Free Essay

Nike Casestudy

In: Business and Management

Submitted By rellers
Words 1937
Pages 8
Nike: Sweatshops and Business Ethics (Adapted/summarised from original)
By Charles Hill*, University of Washington

Introduction:

Nike is a global corporation, founded 1972, and now one of the leading marketers of athletic shoes and apparel. It has a turnover of $10bn and operates in some 140 countries. Nike does not manufacture anything. It focuses on design and marketing and contracts out (outsources) its manufacturing to some 600 factories worldwide, employing over half a million people.

For over a decade, Nike has been dogged by bad publicity and persistent accusations that that its products are made in “sweatshops” where workers, many of them children, slave away in hazardous conditions for below subsistence wages. Nike’s wealth, its detractors claim, has been built on the backs of the world’s poor. To many, Nike is a symbol of the evils of globalisation.

Nike has taken many steps to remedy the situation but admits there are still problems in overseas factories, despite laying down minimum standards of working conditions and pay, and having their standards independently audited. But the accusations, protests and bad press continue.

The Case against Nike:

In 1996 a CBS 48 Hours news reported from a factory near Ho Chi Min City (formerly Saigon, Vietnam) … The signs are everywhere of an American invasion in search of cheap labour. Millions of people who are literate, disciplined, are desperate for jobs. This is Niketown near what used to be called Saigon, one of 4 factories Nike doesn’t own but subcontracts to make a million shoes per month. It takes 25,000 workers, mostly young women, to “Just Do It”.

But the workers here don’t share in Nike’s huge profits. They work 6 days a week for only $40 a month, just $0.20 an hour.

After interviewing a young woman at the factory, the reporter continued … Her basic wage, even as a sewing team leader, still doesn’t amount to the minimum wage … she’s down to 85 lbs. Like most of the young women who make shoes, she has little choice but to accept the low wages and long hours. Nike says that it requires all subcontractors to obey local laws; but she already put in more overtime than the annual legal limit of 200 hours. Nor is it possible to leave the factory if you haven’t made enough shoes. You have to meet the quota before you can go home.

The clear implication of the story was that Nike was at fault for allowing such working conditions to persist in the Vietnam factory; (which, incidentally, was owned by a Korean company).

* Extracted from “Strategic Management an Integrated Approach” e10, by Charles Hill & Gareth Jones.

Another example of an attack on Nike’s sub-contracting practices was launched by a USA foundation largely financed by labour unions and domestic apparel manufacturers that oppose free trade with low-wage countries. They claimed that Nike’s “Air Jordans” were put together by 11-year-olds in Indonesia earning $0.14 an hour. Nike claimed this was false and that the workers earned $103 per month, equivalent to $0.45 per hour based on a 54-hour week. Nike also claimed it had staff in each factory ensuring the local minimum wage and child labour laws were being observed.

In the 1970s, most Nike shoes were being made in South Korea and Taiwan. When workers in these countries were given freedom to organise, wages rose and Nike moved production to Indonesia, China and Vietnam. These countries prohibited union membership and set the minimum wage at rock bottom. Indonesia admitted that the daily minimum wage of $2.46 is not sufficient to supply the basic needs of one person, let alone a family, where the estimated basic liveable wage is $4.00 per day. In Vietnam the pay is even less at $1.60 per day while 3 basic meals cost about $2.10 a day and then there is rent, transportation, clothing, health care, etc.

Global Exchange (an international human rights organisation) in the late 1990s claimed that in China, Nike and Reebok subcontractors were employing 13 year-olds at $0.10 per hour and worked 17 hours per day in enforced silence. These practices were in contravention of China’s own minimum wage and working hours laws. The claims were condemned by Nike as erroneous and irresponsible. Global Exchange however later got, and leaked, a confidential Ernst & Young report commissioned by Nike which showed that a Nike Vietnamese contractor employed thousands of young women working a 10.5 hour day, 6 days a week in excessive heat, noise and foul air for slightly more than $10.00 a week. It also found that workers with skin or breathing problems had not been transferred to departments free of chemicals, and that more than half the workers who dealt with dangerous chemicals had not been provided with protective clothing. It claimed workers were exposed to carcinogens that exceeded local legal standards by 177 times in parts of the plant, and that 77% of the employees suffered from respiratory problems.

Nike’s Responses:

As a result, Nike called a news-conference and pointed out that they had commissioned the report and had acted upon it. The company stated it had formulated an action plan to deal with the problems cited in the report, and has slashed overtime, improved safety and ventilation, and reduced the use of toxic chemicals. The company also asserted that the report showed that Nike’s internal monitoring system had performed exactly as it should have. Nike stated …

This shows our system of monitoring works. We have uncovered these issues clearly before anyone else, and we have moved fairly expeditiously to correct them.

Unaccustomed to playing defence, Nike formulated a number of strategies and tactics over the years (late 1990s) to deal with the problems of working conditions and pay in subcontractor facilities.

Nike hired former US Ambassador to the UN, Andrew Young, to assess working conditions in subcontractor plants around the world. In 1997 he visited 15 factories in 3 countries over a 2-week period. His report was “mildly critical” stating …

I did not see sweatshops, or hostile conditions; I saw crowded dorms, but the workers were eating at least 2 meals a day on the job and making what I was told were subsistence wages in those cultures.

Young was widely criticised by human rights and labour groups for not taking his own translators with him and for doing slipshod inspections, an assertion he repeatedly denied.

Nike also joined a presidential task force designed to find a way of banishing sweatshops in the shoe and apparel industries. The task force included representatives from industry, human rights and labour groups. They established an agreement on working conditions abroad that included a maximum 60-hour week and payment of at least the local minimum wage. They established an independent monitoring association, later to become known as the Fair Labour Association (FLA), to assess whether companies were abiding by the code. The FLA now includes among its members the Lawyers Committee for Human Rights, the National Council of Churches, the International Labour Rights Fund, some 135 Universities (because of their licensing agreements with sports apparel companies), and companies such as Nike, Reebok and Levi Strauss.

Nike began to commission independent audits of its subcontractors’ factories (like Ernst & Young), and to show its critics that this was not simply a PR exercise, Nike terminated its relationship with 4 Indonesian subcontractors for not complying with its standards for working conditions.

In a speech made to the National Press Club in 1998, Phil Knight, founder of Nike announced …

We have effectively changed our minimum age limits from the ILO standards of 14 or 15 to 18 in all foot-ware manufacturing and 16 in all other types of manufacturing. Existing workers legally employed under the former limits were grandfathered into the new requirements.

During the past 13 months we have moved to a 100% factory audit scheme, where every Nike contract factory will receive an annual check by PricewaterhouseCoopers teams who are specially trained on our Code of Conduct Owner’s Manual and audit / monitoring procedures. To date they have performed about 300 such monitoring visits. In a few instances in apparel factories they have found workers under our age standards. These factories have been required to raise their standards to 17 years of age, to require 3 documents certifying age, and to redouble their efforts to ensure workers meet these standards through interviews and record checks.

Our goal was to ensure workers around the globe are protected by requiring all factories to have no workers exposed to levels above those mandated by the permissible exposure limits (PELs) for chemicals prescribed in the OSHA indoor air quality standards.

These moves were applauded in the business press, but they were treated with sceptical response from Nike’s long-term adversaries in the debate over the use of foreign labour. While conceding that Nike’s policies were an improvement, one critic writing in the New York Times noted that …

Mr. Knight’s child labour initiative is a smokescreen. Child labour has not been a big problem with Nike, and Philip Knight knows that better than anyone. But public relations is public relations. So he announces that he’s not going to let the factories hire kids, and suddenly that’s the headline.

Mr. Knight is a 3-card (trick) player. You have to keep a close eye on him at all times.

The biggest problem with Nike is that its overseas workers make wretched, below subsistence wages. Most of the workers in Nike factories in China and Vietnam make less than $2.00 a day, well below the subsistence levels in those countries. In Indonesia, the pay is less than $1.00 a day.

The company’s current strategy is to reshape its public image while doing as little as possible for the workers Does anyone think it was an accident that Nike set up shop in human rights sinkholes, where labour organising was seen as a criminal activity and deeply impoverished workers were willing, even eager, to take to their places on assembly lines and work for next to nothing.

Dara O’Rourke an assistant professor at MIT, accompanied PricewaterhouseCooper on their audits of several factories in China, Korea and Vietnam. He concluded that although they found minor violations of labour laws and codes of conduct, they missed major labour-practice issues including hazardous working conditions, violations of overtime and wage laws. O’Rourke claimed the problem was that the auditors had limited training and relied on factory managers for data, setting up interviews with workers, all of which were performed in the factory. He claimed the auditors were getting an incomplete and sanitized view of the working conditions.

Continued Controversy:

A wave of protest against Nike continued into the 2000s, particularly from university students who set up “US Students against Sweatshops” (USAS). They did not believe the Fair Labour Association (FLA) was truly independent and they set up an alternative independent auditing organisation, the Workers Rights Consortium (WRC). The WRC is partly backed by and funded by labour unions, and they refuse to cooperate with companies because they feel it would undermine their integrity. When the University of Oregon joined the WRC instead of the FLA, Phil Knight withdrew a $30m donation to the university.

Nike continued to push forward with their own initiatives, including the release of complete reports of all independent audits of its subcontractors’ plant. Global Exchange continued to criticise the company, arguing in mid-2001 that the company was not living up to Phil Knight’s 1998 promises and that it was intimidating workers from speaking out about abuses.

_____________________________

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Ancient Art

... form and content of the pieces as well as compare them to one another. The artworks chosen for this essay are: The Nike of Samothrace (Greek) and a funerary sculpture (African) made by the Bara or Sakalava people of Madagascar, Africa. When it comes to ancient art, there are many different cultures that can be compared and interpreted with one another. The subjects of this essay come from ancient Greek art and ancient African art. Greek art mostly depicted humanism, gods, power, harmony, order, adoration, etc. It served as a symbolization of political, religious, and/or ethical purposes. Greek art upheld spiritual views as well as unity and the dedication to great rulers. In a sense, Greek and African art are similar in many way with only a few differences. African art depicted deep spiritual and religious views. It also expresses the true respect for the human figure (humanism) as Greek art does. Sculptures of warriors and powerful people were often made to hold their spirits in a way of making them live on forever. African art expressed harmony and balance as well as vigor in detail and orientation. The first artwork to be explored will be the Nike “Victory of Samothrace”. (The Meaning of Greek Art, 2012). (Evans, 2010). This is a three-dimensional sculpture that was built between 220 and 185 BC in adoration/celebration of the Greek victory goddess Nike. It was made with Parian marble with a finished color of gray. The detail of the statue showed definite lines, wrinkles...

Words: 744 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Nike Rhetorical Analysis

...The ethos is effective because the brand Nike has been around since 1962 and is recognized worldwide to the public. The company is highly respected in many parts of the athletic industry. The brand also has a long list of spokespeople and commercials that built credibility to the brands name. By choosing an average overweight boy, Nike is using someone is can be relatable to mass audience. The audience can feel as though that they can trust the boy using Nike because the boy is just like the audience. Although it is a critical aspect for Nike to have credibility when selling their products such as using celebrity endorsers, it is also important for the consumer to feel that they have logically made a wise investment in purchasing Nike...

Words: 277 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Nike Ethos Pathos And Logos

...Nike recently released an advertisement video on July 13th, 2015, “Short A Guy,” the hit video has been seen on TV and has over three million views on YouTube. As a company, Nike has set out to have the gear that will make the customer look as nice as they play. Top flight athletes all across the country use their gear, and in this advertisement it showed the likes of Mike Trout, Andrew Luck, and Anthony Davis all wearing Nike apparel playing their own respective sports. Trying to get the audience to buy their athletic gear, this advertisement clearly appeals to those who are interested in athletics and does so through the use of ethos, logos, and pathos. Throughout this advertisement, the audience is taken through a variety of settings and...

Words: 1003 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Nike

...Case Title: Nike Inc. Developing an effective public relations strategy 1. SHORT CYCLE PROCESS | Who | Nike´s Corporation | What | La imagen de la compañía fue muy negativa, por lo que sus ventas bajaron considerablemente | Why | En los medios de comunicación afirmaron que las fábricas subcontratadas para Nike en China e Indonesia obligaban a los trabajadores a tener largas horas por bajos salarios y los gerentes abusaban verbalmente | When | En 1990 | Case difficulty cube How: x Analytical Conceptual Presentation 2. LONG CYCLE PROCESS | Problema | Raíz del problema | La mala publicidad perjudica a la organización terriblemente, ya que los consumidores toman la postura de prohibir la compra de sus productos. | El público fue informado de que Nike estaba maltratando a sus trabajadores en el extranjero | Nike ignoró los problemas y negó su responsabilidad hacia su fabricación por contrato | La compañía no se quería hacer responsable de las acusaciones que se le hacían, ya que culpaban a los contratistas en los países asiáticos | Nike no puede equilibrar entre el objetivo de actividades y cuestiones prácticas laborales | Nike no era coherente entre lo que tenía por escrito en su código de conducta y lo que realmente estaba pasando en las fábricas de China e Indonesia | Los grupos activistas no se convencieron con la implementación de su código de conducta y problemas de administración...

Words: 1051 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Converse

...fama insuperable En 1921 contrataron al jugador de baloncesto Chuck Taylor para promocionar la marca y ser la imagen de Converse All Star y lo será hasta su jubilación en 1968. En 1932, para agradecerle a Taylor su labor de agente comercial y por contribuir al éxito de la marca, su nombre empezó a aparecer en el logo que se encuentra en el tobillo de la zapatilla. Desde ese entonces, la marca no deja de crecer y en 1984 fue el principal esponsor de los juegos olímpicos de Los Angeles. También se le asocia la marca a varias personalidades del mundo del tenis y del baloncesto como Magic Mike. Desde esa época, se han vendido mas de 750millones de pares Tras varias decenias, Converse empezó a perder fama y notoriedad hasta que, en 2003, Nike decidio comprar la marca. Las converse son unas zapatillas clásicas que todo el mundo tiene en sus armarios y que nunca pasan de moda ya que siempre se están diversificando con los distintos modelos (cortas, largas y muy largas), los colores (prácticamente todos, incluso el mas insolito) y materiales (tela,cuero..) Son unas deportivas que se adaptan a todos los estilos, de la mas clásica a la mas excéntrica Todo parece apuntar a que esta tendencia va a seguir por muchos años mas...

Words: 319 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Nike History Essay

...Nike has been around much longer than most would think and continues to be the leading trend setter in athletic wear. Nike was started in January of 1964. The athletic company began as just a small clothing distributing company out of the truck of Phil Knight’s, owner and CEO of Nikes, Car. The Saying you started from the bottom is very true when it comes to Nike who now leads in sales of all athletic gear compared to Adidas who at the time of 1964 was the most popular athletic company. From starting in a truck of a car no one would suspect that this company would not only be defined as the definition of ‘cool’ when purchasing clothing and shoes from stores all over the United States but yet the brand that carries our pop culture. Nike started...

Words: 918 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Assistant

...ADVANCED MARKETING STRATEGY  362MKT Example on Nike Dr. Eric Chu 362Mkt‐2012 Example Company Background • NIKE, Inc. is the world’s leading innovator in  athletic footwear, apparel, equipment and  accessories. The mission of Nike is to bring  inspiration and innovation to every athlete in  the world. 362Mkt‐2012 Example Product Market • Garment Industry – The garment industry consists of different  categories of wearing apparels that serve both  beauty, comfortable and body protection. – Product categories could involve men wear, kids  wear, sports wear, ladies, … 362Mkt‐2012 Example Market Audit (1) • External Environment – By STEEPLE • Social factor: people are more concern with health,  fashion and beauty.  Diverse segments are emerging in  the garment industry. (Opportunity) • Technology: different material by nano technology  could help to build more comfortable garment for  consumer market. Different material available lead to  better design for manufacturers. (Opportunity) • Legal: pirated products costs a lot of money for  litigations in the industry. (Threat) 362Mkt‐2012 Example Market Audit (2) • External Environment – By 5‐forces • Supplier: supplier marketing in the garment industry  are mainly small low costs manufacturers in the area  and many suppliers are available. Suppliers bargaining  power to the industry is low. (Opportunity) • Buyer: Information transparency increase and there are  lot more competitive products for customers to choose...

Words: 888 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Air Jordan XX9: Brand Analysis

...There are numerous sneakers launched by distinct identified and unknown organizations for gamers each and every yr. Some sneakers are extremely unique and a few are costly. Nike, Reebok Jordan,Adidas are best brand identify who promote favourite sneakers for gamers. This 12 months Jordan business also reviled new sinkers and 1 is most latest Air Jordan and quickly its colorway are releasing quickly. An additional current release of jordan business Air Jordan XX9. The two Michael Jordan and Tinker Hatfield collectively launched Air Jordan series which gets to be most promoting footwear from the 12 months. At exact same time Jordan launched an additional pair of footwear Air Jordan III which can be depending on Chicago Bulls-themed edition which...

Words: 466 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Blue Jeans History

...Blue jeans! The most popular clothes in all the time. We see people wearing this invention on every day and any occasion. There is no fashion trend has been worn for this long as blue jeans. Jeans are an icon of fashion item, and they manufactured in many fits such as skinny, slim, straight, boot cut, low waist, anti-fit, and the classic. Jeans pants have increasing fashionable. The word "jeans" came from a material called Jean which is named by sailors from Genoa in Italy and they wore clothes made from it. Do you ever thought about jeans? How had it made and how it was invented? Jeans was invented by Jacob W. Davis in partnership with Levi Strauss & Co. In 1831, Jacob W. Davis was born and he was trained and worked as a tailor. He owned a tailor shop which is making tents, horse blankets and wagon covers for trains. Jacob was using a really heavy cotton fabrics named "Duck" and "Denim" which he is buying them from Levi Strauss & Co. The history of jeans is begun in San Francisco. One day, a lady customer came to his shop and asked for a clothes for her husband which has obesity and he couldn't find him a suitable clothes in shops. The lady has requested Jacobs two pants to be made as strong as possible. The tailor thinks about the copper rivets that he is using them on horses blankets and he put them on the pockets of the trousers so they don't tear. Then, these pair of pants get liked by people and became a very popular for heavy work. He had come up with an unusual way of...

Words: 908 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Brochure

...Nike, Inc. is the world's largest supplier and manufacturer of athletic shoes, apparel and other sports equipment. The company employed about 56,500 people worldwide and in 2014, Nike's global revenue amounted to about 27.8 billion U.S. dollars. The North American region of Nike generated the largest portion of the company's revenue that year, approximately 12.3 billion U.S. dollars. Of that 12.3 billion U.S. dollars, the Oregon based company's athletic footwear segment generated about 7.5 billion U.S. dollars. Nike, Inc. is the world's largest supplier and manufacturer of athletic shoes, apparel and other sports equipment. The company employed about 56,500 people worldwide and in 2014, Nike's global revenue amounted to about 27.8 billion U.S. dollars. The North American region of Nike generated the largest portion of the company's revenue that year, approximately 12.3 billion U.S. dollars. Of that 12.3 billion U.S. dollars, the Oregon based company's athletic footwear segment generated about 7.5 billion U.S. dollars. Statistics and Facts on Nike Statistics and Facts on Nike A new range of Nike apparel products assist the body’s natural ability to regulate temperature when running in a variety of conditions. The innovations are informed by Nike’s "Nature Amplified" design ethos — an approach focused on the body in motion and fueled by scientific data and athlete insights — to keep runners comfortable, protected and focused on performing at their best. Nike designers...

Words: 1167 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Demand For Sneakers Or Running Shoes

...An increase in the quality of sneakers can cause people to buy one and vice versa. Buyers expectations. If buyers suspect a an increase sneaker prices, the demand for sneakers will increase in the current market and decrease if prices are suspected to drop. Advertising can increase brand loyalty to the goods and increase demand. For example, higher spending on advertising by Nike running shoes has increased global sales. Supply, is the producer's willingness and ability to supply a given good at various price points, holding all else constant. Supply can be influenced by a number of factors that are called the determinants of supply. Generally, the supply of a product depends on its price and cost of production. In simple terms, supply is the function of price and cost of production. some of the factors influencing the supply of a sneaker or ruining shoes is as...

Words: 864 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Nike Political Influence

...Nike, Inc is an American company started by Bill Bowerman and Phil Knight. Based out of Beaverton, Oregon, Nike was founded in 1964 under the name Blue Ribbon Sports. Bowerman and Knight changed the name of the company to Nike after the Greek goddess of victory in 1971. The Nike company designs, develops, and manufacturers athletic and active wear products including footwear, apparel, equipment, and accessories. The company started with one pair of running shoes and has grown into a multinational billion-dollar business that provides everything one may need to be active. Nike's success is in great part to the company's strong and ever evolving marketing strategies that continually meet the needs of their target demographics in unique and emotional...

Words: 910 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Nike Erp

...Case Study: Nike ERP Implementation Nike shoe division grew and spread rapidly around the globe from its inception in 1972 through 1998. Yet in 1999, Nike realized that in order to keep up with the growing demands of their products, and specifically their Air Jordan line of basketball shoes, they would have to make changes in the way they forecasted and projected demands and distributed their products. Eventually it was decided that these changes would take place in the form of the implementation of a new supply chain and Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) software system. This paper will examine the supply chain problems Nike was trying to fix with the new system, the problems that arose from the implementation of the new system, and how Nike resolved these problems. Nike was founded in 1957 on the vision of two men, Bill Bowerman and Phil Knight; a vision to redefine the industry of athletic footwear. Bill Bowerman was a track and field coach at the University of Oregon in search of a competitive edge for his athletes, a competitive edge which could be achieved by spearheading changes to the running shoes of the time. At the time, Adidas and Puma were the dominant brands of running shoes. Phil Knight, a Portland runner with a degree in finance from Stanford University, proposed to compete with the German (Adidas and Puma) brands of running shoes by manufacturing them in Japan, which at the time was experiencing a post WWII boon in its economy, and their stage of manufacturing...

Words: 2341 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Nike

...Cathy Buckland Nike MKTG305-1202A-05 Marketing Management Project Type: Unit 4 Individual Project April 15, 2012 Abstract To get the word out many companies have turned to television and actors and actress for advertising. Nike has made its way through many changes and it has been able to focus on its marketing mix through television ads as well as using billboards, and magazines. Nike Introduction Targeting the market is what every company faces in order to increase sales and in order to keep their company in business. Nike has proven to be able corner and stay one step ahead of the market even in a trying economy it uses athletes, actors and actresses to keep its company going. The brand in today’s market Nike currently has a 47% control of the market with its athletic shoes with sales in the U.S. at 3.7 billion dollars. Nike also targets the market in well over 100 countries which include Europe, and Asia Pacific. Since Nike is such a large producer of many different products its targeting market varies. Nike athletic shoes have been very popular with both the younger crowd as well as adults. Its products are designed with quality this along with the ability to use marketing strategies has continued to keep this company at the top of the list. Nike has used athletes such as Michael Jordan, and Lebron James to promote their products. The strategy allows for the consumers to wear products that they believe in because of the superstar wearing them...

Words: 1412 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Nke I2 Erp

...Nike I2 ERP Implementation Failure Case Study February 9, 2014 Shafer Minnick Morgan Correll Jeff Harvey Nike stands as the World’s leading producer of Athletic Footwear, Apparel and Equipment. As of 2013 they held complete ownership or joint venture in the following companies:  Nike Brand  Cole Haan  Converse  Hurley International  Umbro Athletic Wear  Nike Golf  Jordan Brand This is a rather long and somewhat surprising list to many, based on some of these brands are portrayed as competitors in the daily consumer market. Nike products are sold in over 170 countries worldwide through their network of 700 retails stores. They have 38,00 Nike employees worldwide, based in those retail store, or one of 65 administrative offices or 10 plus Sales Offices or showrooms worldwide. Nike products are manufactured through a contract manufacturing partnership consisting of 900 contract plants worldwide using over 1 million contract employees. These same plants are managed by their local ownership, but Nike spends significant time and money coaching these plants in the Nike sustainable manufacturing plan. The Nike Strategy The Nike Business strategy focuses on Innovation. First the “Innovation to Serve the Athlete”-meaning they desire to design and produce the best products for athlete safety and performance. They want to be the leaders in new and improved products to advance athletic performance. Secondly, “Innovation to Grow the Company”- Nike wants...

Words: 3176 - Pages: 13