Free Essay

Nobody's Story

In: English and Literature

Submitted By shirin16
Words 623
Pages 3
Shirin Bismillah
M.A English (Prev.) IInd Semester

One of the principal ideas of Catherine Gallagher’s essay The Novel and Other Discourses of Suspended Disbelief revolves around the ‘world outside the novel’ and how it got distinguished from other genres and previous forms of fiction. One of the most sophisticated explanation she develops across her Nobody’s Story. Gallagher argues that the condition for the emergence of the novel is the break from the scandal sheets which were scurrilous prose writings directed at real life figures. The female writers composing against the powerful patrons in the scandalous court chronicles of 1700s became the target of a degrading equation which was between a Writer and a Whore. The movement away from this degraded real life identity to the lofty observer of life changed their status from a whore to an intellectual. It is this observer who does not write of a real life personality but of a fictional Nobody who can fabricate stories and characters that are irreproducible and creations of sheer genius. Once the subject of a narrative is unrestrained from a real life identity, it eventually becomes a Nobody. This paper shall examine Henry Fielding’s Tom Jones, who becomes a new citizen of England, with his status of a Foundling.
According to Gallagher, ‘fiction can and does exist independent of the novel’, which was also a response to rise of individualism and middle class that made novel a dominant form. This brings into light the question of reality in 18th century, where identity becomes problematic in each novel. Tom Jones, with a fictitious title, insists on false identity that is discovered on the property of a wealthy landowner, Allworthy. Legally a bastard Tom’s inheritance of his family fortune is threatened according to the English Law. Gallagher suggests that the rise of fiction is from this ‘nobody’ who is indeed ‘everybody’. One can not empirically associate this with a ‘somebody’, who denotes a scandalous personality whose story could only be found through the salacious pamphlets.
Tom Jones can be thought of as Nullius Filius or ‘Son of Nobody’, barred from every legal inheritance, which were also considered children of nobody by the Church. Fielding’s deliberate maneuver of keeping Tom’s legal ambiguity till the end perhaps frames Tom also as Filius Populi or ‘Son of the People’ vindicating him as someone with an obscured genealogy and not having control over his origins. An interesting parallel, which operates as an exact backdrop for Tom Jones is of the ‘Young Pretender’ Bonnie Prince Charles, seen as a bastard child, whose invasion of England in 1745 failed. This idea of being a ‘pretender’ alludes to having no legitimate claim on something but pretending to get hold of something. Tom’s legal status in conformance to this is an allegorical correspondence within and outside the text with the British history.
An allegorized ‘everybody’, Tom Jones also disrupts the notion of genealogical model of power i.e. the kinship structure with the absence of father figure. The reader does not know the real identity of Tom in the beginning which leads to a series of abuses for the supposed mother. The final exposition of Tom Jones is done through a train of events which are hardly moral suggesting the idea of virtue is class based. The misnaming of the protagonist creates a space for fiction with no change in his legal position in the end. Hence this movement away from the scandal sheet to the fictional Nobody brings into existence a new set of mental habits to read a novel where the idea of fictionality is a product of modern specularity.

Gallagher, Catherine, Nobody’s Story: The Vanishing Acts of Women Writers in the Marketplace, 1670-1820. Ocean Press, 1995.

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Things They Carried

...They Carried. In fact, he often points out that he has made entire stories up, after the fact. He defends his decisions by proposing that what he has done is, in fact, not lie, but rather tell a story-truth. He argues that his reason for doing this is to bring the story to life more than it could live through the happening-truth. 'I want you to feel what I felt. I want you to know why story-truth is truer sometimes than happening-truth' (O'Brien, 183). O'Brien believes that, when accompanied by vivid details which essentially make the reader view the scene as a dream, story-truths can carry greater emotional truths than ever possible to be achieved through actual, happening-truths. With this, he shows, contrary to belief, how story-truths are often truer than happening-truths, and demonstrates this through the addition of often graphic details. Happening-truth encompasses actual events that take place. However true these stories may be, they are often times viewed as unreal simply because they have no details to back them up. The entire shit field scene that was put into this book, for example, was turned from a happening-truth into a story-truth because the original version was not believable. The reader can see this through O'Brien describing the letters that he received from Norman Bowker. Norman writes to Tim, telling him that he should write about the event. 'What you should do, Tim, is write a story... You were there --- you can tell it' (O'Brien, 151). Norman does......

Words: 2289 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay


...Examine the endings (with close attention to the last ‘scene’ and the last paragraph) of at least three 20c. short stories and consider how the author handles them and their relation to the story as a whole. The art of ending short stories has been hotly contested for centuries. As humans we naturally desire firm conclusions that tie up the story’s various loose threads and leave us with a sense of satisfaction. Many writers, in modern times, have tried to challenge this convention, preferring to leave endings open for interpretation and development of thought. This is connected with the developing idea that a short story is, in essence, a brief glimpse into a character’s life. In this sense, there is a future outside of the ending, which negates the requirement for an effective conclusion. Flannery O’Connor is an example of a modern writer who sought to challenge the conventions of a story’s ending. Her tale, ‘Everything That Rises Must Converge,’ is told from the perspective of Julian, a college graduate who is being supported by his mother while he seeks employment. The plot revolves around a ride on an integrated bus, and the crisis point comes in the form of a confrontation between Julian’s mother and a black woman wearing the same hat. Julian repeatedly conveys his wish to be rid of his mother, going so far as to dream about her being seriously ill. Despite this, his reaction upon her stroke shows exactly how dependant he is on her: ‘His voice was thin, scarcely a...

Words: 3113 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

A Good Man Is Hard to Find

...A Good Man Is Hard to Find Flannery O’Connor’s short story ‘A Good Man Is Hard to Find’ reveals a harsh, yet realistic view of the world by using three literary elements: foreshadowing, irony, and character. O’Connor begins the story with a mere family vacation. The story seems so simple and innocent, that the deeper meaning is often not recognizable at first. As the story develops the darkness of the plot is revealed to the reader. Overall, the stories three literary elements tie the stories theme together, which is prejudice, religion, and violence. Foreshadowing is an important element that is used several times throughout the story. O’Connor begins the story by foreshadowing the Misfit; a convict who has escaped from the federal penitentiary. It is important that he is mentioned because he eventually ends up murdering the family. The next element of foreshadowing takes place when the family is getting in the car, preparing to head toward their vacation. The grandmother has over dressed herself for the car ride. She is wearing a navy blue, polka dotted dress trimmed with lace and violets. She said that, “In case of an accident, anyone seeing her dead will know that she was a lady.” This statement clearly foretells that something tragic is going to take place. As the family rides along in the car they pass a cotton field with five or six graves in the middle of it. Once again there is an indication of death approaching the family. After the family’s car accident, a......

Words: 1042 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Critical Analysis

...OF THE SHORT STORY ‘YOURS’ BY MARY ROBISON CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF THE SHORT STORY ‘YOURS’ BY MARY ROBISON                                                                                                                   -MAHMUD HASSAN The short story ‘Yours’ is written by Mary Robison. She lives in Gainesville, Florida, where she teaches at the writing program at the University of Florida. The story ‘Yours’ is all about a married couple, Clark and Alison. Mary Robison managed to create a simple but very touching story about life and death, love and compassion. The story tells about a man and a woman, a married couple, who make jacks-o-lanterns out of pumpkins the night before Halloween. In the story we see that Alison is half younger than her husband. Here Clark is of seventy eighty and Alison is of thirty five years old. There is no indication in story for how long they are married. Clark is a doctor, internist and a Sunday water colorist and Alison works in a children day care center. ‘They were both quite tall and looked something alike in their facial features”. In general logic this very the difference of ages between the two seems illogical but there must be something that tied them in marital relationship. May be this relation occurred out of doctor-patient relationship, maybe he was her doctor. Whatever the causes may be it seems from the story that they love each other and trying to keep other happy by praising one another’s work. From the story we come to......

Words: 1578 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Dead Man

...Dead man * Dead man (1995) * Genre: Drama fantasy western * Director : Jim Jarmusch * WritteR: Jim Jarmusch * Cinematography: robby muller * Editing : Jay rabinowitz * Music: Neil young * Starring : Johnny depp- Gary farmer PLOT Johnny Depp as William Blake, a newly-orphaned accountant who leaves his home in Cleveland to accept a job in the frontier town of Machine. Upon his arrival, Blake is told by the factory owner Dickinson (Robert Mitchum) that the job has already been filled.Jobless,hopeless and without money,blake meets a former prostitute called Thel Russell (Mili Avital), who sells flower papers. He lets her take him home. Thel's ex-boyfriend Charlie (Gabriel Byrne) surprises them in bed and shoots Blake, accidentally killing Thel when she tries to shield Blake with her body. the wounded Blake shoots and kills Charlie with Thel's gun before climbing bewilderedly out the window and fleeing Machine on a stolen pinto. Company-owner Dickinson, the father of Charlie, hires three legendary frontier killers, Cole Wilson (Lance Henriksen), Conway Twill (Michael Wincott) , and Johnny "The Kid" Pickett (Eugene Byrd) to hunt Blake as the murderer of his son and Thel, although he seems to care most about recovering the stolen horse. Blake then finds himself below a big american indian guy (Gary farmer) who is attempting to remove the bullet from his chest. the Indian guy called himself Nobody reveals to him that the bullet is too close to...

Words: 1555 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

West Side Story Essay

...The popular 1961 film, West Side Story, follows the adventure and triumph in New York City, of two star-crossed lovers, born into opposing dichotomies. Although the movie may seem like nothing more than a musical about two feuding gangs in the 1950s, this story dates back to the sixteenth century, during the Dark Ages. It is perhaps even more ancient, developed by Ancient Greeks. The exact tale did not originate that far into the past, but its basic plot of a literary tragedy was invented long ago, and was adopted to modern times. West Side Story qualifies as a literary tragedy because the established tragic hero impacts the rise, climax, fall, and ultimate inescapable disaster of the story. The plot structure of a literary tragedy follows a very specific and necessary path throughout the story. The tale begins with hatred, fighting, and conflict, at nobody’s ideal. The plot requires a reason to escalate or rise, which is the Tony, the tragic hero, and his desire to reach his ideal of love. Other characters’ ideals are also attempted to be achieved. The individual members of the Jets and Sharks strive to gain superiority and territory from each other. The gangs start the path to their ideals by arranging a fight to decide who the victorious and superior gang will be. Tony rises towards his ideal when he meets Maria, and makes a proud and willful decision to pursue a relationship, despite forces acting against them. Uncontrollable forces act upon our hero, such as his......

Words: 850 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Power of Women

...image for her readers by using phrases such as “starveling ribs, slavering jaws, and lolling tongue” (625, Carter). These phrases are all used to stress the starvation or more the desperation of wolves hunting for prey. When the “slavering jaws” (625), “lolling tongue” (625), starveling ribs are put together a beast is created in that every ounce of their being is concentrated to finding something that will satisfy their hunger. Every detail including the wolf’s grizzly features is meant to help the reader picture the sometimes excessive masculinity the beast inside men. However even this masculinity, which is usually related to power and dominance is be easily undertaken by the feminine nature of a beautiful, young woman. Throughout the story the young girl begins to transition to womanhood. And this womanhood enables her to bed the beast of a man who is to have her virginity. The girl in the red shawl is introduced as an adolescent in the midst of puberty. According to the text, she has begun to show with “her breasts [that] have just begun to swell” (627, Carter) and her “woman’s bleeding” (627). As a young girl, she is showered with love, adoration, and affection. Many girls with this type of protection are sometime naïve and don’t...

Words: 854 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Should Public Figures Be Held Accountable for Their Actions, Even Those Done in Private?

...In this time and day of the twenty-first century where there is an elaborate system established to report the work of public figures, the idea of privacy is beginning to blur into the lines of public exposure, and the ones at stake are the public figures - be they celebrities, politicians or athletes. Actions undertaken in private are what they are - private. However, with intense scrutiny from the media, these actions are no longer private, and are subject to criticism and judgement from the public who crave these news like flies crave honey. The issue at hand is the matter of whether these public figures should be responsible, criticized and even punished for acts that were meant to be conducted in private. The very concept of privacy for public figures is practically non-existent, especially when the media watches over them like hawks do their prey. Hence, I disagree that public figures should be held accountable for the actions, even actions undertaken in private. While public figures wield great influence to our society and are even labeled as role models, often the public forgets that privacy is entitled to everybody, and that as long as they perform well in their job, there is absolutely no reason for the public to be this interested in their private lives. Article 12 of the United Nations Declaration of Human Rights states “No one shall be subjected to arbitrary interference with his privacy, family, home or correspondence, nor to attacks upon his honour and......

Words: 886 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

How Does the Writer Effectively Depict the Life of an Ordinary Indian?

...transport. Building materials add to this picture of rural poverty and were told of “bamboo thatch, straw and mud” which contrast sharply to the bright colours of “the big house.” This contract informs us of a stark wealth gap in the village which is true of all India. The depiction of most of the indians in the story are farmers who have a hard life working on a farm with sheep and other livestocks. Muni is one of them, a farmer who owned a “flock of forty sheep and goats and sallied forth every morning driving the flock to the highway a couple of miles away.”. His daily routine is to spend all his time and effort on a farm, hardworking to earn more money since he and his wife barely earn any money to support themselves. The writer tells us Muni’s routine to show us how they live their ordinary lives. As time passes, people get older, they are more uncared and neglected in society. Muni’s fortunes start “gradually declining, unnoticed.”, his stock has come down to two goats which are worthless, he used to have tons of sheep and now it’s left with two goats that nobody wants, and is obviously going through a severe economic poverty. Now he is helpless, and nobody’s willing to financially support him in any ways. Like many Indians, Muni struggles to bring in money and owns only two goats...

Words: 614 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay


...and physically and trying to expose to his family that how money works and important through their life that is possible to change anything in the world even their racial problem. MAMA: Oh—So now it’s life. Money is life. Once upon a time freedom used to be life—now it’s money. I guess the world really do change . . . WALTER: No—it was always money, Mama. We just didn’t know about it. MAMA: No . . . something has changed. You something new, boy. In my time we was worried about not being lynched . . . You ain’t satisfied or proud of nothing we done. I mean that you had a home; that we kept you out of trouble till you was grown; that you don’t have to ride to work on the back of nobody’s streetcar—You my children—but how different we done become. Mother of the main conflict in the story is trying to tell his son that money is not life, freedom is life, which is starts with home that covers you form bad thing and makes personality Passionate, ambitious, and bursting with the energy of his dreams, Walter Lee is a desperate man,...

Words: 846 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Pink Floyd Influences

...There are countless significant and meaningful songs that have been released between 1950 and the present day that it would be impossible to analyze each one of them. There are, however, a few ones that shine brighter than the rest. Artists such as The Beach Boys, the Beatles, and the Rolling Stones have had such a huge impact on some people and society that they are still recognized to this day. It’s important to remember that songs are not just made to sound good for the listener. Songs carry a message that could sometimes have a huge influence and impression on people. They can be used to motivate, tell a story and remind people that they are not alone. Pink Floyd, a band formed in 1965, often carried messages through their songs and offer a unique style to their music that help portray their messages. They are an important band and should be covered in “The Rock and Roll Era and Beyond” so students can learn of their significance. Pink Floyd was an English rock band that was formed in 1965. They were mainly active through the 70s and 80s and had a few active periods...

Words: 1635 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

The Destructors and the Rocking Horse Winner

...conflicts concluded? d. The effects of the reader III. The Rocking-Horse Winner e. Conflict of Paul vs his mother f. How did the conflict unfold and the characters affected. g. How are the conflicts resolved? Does the protagonist succeed in achieving their goals? h. The effects of the reader IV. Conclusion The conflict of The Destructors by Graham Greene and that of The Rocking-Horse Winner had some similarities and differences in regards to the conflict, plot, and structure. Both display a very invigorating tale and a mystery regarding the conclusion of each story. These shorts stories were both about children who did not have an understanding and were naïve to the ways of the world. Each displayed a very disturbing outcome and some more than others. The conflict lead to a surprising turn of events displayed itself as the stories were depicted. The Destructors by Graham title clearly described and assisted the reader in the series of events to come. One is lead to assume that in some way or form destruction will take place. The conflict that leads to the destruction is the internal turmoil going on with (T) Trevor. He was upset about his family’s current living situation. The narrator makes statements such as “The fact that his father, a former architect and present clerk, had “come down in the world” and that his mother considered herself better than the neighbors Greene (1954). This statement means at one time......

Words: 1273 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Dog's Story

...Hachiko:a dog's story Hey! it's a nice movie...You know I really loved dogs and this story about dogs really touched me. It's not because he rescued someone or do something heroic but this is something different. Among the dog's movies that I ever watched this is the story that I truly like and I can't help of sharing this for you. There was a dog which should be delivered in a certain place but apparently the dog lost in travel. Then there was a man found that cutie dog along the road. The man brought that dog in his home because when he found that puppy there are no identification or location where the dog should be delivered. At that night the man watching television with his new pet. afterwards, he go upstairs and sleep with his wife. Suddenly, the puppy realize that he was already alone in the room. So, he push the door and try to find the man...while looking around he found stairs and decided to go up there. He saw someone sleeping on the he move closer and he tounged the feet that he saw at the bottom of the bed. Then, a women shouted and so frightened that makes her husband awake. The man explained to his wife about that puppy. Because of the disturbance that causes by that dog the man lazily raise in bed and decided to bring back the puppy in the room where in left it. But the problem is the puppy follow him again and again for that he decided there to stay for a while He gets a bowl of popcorn and share it with that naughty puppy. Yet, the man fall......

Words: 1290 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

The Things They Carried

...The Things They Carried written by Tim O’Brien is a postmodern novel that details the daily activities of Alpha Company (a platoon of soldiers) throughout the Vietnam War. O’Brien depicts the harsh realities and terrors associated with war and the harsh effects soldiers are faced to deal with on an ongoing basis. Given the time frame and settings of both these chapters at first glance, “The Lives of the Dead” and “In the Field” appear to be critically different, but after further analysis one can easily fathom that they are in fact quite similar. O’Brien emphasizes these similarities by using the theme of death and the effects correlated with it, regardless of the situation. The effects of death are then identified by studying several characters reactions to the death of various platoon members and key people within their lives. By doing this O’Brien is able to connect these chapters seamlessly, and thus strengthen the theme of death throughout his novel. “The Lives of the Dead” is an unique chapter as it not only captures what it is like to be a soldier in the Vietnam War, but it also focuses on the experiences one faces with death. Furthermore, how it doesn’t matter your age, gender or status death will ultimately play a key role in your life. After Lieutenant Jimmy Cross sent in an air strike on a seemingly deserted area that resulted in the death of one old man, the members of Alpha Company are forced to cope with the death. Once again, the majority of them take it as a......

Words: 1161 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Angela's Ashes

...Rivera 1 Rivera 1 Paola Rivera Wld Lit O Ms. Ziemlak Monday, November 28, 2011 Angela’s Ashes Questions: 1. I liked Angela’s Ashes a lot; I thought it was a very powerful literary text. The moment when Frank says, “ Worse than the ordinary miserable childhood is the miserable Irish childhood, and worse yet is a miserable Irish Catholic childhood” (6). At this moment I immediately could recognize that Angela’s Ashes was going to be an emotional memoir of the author’s life. I enjoyed the fact that this was a bildungsroman novel, meaning it was a coming-of-age novel. In being this type of novel we see how Frank evolves from a naïve boy into a man who is surely to prove nothing like his father. 2. Through the novel, I was able to identify the following themes: Drinking in Irish culture, Hunger and Food, Antagonism between Presbyterians vs. Catholics, Poverty, and Honor. Drinking in Irish culture, is seen as a way to escape the hardships of Irish life, Frank’s father uses this as an excuse to keep drinking, and he is also motivated by others to do so. Hunger and the value of food is one of the most important themes, given that a lot of the suffering the McCourt’s have to go through id the scarcity of food. Since their dad is an alcoholic who can’t keep a job, the kids usually suffered from sever hunger all the time, their dad would rather spend the little money he earned on a pint, and what was left was used on cigarettes for him and Angela. The Antagonism......

Words: 736 - Pages: 3