is yet to be determined,...

Words: 1295 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Feminist Proposal Essay

...role models for LGBT youth “likely increase heath and behavioural risks”, and that establishing supportive relationships with “peers, family members or other caring adults” could potentially reduce the “impact of stigma and shield LGBT youth from negative health risks (Bird, Kuhns Garofalo). Of particular significance for LGBT youth may be the “other caring adults’ that may serve as role models for LGBT youth who may lack supportive relationships with peer and family due to the stigmatization of LGBT identities. Bird, Kuhns and Garofalo suggest that role modelling is “an important factor for adolescent development and a critical factor in reducing risk and increasing protective factors for healthy development” (BKG year). They also identified that the effectiveness of these relationships depend on role models who have concern for the youth’s wellbeing and LGBT identity, and one “who is...

Words: 684 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Hris Module

...3rd Edi ti on Elements of Effective Practice for Mentoring™ Newly revised edition, which includes evidenced-based operational standards Sponsored by Introduction As a strategy for helping young people succeed in school, work and life, mentoring works. It helps give young people the confidence, resources and support they need to achieve their potential. But, the fact is this: these positive outcomes are only possible when young people are engaged in high-quality mentoring relationships. The Elements of Effective Practice for Mentoring holds the key to success in producing high-quality relationships. The new edition of the Elements provides six evidence-based standards for practice that incorporate the latest research and best-available practice wisdom. It also reprises advice that appeared in earlier editions on program design and planning; program management; program operations; and program evaluation. We believe adherence to the Elements will ensure that mentoring relationships thrive and endure. They include measures that any mentoring program in any setting can implement, as well as measures that any agency can incorporate within the mentoring element of broad-based, positive youth development programming. This means that community-based, corporate-based, school-based, faith-based and Internet-based mentoring programs can use the Elements to meet the specific needs of the young people they serve and the milieu in which they operate. And, it means that afterschool...

Words: 7208 - Pages: 29

Free Essay

The Impact of School-Based Mentoring on Youths with Different Relational Profiles

...2, 450 – 462 © 2010 American Psychological Association 0012-1649/10/$12.00 DOI: 10.1037/a0021379 The Impact of School-Based Mentoring on Youths With Different Relational Profiles Sarah E. O. Schwartz, Jean E. Rhodes, and Christian S. Chan University of Massachusetts Boston Carla Herrera Public/Private Ventures, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Associations between youths’ relationship profiles and mentoring outcomes were explored in the context of a national, randomized study of 1,139 youths (54% female) in geographically diverse Big Brothers Big Sisters school-based mentoring programs. The sample included youths in Grades 4 –9 from diverse racial and ethnic backgrounds, the majority of whom were receiving free or reduced-price lunch. Latent profile analysis, a person-oriented approach, was used to identify 3 distinct relational profiles. Mentoring was found to have differential effects depending on youths’ preintervention approach to relationships. In particular, youths who, at baseline, had satisfactory, but not particularly strong, relationships benefited more from mentoring than did youths with profiles characterized by either strongly positive or negative relationships. Implications for research and practice are discussed. Keywords: youth mentoring, parent relationships, teacher relationships, latent profile analysis Youth mentoring programs such as Big Brothers Big Sisters (BBBS) pair youths with volunteers who are trained to provide support and guidance. Such...

Words: 12031 - Pages: 49

Premium Essay

Manage Marketing Process

...Running Head: MARKETING 1 Marketing Student Name: Date Professor Name of Professor Developing Marketing Plan: A management plan for the marketing activities, with clear strategies and actions for the achievement of marketing objectives: The following are the steps described the management plan for the Houzit stores marketing activities: Marketing Activities: The three marketing activities those indicated the potential for the Houzit stores are: • Leading home-ware magazines • In-store advertising displays that will display featured products with other areas in Houzit’s assortment and with displays the web address line of ‘Find us at www.houzit.com’ • The company’s web page will display visual advertise on the home page and will use the PR copy in article marketing on popular article content sites Integration of organizational activities: The PR article and featured in the advertising of ‘stylish bathroom’ and ‘exotic mirrors ‘are integrated with the range of marketing, promotional and sales activities to ensure the achievement of the established marketing activities. The tagline of the products featured and advertising campaign can be helped the company’s to create image in the customers mind and attracts them that ensure it achieve the goals of the established marketing activities (Florès, 2014). Monitor progress: Houzit’s marketing team monitor process through the collects statistical, information, feedback and data from the...

Words: 1473 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Feedback and Support

...CMC 4100: Coaching and Mentoring in the Clinical Setting Module 5: Feedback and Support in Coaching and Mentoring Module 5: Feedback and Support in Coaching and Mentoring An important aspect of coaching and mentoring is the ability to offer effective feedback and support. Again, these are transferrable skills which can be developed to help you facilitate a range of situations. It is also important that you personally receive effective feedback to assist you in your ongoing professional development. Learning objectives On completion of this module, students should be able to:     Describe the components of effective feedback; Initiate strategies to obtain feedback on their own performance in the clinical setting; Use effective strategies for giving feedback to others within the coaching/mentoring relationship; Identify an appropriate method for obtaining ongoing support in relation to their own professional development. Overview The overall aim of this unit is to equip students with the skills and understanding necessary to use coaching and mentoring techniques when facilitating professional development in the clinical setting. An integral part of this will be the giving of feedback to learners on aspects of their performance and professional development journey. Additionally, to further develop yourself as a skilled educator, it is important that you utilise skills for obtaining feedback on your own performance. In this unit, we use the term „feedback‟ to describe any communication...

Words: 2770 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Coaching and Mentoring

...Week Eight Assignment Tracey Petersen MAOL 545 June 2015 Mentoring is the “in” thing (Colley, 2000). It has become highly popular in professional settings in the last decade. According to The Center for Creative Leadership, “77 % of U.S. companies have implemented formal mentoring programs (Karasik, 2010). In the current global professional climate, it seems that our employees and team members are our greatest assets (www.mentoringtalent.com). Mentoring programs can enable team members to reach their fullest potential. Traditionally, the concept of mentoring has been informal; formalizing it in an organizational setting has its challenges, but also rewards. There have been many attempts at defining the concept of mentoring, but for Nathalie Gehrke, author of “Towards a Definition of Mentoring”, none seem to fully embrace the essence of the concept. Gehrke started out with this initial definition: “A mentor acts as a coach, much like in athletics, advising and teaching the political nuts and bolts, giving feedback and rehearsing strategies” (Gehrke, 1990, p.190) .The best way to define a mentor is to experience the mentor/protégé relationship The relationship with the mentor inspires employees to seek new questions, not answers. Loading...The greatest gift a mentor can do for a protégé is offer a “new and whole way of seeing things” (Gehrke, 1990, p.192). Mentoring is a fluid and ever changing concept. There are no rules to define it. The insights, knowledge and services...

Words: 2710 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Gaining Power and Influence in the Credit Union

...the two main types of power that I use to gain power and influence in my position as a service and sales trainer at the credit union. Referent Power Referent power “is sometimes thought of as charisma, charm, admiration, or appeal. Referent power comes from one person liking and respecting another, and strongly identifying with that person in some way.” (Mindtools.com) I have been told by other co-workers that I have charisma and appeal. I have a very positive outlook at work and in my training sessions. I train on the two things that most people struggle with; consist exceptional member service and sales. This is why I use referent power to influence my trainees. Trainees come to me when things are not going well and they are very negative. If I followed the same mindset as my trainees, then we would not get any improvement. I need to show them that they can be successful and sales and member service is positive. Expert Power Expert power is “when you have knowledge and skills that enable you to understand a situation, suggest solutions, use solid judgment, and generally outperform others.” (Mindtools.com) I have an advantage over other trainers in my credit union because I am the only service and sales trainer. I am looked to as the expert in these two areas of the credit union. Since I have expert power, I am consistently building and maintaining expert power. Since the credit union is small, one way that I build and maintain...

Words: 905 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Mentorship Competency

...is safe, accountable, and competent. The expectations of students within academia and within the staff mix on units can vary giving students a sense of role ambiguity diminishing the sense of belonging and taking away from the clinical learning experience. According to Higgins, Lathlean, Levett-Jones, & McMillan (2009),“Nursing students’ motivation and capacity to learn, self-concept, confidence, the extent to which they are willing to question or conform to poor practice and their future career decisions are influenced by the extent to which they experience belongingness (p.316).”Acceptance by senior and experienced nurses plays a pivotal role in the development of self-concept and application of theoretical perspectives into practice. Negative experiences with staff are detrimental to the learning process by creating environments of stress, anxiety, and an overall feeling of un-acceptance by staff, and at times, instructors. This can be attributed to the many factors that are influencing the profession of nursing including increased workloads, decreased staffing, scope of practice issues, safe work environments, and violence in the workplace (Lofmark et al, 2008). These issues influence nurses perceptions of their jobs and can negatively affect their attitudes towards themselves, colleagues, patients, and students (Ali & Panther, 2008). Addressing these issues is difficult as resources such as funding are scarce. This is creating environments that...

Words: 2844 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Itit

...AU/ACSC/0607C/97-03 UNDERSTANDING THE IMPACT OF CULTURAL DIVERSITY ON ORGANIZATIONS A Research Paper Presented To The Research Department Air Command and Staff College In Partial Fulfillment of the Graduation Requirements of ACSC by Maj Molly K. Moon March 1997 Disclaimer The views expressed in this academic research paper are those of the author(s) and do not reflect the official policy or position of the US government or the Department of Defense. ii Contents Page DISCLAIMER ................................................................................................................ ii LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS.......................................................................................... iv PREFACE....................................................................................................................... v ABSTRACT................................................................................................................... vi INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................................... 1 FROM GRUDGING ACKNOWLEDGMENT TO MANAGING DIVERSITY .............. 3 IMPACT OF DIVERSITY ON INDIVIDUALS AND ORGANIZATIONS.................... 9 Diversity Climate Factors.......................................................................................... 12 Identity Structures................................................................................................ 12 Prejudice...

Words: 8267 - Pages: 34

Free Essay

Research Spotlight on Peer Tutoring

...Research Spotlight on Peer Tutoring NEA Reviews of the Research on Best Practices in Education Found In: teaching strategies 145 Peer tutoring is a term that’s been used to describe a wide array of tutoring arrangements, but most of the research on its success refers to students working in pairs to help one another learn material or practice an academic task. Peer tutoring works best when students of different ability levels work together (Kunsch, Jitendra, & Sood, 2007). During a peer tutoring assignment it is common for the teacher to have students switch roles partway through so that the tutor becomes the one being tutored. Since explaining a concept to another helps extend one’s own learning, this practice gives students the opportunity to understand better the material being studied. What does the research say about peer tutoring? In reviews of peer tutoring programs, researchers found: * When students participated in the role of reading tutor, improvements in reading achievement occurred * When tutors were explicitly trained in the tutoring process, they were far more effective and the students they were tutoring experienced significant gains in achievement * Most of the students benefited from peer tutoring in some way, but same-age tutors were as effective as cross-age tutors (Burnish, Fuchs & Fuchs, 2005; Topping, 2008)  Some benefits of peer tutoring for students include higher academic achievement, improved relationships with peers, improved personal...

Words: 6206 - Pages: 25

Free Essay

The Effects of Mentoring at-Risk Youth

...James Spencer HUS345 THE EFFECTS OF MENTORING AT-RISK YOUTH Abstract: Mentoring has arguments both for and against its effectiveness in relation to at-risk youth. These programs have been known to help in areas of self-esteem, attitudes toward drugs and alcohol, grades, attendance and disciplinary problems in school. Although, the scope of at-risk youth can be quite narrow, if administered correctly it can be inclusive of all teens with emotional and behavioral problems. These programs should not be considered a quick fix to such a large problem, but it can be used as a means to an end. Mentoring programs for youth and teens considered to be at-risk have begun to grow throughout the country. Not all programs agree on a generalized approach, but it is fair to say the concept is the same when dealing with this group of youth. The term mentor is basically described as a trusted counselor or teacher. The term at-risk, for purposes of this study, relates to youth from single parent households, who exhibit emotional and behavioral problems. The overall consensus is to pair a responsible and caring adult with a troubled adolescent youth. The ultimate goal is for a relationship to form and to build a bond of trust with an adult who can in turn, help them deal with the troubles...

Words: 2280 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Sodexo Group Assignment

...Analysis of the Case "Sodexo and Principle Financial Group Recognized for the Effective Management of Diversity" DG MGT 312 4/6/2015 University of Phoenix Question 1 To develop a positive attitude towards cultural differences, it is essential to overcome cultural isolation, generating negative reactions. Adaptation and integration in a foreign culture is based not as much on the knowledge of the language, customs, norms, and values, but on a personal interest in understanding one’s values ​​and viewpoints, close emotional contact with the representatives. Thus, in the system of human resource management cultural characteristics of a nation become one of the reserves of the organization, which makes it necessary to objectively consider this range of problems. The main method that the Sodexo uses in the management of the diversity of the company is based on the integration of the one’s (home) and a new culture. This method of the reaction on the multicultural personality, internalized norms and values are managed on the extent in which people perceive others cultures’ as their own one. Due to the globalization of international business, Sodexo pay significant attention to the development of staff in multinational companies and the skills of intercultural sensitivity and adaptability. The company has developed special training programs, which aim to familiarity with the values, attitudes, traditions, religion, norms of behavior accepted in the cultures. According to the...

Words: 1052 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Wwjk

...CHAPTER DEVELOPING AN EVALUATION PLAN 4 As program staff start planning for program development and begin addressing the components of the logic model, they should keep in mind that as the logic model takes shape, the development of evaluation plans will follow soon after. The logic model can act as a guide to assist you in determining when your evaluation plan should be developed. As you identify the accomplishments and outcomes in your logic model, the next question to ask yourself is, “How will I determine if I met my accomplishments and reached the outcomes I identified?” The evaluation plan will provide a framework for why the evaluation is to be conducted, what is to be evaluated, and how the evaluation will be conducted. After you have assessed the community needs and determined what services/activities will be implemented to address those needs, the evaluation plan is the next step in your planning process. Empowerment Evaluation Before learning how to develop an evaluation plan, it is important to look at the purpose of conducting a program evaluation and understand the type of evaluation models available. This section of the chapter introduces the empowerment evaluation model and the benefits of using this model for program development and improvement. Gutierrez (1994) defines empowerment as the “process of increasing personal, interpersonal, or political power so that individuals, families, and communities can take action to improve their situations” (p. 202)...

Words: 6724 - Pages: 27

Premium Essay

African American Parents Influence On Student Achievement

...the home. Home actions such as positive attitudes towards the child’s education, school, or teachers show signs of affecting children’s education standards. In Lillian T. Eby’s Does Mentoring Matter she explains how “supportive relationships with adults are important for personal, emotional, cognitive, and psychological growth”. So in order for a child to successfully grow and develop, not only academically but also emotionally and psychologically, a strong parental figure or mentor is required to motivate the child. Eby also talks about how academic mentoring personifies the apprentice model of education where a faculty member imparts knowledge, provides support, and offers guidance to a student protégé on academic as well as non-academic issues. This type of mentoring may spark psychological adjustment and a sense of professional identity. The effects of mentoring upon the effects of young individuals explained more clearly by Lillian T. Ebby and David Duboise. In their study three major areas of mentoring were reviewed in order to find the overall effects. The results demonstrated that mentoring was directly correlated to a variety of behavioral, health related, motivational, and career outcomes. In Getting it Right from the Start Thomas G. Sticht attempts to explain parenthood and the negative affects that can arise from inactive parenting, but also how an active parenting style can positively affect a child. He goes on to describe a number of the impacts he found on children...

Words: 1935 - Pages: 8