Norstorm Hr Case Analysi

In: Business and Management

Submitted By RA007
Words 917
Pages 4
|



1. What is the cause of the problems described in the case? How serious are these problems?
The cause of Problem in Nordstrom is misaligned Compensation system. The Compensation is
not vertically aligned with the Strategy of the company. Nordstrom depended on its sales employee
for customer care and selling the products. However, the compensation structure was not adequately
aligned to reward those behaviours which forced employees to work off-hours without getting
Compensated for it.
The problems were very serious as is evident from the case; the company came under a barrage of
national class action suits which made a huge dent into the brand of the company. They had to make
a $15 million fund which wasn’t enough. More importantly, it broke the numero Uno position and aura
that Nordstrom was enjoying vis-à-vis their competitors.

2. Are Nordstrom employees pressured inappropriately by the sales-per-hour system? By management?
Yes, Nordstrom employees are pressured quite inappropriately by the SHP ( Sales Hour Performance)
system. In this system, employees were assigned a given SHP and if they go above the SHP , then
they would be eligible for commission otherwise they will just get the base price. Now, the employees
worked “off hours” for doing everything from writing Thank You letters to sales meetings etc. but if
they add the “off hours” then the SHP will go below the stipulated figure and they will not eligible for
commission and without the overtime hours their salary reduced substantially.
So, it was counter mechanism, if you punch in all the work hours , the employee would suddenly find
himself in the bottom rung of SHP which lead to reduced pay, termination as well. And if one doesn’t
add the extra hours then also the pay is reduced but one can maintain SHP. So employees tried not
to put their “off hours” but worked…...

Similar Documents

Case Analysi

...  division  needed  to  be  carefully  coordinated  with  those  in  other  divisions  if  the  company  was  to  successfully  leverage  its doll character brands across all divisions.   The Capital Budgeting Process at New Heritage  The annual investment process at New Heritage began with personnel in each division proposing  projects for investment that were aligned with the company’s multi‐year strategy plans.  As the company grew, deliberate steps were taken to decentralize some of the project approval process and increase spending authority at the division level. However, large and/or strategic spending proposals were reviewed at the corporate level by a capital budgeting committee consisting of the CEO, CFO, COO, the controller, and the division presidents.   Each project proposal presented to the committee included the following information:  brief  description of the project and the strategic rationale; overview base case financials (five‐year  operating and cash flow forecasts); spending requirements by asset category, personnel requirements,   key project financial performance measures (NPV, IRR, payback period, profitability index); and  project risks and milestones.  Proposed projects ran the gamut from relatively minor, tactical projects  (the replacement of obsolete assembly equipment) to major strategic projects that would significantly  alter the company’s market position (an acquisition, for example).   Some projects were  HARVARD BUSINESS...

Words: 2246 - Pages: 9

Norstorm Hr Case Analysi

...| 1. What is the cause of the problems described in the case? How serious are these problems? The cause of Problem in Nordstrom is misaligned Compensation system. The Compensation is not vertically aligned with the Strategy of the company. Nordstrom depended on its sales employee for customer care and selling the products. However, the compensation structure was not adequately aligned to reward those behaviours which forced employees to work off-hours without getting Compensated for it. The problems were very serious as is evident from the case; the company came under a barrage of national class action suits which made a huge dent into the brand of the company. They had to make a $15 million fund which wasn’t enough. More importantly, it broke the numero Uno position and aura that Nordstrom was enjoying vis-à-vis their competitors. 2. Are Nordstrom employees pressured inappropriately by the sales-per-hour system? By management? Yes, Nordstrom employees are pressured quite inappropriately by the SHP ( Sales Hour Performance) system. In this system, employees were assigned a given SHP and if they go above the SHP , then they would be eligible for commission otherwise they will just get the base price. Now, the employees worked “off hours” for doing everything from writing Thank You letters to sales meetings etc. but if they add the “off hours” then the SHP will go below the stipulated figure and they will not eligible for commission and without the...

Words: 917 - Pages: 4

Hr Case Study

... advantage. We will distinguish ourselves by creating an environment that fosters teamwork and innovation, by developing and utilizing our employees’ abilities to the fullest, and by treating each other with dignity and respect.” • Among the changes Mack made were the following: o Promoted promising employees more aggressively o Hired away top talent from competitors o Reorganized divisions and reassigned personnel • Mack also hired Thomas DeLong, a former BYU professor who specialized in organizational development, to “bring HR to a new level.” DeLong become Chief Development Officer and set up an HR management division called the Office of Development. • Mack faced particular suspicion from the Investment Banking division, in large part since he had come from Fixed Income. In response, he devoted a great deal of time and effort to meeting with I-bankers and their needs. • To improve cooperation and collaboration, each division’s plans were discussed firm-wide so that everyone could clearly understand the entire firm’s goals, and their particular impact on them. • MS also introduced a training program, with training in four skill areas: technical, professional, product, and management. Training sessions brought together managers from lots of divisions and improved communication between them. • Mack also frequently had dinner with employees, from managing directors to analysts, and encouraged managers to do the same. His goal was......

Words: 1046 - Pages: 5

Advance Hr Case Study

...Introduction Terry has been working as a Sales Manager in a publishing company for 10 years. Terry’s working attitude has been positive and full of passion for his job. Even though Terry is in his mid-forties, he has the drive and energy of a young working adult. Every week he will pump in 60 or more hours in his work. He was labeled as a workaholic and his peers felt the pressure working together with him. Annette has been recently appointed as HR Manager in the company. Annette felt that the employees in the company should have a work-life balance. When she learnt of Terry’s long working hours, she became worried. In the long run, it could affect Terry’s health and his lifespan as a Sales Manager in the company will be shorten if anything or accident should happen to him. When the CEO of the company want to reward Terry for his dedicated commitment to his work, Annette felt that it is not right to reward Terry due to his long hours working habits as it might send the wrong message across to the rest of the employees in the company. But to the CEO’s concern, sales are the most important factor as it generates revenue for the company. Furthermore, Terry is achieving great results. The CEO also hopes to use Terry as an inspiration to the sales department. Q1. Are Annette’s concerns about Terry’s work habits justified? Is Terry a disaster waiting to happen? It is justifiable that Annette’s concern for Terry’s work habits as part of the roles and...

Words: 498 - Pages: 2

Hr Case Study

...  of  Evaluation  in  Training  –  Evaluating  Reactions  and  Learning  –  Evaluating the transfer of training – Evaluating the results of the training  Text Book:    1. Donald J. Ford, Bottom‐Line Training, Prentice‐Hall of India Pvt. .Ltd., New Delhi  Reference Books:   1. Armstrong Michael, A Handbook of Human Resource Management(11th ed),2009, Kogan Page  2. Lynton Rolf and Pareek Udai, Training for Development (Third ed.), July 2011, Sage Publications, New Delhi     3.      Noe Raymond, Employee Training and Development,  2006,  Mc‐Graw Hill  Mode of Evaluation: Mid Term,  End Term and any of these following components: Projects /  case analysis and  case discussion / Term Paper/ Class Participation / Assessment of Class Notes etc Lot more weight age to be given  to projects and in‐class case discussions/ exercises; weight age to end‐term to be reduced.  Recommended by the Board of Studies on  : 27‐08‐2011  Date of Approval by the Academic Council  : 23 AC held on 30.8.2011  HOURS 1  15  2  15  3  15  Proceedings of the 23rd Academic Council of VIT [30.8.2011] 180 ...

Words: 349 - Pages: 2

Hr Case Study

...STAFFING MANAGEMENT INSTRUCTOR’S MANUAL Four Recruitment and Retention Case Scenarios By Marcia R. Gibson, Ed.D. Project team Author: SHRM Project contributors: External contributor: Editor: Design: Marcia R. Gibson, Ed.D. Nancy A. Woolever, SPHR Sharon H. Leonard Courtney J. Cornelius, copy editor Kellyn Lombardi, graphic designer © 2008 Society for Human Resource Management. Marcia R. Gibson, Ed.D. Note to Hr faculty and instructors: SHRM cases and modules are intended for use in HR classrooms at universities. Teaching notes are included with each. While our current intent is to make the materials available without charge, we reserve the right to impose charges should we deem it necessary to support the program. However, currently, these resources are available free of charge to all. Please duplicate only the number of copies needed, one for each student in the class. For more information, please contact: SHRM Academic Initiatives 1800 Duke Street, Alexandria, VA 22314, USA Phone: (800) 283-7476 Fax: (703) 535-6432 Web: www.shrm.org/hreducation 08-0873-IM Introduction These recruitment and retention case scenarios are designed to be presented sequentially, since each scenario builds upon the previous one. They are intended for undergraduate college students. LearNING oBjectIVeS Students will learn to:  Determine recruitment needs. Identify recruitment policies and guidelines. Determine a recruitment strategy. Develop a communication plan to...

Words: 6125 - Pages: 25

Hr Mgmnt Case Study

...ASSIGNMENT George is a twelve year experienced registered nurse working the evening shift in the post-operative ward at Harmony Hill Memorial Hospital.  George wants to complete his Bachelor’s degree in nursing and the needed courses are only offered in the evenings.  George 's supervisor informs the staff of an upcoming opening in the morning shift and advises them of the application deadline.  Based on some of the rumors that have circulated regarding past practices of his supervisor, George knows that his supervisor has already filled the position with one of her closest friends and that George's completing an application and interviewing for the position is nothing more than an exercise in futility.  George brings his concerns to you, the HR supervisor.  He claims that his gender and sexual orientation has affected his nursing supervisor's decision and that any complaint from him to the nursing supervisor will result in retaliation or termination. In 4 to 5 pages respond to the following: 1. What would you say to George about the ideal legal and ethical hiring practices? 2. What can you do to ensure that the recruitment and selection process is fair and consistent with the requirements of federal and state laws on hiring practices? 3. How would you address this with George's nursing supervisor? 4. What steps can be taken in addressing George's concerns for retaliation or termination? 5. Where does the human resource department fit into this scenario...

Words: 1731 - Pages: 7

Hr Planning Case 2

...Clipper Products Forecasting is a process of predicting or estimating the future based on past and present data. Forecasting provides information about the potential future events and their consequences for the organisation. It may not reduce the complications and uncertainty of the future. However, it increases the confidence of the management to make important decisions. Forecasting is the basis of premising. Forecasting uses many statistical techniques. Therefore, it is also called a Statistical Analysis. In this case for Clipper Products it was noted that the organization has decided to not renew their Service Contracts when they expire within the next year however they will continue to support the contracts until expiry. Upon my calculations, to summarize, at 6 months there will be 6 Account Managers, 188 cleaners and 11 supervisors. Clipper Products has decided to not renew 30 of 50 contracts that are due to expire. The contracts have been reduced by 60 % therefore the workforce should be reduced by 60 % based on the metrics required to fill each contract. A hiring freeze has been invoked at this time as we know now we have an HR Surplus. An HR Surplus is when my internal workforce exceeds the required demand required. A surplus requires downsizing efforts by the organization in order to maintain the established budget. The strategy will consist of invoking a hiring freeze, natural attrition, reducing hours and shifts, layoffs and lastly termination with...

Words: 567 - Pages: 3

Business Analysi

... turn, agreed that Microsoft could use Apple technology in the Windows operating system. While Apple believed this agreement restricted Microsoft’s use of Mac technology to Windows 1.0, it actually gave Microsoft a royalty-free, perpetuating and non-terminating license to copy the Macintosh operating system. Although Apple claimed the agreement was violated by subsequent versions of Windows, it was unable to prove copyright infringement in its case against Microsoft in 1997. The Players (or) Send in the Clones Competition Intensifies Apple now faced competition from numerous companies using the Windows operating system. Companies like Dell, Hewlett Packard, Compaq and Gateway cloned IBM’s x86 system architecture and used lower-cost Intel chips and boards to flood the market with relatively inexpensive personal computers. Many of the computers lacked internal hard drives, but retailed at a fraction of their superior Mac counterparts, effectively taking command of the consumer market. Apple it seemed had nearly priced itself out of the market. For example, it charged $10000 for the Mac LX (nee the Lisa) and $5500 for its Mac II’s. A deluxe model Mac II shipped with 1mb of RAM and a 40mb hard drive (Goodell, 1996). Realizing Apple had nearly priced itself out of the market, competitors seized the opportunity to sell entry-level systems. In 1986, IBM introduced its 5140 Convertible pc, with an 4.77-MHz Intel chip, enclosed monitor, no...

Words: 3798 - Pages: 16

Hr Case Study Accenture

..., knowledge-sharing tools and community-building activities. Questions: 1. Identify how some Accenture-type efforts have and have not occurred in your current and previous workplaces. Also, discuss why focusing on employee retention pays off for Accenture clients, and not just for Accenture itself. * One company, faced with high attrition among its managers, was able to discover the root cause, address the issues and improve retention. Another successfully performed a diagnostic of its enterprise learning capabilities to determine which forms of training would have the greatest impact on performance. * Still another analyzed how to improve customer satisfaction and workforce performance in its retail channel and was able to achieve double-digit growth in sales productivity. In each case, the companies were able to avoid other remedies that would have been more costly and less productive. * How did these organizations do it? Through talent analytics—a precise, science-based analysis of employee performance and how a workforce is supported. This ability to process literally millions of data points can help executives make decisions based on objective data rather than hunches and intuition. And by giving organizations new insights into the patterns in workforce and HR performance that spur innovation and improve business performance, talent analytics can also provide them with a real talent advantage. * The journey to better ROI Companies can begin by...

Words: 1123 - Pages: 5

Hr Case Study 11

...JH Date: September 25, 2013 Case 11: Investigating a Sexual Harassment Case Step 1: HR Problem Identification Mary Booth, a SenGlas Company Shipping Coordinator, came to the HR Manager James Tilden and said she wanted to file a formal complaint against one of her coworkers for his harassing behavior. The coworker, Bob Simonsky, had made false accusations about Mary to Ginny Miller, revved his forklift engine and drove straight at Mary while laughing and slammed the metal forks of his fork-lift on the ground in an intimidating manner. In addition, he continuously refused to take directions from Mary about which trucks to load or unload, twice had thrown a cigarette butt at her and regularly tore up instructions she left for him. Two other fork lift drivers, John Griffin and Henry Jackson, had overheard Simonsky say that women did not belong in the warehouse area and that he preferred working with men and the he had told another worker, Henry Mueller, that “Booth had f***** with the wrong person and that when he got through with her not even Jesus Christ himself would be able to save her.” When Mary first started in the position as Shipping Coordinator, Simonsky had told her, “I hate that maggot”, referring to Sally Jenkins, the previous Shipping Coordinator, “I should have killed her when I had the chance.” Step 2: Identify Cause(s) of HR Problem First, James Tilden reads up on the current Sexual Harassment Policy. It states “all employees are entitled to work...

Words: 525 - Pages: 3

Ideal Case Hr

...Olympic Group Acquisition of Ideal Case Olympic Group (OG), an Egyptian white goods giant, acquisitioned IDEAL, a state-owned home appliance company. The case discusses the macro-economic and political environment past, present and future in Egypt, the history of the home appliance industry in Egypt, and IDEAL’s and OG’s business model. After an in-depth insight into these topics are addressed, the situation post acquisition with production, human resources, staff, operations and the IDEAL brand image were explored in search of an answer for the best way to integrate the two companies. Many obstacles arose because the companies were so vastly different from each other, starting with the obvious: transforming IDEAL from a state-owned company to a private-owned company. Saying so, the differences were on complete opposite ends of the spectrum in regards to the organization structures, ideas, values and overall culture of the companies individually. Another worrisome conflict that was very evident was the emerging of employees from the two firms, as uncertainty prevailed in the most effective and efficient way to accomplish this without negatively impacting overall performance. I would recommend that OG create programs or incentives to help keep employee morale high. For example, tracking individual’s progress in a recording system to ultimately demonstrate the opportunities available to them and how they can and will accomplish an achievement in exchange of......

Words: 321 - Pages: 2

Hr Case Study 1

... teacher/department head, and HR manager can determine if the candidate has their ideal qualities and character. Ff they are qualified, they’ll move to the next method: the formal interview. Creating a more structured interview is one of the greatest changes they made. A panel meeting before the interview is important. Here, the members can review the interview questions and ensure that all legal issues are avoided, and to make sure that the questions asked will hopefully provide the answers they are looking for. Defining the criteria is also a crucial step. The criteria will provide an outline of the ideal candidate to each panel members. It can also help ensure that disparate impact and/or disparate treatment doesn’t transpire during the interview. Setting the criteria also provides a measuring tool in which the candidates can be measured against. This ensures that all candidates are rated and measured consistently and equally. When I first read through the case study, I felt that dedicating an entire day for interviews was too time-consuming and not an effective use of time and resources. Not only is it a waste of resources, the number of candidates being interviewed can also affect how they are rated by the panel members. . “Interviewers’ ratings of an applicant are influenced by the order in which candidates are interviewed. For example, when an average applicant is interviewed immediately following one or more below-average applicants, the average...

Words: 2661 - Pages: 11

Hr Case Study

...Cindy Following on from our recent discussion, I appreciate your openness about the current situation and for the opportunity to justify the importance of Human Resources (HR) as a value added function, especially as we move towards a new corporate structure. If correctly aligned to the business strategy, HR is critical in ensuring the success of the transition. Under Arnold’s leadership, the focus was to operate as a “one family company”, with HR was responsible for organising expensive leadership programs and sales conferences. There is a lot more to the role of HR than what the Board understands. Let me explain – 1. Using your knowledge of HR strategy, provide a rationale for the contribution of HR to the change process in this corporate context. With the impact of globalisation and the need to remain competitive, companies have had to reassess various departmental activities to meet new organisational objectives (Lawler & Mohrman, 2003). A new strategic role for HR is one of these changes. Cabrera & Bonache (as cited in Lengnick-Hall et al., 2009) argued that Human Resource Management (HRM) practices are an essential part of a company’s corporate business strategy. Combining business strategy and people management together creates a new set of responsibilities, a bigger challenge for HRM and an increase in HR deliverables (Conner & Ulrich, 1996). Therefore, HR professionals must concentrate more on HR strategy, and move away from the...

Words: 1448 - Pages: 6

Hr Nokia Case

...Intro In the recent years the role of high-tech companies is comparable to the biggest scientific centers that creates value for generations. The rapid development of those companies allows employees to get solid remunerations along with special working circumstances. Those actions enable people to focus on their job and do not spread attention on inconveniences, that is connected with the internal atmosphere. The bright example of such organization is Nokia Company. Nokia was formed as a result of the merger of 3 companies that face people from different cultural and national backgrounds. The management policy of the company had an aim to introduce business procedures that will overcome certain difficulties. Implementation of HR practices reflected in amazing financial results and expanded their market share worldwide. The perfect balance of unique ideas along with information technology development were extremely beneficial for the all members of corporative hierarchy. However, a number of obstacles arose and led to the damaged corporate image. How do reorganizations and massive layoffs, for example in the spring of 2003, affect Nokia’s employees in terms of their attitude and behaviour?  Layoffs and reorganizations itself are the actions directed to terminate or replace a unit of workforce, in order to reach the highest possible effectiveness or stay efficient in hard conditions. Declining of the entire technological industry and bankruptcies among high...

Words: 1604 - Pages: 7